Skip to content
S6721Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA6919

Recognize Montaukett Indian Nation

Official title

“Relates to the reinstatement of state recognition and acknowledgement of the Montaukett Indian Nation”

Sponsor Anthony H. PalumboSD-1Affects Legal
Status
Senate Floor Calendar
Impact
7/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Vetoed via A6919

What's happening

This bill reinstates state recognition and acknowledgment of the Montaukett Indian Nation in New York and outlines its tribal governance.

Why it matters

  1. Restores formal state recognition to the Montaukett Indian Nation. , which could impact their ability to access state resources, assert land or cultural rights, and participate in government-to-government relations with New York.

  2. Specifies a governance structure for the Montaukett Nation. , mandating elected positions (chief or sachem, three trustees, and a secretary) and outlining fair, democratic processes for leadership selection, terms, and voter eligibility.

  3. Addresses historical legal injustices. by explicitly overturning a 1910 court decision that declared the tribe "extinct," potentially setting a precedent for how New York handles other historical cases of tribal recognition or disenfranchisement.

  4. Strengthens the tribe’s self-determination. by allowing the Montaukett Indian Nation to determine membership, voting qualifications, and leadership according to their own customs and regulations, rather than those imposed by external authorities.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Recognize Montaukett Indian Nation

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Anthony H. Palumbo

Senator · Senate District 1

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Substituted by A6919
  2. Advanced to third reading
  3. 2nd report cal.
  4. 1st report cal.973
  5. Referred to investigations and government operations

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A6919Assembly

Restore Montaukett Recognition

Vetoed · Sponsor Fred Thiele

Impact 7 · SignificantVetoed

Full text

3 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

6721

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

May 5, 2023

Introduced by Sen. PALUMBO -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Investigations and Government Operations

AN ACT to amend the Indian law, in relation to the reinstatement of state recognition and acknowledgement of the Montaukett Indian Nation

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Legislative findings. The Montaukett Indian Nation seeks reinstatement of its recognition and acknowledgment by the state of New York. Such recognition and acknowledgment was improperly removed from the Montaukett Indian Nation in 1910 in the case of Pharaoh v. Benson, 69 Misc. Rep. 241(Supreme, Suffolk Co., 1910) affirmed 164 App. Div. 51, affirmed 222 N.Y. 665, when the Montaukett Indian Nation was declared to be "extinct".

The court ruled that "the tribe has disintegrated and been absorbed into the mass of citizens and at the time of commencement of this action there was no tribe of Montaukett Indians". This arbitrary ruling ignored earlier U.S. Supreme Court decisions defining Indian Nations according to criteria under which the Montaukett Indian Nation qualified as an existing sovereign tribe and giving Congress, rather than the courts, power to decide the status of an Indian.

In the first of these U.S. Supreme Court decisions, United States v. Roger, 45 U.S. 567 (1848), the court ruled that the primary criteria for Indian identity was evidence that an Indian had to have some genealogical connection with a recognized group that had existed before the arrival of the European white explorers, traders, and settlers. Verified evidence demonstrates that the Montaukett Indian Nation existed prior to the Doctrine of Discovery and, as a sovereign tribe, ruled from the end of the Island to what is today the town of Hempstead.

Subsequently, a decade before the Montaukett decision, in Montoya v. U.S., 180 U.S. 261 (1901), the U.S. Supreme Court further defined an

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD11003-03-3

Indian tribe as "a body of Indians of the same or similar race, united in a community under one leadership or government, and inhabiting a particular though sometimes well-defined territory". The Montaukett Indian Nation also met this criteria.

Further, at the time of Pharaoh v. Benson decision, the judicial branches of state and federal governments had no authority to determine the status of an Indian tribe. Only the U.S. Congress had such power. In 1903, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in the United States v. Rickert, 188 U.S. 432 (1903) that only Congress can determine when changes in customs are sufficient to invalidate tribal status.

The U.S. Supreme Court also ruled in Butts v. Northern Pacific Railroad (1911), that neither the lapse of time, allotment of a portion of the tribal lands in severalty, immigration of a majority of the tribe, nor the fact that the habits and customs of the tribe have changed by intercourse with whites authorize the courts to disregard tribal status. That same year, the U.S. Supreme Court again spoke to the question of judicial authority in cases involving tribal existence, holding in Tiger v. Western Investment Company, 221 U.S. 286 (1911) that only the U.S. Congress had the authority to determine changes in tribal status.

In 1994, the State Supreme Court, in the case of Breakers Motel, Inc. v. Sunbeach Montauk Two, Inc., subsequently described the Pharaoh case as being of "questionable propriety", a recognition by the State Supreme Court that the decision removing recognition and acknowledgment from the Montaukett Indian Nation was dubious.

This legislature finds that in Pharaoh v. Benson, the Court improperly ignored U.S. Supreme Court precedent and lacked jurisdiction to judge the status of the Montaukett Indian Nation. It is the purpose of this legislation to reverse this improper and illegal result by the reinstatement of acknowledgment and recognition by the State of New York to the Montaukett Indian Nation.

§ 2. Section 2 of the Indian law, as added by chapter 174 of the laws of 2013, is amended to read as follows:

§ 2. New York state Indian nations and tribes. The term "Indian nation or tribe" means one of the following New York state Indian nations or tribes: Cayuga Nation, Oneida Nation of New York, Onondaga Nation, Poospatuck or Unkechauge Nation, Saint Regis Mohawk Tribe, Seneca Nation of Indians, Shinnecock Indian Nation, Tonawanda Band of Seneca, the Montaukett Indian Nation, and Tuscarora Nation.

