Skip to content
S7742Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA8266

Limit Overdraft Bank Fees

Official title

“Relates to overdraft fees charged by banking organizations”

Sponsor Luis R. SepúlvedaSD-32Affects Finance
Status
In Senate Committee
Banks
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Banks

What's happening

This bill requires banks to report overdraft and non-sufficient funds fee revenue and imposes new restrictions and delays on charging such fees.

Why it matters

  1. Increases transparency by requiring banks to publicly report how much revenue they earn from overdraft and non-sufficient funds (NSF) fees, and the proportion of this revenue compared to their net income. This will give consumers, regulators, and advocates a clearer picture of how reliant each bank is on these fees, potentially spotlighting predatory practices.

  2. Gives account holders a 10-day grace period after an overdraft or NSF transaction before any fees can be charged. This change could help consumers avoid costly penalties by allowing them time to deposit funds and rectify account shortfalls, reducing the likelihood of cascading financial hardship from a single mistake or timing issue.

  3. Bans certain fee practices that have been criticized as unfair or exploitative, such as charging overdraft fees when an account was positive at the time of a debit card transaction, and charging multiple NSF fees if the same transaction is re-presented for payment. This addresses so-called “gotcha” or “junk” fee practices that can disproportionately affect lower-income and financially vulnerable consumers.

  4. Limits fees for overdraft protection transfers so that only one fee can be charged per overdraft event, even if a transfer fails to fully cover the overdraft. This provision prevents banks from double-dipping by charging both an overdraft and a transfer fee for the same incident, which can quickly escalate the financial burden on account holders.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Limit Overdraft Bank Fees

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Luis R. Sepúlveda

Senator · Senate District 32

Chair, Cities 1

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to banks
  2. Referred to rules

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A8266Assembly

Limit Bank Overdraft Fees

In Assembly Committee · Banks · Sponsor John Zaccaro Jr.

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

7742

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

November 13, 2023

Introduced by Sen. SEPULVEDA -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Rules

AN ACT to amend the banking law, in relation to overdraft fees charged by banking organizations

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. The banking law is amended by adding a new section 37-b to read as follows:

§ 37-b. Report on overdraft fees. 1. Every banking organization subject to the examination authority of the superintendent shall report annually, on or before March first, to the superintendent on the amount of revenue earned from overdraft fees and non-sufficient funds fees collected in the most recently completed calendar year and the percentage of that revenue as a proportion of the net income of the banking organization. The superintendent shall publish a report containing such data for each organization on the department's internet website.

2. The superintendent shall publish the first report required by this section on or before August thirty-first, two thousand twenty-four, covering data from the two thousand twenty-three calendar year, and annually thereafter by March thirty-first of each year.

3. As used in this section:

(a) "Non-sufficient funds fees" means fees resulting from the initiation of a transaction that exceeds the customer's account balance if the customer's banking organization declines to make the payment.

(b) "Overdraft fees" means fees resulting from the processing of a debit transaction that exceeds a customer's account balance.

§ 2. The banking law is amended by adding a new section 135 to read as follows:

§ 135. Overdraft fees. 1. No banking organization shall impose an overdraft fee or non-sufficient funds fee prior to a period of ten days from the date of the subject transaction during which time period the

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD13438-02-3

member may deposit funds in an amount sufficient to cover the transaction.

2. For the purposes of this section:

(a) "Non-sufficient funds fees" means fees resulting from the initiation of a transaction that exceeds the customer's account balance if the customer's bank or trust company declines to make the payment.

(b) "Overdraft fees" means fees resulting from the processing of a debit transaction that exceeds a customer's account balance.

§ 3. Section 456 of the banking law is amended by adding a new subdivision 10 to read as follows:

10. (a) Impose an overdraft fee or non-sufficient funds fee prior to a period of ten days from the date of the subject transaction during which time period the member may deposit funds in an amount sufficient to cover the transaction.

(b) For the purposes of this subdivision:

(i) "Non-sufficient funds fees" means fees resulting from the initiation of a transaction that exceeds the customer's account balance if the customer's bank or credit union declines to make the payment.

(ii) "Overdraft fees" means fees resulting from the processing of a debit transaction that exceeds a customer's account balance.

§ 4. The banking law is amended by adding a new section 6-q to read as follows:

§ 6-q. Improper practices relating to the imposition of certain fees. 1. No banking organization shall charge overdraft fees on debit card transactions that do not exceed the account's positive balance in cases where a subsequent, unrelated transaction lowers the consumer's available balance to below the amount of the original charge when the original transaction is presented for settlement.

2. A fee for an overdraft protection transfer, where such service is available and enrolled in by the consumer, may only be charged when the transfer amount is sufficient to cover an overdraft transaction. If the amount transferred from another account of the consumer is not sufficient to prevent an overdraft, then the banking organization may only charge a single fee for the overdraft transaction and may not charge a second fee for a transfer of funds which is insufficient to prevent the overdraft.

3. Institutions shall not charge more than one non-sufficient funds fee per transaction, regardless of how many times that transaction is re-presented for payment by a merchant. Banking organizations shall update associated software, or require the software update of their third-party service providers, in order to prevent multiple fees from being charged for a single transaction in violation of this subdivision.

