Skip to content
S4882Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA2877

Strengthen Utility Storm Response

Official title

“Relates to strengthening of utility storm response and compliance”

Sponsor Shelley MayerSD-37+6 co-sponsorsAffects Economy
Status
In Assembly Committee
Corporations, Authorities And Commissions
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 5 of 7

In Assembly · Corporations, Authorities And Commissions

What's happening

This bill strengthens New York's utility storm response requirements, makes penalties for violations more severe, and expands emergency planning and oversight for regulated utilities.

Why it matters

  1. Penalty calculations for utility violations will become more nuanced and potentially much higher. , as the Public Service Commission (PSC) is directed to consider the full scope of harm—including impacts on individuals, businesses, repeat offenses, and whether prior warnings existed—rather than using flat or capped dollar amounts. This increases utilities’ financial exposure and accountability for storm response failures.

  2. The law eliminates prior limitations and distinctions on penalties for different types of violations. (e.g., those leading to injury or property damage), instead applying a broader and more detailed set of criteria for all violations. This aims to close loopholes and ensure serious or repeated failures are more likely to face substantial penalties.

  3. The bill greatly expands the scope and rigor of emergency planning requirements for regulated utilities. , mandating detailed annual emergency response plans (including communication redundancies, outreach to vulnerable customers, safety protocols, and mutual assistance agreements) for electric, gas, water, telephone, and cable companies, not just combination utilities.

  4. Regulators are granted clearer authority to investigate, require plan modifications, and withhold cost recovery if utilities fail to implement emergency plans adequately. , thus giving the PSC more tools to ensure utilities are genuinely prepared for major storms or emergencies—and not just on paper. This could result in better storm resilience and customer protection.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Strengthen Utility Storm Response

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Shelley Mayer

Senator · Senate District 37

Chair, Education

History

  1. Referred to corporations, authorities and commissions
  2. Delivered to assembly
  3. Passed senateVote 42–20
  4. Advanced to third reading
  5. 2nd report cal.
  6. 1st report cal.293
  7. Referred to energy and telecommunications
  8. Returned to senate
  9. Died in assembly
  10. Referred to corporations, authorities and commissions
  11. Delivered to assembly
  12. Passed senateVote 38–21
Show 4 earlier actions
  1. Advanced to third reading
  2. 2nd report cal.
  3. 1st report cal.877
  4. Referred to energy and telecommunications

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A2877Assembly

Strengthen Utility Storm Response

In Assembly Committee · Corporations, Authorities And Commissions · Sponsor Steven Otis

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

10 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

4882

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

February 16, 2023

Introduced by Sens. MAYER, COMRIE, HARCKHAM, HINCHEY, HOYLMAN-SIGAL, SALAZAR -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Energy and Telecommunications

AN ACT to amend the public service law, in relation to strengthening of utility storm response and compliance

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Section 25 of the public service law, as added by chapter 665 of the laws of 1980, subdivision 2, paragraph (a) of subdivision 3 and paragraph (a) of subdivision 4 as amended by chapter 375 of the laws of 1986, is amended to read as follows:

§ 25. Penalties. 1. Every public utility company, corporation or person and the officers, agents and employees thereof shall obey and comply with every provision of this chapter and every order or regulation adopted under authority of this chapter so long as the same shall be in force.

2. Any public utility company, corporation or person and the officers, agents and employees thereof that knowingly fails or neglects to obey or comply with a provision of this chapter or a regulation or [an] order adopted under authority of this chapter so long as the same shall be in force, shall forfeit to the people of the state of New York a sum [not exceeding one hundred thousand dollars constituting a civil penalty for each and every offense and, in the case of a continuing violation, each day shall be deemed a separate and distinct offense] that shall be set by the public service commission after considering the following:

(a) the scope of damages caused by the violation to individuals, businesses and the state;

(b) each individual act or omission which led to the violation;

(c) whether the violation was knowing or willful;

(d) whether the violation was recurring, or had been the subject of a previous finding by the commission;

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD07736-01-3

(e) whether the violation was of a provision of this chapter, or a regulation or order adopted under the authority of this chapter, adopted specifically for the protection of human safety, including but not limited to the commission's code of gas safety regulations, and whether the violation caused or constituted a contributing factor in bringing about a death or personal injury, as determined by the commission;

