Skip to content
S8118Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA9363

Require Colleges Report Admissions Data

Official title

“Relates to early decision admissions data reporting by colleges”

Sponsor Andrew GounardesSD-26Affects Education
Status
In Assembly Committee
Higher Education
Impact
6/10
Moderate
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 5 of 7

In Assembly · Higher Education

What's happening

This bill requires New York higher education institutions using early decision admissions to report and publicly disclose detailed admissions and financial aid data annually.

Why it matters

  1. Increases transparency about who is admitted via early decision. by requiring colleges to break down admissions data by race/ethnicity, income, high school type (public, private, charter, independent, or homeschooled), and geography, helping students and parents understand who benefits most from early decision policies.

  2. Reveals how financial aid is distributed across admissions plans. , including whether students admitted early decision have their full financial need met, Pell Grant receipt rates, and average/median family incomes—shedding light on whether early decision favors wealthier applicants.

  3. Creates accountability and comparability across institutions. by mandating that all data be published in a standardized, easily accessible format on the state education department’s website, making it simpler for students, families, and policymakers to compare practices and outcomes across schools.

  4. Imposes real financial penalties for non-compliance. , with the threat of losing up to 10% of state aid for colleges that willfully fail to report, thereby strongly incentivizing accurate and timely public disclosure.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Require Colleges Report Admissions Data

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Andrew Gounardes

Senator · Senate District 26

Chair, Budget And Revenue

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to higher education
  2. Delivered to assembly
  3. Passed senateVote 49–12
  4. Ordered to third reading cal.1209
  5. Committee discharged and committed to rules
  6. Referred to higher education

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A9363Assembly

Publish College Admissions Data

In Assembly Committee · Higher Education · Sponsor Chantel Jackson

Impact 6 · Moderate0% to pass

Full text

4 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

8118

IN SENATE

January 8, 2024

Introduced by Sen. GOUNARDES -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Higher Education

AN ACT to amend the education law, in relation to early decision admissions data for higher education institutions

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Title 7 of the education law is amended by adding a new article 129-C to read as follows:

ARTICLE 129-C

EARLY DECISION ADMISSIONS DATA FOR HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS

Section 6450. Early decision admissions data for higher education insti-

tutions.

§ 6450. Early decision admissions data for higher education institutions. 1. Definitions. As used in this section, the following terms shall have the following meanings:

(a) "Acceptance rate" shall mean the percentage of applicants a higher education institution accepts, computed by dividing the accepted number of applicants by the total number of applicants and multiplying such quotient by one hundred.

(b) "Academic year" shall be as defined in subdivision five of section six hundred fifty-one of this chapter.

(c) "Drop-down menu" shall refer to a graphical control element that allows a user of a website to choose one value from a list.

(d) "Early action" shall mean an admissions plan that allows a student to apply at an earlier stage of the admissions process and receive an expedited admissions decision but does not require such student to commit to attend such institution upon receiving a decision of admittance.

(e) "Early decision" shall mean an admissions plan that allows a student to apply at an earlier stage of the admission process and receive an expedited admissions decision that requires such student to commit to attend a higher education institution should such student be

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD13406-07-4

admitted and to withdraw all other applications to other higher education institutions. Early decision shall not include early action.

(f) "Estimated cost of attendance" shall mean the total amount, not including grants and scholarships, that it costs to attend a higher education institution, which may include, among other expenses, tuition and fees, housing and meals, allowances for books, supplies, and transportation, and dependent care.

(g) "Federal Pell grant" shall refer to the grants disbursed to students pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1070.

(h) "Full financial need" shall mean that the aid a student receives from the higher education institution fully covers the estimated cost of attendance.

(i) "General admission" shall mean an admissions plan for which students do not apply at an earlier stage of the admissions process and receive an expedited admissions decision. General admission shall not include early action.

(j) "Higher education institution" shall mean any four-year institution given the power to confer undergraduate degrees in this state by the board of regents as provided in section two hundred eighteen of this chapter but shall not include institutions offering career education, as defined in subdivision twenty-four of section two of this chapter, professional and/or technical schools, or educational work connected with libraries, museums, university and educational extension courses and similar agencies.

(k) "Income" shall refer to the adjusted gross income used to determine the amount of federal Pell grant paid by the secretary of education under 20 U.S.C. § 1070a or otherwise reported to the higher education institution.