§ 5. This act shall take effect on the sixtieth day after it shall have become a law.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the banking law, in relation to overdraft fees charged by banking organizations

Purpose

Requires the annual reporting of overdraft fees and non-sufficient funds fees by banking organizations and credit unions subject to the authority of the Superintendent of the Department of Financial Services who shall issue an annual report on such information. Imposes additional require- ments regarding the imposition of overdraft fees and non-sufficient funds fees.

Summary of provisions

Section one: Adds a new section 37-b to the banking law requiring an annual report on overdraft fees and non-sufficient funds fees.

Read the full memo (1,826 words)

Section two: Adds a new section 135 to the banking law requiring a ten- day grace period before an overdraft fee or a non-sufficient funds fee can be imposed.

Section three: Adds a new subdivision 10 to section 456 of the banking law requiring a ten-day grace period before an overdraft fee or a non- sufficient funds fee can be imposed. Also defines non-sufficient funds fee and overdraft fees for purposes of the subdivision.

Section four: Adds a new section 6-q to the banking law regarding improper practices relating to the imposition of certain fees

Section five: Provides for the effective date.

Justification

On July 12, 2022 the NYS Department of Financial Service's issued a guidance letter to all regulated depository institutions regarding deceptive and unfair practices with regard to the imposition of over- draft fees and nonsufficient funds (NSF) fees. This legislation seeks to codify the recommendations set forth by the department in that letter.

The department's guidance letter which follows sets forth the complete justification for this legislation.

July 12, 2022

Industry Letter: Avoiding Improper Practices Related to Overdraft and Non-Sufficient Funds Fees TO: All Regulated Depository Institutions

The New York State Department of Financial Services (the "Department"), as part of its mission, continues to focus on making affordable banking products and services available to underserved communities, including low- and moderate-income individuals, immigrants, and people of color. It is well documented that high and unpredictable bank account fees are among the reasons that many households remain unbanked. 1 It is there- fore imperative that regulated depository institutions ("Institutions") be transparent in the fees associated with deposit accounts and elimi- nate onerous fees, in order to attract and retain consumers from these underserved communities in the banking system.

Earlier this year, the Department issued Guidance encouraging Insti- tutions to offer Bank On accounts, which, among other things, eliminate overdraft and non-sufficient funds ("NSF") fees.121 The Department, through the supervisory process, has identified several unfair or decep- tive acts or practices regarding the imposition of overdraft fees and NSF fees. The purpose of this Guidance is to alert Institutions that the Department will evaluate whether Institutions are engaged in deceptive or unfair practices with respect to overdraft and NSF fees in future Consumer Compliance and Fair Lending examinations.

I. Overdraft Fees Relating to Authorize Positive, Settle Negative ("APSN") Transactions

The Department has found that some Institutions charge an overdraft fee on debit card transactions that do not exceed the account's positive balance in cases where a subsequent, unrelated transaction lowers the consumer's available balance to below the amount of the original charge when the original transaction is presented for settlement. Stated differently, some Institutions are charging consumers an overdraft fee even though they had a sufficient positive balance at the time that the transaction was authorized by the Institution. The imposition of over- draft fees in such situations (referred to as "Authorize Positive, Settle Negative" or "APSN" transactions) is unfair, because it causes injury to consumers that consumers cannot reasonably avoid. Consumers have no control over or involvement in the settlement and presentment of debit card transactions, which typically takes place some days after the consumer conducts the transaction. When an Institution authorizes a debit card transaction on an account with sufficient funds to cover the transaction, the consumer reasonably expects that they will not incur an overdraft charge on that transaction. Furthermore, there is no benefit to consumers or competition from an Institution's overdraft charges on APSN transactions. Given previous federal regulatory scrutiny of this topic,111 the Department understands that some Institutions may have already taken steps to avoid this practice. To the extent that Insti- tutions are currently charging overdraft fees related to APSN trans- actions, the Department expects those Institutions to discontinue the practice.

II. Double Fees Arising from Futile Overdraft Protection Transfers

Institutions frequently offer consumers an overdraft protection service for a fee. This service automatically transfers funds from another account held by the consumer at the same institution, such as a savings account, to cover what would have otherwise been an overdraft trans- action, thereby preventing the imposition of an overdraft fee. The Department has found that some Institutions charge a fee for overdraft protection transfers even where the transfer amount is insufficient to prevent the actual overdraft. In those cases, the transfer fails to prevent the occurrence of an overdraft and the imposition of an accompa- nying overdraft fee.

The practice of charging a consumer both an overdraft protection fee and a fee for the overdraft that the "protection" failed to prevent (a "Double Fee") constitutes an unfair practice. A Double Fee injures consumers by imposing fees for a transfer that provides no value to the consumer and is not reasonably avoidable by consumers, who have no reason to expect that they will be charged a fee for an overdraft protection transfer that does not in fact protect them against an over- draft. The imposition of Double Fees offers no benefit to either consum- ers or competition.

