Skip to content
S5137Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA4721

Allow Class Actions Against Government

Official title

“Relates to prohibiting a court from denying class certification solely because the action involves governmental operations”

Sponsor Kristen GonzalezSD-59+1 co-sponsorAffects Finance
Status
Senate Floor Calendar
Impact
7/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Vetoed via A4721

What's happening

This bill ensures courts cannot deny class action certification solely because a case involves governmental operations.

Why it matters

  1. Expands access to collective legal remedies. By preventing courts from denying class action certification just because a case involves government operations, the bill allows more people to challenge government actions as a group, making it easier for individuals with similar grievances to seek justice together.

  2. Levels the legal playing field. Government agencies often have more resources than individual plaintiffs. Class actions can help balance this disparity, allowing affected individuals to pool their resources and mount a stronger case against potentially harmful or unlawful government practices.

  3. Promotes governmental accountability. Allowing class actions in cases involving government operations can put additional pressure on public agencies to comply with the law and correct systemic issues, since the threat of group litigation may deter misconduct or negligence.

  4. Clarifies court procedures. The bill provides clear guidance to judges, ensuring that government involvement alone cannot be used as a technicality to block class action suits, potentially reducing inconsistent rulings and increasing predictability in the legal process.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Plaintiffs seeking class certification in cases involving governmental operations

    The bill would prevent courts from denying or withholding certification solely because a case involves governmental operations.

  • Government agencies facing class actions

    Governmental operations alone would no longer be a sufficient basis for denying class certification in cases involving their activities.

  • Judges deciding class certification motions

    Courts would have to apply the new restriction while continuing to require that the existing class action prerequisites be satisfied.

Headline styles

Allow Class Actions Against Government

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Kristen Gonzalez

Senator · Senate District 59

Chair, Internet And Technology

1 Co-sponsor

History

  1. Substituted by A4721
  2. Advanced to third reading
  3. 2nd report cal.
  4. 1st report cal.1280
  5. Reported and committed to finance
  6. Referred to judiciary

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A4721Assembly

Protect Class Action Rights

Vetoed · Sponsor Michaelle C. Solages

Impact 6 · ModerateVetoed

Full text

2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

S. 5137 A. 4721

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

SENATE - ASSEMBLY

February 23, 2023

IN SENATE -- Introduced by Sen. GONZALEZ -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Judiciary

IN ASSEMBLY -- Introduced by M. of A. SOLAGES -- read once and referred to the Committee on Codes

AN ACT to amend the civil practice law and rules, in relation to certification of class actions in cases involving governmental operations

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Section 902 of the civil practice law and rules, as amended by chapter 474 of the laws of 1975, is amended to read as follows:

§ 902. Order allowing class action. Within sixty days after the time to serve a responsive pleading has expired for all persons named as defendants in an action brought as a class action, the plaintiff shall move for an order to determine whether it is to be so maintained. An order under this section may be conditional, and may be altered or amended before the decision on the merits on the court's own motion or on motion of the parties. The action may be maintained as a class action only if the court finds that the prerequisites under section 901 have been satisfied. Among the matters which the court shall consider in determining whether the action may proceed as a class action are:

1. the interest of members of the class in individually controlling the prosecution or defense of separate actions;

2. the impracticability or inefficiency of prosecuting or defending separate actions;

3. the extent and nature of any litigation concerning the controversy already commenced by or against members of the class;

4. the desirability or undesirability of concentrating the litigation of the claim in the particular forum;

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD02064-01-3

5. the difficulties likely to be encountered in the management of a class action.

However, a court shall not deny or withhold class certification solely because the action involves governmental operations.

§ 2. This act shall take effect immediately.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the civil practice law and rules, in relation to certif- ication of class actions in cases involving governmental operations

Purpose

The civil practice law and rules is amended to provide that a court may not deny or withhold class certification solely because the action involves governmental operations. This bill will not require the court to certify a class. More importantly, this bill will specify once the requirements of article 9 are satisfied, certification cannot be denied solely because the case involves governmental operations.

Summary

Section 1. Amends section 902 of the civil practice law and rules, as amended by chapter 474 of the laws of 1975.

