Skip to content
S5269Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA5735

Faster Child Support Conferences

Official title

“Authorizes expedited settlement conference processes for establishing child support orders”

Sponsor Roxanne J. PersaudSD-19+2 co-sponsorsAffects Legal
Status
In Senate Committee
Rules
Impact
6/10
Moderate
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Rules

What's happening

This bill authorizes New York family courts to create expedited settlement conferences for parents who agree on child support orders.

Why it matters

  1. Streamlines Child Support for Cooperative Parents. This bill creates a faster process for parents who already agree on child support, potentially reducing court time, stress, and legal expenses compared to traditional hearings.

  2. Limits to Appropriate Cases. The expedited option is not available for complex or high-conflict situations—such as cases involving minor parents without attorneys, parentage disputes, existing orders of protection, or when spousal support is also in question—helping to protect vulnerable parties and ensure fairness.

  3. Emphasizes Transparency and Consent. Parties are informed of their rights, including the right to counsel, voluntary participation, and the impact of their agreement (especially regarding future modifications), aiming to prevent misunderstandings and coercion.

  4. Requires Data Reporting and Oversight. The courts must publish annual data on how often expedited conferences are used, success rates, and reasons for exclusion or failure, enabling ongoing public and legislative evaluation of the policy's effectiveness and equity.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Faster Child Support Conferences

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Roxanne J. Persaud

Senator · Senate District 19

Chair, Social Services

History

  1. Committed to rules
  2. Advanced to third reading
  3. 2nd report cal.
  4. 1st report cal.779
  5. Referred to judiciary
  6. Committed to rules
  7. Advanced to third reading
  8. 2nd report cal.
  9. 1st report cal.646
  10. Referred to judiciary

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A5735Assembly

Faster Child Support Settlements

In Assembly Committee · Judiciary · Sponsor Karines Reyes

Impact 6 · Moderate0% to pass

Full text

4 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

5269

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

March 1, 2023

Introduced by Sen. PERSAUD -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Judiciary

AN ACT to amend the family court act, in relation to authorizing expedited settlement conference processes for establishing child support orders

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subdivisions (c) and (d) of section 439-a of the family court act are relettered (d) and (e) and a new subdivision (c) is added to read as follows:

(c) (i) Purpose. To authorize the development of expedited settlement conference processes in each family court to facilitate the establishment of child support orders pursuant to section four hundred thirteen of this article consistent with the state's child support guidelines for parents who agree on child support and seek to voluntarily engage in a settlement conference, expedited settlement conferences shall be authorized and developed pursuant to this section. Such expedited settlement conferences are not for the purpose of parents' negotiation or mediation of disputes concerning income or issues related to the determination of child support. Further, such expedited settlement conferences are not for use in actions brought by public welfare officials for support pursuant to subdivision one of section one hundred two of the social services law. The court administration shall promulgate or amend forms as necessary to implement the terms of this section.

(ii) Initiating the expedited settlement conference. (A) An expedited settlement conference may be initiated:

(1) by a petitioner selecting the option for a conference on the petition, with no objection by the respondent.

(2) by referral from a family court.

(B) Parties seeking to engage in an expedited settlement conference shall apply for child support services pursuant to title IV-d of the

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD09871-01-3

federal social security act, either by indication on the petition for support or on the stipulation for child support.

(C) The following cases shall be excluded from an expedited settlement conference process:

(1) Cases that involve minor parents who are unrepresented by legal counsel.

(2) Cases that require a determination of parentage.

(3) Cases between parties who are also parties to a temporary or final order of protection issued by any court of competent jurisdiction.

(4) Cases that involve spousal support in addition to child support.

(iii) Exchange of financial affidavits and supporting documentation. The parties shall exchange financial affidavits and supporting documentation in accordance with section four hundred twenty-four-a of this article, unless the parties expressly waive all or further financial disclosure.

