What's happening
The bill creates the Education Affordability Act, offering tax credits for contributions to scholarship organizations, public schools, and for certain educational expenses.
Why it matters
Could shift funding dynamics between public and private schools. By offering sizable tax credits for donations to both public and private (including religious) school-related organizations, the bill could incentivize private support for nonpublic education, potentially increasing resources for private schools and scholarship recipients while also bolstering some public school programs.
May expand access to private education for lower- and middle-income families. The act specifically provides a separate refundable tax credit for tuition expenses paid by lower- and middle-income families (up to 15% of tuition or 12% of public per-pupil spending), potentially making private schooling more affordable for families who otherwise could not consider it.
Introduces new administrative requirements and oversight. The bill establishes a structured approval and reporting system for organizations that receive contributions and issue scholarship certificates, with oversight by both the Department of Taxation and Finance and the Education Department. This could add transparency but also administrative complexity.
Potential fiscal impact on state revenue and public education funding. By granting substantial tax credits (up to $300 million annually) for private donations, the bill might reduce state tax revenue. This could have downstream effects on state budgeting, including for public education, unless offset by other means.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Create Education Tax Credit
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
No co-sponsors yet.
History
- Referred to investigations and government operations
- Referred to investigations and government operations
Full text
12 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
4766
2023-2024 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
February 14, 2023
Introduced by Sen. LANZA -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Investigations and Government Operations
AN ACT to amend the tax law and the education law, in relation to enacting the "education affordability act"
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Short title. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "education affordability act".
§ 2. The tax law is amended by adding a new section 48 to read as follows:
§ 48. Education affordability tax credit. (a) Definitions. For the purposes of this section, the following terms shall have the same definitions as provided for in article twenty-five of the education law:
"Authorized contribution";
"Contribution";
"Educational program";
"Educational scholarship organization";
"Eligible pupil";
"Local education fund";
"Nonpublic school";
"Public education entity";
"Public school";
"Qualified contribution";
"Qualified educator";
"Qualified school";
"Scholarship"; and
"School improvement organization".
(b) Allowance of credit. A taxpayer subject to tax under article nine-A or twenty-two of this chapter shall be allowed credit against such tax, pursuant to the provisions referenced in subdivision (l) of
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD08652-01-3
this section, with respect to qualified contributions made during the taxable year.
(c) Amount of credit. For taxpayers whose federal adjusted gross income is less than three hundred thousand dollars for the taxable year during which such taxpayer made at least one qualified contribution, the amount of the credit shall be ninety percent of the taxpayer's total qualified contributions, capped at eight hundred seventy-five thousand dollars. For taxpayers whose federal adjusted gross income is greater than or equal to three hundred thousand dollars for the taxable year during which such taxpayer made at least one qualified contribution, the amount of credit shall be seventy-five percent of the taxpayer's total qualified contributions, capped at eight hundred seventy-five thousand dollars. A taxpayer that is a partner in a partnership, member of a limited liability company or shareholder in an S corporation shall be allowed to claim its pro rata share of the credit earned by the partnership, limited liability company or S corporation, provided that such a taxpayer shall not claim credit in excess of eight hundred seventy-five thousand dollars.
(d) Information to be posted on the department's website. The commissioner shall maintain on the department's website a running total of the amount of available credit for which taxpayers may apply pursuant to this section. Such running total shall be updated on a daily basis. Additionally, the commissioner shall maintain on the department's website a list of the school improvement organizations, local education funds and educational scholarship organizations approved to issue certificates of receipt pursuant to article twenty-five of the education law. The commissioner shall also maintain on the department's website a list of public education entities, school improvement organizations, local education funds and educational scholarship organizations whose approval to issue certificates of receipt has been revoked along with the date of revocation.
(e) Applications for contribution authorization certificates. Prior to making a contribution to a public education entity, school improvement organization, local education fund, or educational scholarship organization, the taxpayer shall apply to the department for a contribution authorization certificate for such contribution. Such application shall be in the form and manner prescribed by the department. The department may allow taxpayers to make multiple applications on the same form, provided that each contribution listed on such application shall be treated as a separate application and that the department shall issue separate contribution authorization certificates for each such application.
