What's happening
This bill allows courts to review and overturn parole denial decisions, requires parole interviews to be recorded, and ensures all hearing documents are part of the appeal record.
Why it matters
Grants people denied parole the right to meaningful court review. The bill allows courts to fully reconsider (de novo) parole denial decisions, not just check for procedural errors, giving incarcerated individuals a real chance to challenge denials.
Increases accountability and transparency in parole proceedings. By requiring that parole interviews are audio recorded and that all documents considered by the parole board are part of the official record, the bill makes it harder for errors or bias to go unchallenged.
Strengthens the legal rights of incarcerated individuals. The bill ensures access to legal representation in parole appeals and that the full hearing record is available for appeal, making the appeal process more robust and potentially fairer.
Could impact parole board behavior and release rates. Knowing their decisions and processes are subject to thorough court review and are fully documented may incentivize parole boards to be more careful, transparent, and consistent in their decision-making.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Who cares
Incarcerated people denied parole
The bill would make parole denials final for Article 78 review and allow courts to reconsider release decisions from scratch, including setting a release date.
New York State Board of Parole
The bill would require audio recordings of every release interview, verbatim records within 30 days where required, and inclusion of all submitted documents in the appeal record.
Attorneys representing incarcerated people
The bill would extend the language allowing representation and assigned counsel for financially eligible individuals to appeals from board decisions, rather than only appeals to the board.
Courts reviewing parole decisions
The bill would authorize courts to affirm or modify release decisions, order a new board interview, or set a release date, and to require the petitioner to appear.
Headline styles
Allow Court Review of Parole
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
2 Co-sponsors
History
- Referred to crime victims, crime and correction
- Referred to crime victims, crime and correction
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Let Courts Review Parole Denials
In Assembly Committee · Correction · Sponsor Daniel O'Donnell
Full text
2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
474
2023-2024 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
January 4, 2023
Introduced by Sens. SEPULVEDA, SALAZAR -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Crime Victims, Crime and Correction
AN ACT to amend the executive law, in relation to appeals of parole determination
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Paragraphs (a) and (b) of subdivision 4 of section 259-i of the executive law, paragraph (a) as amended by section 11 of part E of chapter 62 of the laws of 2003 and paragraph (b) as amended by chapter 322 of the laws of 2021, are amended to read as follows:
(a) Except for determinations made upon preliminary hearings upon allegations of violation of presumptive release, parole, conditional release or post-release supervision, all determinations made pursuant to this section may be appealed in accordance with rules promulgated by the board except that a decision by the board denying parole release shall be a final decision for the purposes of article seventy-eight of the civil practice law and rules. Any board member who participated in the decision from which the appeal is taken may not participate in the resolution of that appeal. The rules of the board may specify a time within which any appeal shall be taken and resolved.
(b) Upon an appeal [to the] from a board decision, the incarcerated individual may be represented by an attorney. Where the incarcerated individual is financially unable to provide for his or her own attorney, upon request an attorney shall be assigned pursuant to the provisions of subparagraph (v) of paragraph (f) of subdivision three of this section.
§ 2. Subdivision 5 of section 259-i of the executive law, as amended by chapter 166 of the laws of 1991, is amended to read as follows:
5. Actions of the board. Any action by the board or by a hearing officer pursuant to this article shall be deemed a judicial function and shall not be reviewable if done in accordance with law except that upon
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD01601-01-3
an appropriate petition the court may consider a release decision de novo. The court may in its own discretion require an appearance by the petitioner. The court may affirm the decision of the board, modify the decision, order a de novo interview for reconsideration by the board or provide a release date for the petitioner.
§ 3. Subparagraph (i) of paragraph (a) of subdivision 6 of section 259-i of the executive law, as amended by chapter 322 of the laws of 2021, is amended to read as follows:
(i) The board shall provide for the making of a verbatim record of each parole release interview within thirty days of such interview, except where a decision is made to release the incarcerated individual to parole supervision, and each preliminary and final revocation hearing, except when the decision of the presiding officer after such hearings result in a dismissal of all charged violations of parole, conditional release or post release supervision. An audio recording shall also be made of each parole release interview in its entirety. All documents submitted to the board shall be included in the hearing record for purposes of appeal.
