Skip to content
S5445Senate2023-2024 Session

Tighten Car Broker Rules

Official title

“Relates to designating new automotive broker businesses”

Status
In Senate Committee
Consumer Protection
Impact
7/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Consumer Protection

What's happening

This bill bans dealer payments to car brokers and tightens consumer protections and broker requirements.

Why it matters

  1. Statewide business changes. New York automobile brokers would be barred from accepting dealer or manufacturer payments and advertising pricing or financing offers. Their required surety bond would rise from $100,000 to $250,000.

  2. Buyer protections. New-car brokerage contracts would include a single, all-inclusive consumer fee and a three-day cancellation right. Consumers would have to personally deliver signed purchase or lease documents to the dealership for identity verification.

  3. Stronger enforcement. Civil penalties would rise from $1,000–$3,000 to $4,000–$10,000 per violation, with municipal enforcement and private lawsuits added. Registered brokers would have 90 days to comply.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Automobile brokers

    They would face new payment restrictions, advertising limits, contract requirements, security standards and recordkeeping duties.

  • Car buyers and lessees

    They would receive additional fee disclosures, dealer bids and cancellation protections when using brokers.

  • Motor vehicle dealers

    They could not pay brokers for sales or leases and could sue over violations causing lost sales.

  • Department of Motor Vehicles and local enforcement officials

    DMV would adopt disclosure rules and oversee broker compliance, while local officials would gain enforcement authority.

Headline styles

Tighten Car Broker Rules

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Jessica Scarcella-Spanton

Senator · Senate District 23

Chair, Veterans, Homeland Security And Military Affairs

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to consumer protection
  2. Referred to consumer protection

Full text

11 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

5445

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

March 6, 2023

Introduced by Sen. SCARCELLA-SPANTON -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Consumer Protection

AN ACT to amend the general business law and the vehicle and traffic law, in relation to designating new automotive broker businesses

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subdivision 1 of section 736 of the general business law, as amended by chapter 28 of the laws of 2018, is amended to read as follows:

1. "Automobile broker business" means any person who, for a fee, commission or other valuable consideration, regardless of whether such fee, commission, or consideration is paid directly by a consumer, offers to provide, provides, or represents that he or she will provide a service of purchasing, arranging, assisting, facilitating or effecting the purchase or lease of an automobile as agent, broker, or intermediary for a consumer. "Automobile broker business" does not include any person registered as a new motor vehicle dealer or qualified dealer pursuant to article sixteen of the vehicle and traffic law, any person registered under section four hundred fifteen-a of the vehicle and traffic law, only when operating under activity covered by such registration, an automobile auctioneer, only when operating in the manner described in section twenty-three of this chapter, nor any bona fide employee of a registered new motor vehicle dealer or qualified dealer while acting for such new motor vehicle dealer or qualified dealer, or any person who sells, offers for sale or lease or acts as agent, broker or intermediary in effecting the purchase or lease of three or fewer automobiles in any calendar year, any national service which aggregates information for consumers, but does not otherwise have contact with consumers, [or] any motor vehicle franchisor, manufacturer, or distributor, distributor

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD00498-01-3

branch or factory branch registered under article sixteen of the vehicle and traffic law.

§ 2. Section 736-a of the general business law, as added by chapter 477 of the laws of 2017, is amended to read as follows:

§ 736-a. Registration required. 1. (a) No person shall engage in business as an automobile broker business, as defined in section seven hundred thirty-six of this article, without first having been issued a certificate of registration for an automobile broker business pursuant to paragraph c of subdivision seven of section four hundred fifteen of the vehicle and traffic law. A certificate of registration for an automobile broker business shall be valid for a period of two years.

(b) No automobile broker business shall represent or accept payment from, either directly or indirectly, a franchisee, dealer, franchisor, manufacturer, distributor, distributor branch and/or factory branch, as such terms are defined in sections four hundred fifteen and four hundred sixty-two of the vehicle and traffic law.

(c) No automobile broker business shall perform any services involving the purchasing, arranging, assisting, facilitating or effecting the purchase or lease of an automobile as agent, broker, or intermediary for a consumer, unless done pursuant to a contract that complies with the provisions of section seven hundred thirty-eight of this article.

2. A certificate of registration for an automobile broker business shall not permit the registrant to display for sale or lease any new or used motor vehicles without registration as a dealer under section four hundred fifteen of the vehicle and traffic law.

