Skip to content
S7772Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA8364

Protect Prisoners’ Basic Rights

Official title

“Protects the rights of people in prisons, jails and forensic facilities”

Status
In Senate Committee
Crime Victims, Crime And Correction
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Crime Victims, Crime And Correction

What's happening

This bill expands and clarifies the rights of incarcerated people in New York, including visitation, communication, protection from abuse, and humane conditions.

Why it matters

  1. Codifies International Human Rights Standards. The bill explicitly incorporates principles from international human rights law (e.g., the Mandela Rules), aiming to raise New York’s incarceration standards to those recognized globally. This matters because it sets a legal expectation for humane treatment and dignity, not just minimum constitutional requirements.

  2. Strengthens Oversight and Legal Recourse. By creating a direct right for incarcerated people to bring state court actions for violations of their rights under this law—including injunctions, damages, and other relief—this bill provides a more accessible and enforceable mechanism for challenging abuses and neglect inside correctional facilities.

  3. Addresses Systemic Barriers to Family and Community Ties. By guaranteeing daily contact visitation, unfettered package deliveries, and free, regular access to internet-connected tablets for calls and emails, the legislation aims to reduce social isolation, which research shows is linked to better post-release outcomes and reduced recidivism.

  4. Narrows Discretion for Use of Force and Solitary Confinement. The bill sets strict, detailed limits on when force can be used and when restraints or solitary-like conditions are permitted, requiring individualized, documented justification and regular review. This is significant in addressing well-documented problems of abuse, retaliation, and the mental health harms of isolation in New York prisons and jails.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Protect Prisoners’ Basic Rights

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Julia Salazar

Senator · Senate District 18

Chair, Crime Victims, Crime And Correction

History

  1. Referred to crime victims, crime and correction
  2. Referred to rules

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A8364Assembly

Protect Prisoners' Human Rights

In Assembly Committee · Correction · Sponsor Phara Souffrant Forrest

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

13 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

7772

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

November 27, 2023

Introduced by Sens. SALAZAR, BRISPORT, CLEARE, GONZALEZ, JACKSON, RAMOS, SEPULVEDA -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Rules

AN ACT to amend the correction law, in relation to the rights of people in prisons, jails, and forensic facilities

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Short title. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "rights behind bars; protecting the rights of people in prisons, jails, and forensic facilities, and their loved ones, in New York state act".

§ 2. Legislative findings and intent. The legislature hereby finds and declares:

A. Incarcerated individuals, their families, and loved ones have human rights. The legislature finds that New York's prisons and jails systematically fail to recognize and protect the human rights of incarcerated individuals, their families, and their loved ones. While some of these rights are protected by the law and constitution of New York State, and the law and constitution of the United States, it is well-documented that the rights protected under existing law are often not recognized in practice and that there are gaps in existing law. The intent of this act is to: (i) make clear some of the rights that already exist under New York law but are not being consistently followed, (ii) close some of the gaps in existing law, and (iii) enshrine into New York State law some of the well-established principles and obligations under international human rights law.

B. Numerous recent studies, reports, and court decisions have documented systemic, widespread, and persistent human rights violations in New York's correctional facilities. These include: NYS Inspector General Lucy Lang, Racial Disparities in the Administration of Discipline in New York State Prisons, November 2022; Neff, Santo, and Meagher, How A 'Blue

