Skip to content
S7428Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA3375

Raise Bottle Redemption Fees

Official title

“Relates to registration as a redemption center and the handling fee paid to any dealer or operator of a redemption center”

Sponsor Michelle HincheySD-41Affects Environment & Energy
Status
In Senate Committee
Environmental Conservation
Impact
6/10
Moderate
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Environmental Conservation

What's happening

This bill increases the beverage container handling fee to five cents, changes how unclaimed deposits are split, and establishes new registration and audit rules for bottle redemption centers in New York.

Why it matters

  1. Raises funding for redemption centers and stores. By increasing the handling fee from 3.5 to 5 cents per container, the bill provides more financial support to local redemption centers and retailers who manage bottle and can returns—potentially helping these businesses cover rising labor and processing costs and remain sustainable.

  2. Shifts state and private sector revenue balance. The share of unclaimed deposits remitted to the state drops from 80% to 47%, letting beverage companies keep a much larger portion (53%) of unclaimed deposits. This could encourage deposit initiators to improve redemption rates, but it may also reduce state revenue available for environmental initiatives or other programs funded by these deposits.

  3. Establishes stronger oversight and accountability. The new registration and annual renewal requirements for redemption centers, along with mandatory reporting of operational data, create a regulatory framework intended to prevent fraud and ensure only compliant centers receive handling fees. It also gives the Department of Environmental Conservation more tools to audit, monitor, and revoke registrations if rules are violated.

  4. Imposes tougher anti-fraud and penalty measures. The bill creates and escalates penalties for knowingly attempting to redeem containers without a New York deposit, including higher fines and potential loss of registration for repeat offenders. This aims to deter out-of-state or fraudulent container returns and protect the integrity of the deposit system.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Raise Bottle Redemption Fees

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Michelle Hinchey

Senator · Senate District 41

Chair, Agriculture

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Print number 7428a
  2. Amend (t) and recommit to environmental conservation
  3. Referred to environmental conservation
  4. Referred to environmental conservation

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A3375Assembly

Increase Redemption Center Fees

In Assembly Committee · Environmental Conservation · Sponsor Carrie Woerner

Impact 7 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

6 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

7428--A

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

May 24, 2023

Introduced by Sen. HINCHEY -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Environmental Conservation -- recommitted to the Committee on Environmental Conservation in accordance with Senate Rule 6, sec. 8 -- committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee

AN ACT to amend the environmental conservation law, in relation to registration as a redemption center and the handling fee paid to any dealer or operator of a redemption center

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subdivision 6 of section 27-1007 of the environmental conservation law, as added by section 4 of part SS of chapter 59 of the laws of 2009, is amended to read as follows:

6. In addition to the refund value of a beverage container as established by section 27-1005 of this title, a deposit initiator shall pay to any dealer or operator of a redemption center a handling fee of [three and one-half] five cents for each beverage container accepted by the deposit initiator from such dealer or operator of a redemption center. Payment of the handling fee shall be as compensation for collecting, sorting and packaging of empty beverage containers for transport back to the deposit initiator or its designee. Payment of the handling fee may not be conditioned on the purchase of any goods or services, nor may such payment be made out of the refund value account established pursuant to section 27-1012 of this title. A distributor who does not initiate deposits on a type of beverage container is considered a dealer only for the purpose of receiving a handling fee from a deposit initiator.

§ 2. Paragraphs a and c of subdivision 4 of section 27-1012 of the environmental conservation law, as added by section 8 of part SS of chapter 59 of the laws of 2009, are amended to read as follows:

a. Quarterly payments. An amount equal to [eighty] forty-seven percent of the balance outstanding in the refund value account at the close of each quarter shall be paid to the commissioner of taxation and finance

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD07158-07-4

at the time the report provided for in subdivision three of this section is required to be filed. The commissioner of taxation and finance may require that the payments be made electronically. The remaining [twenty] fifty-three percent of the balance outstanding at the close of each quarter shall be the monies of the deposit initiator and may be withdrawn from such account by the deposit initiator. If the provisions of this section with respect to such account have not been fully complied with, each deposit initiator shall pay to such commissioner at such time, in lieu of the amount described in the preceding sentence, an amount equal to the balance which would have been outstanding on such date had such provisions been fully complied with. The commissioner of taxation and finance may require that the payments be made electronically.

c. Final report. A deposit initiator who ceases to do business in this state as a deposit initiator shall file a final report and remit payment of [eighty] forty-seven percent of all amounts remaining in the refund value account as of the close of the deposit initiator's last day of business. The commissioner of taxation and finance may require that the payments be made electronically. The deposit initiator shall indicate on the report that it is a "final report". The final report is due to be filed with payment twenty days after the close of the quarterly period in which the deposit initiator ceases to do business. In the event the deposit initiator pays out more in refund values than it collects in such final quarterly period, the deposit initiator may apply to the commissioner of taxation and finance for a refund of the amount of such excess payment of refund values from sources other than the refund value account, in the manner as provided by the commissioner of taxation and finance.

