What's happening
This bill requires election officials and courts to interpret petition objections liberally to protect candidates' and voters' rights, making technical errors less likely to invalidate petitions.
Why it matters
Reduces technical disqualifications. By specifying that minor mistakes—like incorrect addresses, wrong city/town names, or pagination errors—cannot invalidate a petition, the bill makes it less likely for candidates to be disqualified over simple clerical errors.
Protects voter and candidate intent. The bill explicitly directs officials and courts to interpret petition rules in a way that prioritizes the rights of individuals to run for office and voters to support their chosen candidates, which could result in more candidates appearing on ballots and greater voter choice.
Limits grounds for objections. Only substantive issues (such as not meeting the minimum signature requirement or genuinely confusing misstatements about the office sought) can lead to petition rejection, meaning objections must be based on material flaws rather than technicalities.
Promotes consistency and fairness. By setting clear standards for handling petition objections, the bill aims to create a more uniform and predictable process across different election boards and courts, reducing arbitrary or inconsistent decisions.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Who cares
Candidates seeking ballot access
The bill would protect designating and nominating petitions from invalidation over pagination errors, misstated signature counts and certain address or office-description errors.
- Likely concerns
Election boards and courts
They would have to interpret election laws, rules and regulations liberally when ruling on petition objections to protect candidates’ right to run and voters’ choice.
- Likely concerns
Petition challengers
The bill would limit the grounds for valid objections, including requiring that an inaccurate office description would confuse a reasonable voter.
- Likely concerns
Petition signers and witnesses
Their use of a village, hamlet or census-designated place instead of a city or town—or a New York City borough instead of a county—would not alone support a valid objection.
Headline styles
Make Ballot Access Easier
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
No co-sponsors yet.
History
- Referred to elections
- Referred to elections
Full text
2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
6740
2023-2024 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
May 8, 2023
Introduced by Sen. MAY -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Elections
AN ACT to amend the election law, in relation to objections to designating and nominating petitions
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Section 6-154 of the election law is amended by adding a new subdivision 2-a to read as follows:
2-a. (a) When ruling on objections to designating and nominating petitions, the officer or board with whom such objection is filed shall construe all election laws, rules, and regulations liberally so as not to deprive an individual of their right to run for office, or the voters of their right to elect a candidate of their choice.
(b) The officer or board making a determination as to the sufficiency of a petition shall abide by the following when making such determination:
(i) Objections related to a voter or witness statement address shall not be valid if the voter or witness and the address are reasonably ascertainable by the officer or board making a determination.
(ii) Objections shall not be valid simply because a voter or witness writes in the name of the village, hamlet, or census designated place in which such voter or witness lives rather than the city or town in which such voter or witness lives. In the city of New York, an objection shall not be valid simply because a voter or witness writes in the name of the borough in which such voter or witness lives rather than the county in which such voter or witness lives.
(iii) Objections related to pagination errors shall not be a basis for invalidating a petition.
(iv) A petition shall not be invalidated because the signature count appearing on the cover sheet is misstated. Only the number of signatures actually appearing on the petition shall be counted.
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD11183-01-3
(v) A petition shall not be invalidated because the stated number of signatures that appear in the witness statement is inaccurate. Only the number of signatures actually appearing on the petition shall be counted.
(vi) An objection to a petition premised on the public office for which a candidate was designated for nomination being inaccurately stated shall be valid only if a reasonable voter would be confused by the description of such misstated office.
(vii) When the date appearing on the witness statement is earlier than the stated date of some voter signatures, only the voter signatures that bear a date that is later than the date borne by the witness statement shall be invalid.
(viii) A petition may be rejected by the board of elections if such petition does not meet the minimum number of signatures required pursuant to section 6-136 of this article.
§ 2. Section 16-102 of the election law is amended by adding a new subdivision 2-a to read as follows:
2-a. (a) When ruling on objections to designating and nominating petitions, the court shall construe all election laws, rules, and regulations liberally so as not to deprive an individual of their right to run for office, or the voters of their right to elect a candidate of their choice.
