Skip to content
S8474Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA10030

Make Staten Island Independent

Official title

“Incorporates the city of Staten Island”

Sponsor Andrew J. LanzaSD-24Affects Finance
Status
In Senate Committee
Finance
Impact
10/10
Transformational
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Finance

What's happening

This bill separates Staten Island from New York City and creates an independent city government.

Why it matters

  1. Local control. Richmond County would become the city of Staten Island, with its own mayor, comptroller and 15-member council.

  2. Schools and services. The bill creates a separate city school district with a nine-member elected board. New York City would continue municipal services during the transition, subject to existing budget restraints.

  3. Assets and workforce. The cities would divide property, debt and other obligations, with unresolved allocations decided in court. Employees would retain pay and benefits, with no layoffs resulting from transferred functions.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Staten Island residents

    They would elect a separate city government responsible for local services and planning.

  • New York City officials

    They would negotiate the division of assets, liabilities and service responsibilities with Staten Island officials.

  • Municipal employees and unions

    The bill preserves employment protections and collective bargaining benefits while allowing affected employees to remain with New York City.

  • Staten Island students and parents

    Their public schools would fall under a separate district governed by an elected school board.

Headline styles

Make Staten Island Independent

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Andrew J. Lanza

Senator · Senate District 24

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to finance

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A10030Assembly

Create Staten Island City

In Assembly Committee · Cities · Sponsor Michael Tannousis

Impact 9 · Transformational0% to pass

Full text

1211 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

8474

IN SENATE

February 2, 2024

Introduced by Sen. LANZA -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Finance

AN ACT to incorporate the city of Staten Island; to enact a charter for the city of Staten Island; to provide a period of transition prior to the establishment of the city of Staten Island; to amend the education law, in relation to the establishment of the… Show all

AN ACT to incorporate the city of Staten Island; to enact a charter for the city of Staten Island; to provide a period of transition prior to the establishment of the city of Staten Island; to amend the education law, in relation to the establishment of the city school district of the city of Staten Island; to amend the education law, in relation to the transfer of the college of Staten Island of the city university of New York to the state university of New York; to amend the judiciary law, in relation to providing for the judiciary within the city of Staten Island; to amend the public housing law, the education law, the public authorities law and the private housing finance law, in relation to providing membership on certain authorities for the city of Staten Island; to amend the executive law, the elder law and the social services law, in relation to probation and social services within the city of Staten Island; to amend the county law, in relation to the treatment of the county of Richmond in similar fashion to counties within a city having a population of one million or more; to amend the election law, the state finance law and the surrogate's court procedure act, in relation to making conforming changes relating to the establishment of the city of Staten Island; to amend the general municipal law, in relation to the city of Staten Island industrial development agency; to amend the local emergency housing rent control act, the emergency tenant protection act of nineteen seventy-four, the general business law and the real property tax law, in relation to the continuation of existing housing regulations for the city of Staten Island; to amend the tax law, the state finance law, the public authorities law and the New York state financial emergency act for the city of New York, in relation to applicability of the authority of the financial control board; to amend the general city law, chapter 772 of the laws of 1966 relating to imposition of a city business tax and the tax law, in relation to providing authority for the city of Staten Island to continue presently applicable taxes within such city; to enact the administrative code of the city of Staten Island, in relation to procedures and administration of essential city services and the authority of such city to impose taxes; and making appropri- [ ] is old law to be omitted. ations to advance moneys for the establishment of the city of Staten Island and the city school district of the city of Staten Island

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

THE CITY OF STATEN ISLAND ACT

CONTENTS

SECTION(S) SUBJECT

1-001 Short title. 1-002 Legislative history, findings and intent and statement of

purposes. 1-003 Definitions. 1-004 Incorporation. 2-001 Charter of the city of Staten Island. 3-001 Legislative findings and declaration of purposes. 3-002 Elections. 3-003 Staten Island city government-transition. 3-004 Employees of the city of Staten Island. 3-005 Assistance to the city of Staten Island. 3-006 Provision of municipal services on the city of Staten