(l) "Independent" shall refer to a high school that does not receive public funding and is governed by a board of governors or trustees.

(m) "Private" shall refer to a high school that does not receive public funding.

(n) "Type of admission plan" shall refer to early decision, early action, and general admission.

2. Requirement for data reporting. All higher education institutions in this state who employ early decision admissions shall report to the commissioner, on or before the first of July of each year, the following data:

(a) the deadlines by which prospective students must apply for early decision, early action, and/or general admission at the institution;

(b) the timelines when early decision, early action, and/or general admission prospective students can generally expect to receive an admissions decision from the institution;

(c) the overall acceptance rate for first-year students in the prior academic year, including total number of applications received;

(d) the acceptance rate for early decision, early action, and general admissions for first-year students in the prior academic year, including total number of applications received for each type of admissions plan and disaggregated by type of admission plan such students were accepted under;

(e) the number and percentage of first-year students admitted early decision, early action, and general admissions in the prior academic year, disaggregated by type of admission plan such students were accepted under;

(f) the racial and/or ethnic identity of all prospective students who applied for the first-year class of the prior academic year, as reported by such students;

(g) the racial and/or ethnic identity of all first-year students of the prior academic year, as reported by such students, who were accepted under an early decision, early action, or general admissions plan, by number and percentage, and disaggregated by type of admissions plan such students were accepted under;

(h) how many first-year students, by number and percentage, of the prior academic year received federal Pell grants, disaggregated by type of admission plan such students were accepted under;

(i) the amount of financial aid disbursed for the first-year students of the prior academic year, disaggregated by type of admission plan such students were accepted under;

(j) average financial aid disbursed for the first-year students of the prior academic year, disaggregated by type of admission plan such students were accepted under;

(k) whether full financial need was met for first-year students of the prior academic year admitted early decision;

(l) the median and average income of first-year students of the prior academic year, disaggregated by type of admission plan such students were accepted under;

(m) how many first-year students, by number and percentage, of the prior academic year attended a public, charter, private, or independent high school, or were homeschooled, disaggregated by type of admission plan such students were accepted under;

(n) how many first-year students, by number and percentage, of the prior academic year attended high school in this state, another state, district, or territory of the United States, or another nation, disaggregated by type of admission plan such students were accepted under; and

(o) a detailed description of a prospective student's commitment to the institution upon applying early decision, including potential consequences, if any, if such student rescinds upon a commitment to attend such institution after receiving a decision of admittance.

3. Requirement for data publishing. (a) The commissioner shall, on or before the first of September of each year, publish the data required under subdivision two of this section in a clear and prominent location on the department's website.

(b) The commissioner shall ensure that a user of such website is easily able to access the college admissions data described in subdivision two of this section for each higher education institution which reports such data via a drop-down menu on such website.

4. Penalties. (a) Any higher education institution deemed by the commissioner to willfully violate the provisions of this section shall be subject to a civil penalty equivalent to ten percent of state aid, as provided in section six thousand two hundred twenty-one of this title for senior colleges of the city university of New York, article eight of this title for the state university of New York, and section six thousand four hundred one of this title for certain independent institutions of higher education, received in the prior fiscal year.

(b) The commissioner shall maintain the discretion to provide an opportunity for a higher education institution to cure a violation of this section before levying the fines described in paragraph (a) of this subdivision.

§ 2. This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become a law and shall apply to academic years commencing on and after such date. Effective immediately, the addition, amendment and/or repeal of any rule or regulation necessary for the implementation of this act on its effective date are authorized to be made and completed on or before such effective date.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the education law, in relation to early decision admis- sions data for higher education institutions

Purpose or general idea of bill

To require colleges who use early decision admissions to report on the impact of such admissions

Summary of provisions

Section one of this bill adds a new article 129-c to the Education Law to require higher education institutions which offer early decision admissions to report on:

Read the full memo (1,150 words)

- Deadlines by which prospective students must apply early decision, early action, and/or general admissions to the college, and when they can generally expect to hear back

-The overall acceptance rate for first-year students vs. students admit- ted early decision, early action, or general admissions, including total number of applications received - The number of first-year students admitted under each type of admissions plan and percentage that they make up of the first-year class

