Skip to content
S4451Senate2023-2024 Session

Update Sex Offender Risk Tools

Official title

“Relates to sex offender risk assessment instruments”

Sponsor Liz KruegerSD-28Affects Public Safety & Consumer Affairs
Status
In Senate Committee
Crime Victims, Crime And Correction
Impact
6/10
Moderate
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Crime Victims, Crime And Correction

What's happening

This bill requires the use and regular revalidation of a risk assessment instrument, based on current data, for evaluating sex offenders in New York.

Why it matters

  1. Mandates use of empirically validated risk assessment tools. The bill requires New York to use a risk assessment instrument for sex offenders that is not just based on expert opinion, but is empirically validated and periodically revalidated using current data, aiming to make risk classifications more scientifically accurate and reliable.

  2. Establishes regular, public reporting and system oversight. It directs the creation of a statewide database tracking recidivism among sex offenders and requires retroactive studies at least every five years. These studies and the resulting reports to the governor and legislature are intended to ensure ongoing evaluation and improvement of risk prediction methods.

  3. Aims to improve public safety and fairness. By incorporating only those risk factors proven to actually predict re-offense, and by requiring ongoing review, the changes seek to better protect the public from high-risk individuals while reducing unnecessary restrictions or stigma for lower-risk offenders.

  4. Could influence sentencing, supervision, and public notification. Because risk assessment results affect how offenders are classified, how much of their information is made public, and the length and type of post-release supervision, these reforms could have significant impacts on both offender rights and community safety.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Update Sex Offender Risk Tools

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Liz Krueger

Senator · Senate District 28

Chair, Finance

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to crime victims, crime and correction
  2. Referred to crime victims, crime and correction

Full text

6 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

4451

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

February 8, 2023

Introduced by Sen. KRUEGER -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Crime Victims, Crime and Correction

AN ACT to amend the correction law, in relation to risk assessment instruments for sex offenders

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subdivision 3 of section 168-d of the correction law, as amended by chapter 11 of the laws of 2002, is amended to read as follows:

3. For sex offenders released on probation or discharged upon payment of a fine, conditional discharge or unconditional discharge, it shall be the duty of the court applying the guidelines and risk assessment instrument established in subdivision five of section one hundred sixty-eight-l of this article to determine the level of notification pursuant to subdivision six of section one hundred sixty-eight-l of this article and whether such sex offender shall be designated a sexual predator, sexually violent offender, or predicate sex offender as defined in subdivision seven of section one hundred sixty-eight-a of this article. At least fifteen days prior to the determination proceeding, the district attorney shall provide to the court and the sex offender a written statement setting forth the determinations sought by the district attorney together with the reasons for seeking such determinations. The court shall allow the sex offender to appear and be heard. The state shall appear by the district attorney, or his or her designee, who shall bear the burden of proving the facts supporting the determinations sought by clear and convincing evidence. Where there is a dispute between the parties concerning the determinations, the court shall adjourn the hearing as necessary to permit the sex offender or the district attorney to obtain materials relevant to the determinations from any state or local facility, hospital, institution, office, agency,

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD07064-01-3

department or division. Such materials may be obtained by subpoena if not voluntarily provided to the requesting party. In making the determinations, the court shall review any victim's statement and any relevant materials and evidence submitted by the sex offender and the district attorney and the court may consider reliable hearsay evidence submitted by either party provided that it is relevant to the determinations. Facts previously proven at trial or elicited at the time of entry of a plea of guilty shall be deemed established by clear and convincing evidence and shall not be relitigated. The court shall render an order setting forth its determinations and the findings of fact and conclusions of law on which the determinations are based. A copy of the order shall be submitted by the court to the division. Upon application of either party, the court shall seal any portion of the court file or record which contains material that is confidential under any state or federal statute. Either party may appeal as of right from the order pursuant to the provisions of articles fifty-five, fifty-six and fiftyseven of the civil practice law and rules. Where counsel has been assigned to represent the sex offender upon the ground that the sex offender is financially unable to retain counsel, that assignment shall be continued throughout the pendency of the appeal, and the person may appeal as a poor person pursuant to article eighteen-B of the county law.

