Skip to content
S7005Senate2023-2024 Session

Stop Medical Debt Collection

Official title

“Relates to medical debt”

Sponsor Brad Hoylman-SigalSD-47Affects Legal
Status
In Senate Committee
Judiciary
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Judiciary

What's happening

This bill requires hospitals to publicly disclose pricing information and restricts debt collection actions if they fail to comply with transparency requirements.

Why it matters

  1. Empowers patients and families. By requiring hospitals to publish actual negotiated rates (not just "list prices") for hundreds of services, patients can better compare prices and avoid surprise bills, helping them make more informed healthcare decisions.

  2. Creates real financial consequences for hospitals. Hospitals that fail to comply with transparency rules face strict penalties—including being barred from suing patients, sending bills to collections, or reporting medical debt to credit bureaus—potentially reducing aggressive debt collection for non-transparent facilities.

  3. Improves accountability and oversight. The law mandates the Department of Health to monitor compliance, investigate complaints, and publicize noncompliant hospitals, increasing pressure on facilities to follow transparency rules and deterring misconduct.

  4. Protects consumers during disputes. If a patient challenges a hospital’s compliance, all debt collection actions must be paused until the legal question is resolved, and if the hospital is found noncompliant, the patient can recover costs, have lawsuits dismissed, and clear negative credit reports, offering strong recourse for unfair billing practices.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Stop Medical Debt Collection

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Brad Hoylman-Sigal

Senator · Senate District 47

Chair, Judiciary

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to judiciary
  2. Referred to judiciary

Full text

10 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

7005

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

May 16, 2023

Introduced by Sen. HOYLMAN-SIGAL -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Judiciary

AN ACT to amend the civil practice law and rules, the general business law and the public health law, in relation to medical debt

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subdivision (a) of section 5201 of the civil practice law and rules is amended to read as follows:

(a) Debt against which a money judgment may be enforced. A money judgment may be enforced against any debt, which is past due or which is yet to become due, certainly or upon demand of the judgment debtor, whether it was incurred within or without the state, to or from a resident or non-resident, unless it is exempt from application to the satisfaction of the judgment. A debt may consist of a cause of action which could be assigned or transferred accruing within or without the state. No money judgment shall be sought, entered, or enforced in an action arising from non-payment of facility items and services by a patient or patient guarantor that is brought by a facility, as defined under section twentyeight hundred thirty-one of the public health law, that is in material noncompliance with section twenty-eight hundred thirty-one of the public health law on the date that the relevant facility items or services are purchased from a provider to a patient by the facility in material noncompliance.

§ 2. Section 7501 of the civil practice law and rules, as amended by chapter 532 of the laws of 1963, is amended to read as follows:

§ 7501. Effect of arbitration agreement. A written agreement to submit any controversy thereafter arising or any existing controversy to arbitration is enforceable without regard to the justiciable character of the controversy and confers jurisdiction on the courts of the state to enforce it and to enter judgment on an award. In determining any matter arising under this article, the court shall not consider whether the

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD11445-01-3

claim with respect to which arbitration is sought is tenable, or otherwise pass upon the merits of the dispute. No facility, as defined under section twenty-eight hundred thirty-one of the public health law, shall enforce an arbitration agreement or clause in any facility document, including contracts, agreements, statements, or bills, in an action arising from patient or patient guarantor non-payment of facility items or services, if that facility is in material noncompliance with section twenty-eight hundred thirty-one of the public health law on the date that the relevant facility items or services are purchased from a provider to a patient by the facility in material noncompliance.

§ 3. Section 601 of the general business law is amended by adding two new subdivisions 12 and 13 to read as follows:

12. Attempt to collect a medical debt, or debt arising from nonpayment of facility items and services, from a patient or patient guarantor by referring the debt, directly or indirectly, to a debt collector or debt collection agency if the principal creditor is a facility, as defined by section twenty-eight hundred thirty-one of the public health law, or an affiliate, that is in material noncompliance with section twenty-eight hundred thirty-one of the public health law on the date that the relevant facility items or services are purchased from a provider to a patient by the facility; or

13. Disclose or cause to be disclosed information affecting the debtor's reputation for credit worthiness, including to a consumer credit reporting agency as defined in article twenty-five of this chapter, if the principal creditor is a facility, as defined by section twentyeight hundred thirty-one of the public health law, or an affiliate, that is in material noncompliance with section twenty-eight hundred thirtyone of the public health law on the date that the relevant facility items or services are purchased from a provider to a patient by the facility, and the action arose from patient or patient guarantor nonpayment of facility items or services.

