What's happening
This bill creates a New York data protection office and taxes businesses handling residents’ personal data.
Why it matters
New oversight. A seven-member board would oversee a statewide office empowered to write privacy rules, investigate complaints, audit businesses and halt noncompliant data operations.
Tax and exemptions. Covered businesses would pay 2% of estimated receipts from handling New Yorkers’ data, excluding the first $5 million. Businesses established within the previous three years would be exempt from the tax.
Registration and disclosure. Covered data controllers and processors would register annually, pay fees and disclose data practices and receipts, with fines for noncompliance. The office would publish an annual report; incidental data operations would be excluded from coverage.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Who cares
Data controllers and processors
Covered businesses would face registration fees, reporting requirements, privacy oversight and a new receipts tax.
Digital advertising businesses
The bill explicitly covers targeted-ad platforms and businesses participating in real-time advertising auctions.
New York residents
The office would handle their complaints and set rules governing consent, access, deletion and safeguards for personal data.
State tax administrators
They would use the office’s registry to assess the tax and consider businesses’ alternative receipts estimates.
Headline styles
Regulate and Tax Data Businesses
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
2 Co-sponsors
History
- Referred to finance
- Referred to finance
Full text
9 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
5662
2023-2024 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
March 13, 2023
Introduced by Sens. GOUNARDES, HOYLMAN-SIGAL, JACKSON -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Finance
AN ACT to amend the executive law and the tax law, in relation to establishing the data economy labor compensation and accountability act
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Short title. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "data economy labor compensation and accountability act".
§ 2. Legislative intent. a. The legislature finds that the commercialization of personal consumer data has wrought wholesale and disruptive transformations in our global markets, politics, psychology, socialization, and the basic functioning of society;
b. The legislature further finds that, according to a 2016 Rockefeller Foundation study Data Financing for the Global Good, the "data economy," in which millions of data points are endlessly gathered, organized, and exchanged by a series of vendors for the purpose of deriving value from accumulated information, has produced enough value in industrialized countries to equal 4% of their gross domestic product;
c. The legislature further finds that the consumers whose emails, texts, Internet searches, purchasing history, profile information, swipes, clicks, and more have produced such tremendous amounts of value do not receive the direct dividends of their labor;
d. The legislature further finds that large swaths of our global and national society have yet to benefit from the revolution wrought by such commercialization of their data and technology at large;
e. The legislature further finds that the proliferation of targeted advertising based on the sale, transfer, or licensing of personal consumer data has led to an exploitation of individual users' attention, leading to reduced productivity, mental acuity, and overall emotional
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD01552-02-3
and social well-being as well as overcrowding of digital spaces and depletion of the "common good" of limited user attention;
f. The legislature further finds that the collection and storage of vast amounts of personal consumer data carries an inherent risk of security breach if such data is compromised;
g. The legislature hereby declares that a levy on the gross receipts of commercial interests engaged in such commodification will erode the aforementioned negative externalities by incentivizing companies to collect fewer points of personal consumer data, to provide fair market value dividends directly to consumers in exchange for their productive labor, to proactively mitigate the security risks of data breaches, and to more judiciously preserve the commons of digital space and limited user attention;
h. The legislature further declares that a levy on the gross receipts of such commercial interests will redistribute the wealth created by the value of consumers from the shareholders who exploit this free labor back to the people who generate such labor;
i. The legislature further declares that the creation of a "data tax" will put New York on par with other domestic and foreign states such as Maryland, Vermont, and Austria who have similarly recognized the social, economic, and ethical justification for such tax.
§ 3. The executive law is amended by adding a new article 51 to read as follows:
ARTICLE 51
OFFICE OF CONSUMER DATA PROTECTION Section 1004. Definitions.
1005. Applicability.
1006. Office of consumer data protection.
1007. Annual report.
§ 1004. Definitions. For the purposes of this article, the following terms shall have the following meanings:
1. "Code of conduct" shall mean a set of written policies adopted by a data controller or processor in order to facilitate compliance with the provisions of this article and any regulations promulgated by the office of consumer data protection, taking into account the specific characteristics of the data controller or processor's data operations. All codes of conduct shall be approved by the office data protection. Either a code of conduct or the data protection certification described in subdivision eight of this section may be used to demonstrate compliance with the provisions of this article and with data protection regulations promulgated by the office of consumer data protection.
2. "Consumer" shall mean a natural person who is a New York resident.
3. "Data breach" shall mean a breach of security leading to the accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alteration, unauthorized disclosure of, or access to, personal data transmitted, stored or otherwise processed.