§ 2. Subdivision 2 of section 168-k of the correction law, as amended by chapter 684 of the laws of 2005, is amended to read as follows:

2. The division shall advise the board that the sex offender has established residence in this state. The board shall determine whether the sex offender is required to register with the division. If it is determined that the sex offender is required to register, the division shall notify the sex offender of his or her duty to register under this article and shall require the sex offender to sign a form as may be required by the division acknowledging that the duty to register and the procedure for registration has been explained to the sex offender. The division shall obtain on such form the address where the sex offender expects to reside within the state and the sex offender shall retain one copy of the form and send two copies to the division which shall provide the information to the law enforcement agency having jurisdiction where the sex offender expects to reside within this state. No later than thirty days prior to the board making a recommendation, the sex offender shall be notified that his or her case is under review and that he or she is permitted to submit to the board any information relevant to the review. After reviewing any information obtained, and applying the guidelines and risk assessment instrument established in subdivision five of section one hundred sixty-eight-l of this article, the board shall within sixty calendar days make a recommendation regarding the level of notification pursuant to subdivision six of section one hundred sixty-eight-l of this article and whether such sex offender shall be designated a sexual predator, sexually violent offender, or predicate sex offender as defined in subdivision seven of section one hundred sixty-eight-a of this article. This recommendation shall be confidential and shall not be available for public inspection. It shall be submitted by the board to the county court or supreme court and to the district attorney in the county of residence of the sex offender and to the sex offender. It shall be the duty of the county court or supreme court in the county of residence of the sex offender, applying the guidelines and risk assessment instrument established in subdivision five of section one hundred sixty-eight-l of this article, to determine the level of notification pursuant to subdivision six of section one hundred sixty-eight-l of this article and whether such sex offender shall be designated a sexual predator, sexually violent offender, or predicate sex offender as defined in subdivision seven of section one hundred sixty-eight-a of this article. At least thirty days prior to the determination proceeding, such court shall notify the district attorney and the sex offender, in writing, of the date of the determination proceeding and the court shall also provide the district attorney and sex offender with a copy of the recommendation received from the board and any statement of the reasons for the recommendation received from the board. This notice shall include the following statement or a substantially similar statement: "This proceeding is being held to determine whether you will be classified as a level 3 offender (risk of repeat offense is high), a level 2 offender (risk of repeat offense is moderate), or a level 1 offender (risk of repeat offense is low), or whether you will be designated as a sexual predator, a sexually violent offender or a predicate sex offender, which will determine how long you must register as a sex offender and how much information can be provided to the public concerning your registration. If you fail to appear at this proceeding, without sufficient excuse, it shall be held in your absence. Failure to appear may result in a longer period of registration or a higher level of community notification because you are not present to offer evidence or contest evidence offered by the district attorney." The court shall also advise the sex offender that he or she has a right to a hearing prior to the court's determination, that he or she has the right to be represented by counsel at the hearing and that counsel will be appointed if he or she is financially unable to retain counsel. A returnable form shall be enclosed in the court's notice to the sex offender on which the sex offender may apply for assignment of counsel. If the sex offender applies for assignment of counsel and the court finds that the offender is financially unable to retain counsel, the court shall assign counsel to represent the sex offender pursuant to article eighteen-B of the county law. If the district attorney seeks a determination that differs from the recommendation submitted by the board, at least ten days prior to the determination proceeding the district attorney shall provide to the court and the sex offender a statement setting forth the determinations sought by the district attorney together with the reasons for seeking such determinations. The court shall allow the sex offender to appear and be heard. The state shall appear by the district attorney, or his or her designee, who shall bear the burden of proving the facts supporting the determinations sought by clear and convincing evidence. It shall be the duty of the court applying the guidelines and risk assessment instrument established in subdivision five of section one hundred sixty-eight-l of this article to determine the level of notification pursuant to subdivision six of section one hundred sixty-eight-l of this article and whether such sex offender shall be designated a sexual predator, sexually violent offender, or predicate sex offender as defined in subdivision seven of section one hundred sixty-eight-a of this article. Where there is a dispute between the parties concerning the determinations, the court shall adjourn the hearing as necessary to permit the sex offender or the district attorney to obtain materials relevant to the determinations from the state board of examiners of sex offenders or any state or local facility, hospital, institution, office, agency, department or division. Such materials may be obtained by subpoena if not voluntarily provided to the requesting party. In making the determinations the court shall review any victim's statement and any relevant materials and evidence submitted by the sex offender and the district attorney and the recommendation and any material submitted by the board, and may consider reliable hearsay evidence submitted by either party, provided that it is relevant to the determinations. If available, facts proven at trial or elicited at the time of a plea of guilty shall be deemed established by clear and convincing evidence and shall not be relitigated. The court shall render an order setting forth its determinations and the findings of fact and conclusions of law on which the determinations are based. A copy of the order shall be submitted by the court to the division. Upon application of either party, the court shall seal any portion of the court file or record which contains material that is confidential under any state or federal statute. Either party may appeal as of right from the order pursuant to the provisions of articles fifty-five, fifty-six and fifty-seven of the civil practice law and rules. Where counsel has been assigned to represent the sex offender upon the ground that the sex offender is financially unable to retain counsel, that assignment shall be continued throughout the pendency of the appeal, and the person may appeal as a poor person pursuant to article eighteen-B of the county law.

