Skip to content
S626Senate2023-2024 Session

Expand Prison Oversight Board

Official title

“Increases the number of members on the state commission of correction and relates to inspection and procedures applicable to unsafe or unsanitary correctional facilities”

Status
Stricken
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Crime Victims, Crime And Correction

What's happening

This bill reforms the State Commission of Correction by expanding its membership, strengthening oversight and transparency of correctional facilities, and establishing stricter procedures for investigating and addressing unsafe, unsanitary, or abusive conditions.

Why it matters

  1. Diversifies and expands commission membership. By increasing the State Commission of Correction from three to nine members and requiring representation from formerly incarcerated individuals, public health professionals, and those with backgrounds in public defense and prisoners’ rights, the bill seeks to ensure broader perspectives and reduce law enforcement dominance in oversight decisions.

  2. Guarantees annual, unannounced inspections and public reporting. Mandatory annual inspections of every correctional facility—without advance notice—combined with the requirement to make detailed findings, violations, and interviews publicly available online, aims to increase transparency and make it harder for facilities to hide poor conditions or abuses.

  3. Mandates rapid response and legal accountability for unsafe conditions. The commission is now required (not merely permitted) to notify top state officials and seek court orders when violations are found, and, in cases of imminent harm or constitutional violations, must order facility closures without needing court approval, imposing legal consequences for neglecting these duties.

  4. Strengthens oversight of deaths and serious injuries. The Correction Medical Review Board’s role is expanded to include serious injuries (not just deaths), full-time commitment is required of its members, and its reports must be made available to the public and next-of-kin, helping families and advocates access information and pushing correctional facilities to improve medical care and accountability.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Incarcerated people and their families

    The bill would create a process for incarcerated people to request facility reviews and require death and serious-injury investigation reports to be published and delivered to next of kin or authorized legal representatives.

  • Correctional facility administrators

    The bill would require annual inspections generally without advance notice, immediate reporting of serious injuries, and closure orders when conditions pose specified risks to incarcerated people.

  • State Commission of Correction

    The bill would expand the commission from three to nine members, broaden appointment authority, establish a funding floor and require stronger enforcement and public reporting.

  • Formerly incarcerated people and prisoner-rights advocates

    The bill would require at least one formerly incarcerated commission member and limit members with law-enforcement, prosecution or corrections backgrounds relative to those with defense or legal-services backgrounds.

Headline styles

Expand Prison Oversight Board

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Brad Hoylman-Sigal

Senator · Senate District 47

Chair, Judiciary

1 Co-sponsor

History

  1. Recommit, enacting clause stricken
  2. Referred to crime victims, crime and correction

Full text

6 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

626

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

January 5, 2023

Introduced by Sens. HOYLMAN, SALAZAR -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Crime Victims, Crime and Correction

AN ACT to amend the correction law, in relation to the membership of the state commission of correction and to inspection and procedures applicable to unsafe or unsanitary correctional facilities

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Section 40 of the correction law is amended by adding a new subdivision 7 to read as follows:

7. "Serious injury" means the same as such term is defined in section fifty-one hundred two of the insurance law.

§ 2. Section 41 of the correction law, as added by chapter 865 of the laws of 1975, is amended to read as follows:

§ 41. State commission of correction; organization. 1. (a) There shall be within the executive department a state commission of correction. It shall consist of [three] nine persons [to be], two of whom shall be appointed by the governor[, by and with the advice and consent of the senate], two of whom shall be appointed by a majority vote of the membership of the assembly, two of whom shall be appointed by a majority vote of the membership of the senate, two of whom shall be appointed by the attorney general, and one of whom shall be appointed by the correctional association. All appointments shall be by and with the advice and consent of the senate to ensure the requirements of this subdivision are met.

(b) At least one member of the commission shall be a formerly incarcerated person, and a preference in appointment shall be granted to nominees who have been personally affected by contact with the criminal legal system. At least one member of the commission shall have a professional background in public health. No more than three members of the commission shall have a background in law enforcement, criminal prose-

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD00210-01-3

cution, or employment within a corrections agency, and the members of the commission with such backgrounds shall never be greater than the number of members of the commission with backgrounds in indigent criminal defense services, prisoner's rights litigation, or public legal services. The remaining members of the commission shall have expertise in any other field deemed useful for the promotion of an efficient, humane, and lawful correctional system. The [governor] members of the commission shall designate one of the appointed members as chairman to serve [as such] at [the] their pleasure [of the governor]. The members shall devote full time to their duties and shall hold no other salaried public position.