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD13213-04-3

Wall' Inside New York State Prisons Protects Abusive Guards, The Marshall Project in partnership with the New York Times, May 2023; Neff, Santo, and Meagher, In New York Prisons Guards Who Brutalize Prisoners Rarely Get Fired, The Marshall Project in partnership with the New York Times, May 2023; Law, V., The Worst Prison in New York State, Prison Legal News, March 2022; Gelardi and Brown, State Prisons Are Routinely Violating New York's Landmark Solitary Confinement Law, New York Focus, September 2022; Bryant, 19 People Have Died From NYC Jails in 2022, The Vera Project, December 2022; Weill-Greenberg, Disabled and Abandoned in New York State Prisons, The Nation, October 2021; Marcius, Hundreds of Women Set to Sue New York Over Allegations of Prison Sex Abuse, New York Times, November 2022; Monitor's Reports in Nunez, et al. v. NYC Department of Correction, et al., 11-cv-05845 (LTS) (SDNY) (multiple reports issued by Court-appointed Monitor as part of the settlement of a class action lawsuit relating to conditions in NYC jails on Rikers Island, starting in 2016 and continuing to the present); and Post-Visit Briefing Reports issued periodically by the Correctional Association of New York ("CANY") pursuant to their statutory authority to conduct monitoring visits in NYS prisons (Nine Post-Visit Briefings were issued by CANY from June 2021 through December 2022. Among the findings during this period were that 45% of incarcerated individuals interviewed reported witnessing or experiencing verbal, physical, or sexual abuse by prison staff, and 36% reported witnessing or experiencing racialized abuse by prison staff.).

C. Some of the human rights of incarcerated individuals in New York State are protected by provisions in the New York State Constitution, including, Article I, sections 5 (prohibiting cruel and unusual punishment), 6 (right to due process), 8 (right to speak freely), 11 (guaranteeing equal protection of the laws), and 12 (prohibiting unreasonable searches and seizures); the United States Constitution, including the 1st Amendment (free speech), 4th Amendment (prohibition of unreasonable searches and seizures), 8th Amendment (prohibition of cruel and unusual punishments), and 14th Amendment (guaranteeing equal protection of the law and due process of law). However, these provisions and laws do not go far enough to protect the rights of people incarcerated in New York. The intent of this act, in part, is to incorporate into New York law additional human rights protections for incarcerated people as enshrined in key documents included in the body of international human rights law, including, the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights, recognizing basic human rights applicable to all people, including, in Article 5, the right not to be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or punishment; the International Covenant of Civil and Political Rights, including Article 7 (No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment), and Article 10 (All persons deprived of their liberty shall be treated with humanity and with respect for the inherent dignity of the human person); the Basic Principles for the Treatment of Prisoners (General Assembly Resolution 45/111); the Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman, or Degrading Treatment or Punishment; the United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules); and other applicable and binding principles of international human rights law.

D. The fundamental approach of international human rights law to the treatment of people in prison is expressed in Rule 3 of the Mandela Rules, which recognizes that "imprisonment and other measures that result in cutting off persons from the outside world are afflictive by the very fact of taking from these persons the right of self-determination by depriving them of their liberty. Therefore the prison system shall not, except as incidental to justifiable separation or the maintenance of discipline, aggravate the suffering inherent in such a situation." In turn, Rule 4 requires that incarceration must be used to "ensure the reintegration of such persons into society upon release so that they can lead a law-abiding and self-supporting life" and Rule 5 thus requires prisons and jails to "minimize any differences between prison life and life at liberty that tend to lessen the responsibility of the {incarcerated people} or the respect due to their dignity as human beings."

To effectuate these rights, the Mandela Rules require, among other protections, that incarcerated people be allowed regular communication with their family and friends, including through visits and through writing, telecommunication, electronic means, and digital means (Rule 58.1), that people in prison have a right to "food of nutritional value adequate for health and strength, of wholesome quality and well prepared and served", and that any use of force against an incarcerated individual be "no more than is strictly necessary" (Rule 82). They also establish basic rights related to access to programming and treatment, connections to community entities, and restrictions on the use of restraints.

E. In keeping with these legislative findings, this act aims to clearly recognize and establish the broad human rights framework that protects all incarcerated individuals in New York State. This act specifically addresses certain issues that have arisen in New York prisons and jails in recent years. That has included: violations of the HALT Solitary Confinement Law; restrictions on packages, visits, and mail; staff abuse and brutality; and denials of other basic rights.