§ 3. Section 27-1013 of the environmental conservation law, as amended by section 7 of part F of chapter 58 of the laws of 2013, is amended to read as follows: § 27-1013. Redemption centers.

1. (a) (i) As of the effective date of the chapter of the laws of two thousand twenty-four that amended this section and subject to applicable provisions of local and state law, any person, firm or corporation which establishes a redemption center, at which redeemers and dealers may return empty beverage containers and receive payment of the refund value of such beverage containers, shall submit an application to the commissioner for registration as a condition of operation.

(ii) Any redemption center in business on or before April first, two thousand twenty-four may continue to operate as if the department had issued such redemption center a registration required by regulations adopted under this section; provided, however, that such redemption center shall submit a renewal application to the commissioner in accordance with applicable regulations by the thirty-first of December next succeeding the effective date of this subparagraph.

(iii) An application for registration or renewal shall be in a form prescribed by the commissioner and shall, at a minimum, require the name and physical address of the redemption center, the name, address and contact information of the owner and/or operator of the redemption center, the names and addresses of each dealer or distributor with which the redemption center has contracted to collect, sort and obtain the refund value and handling fee of empty beverage containers, as applicable, the number of beverage containers redeemed by the redemption center during the preceding twelve months, as applicable, and such other information as the commissioner deems necessary for proper administration of this title. The commissioner may require applications for registration to be submitted electronically. The commissioner shall electronically issue a redemption center registration certificate or renewal certificate in a form prescribed by the commissioner within thirty days of receipt of such application. A registration certificate or renewal certificate issued pursuant to this subdivision shall be issued for one year and shall be subject to annual renewal in accordance with procedures specified by the commissioner.

(iv) Any registered redemption center that ceases operations shall notify the commissioner of such cessation in writing within thirty days in a form prescribed by the commissioner.

(b) The commissioner shall issue a registration or renewal within thirty days of the submission of an application by a person, firm or corporation which establishes a redemption center in accordance with the provisions of this section, subject to applicable provisions of local and state laws. An application for registration or renewal shall be deemed approved if the department fails to act on such application within thirty days of submission. Registrations and renewals shall be issued at no cost to the applicant. The costs attributable to the department for the review and processing of registration and renewal applications pursuant to this section shall be paid for out of the state's portion of the outstanding balance in the refund value account which is regularly deposited into the general fund in accordance with section 27-1012 of this title.

(c) After due notice and opportunity of hearing, pursuant to the provisions of section 71-1709 of this chapter, the department may deny an application for registration or renewal or revoke a registration. In determining whether or not to revoke a registration, the commissioner shall, at a minimum, take into consideration the compliance history of an applicant, good faith efforts of an applicant to comply, any economic benefit from noncompliance and whether any violation was procedural in nature. The commissioner's determination to revoke a registration is subject to review under article seventy-eight of the civil practice law and rules.

(d) Any person, firm or corporation required to be registered under this section which, without being registered, redeems beverage containers in this state, shall not be eligible to receive a handling fee for any such redeemed beverage containers, and if such person, firm or corporation has received such a handling fee, it shall be promptly refunded.

(e) The commissioner shall promulgate rules and regulations governing the performance of audits in connection with pick-ups of redeemed beverage containers. Such audits shall be conducted by the department at the request of a distributor, deposit initiator, redemption center or dealer, upon no less than two business days' notice, to monitor beverage container pick-ups and party compliance with the provisions of this chapter. A distributor, deposit initiator, redemption center or dealer may request the department to conduct an audit no more than ten times per calendar year with respect to each pick up agent or redemption center with which the requester conducts pick up transactions. Such audits shall, at a minimum, include the following parameters: (i) all audits shall be conducted on an entire pick-up shipment at one of two locations, including at the site of such redemption center or site at which such pick up shipment of redeemed beverage containers is delivered and counted; (ii) a department auditor shall be present at the redemption center at which such audit shall be performed to witness the weighing of all individual bags of beverage containers included in the pickup transaction; (iii) a department inspector shall be present at the delivery/counting site of such pick up shipment of redeemed beverage containers at the time of such audit to witness the counting of containers; and (iv) there shall be a secure chain of custody between the pickup location and point of delivery/counting that shall remain secured until audited in the presence of the department's auditor. Audit results shall be promptly reported to the distributor, deposit initiator, redemption center and/or dealer whose pick up transaction is the subject of such audit.