3. Any person that sells or leases five or more vehicles in a calendar year to or through one or more automobile broker business shall be deemed to be dealing in motor vehicles as that term is used in paragraph a of subdivision one of section four hundred fifteen of the vehicle and traffic law.

4. The commissioner of motor vehicles shall adopt rules and regulations necessary to effectuate the provisions of this section, including regulations that require the disclosure of the name, address, and registration number of an automobile broker business that provided the service of arranging, assisting, facilitating or effecting the purchase or lease of any new motor vehicle, and the fee collected by the broker from the consumer for providing such service. Such rules and regulations shall require that such information of the automobile broker business and its fee for service be printed on any invoice, bill of sale, or buyer's order, and on any application for registration or title submitted by any dealer to the department of motor vehicles on behalf of the consumer related to such purchased or leased motor vehicle.

§ 3. The opening paragraph and paragraph (e) of subdivision 1 and subdivisions 3 and 4 of section 738 of the general business law, the opening paragraph and paragraph (e) of subdivision 1 as amended and subdivision 4 as added by chapter 28 of the laws of 2018 and subdivision 3 as amended by chapter 477 of the laws of 2017, are amended to read as follows:

Every contract between a consumer and an automobile broker business for the purchase of [an automobile] a motor vehicle, other than a new motor vehicle, shall be in writing, shall be dated, shall contain the street address of the automobile broker business and the consumer and shall be signed by the consumer and by the automobile broker business. Every contract shall comply with the requirements set forth in this section and contain the following:

(e) A description of any other services and an itemization of the charges for each. Such description shall include disclosure of the automobile dealer from which the automobile was purchased, as well as all fees, commissions or other valuable [considerations paid by an automobile dealer] consideration owed by the consumer to the automobile broker business for selling, arranging, assisting or effecting the sale of an automobile as agent, broker, or intermediary between the consumer and the automobile dealer.

3. Every contract between a consumer and an automobile broker business for the service of arranging, assisting, facilitating or effecting the purchase or lease of a new motor vehicle shall be in writing, shall be dated, shall contain the street address of the automobile broker business and the consumer, and shall be signed by the consumer and by the automobile broker business. Every such contract shall comply with the requirements set forth in this section and contain the following provisions, which shall be printed in at least twelve-point bold type and shall not be negated or superseded by any additional provision:

(a) A title, across the top of the document in at least sixteen-point bold type, of "Contract for Automobile Brokering Services for a New Motor Vehicle".

(b) A statement of whether a solicited new motor vehicle is or will be manufactured in accordance with United States specifications and is or will be certified by the manufacturer as such if the new motor vehicle is not or will not be manufactured in accordance with United States safety and environmental specifications, and the consumer has retained the automobile broker business to arrange for the modification of the new motor vehicle to meet such specifications, the name and street address of the modification facility and a statement in immediate proximity to such information that the automobile broker business assumes full financial responsibility that the new motor vehicle will be properly modified to meet all United States safety and environmental specifications.

(c) A statement that the consumer may cancel the contract for automobile brokering services for a new motor vehicle for any reason within three days of the execution of such contract and that the consumer has the right to a full refund within ten business days following receipt of the notice of cancellation.

(d) A statement that, if the requested new motor vehicle cannot be procured by the automobile broker business within thirty days following the date of execution of the contract for automobile brokering services for a new motor vehicle, the consumer has the right to cancel the contract and to receive a full refund within ten business days following receipt of the request for a refund, unless the delay in delivery is attributable to the consumer.

(e) A statement that the consumer shall be provided with the contents of each bid received by the automobile broker business in response to its solicitation on behalf of such consumer.

(f) The amount of the fee to be paid by the consumer to the automobile broker business for the service of arranging, assisting, facilitating or effecting the purchase or lease of a new motor vehicle.

(g) A statement that the single fee authorized by such contract for automobile brokering services for a new motor vehicle is inclusive of all charges incident to the purchasing, arranging, assisting, facilitating or effecting the purchase or lease of such new motor vehicle by the automobile broker business as agent, broker, or intermediary and that no other charge or expense whatsoever shall be taken, received, reserved or contracted for by the automobile broker business for such services.

4. The contract for automobile brokering services for a new motor vehicle shall be accompanied by a completed form in duplicate, captioned "Notice of Cancellation" which shall be attached to the contract and easily detachable, and which shall contain in at least twelve-point type the following:

"Notice of Cancellation

You may cancel this Contract for Automobile Brokering Services for a New Motor Vehicle, without any penalty or obligation, within three days from the date that a copy of an executed contract is received by you. You may also cancel this contract, without penalty or obligation, if the automobile broker business does not produce a bid meeting your specifications within thirty days of the date of execution of this contract.