In regard to some of these issues, the law is already clear, but New York's prisons and jails are not consistently following it. For example, despite clarity concerning who qualifies as disabled under the HALT Solitary Confinement Law, and who, therefore, cannot be placed in segregated confinement, the NYS Department of Corrections and Community Supervision has consistently placed people with disabilities in segregated confinement. The intent of the amendments to paragraph (c) of subdivision 33 of section 2 of the correction law made by section five of this act is not to define disability, which is already in the law, but rather to make clear via examples what is already required. Similarly, while the correction law is already clear that people facing possible placement in segregated confinement or facing Tier III tickets must have access to meaningful representation, including by any lawyer or law student; that hearing officers must conduct individualized assessments of the fact to determine if the allegations meet the threshold requirements for placement in segregated confinement or alternatives; and that people in alternative disciplinary units must have access to out-of-cell time in group settings, access to core programs available in the general population; and a presumption against the use of restraints unless an individualized determination is made finding a significant and unreasonable risk, prisons and jails are not complying with these provisions and so this act reiterates and clarifies these requirements.

This act is not intended as an all-inclusive compendium of the human rights protections afforded to people in jail or prison under international law, as the intent is to correct and clarify certain specific rights within the overall human rights framework. Among other protections, this act aims to ensure that people have a right to visit with their loved ones, to have regular communication with their loved ones, to receive care packages from their loved ones, to have access to healthy and nutritious food, to be free from staff brutality and retaliation, to be free from the torture of prolonged solitary confinement, and to have access to real and meaningful out-of-cell group programming and engagement. Recognition of these basic human rights will alleviate suffering of incarcerated individuals, strengthen ties with families and communities, better prepare people for release, increase safety in prisons and jails and in outside communities, and unequivocally establish as the policy of the State of New York that brutality, racism, sexual abuse, harassment, and denials of access to family and loved ones have no place in New York's jails and prisons and will not be tolerated.

§ 3. Section 2 of the correction law is amended by adding eleven new subdivisions 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44 and 45 to read as follows:

35. "Contact visit" means a visit between an incarcerated individual and one or more visitors in a visiting room or equivalent space in which the incarcerated individual and their visitor are in the same unobstructed space as each other without physical barriers between the incarcerated individual and their visitor or visitors, that is conducive to meaningful social interaction and activity, and with the ability to interact freely with their visitor, including but not limited to the ability to communicate freely, hold hands, hug, kiss, have other appropriate physical contact, purchase and share food and drinks from the vending machine, and take photographs together.

36. "Visitor" means any individual who comes to visit a person incarcerated in a correctional facility or secure facility, including, but not limited to, a family member, friend, advocate, or loved one.

37. "Cell" means any room, area or space that is used or is intended to be used by an incarcerated individual for sleep, or that is not a shared space conducive to meaningful congregate social interaction among many people in a group setting where an individual is held for any purpose.

38. "Cell confinement" means being in a cell.

39. "Out-of-cell" means being in a space outside of, and in an area away from, a cell, in a group setting with other people all in the same shared space without physical barriers between people that is conducive to meaningful and congregate social interaction and activity.

40. "Congregate recreation" means out-of-cell recreation in a group setting with other people all in the same shared space that takes place outside, weather permitting, in an open yard without being caged or covered, and when weather does not permit or when an incarcerated individual so chooses, in a non-caged gymnasium or equivalent.

41. "Core programs" means any and all programs that can be assigned by a department program committee, any and all required department programs, and any and all programs that are considered for purposes of good time, merit time, other time allowance, parole release, or other release mechanisms. Core programs shall include, but not be limited to, academic classes, vocational programs, transitional services, alcohol and substance abuse treatment, aggression replacement training, sex offense counseling and treatment, and any other assigned or required programs.