Island. 3-007 Debt, property, obligations and other allocations. 3-008 Continuance of municipal services. 3-009 Powers of the city of Staten Island to adopt and amend

local laws. 3-010 Powers of the city of Staten Island relating to home

rule powers. 4-001-4-020 City school district of the city of Staten Island. 5-001-5-003 Transfer of The College of Staten Island. 6-001 Interim court structure for the city of Staten Island. 7-001-7-002 New York city housing authority. 7-003-7-005 New York city construction fund. 7-006-7-008 New York city municipal water finance authority. 7-009 New York city housing development corporation. 7-010 Dormitory authority act; court facilities and combined

occupancy structures. 7-011 New York city school construction authority. 8-001-8-023 Municipal powers; authority of the county of Richmond

and the city of Staten Island. 9-001-9-017 Municipal services; city of Staten Island. 10-001-10-008 Landlord-tenant relationships. 11-001 Constitutional real property tax limitations; city of

Staten Island. 12-001-12-020 Municipal assistance corporation for the city of New York;

revenues. 13-001 Taxes; tax collection authority. 14-001 Administrative code of the city of Staten Island. 15-001 Appropriations; transition government and establishment of

the city of Staten Island. 15-002 Appropriation; city school district of the city of Staten

Island. 16-001 Severability. 17-001 Effective date.

Section 1-001. Short title. This act shall be known and may be cited as "The City of Staten Island Act".

§ 1-002. Legislative history, findings and intent and statement of purposes. 1. The legislature hereby finds, determines and declares:

(a) that Article IX, section 1 of the New York State Constitution states that "effective local self-government and intergovernmental cooperation are purposes of the people of the state" and subdivision (a) of section 2 of Article IX, further declares that "the legislature shall provide for the creation and organization of local government;"

(b) that consistent with these constitutional provisions and in order to provide for an effective republican form of government in accordance with the constitution of the United States of America, the people of the state of New York, represented in the senate and assembly, did enact chapter 773 of the laws of 1989, as amended by chapter 17 of the laws of 1990, which authorized the borough of Staten Island, upon approval by referendum to consider formally separating from its existing municipal government, authorized the creation of a charter commission for the city of Staten Island, authorized, upon approval of a subsequent referendum, the adoption of a charter, and most importantly, required that within three months of adoption of the charter by the voters of Staten Island, the charter commission submit to the governor and the legislature, proposed legislation enabling the borough of Staten Island to disengage and separate from its existing municipal government, and that only upon enactment of such enabling legislation, could the charter for the city of Staten Island take effect;

(c) that the legislature, in requiring the subsequent enactment of enabling legislation before a charter for the city of Staten Island could take effect, reaffirmed its paramount constitutional authority to distribute the powers of local government, as between city and county governments, as it deems best;

(d) that preserving historical and natural boundaries, as well as the integrity of political subdivisions of the state, and providing meaningful representation of the smaller boroughs in the city of New York affairs, are among those legitimate state interests and policies which have been validated by the federal courts;

(e) that the people of the state of New York enacted chapter 773 of the laws of 1989, as subsequently amended, to provide a process by which the people of Staten Island could carefully study and consider the legal disengagement and separation of the borough of Staten Island from the city of New York as an acceptable means of implementing the substantial state interest in providing effective local self-government for the citizens of Staten Island; and

(f) that the issues of legal disengagement and separation of the borough of Staten Island from the city of New York raise concerns of statewide importance, not limited to Staten Island residents or New York city residents.

2. The legislature further finds, determines and declares:

(a) that the New York State Constitution entitles the people of Staten Island to "effective local self-government;"

(b) that the existing charter of the city of New York does not provide meaningful representation to the borough of Staten Island, therefore precluding "effective local self-government;"

(c) that given the constraints of the United States Supreme Court articulated in Board of Estimate of the City of New York v. Beverly Morris, 489 US 103 (1989), the only viable alternative to providing "effective local self-government" is legal disengagement and separation from the city of New York and the creation of the new city of Staten Island;

(d) that such legal separation of Staten Island from the city of New York is economically feasible, with minimal fiscal impact on the state of New York;

(e) that the city of New York should have a meaningful role and the opportunity to provide significant input in the process by which Staten Island legally disengages and separates from the city of New York, including participation in a transition period, but the city of New York should not in the exercise of the aforesaid role, be permitted to unilaterally prevent the legal disengagement and separation of Staten Island; and

(f) that in connection with the process of legal disengagement and separation, there is hereby specifically delegated to a group of representatives from both the city of New York and the proposed city of Staten Island the task of evaluating and accounting for the allocation of all assets and liabilities, as well as the provision of municipal services during the transition period, all of which shall be determined in the context of the overall best interest of the state of New York.

