Skip to content
S6557Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA7502

Limit Utility Profits, Lower Bills

Official title

“Requires certain utilities to adopt the common equity ratio and rate of return on equity authorized by the public service commission”

Sponsor Shelley MayerSD-37+3 co-sponsorsAffects Environment & Energy
Status
In Assembly Committee
Energy
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 5 of 7

In Assembly · Energy

What's happening

This bill requires New York utility companies to use standardized, transparent rules for setting equity ratios and rates of return, with annual reviews and mechanisms to adjust customer bills accordingly.

Why it matters

  1. Increases transparency and public involvement. By requiring standardized, publicly explained methods for setting utility profit margins and equity ratios, the bill aims to make utility rate-setting more understandable and accessible to the public, not just industry experts or insiders.

  2. Imposes annual reviews and adjustments tied to actual performance. The bill mandates yearly recalculations of allowed utility profits, with mechanisms to refund customers if utilities earn more than permitted, or to collect additional funds if they earn less, ensuring rates more closely track economic conditions and utility performance.

  3. Shifts the burden of proof onto utilities for higher profits. Utilities that want to deviate from the standardized rates must justify their case in public hearings, presenting detailed evidence that higher profits are necessary for their financial health or investment needs—potentially making it harder for utilities to secure higher returns without strong justification.

  4. Prioritizes consumer and disadvantaged community interests. During any negotiations over utility profit levels, specific consideration must be given to minimizing costs for consumers, promoting equity, and addressing the needs of disadvantaged communities, signaling a legislative intent to protect vulnerable populations from excessive rate burdens.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Limit Utility Profits, Lower Bills

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Shelley Mayer

Senator · Senate District 37

Chair, Education

History

  1. Referred to energy
  2. Delivered to assembly
  3. Passed senateVote 54–8
  4. Advanced to third reading
  5. 2nd report cal.
  6. 1st report cal.296
  7. Referred to energy and telecommunications
  8. Returned to senate
  9. Died in assembly
  10. Referred to energy
  11. Delivered to assembly
  12. Passed senateVote 51–8
Show 6 earlier actions
  1. Advanced to third reading
  2. 2nd report cal.
  3. 1st report cal.883
  4. Print number 6557a
  5. Amend and recommit to energy and telecommunications
  6. Referred to energy and telecommunications

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A7502Assembly

Limit Utility Profits

In Assembly Committee · Energy · Sponsor Didi Barrett

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

4 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

6557--A

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

April 26, 2023

Introduced by Sen. MAYER -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Energy and Telecommunications -- committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee

AN ACT to amend the public service law, in relation to requiring certain utilities to adopt the common equity ratio and rate of return on equity authorized by the public service commission

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Legislative intent. The legislature finds and declares that:

1. The increasing burden of high utility rates leaves New York residents with extreme financial difficulties. Soaring electricity rates leave one in five New York residents at risk of having their electricity cut off. Meanwhile, the long-term trend of utilities receiving record profits threatens the livelihood of millions of New Yorkers who struggle to afford utility bills.

2. The current process in which the public service commission (hereinafter the "commission") and regulated utilities set rates for utility bills to ratepayers has historically been inaccessible and indecipherable to the public and often runs contrary to the stated goals of the commission to ensure affordable, safe, secure, and reliable utility service for New York residential and business consumers.

3. Regulated utilities are entitled to earn a fair and reasonable rate of return on their capital investments, pursuant to Supreme Court rulings in Federal Power Commission et al. v. Hope Natural Gas Co. (1944) and Bluefield Water Works and Improvement Co. v. Public Service Commission of West Virginia (1923). However, recent trends suggest that the "fair and reasonable" legal standard is not always reflected in actual utility rates for consumers. Aligning the incentives of regulated utilities and ratepayers is essential to protect the interests of

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD10360-04-3

all New York residents by establishing a more accurate standard for a regulated utility's right to earn a fair and reasonable rate of return.

§ 2. The public service law is amended by adding a new section 65-c to read as follows:

§ 65-c. Setting a rate of return on equity and common equity ratio. 1. Definitions. For the purposes of this section, the following terms shall have the following meanings:

(a) "Regulated utility" means an "electric corporation", "gas corporation", "steam corporation", or "water-works corporation" as defined in section two of this chapter.

(b) "Generic financing methodology" means a standardized procedure for determining the authorized rates of return on equity and common equity ratios of utilities regulated by the commission.