2. The members shall hold office for terms of five years; provided that of the three members first appointed, one shall serve for a term of two years, one shall serve for a term of three years and one shall serve for a term of five years from January first next succeeding their appointment. No member shall serve for more than ten years. Any member of the commission may be removed by the governor for cause after an opportunity to be heard in his or her defense.

3. Any member chosen to fill a vacancy created other than by expiration of term shall be appointed for the unexpired term of the member whom he or she is to succeed. Vacancies caused by expiration of term or otherwise shall be filled in the same manner as original appointments; provided, however, that if a position on the commission remains vacant for any period longer than one hundred eighty days, the members of the commission may appoint an individual to fill such vacancy whose appointment satisfies the requirements of paragraph (b) of subdivision one of this section.

4. The appropriations available to pay for the expenses of the commission during each fiscal year shall not be less than two percentum of the appropriations available to pay for the expenses of the department during such fiscal year.

§ 3. Subdivision 3 of section 45 of the correction law, as amended by chapter 322 of the laws of 2021, is amended to read as follows:

3. Except in circumstances involving health, safety or alleged violations of established standards of the commission, visit, and inspect every correctional [facilities] facility in the state on an annual basis consistent with a schedule determined by the chairman of the commission[, taking into consideration available resources, workload and staffing], and appraise the management of such correctional facilities with specific attention to matters such as safety, security, health of incarcerated individuals, sanitary conditions, rehabilitative programs, disturbance and fire prevention and control preparedness, and adherence to laws and regulations governing the rights of incarcerated individuals. The commission shall not disclose its schedule for inspections or provide advance notice to any correctional facility of a planned inspection unless such notice is required to carry out the duties of the commission.

§ 4. Subdivision 4 of section 46 of the correction law, as amended by chapter 322 of the laws of 2021, is amended and two new subdivisions 5 and 6 are added to read as follows:

4. In any case where any rule or regulation promulgated by the commission pursuant to subdivision six of section forty-five of this article or the laws relating to the construction, management and affairs of any correctional facility or the care, treatment and discipline of its incarcerated individuals, are being or are about to be violated, the commission shall immediately notify the person in charge or control of the facility of such violation, recommend remedial action, and direct such person to comply with the rule, regulation or law, as the case may be. The commission shall also immediately notify the governor, the chair and members of the assembly standing committee on correction, and the chair and members of the senate standing committee on crime victims, crime, and correction, of the alleged or documented violation and the remedial action that the commission recommends. Upon the failure of such person to comply with the rule, regulation or law the commission [may] shall promptly apply to the supreme court for an order directed to such person requiring compliance with such rule, regulation or law; provided, however, that if the commission decides to close a facility pursuant to section forty-five of this article, the commission shall not be required to apply for an order. Upon such application the court [may] shall issue such order as may be just and a failure to comply with the order of the court shall be a contempt of court and punishable as such.

5. (a) In any case where there is a reasonably foreseeable risk that conditions at a correctional facility might violate the constitutional rights of people incarcerated there, cause imminent harm to any incarcerated person, or cause the imminent death of any incarcerated person, the commission shall be required to order the closure of such correctional facility pursuant to subdivision eight of section forty-five of this article. Such correctional facility shall remain closed permanently or until the commission has determined that such correctional facility can resume operations in compliance with all regulations promulgated by the commission and without posing any reasonably foreseeable harm to any person incarcerated there. The commission shall not need to apply for a court order pursuant to subdivision four of this section before deciding to close a correctional facility. Failure to take action pursuant to this subdivision or subdivision four of this section shall constitute neglect of a ministerial matter. For the purposes of this subdivision, "ministerial matter" shall have the same meaning as such term is defined in paragraph (d) of subdivision one of section seventy-three of the public officers law.