(iv) Conduct of the conference. (A) At the outset of the expedited settlement conference, the parties shall be informed as to how the conference will proceed. Such notice shall include, but not be limited to:

(1) that the parties have a right to consult with or retain an attorney prior to reaching agreement;

(2) that participation in the conference is voluntary and that, at any time during the conference, either party can indicate that they choose to discontinue the conference for any reason;

(3) that section four hundred twenty-four-a of the family court act requires parties to a support case to engage in financial disclosure and that there shall be no further financial disclosure or discovery if the parties achieve a validly executed child support agreement through the expedited settlement conference process; and

(4) that child support orders, including court-ordered agreements, can be modified on the bases enumerated in section four hundred fifty-one of this article and as listed on the stipulation for child support form, and that a validly executed agreement between the parties opting out of the bases for modification under subparagraphs (i) and (ii) of paragraph (b) of subdivision three of section four hundred fifty-one of this article means those bases will not be available to a party seeking modification of the court-ordered agreement in the future.

(B) For the purposes of this section, the family court staff facilitating the conference shall review the financial affidavit submitted by each party and any other documentation or information provided by the parties and shall complete a child support guidelines worksheet to calculate the support obligation.

(C) The family court staff facilitating the conference shall review the child support guidelines worksheet with the parties and the support obligation resulting from the calculations and confirm that the parties received and had the opportunity to review a copy of the child support standards chart promulgated by the commissioner of the office of temporary and disability assistance pursuant to section one hundred eleven-i of the social services law.

(D) Where the combined parental income exceeds the amount set forth in paragraph (b) of subdivision two of section one hundred eleven-i of the social services law, the parties shall be informed at the expedited settlement conference that the law permits, but does not require, the use of the child support percentages in calculating the child support obligation on the income above the statutory cap and that the child support obligation for parental income above the statutory cap may be determined pursuant to the factors listed in paragraph (f) of subdivision one of section four hundred thirteen of this article as an alternative to applying the child support percentages.

(E) To the extent resources are available in a family court, the expedited settlement conference and subsequent appearances before a support magistrate may be held virtually upon consent of the parties and in accordance with subdivision (c) of section four hundred thirty-three of this part.

(F) The court shall provide interpretation services for parties in expedited child support settlement conferences when a court determines that a party or witness, or an interested parent or guardian of a minor party in such proceeding, is unable to understand and communicate in English to the extent that he or she cannot meaningfully participate in such proceedings. The clerk of the court or another designated administrative officer shall schedule an interpreter at no expense from an approved list maintained by the office of court administration. The court may permit an interpreter to interpret by telephone or live audiovisual means. If no pre-approved interpreter is available, the clerk of the court or another designated administrative officer shall schedule an interpreter at no expense as justice requires. This subparagraph shall not alter or diminish the court's authority and duty to assure justness in proceedings before it. A person with limited English proficiency, other than a person testifying as a witness, may waive a court-appointed interpreter, with the consent of the court, if the person provides his or her own interpreter at his or her own expense.

(v) Issuance of a child support stipulation or referral to a support magistrate; effect. (A) If an expedited settlement conference results in an agreement of the parties, each party shall sign the child support stipulation and same shall be provided to a support magistrate for review and confirmation on the date of the conference. A child support order issued under this section and confirmed by a court pursuant to section four hundred twenty-five of this article constitutes an order of the court and is enforceable by any means available for the enforcement of child support obligations under this part, this article, article five-b of this chapter, article fifty-two of the civil practice law and rules, or any other applicable provisions of law.

(B) If a conference does not result in agreement by all parties to the child support order, the parties shall be referred to a support magistrate on the date of the conference for continued proceedings on the petition for support.

(vi) Evaluation and data reporting. The court administration shall make publicly available an annual report on data related to measures of the operation and impact of family court expedited settlement conference processes including, but not limited to:

(A) the number of support orders established through expedited settlement conference processes.

(B) the average time required to complete the process for cases where parties reach agreement such as the time between filing and issuance of child support order upon stipulation.