§ 4. This act shall take effect on the one hundred eightieth day after it shall have become a law.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the executive law, in relation to appeals of parole determination
Purpose
To change the parole appeal process to provide for timely and comprehen- sive review of parole denials.
Summary of provisions
Section 1 amends subdivision 4 of section 259-i of the executive law.
Read the full memo (878 words)
Section 2 amends subdivision 5 of section 259-i of the executive law.
Section 3 amends subdivision i of paragraph a of subdivision 6 of section 259-i of the executive law.
Section 4 states the act shall take effect on the one hundred eightieth day after the signing of this bill into law.
Justification
When an inmate is denied release by the Board of Parole he or she may file an administrative appeal of that denial to the board's Appeals Unit followed by an Article 78 petition to Supreme Court should the decision be upheld by the Appeals Unit. Under the board's own rules, the Appeals Unit has 120 days to answer an administrative appeal. An inmate has a right to counsel for the administrative appeals process but not for an Article 78 petition to the court.
According to data from the Board of Parole, in 2012 and 2013, the Appeals Unit received more than 4000 perfected appeals and issued deci- sions in 2699 such appeals, or roughly two thirds. Of the latter, 2628 decisions were affirmed and 71 were reversed. During those same two years, only 4 decisions were made within the allotted four-month time period while 2695 were decided after the requisite deadline. Most appeals, 1279, were decided between six and nine months after the initial decision was issued by the board.
In other words almost every inmate who appealed a parole determination had to wait four months while the Appeals Unit failed to make a decision before he or she was able to file an Article 78 petition in court chal- lenging the denial of parole. Of the inmates who eventually received a decision from the Appeals Unit, nearly all of them were affirmations of the board's determination. This is not a meaningful appeal process and is a waste of time for both the inmate and appointed counsel. Addi- tionally, since the board does not currently provide timely administra- tive decisions to the court, the court is in no worse position by treat- ing the parole board's determination as a final decision.
When an inmate is finally able to file a petition challenging the parole denial, there is usually an additional delay of many months before the board produces a transcript of the parole interview to the petitioner and to the court. The board reports that when they use State hearing reporters, there is an average 4- to 6-month delay before the transcript is received by its own transcription unit. A month or two after the transcript is finalized the attorney general's office answers the inmate's petition and, several months later, the court issues a deci- sion.
By law a parole "hit," that is, the waiting period before an inmate is eligible to reappear before the board, can be no more than two years. In most cases, by the time the court is able to make 'a decision on the petition, the inmate is already scheduled to see the board again. Very few cases make it to the Appellate Division because the majority of them are moot by virtue of having reached the inmate's next scheduled appear- ance before the board. By delay, the board escapes review of its deci- sions.
The parole appeal process is also crippled by the fact that the board does not send the entire record below to the court for review. Recent- ly, a superintendent of a correctional facility appeared before the board to testify on behalf of an inmate seeking parole, a very rare occurrence. When the board denied parole release, the inmate appealed. The transcript given to the court did not include the superintendent's testimony. The board only sent a transcript of the interview of the inmate himself. The board routinely fails to forward letters of support and other documents to the court reviewing the record on appeal.
This bill aims to speed up the process of parole appeals and provide for needed court oversight of the board's decisions. It permits inmates to bypass the parole appeals unit to appeal directly to the court and allows the court to receive the entire record that had been before the board. It transfers the right to counsel from the administrative appeal to the Article 78 petitioning process. It also permits the court broader remedies upon review, including the right to order an inmate to be released from prison. The bill requires the boardòto make a timely tran- script of its hearings and provide an audio recording of the hearing, including any testimony by witnesses other than the inmate being consid- ered for parole.
Legislative history
S.2141 of 2021-22; Referred to Crime Victims, Crime,and Correction;
S.2697 of 2019-20; Referred to Crime Victims, Crime and Correction;
A.1908 of 2017-18; Referred to Ways and Means;
A.2463 of 2015-16; Referred to Ways and Means, Advanced to Third Reading
Fiscal implications
None.
Local fiscal implications
None.
Effective date
This act shall take effect one hundred eighty days after it becomes law.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.