(f) Contribution authorization certificates. 1. Issuance of certificates. The commissioner shall issue contribution authorization certificates in two phases. In phase one, which begins on the first day of January and ends on the thirty-first day of January, the commissioner shall accept applications for contribution authorization certificates. Commencing after the fifth day of February, the commissioner shall issue contribution authorization certificates for applications received during phase one, provided that if the aggregate total of the contributions for which applications have been received during phase one exceeds the amount of the credit cap in subdivision (h) of this section, then phase one of the credit cap application shall be allocated in two steps. In step one, the allocation shall equal the contribution cap divided by the total number of applications for contributions, rounded down to the nearest cent. Each application requesting an amount which is less than or equal to the allocation in step one shall receive the amount on their application for contribution and the difference, which shall be referred to as "excess distributions" for the purposes of this subdivision, shall be available for allocation in step two. Each application requesting an amount which exceeds the allocation in step one shall be allocated credits in step two. In step two, if excess distributions equal zero then each application shall receive the allocation amount from step one, otherwise each application shall receive an amount equal to the sum of the (i) the allocation amount in step one and (ii) a pro rata share of aggregate excess distributions based on the difference between the amount on their application for contribution and the allocation in step one. For the purposes of this subdivision, multiple applications by the same taxpayer shall be treated as one application. If the credit cap is not exceeded, phase two commences on February twentieth and ends on October thirty-first. During phase two the commissioner shall issue contribution authorization certificates on a first-come first serve basis based upon the date the department received the taxpayer's application for such certificate. Contribution authorization certificates for applications received during phase one shall be mailed no later than the twentieth day of February. Contribution authorization certificates for applications received during phase two shall be mailed within five days of receipt of such applications.
2. Contribution authorization certificate contents. Each contribution authorization certificate shall state (i) the date such certificate was issued, (ii) the date by which the authorized contribution listed on the certificate must be made, which shall be no later than December thirtyfirst of the year for which the contribution authorization certificate was issued, (iii) the amount of authorized contribution, (iv) the certificate number, (v) the taxpayer's name and address, (vi) the name and address of the public education entity, school improvement organization, local education fund or educational scholarship organization to which the taxpayer may make the authorized contribution, and (vii) any other information that the commissioner deems necessary.
3. Notification of the issuance of a contribution authorization certificate. Upon the issuance of a contribution authorization certificate to a taxpayer, the commissioner shall notify the public education entity, school improvement organization, local education fund or educational scholarship organization of the issuance of such contribution authorization certificate. Such notification shall include (i) the taxpayer's name and address, (ii) the date such certificate was issued, (iii) the date by which the authorized contribution listed in the notification must be made by the taxpayer, (iv) the amount of the authorized contribution, (v) the contribution authorization certificate's certificate number, and (vi) any other information that the commissioner deems necessary.
(g) Certificate of receipt. 1. In general. No public education entity, school improvement organization, local education fund, or educational scholarship organization shall issue a certificate of receipt for any contribution made by a taxpayer unless such public education entity, school improvement organization, local education fund, or educational scholarship organization has been approved to issue certificates of receipt pursuant to article twenty-five of the education law. No public education entity, school improvement organization, local education fund, or educational scholarship organization shall issue a certificate of receipt for a contribution made by a taxpayer unless such public education entity, school improvement organization, local education fund, or educational scholarship organization has received notice from the department that the department issued a contribution authorization certificate to the taxpayer for such contribution.
2. Timely contribution. If a taxpayer makes an authorized contribution to the public education entity, school improvement organization, local education fund, or educational scholarship organization set forth on the contribution authorization certificate issued to the taxpayer no later than the date by which such authorized contribution is required to be made, such public education entity, school improvement organization, local education fund, or educational scholarship organization shall, within thirty days of receipt of the authorized contribution, issue to the taxpayer a certificate of receipt; provided, however, that if the taxpayer contributes an amount that is less than the amount listed on the taxpayer's contribution authorization certificate, the taxpayer shall not be issued a certificate of receipt for such contribution.
3. Certificate of receipt contents. Each certificate of receipt shall state (i) the name and address of the issuing public education entity, school improvement organization, local education fund, or educational scholarship organization, (ii) the taxpayer's name and address, (iii) the date for each contribution, (iv) the amount of each contribution and the corresponding contribution authorization certificate number, (v) the total amount of contributions, (vi) certificate of receipt number and (vii) any other information that the commissioner may deem necessary.