(C) the number of cases in which the expedited settlement conference process is deemed unavailable to parties because they are also parties to a temporary or final order of protection.

(D) the percentage of cases in which the expedited settlement conference process is begun but then terminated without resulting in a stipulation for child support.

§ 2. This act shall take effect on the one hundred twentieth day after it shall have become a law. Effective immediately, the addition, amendment and/or repeal of any rule or regulation necessary for the implementation of this act on its effective date are authorized to be made and completed on or before such effective date.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the family court act, in relation to authorizing expe- dited settlement conference processes for establishing child support orders

Purpose of bill

This legislation provides for the development of expedited settlement conference processes in each family court to facilitate the establish- ment of child support orders consistent with the state's child support guidelines for parents who agree on child support and seek to voluntar- ily engage in a settlement conference.

Summary of provisions

Section 1 amends section 439-a of the family court act by adding a new section 439-a(c) providing for the development of expedited settlement conference processes in each family court to facilitate the establish- ment of child support orders pursuant to section four hundred thirteen of the family court act consistent with the state's child support guide- lines for parents who agree on child support and seek to voluntarily engage in a settlement conference.

Read the full memo (2,544 words)

Section 1 provides that the expedited settlement conference is initiated by the petitioner selecting an option for a conference on the petition (with no objection by the respondent) or by referral from a family court. It provides that certain cases are excluded from an expedited settlement conference process under this section including: (i) cases that involve minor parents who are unrepresented by legal counsel; (ii) cases that require a determination of parentage; (iii) cases between parties who are also parties to a temporary or final order of protection issued by any court of competent jurisdiction; and (iv) cases that involve spousal support in addition to child support.

Section 1 sets forth that the parties shall exchange financial affida- vits and supporting documentation in accordance with section four hundred twenty-four-a of the family court act unless the parties expressly waive all or further financial disclosure.

It further describes the conduct of the conference, including the requirement that parties shall be informed as to how the conference will proceed.

Section 1 provides that the family court staff facilitating the confer- ence shall review the financial affidavit submitted by each party and any other documentation or information provided by the parties and shall complete a child support guidelines worksheet to calculate the support obligation and shall review the worksheet with the parties and confirm that the parties received and had the opportunity to review a copy of the child support standards chart promulgated by the Commissioner of the New York State Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance pursuant to section one hundred eleven-i of the social services law.

It further provides that where the combined parental income exceeds the amount set forth in paragraph (b) of subdivision two of section one hundred eleven-i of the social services law, the parties shall be informed at the expedited settlement conference that the law permits, but does not require, the use of the child support percentages in calcu- lating the child support obligation on the income above the statutory cap and that the child support obligation for parental income above the statutory cap may be determined pursuant to the factors listed in subdi- vision (0 of section four hundred thirteen of the family court act as an alternative to applying the child support percentages.

Section 1 states that to the extent resources are available in a family court, the expedited settlement conference and subsequent appearances before a support magistrate may be held virtually upon consent of the parties and in accordance with subdivision (c) of section four hundred thirty-three of the family court act and that expedited child support settlement conferences are considered proceedings in civil cases in the trial courts such that Part 217.1 of the Uniform Rules for the N.Y. Trial Courts applies and obligates the court to provide interpretation services for parties in expedited child support settlement conferences as needed.

Section 1 further provides that if an expedited settlement conference results in an agreement of the parties, each party shall sign the child support stipulation and same shall be provided to a support magistrate for review and confirmation on the date of the conference. If a confer- ence does not result in agreement by all parties to the child support order, the parties shall be referred to a support magistrate on the date of the conference for further proceedings in the case.

Finally, Section 1 directs the court administration to make publicly available an annual report on data related to certain enumerated meas- ures of the operation and impact of family court expedited child support settlement conference processes.

Section 2 provides that the act shall take effect on the one hundred and twentieth day after it becomes law.