3. The legislature further finds, determines and declares:

(a) that by virtue of the authority vested in the legislature by the New York State Constitution to provide for the "creation and organization of local governments" as well as for "effective local self-government" and "intergovernmental cooperation," the interests of the people of the state would be served and promoted by the separation and creation of a new municipality to be called the city of Staten Island; and

(b) that in furtherance of such purposes, the recommendations of the charter commission shall be implemented in connection with the creation of the city of Staten Island.

4. The legislature further finds, determines and declares that the establishment of the city of Staten Island is authorized by the New York State Constitution, constitutes a state purpose for the benefit of the people of the state of New York and therefore the city of Staten Island Act is hereby enacted.

§ 1-003. Definitions. As used in this act, the following terms shall have the following meanings:

1. "Effective date of this charter" shall mean the first of November next succeeding the date on which this act shall have become a law.

2. "Date of incorporation of the city of Staten Island" or "date of incorporation" shall mean the date on which the city of Staten Island is incorporated, the first of January next succeeding the date on which this act shall have become a law.

3. "Date of establishment of the city of Staten Island" or "date of establishment" shall mean the date on which the city of Staten Island is first authorized to exercise full municipal authority, except for judicial authority, over the citizens and territory of the city of Staten Island, the first of July in the second year next succeeding the year in which this act shall have become a law.

4. "Transition period" shall mean the period of time between the date of incorporation and the first of July in the second year next succeeding the year in which this act shall have become a law from and including the date of incorporation until the date of establishment.

5. "Preceding municipality" shall mean the city government for the geographical area of the city of Staten Island existing immediately prior to the incorporation of the city of Staten Island and which shall exercise full municipal powers and duties for such area during the transition period.

6. "Judiciary transition period" shall mean the period of time between the date of incorporation of the city of Staten Island and December thirty-first in the fifth year following such incorporation or until the provisions of article 5-C of the judiciary law are specifically superseded by state law. At the conclusion of the judiciary transition period, the city of Staten Island shall be authorized to exercise full judicial authority over the citizens and territory of the city of Staten Island.

§ 1-004. Incorporation. The city of Staten Island is hereby incorporated on the first of January next succeeding the date on which this act shall have become a law. The boundaries of such city shall be as described in section 1-02 of the charter of the city of Staten Island as set forth in section 2-001 of this act. During the transition period such city shall not have the powers or duties of a municipality except those which are provided for pursuant to this act to provide for the transition of government and the establishment of such city. During the transition period, the preceding municipality shall possess and exercise full municipal powers and duties for the area to become the city of Staten Island except for those powers and duties as may be provided by the provisions of this act. Powers and duties of the city of Staten Island not yet in effect shall remain with the preceding municipality until such time as those powers and duties are transferred to the city of Staten Island pursuant to the provisions of this act. Except as otherwise provided by this act, full powers and duties shall devolve to the city of Staten Island on the first of July in the second year next succeeding the date on which this act shall have become a law. The following powers, duties and functions regarding the judiciary during the judicial transition period and other matters as jointly determined by the city of Staten Island and the preceding municipality in accordance with the provisions as outlined elsewhere in this act, will be shared by both municipalities. The city of Staten Island shall be established on the first of July in the second year next succeeding the date on which this act shall have become a law, on which date the city of Staten Island shall possess full municipal powers and duties as are provided under law and the preceding municipality shall cease to possess municipal powers and duties regarding the city of Staten Island.

§ 2-001. Charter of the city of Staten Island. The city charter of the city of Staten Island is enacted to read as follows:

Charter of the City of Staten Island

Table of Contents Preamble Chapter 1 General Provisions Chapter 2 Powers of the City Chapter 3 Mayor Chapter 4 Common Council Chapter 5 Comptroller Chapter 6 The Budgetary Process: Expense and Capital Chapter 7 Planning Department Chapter 8 Franchises Chapter 9 Contracting Chapter 10 Referendum and Amendment Chapter 11 Property of the City Chapter 12 Personnel Management Chapter 13 Equal Employment Practices Commission Chapter 14 Collective Bargaining Chapter 15 Transitory Provisions Chapter 16 Labor Relations

CHARTER OF THE CITY OF STATEN ISLAND

Preamble

The People of Staten Island, exercising their right to propose a government of their choosing through which all people can be effectively represented, do hereby adopt this Charter.

