Skip to content
S5398Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA2868

Require Judges Be Licensed

Official title

“Relates to the right of defendants in misdemeanor or felony cases to have such matter appear before a judge or justice admitted to practice law in New York”

Sponsor Brad Hoylman-SigalSD-47Affects Legal
Status
In Senate Committee
Judiciary
Impact
7/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Judiciary

What's happening

This bill allows defendants in misdemeanor or felony cases to choose to have their case heard only by a judge admitted to practice law in New York.

Why it matters

  1. Expands defendants’ rights. This bill gives defendants in misdemeanor or felony cases the ability to require that their case be heard by a judge or justice who is a licensed attorney in New York, which could improve the quality and consistency of legal rulings, especially in smaller towns where non-lawyer judges are common.

  2. Limits non-lawyer judges’ authority. Although non-lawyer justices can still handle certain preliminary matters (like arraignments, bail, and orders of protection), they would no longer preside over the full case if the defendant elects to have a lawyer-judge, potentially reducing the influence of lay justices in criminal proceedings.

  3. Aims to protect due process. By ensuring access to a judge with formal legal training upon request, the bill addresses concerns about fairness, legal expertise, and defendants’ rights, especially in rural or less-populated areas where non-lawyer judges have historically overseen serious criminal matters.

  4. Seeks smoother implementation. The bill requires the court system to create clear rules and timely procedures so defendants are properly informed of this new right and cases are reassigned with minimal delay, aiming to prevent court backlogs or confusion.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Defendants charged with misdemeanors or felonies in justice courts

    They could elect in writing, within the specified deadline, to proceed before a judge admitted to practice law in New York, subject to exceptions for specified proceedings.

  • Justice court judges not admitted to practice law in New York

    They could still handle specified proceedings after an election, including arraignments, pleas, bail, counsel assignments and temporary orders of protection.

  • Defense attorneys and prosecutors

    They would need to account for an election deadline tied to the first appearance involving certain defense motions or court decisions on prosecution motions.

  • Chief administrator of the courts

    The bill would require rules and an election form to ensure timely notice to defendants and assignment to attorney judges with minimum practicable delay and burden to the parties.

Headline styles

Require Judges Be Licensed

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Brad Hoylman-Sigal

Senator · Senate District 47

Chair, Judiciary

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to judiciary
  2. Referred to judiciary

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A2868Assembly

Require Judges Be Licensed

In Assembly Committee · Judiciary · Sponsor Daniel O'Donnell

Impact 7 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

5398

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

March 3, 2023

Introduced by Sen. HOYLMAN-SIGAL -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Judiciary

AN ACT to amend the uniform justice court act, in relation to the right of defendants in misdemeanor or felony cases to have such matter appear before a judge or justice admitted to practice law in New York

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. The uniform justice court act is amended by adding a new section 105-a to read as follows: § 105-a. Election to proceed in certain criminal actions.

a. A defendant appearing in a justice court pursuant to an accusatory instrument that charges a misdemeanor or felony may elect to proceed in such matter only before a justice or judge admitted to practice law in this state. Such election shall be by written instrument in a form prescribed by the chief administrator of the courts and shall be filed with such court not later than the completion of the first appearance at which either the defendant makes a motion or such court decides a motion made by the prosecutor, other than a motion in relation to any matter specified in subdivision b of this section.

b. Notwithstanding an election pursuant to subdivision a of this section, a justice or judge not admitted to practice law in this state may arraign the defendant, enter a plea, vacate a plea entered by such justice or judge, issue or modify a securing order, fix or modify bail, assign counsel, conduct a proceeding pursuant to article one hundred seventy or one hundred eighty of the criminal procedure law, issue a temporary order of protection, or suspend a license or registration pursuant to article twenty of the vehicle and traffic law.

c. The chief administrator shall promulgate rules to effectuate the provisions of this section. Such rules shall ensure that defendants are timely advised of the right of election established in this section and that each case in which a defendant makes such an election is assigned

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD01812-01-3

to a justice or judge admitted to practice law in this state with minimum practicable delay and burden to the parties.

§ 2. This act shall take effect on the one hundred twentieth day after it shall have become a law. Effective immediately, the addition, amendment and/or repeal of any rule or regulation necessary for the implementation of this act on its effective date are authorized to be made on or before such date.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the uniform justice court act, in relation to the right of defendants in misdemeanor or felony cases to have such matter appear before a judge or justice admitted to practice law in New York

Purpose

This bill would give defendants in criminal cases in town and village justice courts the right to choose to appear in front of a judge who is a lawyer.