§ 3. The Indian law is amended by adding a new article 11 to read as follows:

ARTICLE 11

THE MONTAUKETT INDIAN NATION Section 170. Reinstatement of state recognition and acknowledgment.

171. Leadership of Montaukett Indian Nation; elections; terms of

office.

172. Qualifications of voters.

173. Qualifications for office.

§ 170. Reinstatement of state recognition and acknowledgment. Recognition and acknowledgement of the Montaukett Indian Nation by the state of New York is hereby reinstated.

§ 171. Leadership of Montaukett Indian Nation; elections; terms of office. In accordance with the tribal governance rules, customs and regulations of the Montaukett Indian Nation, a sovereign nation, the tribe shall have a chief or sachem, three tribal trustees, and a tribal secretary. The trustees shall be elected by a majority vote by ballot of lineal members of the nation eligible to vote at an annual tribal meeting which shall be held on the first Tuesday in April. All officers shall hold office for a period of two years.

§ 172. Qualifications of voters. No person shall vote at the election provided for in section one hundred seventy-one of this article unless such person is at least eighteen years of age and is certified as a lineal member of the Montaukett Indian Nation in accordance with the nation's governance rules, customs and regulations.

§ 173. Qualifications for office. All officers shall qualify for office and perform their respective duties in accordance with the governance rules, customs and regulations of the Montaukett Indian Nation.

§ 4. This act shall take effect immediately.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the Indian law, in relation to the reinstatement of state recognition and acknowledgement of the Montaukett Indian Nation

Purpose

Relates to the reinstatement of state recognition and acknowledgement of the Montaukett Indian Nation. It provides for the leadership of the Montaukett Indian Nation; qualification of voters and office

Summary of specific provisions

Section 1. Legislative Findings

Read the full memo (735 words)

Section 2. Amends Section 2 of the Indian Law to add the Montaukett Indian Nation to the list of New York State Indian Nations and Tribes

Section 3. Amends the Indian Law by adding a new Article 11 - "The Montaukett Indian Nation"

Section 4. Provides for an immediate effective date

Justification

The Montaukett Indian Nation seeks reinstatement of its recognition and acknowledgment by the state of New York. Such recognition and acknowl- edgment was improperly removed from the Montaukett Indian Nation in 1910 in the case of Pharaoh v. Benson,69 Misc. Rep. 241(Supreme, Suffolk Co., 1910) affirmed 164 App. Div. 51, affirmed 222 N.Y. 665, when the Montaukett Indian Nation was declared to be "extinct".

The court ruled that "the tribe has disintegrated and been absorbed into the mass of citizens and at the time of commencement of this action there was no tribe of Montaukett Indians". This arbitrary ruling ignored earlier U.S. Supreme Court decisions defining Indian Nations according to criteria under which the Montaukett Indian Nation qualified as an existing sovereign tribe and giving Congress, rather than the courts, power to decide the status of an Indian.

In the first of these U.S. Supreme Court decisions, United States v. Roger, 45 U.S. 567 (1848), the court ruled that the primary criteria for Indian identity was evidence that an Indian had to have some genealogi- cal connection with a recognized group that had existed before the arrival of the European white explorers, traders, and settlers. Verified evidence demonstrates that the Montaukett Indian Nation existed prior to the Doctrine of Discovery and, as a sovereign tribe, ruled from the end of the Island to what is today the town of Hempstead.

Subsequently, a decade before the Montaukett decision, in Montoya v. U.S., 180 U.S. 261 (1901), the U.S. Supreme Court further defined an Indian tribe as "a body of Indians of the same or similar race, united in a community under one leadership or government, and inhabiting a particular though sometimes well-defined territory". The Montaukett Indian Nation also met this criteria.

Further, at the time of Pharaoh v. Benson decision, the judicial branch- es of state and federal governments had no authority to determine the status of an Indian tribe. Only the U.S. Congress had such power. In 1903, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in the United States v. Rickert, 188 U.S. 432 (1903) that only Congress can determine when changes in customs are sufficient to invalidate tribal status.

The U.S. Supreme Court also ruled in Butts v. Northern Pacific Rail Road (1911), that neither the lapse of time, allotment of a portion of the tribal lands in severalty, immigration of a majority of the tribe, nor the fact that the habits and customs of the tribe have changed by inter- course with whites authorize the courts to disregard tribal status.

That same year, the U.S. Supreme Court again spoke to the question of judicial authority in cases involving tribal existence, holding in Tiger v. Western Investment Company, 221 U.S. 286 (1911) that only the U.S. Congress had the authority to determine changes in tribal status.

In 1994, the State Surpreme Court, in the the case of Breakers Motel, Inc. v. Sunbeach Montauk Two, Inc., subsequently described the Pharaoh case as being of "questionable propriety", a recognition by the State Supreme Court that the decision removing recognition and acknowledgment from the Montaukett Indian Nation was dubious.

This legislature finds that in Pharaoh v. Benson, the Court improperly ignored U.S. Supreme Court precedent and lacked jurisdiction to judge the status of the Montaukett Indian Nation. It is the purpose of this legislation to reverse this improper and illegal result by the rein statement of acknowledgment and recognition by the State of New York to the Montaukett Indian Nation.

Legislative history

2021-22: S.6889/A.4069- Veto #110 of 2022

2019-20: S.3691/A.5411

2018: S.7770/A.9898 - Veto #360 of 2018

2017: S.3006/A.2325 - Veto #174 of 2017

2015-16: S.375A/A.202A

2014: S.7619/A.9704

Fiscal implications

None

Effective date

This act shall take effect immediately.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.