Justification

This legislation develops an expedited settlement conference process for child support cases in the New York Family Courts for parents who choose to reach agreement on child support and do not dispute income available for support. This legislation brings needed attention to a significant economic justice issue for families, especially for those living in poverty, and an area of civil justice that demands reform. Child support is of critical importance to families: it affects 16 million children and 11 million mothers in the U.S. For the lowest income house- holds nationwide, child support from another parent living separately can comprise more than 57% of income. Thus, the child support system plays a critical role in determining economic justice for single parents and children living in poverty.

New York primarily utilizes its courts to determine child support for families, with the state child support agency handling child support collection, enforcement, and some support establishment. Child support is calculated pursuant to the New York Child Support Standards Act, which was enacted in 1989 to provide a fair and consistent method for determining child support payments based on parental income. For some parents, proof of income is straightforward, for example, where the parent earns traditional W-2 tax reportable income. For others who are paid in cash or own a business with complicated or incomplete records, proof of income can be challenging and the process to obtain it through litigation lengthy. (Litigation can become more challenging where parents hide or under-disclose income; that more than 90% of parents in child support courts have no legal representation makes fair support in many cases even more difficult to obtain. )

The courts are uniquely equipped to handle these disputed or complex matters. Yet the current judicial system is one-size-fits-all, so that both complicated and straightforward cases proceed through the same courthouse doors. With the vast majority of New York's child support establishment being handled through a judicial system, the courts are flooded with child support cases. In 2019 alone, there were almost 200,000 filings for child support in the New York Family and Supreme/Integrated Domestic Violence Courts, representing more than one-third of the family law petitions filed in the state. Without triaging based on type or complexity of case, courts experience serious delays even where they could be avoided - especially egregious in straightforward matters - and hold case appearances that are often brief and superficial without the time needed to address the key issues. In addition to both reflecting and causing system inefficiencies, court delays are the worst enemy of custodial parents who are living in pover- ty. Indeed, many parents may decide to forego child support orders alto- gether where court delays threaten job loss because of missed days of work, or because they must secure childcare for days in court that they cannot afford. For noncustodial parents who cannot afford to pay child support, court inefficiencies can also be costly in terms of missed days of work.

The inefficiencies around obtaining child support in the courts have been exacerbated since the start of the COVID19 pandemic when the New York Family Courts largely closed for petitions to establish child support, deferring this needed support for some indefinitely, and other relief in support cases. In 2020, the number of filings dropped to approximately half of the typical number in previous years, and this continued in 2021 and 2022. The courts were slow to regain full func- tionality in some jurisdictions, especially in New York City where the courts typically received more than 60,000 filings for child support annually pre-pandemic. This created a backlog of cases, but the courts have not publicized a plan to address this crisis. And challenges around making the courts fully accessible both in person and virtually - have highlighted both the need and opportunity for innovative justice solutions. One way to improve the child support system is to expand the "menu of options" for parents whose children need support. The expedited settlement conference process developed through this legislation is designed for parents who seek to voluntarily agree to child support in accordance with the Child Support Standards Act. (State law provides the opportunity for parents to agree to child support; once parents are advised of the presumptive amount of support under the Child Support Standards Act, they can agree to "deviate" from that amount and record the reasons for deviation in a written agreement.) The conferences would be held in the Family Courts where parents file for child support and would be facilitated by trained court staff. (Court staff facilitating the conferences should be court attorneys and/or trained on applicable law and competent to deliver legal information to litigants.) In the conference, parents would provide proof of income and finances (unless they expressly waive this disclosure requirement), and staff would complete the child support worksheet and inform them of the child support guidelines calculation. The conference process for reaching an agreement would be expedited: parties engaging in the process would meet with court staff for a conference on the return date (which could be held virtually) and, where the parties sign a stipulation, it would be transmitted to a support magistrate that day for review and signa- ture. If parents do not reach agreement in the expedited settlement conference, they would appear before the support magistrate for further proceedings in the litigation. The expedited settlement conference proc- ess would not be utilized where one parent is a minor without legal representation or where parentage needs to be established, or for those who are seeking spousal support in addition to child support. Families utilizing the expedited settlement conference process with combined parental income above the "cap" under New York State law for application of the child support guidelines would be informed on relevant law for applying the child support percentage to this above the cap income, and expressly agree to,the application of the guidelines or factors under N.Y. Family Court Act 413(f).