(f) whether the violation was of a provision of this chapter, or a regulation or order adopted under the authority of this chapter, specifically designed to protect the overall reliability and continuity of service, the duration of any such violation, whether such violation affected the reliability or continuity of service, the duration of any such effect on the reliability or continuity of service, and whether any effect on the reliability or continuity of service was recurring;

(g) the economic losses of ratepayers, in the form of increased service rates or otherwise, associated with damage to or weakening of infrastructure in connection with the event out of which the violation arose, including but not limited to investments and costs associated with repairing, improving, or replacing such infrastructure;

(h) whether the violation was caused in whole or in part due to the systematic failure of the entity to maintain or replace obsolete or deteriorated materials or equipment;

(i) the degree of preparation, including but not limited to the utilization of mutual aid or other contingent resources, for a storm event or other event out of which the violation arose for which there was advance warning or notice;

(j) with respect to telephone corporations, cable television companies and the officers, agents and employees thereof, whether a loss of commercial electricity caused the violation; and

(k) mitigating factors relevant to the seriousness of the violation, as determined by the commission.

3. [Notwithstanding the provisions of subdivision two of this section, any such public utility company, corporation or person and the officers, agents and employees thereof that knowingly fails or neglects to obey or comply with a provision of this chapter, or an order or regulation adopted under the authority of this chapter, adopted specifically for the protection of human safety, including but not limited to the commission's code of gas safety regulations shall, if it is determined by the commission that such safety violation caused or constituted a contributing factor in bringing about a death or personal injury, forfeit to the state of New York a sum not to exceed the greater of:

(a) two hundred and fifty thousand dollars constituting a civil penalty for each separate and distinct offense; provided, however, that for purposes of this paragraph each day of a continuing violation shall not be deemed a separate and distinct offense. The total period of a continuing violation, as well as every distinct violation, shall be similarly treated as a separate and distinct offense for purposes of this paragraph; or

(b) the maximum forfeiture determined in accordance with subdivision two of this section.

4. Notwithstanding the provisions of subdivision one or two of this section, a public utility company, corporation or person and the officers, agents and employees thereof that knowingly fails or neglects to obey or comply with a provision of this chapter, or an order or regulation adopted under authority of this chapter, designed to protect the overall reliability and continuity of electric service, shall forfeit to the state of New York a sum not to exceed the greater of:

(a) five hundred thousand dollars constituting a civil penalty for each separate and distinct offense; provided, however, that for purposes of this paragraph each day of a continuing violation shall not be deemed a separate and distinct offense. The total period of a continuing violation, as well as every distinct violation, shall be similarly treated as a separate and distinct offense for purposes of this paragraph; or

(b) the maximum forfeiture determined in accordance with subdivision two of this section.

5.] Penalties provided for pursuant to this section shall be recovered in an action as provided in section twenty-four of this article.

[6] 4. Any payment made by a public utility company, corporation or person and the officers, agents and employees thereof as a result of an action as provided in section twenty-four of this article and the cost of litigation and investigation related to any such action shall not be included by the commission in revenue requirements used to establish rates and charges.

[7] 5. In construing and enforcing the provisions of this chapter relating to forfeitures and penalties, the act of any director, officer, agent or employee of a public utility company, corporation or person acting within the scope of his or her official duties or employment shall be deemed to be the act of such public utility company, corporation or person.

§ 2. Section 25-a of the public service law, as added by section 2 of part X of chapter 57 of the laws of 2013, is amended to read as follows:

§ 25-a. Combination gas and electric corporations; administrative sanctions; recovery of penalties. Notwithstanding sections twenty-four and twenty-five of this article: 1. Every combination gas and electric corporation and the officers thereof shall adhere to every provision of this chapter and every order or regulation adopted under authority of this chapter so long as the same shall be in force.