42. "Represented" means an incarcerated individual having an attorney (licensed in any jurisdiction of the United States), law student with supervision by any attorney regardless of whether the attorney is affiliated with a law school, paralegal, or other incarcerated individual provide representation at any and all stages of a hearing and appeal, including but not limited to opening and closing statements, presentation of evidence, calling and questioning witnesses, cross-examining witnesses, reading of the disposition, sentencing, and appeal, with the choice by the incarcerated individual and their representative of either having the representative physically present at any and all stages of the hearing in the same room and/or participating through videoconference.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the correction law, in relation to the rights of people in prisons, jails, and forensic facilities

Purpose or general idea of bill

This bill aims to accomplish two goals: (1) to clearly place the rights of incarcerated people and their families in New York within the frame- work and protections of international human rights law and norms, and (2) to correct, clarify, and establish certain specific protections relating to how incarcerated individuals and their families are treated within New York's prisons, jails, and secure forensic facilities, including relating to visitation, use of segregated confinement, due process rights, packages, and other matters.

Summary of specific provisions

Section 1 states the name by which the bill shall be known, which is the "Rights Behind Bars; Protecting the Rights of People in Prisons, Jails, and Forensic Facilities, and Their Loved Ones, in New York State Act.".

Read the full memo (2,471 words)

Section 2 sets forth, in five parts, the legislative findings and intent:

PART A recognizes the systematic lack of human rights protections for incarcerated individuals and their loved ones in New York, and the necessity for the legislature to clarify rights that exist under New York law but are not consistently followed, to close gaps in existing law, and to enshrine into New York law well-established principles and obligations under international human rights law.

PART B cites a sampling of relevant studies, reports, and legal deci- sions which support the need for this legislation.

PART C cites relevant provisions of the New York and U.S. consti- tutions, as well as key portions of international human rights law docu- ments relating to the rights of incarcerated people, including the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights, the International Covenant of Civil and Political Rights, the Basic Principles for the Treatment of Prisoners, the Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman, or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, and the United Nations Standing Mini- mum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners (the Nelson Mandela Rules.)

PART D focuses on particular sections of the Mandela Rules which provide guidance as to the treatment of people who are incarcerated, including, Rule 3 (prohibiting, generally, actions which "aggravate the suffering inherent" in cutting people off from the outside world and depriving them of their liberty), Rule 4 (requiring that incarceration be used to "ensure the reintegration OF INCARCERATED PERSONS into society upon release"), Rule 5 (requiring carceral facilities to "minimize any differences between prison life and life at liberty that tend to lesson . . . the respect due to their dignity as human beings"), Rule 58.1 requiring that people be allowed regular communication with family and friends, Rule 22 requiring the rights of people in prison to nutritious

and wholesome food, and Rule 82 prohibiting any use of force against an incarcerated person that is not strictly necessary."

PART E notes specific areas which have arisen in recent years in New York correctional facilities, including systemic violations of the HALT Solitary Confinement Law, improper and unjustified restrictionsPackages, visits, and mail, staff abuse and brutality, and other issues, and states the intent of the legislation, namely, to clarify and enforce the human rights of incarcerated individuals in New York.

Section 3 amends correction law section 2 by the addition of eleven paragraphs which define the following terms: "contact visit", "visitor", "cell", "cell confinement", "out-of-cell", "congregate recreation", "core programs", "represented", "personal property", "secure facility", and "incarcerated individual."

Section 4 amends correction law section 2 (23) through the addition of three paragraphs: (a) allows cell confinement beyond seventeen hours per day for medical or mental health treatment only with determination that such confinement is medically necessary, b) renders any such confinement null if not medically necessary and if the environment is not as least restrictive as appropriate, and (c) sets forth items and activities incarcerated to which persons in such medically necessary confinement must have access.

Section 5 amends correction law section 2 (33) related to the phrase "special populations" to make clear via examples what is already required under settled law per the HALT Solitary Confinement Law that all people with mental health diagnosis, on the mental health caseload, with any intellectual, developmental, or cognitive impairment, with traumatic brain injury or organic brain syndrome, who have been on the mental health case-load or had a mental health diagnosis within the previous year, or who have had a diagnosis of intellectual, develop- mental, cognitive, physical, or sensorial disability with the previous year are protected. In addition, this section clarifies and extends the prohibition of imposing segregated confinement on individuals who are pregnant or in the post-partum recovery period or are caring for a child.