The expedited settlement conference process authorized by this proposal excludes parties that are also parties to a temporary or final order of protection from any court of competent jurisdiction. This recognizes that reaching voluntary agreement on child support may be difficult where one parent is experiencing or has experienced a pattern of behav- ior used by the other parent to establish and maintain power and control over them, as domestic violence is defined by the New York State Office to Prevent Domestic Violence. At the same time, given the national prevalence of domestic violence, we know that many families involved in child support proceedings in the New York Family Courts are experiencing or have experienced domestic violence in the very relationships that involve children on whose behalf they are utilizing the courts to estab- lish child support. At present, there is no uniform training on domestic violence for court personnel involved in child support proceedings in the New York Family Courts or screening for domestic violence among litigants in child support proceedings. We urge the Office of Court Administration (OCA) to explore developing training on domestic violence for all court staff involved in child support proceedings in the New York Family Courts, including staff facilitating the expedited settle- ment conference processes authorized under this legislation, and screen- ing tools and processes for domestic violence among litigants. To the extent possible, OCA could leverage and adapt existing resources in other areas, such as the domestic violence screening tool and training guide developed by the DV/IPV Stakeholders Group it convened in connection with its initiative to offer alternative dispute resolution in some New York courts.

This proposal will benefit the child support system, the family court system overall, and families who depend on them. Developing an expedited settlement conference process to handle straightforward child support needs would reduce the volume of pending child support cases in the courts, infusing the judicial system with needed efficiency. Those fami- lies whose circumstances require or would benefit from judicial atten- tion in court would get it, and the system overall would engage in a better use of jurists' time and expertise. Moreover, the expedited settlement conference process would provide more efficient justice for parents whose circumstances do not require litigation and who choose to engage in a more streamlined process to achieve a child support agree- ment and order. The legislation situates these conferences in court with due process protections and judicial oversight of the agreement, ensur- ing fairness for parents. And significantly, the expedited settlement conference process developed through this legislation would help ensure fair support to children more quickly. Models in other states provide guidance, including Massachusetts, which implemented a similar confer- ence process during the COVID-19 pandemic to address a backlog in child support cases in court and resolved over 9,000 cases in one year. The proposed new conference process is cost-effective. All cases handled through an expedited settlem ent process would be considered "IV-D cases" under Title IV-D of the federal Social Security Act and families would be entitled to collection and enforcement services through the State's child support agencies. Since the courts' expedited settlement processes would involve IV-D cases, any new resources or portion of existing resources that are allocated to the proposed new processes would be considered child support program activities under Title 1V-D and would be eligible for 66 percent reimbursement under Federal Finan- cial Participation funding. Further, to the extent the expedited settle- ment conference processes improve New York's performance under federally established child support program measures, there is a potential for an increased federal child support incentive award for the State.

To evaluate the expedited conference process and generate publicly available data about the process, the legislation provides that the court administration shall make publicly available an annual report on data related to the following measures of the operation and impact of family court expedited settlement conference processes: the number of support orders established through expedited settlement conference proc- esses; the average time required to complete the process for cases where parties reach agreement (i.e., the time between filing and issuance of child support order upon stipulation); the number of cases in which the expedited settlement conference process is deemed unavailable to parties because they are also parties to a temporary or final order of protection; and the percentage of cases in which the expedited settle- ment conference process is begun but then terminated without resulting in a stipulation for child support.

Fiscal implications

To be determined in accordance with federal Title IV-D funds available to the State.

Effective date

This act shall take effect on the one hundred and twentieth day after it becomes law.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.