2. (a) The commission shall have the authority to assess a civil penalty in an amount as set forth in this section and against a combination gas and electric corporation and the officers thereof subject to the jurisdiction, supervision, or regulation pursuant to this chapter [in an amount as set forth in this section. In determining the amount of any penalty to be assessed pursuant to this section, the commission shall consider: (i) the seriousness of the violation for which a penalty is sought; (ii) the nature and extent of any previous violations for which penalties have been assessed against the corporation or officer; (iii) whether there was knowledge of the violation; (iv) the gross revenues and financial status of the corporation; and (v) such other factors as the commission may deem appropriate and relevant].

The remedies provided by this subdivision are in addition to any other remedies provided in law.

(b) Whenever the commission has reason to believe that a combination gas and electric corporation or such officers thereof should be subject to imposition of a civil penalty as set forth in this subdivision, it shall notify such corporation or officer. Such notice shall include, but shall not be limited to: (i) the date and a brief description of the facts and nature of each act or failure to act for which such penalty is proposed; (ii) a list of each statute, regulation or order that the commission alleges has been violated; [and] (iii) the amount of each penalty that the commission proposes to [assess] be assessed; and (iv) any proposed actions that the commission deems necessary to address such alleged violation or violations. The commission is authorized to undertake any additional administrative or investigatory actions related to such violation or violations, including but not limited to, service of an administrative complaint, implementation of discovery, interviews, depositions, entering into a settlement agreement or other stipulation, and the holding of evidentiary hearings, as provided in this chapter.

(c) Whenever the commission has reason to believe that a combination gas and electric corporation or such officers thereof should be subject to imposition of a civil penalty or penalties as set forth in this subdivision, the commission shall hold a hearing to demonstrate why the proposed penalty or penalties should be assessed against such combination gas and electric corporation or such officers.

3. Any combination gas and electric corporation or such officers thereof determined by the commission to have failed to [reasonably] comply as shown by a preponderance of the evidence, at an evidentiary hearing, with a provision of this chapter, regulation or an order adopted under authority of this chapter so long as the same shall be in force shall forfeit a sum [not exceeding the greater of one hundred thousand dollars or two one-hundredths of one percent of the annual intrastate gross operating revenue of the corporation, not including taxes paid to and revenues collected on behalf of government entities, constituting a civil penalty for each and every offense and, in the case of a continuing violation, each day shall be deemed a separate and distinct offense] that shall be set by the public service commission, after considering the following:

(a) the scope of damages caused by the violation to individuals, businesses and the state;

(b) each individual act or omission which led to the violation;

(c) whether the violation was knowing or willful;

(d) whether the violation was recurring, or had been the subject of a previous finding by the commission;

(e) whether the violation was of a provision of this chapter, or a regulation or order adopted under the authority of this chapter, adopted specifically for the protection of human safety, including but not limited to the commission's code of gas safety regulations, and whether the violation caused or constituted a contributing factor in bringing about a death or personal injury, as determined by the commission;

(f) whether the violation was of a provision of this chapter, or a regulation or order adopted under the authority of this chapter, specifically designed to protect the overall reliability and continuity of service, the duration of any such violation, whether such violation affected the reliability or continuity of service, the duration of any such effect on the reliability or continuity of service, and whether any effect on the reliability or continuity of service was recurring;

(g) the economic losses of ratepayers, in the form of increased service rates or otherwise, associated with damage to or weakening of infrastructure in connection with the event out of which the violation arose, including but not limited to investments and costs associated with repairing, improving, or replacing such infrastructure;

(h) whether the violation was caused in whole or in part due to the systematic failure of the entity to maintain or replace obsolete or deteriorated materials or equipment;

(i) the degree of preparation, including but not limited to the utilization of mutual aid or other contingent resources, for a storm event or other event out of which the violation arose for which there was advance warning or notice;

(j) with respect to any telephone corporation or cable television company to which this section applies by reason of the application of section twenty-five-b of this article, and with respect to any officer of any such telephone corporation or cable television company, whether a loss of commercial electricity caused the violation; and

(k) mitigating factors relevant to the seriousness of the violation, as determined by the commission.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the public service law, in relation to strengthening of utility storm response and compliance

Purpose

To incentivize better regulatory compliance by utilities through increased flexibility for the Public Service Commission to assess penal- ties on utilities for violations of the public service law, and to expand emergency response plan requirements.