(c) "Authorized common equity ratio" means the authorized percentage of a utility's total capitalization, such as common equity, preferred stock, and long-term debt, that consists of common equity, retained earnings, and capital surplus.

(d) "Actual common equity ratio" means the actual percentage of a utility's total capitalization, such as common equity, preferred stock, and long-term debt, that consists of common equity, retained earnings, and capital surplus.

(e) "Authorized rate of return on equity" also known as return on equity ("ROE") or the cost of equity capital, means the return on the equity portion of the rate base that regulated utilities are authorized to collect in rates.

(f) "Actual rate of return on equity" means a measure of financial performance calculated by dividing net income by shareholders' equity.

(g) "Rate period" means the time period in which a regulated utility collects rates that are authorized and approved by the commission.

(h) "Publicly available data" means published data that is openly accessible via the internet, or indirectly accessible through a public library or similar institution.

2. Setting the generic financing methodology; common equity ratio; rate of return on equity. (a) On an annual basis, the commission shall promulgate rules and regulations that:

(i) update the generic financing methodology such that, to the greatest extent possible, all of its calculations are based upon publicly available data;

(ii) set a fair and reasonable authorized common equity ratio for each regulated utility and a single authorized rate of return on equity for all regulated utilities, based on the generic financing methodology; and

(iii) reconcile the prior rate period's authorized rate of return on equity to a calculation of the average monthly rate of return on equity produced by the generic financing methodology for that rate period, such as a "true-up mechanism". In making this determination, the commission shall require that: (A) any revenues derived from an authorized rate of return on equity exceeding the average monthly rate of return on equity be returned to ratepayers in the form of a surcredit to their bills for the following rate period; and (B) any revenues that would have been derived from an average monthly rate of return on equity exceeding the authorized rate of return on equity shall be recovered from ratepayers in the form of a surcharge to their bills for the following rate period.

(b) The promulgated generic financing methodology, authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, and the prior year's average monthly rate of return on equity shall clearly state the methods used to justify and explain its proposed guidance.

(c) The promulgated generic financing methodology, authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, and prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity shall be subject to traditional notice and comment procedures, as outlined in the state administrative procedure act, which shall include input from public interest organizations, utility accounting experts, representatives from regulated utilities, and other organizations and interested parties, including residents of this state, as necessary.

(d) The final generic financing methodology, authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, and prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity adopted by the commission, following the notice and comment period, shall give preference to the best interest of the ratepayers.

3. Adopting the authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity and/or prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity. Except as provided in subdivision four of this section, every regulated utility shall:

(a) adopt the authorized common equity ratio based on the generic financing methodology for the following rate period as set specifically for each regulated utility by the commission;

(b) adopt the authorized rate of return on equity based on the generic financing methodology for the following rate period; and

(c) adopt the surcredit/surcharge based on the prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity, as outlined in subdivision two of this section, for the following rate period.

4. Rebutting the authorized common equity ratio, rate of return on equity, and prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity. (a) The burden of rebutting the authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, and/or prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity shall rest exclusively with the regulated utility during a public hearing facilitated by the commission. In order to rebut the authorized common equity ratio and/or authorized rate of return on equity, the regulated utility shall first initiate a request for public hearing through procedures outlined by the commission. Should the commission find a substantial basis for the claims outlined by the regulated utility in its request, it shall publish a set of dates from which a public hearing shall take place.

(b) During the public hearing the regulated utility shall:

(i) present documentary evidence, including but not limited to exhibits, written and oral testimony, and data, describing why the authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, or prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity is insufficient to meet its current or future operating and capital needs;

(ii) present documentary evidence, including but not limited to exhibits, written and oral testimony, and data, describing why the authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, or prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity does not provide a fair and reasonable return;

(iii) describe with sufficient detail why the authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity or prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity adopted by the commission is insufficient for the regulated utility to attract capital at reasonable terms; and

(iv) describe with sufficient detail why the authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, or prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity is insufficient for the regulated utility to maintain its financial integrity during the rate year.

(c) If the commission determines, by a preponderance of the evidence, after the conclusion of the public hearing, that the regulated utility has sufficiently demonstrated that the authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, or prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity is insufficient to meet the regulated utilities' operating needs, capital needs, or both, then the commission and the regulated utility shall then enter into settlement negotiations through adjudication pursuant to the procedures set out under this article.