(b) The court shall abide by the following when making such determination:
(i) Objections related to a voter or witness statement address shall not be valid if the voter or witness and the address are reasonably ascertainable by the officer or board making a determination.
(ii) Objections shall not be valid simply because a voter or witness writes in the name of the village, hamlet, or census designated in which such voter or witness lives rather than the city or town in which such voter or witness lives. In the city of New York, an objection shall not be valid simply because a voter or witness writes in the name of the borough in which such voter or witness lives rather than the county in which such voter or witness lives.
(iii) Objections related to pagination errors shall not be a basis for invalidating a petition.
(iv) A petition shall not be invalidated because the signature count appearing on the cover sheet is misstated. Only the number of signatures actually appearing on the petition shall be counted.
(v) A petition shall not be invalidated because the stated number of signatures that appear in the witness statement is inaccurate. Only the number of signatures actually appearing on the petition shall be counted.
(vi) An objection to a petition premised on the public office for which a candidate was designated for nomination being inaccurately stated shall be valid only if a reasonable voter would be confused by the description of such misstated office.
(vii) When the date appearing on the witness statement is earlier than the stated date of some voter signatures, only the voter signatures that bear a date that is later than the date borne by the witness statement shall be invalid.
(viii) A petition may be rejected by the board of elections if such petition does not meet the minimum number of signatures required pursuant to section 6-136 of this chapter.
§ 3. This act shall take effect immediately.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the election law, in relation to objections to designat- ing and nominating petitions
Purpose
To reduce the number of arbitrary hurdles the petitioning process imposes on persons seeking to run for public office.
Summary of provisions
The bill amends §§ 6-154 and 16-102 of the election law, requiring any board of elections official or judge ruling on the validity of objections to designating and nominating petitions to construe the rele- vant election law, rules, and regulations liberally so as not to deprive an individual of their right to run for office, or the voters of their right to elect a candidate of their choice. The bill requires the board of elections official or judge, when evaluating the sufficiency of a petition to abide by the following:
Read the full memo (629 words)
*objections related to a voter or witness statement address should fail if the voter or witness and their address is reasonably ascertainable
*an objection will not be valid simply because a voter or witness writes in the name of their village rather than their town. In the city of new york, an objection will not be valid simply because a voter or witness writes in the name of their borough rather than their county
*pagination errors shall not be a basis for invalidating a petition
*a petition packet should not be invalidated simply because the signa- ture count appearing on the cover sheet is misstated
*a petition will not be invalidated simply because the stated number of signatures that appear in the witness statement is inaccurate
*a challenge to a petition premised on the relevant office being inaccu- rately stated will be valid only if the misstated office is likely to confuse voters
*When the date appearing on the witness statement is earlier than the stated date of some voter signatures, only the voter signatures that carry a date that is later than the date born by the witness statement will be invalid.
* A petition may be rejected if such a petition does not meet the mini- mum number of signatures required under the election law.
Justification
Despite efforts over the past several years to make ballot access easi- er, there are still a number of arcane election requirements that make it unnecessarily difficult for candidates to get on the ballot. The petitioning process is intended to require potential candidates to show a threshold level of support from the community they wish to represent, and candidates are required to collect a minimum number of valid signa- tures, depending on the size of the district or municipality. Yet far too often, established incumbents and political parties are able to leverage the often obscure regulations of the petitioning process to keep new candidates off the ballot.
Election law allows a voter's signature to be invalidated for many seem- ingly arbitrary or unnecessary reasons, even in cases where there is no allegation of fraud or forgery. As a result, many candidates each year are thrown off the ballot when signatures from registered voters in their district are invalidated for technical errors. These technical errors could include a witness failing to correctly count the number of signatures on a petition sheet, a voter writing the name of their village or borough rather than their town or county, or a campaign acci- dentally submitting a petition packet with the pages out of order. In these and many other cases, the rights of voters to see the candidate they signed for on the ballot are overlooked. While many petition requirements are necessary to prevent fraud, others now serve little discernible purpose other than to discourage people from running for office.
Legislative history
2021-2022: S.8444 (Reichlin-Melnick)
Fiscal implications
None.
Effective date
This act shall take effect immediately.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.