Skip to content
S7200Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA3229

Let Justice Courts Hear Business Claims

Official title

“Authorizes the exercise of jurisdiction over commercial claims in justice courts”

Sponsor Pamela HelmingSD-54Affects Legal
Status
In Senate Committee
Judiciary
Impact
6/10
Moderate
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Judiciary

What's happening

This bill allows justice courts in New York to handle commercial claims, establishing specific procedures and rules for such cases.

Why it matters

  1. Expands access to lower-cost, faster justice for small businesses and organizations. By allowing justice courts to handle commercial claims, local businesses and organizations can more easily resolve disputes close to home, without the expense and delay of higher courts.

  2. Imposes limits to prevent abuse by frequent filers and collection agencies. The bill places caps on the number of commercial claims a business or organization can file per month and restricts claim-buying by collection agencies, aiming to curb potential harassment or exploitation of the court process.

  3. Creates consumer protections and transparency. Distinguishes between general commercial disputes and those involving individual consumers, requiring additional steps (like demand letters) for claims arising from consumer transactions, and mandates that parties receive clear information about their rights and court procedures.

  4. Streamlines procedure but preserves key legal safeguards. Justice courts must use informal, simplified procedures for commercial claims, making the process less intimidating and more accessible, yet still ensure fairness, allow for jury trials in certain cases, and facilitate judgment enforcement—including actions against businesses using false names or failing to pay court-ordered debts.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • New York-based corporations, partnerships and associations

    The bill would let them bring money claims within the small-claims dollar limit in justice courts through simplified procedures, with a $25 filing fee plus mailing costs and a five-case monthly cap.

  • Consumers sued by businesses

    Claims arising from personal, family or household transactions would require a demand letter before filing, and defendants could request evening hearings and file counterclaims.

  • Justice court judges and clerks

    They would handle new commercial claims parts, including simplified filings, hearing notices, judgment records and assistance with information subpoenas for collecting unpaid judgments.

  • State and local business licensing authorities

    They would have to consider certain deliberate or repeated failures to pay commercial claims judgments as grounds for licensing sanctions.

Headline styles

Let Justice Courts Hear Business Claims

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Pamela Helming

Senator · Senate District 54

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to judiciary
  2. Referred to judiciary

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A3229Assembly

Let Local Courts Hear Business Claims

In Assembly Committee · Judiciary · Sponsor Marjorie Byrnes

Impact 6 · Moderate0% to pass

Full text

8 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

7200

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

May 18, 2023

Introduced by Sen. HELMING -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Judiciary

AN ACT to amend the uniform justice court act, in relation to authorizing the exercise of jurisdiction over commercial claims in justice courts

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. The uniform justice court act is amended by adding a new article 18-A to read as follows:

ARTICLE 18-A

COMMERCIAL CLAIMS Section 1820. Commercial claims defined.

1821. Parts for the determination of commercial claims estab-

lished.

1822. Commencement of action upon commercial claims.

1823. Informal and simplified procedure on commercial claims.

1824. Remedies available; transfer of commercial claims.

1825. Trial by jury; how obtained; discretionary costs.

1826. Proceedings on default and review of judgments.

1827. Judgment obtained to be res judicata in certain cases.

1828. Procedures relating to corporations, associations, insur-

ers and assignees.

1829. Limitation on right to resort to commercial claims proce-

dures.

1830. Indexing commercial claims part judgments.

1831. Enforcement of commercial claims judgments.

1832. Duty to pay judgments.

1833. Designation of defendant; amendment procedure. § 1820. Commercial claims defined.

(a) The term "commercial claim" or "commercial claims" as used in this act shall mean and include any cause of action for money only not in

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD03995-01-3

excess of the maximum amount permitted for a small claim in the small claims part of the court, exclusive of interest and costs, provided that subject to the limitations contained in section eighteen hundred twenty-eight of this article, the claimant is a corporation, partnership or association, which has its principal office in the state of New York and provided that the defendant either resides, or has an office for the transaction of business or a regular employment, within the county in which the court is located.

(b) The term "consumer transaction" means a transaction between a claimant and a natural person, wherein the money, property or service which is the subject of the transaction is primarily for personal, family or household purposes. § 1821. Parts for the determination of commercial claims established.