5. Settlement negotiations following successful rebuttal. All settlement negotiations shall take into consideration the following factors prior to reaching a final authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, or prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity:

(a) testimonies and exhibits from expert witnesses, including those from outside public interest organizations;

(b) how the negotiated settlement reduces delivery rates for consumers;

(c) how the negotiated settlement improves equity for, minimizes impacts on, and prioritizes benefits to utility rates for disadvantaged communities as defined in section 75-0101 of the environmental conservation law;

(d) whether the testimony and exhibits of the regulated utility reflect positions that are in the best interest of the public and promote principles of equity for disadvantaged communities;

(e) whether the proposals of the regulated utility would result in the lowest possible delivery cost to the benefit of the rate payer; and

(f) whether the new settlement agreement provides a just and reasonable return for the regulated utility.

6. Reports and legislative hearing on findings between the commission and regulated utilities. (a) Annually, the commission shall submit to the governor and the legislature, a report outlining the findings and determinations of the final authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity and/or prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity, whether set through the procedures outlined in subdivisions three and four of this section or through negotiated settlements outlined in subdivision five of this section, between a regulated utility and the commission during the previous year.

(b) Such report shall analyze and describe in clear, accessible language how the final authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, and/or prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity has changed, reflects new circumstances, or remained the same during the previous year.

(c) Such report shall include all monthly data used for generic financing methodology calculations that is not publicly available data, together with an explanation of why it was necessary to use such nonpublic data instead of a publicly available data source.

(d) The annual report shall be published online on the commission's website and be made publicly available.

§ 3. This act shall take effect one year after it shall have become a law.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the public service law, in relation to requiring certain utilities to adopt the common equity ratio and rate of return on equity authorized by the public service commission

Purpose

To require regulated utilities to adopt the rate of return on equity and common equity ratio as promulgated by the Public Service Commission by using an updated generic financing methodology when setting final utili- ty rates, which will provide the lowest possible delivery rates for ratepayers.

Summary of specific provisions

Section 1 outlines the legislative intent, emphasizing the inaccessible and outdated nature in which regulated utilities and the Public Service Commission set final utility rates for consumers.

Read the full memo (2,449 words)

Section 2 amends the public service law by adding a new section 65-c, which includes six new sections. First, it sets forth definitions to be applied in this section, including: regulated utility, generic financing methodology, authorized and actual common equity ratio, authorized and actual rate of return on equity, rate period, and publicly available data.

Second, it requires the commission, on an annual basis, to promulgate rules and regulations that: first, update the generic financing method- ology such that, to the greatest extent possible, all of its calcu- lations are based upon publicly available data; second, set a fair and reasonable authorized common equity ratio for each regulated utility and a single rate of return on equity for all regulated utilities based on the generic financing methodology; and third, reconcile the prior rate period's authorized rate of return on equity produced by the generic financing methodology for that rate period (i.e. a "true-up mechanism"). In this true-up process, the commission shall require that any revenues derived from the authorized rate of return on equity that exceeded the average monthly rate of return on equity be returned to ratepayers in the form of a surcredit to their bills for the following rate period, and that any revenues that would have been derived from an average monthly rate of return on equity exceeding the authorized rate of return on equity shall be recovered from ratepayers in the form of a surcharge to their bills for the following rate period.

The promulgated generic financing methodology, authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, and prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity shall include input from outside experts, utility representatives, interested organizations, and the public. The final regulations shall give preference to the best interest of the ratepayer.

Third, it requires every regulated utility to: adopt the authorized common equity ratio for the following rate period as set specifically for each regulated utility by the commission; adopt the authorized rate of return on equity for the following rate period; and adopt the surcredit/surcharge based on the prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity.

Fourth, it outlines the procedures in which a regulated utility may rebut the commission's authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, or prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity. It must first initiate a request for public hearing. If the commission finds substantial basis for the regulated utility's claims, it shall publish dates from which a public hearing shall take place. During the public hearing, a regulated utility must: present documentary evidence, testimony, and exhibits indicating why the author- ized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, or prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity as set by the commission is insufficient to meet its current or future operating and capital needs, does not provide a fair and reasonable return, describe why it is insufficient to attract capital at reasonable terms, and why it is insufficient to to maintain financial integrity during the rate year. If the commission determines, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the regulated utility has successfully met its burden, then it shall order settlement negotiations via commission-led adjudication.