4. "Data controller" or "controller" shall mean a natural or legal person which, alone or jointly with others, determines the purposes and means of processing of personal data. This includes but is not limited to any business, website, or platform that collects data while selling electronic advertising space on its platform tailored to any one or any aggregation of the items of personal data defined in this section. No data controller is exempt from the requirements of this article if they are processing pseudonymized data, whereby processing means any operation or set of operations that are performed on personal data or on sets of personal data, whether or not by automated means. For purposes of this subdivision "pseudonymized" or "pseudonymization" means the processing of personal data in a manner that renders the personal data no longer attributable to a specific data subject without the use of additional information, provided that the additional information is kept separately and is subject to technical and organizational measures to ensure that the personal data is not attributed to an identified or identifiable data subject. Any entity participating in real time auctions to facilitate the sale of digital advertising space, any entity collecting anonymized or aggregated data for the purpose of advertising, marketing, or transferring data to any party purchasing digital advertising space, and any company collecting the data of data subjects via an internet or phone-based platform, application or website registry that also markets or advertises products to consumers are considered data controllers under this article.
5. "Data operations" shall mean the collection, storage, transfer, sale, or licensing of personal data by a data controller or data processor.
6. "Data processor" or "processor" shall mean a natural or legal person that processes data on behalf of the controller. Provided, however, that when such natural or legal person is both a data controller and data processor, as defined in this section, such person shall be deemed one entity for the purposes of registration as described in paragraph (b) of subdivision two of section one thousand six of this article and taxation as described in section one hundred eighty-five of the tax law.
7. "Data protection audit" shall mean an audit conducted by the office or consumer data protection in order to assess whether a data controller or processor is in compliance with a data controller or processor's code of conduct, regulations promulgated by the office, and/or any relevant federal, state or local law. The office of consumer data protection shall adopt a rating system of "high assurance," "reasonable assurance," "limited assurance," and "very limited assurance" to measure levels of compliance with such code of conduct, laws and regulations.
8. "Data protection certification" shall refer to a certification, created by the office of consumer data protection, which serves to demonstrate compliance with the provisions of this article and with data protection regulations promulgated by such office. Data protection certification shall be voluntary for all data controllers and processors. The office shall create the criteria for such certification. Successful certification may be demonstrated by a certificate, seal, or mark which data controllers and processors may conspicuously display.
9. "Data protection impact assessment" shall mean an internal evaluation which the office of consumer data protection requires data controllers and processors to carry out in order to evaluate the level of risk associated with such controller or processor's data operations. Such assessment shall examine the origin, nature, particularity, and severity of such risk. Where a data protection impact assessment indicates that a controller or processor's data operations involve a high degree of risk, as determined by the office of consumer data protection, which cannot be mitigated by appropriate measures, such controller or processor shall be obligated to receive express approval from the office of consumer data protection prior to commencing or resuming data operations.
10. "Data subject" or "subject" shall mean a natural person for whom a data controller holds personal data, as defined in subdivision thirteen of this section, and who can be identified, directly or indirectly, by reference to such personal data.
11. "Newly established" shall refer to a limited history of data operations as determined by the office of consumer data protection. Such office may consider factors such as date of incorporation or other form of organization, whether in this state or another state, territory, district, province, nation or other jurisdiction, foreign or domestic, amount of capital raised, the entrepreneurial nature of a data controller or processor's business, or any other factor the office deems relevant in determining limited operating history and an initial date of data operations, provided that such office shall promulgate regulations with the guidelines used for determining such date and that such office shall adhere to such guidelines consistently when determining such date for all data controllers and processors required to register under paragraph (b) of subdivision two of section one thousand six of this article.
12. "Office" shall mean the office of consumer data protection established by section one thousand six of this article.
13. "Personal data" shall mean any computerized information about a data subject as set forth in this subdivision that is not made publicly available through federal, state or local government agencies or any publicly available information as it relates to a data subject's business license, status or profession, regardless of whether it is collected for the purpose of selling or transferring it to another entity. Personal data shall mean information that identifies, relates to, describes or is reasonably linked to a particular data subject or household, including but not limited to:
(a) physical address;
(b) legal name;
(c) alias;
(d) unique personal identifier;
(e) online identifier;
(f) internet protocol address;
(g) email address;
(h) account name;
(i) social security number;
(j) driver's license number;
(k) passport number;
(l) place of birth;
(m) mother's maiden name;
(n) date of birth;
(o) phone number;
(p) audio, visual, thermal or olfactory data;
(q) profession or employment related information;
(r) medical history, records of past medical treatment, or any diagnosis of a physical or mental health condition, including diagnosis, treatment or referral for addiction or substance abuse;
(s) educational information that is not already publicly available through a local, state, or federal agency;
(t) real time geolocation data or stored geolocation history;
(u) any unique biometric data, body measurement, technical analysis or measurements collected for the purpose of allowing a data subject to authenticate the subject on a device, internet application, or web-based platform;
(v) names and identifying information of a subject's immediate family;
(w) internet or any other electronic network activity, including browsing history, search history, and information regarding a subject's activity on a website or interaction with an electronic advertisement;
(x) any other information that alone, or combined with any of the information described in this subdivision, could be reasonably used to identify an individual data subject or household; and
(y) any inferences drawn from any of the combined forms of personal data that are used to create a profile of the data subject reflecting the subject's preferences, choices, characteristics, psychological trends, intelligence, aptitude, physical health or behavior.
"Personal data" shall also include any information which creates probabilistic identifiers that can be used to isolate, individualize, or identify a data subject or device to a degree of certainty more probable than not based on any item of personal information defined in this subdivision.