2. The commissioner is hereby empowered to promulgate rules and regulations governing (a) the circumstances in which deposit initiators, dealers and distributors, individually or collectively, are required to accept the return of empty beverage containers, including beverage containers processed through reverse vending machines and make payment therefor; (b) the sorting of the containers which a deposit initiator or distributor may require of dealers and redemption centers; (c) the collection of returned beverage containers by deposit initiators or distributors, including the party to whom such expense is to be charged, the frequency of such pick ups and the payment for refunds and handling fees thereon; (d) the right of dealers to restrict or limit the number of containers redeemed, the rules for redemption at the dealers' place of business, and the redemption of containers from a beverage for which sales have been discontinued; (e) [to issue] registrations and renewals issued to persons, firms or corporations which establish redemption centers, subject to applicable provisions of local and state laws, at which redeemers and dealers may return empty beverage containers and receive payment of the refund value of such beverage containers[. Such registrations shall be issued at no cost. Should the department require by regulations adopted pursuant to this paragraph that redemption centers must obtain a registration as a condition of operation, any redemption center in business as of March first, two thousand thirteen that previously provided the department with the notification information required by regulations in effect as of such date may continue to operate as if the department had issued such redemption center a registration required by regulations adopted under this paragraph; provided, however, that such redemption center shall provide the department with any other information required by regulations adopted pursuant to this paragraph. The department may, after due notice and opportunity of hearing, pursuant to the provisions of section 71-1709 of this chapter, deny an application or revoke a registration. In determining whether or not to revoke a registration the commissioner shall at a minimum, take into consideration the compliance history of a violator, good faith efforts of a violator to comply, any economic benefit from noncompliance and whether the violation was procedural in nature. The commissioner's determination to revoke a registration is subject to review under article seventy-eight of the civil practice law and rules]; and (f) the operation of mobile redemption centers in order to ensure that to the best extent practicable containers are not proffered for redemption to a deposit initiator or distributor outside of the geographic area where such deposit initiator sells containers and initiates deposits.

[2.] 3. The department may require a redemption center to obtain a permit, as an alternative to registration if such center is located at the same facility or site as another solid waste management facility otherwise subject to the requirements of title seven of this article or the regulations promulgated pursuant thereto.

[3.] 4. No dealer or distributor, as defined in section 27-1003 of this title, shall be required to obtain a permit to operate a redemption center at the same location as the dealer's or distributor's place of business. Operators of such redemption centers shall receive payment of the refund value of each beverage container from the appropriate deposit initiator or distributor as provided under section 27-1007 of this title.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the environmental conservation law, in relation to registration as a redemption center and the handling fee paid to any dealer or operator of a redemption center

Purpose

This bill would increase the handling fee paid to any dealer or operator of a redemption center from three and half cents to five cents and permit deposit initiators to retain fifty-three percent of the balance outstanding accumulated in the refund value account due to unredeemed bottle deposits.

Summary of provisions

Section 1: Amends subdivision six of section 27-1007 of the environ- mental conservation law to direct deposit initiators to pay a five cent handling fee for each beverage container accepted by the deposit initi- ator from a dealer or operator of a redemption center.

Read the full memo (1,228 words)

§ 2: Amends subparagraphs a and c of subdivision four of section 27-1012 of the environmental conservation law to permit deposit initiators to retain fifty-three percent of the balance outstanding in the refund value account at the close of each quarter.

§ 3: Adds a new subdivision one to section 27-1013 of the environmental conservation law and renumbers the remaining subdivisions accordingly. Paragraph (a) of subdivision one requires redemption centers to register annually with the state as a condition of operation, provided that redemption centers in business before April 1, 2024, need not submit a renewal application prior to the December 31st next succeeding the effective date of the legislation. Applications shall be submitted in a form prescribed by the commissioner which shall, at a minimum, require certain specified information. Pursuant to paragraph (b), applications for registration and renewal shall be deemed approved if the department fails to act on such within thirty days of submission. Paragraph (c) authorizes the commissioner to deny an application for registration or renewal after due notice and opportunity of hearing and such a revoca- tion is subject to review under article 78 of the Civil Practice Law and Rules. Paragraph (d) prohibits receipt of a handling fee by any person, firm or corporation which is not registered with the commissioner, and if one has been received, it shall be promptly refunded. Paragraph (e) requires the commissioner to promulgate rules and regulations governing audits in connection with pick ups of redeemed beverage containers. Such rules shall contain minimum specified parameters. The department shall conduct such audits upon the request of a distributor, deposit initi- ator, redemption center or dealer, provided such requests shall be limited to no more than ten per calendar year with respect to each pick up agent or redemption center with which the requester conducts pick up transactions. Requests for audits must be made upon no less than two business days' notice to the department.