Fifth, it sets out the standards from which settlement negotiations shall take place. Specifically, it requires the commission to consider: testimony and exhibits from expert witnesses, including those from public interest organizations; how the negotiated settlement reflects the lowest possible delivery rates for consumers; how the negotiated settlement improves equity for disadvantaged communities as defined in the environmental law, how the proposed rates reflect the best interest of the public and promote principles of equity for disadvantaged commu- nities; whether the proposals result in the lowest possible delivery cost to the benefit of the ratepayer; and whether the new settlement agreement provides a just and reasonable return.

Sixth, it requires the commission to submit to the Governor and legisla- ture, a report outlining the findings and determinations of the final authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, or prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity. The report must describe its findings in clear, accessible language and describe whether, if at all, the final determinations changed, reflect changed circumstances, or remained the same during the previous year. The report must also include all monthly data used for generic financing methodol- ogy calculations that is not publicly accessible data, together with an explanation why it was necessary to use non-public data instead of a publicly available data source. Lastly it shall be published online on the commission's website and made publicly available.

Section 3 sets forth the effective date.

Justification

Ratemaking represents one of the most fundamental undertakings between regulated utilities and the New York Public Service Commission (i.e. the commission). This intricate and protracted process leads to the determi- nation of final rates that a utility can charge to their customers in the form of utility bills. As a result, decisions made in ratemaking can have enormous economic impacts on consumers.(1)

But the ratemaking process is in dire need of reform. Existing proce- dures are inaccessible, outdated, and more often than not disproportion- ately benefit utilities at the ratepayers' expense. Millions of New Yorkers have difficulty understanding their utility bills, let alone making clear determinations on how a utility ends up justifying its rates. One core reason underlies this problem: the very manner in which final rates are decided is driven by the utility rather than the commis- sion.

Under the current ratemaking process, a utility begins by submitting a "rate case," a formal proceeding before the commission requesting new rates to cover the cost of operating and capital expenses. The utility's request includes detailed information about its current delivery system and financial accounts, in addition to the proposed rates it requests for the upcoming "rate period," the time frame in which the utility can collect rates from consumers based on the amount approved by the commis- sion.

Once a rate case is filed, the commission reviews the utility's docu- ments and rate requests, and develops a counter-proposal. Generally, two percentages drive this evaluation: the "common equity ratio" and the "rate of return on equity." The common equity ratio is the percentage of a utility's total capitalization, which consists of common equity (i.e. shares), retained earnings, and capital surplus. The rate of return on equity is the return on the equity portion of the rate base that utili- ties are authorized to collect in rates.(2) When combined, these deter- minations make up the ceiling from which a utility can charge customers through monthly utility bills. Herein lies the challenge.

To explain, both the utility and the commission provide their own common equity ratios and rates of return on equity. The utility uses its own accounting determinations, while the commission bases its on the "gener- ic financing methodology," a standardized formula driven by its staff. Notably, the commission's methodology is based on a 1994 recommended decision(3) that exists as "policy guidance," a non-binding administra- tive statement of general applicability used by the commission to direct its policies or determinations. While the generic financing methodology operates to serve the common good, its inputs are outdated and subject to change due to its non-binding nature.

Because of the disparity between the percentages proposed by the utility and the commission, settlement negotiations are typically held through an administrative law judge tasked with hearing evidence and recommend- ing a final decision. It is during this process that the utility and commission typically propose a settlemenet to decide the final rates.(4)

The debates over percentages and fractions of percentages can have enor- mous financial implications. As one expert noted from his 2022 testimo- ny: setting a common equity ratio at 48% rather than the utility's proposal of 50% would save ratepayers $64.2 million in the rate year, while setting a rate of return on equity at 8.75% rather than the utili- ty's proposal of 10% would save electric ratepayers $225.1 million and gas ratepayers an additional $85.5 million.(5) The combined savings in a one-year rate case resulting from a 48% common equity ratio and an 8.75% return on equity would total $374.8 million.(6)