4. Notification to the department for the issuance of a certificate of receipt. Upon the issuance of a certificate of receipt, the issuing public education entity, school improvement organization, local education fund, or educational scholarship organization shall, within thirty days of issuing the certificate of receipt, provide the department with notification of the issuance of such certificate in the form and manner prescribed by the department.
5. Notification to the department of the non-issuance of a certificate of receipt. Each public education entity, school improvement organization, local education fund, or educational scholarship organization that received notification from the department pursuant to subdivision (f) of this section regarding the issuance of a contribution authorization certificate to a taxpayer shall, within thirty days of the expiration date for such authorized contribution, provide notification to the department for each taxpayer that failed to make the authorized contribution to such public education entity, school improvement organization, local education fund, or educational scholarship organization in the form and manner prescribed by the department.
6. Failure to notify the department. Within thirty days of the discovery of the failure of any public education entity, school improvement program, local education fund, or educational scholarship organization to comply with the notification requirements prescribed by paragraphs four and five of this subdivision, the commissioner shall issue a notice of compliance failure to such entity, program, fund, or organization. Such entity, program, fund, or organization shall have thirty days from the date of such notice to make the notifications prescribed by paragraphs four and five of this subdivision. Such period may be extended for an additional thirty days upon the request of the entity, program, fund, or organization. Upon the expiration of the period for compliance set forth in the notice prescribed by this paragraph, the commissioner shall notify the commissioner of education that such entity, program, fund, or organization failed to make the notifications prescribed by paragraphs four and five of this subdivision.
(h) Credit cap. The maximum permitted credits under this section available to all taxpayers for qualified contributions for calendar year two thousand twenty-four shall be one hundred fifty million dollars. In calendar year two thousand twenty-five the maximum permitted credits under this section available to all taxpayers shall be two hundred twenty-five million dollars plus any amounts that are required to be added to the cap pursuant to subdivision (i) of this section. For calendar year two thousand twenty-six and each calendar year thereafter, the maximum permitted credits available to all taxpayers shall be three hundred million dollars plus any amounts that are required to be added to the cap pursuant to subdivision (i) of this section. The maximum permitted credits under this section for qualified contributions shall be allocated fifty percent to public education entities, school improvement organizations, and local education funds and fifty percent to educational scholarship organizations.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the tax law and the education law, in relation to enact- ing the "education affordability act"
Purpose
Establishes the "education affordability act" and tax credit.
Summary of provisions
SECTION 1: Title
Read the full memo (1,153 words)
Section 2
Provides for definitions in Tax Law, sets limits for the maximum value of credit that may be received and income eligibility for recipients. Also directs the manner in which information pertaining to the tax credit should be disseminated and in which contributions shall be certified. 'Caps the maximum total value of tax credits. Provides for a written report on how the credit has been utilized.
Section 3
Conforming language
Section 4
Creates the Education Affordability Tax credit
Section 5
Conforming language
Section 6
Establishes the home-based instructional materials credit
Sections 7-8
Conforming Language
Section 9
Establishes the Helping Open Opportunities to Learn Tax Credit for low and middle income taxpayers
Section 10
Provides definitions and methods of contributions in Education Law
Section 11
Allows school districts to accept and solicit gifts and donations, and exempts such gifts from determinations of State aid
Section 12
Severability clause
Section 13
Effective Date
Justification
Parents worry about their children's education. For many parents, the decision to enroll their child in one particular school over another is difficult. Not every learning environment is a good fit for every child. This bill would provide some monetary relief to lower and middle income parents who pay tuition for their child to attend a primary or secondary school. Our children are our future. We need to trust that their parents have their best interest at heart when they are making decisions about their education. We should support their decisions regarding the educa- tion of their children.