Summary of specific provisions

Section one of the bill adds a new section 105-a to the Uniform Justice Court Act ("UJCA") entitled "Election to proceed in certain criminal actions." The new section gives a defendant who has been charged with a misdemeanor or felony, and who is appearing in a just ice court, the right to proceed before a judge who is a lawyer. Thus, a defendant may "opt out" of proceeding before a non-attorney judge in a criminal case. The defendant must make such an election in writing, on a form to be prescribed by the chief administrator of the courts, within specified time frames.

Read the full memo (1,089 words)

This legislation would create an automatic right to have a case reas- signed to an attorney judge, as provided in the first sentence of subdi- vision (a) of new UJCA § 105-a. As a result, the current "good cause shown" standard of Criminal Procedure Law ("CPL") 170.25 would no longer have to be met by a defendant seeking to proceed before a lawyer judge. The newly created "opt-out" right would only be available after arraign- ment and before the making of substantive motions to prevent forum shop- ping. Subdivision (c) of the new UJCA § 105-a requires the chief admin- istrator of the courts to promulgate implementing rules, which must ensure timely notice to defendants of the right to elect to proceedò before an attorney judge and must also ensure that when such an election is made, the case is re assigned to an attorney judge in a timely manner. It is the legislative intent that notice of the "opt out" right will be given to defendants during arraignment in two ways: instruction by the judge and through the form used to make the election, which will also explain the right and how to exercise it.

The text of this bill is substantially the same as that proposed by the Special Commission on the Future of the New York State Courts in Septem- ber 2008. The Commission's report, discussed below, identified a variety of problems in the local justice court system and proposed a number of different solutions. Model legislation was included as an appendix to the report, and the proposed model legislation was divided into 4 lettered parts, each addressing a different set of issues. This bill addresses one issue only - the due process concerns that stem from having non-attorney judges presiding over criminal cases - and the bill text is contained in section 2 of Part C of the Commission's proposed Model Legislation.

Justification

In late 2006, the Assembly Judiciary and Codes committees held a public hearing to address reform of the NYS justice courts. The hearing followed a series of articles in the New York Times that reported on a variety of problems and alleged abuses by some justices of the town and village courts. Some of the cases profiled in the NYT series highlighted the due process and other violations that can result from non-lawyer justices' lack of familiarity with legal and ethical rules, especially in criminal cases where liberty interests are at stake. The debate over the town and village justice courts- whether they should continue in their present form and whether or not judges should have to be attorneys admitted to practice, as required for all other courts in the state has gone on since at least the early part of the 20th century. As part of this most recent renewal of the debate, a special commission established in 2006 by Chief Judge Judith Kaye issued a report in September 2008 entitled Justice Most Local: The Future of Town and Village Courts in New York State (hereinafter referred to as Justice Most Local). The special commission's report dealt with a wide array of issues, and an appendix to the report includes proposed model legi slation designed to address those issues. This bill address only a single issue: the right of a Criminal defendant, whose liberty is at issue, to proceed in front of a judge who is a lawyer. After an extensive review of the justice courts that included visits to courts across the state, meetings with justices, clerks, prosecutors, public defenders, probation officers and other local government officials, and four public hearings, the special commission concluded that "immediate action" was needed to address, among other things, "due process violations and other legal errors," Justice Most Local, p. 10. In its summary under the heading "Safeguard- ing Due Process Rights," the report said the following about non-attor- ney justices: "... we remain concerned about due process issues and the legal consequences that can be imposed by justices who have not received a legal degree. After extensive debate about the possible proposals that might address these recurring concerns, we believe that the simplest and most effective solution is to provide all defendants...an "opt-out" right to hive his or her case heard by an attorney judge, at a point after arraignment but before a trial is scheduled or before substantive motions are made.... We be lieve that such an "opt-out " right should address any substantive or due process concerns, without entirely dismantling a system that has been in place for hundreds of years." Justice Most Local, p.17. This bill therefore Creates such an "opt-out" right, in substantially the same form propose d by the special commis- sion, as the most practical compromise that will give defendants the right to have potentially complex legal issues resolved by lawyer judges without completely divesting non-attorney justices of criminal jurisdic- tion.

Legislative history

S.0426 of 2021-2022 (Hoylman): Died in Judiciary

A.4292 of 2021-2022 (O'Donnell): Died in Judiciary

S.7058 of 2019-2020 (Hoylman): Died in Judiciary

A.8791 of 2019-2020 (O'Donnell): Died in Judiciary

A.9598 of 2017-2018 (O'Donnell): Died in Judiciary

A.3149 of 2013-2014 (O'Donnell): Died in Codes S.5839 of 2011-2012 (Parker): Died in Energy and Telecommunications

A.5221 of 2011-2012 (Englebright): Died in Energy

A.5899/S.4091 (2009-2010)(advanced to third reading in Assembly in 2009).

Fiscal implications

To be determined.

Effective date

This act shall take effect 120 days after the date on which it shall have become a law.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.