(b) Upon a recommendation made by the governor or the attorney general, or upon a resolution passed in the assembly or senate, or upon the request of a considerable number of people incarcerated in any correctional facility or particular wing, annex, or housing unit thereof, asking the commission to inspect any correctional facility and recommend remedial actions or close a correctional facility pursuant to powers granted in section forty-five of this article, the commission shall discuss such matter at the next stated meeting to occur after ten business days, provided that such meeting occurs within forty-five days of such request. The commission shall inspect the correctional facility or facilities in question, collect any relevant documents, and conduct any interviews of incarcerated people, staff, medical providers, and supervisors at such correctional facility prior to such meeting and make the result of its inspection and analysis public online before its next stated meeting. Such analysis shall, at a minimum, include a description of the factors contained in subdivision three of section forty-five of this article. At such meeting, the commission shall determine whether, based on its inspection and analysis, the correctional facility lacks compliance with any law or regulation promulgated by the commission, and whether such non-compliance poses an imminent harm to any incarcerated person in the custody of that correctional facility. At such stated meeting the commission shall state on the record the reasoning underlying its determination to take no action, recommend remedial action, apply to the supreme court for an order, or order the closure of a facility.

6. (a) Twice per year, at intervals separated by approximately six months, the commission shall publish a report containing the results of its annual inspections of correctional facilities in a prominent place on its website, and shall deliver a copy of such report to the governor, the temporary president of the senate, the speaker of the assembly, and the attorney general. Such reports shall contain, without limitation, detailed information about any violations of regulations or applicable laws at each correctional facility inspected, notable excerpts from interviews with incarcerated people, staff, medical providers, and supervisors at each facility, descriptions of deaths or serious injuries that have occurred at any correctional facility that was inspected, copies of recommendations or directives that have been issued by the commission to any correctional facility during the period of time covered by the report, and copies of any correctional facility's response to such recommendations or directives.

(b) As soon as the commission completes an investigation of a death or serious injury suffered by an incarcerated person in the custody of a correctional facility, the commission shall publish on its website a report containing the result of such investigation, including without limitation the complete result of the commission's investigation of such incident, true and correct copies of records that the commission has received from such facility in connection with its investigation of such incident, a determination as to whether conditions in the correctional facility or the quality of medical care or supervision that the incarcerated person received were contributing factors or related to the cause of death, and a list of regulations or applicable laws that may have been violated in proximate relation to such incident. The commission shall also cause such report to be delivered to the next-of-kin or authorized legal representative of such incarcerated person. Such reports shall not be redacted except as otherwise required to protect confidential medical records and behavioral health records in accordance with state and federal laws, rules, and regulations.

(c) The commission may publish information contained in its reports, data on deaths or serious injuries of incarcerated people at correctional facilities, and information on uncured violations of laws and regulations at any correctional facility in a searchable database format on its website if the commission determines that such a format will facilitate greater public access to such information.

(d) If, in the course of the commission's investigations or inspections, the commission finds evidence of a pattern of malfeasance, nonfeasance, abuse, or negligence on the part of staff or management at any correctional facility, the commission shall immediately report such evidence to the attorney general and the district attorney for the county in which such correctional facility is located, and such evidence shall be published within the reports issued by the commission pursuant to paragraph (a) of this subdivision.

§ 5. Section 43 of the correction law, as added by chapter 865 of the laws of 1975, subdivisions 1 and 2 as amended by chapter 379 of the laws of 1988, is amended to read as follows:

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the correction law, in relation to the membership of the state commission of correction and to inspection and procedures applica- ble to unsafe or unsanitary correctional facilities

Purpose

This bill expands the enforcement and oversight capacity of the state commission of correction to facilitate greater compliance and safety within New York's correctional facilities.

Summary of specific provisions

Section one adds a definition of "serious injury" to article 3 of the correction law and defines such term as it is defined in section 5102 of the insurance law.

Read the full memo (1,130 words)

Section two amends section 41 of the correction law to add six commis- sioners to the state commission of correction and restructures the apportionment of appointments. Two commissioners shall be appointed by the governor, two by the Assembly, two by the Senate, two by the Attor- ney General, and one by the Correctional Association of New York. Addi- tionally, at least one member of the commission shall be a formerly incarcerated person and at least one member shall have a background in public health. No more than three members shall have backgrounds in law enforcement, criminal prosecution, or corrections, and the number of commissioners with such background shall never be greater than the number of commissioners with backgrounds in criminal defense, indigent legal services, prisoner's rights litigation, and public legal services. All appointments must be on advice and consent of the Senate in order to ensure that the appointments meet these criteria. The commission is empowered to appoint its own chairman and if a vacancy on the commission lasts longer than 180 days the commission may fill the vacancy on its own motion. A new subdivision is added that requires that the commission is funded with at least 2% of the budget allocated annually for the Department of Corrections and Community Supervision.