The birth of a city, must, of necessity, take place in an aura of excitement and great expectations. When it occurs at a time when society is experiencing strong institutional challenges in a climate of skepticism, it places heavy burdens on those responsible for leadership to sustain a commitment by the people to live and function together as a community.

The provision of a structure of governance at the local level is an extraordinary and crucial responsibility. Sophocles wisely observed that "the city is the people." The City of Staten Island must place a high premium on assuring meaningful participation of its citizenry in the governmental decisions affecting their lives.

We must respect the principles of equality and of the social dignity of all of our residents and provide for the complete development of the individual, promoting actions which favor the advancement of men and women in realizing their fullest potential. We must embrace policies that promote and give effectiveness to the rights of every person, with particular attention to those who face special challenges, in striving for a full life.

We must assert a policy of favoring equal opportunity employment for all women and men. We must foster a culture that is peaceful and nonviolent and that safeguards the rights of all inhabitants to carry out their lawful activities on Staten Island.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to incorporate the city of Staten Island; to enact a charter for the city of Staten Island; to provide a period of transition prior to the establishment of the city of Staten Island; to amend the education law, in relation to the establishment of the city school district of the city of Staten Island; to amend the education law, in relation to the transfer of the college of Staten Island of the city university of New York to the state university of New York; to amend the judiciary law, in relation to providing for the judiciary within the city of Staten Island; to amend the public housing law, the education law, the public authorities law and the private housing finance law, in relation to providing membership on certain authorities for the city of Staten Island; to amend the executive law, the elder law and the social services law, in relation to probation and social services within the city of Staten Island; to amend the county law, in relation to the treatment of the county of Richmond in similar fashion to counties with- in a city having a population of one million or more; to amend the election law, the state finance law and the surrogate's court procedure act, in relation to making conforming changes relating to the establish- ment of the city of Staten Island; to amend the general municipal law, in relation to the city of Staten Island industrial development agency; to amend the local emergency housing rent control act, the emergency tenant protection act of nineteen seventy-four, the general business law and the real property tax law, in relation to the continuation of exist- ing housing regulations for the city of Staten Island; to amend the tax law, the state finance law, the public authorities law and the New York state financial emergency act for the city of New York, in relation to applicability of the authority of the financial control board; to amend the general city law, chapter 772 of the laws of 1966 relating to impo- sition of a city business tax and the tax law, in relation to providing authority for the city of Staten Island to continue presently applicable taxes within such city; to enact the administrative code of the city of Staten Island, in relation to procedures and administration of essential city services and the authority of such city to impose taxes; and making appropriations to advance moneys for the establishment of the city of Staten Island and the city school district of the city of Staten Island

Purpose

Incorporates the city of Staten Island.

Summary of provisions

This legislation incorporates the city of Staten Island and enacts a charter for such city. The legislation makes conforming changes in the law to reflect the creation of the city of Staten Island and the result- ing effects on the city of Staten Island.

Read the full memo (2,159 words)

1. Sections 1-1001 through 1-004 provide for the history of the move toward incorporation and the subsequent incorporation of the city of Staten Island;

2. Section 2-001 enacts the city charter for the city of Staten Island;

3. Sections 3-001 through 3-010 provide the mechanism to represent the interests of the city of Staten Island and to provide for its transition to a city form of government. The election of city officials is provided for as well as the transfer and appointment of civil service employees. Vacancy, residency and retirement issues involved in the transfer are also covered. The legislation provides a procedure for the allocation of the proportion of debt between the city of Staten Island and the city of New York. Included also are provisions for the continuance of municipal services and powers of the city of Staten Island during the period of transition;

4. Sections 4-001 through 4-020 provide for the creation of the city school district of the city of Staten Island. These sections also make conforming amendments to the education law reflecting the creation of such city school district. Transition period provisions relating to functions of the city school district are also provided for;

5. Sections 5-001 through 5-003 provide for the transfer of the college of Staten Island of the city university of New York to the State Univer- sity of New York. The transfer of employee rights, contract rights and provisions affecting real property rights are provided for as well. Conforming amendments to the education law are made;

6. Sections 6-001 provide for the continuance of the court system for the city of Staten Island. These sections provide, as nearly as possi- ble, for the maintenance of a court system that reflects the present city-wide court system in New York city. The transfer and protection of employee rights are also provided for in the legislation.