§ 4. The public health law is amended by adding a new section 2831 to read as follows:

§ 2831. The hospital price transparency act. 1. As used in this section:

(a) "Ancillary service" means a facility item or service that a facility customarily provides as part of or in conjunction with a shoppable primary service.

(b) "Chargemaster" means the list of all facility items and services maintained by a facility for which the facility has established a charge.

(c) "Collections action" includes any of the following actions taken with respect to a debt for items and services that were purchased from or provided to a patient by a facility:

(i) attempting to collect a debt from a patient or patient guarantor by referring the debt, directly or indirectly, to a debt collector, a collection agency, or other third-party retained by or on behalf of the facility;

(ii) initiating a lawsuit against the patient or patient guarantor, or enforcing an arbitration or mediation clause in any facility documents including contracts, agreements, statements, or bills; or

(iii) directly or indirectly causing a report to be made to a consumer reporting agency.

(d) "De-identified maximum negotiated charge" means the highest charge that a facility has negotiated with all third-party payers for a facility item or service.

(e) "De-identified minimum negotiated charge" means the lowest charge that a facility has negotiated with all third-party payers for a facility item or service.

(f) "Discounted cash price" means the charge that applies to an individual who pays cash, or cash equivalent, for a facility item or service.

(g) "Facility" includes the following:

(i) general hospitals as defined in section twenty-eight hundred one of this article; and

(ii) any hospital, as defined in section twenty-eight hundred one of this article, to which the department determines this section should apply.

(h) "Gross charge" means the charge for a facility item or service that is reflected on a facility's chargemaster, absent any discounts.

(i) "Facility items and services" and any variation of this phrase means all items and services, including individual items and services and service packages, that may be provided by a facility to a patient in connection with an inpatient admission or an outpatient department visit for which the facility has established a standard charge. This includes, but is not limited to:

(i) supplies and procedures;

(ii) room and board;

(iii) use of the facility and other areas, the charges for which are generally referred to as facility fees;

(iv) services of physicians and non-physician practitioners, employed by the facility, the charges for which are generally referred to as professional charges; and

(v) any other item or service for which a facility has established a standard charge.

(j) "Machine-readable format" means a digital representation of data or information in a file that can be imported or read into a computer system for further processing, including .XML, .JSON, and .CSV formats.

(k) "Payer-specific negotiated charge" means the charge that a facility has negotiated with a third-party payer for a facility item or service.

(l) "Service package" means an aggregation of individual facility items and services into a single service with a single charge.

(m) "Shoppable service" means a service that may be scheduled by a health care consumer in advance.

(n) "Standard charge" means the regular rate established by the facility for a facility item or service provided to a specific group of paying patients. This term includes all of the following, as defined under this section:

(i) the gross charge;

(ii) the payer-specific negotiated charge;

(iii) the de-identified minimum negotiated charge;

(iv) the de-identified maximum negotiated charge; and

(v) the discounted cash price.

(o) "Third-party payer" means an entity that is, by statute, contract, or agreement, legally responsible for payment of a claim for a facility item or service.

2. Notwithstanding any other law, a facility must make public the following:

(a) a digital file in a machine-readable format that contains a list of all standard charges for all facility items and services as provided in subdivision three of this section; and

(b) a consumer-friendly list of standard charges for a limited set of shoppable services as provided in subdivision three of this section.

3. (a) A facility shall maintain a list of all standard charges for all facility items and services in accordance with this section. This list must include, as applicable:

(i) a description of each facility item or service provided by the facility; and

(ii) the following charges for each individual facility item or service when provided in either an inpatient setting or an outpatient department setting, as applicable:

(A) the gross charge;

(B) the de-identified minimum negotiated charge;

(C) the de-identified maximum negotiated charge;

(D) the discounted cash price; and

(E) the payer-specific negotiated charge, listed by the name of the third-party payer and plan associated with the charge and displayed in a manner that clearly associates the charge with each third-party payer and plan; and

(iii) any code used by the facility for purposes of accounting or billing for the facility item or service, including, but not limited to, the Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) code, the Healthcare Common Procedure Coding System (HCPCS) code, the Diagnosis Related Group (DRG) code, the National Drug Code (NDC), or other common payer identifier.

(b) The standard charges contained in the list required to be maintained by a facility under paragraph (a) of this subdivision must reflect the standard charges applicable to that location of the facility, regardless of whether the facility operates in more than one location or operates under the same license or approval as another facility.

(c) The information contained in the list required under paragraph (a) of this subdivision must be published in a single digital file that is in a machine-readable format.

