Skip to content
S5574Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA6870

Ban Jury Discrimination

Official title

“Relates to prohibiting certain discriminatory peremptory challenges to prospective jurors”

Sponsor Andrew GounardesSD-26Affects Legal
Status
In Assembly Committee
Codes
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 5 of 7

In Assembly · Codes

What's happening

This bill prohibits the use of peremptory challenges to remove prospective jurors based on protected characteristics such as race or gender.

Why it matters

  1. Reduces the potential for bias in jury selection. by making it explicit that peremptory challenges cannot be used to exclude jurors based on a wide range of protected characteristics, such as race, gender, age, disability, religion, and sexual orientation, aiming to create more diverse and representative juries.

  2. Establishes a clear process for challenging suspected discriminatory peremptory strikes. If a party believes a peremptory challenge was made for an unlawful reason, they can object, triggering a review outside the presence of the jury panel to prevent tainting the jury pool.

  3. Requires the party exercising the challenge to provide their reasoning. , and instructs judges to only consider the reasons actually given—prohibiting speculation or consideration of possible justifications not stated—thus increasing accountability and transparency in jury selection decisions.

  4. Lowers the standard for sustaining an objection. The court does not need to find that discrimination was intentional or purposeful; it is enough if a reasonable person could see a protected characteristic as a factor, making it easier to prevent and address subtle or implicit bias.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Prosecutors and criminal defense attorneys

    The bill would require them to explain challenged peremptory strikes and bar strikes based on any listed protected characteristic.

  • Criminal court judges

    Judges would have to reject a strike if a reasonable person would view a listed characteristic as a factor, without requiring proof of purposeful discrimination, and explain their ruling on the record.

  • Prospective jurors

    The bill would prohibit their removal through peremptory challenges based on race, gender, gender identity or expression, religion, age, disability, sexual orientation or other listed characteristics.

Headline styles

Ban Jury Discrimination

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Andrew Gounardes

Senator · Senate District 26

Chair, Budget And Revenue

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to codes
  2. Delivered to assembly
  3. Passed senateVote 46–11
  4. Advanced to third reading
  5. 2nd report cal.
  6. 1st report cal.549
  7. Referred to codes
  8. Returned to senate
  9. Died in assembly
  10. Referred to codes
  11. Delivered to assembly
  12. Passed senateVote 51–11
Show 3 earlier actions
  1. Ordered to third reading cal.1501
  2. Committee discharged and committed to rules
  3. Referred to codes

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A6870Assembly

Ban Biased Jury Selection

In Assembly Committee · Codes · Sponsor Catalina Cruz

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

5574

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

March 8, 2023

Introduced by Sen. GOUNARDES -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Codes

AN ACT to amend the criminal procedure law, in relation to prohibiting peremptory challenges of prospective jurors based on race, color, national origin, ancestry, gender, gender identity or expression, religion, religious practice, age, disability, or sexual orientation

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subdivision 1 of section 270.25 of the criminal procedure law is amended to read as follows:

1. A peremptory challenge is an objection to a prospective juror for which no reason need be assigned. Upon any lawful peremptory challenge, the court must exclude the person challenged from service.

§ 2. Section 270.25 of the criminal procedure law is amended to add a new subdivision 4 to read as follows:

4. (a) A party shall not use a peremptory challenge to remove a prospective juror on the basis of such juror's race, color, national origin, ancestry, gender, gender identity or expression, religion, religious practice, age, disability, or sexual orientation.

(b) A party may object to the improper use of a peremptory challenge if such party believes that such challenge was made on an unlawful basis in violation of paragraph (a) of this subdivision. After such objection is made, any further discussion shall be conducted outside the presence of the panel. The objection shall be made before the jury is impaneled, unless information becomes known that could not have reasonably been known before the jury was impaneled.

(c) Upon the objection made pursuant to paragraph (b) of this subdivision, the party exercising the peremptory challenge shall state the reasons for exercising such challenge to the court.

(d) The court shall evaluate the reasons given to justify the peremptory challenge in light of the totality of the circumstances. The court

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD10065-01-3

shall consider only the reasons actually given and shall not speculate on, or assume the existence of, other possible justifications for the use of the peremptory challenge. If the court determines that, in the view of a reasonable person, the race, color, national origin, ancestry, gender, gender identity or expression, religion, religious practice, age, disability, or sexual orientation of a juror was a factor in the exercise of the peremptory challenge, then the objection shall be sustained and the peremptory challenge shall be defeated. The court need not find purposeful discrimination to sustain such objection. The court shall explain the reasons for its ruling on the record.

