Skip to content
S8215Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA8070

Protect Delivery App Workers

Official title

“Relates to protections and rights afforded to delivery network company workers”

Sponsor Robert JacksonSD-31Affects Economy
Status
In Senate Committee
Labor
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Labor

What's happening

This bill establishes new rights and protections for delivery app workers in New York, including notice, challenge procedures, and limits on deactivation.

Why it matters

  1. Establishes a clear process for deactivation, making it harder for delivery app companies to arbitrarily or unfairly remove workers from their platforms. This helps protect workers from losing income due to unclear rules or opaque algorithms, and ensures that deactivation is based on documented, fair reasons.

  2. Creates strong transparency and documentation requirements. companies must provide advance notice (with exceptions for egregious misconduct), detailed written explanations, and access to all records used to justify a worker’s deactivation. This allows workers to understand and potentially contest the reasons for their removal.

  3. Guarantees workers a right to challenge deactivation, both internally and through legal channels. Workers can use a company’s appeal process, but also retain the right to file a complaint with the state or take civil action, increasing their leverage against unfair treatment.

  4. Prohibits retaliation and discrimination, including for asserting rights or reporting violations. This is especially significant for vulnerable workers, including immigrants, as it bars companies from threatening immigration-related actions or punishing workers for speaking out, making complaints, or helping others understand their rights.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • App-based delivery workers

    The bill would limit grounds for deactivation, require notice and supporting records, and let workers challenge deactivations internally, through the Labor Department or in court.

  • Delivery network companies

    Covered platforms would have to investigate deactivations, establish appeal procedures, retain compliance records and regularly submit deactivation data to the Labor Department.

  • New York State Department of Labor

    The department would administer and enforce the protections, investigate suspected violations and set rules for company records and worker notices.

  • Immigrant delivery workers

    The bill would prohibit companies from threatening to report workers’ or family members’ immigration status in response to workers exercising their rights.

Headline styles

Protect Delivery App Workers

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Robert Jackson

Senator · Senate District 31

Chair, Civil Service And Pensions

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to labor

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A8070Assembly

Protect Delivery App Workers

In Assembly Committee · Labor · Sponsor Linda Rosenthal

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

9 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

8215

IN SENATE

January 12, 2024

Introduced by Sen. JACKSON -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Labor

AN ACT to amend the labor law, in relation to protections and rights afforded to delivery network company workers

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. The labor law is amended by adding a new article 21-B to read as follows:

ARTICLE 21-B

DELIVERY NETWORK COMPANIES Section 790. Definitions.

790-a. Deactivation requirements.

790-b. Right to challenge deactivation.

790-c. Notice of deactivation.

790-d. Access to records substantiating deactivation.

790-e. Affirmative production of records.

790-f. Notice of rights.

790-g. Network company records.

790-h. Retaliation prohibited.

790-i. Rulemaking authority.

790-j. Enforcement power and duties.

790-k. Violation.

790-l. Investigation.

§ 790. Definitions. For the purposes of this article, the following terms shall have the following meanings:

1. "Adverse action" means reducing compensation; garnishing tips or gratuities; temporarily or permanently denying or limiting access to work, incentives, or bonuses; offering less desirable work; terminating; deactivating; threatening; penalizing; retaliating; engaging in unfair immigration-related practices; filing a false report with a government agency; or discriminating against any person for any reason.

2. "Deactivate" or "deactivation" means the blocking of a DNC worker's access to a DNC's digital network, prohibiting a DNC worker from accepting any future DNC orders for such DNC, or other material restriction of

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD13223-01-3

a DNC worker's access to such DNC's digital network. The term "deactivation" shall not include a temporary suspension lasting less than forty-eight hours.

3. "Deactivation policy" means a DNC's policy for measures to be taken prior to implementing the deactivation of a DNC worker adopted pursuant to subdivision one of section seven hundred ninety-a of this article.

4. "Deactivation challenge procedure" means a procedure under which a DNC worker may challenge their deactivation under section seven hundred ninety-b of this article.

5. (a) "Delivery network company" or "DNC" means a person, corporation, partnership, sole proprietorship, or other entity that is operating in New York state exclusively using a digital network to connect DNC customers with DNC workers who provide delivery for orders of products made via a digital network.

(b) "Delivery network company" shall not include:

(i) a transportation network company, as defined by section sixteen hundred ninety-one of the vehicle and traffic law; or

(ii) a restaurant, or restaurant chain, that enables customers to place orders for food using a digital network that was created specifically for use by customers of such restaurant or restaurant chain.

6. "Delivery network company customer" or "DNC customer" means an individual or other entity who uses a delivery network company's digital network to request a DNC order.