Section 6 amends correction law section 137 (3) by requiring incarcerat- ed individuals be provided: weather appropriate clothing, sufficient quality of a variety of fresh food to meet Department of Health guide- lines, adequate mealtimes, and applicable wheelchair assistance.

Section 7 amends correction law section 137 (5) by barring any use of force by staff against an incarcerated person except as a last resort after exhausting de-escalation techniques and where no alternatives exist to prevent imminent physical harm to another person, major proper- ty damage that raises an imminent safety or security risk, or escape. Even when authorized, staff shall only use the minimum amount of force required. This section also specifically bans the use of steel batons, prohibits retaliation, forbids staff from providing any false informa- tion in any official report, and makes all staff mandatory reporters of any observed misconduct by other staff.

Section 8 amends correction law section 137 (6) law by the addition of seven paragraphs:

(p) outlines visitation rights; including allowance for four in-person visitors every day for at least several hours per incarcerated individ- ual, access to showers prior to a visit, and related visitor rights.

q) allows incarcerated individuals to receive packages in a timely manner, by mail or visitors, and eliminates any requirement that pack- ages be from or delivered by vendors.

(r) emphasizes HALT's requirement of out-of-cell time and group program- ming by providing all incarcerated persons, apart from those in segre- gated confinement, access to at least fourteen hours of out-of-cell time per day, congregate programming and activities, and recreation.

(s) requires that any correspondence incarcerated individuals receive must be delivered in its original form.

(t) gives all incarcerated individuals access to anything technological- ly available, including use of personal tablets or devices, and free use of functions within that device to increase general connections and accessibility. This provision also requires that all personal phone calls and e-mails be free.

(u) ensures commissaries are financially accessible and contain nutri- tious options.

(v) permits incarcerated individuals to bring state court actions for any violations of this section.

Section 9 amends correction law section 137 (6)(j)(ii) by adding two new clauses: (A) clarifying that time spent in certain locations does not constitute "out-of-cell" time, such as a "recreation area' contiguous to a cell, and (B) requiring that if a person voluntarily chooses not to participate in congregate out-of-cell time, they shall be offered access to comparable individual programming, recreation, and individual time away from their cells.

Section 10 amends correction law 137 (6)(j)(v) by requiring that indi- viduals in residential rehabilitation units have access to the same programs available to the general population.

Section 11 amends correction law section 137 (6)(j)(vii) prohibiting the use of restraints when individuals are participating in out-of-cell activities unless an individualized assessment is made at the time of or immediately following an incident that the use of restraints are required for the individual due to an imminent risk of serious physical injury to self or others. The assessment must be memorialized in writ- ing. A new subsection A requires the use of the least restrictive restraint possible for no more than the necessary amount of time. A new subsection B limits the use of restraints to the day applied unless a determination based on concrete evidence finds the contrary necessary. A new subsection C provides limits and regulations to continued use of restraints.

Section 12 amends correction law section 137(6)(k) by the addition of three new subparagraphs:

(v) sets specific limits to segregated confinement and residential reha- bilitation unit times, regardless of the number of charges associated with the incident at hand.

(vi) requires that any imposition of a disciplinary sanction must be based on a finding of guilt of the charged act or acts by clear and convincing evidence.

(vii) requires hearing officers to engage in a meaningful fact-finding process, with detailed statements of evidence and reasons why the incar- cerated individual's evidence or defense was credited or rejected.

Section 13 amends correction law section 137 (6)(1) by the addition of five new subparagraphs:

(i) provides for notice of the rights to representation for persons facing placement in segregated confinement or an RRU.

(ii) requires people incarcerated and their representation, if applica- ble, to be provided all evidence relating to their charge and/or hearing as quickly as possible and no later than forty-eight hours prior to said hearing.

(iii) lists the rights incarcerated people and their representatives, if applicable, have during hearings.

(iv) requires a recording of all disciplinary hearings, and for such to be provided to the incarcerated person and their representative, if applicable.

(v) allows for time spent in segregated confinement or a residential rehabilitation unit preceding a hearing to be credited as either the sanction imposed or as good time behavior allowance time, contingent on the outcome.