Read the full memo (965 words)

Section 2. Sets the effective date

Justification

In New York State, courts have generally been unwilling to certify a class action when governmental operations are involved, reasoning that a class action is not superior to other available methods to litigants. The idea that the government is a special litigant is incorrect and unjust - all New Yorkers should be able to stand equally before the courts. Low-income and older New Yorkers are more likely to be a plain- tiff in a class action suit due to a lack of resources to bring individ- ual actions. Making it harder to bring justice when government agencies act illegally only further enables them to continue harmful practices. This legislation seeks to prevent a court from denying or withholding class certification solely because a lawsuit involves governmental oper- ations and allow all New Yorkers the opportunity to seek justice while streamlining the litigation process in the courts.

Legal Services for New York City, a not-for-profit organization that provides legal service for low-income people, supports this bill. The courts reason that a class action is not superior to other available methods (and thus fails to satisfy the requirement of § 901 (a) (5)) because the doctrine of (STARE DECISIS) provides adequate protection to putative class members. (JONES V. BERMAN), 37 N.Y. 2d 42, 57 (1975). A judgment in favor of the plaintiff may protect (SUBSEQUENT) or (FUTURE) litigants under the doctrine of (STARE DECISIS) However, it will have no effect whatsoever on persons who already have been and will be adversely affected by an agency's policies from the date the action was filed until a final determination. (SEE TINDELL V. KOCH), 154 A.D. 2nd 689, 565 N.Y.S. 2nd 789, 792 (1st Dep't 1991). (STARE DECISIS) applies only after the final determination has been reached in an action that has not been certified as a class action. Potential class members already adversely affected by the agency's policy while the lawsuit is still pending would obtain no relief at all, unless they commenced individual actions before a final determination in order to preserve their rights to the relief sought in a similar proceeding. (SEE ALSO LAMBOY V. GROSS), 129 Misc. 2nd 564, 493 N.Y.S.2nd 709, (AFF'D) 126 A.D. 2nd 265, 513 N.Y.S. 2nd 393 (1st Dep't 1987). Thus, class certification is supe- rior to this doctrine of (STARE DECISIS) to insure relief to members of a proposed class who have already been or will be affected by a govern- mental agency's policy before a final decision is issued in a lawsuit.

Moreover, it is often the case that persons who are similarly situated to the plaintiff in a lawsuit already filed are individuals who are low-income, elderly, or differently-abled, in which it would be increas- ingly difficult to pursue actions. Class action is the best method to protect these potential class members. Finally, even if a person were able to obtain free legal representation for their individual claims, the multiplicity of lawsuits seeking the identical relief can give rise to inconsistent rulings by various state courts. This results in unnec- essary expenditure of energy and judicial resources, forcing the legal service bar, the Attorney General's office and the courts repeatedly to litigate and decide the same issues of law. Despite the court's assump- tion that governmental agencies follow the rules of law laid down by court decisions, potential class members continually confront the reali- ty that successes in non-class actions are applied only to the individ- ually named plaintiffs rather than to all those similarly situated.

In sum, § 902 of the CPLR should be amended to specify that once the requirements of the class action provisions of article 9 are satisfied, certification cannot be denied on the grounds that because the case involves a governmental agency, the court's decision will be applied to all individuals similarly situated.

Racial justice impact

Government agencies that act illegally most severely harm low-income communities of color. Further, individuals with fewer resources are more likely to enter into a class action lawsuit because they are unable to take individual action.

We have witnessed class action lawsuits go forward to address discrimi- nation and low standards of care that impact the most vulnerable such as in the cases of Merton Simpson v. Department of Civil Service, City of New York v. Maul, Fleming v. Barnwell Nursing Home & Health Facilities, and Brad H. v. City of New York.

This bill will ensure that a large amount of New York's population will be able to stand equally before the courts as a collective in instances of injustice involving governmental operations.

Gender justice impact

TBD.

Prior legislative history

1995-96: A4933; passed Assembly.

1997-98: A3289; passed Assembly.

1999-2000: A3299; passed Assembly.

2001-02: A7700; passed Assembly.

2003-04: A5942; passed Assembly.

2005-06: A6929; passed Assembly.

2007-08: A4131; passed Assembly.

2009-10: A5019; passed Assembly.

2011-12: A2334; passed Assembly.

2013-14: A6871; advanced to third reading.

2015-16: A2191; advanced to third reading.

2017-18: A3181; referred to Codes.

2019-20: A2446; referred to Codes.

2021-22: A6501; passed Assembly.

Fiscal implications

None.

Effective date

This act shall take effect immediately.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.