7. "Delivery network company order" or "DNC order" means the pickup and delivery of products by a DNC worker to a DNC customer through the use of a DNC's digital network:

(a) beginning when a DNC worker accepts a DNC customer's request for such pickup and delivery of such products through such digital network;

(b) continuing while the DNC worker transports such products; and

(c) ending when the DNC worker delivers such products to such DNC customer, or to such DNC customer's requested delivery location.

8. "Delivery network company worker" or "DNC worker" means an individual who has entered into an agreement with a DNC to pickup and deliver DNC orders for compensation.

9. "Digital network" means any system or service offered or utilized by a delivery network company that enables DNC orders to be delivered by DNC workers, including but not limited to a smartphone application or online website.

10. "Discrimination" means any of the unlawful discriminatory practices described in section two hundred ninety-six of the executive law.

11. "Egregious misconduct" means an action or behavior by a DNC worker that: (a) endangers the physical safety of a DNC customer, a third party, a DNC, or an animal; (b) intentionally causes economic harm to a DNC customer, a third party, or a DNC; (c) is threatening, harassing, or abusive to a DNC customer, a third party, or a DNC; or (e) constitutes a misdemeanor or felony under the laws of this state.

12. "Products" shall include, but not be limited to, prepared foods, packaged foods, alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages, and other goods.

13. "Unwarranted deactivation" shall mean a deactivation in violation of section seven hundred ninety-a of this article.

§ 790-a. Deactivation requirements. 1. A delivery network company shall adopt a policy for measures to be taken prior to implementing the deactivation of a DNC worker. Such policy shall be reasonably related to such DNC's safe and efficient operations. Policies including any of the following shall not be in compliance with this subdivision:

(a) Any rule or policy that would result in a deactivation based on a DNC worker's availability to work or number of hours worked;

(b) Any policy that would result in a deactivation based on a DNC worker's acceptance or rejection of any individual DNC order, or any number or proportion of DNC orders;

(c) Any policy that would result in a deactivation based on a DNC worker's cancellation of a DNC order with reasonable cause, as shall be defined by such DNC;

(d) Any policy that would result in a deactivation based on a DNC worker contacting such DNC;

(e) Any policy that would result in a deactivation based solely on a quantitative metric derived from aggregate customer ratings of a DNC worker's performance;

(f) Any policy that would result in a deactivation based on statements by a DNC worker regarding compensation and/or working conditions made to customers, other DNC workers, other DNCs, the media, public officials, and/or the public; or

(g) Any policy that would result in a deactivation based on a DNC worker asserting their legal rights.

2. A delivery network company shall provide each DNC worker a copy of its deactivation policy before allowing such DNC worker to accept any DNC orders for such DNC. Such deactivation policy shall be written in plain language in the language selected by the DNC worker as such DNC worker's primary language. Such deactivation policy shall be made available to any former DNC worker of a DNC for no less than three years after deactivation of such DNC worker.

3. A delivery network company shall conduct a fair and objective investigation, as determined by the commissioner, prior to the deactivation of any DNC worker. Such investigation shall be sufficiently thorough to justify such deactivation and demonstrate an unbiased and neutral view of facts collected. If such DNC worker refuses to participate in such investigation or provide relevant information, such DNC may complete such investigation based on available sources of information. Such DNC shall demonstrate by a preponderance of the evidence that such DNC worker violated such DNC's deactivation policy prior to deactivation of such DNC worker. A DNC shall apply its deactivation policy in a consistent manner.

4. Deactivation of a DNC worker by a DNC shall be in violation of this article if such deactivation is intended to or results in discrimination.

5. Notwithstanding the provisions of this section, a delivery network company shall be authorized to immediately deactivate a DNC worker if such deactivation is required to comply with any applicable court order or local, state, or federal law or regulation, or where such DNC worker has engaged in egregious misconduct. In the case of egregious misconduct by a DNC worker, a DNC may deactivate such DNC worker before conducting the investigation required pursuant to subdivision three of this section. In such a case, such investigation shall not take longer than fourteen days. If such investigation is delayed due to extraordinary circumstances, such DNC shall provide such DNC worker with written notice that such investigation is delayed, the reason for such delay, and the date on which the completion of such investigation is anticipated.

§ 790-b. Right to challenge deactivation. 1. A delivery network company shall not subject a DNC worker to an unwarranted deactivation.

2. A DNC worker shall have the right to challenge their deactivation through an internal deactivation challenge procedure.

3. A DNC shall create an internal deactivation challenge procedure that shall be available to DNC workers immediately upon their deactivation, and up to ninety days after such deactivation.

4. A DNC's deactivation challenge procedure shall be available to its DNC workers in writing, in a format that is readily accessible, and in English and any language that such DNC knows or has reason to know is the primary language of such DNC worker. Such deactivation challenge procedure shall be available to DNC workers and former DNC workers for up to three years after their deactivation. The commissioner may prescribe the form and content of a DNCs deactivation challenge procedures.