(d) The list required under paragraph (a) of this subdivision must be displayed in a prominent location on the home page of the facility's publicly accessible internet website or accessible by selecting a dedicated link that is prominently displayed on the home page of the facility's publicly accessible internet website. If the facility operates multiple locations and maintains a single internet website, the list required under paragraph (a) of this subdivision must be posted for each location the facility operates in a manner that clearly associates the list with the applicable location of the facility.

(e) The list required under paragraph (a) of this subdivision must:

(i) be available:

(A) free of charge;

(B) without having to register or establish a user account or password;

(C) without having to submit personal identifying information;

(D) without having to enter a code to access the list; and

(E) without having to overcome any other barrier that limits the availability or accessibility of the list;

(ii) be accessible to a common commercial operator of an internet search engine to the extent necessary for the search engine to index the list and display the list as a result in response to a search query of a user of the search engine;

(iii) be formatted in a manner prescribed by the department under subdivision five of this section;

(iv) be digitally searchable; and

(v) use the following naming convention specified by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, specifically: _ name>_standardcharges.{json/xml/csv}.

(f) The facility must update the list required under paragraph (a) of this subdivision at least once a year. The facility must clearly indicate the date on which the list was most recently updated, either within the list itself or in a manner that is clearly associated with the list.

4. (a) Except as provided by paragraph (c) of this subdivision, a facility shall maintain and make publicly available a list of the standard charges described in subparagraphs (i), (ii), (iii), (iv) and (v) of paragraph (d) of this subdivision for at least three hundred shoppable services provided by the facility. The facility may select the shoppable services to be included in the list, except that the list must include:

(i) the seventy services specified as shoppable services by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services; or

(ii) if the facility does not provide all of the seventy services specified as shoppable services by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, as many of those shoppable services the facility does provide.

(b) In selecting a shoppable service for purposes of inclusion in the list required under paragraph (a) of this subdivision, a facility must:

(i) consider how frequently the facility provides the service and the facility's billing rate for that service; and

(ii) prioritize the selection of services that are among the services most frequently provided by the facility.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the civil practice law and rules, the general business law and the public health law, in relation to medical debt

Purpose

To create hospital price transparency requirements that mirror federal regulations and allow the health department to enforce hospital price transparency.

Summary of specific provisions

Section 1 amends the civil practice law and rules to bar noncompliant hospitals from seeking, entering, or enforcing money judgements related to medical debts.

Read the full memo (1,038 words)

Section 2 amends the civil practice law and rules to bar noncompliant hospitals from enforcing arbitration clauses.

Section 3 amends the general business law by barring noncompliant hospi- tals from reporting medical debt to credit agencies and instituting collections actions regarding medical debt.

Section 4 adds a new section 2830 to the public health law which:

1) Defines the following terms:

a. Ancillary service

b. Chargemaster

c. Collections action

d. De-identified maximum negotiated charge

e. De-identified minimum negotiated charge

f. Discounted cash price

g. Facility

h. Gross charge

i. Facility items and services

j. Machine-readable format

k. Payer-specific negotiated charge 1. Service package

m. Shoppable service

n. Standard charge

o. Third party payer

2) Requires hospitals to make public a digital file of its standard charges and a separate consumer-friendly list of standard charges for shoppable services

3) Institutes requirements regarding the content, format, and display of the public list of standard charges

4) Institutes requirements regarding the content, format, and display of the consumer-friendly list of standard charges for shoppable services, also allowing hospitals to create a price estimator tool for shoppable services instead of a list of standard charges.

5) Prescribes considerations for the health department in formatting requirements for lists of standard charges

6) Requires that hospitals submit updated lists of standard charges to the, health department

7) Defines the mechanisms by which the health department can monitor and enforce hospital compliance with this this section

8) Defines material noncompliance with this section and institutes procedures regarding corrective action plans

9) Authorizes the health department to impose administrative penalties on noncompliant facilities, subject to certain limitations

10) Allows the health department to submit recommendations to the legis- lature for amendments to this section, especially in response to amend- ments by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services to 45 C.F.R. Part 180

11) Prohibits noncompliant hospitals from enforcing mediation or alter- native dispute resolution clauses

12) Creates a private right of action for individuals who are subject to collections actions by noncompliant hospitals

13) Clarifies that this legislation does not require refunds except for certain circumstances and does not prevent hospitals from billing patients or insurers

Section 5 provides the effective date.