§ 3. This act shall take effect on the one hundred eightieth day after it shall have become a law and shall apply to all jury selections commenced on or after such date.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the criminal procedure law, in relation to prohibiting peremptory challenges of prospective jurors based on race, color, national origin, ancestry, gender, gender identity or expression, reli- gion, religious practice, age, disability, or sexual orientation

Purpose or general idea of bill

To ensure that peremptory challenges of jurors are not based on unlawful discrimination

Summary of provisions

Section one of this bill amdends subdivision one of section 270.25 of the Criminal Procedure Law to clarify that only lawful peremptory chal- lenges shall result in a juror being excluded from service.

Read the full memo (835 words)

Section two of the bill creates a new subdivision four in section 270.25 of the Criminal Procedure Law to provide a standard which peremptory challenges to jurors must adhere to in order to be sustained by a judge.

Section three sets the effective date.

Justification

In 1986, the Supreme Court of the United States found in Batson v. Kentucky that racial discrimination in the selection of jurors both deprives the accused of important constitutional rights during a trial and is devastating to the community at large as it "undermines public confidence in the fairness of our system of justice."

Batson was specifically addressing the discriminatory use of peremptory challenges in criminal cases. Unlike challenges for cause, which allows for the disqualification of a potential juror for an explicitly stated reason, peremptory challenges allow for striking a potential juror with- out cause or reason. As was affirmed in Baston, these challenges are often intentionally or unintentionally discriminatory in nature, as the ability to strike jurors without cause opens the door for that decision to be based on conscious or unconscious bias. Theoretical and empirical evidence across disciplines such as psychology, sociology, criminology, and law agree, having concluded that peremptory challenges, by their very nature, are fertile ground for the influence of bias on jury selection.

The decision in Batson V. Kentucky led to the creation of the three-step Batson challenge: first, the objecting party must establish a prima facie case of racial or gender discrimination in the peremptory chal- lenge, by establishing an inference of discrimination. Next, the burden shifts to the party making the peremptory challenge to provide a "neutral" explanation of their challenge. Thirdly, the court must decide if such stated reasons are actually the truth or a pretext for purpose- ful discrimination. If the peremptory challenge fails this test, it is struck down.

Beyond this requirement of neutrality, however there are no criteria for evaluating explanations for peremptory challenges. In Purkett v. Elem, the court went so far as to state that the explanations do not need to be "persuasive or even plausible." Thus, despite this supposed remedy, examinations of jury selection proceedings have shown that when either the prosecution and defense are challenged on Batson grounds, a vast majority of neutral justifications are accepted by judges as legitimate. It is unsurprising, then, that research has shown that the current safe- guards against such bias and discrimination are untenable: even when attorneys are aware of the impact of bias, they are unlikely to admit it, and even when judges scrutinize peremptory justifications for evidence of discrimination, they are unlikely to find it.

This bill, recommended by an August 2022 report of the New York State Justice Task Force, would follow the lead of other states such as Wash- ington and California which have all recently put into place certain safeguards to ensure that the protections of Batson are better enforced during jury selection. It would create a "reasonable person" standard, long recognized in other parts of statute and widely understood by both courts and practitioners, to uphold peremptory challenges. Peremptory challenges which, in the view of a reasonable person, were made as the result of certain protected characteristics of the juror will be struck down. The bill also expands the list of protected classes, which under the federal Batson standard applies only to race and gender, to also include color, national origin, ancestry, gender identity or expression, religion, religious practice, age, disability, and sexual orientation. This more expansive list would mirror that contained in New York Unified Court System's directives on voir dire (the preliminary examination of a potential juror by a counsel or judge), which emphasize that a fair juror does not base a decision on the list of protected classes enumer- ated above.

This bill addresses New York's peremptories problem, in which criminal convictions are not infrequently overturned based on evidence that a prosecutor used racial criteria to select a jury that they believed would more likely return a conviction (see People v. Morant for exam- ple), head on. It represents a commonsense approach to ensure that the protections of Batson, decades in place yet rarely enforced, are fully upheld.

Prior legislative history

None

Fiscal implications

None

Effective date

This act shall take effect on the one hundred eightieth day after it shall have become a law and shall apply to all jury selections commenced on or after such date.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.