Summary of provisions

Section 1 amends section 25 of the public service law to eliminate the statutory limits on penalties for violations by public utility compa- nies, and to institute a new process by which the public service commis- sion sets a penalty after consideration of a number of factors relevant to the violation in question.

Read the full memo (877 words)

Section 2 amends section 25-a of the public service law to alter the provisions relating to imposing penalties on combination gas and elec- tric corporations, including by eliminating the statutory limits on penalties for violations, instituting a new process by which the public service commission sets a penalty after consideration of a number of factors relevant to the violation in question, removing the qualifica- tion of "reasonable" compliance with law from the determination as to whether a violation occurred, and providing for an evidentiary hearing in connection with such determination.

Section 3 applies the provisions of section 25-a to other regulated utilities.

Section 4 amends emergency response plan requirements to augment the standards for communication systems and remove the qualification of "reasonable" compliance.

Section 5 amends section 94 of the public service law to apply detailed emergency response plan requirements to telephone companies.

Section 6 amends section 216 of the public service law to apply detailed emergency response plan requirements to cable television companies.

Section 7 provides for severability. Section 8 sets the effective date.

Justification

Following utility service outages in several recent storms such as Quinn, Riley, and Isaias, the Public Service Commission (PSC) conducted inquiries into the emergency response performance of a number of utili- ties. While the PSC found violations and assessed penalties, it cited statutory limitations on the penalties it could impose as a factor in its determination as to the size of those penalties.

Notwithstanding the alleged (and in some cases, admitted) violations with respect to an inadequate emergency response plan in connection with storms Quinn and Riley, customers experienced sustained outages and insufficient communications following Tropical Storm Isaias just over two years later. This suggests that penalties are insufficient to incen- tivize a change in behavior, and that utilities appear to view current statutory penalties as simply a cost of doing business. A pattern of major outages, poor planning, poor communication, and poor customer service are unacceptable at any time, but the failures of utilities in the wake of Tropical Storm Isaias were particularly hard on customers because the COVID-19 pandemic forced many people to work remotely and otherwise avoid leaving home. This situation predictably magnified the consequences of sustained outages on customers, including threats to health and safety, yet utilities did not calibrate their emergency response accordingly.

This bill addresses the inadequate incentives for utilities to improve by achieving two goals: (1) enhanced capacity for the PSC to impose penalties significant enough to be a true deterrent to future violations; and (2) expansion of emergency response plan requirements to ensure that utilities devote more resources to proper planning. The penalty provisions of this bill are significant. Eliminating the statu- tory limits on penalties will mean greatly increased liability for util- ities in the event of violations, thereby better incentivizing compli- ance. By requiring the PSC to assess penalties based on an enumerated set of factors, this approach also allows for the imposition of penal- ties that are proportionate to the violations in question. Further, utilities have in the past argued broadly against the need to assume responsibility for poor performance by pointing to "reasonable" compli- ance with the law. To foreclose arguments about whether a utility "reasonably" complied, and to hold utilities to account for poor performance, the bill removes the "reasonably" qualifier. Finally, these stronger penalty provisions are extended to cover utilities other than combination gas and electric corporations.

In a similar vein, this bill extends emergency response plan require- ments to telephone and cable television companies. Emergency response plans (ERPs) detail, inter alia, how a utility plans to restore service, communicate with the public and government officials regarding service interruptions, and ensure a safe and efficient response overall. Currently, only electric corporations are statutorily required to prepare ERPs with a high level of detail and to make them publicly available, thus limiting PSC oversight of other utilities. Expanding the scope of ERP requirements to include telephone companies and cable companies (which provide valuable communication and information dissem- ination services during storms and other major events) will provide for greater accountability to the public, in no small part because it allows the PSC to assess penalties for failure to adhere to ERPs.

Prior legislative history

2021-2022: S4960/A7065, passed Senate; referred to Corporations, Author- ities and Commissions in Assembly

Fiscal implications

TBD

Effective date

This act shall take effect 90 days after becoming law, provided that the department of public service or the public service commission is author- ized to promulgate any regulations or orders necessary to implement the act, effective immediately.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.