To cancel this contract, mail or deliver a signed and dated copy of this cancellation notice, or any other written notice, to (name of automobile broker business) at (address of automobile broker business) not later than midnight of the third day following your receipt of a signed contract.

I hereby cancel this transaction.

________________________________ (signature of consumer)

_____________________ (date)"

5. An automobile broker business shall deliver to the consumer or mail to him or her at the address shown on [the] any contract required by this section, an executed copy thereof.

[4. An] 6. In addition to the brokering services agreement required by subdivision one of this section, an automobile broker business in any transaction involving the lease of a vehicle shall provide the retail lessee with a retail lease agreement as provided for in section three hundred thirty-seven of the personal property law. [The automobile broker shall provide a written disclosure of the amount of any fee, commission or other consideration paid or expected to be paid by the lessor to the automobile broker business in connection with a transaction involving the lease of a vehicle. Such disclosure shall be signed by the retail lessee. The automobile broker business shall provide the retail lessee with a signed copy of such disclosure together with the retail lease agreement referenced herein.] Nothing in this section shall be construed to permit the delivery of an executed retail lease agreement to a new motor vehicle by a person other than the prospective lessee.

§ 4. Subdivision 1 of section 740-a of the general business law, as amended by chapter 477 of the laws of 2017, is amended to read as follows:

1. Automobile broker businesses shall obtain and continue in effect a surety bond in an amount of [one] two hundred fifty thousand dollars executed by a surety company authorized to transact business in the state by the department of financial services of the state or its successor. The bonds shall be approved as to form by the secretary of state and shall be conditioned on the automobile broker business' payment of all valid bank drafts, including checks, drawn for the purchase of motor vehicles and safekeeping of all customer deposits related to the sale of a motor vehicle between the time of receipt of such customer deposit and the transfer of good title to the vehicle to the customer.

§ 5. Section 741 of the general business law, as added by chapter 616 of the laws of 1988, is amended to read as follows:

§ 741. Deceptive acts and frauds prohibited. 1. It is hereby declared to be a deceptive trade practice and unlawful for an automobile broker business to misrepresent directly or indirectly in its advertising, promotional materials, sales presentation, or in any manner:

[1.] (a) The nature of the services to be performed and that a third party will be paying for any such services;

[2.] (b) The time within which the services will be performed;

[3.] (c) The cost of the services to be performed; [and

4.] (d) The ability of the automobile broker business to perform the services; and

(e) That the automobile broker business is affiliated with any new motor vehicle manufacturer, distributor, distributor branch and/or factory branch including the use of any trademarks or copyrighted material without the express, written consent of the owner of such material.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the general business law and the vehicle and traffic law, in relation to designating new automotive broker businesses

Purpose or general idea of bill

To decrease the incidents of deceptive practices by automobile broker businesses who seek to facilitate the sale or lease of motor vehicles.

Summary of provisions

Amendment to B-print - eliminate the need to obtain 3 bids, the require- ment that a bid be from a local dealer by deleting old section 3 renum- bering the bill and deleting other references to the 3-bid requirement

Read the full memo (1,200 words)

Section 1 amends subdivision 1 of section 736 of the General Business Law to clarify which types of enterprises are not automobile broker businesses.

Section 2 amends section 736-a of the General Business-Law to add condi- tions to an automobile broker business registration and to empower the Department of Motor Vehicles to issue regulations governing such activ- ity.

Section 3 amends section 738 of the General Business Law to require brokers to have a signed contract before facilitating a sale or lease of a new motor vehicle and to allow consumers to cancel their brokering contract in certain situations, including if an automobile broker busi- ness fails to find a vehicle within thirty (30) days.

Section 4 amends section 740-a of the General Business Law to raise the surety bond requirement for brokers from $100,000 to $250,000.

Section 5 amends section 741 of the General Business Law to prohibit brokers from engaging in various forms of deceptive advertising and business practices, including refusing to disclose its DMV or local government registration number or advertising in a way that confuses a consumer as to whether the business is a dealer and not a broker.

Section 6 amends section 741-b of the General Business Law to require brokers to disclose fees and consumer rights to consumers obtain a writ- ten acknowledgment from consumers about these rights, and to notify dealers as to the provisions of section 739 of the General Business Law, which provide that contracts that violate Article 35-B are void and unenforceable.