Section three amends section 45 of the correction law to specify that the commission's inspections of correctional facilities shall be on an annual basis and shall not be contingent upon workload, available resources, or staffing. Additionally, the commission is prohibited from notifying correctional facilities in advance of its schedule for inspections unless such notification is necessary to fulfill its duties.

Justification

The State Commission of Correction was substantially reformed by chapter 865 of the laws of 1975 in response to riots at jails and prisons in New York, including the Attica prison uprising. The bill jacket for that law states that its purpose is to create "a full-time and vigorous watchdog organization to oversee the performance of the State and local correc- tional system." The Attica uprising was of course in response to deplor- able conditions at the Attica state prison. When the state retook control of Attica state prison, law enforcement had shot at least 128 people and killed nine hostages and twenty-nine incarcerated people. Today, incarcerated people at local and State correctional facilities once again face deplorable conditions that shock the conscience and fail to meet or exceed acceptable standards, leading to the deaths of incar- cerated people in the custody of the state of New York and violations of the constitutional rights of New Yorkers in state custody. This lapse, including the ongoing humanitarian crisis at Rikers Island, is in part due to the State Commission of correction's slow abdication of its stat- utory duties over recent decades, which in part has also resulted from reductions in its annual budget. A State comptroller's audit of the SCOC in 2006 found that due to reductions in funding, the SCOC had altogether stopped inspecting State prisons in the 1990s, leaving the Correctional Association of New York, with a staff of six people, as the sole remain- ing independent oversight agency for a State prison system with between 47,000 and 77,000 people in its custody across more than 50 facilities.

At many State and local correctional facilities, the spread of COVID-19 has been uncontrolled. At Rikers Island, incarcerated people have been forced to participate in "fight nights" under the watch of correctional officers. Unauthorized uses of force have been uncontrolled and violence has been rampant. In 2021, 16 people died in the custody of the New York City Department of Corrections. In the summer of 2021, incarcerated people on Rikers Island were crammed into small cells and given plastic bags to urinate and defecate in. Many were denied essential medical services, and incarcerated people under suicide watch went unsupervised. Some housing units on Rikers Island have been entirely unsupervised and in some instances have been controlled by gangs. Incarcerated people at Rikers Island have even missed their court appearances due to the mismanagement of the facility, undermining the sole purpose of pre-trial detention. At some correctional facilities elsewhere in the state, suicide attempts by incarcerated people have increased dramatically. It is clear that the State Commission of Correction is failing as a "a fulltime and vigorous watchdog organization to oversee the performance of the State and local correctional system."

This bill would implement a series of reforms- to empower and restore the vigorous independent watchdog status of the State Commission of Correction. The bill makes many of the commission's enforcement powers mandatory instead of discretionary, heightens reporting requirements, and broadens the participation of various government branches and stake- holders in the appointment of commissioners. It also broadens the back- grounds of commissioners in order to reduce potential conflicts of interest. The bill makes the commission's annual funding a minor percentage of the state prison system's annual allocation to ensure that the commission's funding is always commensurate and proportional to the size of New York's correctional system and that the commission has the funding necessary to annually inspect each of New York's hundreds of State and local correctional facilities.

Ultimately, New York's correctional facilities should be expected to comply with minimum standards and constitutional obligations, or else they are not fit to operate. A more powerful commission will save lives and avoid costly litigation over unsafe conditions, injuries and deaths, and violations of constitutional rights in New York's correctional facilities. A safer correctional system will also protect the safety of corrections officers employed in such facilities.

Legislative history

S.8161 of 2021-2022 (Hoylman): Died in Crime Victims, Crime and Correction

A.8461-A of 2021-2022 (Gallagher): Died in Correction

Fiscal implications

An appropriation of two percent of the Department of Corrections and Community Supervision's budget for the budget of the State Commission of Correction would increase the annual allocation for the State Commission of Correction by $59,868,580 above current levels to a total of $62,345,580, based on 2021-2022 funding levels for both agencies. Increases or reductions in the annual appropriation for DOCCS would increase or reduce the appropriation for the SCOC by a proportional amount.

Effective date

This act shall take effect immediately.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.