At a time when the state is considering ways of reducing the tax burden for New York State residents and educators are seeking an expansion of financial resources, charitable giving for educational purposes should be stimulated. Permitting public education entities such as school districts and individual public schools, including charter schools, and non-profits that promote the arts, civics, and pre-k instruction, to accept and receive voluntary cash contributions will lessen the need for additional tax revenue, encouraging voluntary support for education without prejudice for or against any state-sponsored educational enter- prise. The bill promotes the state's interest in providing the highest quality education to all children in the state. The tax credit does not constitute public aid to non-public sectarian institutions. Addi- tionally, permitting school personnel to claim a credit for the purchase of classroom instructional materials and supplies will ensure a wider availability of such materials and supplies for all students.
"EDUCATION AFFORDABILITY" TAX CREDIT
This bill would provide a tax credit for individuals and corporate fran- chise taxpayers that make qualified contributions to:
(1) Public Schools;
(2) School Improvement Organizations or Local Education Funds, which are defined as not-for-profit organizations that provide support to public schools; or
(3) Educational Scholarship Organizations, which are defined as not-for- profit organizations that provide, at least 90% of their funds for scho- larships to eligible pupils for use at not fewer than three non-public schools.
a. Eligible pupils are defined as children that reside in a household with a federal adjusted gross income of $500,000 or less, provided however, for households with 3 or more dependent children; such income level shall be increased by $10,000 per child in excess of 2, not to exceed $550,000.
It would also allow taxpayers to claim a maximum credit amount of 90% of the taxpayer's qualified contributions, capped at $1 million plus any amount carried over from a prior year. Any amount of qualified contrib- utions that exceed tax liability for any given tax year may be carried forward for 5 years.
It would also require taxpayers to add any amount claimed as a charita- ble donation at the Federal level back to the taxpayer's New York taxa- ble income. This prevents taxpayers from using a qualified contribution as both a charitable itemized deduction and a credit against their New York State income tax.
The tax credit is capped at $150 million for 2021, $225 million for 2022, and $300 million for 2022 and thereafter. If the cap is not reached in a particular calendar year, the unused amount can be carried forward to the immediately succeeding calendar year.
*50% of the annual cap is available for qualified contributions made to public schools, School Improvement Organizations, and Local Education Funds; and *50% of annual cap is available to Educational Scholarship Organiza- tions.
It also requires an annual joint report from the Commissioners of the Departments of Taxation and Finance and Education, which shall include statistics regarding the number of qualified contributions made to each type of recipient and the distribution of the recipients by county.
"HOME-EASED INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIAL" TAX CREDIT:
Bill provides a refundable personal income tax credit for home-based instructional materials purchased by the taxpayer. Establishes that the amount of the credit is the lesser of $200 or 100% of the amount used to purchase instructional materials for home-based educational programs.
"TEACHER INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIAL" TAX CREDIT:
*Provides a refundable personal income tax credit for teachers and instructors who (1) work in a public, charter or non-public school for at least 900 hours during a taxable year; and (2) purchase classroom instructional materials and supplies that are used in classroom instruc- tion at the public, charter or non-public school for which the taxpayer is employed
*Amount of credit is the lesser of $200 or 100% of the amount used to purchase instructional materials and supplies.
"HELPING OPEN OPPORTUNITIES TO LEARN" TAX CREDIT:
Finally the bill creates an additional tax credit to low- and middle-in- come taxpayers (defined as those with income less than or equal to 720% of federal power guidelines - this would equate to a family of four in 2020).
The credit would be received for families how have qualified primary or secondary education tuition expenses.
The credit would be for the lesser of 12% of total Per Pupil State Public School Expenditures or 15% of tuition expenses.
* The FY 2021 Executive budget would provide $10,608 per pupil spending
* 12% of this amount would equal a tax credit of $1,273 for 2020-21
Legislative history
2022: S.5573 - Referred to Investigations and Government Operations
2021: S.5573 - Referred to Investigations and Government Operations
2020: S.8005 - Referred to Investigations and Government Operations
2018: S.5011 - Referred to Investigations and Government Operations
2017: S.5011 - Referred to Investigations and Government Operations
Fiscal implications
$150 million for calendar year 2021, $225 million in calendar year 2022, and $300 million for each calendar year thereafter beginning in 2023 for the tax credit based on qualified contributions; undetermined for the tax savings for the other tax credits.
Effective date
This act shall take effect immediately and shall apply to taxable years beginning after December 31, 2023
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.