Section 7 adds a new section 741-c of the General Business Law to enhance consumer data protections within the automobile brokering indus- try, specifically by requiring brokers to undertake certain physical measures to secure private consumer information and to hold brokers to other relevant General Business Law standards for securing such informa- tion.

Section 8 amends section 743 of the General Business Law to increase penalties and authorize local enforcement and new local laws on broker- ing. Section 8 also allows private actions against brokers and awards attorneys fees to prevailing plaintiffs.

Section 9 amends subdivision 1 of section 415 of the Vehicle and Traffic Law to clarify the definition of dealer activity to distinguish it from brokering activity.

Section 10 amends subdivision 3 of section 415 of the Vehicle and Traf- fic Law to prohibit dealers from using affiliated companies to violate Art. 35-b of the General Business Law.

Section 11 also amends paragraph b-three of subdivision three to clarify the broker registration process and renewal process, including restrictions on the category of business that, or person who may hold an interest in an automobile broker business.

Section 12 amends section 415 of the Vehicle and Traffic Law by adding new two new subdivisions, numbers twenty-one, and twenty-two. Subdivi- sion twenty-one authorizes DMV to penalize automobile broker businesses that fail to register. Subdivision twenty-two requires brokers to keep records for at least six years and authorizes DMV to inspect those records.

Section 13 provides that nothing in this act shall be construed to limit, or to enlarge, the protections that 47 U.S.C. § 230 confers on an interactive computer service for content provided by another information content provider, as such terms are defined in 47 U.S.C. § 230.

Section 14 is the bill's severability clause.

Section 1 establishes the bill's effective date of immediately and the need to come into compliance within 90 days.

Justification

If you have ever bought or leased a car through an automobile broker in New York, you most likely have no idea how much money your broker made off the deal. There is also a very good chance the broker did very little work to find your car, raising the question as to what value a consumer derives from broker services.

Brokers regularly deprive consumers of critical information on potential savings because the brokers obscure how much they are paid, which often occurs long after the consumer signs the dotted line. Nor do brokers make a serious attempt to get the best deal, as they typically work only with only one dealer, or an exclusive few, which are often based out-of- state. As a result, consumers are stuck with whatever deal a broker presents and that's been lined up well before a consumer even contacts a broker.

Compounding the problem, many brokers advertise like new car dealers, obscuring that they are merely an intermediary between the consumer and dealer and violating state laws in the process. Indeed, right now, hundreds and hundreds of automobile broker businesses continue to oper- ate while flouting basic laws requiring that they register with DMV and Make certain consumer disclosures, including that the broker is not an automobile dealer.

Many brokers also fail to make even the simplest of efforts to comply with automotive industry standards for consumer data protection. In addition, no broker provides warranty and recall repair services or employs trained workers to educate consumers about vehicle safety features and other options in today's models.

Unfortunately, the proliferation of broker businesses has also jeopard- ized the enormous investments of New York's 1,000 new car dealerships and the security of over 120,000 career-oriented dealership jobs state- wide. In exchange for the right to sell, lease, and service particular new motor vehicle brands, and according to franchise agreements, dealers must maintain high levels of customer satisfaction.

Sadly, brokers only serve to skim profits and undercut New York based new car dealers and the entire Franchise System with it. They do this by avoiding capital and facility investments dealers must make, exploiting manufacturer incentive programs that only serve to drive dealerships out of business and reduce. Competition, ignoring basic consumer protection laws, and concealing profits from consumers.

Beyond the jobs they create, dealers also pay millions in real property taxes, and hundreds of millions in sales tax annually. Dealers also give consumers the knowledge and comfort of dealing with a reputable business supported by a large motor vehicle manufacturer.

This legislation favorably addresses these problems to protect consumers and ensure fair market competition by maintaining a clear path for responsible brokering. Specifically, this bill will strengthen the broker registration process, increase disclosures, penalties, and enforcement provisions, and require brokers, for the first time, to work only for consumers, including by requiring brokers to solicit at least three bids on the behalf of a consumer.

Prior legislative history

2021 Session - New bill. (Similar to S4364c of 2019/20)

2022 Session - Passed Assembly, referred to Senate Consumer Affairs

Fiscal implications

None to the state.

Effective date

Immediate, except that all registered brokers shall have ninety (90) days to comply.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.