5. A DNC shall review and respond to a DNC worker's challenge to deactivation within fourteen days of receiving such challenge. Such response shall include a written statement that shall include at least one of the following:

(a) Evidentiary substantiation of such deactivation pursuant to section seven hundred ninety-d of this article, and substantive responses to questions or claims made by such DNC worker in such challenge;

(b) Any extraordinary circumstances necessitating a delayed timeline for response, and an anticipated date for a response either substantiating such deactivation or reinstating such DNC worker; or

(c) A determination that such DNC worker did not violate the DNC's deactivation policy and therefore shall be reinstated.

6. In addition to pursuing an internal challenge to deactivation under this section, a DNC worker shall have a right to file a complaint with the department or bring a civil action for violation of the requirements of this article upon receiving the DNC's initial response to an internal challenge, or fourteen days after initiating such challenge, whichever comes first. A DNC worker may pursue all avenues of relief available within three years of the alleged violation, or as tolled pursuant to section seven hundred ninety-l of this article.

§ 790-c. Notice of deactivation. 1. Except as provided under subdivision three of this section, a delivery network company shall provide a DNC worker with a notice of deactivation no later than fourteen days prior to such deactivation, as well as on the date of such deactivation. Such notice of deactivation shall include a written statement of the following:

(a) The reasons for such deactivation;

(b) The effective date of such deactivation;

(c) Any and all records relied upon to substantiate such deactivation pursuant to section seven hundred ninety-d of this article;

(d) The length of such deactivation;

(e) A description of the steps such DNC worker can take to remedy such deactivation;

(f) A notice of such DNC worker's right to challenge such deactivation under section seven hundred ninety-b of this article; and

(g) Any other information required by the commissioner.

2. A DNC shall provide notices of deactivation in a form and manner that shall be designated by the department.

3. For deactivations involving egregious misconduct, a DNC shall provide the DNC worker with a notice of deactivation no later than the effective date of such deactivation.

§ 790-d. Access to records substantiating deactivation. 1. Pursuant to subdivision three of this section, upon notice of deactivation, a DNC shall provide a DNC worker with the records relied upon by such DNC to substantiate such deactivation, unless contrary to local, state, or federal law. Such records shall include, but not be limited to, the date, time, and location of all incidents supporting the decision for such deactivation, records of all evidence considered in such decision, and a certified statement from an individual at such DNC with authority to reinstate such DNC worker, attesting that such records are true and accurate to such individual's knowledge.

2. If a DNC obtains records substantiating a deactivation, after implementing such deactivation, such records shall be provided to the deactivated DNC worker as soon as practicable, but no later than fourteen days from the date such records were obtained.

3. If a DNC worker challenges a deactivation pursuant to subdivision two of section seven hundred ninety-b of this article, all records of such challenge and any responses shall be provided to such DNC worker within fourteen days of such challenge or response.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the labor law, in relation to protections and rights afforded to delivery network company workers

Purpose

This legislation will provide protections for app-based food delivery workers against unwarranted account deactivation.

Summary of specific provisions

Section one amends the labor law by adding a new article 21-B.

Section two establishes the effective date.

Justification

Food delivery services have expanded greatly in recent years, allowing- people to easily place food delivery orders on mobile apps and websites. The expansion of these apps has benefited restaurants, gig economy work- ers and customers; however, the ability for these workers to remain on platform is dependent on the rating and feedback provided by customers. While each platform has its own specific policies, generally, kdelivery worker is at risk of having their account deactivated when their rating drops below a certain threshold, including for ratings and complaints levied against a worker for a slow or delayed delivery. In many cases, workers are provided no warning of a forthcoming deactivation or any opportunity to appeal.

These practices by app companies have led to a highly competitive and speed-driven environment on the streets as delivery drivers compete to receive more orders and earn better tips. The 2022 Bicycle Crash Data Report released by the New York City Department of Transportation showed an increase in the number of injuries and deaths involving e-bikes ands- scooters, a mode of transportation relied upon by many delivery workers, over previous years. Requiring delivery apps to follow a standardprocess for account deactivation, including an opportunity for workers to appeal the decision, will remove some of the uncertainty in their job.

This legislation would protect delivery drivers by requiring all food delivery services to adhere to a deactivation policy that prohibits, account deactivation based on rejection or cancellation of an order _customer ratings or other factors without first conducting a fair and objective investigation, with exceptions for certain egregious miscon- duct. The legislation would also require all delivery drivers to receive advance notice of an impending deactivation and an opportunity to appeal the deactivation. Lastly, the legislation provides the state Department of Labor with the authority to enforce the law and provides workers with protections against retaliation for exercising rights afforded in the bill.

Legislative history

New bill.

Fiscal implications

None to the State.

Effective date

180 days.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.