§ 3. Subdivision 5 and the opening paragraph of subdivision 6 of section 168-l of the correction law, subdivision 5 as added by chapter 192 of the laws of 1995, subparagraph (i) of paragraph (a) of subdivision 5 and the opening paragraph of subdivision 6 as amended by chapter 11 of the laws of 2002, are amended and a new subdivision 5-a is added to read as follows:

5. The board shall develop guidelines and procedures and use a validated risk assessment instrument to assess the risk of a repeat offense by such sex offender and the threat posed to the public safety. Such risk assessment instrument shall be periodically subjected to empirical re-validation. Such guidelines shall [be based upon,] incorporate factors found to be predictive of risk of re-offense, including but not limited to, the following:

(a) criminal history factors indicative of high risk of repeat offense, including:

(i) whether the sex offender has a mental abnormality or personality disorder that makes him or her likely to engage in predatory sexually violent offenses;

(ii) whether the sex offender's conduct was found to be characterized by repetitive and compulsive behavior, associated with drugs or alcohol;

(iii) whether the sex offender served the maximum term;

(iv) whether the sex offender committed the felony sex offense against a child;

(v) the age of the sex offender at the time of the commission of the first sex offense;

(b) other criminal history factors to be considered in determining risk, including:

(i) the relationship between such sex offender and the victim;

(ii) whether the offense involved the use of a weapon, violence or infliction of serious bodily injury;

(iii) the number, date and nature of prior offenses;

(c) conditions of release that minimize risk [or] of re-offense, including but not limited to whether the sex offender is under supervision; receiving counseling, therapy or treatment; or residing in a home situation that provides guidance and supervision;

(d) physical conditions that minimize risk of re-offense, including but not limited to advanced age or debilitating illness;

(e) whether psychological or psychiatric profiles indicate a risk of recidivism;

(f) the sex offender's response to treatment;

(g) recent behavior, including behavior while confined;

(h) recent threats or gestures against persons or expressions of intent to commit additional offenses; and

(i) review of any victim impact statement.

5-a. (a) The board in consultation with the department and the division of criminal justice services shall maintain a statewide database of sex offender recidivism statistics.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the correction law, in relation to risk assessment instruments for sex offenders

Purpose

To update the guidelines of the sex offender risk assessment instrument and require use of a validated instrument.

Summary of provisions

Section 1 makes a technical amendment to section 168-d of the correction law requiring the application of a risk assessment instrument.

Read the full memo (1,229 words)

Section 2 makes the same technical amendment to section 168-k of the correction law in requiring the application of a risk assessment instru- ment.

Section 3 amends subdivisions 5 and 6 and adds a new subdivision 5-a of section 168-1 of the correction law requiring the board of examiners of sex offenders to use a validated risk assessment instrument subjected to periodic empirical re-validation.

Section 4 makes the same technical amendment to subdivisions 1 and 2 of section 168-n of the correction law requiring the application of a risk assessment instrument.

Section 5 provides for an effective date.

Justification

The New York State Board of Examiners of Sex Offenders created risk assessment guidelines back in 1995. The guidelines are used to assess each sex offender's risk of reoffending and to make a recommendation to the courts concerning the risk level that should be assigned to such sex offender. The courts treat these recommendations as presumptively valid and generally only override the board's recommendation if something is brought to their attention that was not taken into account by the guide- lines.

An expert panel, including two assistant district attorneys, a probation officer, a deputy attorney general, a police captain, the acting direc- tor of forensic services at the Office of Mental Health, a physician and a sex offender treatment provider, applied the guidelines to twenty cases, and then modified them. The guidelines were adopted and modified by the panel in January 1996 and, with one slight revision in 1997 and one statutory update in 2006, have remained the same since that time.

Much has developed in the field of stochastic modeling that classify sexual offenders into different risk categories since 1995. For example, the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation is required by state law to use a static (unchanging) risk assessment instrument in addressing an offender's likelihood of sexual re-offense prior to being released on parole; by Probation to asses s offenders pre-sentencing and

on probation caseloads; and by the Department of State Hospitals prior to release from a DHS institution.