- The racial and/or ethnic identity of prospective vs. accepted students, and which type of admissions plan they were accepted under

- How many first-year students received federal Pell grants, disaggre- gated by type of admissions plan

- Total and average amounts of financial aid disbursed to students in each type of admissions plan

- Whether full financial need is met for students applying early deci- sion

- The median and average income of first-year students, disaggregated by type of admissions plan

- What type of high school first-year students attended, and whether it is in state, out-of-state, or abroad, disaggregated by type of admis- sions plan

- A detailed description of a prospective student's commitment to the institution upon applying early decision, and what consequences they may face if they change their mind after being admitted

The report shall be published online on the New York State Education Department's, which regulates colleges through its Office of College and University Evaluation, website. The website shall allow a user to view the data for each college included in the report via a dropdown menu.

Institutions who willfully fail to comply with the provisions of this act shall be subject to a civil penalty worth 10% of state aid, which takes different forms depending on if the institution is private or public.

Section two sets the effective date.

Justification

Many colleges take advantage of early decision (ED) admissions policies, which allow prospective students to apply in November of their senior year and receive an expedited decision in exchange for committing to attend an institution if accepted, in order to secure a significant portion of an upcoming class before the application for general admis- sions opens. This can help a college budget to meet financial need, as they will know how much aid they've already dispensed vs. what they need to reserve for the rest of the class, as well as what an incoming class is likely to look like and thus how to select the rest of the applicants to ensure a diverse range of backgrounds and interests. Many colleges argue that they partner with pipeline programs to use early decision to target underrepresented students, who may not otherwise apply, to build a diverse class early on. ED also allows colleges to lock in institu- tional priorities, such as athletes or legacies, at an earlier stage and lowers their overall admission rate. Early decision is distinct from early action admissions, which allow students to apply early but do not require them to commit to attend if accepted.

Despite these advantages, early decision has one glaring flaw: it requires students to commit to attending before they can compare finan- cial packages in the spring and thus overwhelmingly benefits students from wealthy backgrounds. Providing a significant admissions advantage, with some studies showing that applying ED is worth an extra 100 points on the SAT, at the most elite colleges up to 50% of an incoming class is admitted early decision. At Brown and Duke University, applying ED makes an applicant four times more likely to be admitted than if they were to apply regular decision. At Dartmouth College and Columbia University, an applicant is three times more likely.

A closer look at who exactly benefits from ED, meanwhile, reveals a portrait of stark class and income disparity. Almost a third of students from independent high schools applied ED, more than 3.5 times the percentage of public school students. International applicants are almost three times more likely to apply ED than US residents, and appli- cants from the country's wealthiest ZIP codes are twice as likely to apply ED than other applicants. One study found that the single strong- est predictor of whether a not a student was likely to apply ED was whether they had hired a college admissions consultant, and the share of Black students who apply ED is almost half of those in the regular admissions pool. While some schools commit to meeting the full financial need of the ED applicants they accept, most do not. And while colleges will claim that students can back out of an ED offer and incur no finan- cial penalty, the fact remains that the majority of students and parents are largely unaware of this exception - and the schools, for obvious reasons, are loath to advertise it.

This bill requires all colleges in New York who use early decision admissions to report on how much of their class they are filling from the ED vs. regular admissions pool, acceptance rates for ED vs. regular admissions, the aggregate Pell status and median incomes of ED vs. general admissions students, and average financial aid disbursed for both pools. While the US Department of Education has the ability to collect and disaggregate admissions data such as this across a range of categories, it does not currently do so. And while the Common Data Set survey, meanwhile, which is an attempt by the College Board, Peterson's, and the U.S. News & World Report to get colleges to report on a wealth of admissions information, contains a category on early decisions, several notable institutions leave it conspicuously blank.

In a world in which selective colleges fill more than half their first- year classes by early January, the average student may have virtually no shot at being admitted to some of our state's most celebrated insti- tutions. A snapshot into exactly which types of students are applying ED and how colleges use it to shape their classes will be an invaluable tool for policymakers and the public. It will spur important debates about who benefits from the status quo, who is left behind, and how we can design a better system to uplift all students in the college admis- sions process.

Prior legislative history

None

Fiscal implications

TBD

Effective date

This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become a law and shall apply to academic years commencing on and after such date.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.