Justification

Healthcare costs are a major issue in New York. In 2020, New York had the highest per-capita healthcare spending of any state in the country, 37% higher than the national average, (CMS NHE) in addition to the high- est nationwide spending on hospitals. (CMS table 12) Healthcare prices increased on average 16% from 2016 to 2020, with inpatient hospital prices increasing 25% in that same time period. (Health Cost Institute) But despite skyrocketing prices, a recent report noted that "New York was notably absent from the states that are actively engaged in tackling the issue of high hospital prices." (32BJ Report)

In November 2019, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) finalized a hospital price transparency rule, codified at 45 CFR Part 180. The rule, enforced by the Centers for Medicaid and Medicare Services (CMS), required hospitals to create and make public their lists of standard charges and a consumer-friendly list of shoppable services. HHS declared that the action was "necessary to promote price transparen- cy in health care" and intended to allow the public to "make more informed decisions about their care" thereby "increas(ing) market compe- tition" to "ultimately drive down the cost of health care services, making them more affordable for all patients." (Final Rule) Hospital price transparency does indeed yield immense benefits for consumers. The same medical service, at the same quality level, will have substantially different prices at different facilities, and price transparency allows patients to "price shop" by finding the lowest cost facility where they can get the same service. This is especially salient given that 43k of individual healthcare spending is on shoppable services. (Frost & Newman) Research has consistently shown that healthcare price transpar- ency reduces claim payments (Whaley et al.), lowers prices at both high- cost and low-cost facilities (Robinson & Brown), and allows insurance companies to identify high-cost providers and negotiate lower prices (Younts & Gorelik). Price transparency initiatives may reduce commercial prices by up to 4.7%, yielding $26.6 billion in savings. (RAND) But despite the federal government's good intentions, compliance with the rules has been abysmal. As of August 2022, only 14.3% of hospitals nationwide were deemed to be in full compliance with the federal hospi- tal price transparency rules. (PRA) Only 9% of hospitals in New York State and two of the New York City hospitals studied were fully complaint. (PRA) Despite widespread noncompliance, CMS fined only two hospitals nationwide. (32BJ report). In November, a US Congressional Committee called on the Government Accountability Office to investigate hospital noncompliance and CMS enforcement. (House Letter) State legis- latures have taken action: Colorado (HB1285), Virginia CHB481), and Texas (SB1127) have enacted legislation similar to this bill, codifying federal rules into state law and authorizing state enforcement. By importing federal hospital price transparency requirements into state law, giving state agencies the authority to enforce them, and institut- ing other self-enforcement mechanisms, we can ensure that hospitals comply with price transparency requirements and reduce healthcare costs statewide.

Legislative history

This is new legislation.

Fiscal implications

To be determined.

Effective date

This act shall take effect one year after it shall become law. Footnotes: (CMS NHE) https://www.cms.gov/Research-Statistics-Data- andSystems/Statistics-Trends-and-Reports/NationalHealth ExpendData/NHE-Fact-Sheet (final rule):84 FR 65524, pl https : //www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR -2019-11-27/pdf/ 2019-24931. pdf (PRA): HTTPS://WWW.PATIENTRIGHTSADVOCATE.ORG/AUGUST-SEMI- ANNUAL-COM- PLIANCEREPORT-2022 32BJ Report: HTTPS://WWW.32BJHEALTHFUNDINSIGHTS.ORG/ WPCONTENT/UPLOADS/2022/09/HP-POLICY-PRACTICAL PRINT- DIGITAL.PDF Whaley: HTTPS://JAMANETWORK.COM/JOURNALS/JAMA/ FULLARTICLE/1917438 Robinson: HTTPS://WWW. HEALTHAF- FAIRS.ORG/DOI/FUL1/10.1377/HLTHAFF.2013.0188 Frost & Newman:

HTTPS://COLLECTIONS.NLM.NIH.GOV/MASTER/BORNDIG/ 101711638/SHOPPABLET205ERVICES T20113%203.2.16 0.PDF Younts & Gorelik: HTTPS://WWW.HEALTHCAREDIVE.COM/ NEWS/PRICE-TRANSPARENCYDATA-NEW-VISIBILITY-RATES- PROVIDERS/633854/ RAND: HTTPS://WWW.RAND.ORG/PUBS/RESEARCH REPORTS/ RRA805-1.HTML (p27- 28) Health Cost Institute:

HTTPS://HEALTHCOSTINSTITUTE.ORG/IMAGES//PDFS/HCCI 2020 HEALTH CARE COST AND U TILIZATION REPORT.PDF (House Letter): HTTPS://REPUBLICANS-ENERGYCOMMERCE. HOUSE.GOV/WP-CONTENT/UPLOADS/2022/11/GA0.2022.11.4. LETTER-RE-HOSPI- TAL-PRICE-TRANSPARENCY-FINAL-RULE.HE.PDF

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.