Section 14 amends correction law section 137 (6)(o) by establishing the information that must be included in published monthly reports from the department. The amendment also outlines a detailed list of data and factors which must be included in said reports.

Section 15 contains a severability clause.

Section 16 provides that the provisions of this act shall take effect thirty days after becoming law.

Justification

This "Rights Behind Bars" bill was developed by the sponsors in close collaboration with experts in the functioning of New York's jails and prisons, including legal experts, formerly incarcerated individuals, families of incarcerated or formerly incarcerated individuals, currently incarcerated individuals, and advocacy organizations focused on the rights of people behind bars in New York State. In addition, the Senate sponsor, who is the Chair of the Standing Committee on Crime Victims, Crime and Correction, has a significant amount of direct contact with incarcerated or formerly incarcerated people and their families and loved ones, based on numerous in-person visits to correctional facili- ties throughout the State and, further, based on the high level of tele- phone calls and letters the Senator's office receives from incarcerated or formerly incarcerated individuals or their families.

All of this input led inescapably to two conclusions relating to the rights of people behind bars: (1) there are numerous important issues where the law of New York State is either not as clear as it could be or is not being implemented properly, to the detriment of people who are most directly impacted by incarceration, and (2) a more comprehensive vision, framework, and approach is needed in this State to ensure that the rights of people behind bars are protected.

This bill, therefore, addresses, clarifies, and corrects numerous specific issues in New York - e.g., visitation rights, mail and package access, programming, excessive and unjustified uses of force by staff, misuse of segregated confinement, due process rights, food and meals, and more. In addition, in order to provide the appropriate overall framework for understanding and protecting the rights of people behind bars in New York, this bill also places these rights within a comprehen- sive framework established by international human rights law.

This bill is both pragmatic in addressing a number of specific issues that frequently arise in New York's jails and prisons and is visionary in emphasizing the human rights of those behind bars and recognizing that New York is significantly out-of-compliance with accepted norms and rules of international human rights law as applicable to people held in custody.

The enactment of this bill is essential.

All New Yorkers have a right to expect that people held in custody are treated fairly, as human beings, and are not subjected to brutality, racism, denials of rights, interferences with visits or other forms of contact with the outside world, and are provided meaningful access to the programs and educational resources needed in order to return to their communities safely.

In addition, New Yorkers should be, and are, shocked by the huge amounts of money the State is ordered to pay out in settlements and court verdicts in cases relating, among other things, to brutality from correctional staff. As this bill was being finalized for filing, for example, word came of a $9.25 million verdict against the New York pris- on system in a case of a man killed by the use by correctional staff of unnecessary and excessive force in one of the State's prisons. This court verdict is not unique, though it is large.

The sponsors submit that if this bill were enacted, it would go a long way towards improving conditions within New York's jails and prisons, would result in significantly reduced violence, would make a huge difference in the preparation of individuals for successful re-entry to the community, and would improve family ties and relationships. All of this would have an impact on enhancing the human rights and human digni- ty of all. It would also result in significant cost savings for the State.

Racial and social justice impact

The long-standing racial disparities in New York's jails and prison systems are well-documented. The significant over-representation of people of color in New York's jails and prisons means, regardless of any other factors, that people of color are disproportionately subjected to violations of their basic human rights. When the actual and overt racism experienced by many people in jail and prison is also taken into account, it is clear that the continued failure of New York State to properly protect the safety, dignity, and human rights of incarcerated people is a major crisis with deep racial components. The enactment of this bill, with its corrections and clarifications of many specific issues as well as its placement of these issues within the larger frame- work of international human rights law, would have a significant impact on reducing the racism experienced by so many in the jails and prisons of this state.

Fiscal implications

To be determined. Implementation of these amendments will decrease instances of human rights violations, thereby significantly reducing litigation and judgments against the state. In addition, by reducing the trauma commonly experienced by people who are incarcerated, this bill will further save the state and localities money by significantly reduc- ing recidivism.

Effective date

This act shall take effect on the thirtieth day after it shall have become law.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.