§ 4: Adds technical amendments to subdivision 2 of section 27-1015 of the environmental conservation law and amends subdivision 3 to also apply to redemption centers and dealers by prohibiting distributors, deposit initiators, redemption centers and dealers from knowingly returning a beverage container for its refund value more than once. Following a hearing or opportunity to be heard, a subsequent violation shall result in a civil penalty of not less than $1,000 nor more than $5,000, an amount equal to two times the amount of money received as a result of the violation, and a revocation of the subject redemption center's registration or a withholding of an equivalent amount from the subject distributor's, deposit initiator's or dealer's refund value account. Subdivision four is amended to add a civil penalty for a subse- quent violation of up to $50,000 following a hearing or opportunity to be heard. New subdivision 4-a adds new civil penalties, following a hearing or opportunity to be heard, of up to $25,000 (up to $50,000 for a subsequent violation, plus revocation of the redemption center's registration) for willful tender to a deposit initiator by a redemption center of more than forty-eight empty beverage containers for which the redemption center knows or should reasonably know that no deposit was paid in New York state. New subdivision 4-b addresses shortfalls discov- ered through audit of pick up transactions. Pursuant to subdivision (a), if there is a discrepancy of ten percent or more, then the deposit initiator which requested the audit may withhold up to fifty percent (up to one hundred percent for a subsequent violation) of the handling fee otherwise due to a redemption center. Subdivision (b) authorizes a redemption center which discovers a shortfall of ten percent or more through audit of pick up transactions to receive one hundred fifty percent (up to two hundred percent for a subsequent violation) of the handling fee otherwise due to the redemption center.

§ 5: Establishes the effective date as the thirtieth day after it shall have become a law.

Justification

The New York State Returnable Container Act (the "Bottle Bill") became law in 1982 and has been keeping billions of bottles out of landfills and off roadsides ever since. In the beginning, the law assigned a 51 bottle deposit on consumers, assessed a 1T handling fee to beverage companies, and permitted beverage companies to retain 100% of unredeemed bottle deposit revenues. The handling fee was - and continues to be - the sole source of revenue for the small business redemption centers needed to collect and sort empty bottles in communities throughout the state. When the original handling fee amount proved insufficient to support the redemption centers, the legislature increased the fee to and 2T in 1983 and 1998, respectively. Over the course of 27 years, beverage companies retained more than $2 billion in unredeemed bottle deposit revenues. Then, in 2009, the "Bigger, Better Bottle Bill" raised the handling fee to 31-.1 and adjusted the allocation of unredeemed bottle deposit revenues to 20% to the beverage companies and 80% to the State General Fund.

Now, twelve years later, while the sole revenue source (the handling fee) has remained static, operational costs for small business redemp- tion centers have continued to rise, including increased wage expenses, associated payroll taxes, insurance premiums, and rents. During 2023 alone, nearly fifty redemption centers closed.

Redemption centers cannot be allowed to fail. There are hundreds of small business redemption centers across the state, each of which handles approximately 3.5 million empty bottles annually, for a state- wide total of more than 3.1 billion bottles per year. In communities lacking a grocery store or other large-scale redemption site, their convenience and efficiency are indispensable; collectively, small busi- ness redemption centers have helped New York consistently sustain a statewide bottle return rate of over 60%. Beyond their contributions to recycling and local employment, small business redemption centers also play a vital role in the lives of community members, supporting communi- ty fundraising activities through bottle drives conducted by PTAs, Boy and Girl Scout troops, travel sports teams, and others. This bill does not raise consumer costs.

Legislative history

2022 - A.8517/S.8242 - referred to environmental conservation

Fiscal implications

The re-allocation of unredeemed bottle deposit revenues between the State General Fund and the beverage companies offsets the costs of increasing the handling fee. Based on information received from the Department of Taxation & Finance, we anticipate New York's loss of unre- deemed bottle deposits to be approximately $50 million per year.

Effective date

This act shall take effect on the thirtieth day after it shall have become a law.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.