In addition, utilizing any disclosure that states that an overdraft protection transfer (including any associated fee) serves to prevent an overdraft, where it does not necessarily do so, is deceptive to consum- ers. A consumer's interpretation that a fee for an overdraft protection transfer will only be charged when the transfer actually protects against the overdraft is reasonable, and any misrepresentation is mate- rial to a consumer's choice about whether to enroll in an overdraft protection transfer service.

The Department expects that Institutions will not charge Double Fees. Institutions may, however, continue to charge an overdraft protection fee or an overdraft fee, consistent with consumer disclosures.

III. NSF Fees Relating to Representments

Institutions frequently charge an NSF fee in cases where a transaction, including an Automated Clearing House ("ACH") transaction, is presented for payment but is declined because the consumer has insufficient funds in their account to cover the transaction. Where an Institution returns a merchant's attempted debit entry because the consumer's account had insufficient funds to cover the debit, ACH rules authorize the merchant to "reinitiate" or "re-present" the entry a maximum of two times in an attempt to collect funds.1 The Department has found that some Insti- tutions charge a separate NSF fee for each presentment, or represent- ment, of the same item, resulting in multiple NSF fees for a single transaction ("Multiple NSF Fees"). The practice of charging a consumer Multiple NSF Fees is deceptive where the Institution's disclosures fail to disclose expressly that multiple fees may be charged "per item" or "per transaction." Further, it is deceptive when the Institution represents that only one NSF fee will be charged "per item" or "per transaction" without disclosing that the same processed item may trigger Multiple NSF Fees. Accordingly, the Department expects that Institutions currently charging Multiple NSF Fees make clear, conspicuous, and regu- lar disclosure to consumers that they may be charged more than one NSF fee for the same attempted debit transaction when that debit is repres- ented after being declined for insufficient funds. The Department considers "clear, conspicuous and regular disclosure" to mean that Institutions will include this disclosure in their regular communi- cations with consumers (e.g., in each account statement, rather than in account-opening materials only) together with a direct point of contact for consumers who may have been subject to Multiple NSF Fees.

The practice of charging Multiple NSF fees is also potentially unfair. Consumers have no control over, or involvement in, the representment of debit transactions and no way to avoid representments once a consumer has attempted a transaction. The Department expects Institutions to take immediate action to mitigate the risk that consumers are charged Multi- ple NSF Fees. Steps that Institutions could take to address this issue include limiting NSF fees that can be imposed during a certain time period (e.g., a week), performing periodic manual reviews to identify instances of Multiple NSF Fees, and offering refunds to consumers when Institutions become aware of individual consumers who have been charged Multiple NSF Fees.

The Department recognizes that the unilateral elimination of Multiple NSF Fees may be technically impracticable for some Institutions in the short term, including in cases where their own software or the software of their third-party service providers needs to be updated to allow for automated identification of representments. Nonetheless, Institutions are expected to update their internal systems and software and to work with their third-party service provider(s), as appropriate, to resolve this issue. The Department ultimately expects

Institutions will not charge more than one NSF fee per transaction, regardless of how many times that transaction is presented for payment. Institutions should expect a review of all of the practices identified in this Industry Letter to be included in Consumer Compliance and Fair Lending examinations conducted by the Department.

With respect to the imposition of Multiple NSF fees, these examinations will closely review what steps the Institution has taken to address the risk of Multiple NSF fees in the short term, including what measures they have been able to take unilaterally and which require cooperation from third-party service providers to eliminate this type of fee entire- ly.

The Department is currently undertaking a broader review of practices related to the imposition of overdraft and NSF fees and may in the future issue additional guidance related to these practices.

1 Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked Households, Executive Summary (2017), at 4, available at https.//www.fdic.gov/analysis/household-survev/2017/2017execsumm.pdf.

2 New York State Department of Financial Services, Industry Letter titled "Offering Bank On Accounts as an Alternative to New York Basic Banking Accounts" (Apr. 15, 2022), available at https://www.dfs.ny.goviindustry_guidance/industry_letters/i120220415 offering_bank_on

3 See Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Consumer Compliance Supervisory Highlights (June 2019), available at https://www.fdic.gov/regutlations/examinations/consumer- compliance-su- pervisory/ -highlights/documents/ccs-highlights-june2019.pdf; Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Supervisory Highlights (Winter 2015), available at https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f201503_cfpb_supervisory- highlights-winter-2015.pdf.

4 National Automated Clearing House Association, ACH Operations Bulle- tin 1- 2014: Questionable ACH Debit Origination: Roles and Responsibil- ities of ODFIs and RDFIs (Sept. 30, 2014), available at https://www.nacha.org/news/ach-operations-bulletin-1-2014- questionable- ach-debit-origination-roles-and-responsibilities). The ACH rules require that representments include the description "RETRY PYMT," which allows consumers and Institutions to identify representments. ACH Network Risk and Enforcement Topics (Sept. 18, 2015), available at https://www.nacha.org/rules/ach-network-risk-and-enforcement-topics.

Legislative history

New Bill

Fiscal implications

None to New York State

Local fiscal implications

None

Effective date

Sixty days after it shall have become a law.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.