14. "Sale" or "sold" shall mean the disclosure, dissemination, making available, release, transfer, conveyance, license, rental, or other commercialization of data by a data controller to a third party, whether commercialization occurs via access to raw data or via use of platform interface rather than direct access to raw data. This definition shall include dissemination of data, orally, in writing, or by electronic or other means, for monetary or other valuable consideration, or otherwise for a commercial purpose, by a data controller to a third party.
15. "Third party" shall mean a natural or legal person, public authority, agency, or body other than the data subject, data controller, or data processor of the data controller.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the executive law and the tax law, in relation to estab- lishing the data economy labor compensation and accountability act
Purpose or general idea of bill
To establish the Office of Consumer Data Protection to better regulate companies who profit off of consumer data and to create a tax on their gross receipts
Summary of provisions
Section one of this bill creates a short title.
Read the full memo (976 words)
Section two establishes legislative intent.
Section three adds a new Article 51 to the Executive Law to establish a new Office of Consumer Data Protection and to outline its role and responsibilities.
Section four amends the Tax Law to add a new Section 185 to establish a tax on gross receipts of companies who profit off of consumer data.
Section five provides the effective date.
Justification
The data economy, or the global digital ecosystem in which consumer information is gathered and exchanged for profit by a variety of vendors, has produced tremendous but heretofore unmeasured value. A PricewaterhouseCoopers survey from 2019 found that 94% of global CEOs considered data on customer and client preferences the most critical factor driving long-term business decisions, greater even than financial forecasts and projections. Largely unregulated data brokers, middlemen who collect consumer data to sell or license it to third parties for a variety of uses, generate about $200 billion in annual revenue. And according to a 2016 study by the Rockefeller Foundation "Data Financing for Global Good," the direct value of Internet-related data is estimated in industrialized economies to be between three to four percent of GDP.
Much of the difficulty in capturing the value of the data economy, however, derives from the complex way data is collected and sold in a process known as "real-time bidding." First party platforms such as Amazon or Google collect millions of data points on consumers across apps, search engines, websites, and devices, then aggregate and encrypt this data and turn it over to second party auctioneers. The second party auctioneers then take bids on ad space from third party purchasers bidding on behalf of advertising clients who are looking to target a specific subset of consumers based on certain demographic traits, purchasing history, geographic location, etc. Thus, the first party platform can claim it does not have a consumer's data, second party auctioneers can claim they only have aggregate masses of demographic information, and advertisers can claim they are just buying ad space.
More directly, an advertiser will approach a first party platform such as Facebook looking to target a certain subset of consumers who share known traits. Facebook will then place the ad on their platform based on those traits, and the advertiser is told that the ad has been placed and reaps the profits. The first party platform did not technically "sell" consumer data, just ad space based on data, and the advertiser can claim it never bought data, having never had access but profiting off of it nonetheless.
This bill draws upon established definitions in the European Union's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) to capture all entities controlling or processing consumer data for economic benefit. It is also careful to define "sale" as the "disclosure, dissemination, making available, release, transfer, conveyance, license, rental, or other communication of data...for mone- tary or other valuable consideration, or otherwise for a commercial purpose" to capture the convoluted transaction chains that have come to characterize the data economy. The bill aims to provide transparency and accountability by mandating that companies who commodify consumer data register with a newly created Office of Consumer Data Protection, and then taxes the companies at a rate of two percent of gross receipts estimated to be derived from consumers or "data subjects" who reside in New York (derived by multiplying a data controller or processor's gross domestic receipts by the sum equal to NY GDP divided by US GDP multi- plied by one hundred). This formula will have the desired effect of extracting a greater tax levy from companies with higher gross receipts and/or a larger share of New York consumers whose data is being collected, processed, or sold. This bill excludes from taxation, howev- er, the first five million dollars in revenue. Companies which have been newly formed within the past three years as well as companies which collect, process, or sell data as an incidental part of doing business or which do not derive any economic benefit from such collection, proc- essing, or sale are also exempt.
In implementing a tax on the commercialization of consumer data, New York would join other domestic and foreign states such as Maryland, Vermont, and Austria in recognizing the social, economic, and ethical justification for such a tax. Extracting a small tax on the data economy could incentivize companies to collect less consumer data, reducing the risk of a security breach when such data is inevitably leaked and lead- ing to fewer targeted advertisements which pollute digital spaces and deplete the "common good" of limited user attention. Most importantly, however, a data tax will ensure that the general public whose data is being harvested for profit are able to reap the fruits of their current- ly free labor. By redirecting some tiny portion of the billions of dollars derived from the aggregate value of our swipes, clicks, cookies, browser searches, profiles, emails, texts, purchasing history, credit scores, and more from the shareholders of Silicon Valley tech companies to the New York State budget, we can end the exploitation of free, consumer-provided labor while helping to fund vital public services.
Prior legislative history
2022: S6727 - Referred to Finance
2021: S6727 - Referred to Finance
Fiscal implications
TBD
Effective date
This act shall take effect on the one hundred eightieth day after it shall have become a law.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.