This legislation aims to modernize the manner in which regulated utili- ties and the commission come to set final rates.(7) First, it requires the commission to promulgate regulations that: update the generic financing methodology to reflect new economic reali- ties which are, to the greatest extent possible, based upon publicly available data; set a fair and reasonable authorized common equity ratio for each specific regulated utility and set a single rate of return on equity for all regulated utilities; and reconcile the prior rate peri- od's authorized rate of return on equity produced by the generic financ- ing methodology for that rate period (i.e. a "true-up" mechanism). This true-up mechanism is a flexible approach that operates to reconcile the previous rate period's rates by requiring that revenues that exceeded the average monthly rate of return on equity be returned to ratepayers in the form of a surcredit to.their bills for the following rate period, and that revenues that would have been derived from an average monthly rate of return on equity exceeding the authorized rate of return on equity are recovered from ratepayers in the form of a surcharge to their bills for the following rate period. Each of the proposed regulations shall include input from accounting experts, utility representatives, outside organizations, and the public. The final re gulations must give preference to the best interest of the ratepayer.

Second, it requires every regulated utility to: adopt the authorized common equity ratio as set specifically for each regulated utility for the following rate period; adopt the single authorized rate of return on equity for the following period; and adopt the surcredit/surcharge based on the prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity.

Third, it sets out processes and standards from which a utility can rebut the commission's authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, and/or prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity. This shall take place at a public hearing, in which the regulated utility must present detailed evidence explaining why the commission's regulations are insufficient. The regulated utility must meet its burden by a preponderance of the evidence. If it does then the commission shall order adjudication.

Fourth, it outlines the standards in which settlement negotiations through commission-led adjudication shall take place. It requires the adjudicator to consider: testimony from expert witnesses and public interest organizations; and how the settlement reflects the lowest possible delivery rates for consumers, improves equity for disadvantaged communities as defined in the environmental law, promotes principles of equity, is in the best interest of the public, and provides a just and reasonable return.

Finally, it requires the commission to publish, on an annual basis, a report that describes in clear, accessible language the findings and determinations of the final authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, and/or prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity. The report must include all monthly data used for generic financing methodology calculations that is not publicly available data, with an explanation of why it was necessary to use non- public data instead of a publicly available data source.

By requiring utilities to begin with the presumption of adopting the commission's authorized common equity ratio, authorized rate of return on equity, and surcrdit/surcharge determination based on the prior rate period's average monthly rate of return on equity, and making explicit its requirement to prioritize the lowest possible utility costs for consumers and principles of fairness, New York will return power back to the public institution whose primary mission is to ensure affordable, safe, secure, and reliable access to utility services for New York State's residential and business consumers, at just and reasonable rates, while protecting the natural environment.(8) This legislation recognizes that regulated utilities are entitled to make a fair and reasonable return,(9) while emphasizing that the existing process of ratemaking must be fundamentally restructured.

Prior legislative history

A-print updates the report to be submitted to the Governor and legisla- ture.

Fiscal implications

To be determined.

Effective date

This act shall take effect one year after it shall be enacted into law. 1 For example, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that New York area electricity costs have exceeded the national average by at least 40% over the past five Decembers, and in December 2022, electricity costs in New York were 40.8% higher than the nation. 2 As one writer notes, the process of setting an allowed ROE has consistently proven to be the most contentious and subjective part of a rate case proceeding." Phillip S. Cross, Public Utilities Fortnightly, Equity Returns: 'Allowed' vs. Earned (Nov. 2015). 3 1994 "Recommended Decision" (Case 91-M-0509) (Proceeding on Motion of the Commission to Consider Financial Regulatory Policies for New York State Utilities). 4 As of April 2023, for example, the commission and ConEdison have submitted a request for public comments regarding its "joint proposal" for their ongoing rate case. https://dps.ny.gov/event/con-edison- comments-due-regarding-joint-proposal-submitted-con-edison-rate-case 5 Direct Testimony of William D. Yates for the Public Utility Law Project of New York, Inc. before the New York Public Service Commission (May 20, 2022). 6 id. 7 Regulated utilities means an "electric corporation," "gas corpo- ration," "steam corporation," or "water-works corporation" as defined in section two of the Public Service Law. 8 New York State, Department of Public Service, About Us, https://dps.ny.gov/about-us 9 For decades, the Supreme Court has recognized that regulated utilities are entitled to a reasonable opportunity to recover their "prudently-in- curred costs," and earn a "fair and reasonable rate of return on their capital investments." see Federal Power Commission et al v. Hope Natural Gas Co. ("Hope"), 320 U.S. 591, 603 (1944); Bluefield Water Works and Improvement Co. v. Public Service Commission of West Virginia ("Bluefield"), 262 U.S. 679 (1923).

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.