Research conducted as recently as 2016 has shown that the predictive accuracy of re-offense can be increased slightly when dynamic (changea- ble) factors are combined with static (unchangeable) factors. These dynamic factors include things like substance abuse, personality disor- ders, deviant sexual interests, emotional identification with children, and self-regulation problems. Dynamic and violent risk assessment instruments are also assessed in mandated treatment programs. The combi- nation of using static, dynamic, and violence instruments will give a better picture of the overall risk of recidivism for individuals who have previously sexually offended.

The Static 99/R is the most widely used sexual offender actuarial risk assessment instrument in the world. The assumptions aggregate criminal history as well as demographic characteristics to identify the predic- tors of recidivism. The general idea of any sex offender actuarial risk assessment is that the characteristics of an individual sex offender are compared to the characteristics of a large group of sex offenders who have reoffended over a given period of time. The instruments are not personality tests or psychological profiles, but are predictive statis- tical tools that look at the traits of an individual to see how other similarly situated individuals have fared in the past. The strength of the actuarial method is that it is research-supported rather than subjective, and that the instrument is susceptible to ongoing re-valida- tion and refinement. The Static 99/R also demonstrates a moderate abili- ty to identify recidivists and non-recidivists; recent updates include adding data on older offenders, over 60 years of age, with low recidiv- ism rates.

Validation studies of the underlying assumptions that are used in actu- arial risk assessment instruments are extremely important. The Califor- nia Department of Justice (DOJ) collaborated with the State Authorized Risk Assessment Tools used for Sex Offenders (SARATSO) Committee and conducted two validation studies; one in 2014 and another in 2016 on the Static-99/R risk assessment instrument. Unbiased experts in the field of risk assessment analyze the data. The studies examined the re-of- fence rates of parolee and probation offenders. The study concluded that the overall Static-99/R worked well in predicting the risk of sexual re-offense along various ethnic groups. The conclusion was that re-of- fense was less in California than in international samples; that tran- sients reoffended at higher rates; that the typical sex offender after 5 years of release is likely to offend between 4%12%; after 10 years of release between 6% -22%.

It is hard to compare the predictive accuracy of New York's current risk assessment guidelines to guidelines of the Static 99/R; New York guide- lines have never been tested to see if they in fact accurately predict the risk of reoffending. Additionally, the instrument has never been validated. The process of periodic empirical validation ensures that a risk assessment instrument is accurate, predictive, leads to the same results when different people apply it and appropriately supports the decision-making process in each case under consideration so that the state is not making arbitrary or irrational assignments of risk levels.

A second problem with the guidelines is that they do not take new research into account. It has been noted by clinical psychologists work- ing with sex offenders in New York that many of the factors used in the state's risk assessment guidelines do not have any relation to the level of risk; recommendations have been made that the risk assessment guide- lines should be replaced with more modern and validated instruments such as those used in the Static 99/R. New York's sex offender registry should utilize 21st century actuarial derived risk assessment levels. This will ensure that law enforcement and treatment services focus on the sex offenders most likely to recidivate. The public and law enforce- ment depend on the findings of the Board of Examiners of Sex Offenders, so it is incumbent upon the legislature to ensure that the Board is utilizing the most up-to-date, accurate and scientifically validated risk assessment instrument available. The first line of defense against recidivism is a precise estimation of which sex offenders need the most careful supervision, allowing law enforcement to focus its efforts on those sex offenders who pose a high risk of reoffending. Requiring the use of a validated risk assessment instrument like th e Static 99/R will help the state to identify those high-risk individuals who need to be watched most closely.

Legislative history

2021-2022 - S.3096 No Same As - Died in Crime Victims

2019-2020 - S.4191/A.7509 O'Donnell - died in Crime Victims/Correction

2017-2018 - S.3711/A.1906 O'Donnell - died in Crime Victims/Correction

2015-2016 - S.3097/A.2190- O'Donnell - died in Crime Victims/Correction

2013-2014 - S.3138-A/A.4591-A O'Donnell - died in Crime Victims/ Correction.

2012 - S.7080/A.9258 Aubry - died in Crime Victims/Correction

Fiscal implications

None, as the Static 99/R and other validated risk assessment instruments are in public domain.

Local fiscal implications

None

Effective date

This act shall take effect one hundred eighty days after it shall have become law.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.