The chief administrator shall assign the times and places for holding, and the judges who shall hold, one or more parts of the court for the hearing of commercial claims as herein defined, and the rules may regulate the practice and procedure controlling the determination of such claims and prescribe and furnish the forms for instituting the same. There shall be at least one evening session of each part every month for the hearing of commercial claims, provided however, that the chief administrator may provide for exemption from this requirement where there exists no demonstrated need for evening sessions. The chief administrator shall not combine commercial claims part actions with small claims part actions for purposes of convenience unless a preference is given to small claims and to commercial claims arising out of consumer transactions. Such practice, procedure and forms shall differ from the practice, procedure and forms used in the court for other than small claims and commercial claims, notwithstanding any provision of law to the contrary. They shall constitute a simple, informal and inexpensive procedure for the prompt determination of commercial claims in accordance with the rules and principles of substantive law. The procedure established pursuant to this article shall not be exclusive of but shall be alternative to the procedure now or hereafter established with respect to actions commenced in the court by the service of a summons. No rule to be enacted pursuant to this article shall dispense with or interfere with the taking of stenographic minutes of any hearing of any business claim hereunder. § 1822. Commencement of action upon commercial claims.

(a) (i) Commercial claims other than claims arising out of consumer transactions shall be commenced upon the payment by the claimant of a filing fee of twenty-five dollars and the cost of mailings as herein provided, without the service of a summons and, except by special order of the court, without the service of any pleading other than a required certification verified as to its truthfulness by the claimant on a form prescribed by the state office of court administration and filed with the clerk, that no more than five such actions or proceedings (including the instant action or proceeding) have been instituted during that calendar month, and a statement of its cause of action by the claimant or someone on the claimants behalf to the clerk, who shall reduce the same to a concise, written form and record it in a docket kept especially for such purpose. Such procedure shall provide that the commercial claims part of the court shall have no jurisdiction over, and shall dismiss, any case with respect to which the required certification is not made upon the attempted institution of the action or proceeding. Such procedure shall provide for the sending of notice of such claim by ordinary first-class mail and certified mail with return receipt requested to the party complained against at his residence, if he resides within the county in which the court is located, and his residence is known to the claimant, or at his office or place of regular employment within such county if he does not reside therein or his residence within the county is not known to the claimant. If, after the expiration of twenty-one days, such ordinary first-class mailing has not been returned as undeliverable, the party complained against shall be presumed to have received notice of such claim. Such notice shall include a clear description of the procedure for filing a counterclaim, pursuant to subdivision (d) of this section.

(ii) Such procedure shall further provide for an early hearing upon and determination of such claim. The hearing shall be scheduled in a manner which, to the extent possible, minimizes the time the party complained against must be absent from employment.

(iii) Either party may request that the hearing be scheduled during evening hours, provided that the hearing shall not be scheduled during evening hours if it would cause unreasonable hardship to either party. The court shall not unreasonably deny requests for evening hearings if such requests are made by the claimant upon commencement of the action or by the party complained against within fourteen days of receipt of the notice of claim.

(b) (i) Commercial claims in actions arising out of consumer transactions shall be commenced upon the payment by the claimant of a filing fee of twenty-five dollars and the cost of mailings as herein provided, without the service of a summons and, except by special order of the court, without the service of any pleading other than a required statement of the cause of action by the claimant or someone on the claimants behalf to the clerk, who shall reduce the same to a concise written form including the information required by subdivision (c) of this section, denominate it conspicuously as a consumer transaction, and record it in the docket marked as a consumer transaction, and by filing with the clerk a required certificate verified as to its truthfulness by the claimant on forms prescribed by the state office of court administration.

(ii) Such verified certificate shall certify (A) that the claimant has mailed by ordinary first-class mail to the party complained against a demand letter, no less than ten days and no more than one hundred eighty days prior to the commencement of the claim, and (B) that, based upon information and belief, the claimant has not instituted more than five actions or proceedings (including the instant action or proceeding) during the calendar month.

(iii) Such procedure shall further provide for an early hearing upon and determination of such claim. The hearing shall be scheduled in a manner which, to the extent possible, minimizes the time the party complained against must be absent from employment. Either party may request that the hearing be scheduled during evening hours, provided that the hearing shall not be scheduled during evening hours if it would cause unreasonable hardship to either party. The court shall not unreasonably deny requests for evening hearings if such requests are made by the claimant upon commencement of the action or by the party complained against within fourteen days of receipt of the notice of claim.

(c) The clerk shall furnish every claimant, upon commencement of the action, and every party complained against, with the notice of claim, and with information written in clear and coherent language which shall be prescribed and furnished by the state office of court administration, concerning the commercial claims part. Such information shall include, but not be limited to, the form for certification and filing by the claimant that no more than five such actions or proceedings have been instituted during that calendar month, and an explanation of the following terms and procedures: adjournments, counterclaims, jury trial requests, evening hour requests, demand letters in cases concerning consumer transactions, default judgments, subpoenas, arbitration and collection methods, the responsibility of the judgment creditor to collect data on the judgment debtor's assets, the ability of the court prior to entering judgment to order examination of or disclosure by, the defendant and restrain him, and fees. The information shall be available in English and, if the chief administrator determines it is appropriate or necessary, in Spanish. Large signs in English and, if the chief administrator requires it, in Spanish shall be posted in conspicuous locations in each commercial claims part clerk's office, advising the public of its availability.

(d) A defendant who wishes to file a counterclaim shall do so by filing with the clerk a statement containing such counterclaim within five days of receiving the notice of claim. At the time of such filing the defendant shall pay to the clerk a filing fee of five dollars plus the cost of mailings which are required pursuant to this subdivision. The clerk shall forthwith send notice of the counterclaim by ordinary first-class mail to the claimant. If the defendant fails to file the counterclaim in accordance with the provisions of this subdivision, the defendant retains the right to file the counterclaim, however the claimant may, but shall not be required to, request and obtain adjournment of the hearing to a later date. The claimant may reply to the counterclaim but shall not be required to do so. § 1823. Informal and simplified procedure on commercial claims.

The court shall conduct hearings upon commercial claims in such manner as to do substantial justice between the parties according to the rules of substantive law and shall not be bound by statutory provisions or rules of practice, procedure, pleading or evidence, except statutory provisions relating to privileged communications and personal transactions or communications with a decedent or person with a mental illness. An itemized bill or invoice, receipted or marked paid, or two itemized estimates for services or repairs, are admissible in evidence and are prima facie evidence of the reasonable value and necessity of such services and repairs. Disclosure shall be unavailable in commercial claims procedure except upon order of the court on showing of proper circumstances. The provisions of this act and the rules of this court, together with the statutes and rules governing supreme court practice, shall apply to claims brought under this article so far as the same can be made applicable and are not in conflict with the provisions of this article; in case of conflict, the provisions of this article shall control. § 1824. Remedies available; transfer of commercial claims.

(a) Upon determination of a commercial claim, the court shall direct judgment in accordance with its findings, and, when necessary to do substantial justice between the parties, may condition the entry of judgment upon such terms as the court shall deem proper. Pursuant to section fifty-two hundred twenty-nine of the civil practice law and rules prior to entering a judgment, the court may order the examination of or disclosure by, the defendant and restrain him to the same extent as if a restraining notice had been served upon him after judgment was entered.

(b) The court shall have power to transfer any commercial claim or claims to any other part of the court upon such terms as the rules may provide, and to proceed to hear the same according to the usual practice and procedure applicable to other parts of the court.

(c) No counterclaim shall be permitted in a commercial claims action, unless the court would have had monetary jurisdiction over the counterclaim if it had been filed as a commercial claim. Any other claim sought to be maintained against the claimant may be filed in any court of competent jurisdiction.

(d) If the defendant appears to be engaged in repeated fraudulent or illegal acts or otherwise demonstrates persistent fraud or illegality in the carrying on, conducting or transaction of business, the court shall either advise the attorney general in relation to his authority under subdivision twelve of section sixty-three of the executive law, or shall advise the claimant to do the same, but shall retain jurisdiction over the commercial claim.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the uniform justice court act, in relation to authoriz- ing the exercise of jurisdiction over commercial claims in justice courts

Purpose

Authorizes the exercise of jurisdiction over commercial claims in justice court

Summary of provisions

Section 1: Amends the uniform justice court act by adding a new article 18-A

Section 2: Provides the effective date

Justification

The Uniform Justice Court Act (UJCA) and the Uniform City Court Act (UCCA) establish Rules and Procedures for town and village court justices and city court judges. Both the UJCA and the UCCA contain provisions authorizing these local courts to preside over Small Claims cases (UJCA Part 214; UCCA Article 18). Small Claims courts allows indi- vidual litigants to resolve minor disputes in a timely manner through a straightforward, uncomplicated process. They provide an incredible service in our communities. While all local courts have jurisdiction over Small Claims cases, they do not have the same jurisdiction over Commercial Claims cases. The UJCA contains no provisions authorizing town and village justices to preside over Commercial Claims cases while the UCCA has provisions authorizing city court judges to preside over Commercial Claims cases (UCCA Article 18-A). This creates unequal access to the court system for commercial litigants throughout the state. If a City Court has jurisdiction, a Commercial Claims litigant can file in City Court. These commercial litigants have the ability to resolve minor disputes in a timely manner through an uncomplicated process - just like Small Claims court. However, in most counties and areas of this state, there are no city courts that would have jurisdiction. Many counties do not even have a city. Commercial litigants, in vast areas of our state, do not have the ability to resolve minor disputes. This disparate treatment of litigants results in unequal access to the courts. This bill would authorize town and village justices to preside of over Commercial Claims cases in the same manner as Small Claims and provide litigants throughout the state with equal access to the courts.

Legislative history

New bill.

Fiscal implications

To be determined.

Effective date

This act shall take effect immediately.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.