7. Sections 7-001 through 7-011 make conforming amendments to consol- idated law for membership on certain authorities or the city of Staten Island;

8. Sections 8-001 through 8-023 make conforming technical amendments to various laws reflecting a city form of government for Staten Island relating to probation and social services within the city of Staten Island;

9. Sections 9-001 through 9-017 amend the county law to provide for the treatment of Richmond county to be similar to that afforded to counties within cities with a population of one million or more. Sections 9-050 through 9-053 make conforming changes in law that reflet the establish- ment of the city of Staten Island;

10. Sections 10-001 through 10-008 provide of the continuance and main- tenance of existing housing regulations for the city of Staten Island. A rent guidelines board is established for such city. Existing housing tax exemptions are maintained for the city of Staten Island; 11. Sections 11-001 provides for the continuance of a city real property tax limit of two and one-half percent for the city of Staten Island due to the maintenance of a city form of government rather than a change to a county form of government;

12. Sections 12-001 through 12-020 and provisions of law concerning the municipal assistance corporation for the city of New York to reflect its application to the city of Staten Island as well;

13. Sections 13-001 through 13-007 amend provisions of the general city law and the law providing enabling legislation for the city to impose taxes and tax credits therefore;

14. Section 14-001 provides enactment of provisions similar to the New York city administrative code tax provisions for the city of New York for the city of Staten Island; provides the maintenance and continuance of current applicable tax provisions;

15. Sections 15-001 and 15-002 provide for an advance of moneys out of the general fund to the credit of the local assistance account for the expenses of carrying out provisions for the establishment of the city of Staten Island and the city school district of the city of Staten Island; and

16. Section 16-001 provides severability provisions of the legislation.

17. Section 17 is the effective date.

Justification

The people of the State of New York, represented in the Senate and Assembly enacted Chapter 773 of the Laws of 1989, as amended by Chapter 17 of the Laws of 1990, which authorized the borough of Staten Island to consider formally separating from its existing municipality. These previous Chapter laws provided for two separate referendum by the people of Staten Island. The first vote, which took place in November of 1990, resulted in over 80% of the voters authorizing the establishment of a New York State Charter Commission for Staten Island to draft a charter for the proposed City of Staten Island. The second referendum, which took place in November 1993, resulted in a 65% approval of the proposed charter. During the three years between the two votes, in addition to drafting the proposed Charter, the Charter Commission held 12 public hearings, conducted in-depth research into the myriad legal and fiscal issues involved and compiled its findings in numerous reports which were submitted to the people of Staten Island as well as to the Governor and legislative leaders.

Governor Mario Cuomo's message approving Chapter 773 of 1989 provided the following justification:

The Legislature has declared - overwhelmingly on both sides of the aisle and in both houses - that the people of Staten Island should have the opportunity to vote on the question whether they should be allowed to create a new and separate city. It appears to be universally accepted that they are justified in wanting to consider separation from the City of New York. They have been a part of the City since 1898. But a recent decision by the Supreme Cout of the United States dramatically changed Staten Island's participation in city governance, reducing its equal vote on the Board of Estimate to a relatively small participation in a new city legislative body. That changed circumstance, added to a long list of grievances by the people of the Island over the years, moved the legislature to adopt this bill.

This proposed legislation was initially submitted to the Governor and the Legislative Leaders in 1993, as Senate Bill S.6820 to fulfill the mandate of Chapter 17 of 1990, to "propose legislation enabling the

borough of Staten Island to disengage and separate from the City of New York".

Since the initial introduction of this legislation the population of Staten Island has continued to grow from approximately 350,000 in 1993, to now approximately 475,000. Yet, its local municipal governing struc- ture, for the least populous borough and county within the City of New York, continues to deny Staten Island residents of any meaningful participation in City government.

The 1989 U.S. Supreme Court decision which abolished New York City's most powerful governing body, the Board of Estimate, effectively reduced Staten Island's role in New York City government to that of a mere observer in local municipal affairs. That "changed circumstance", as acknowledged above in Governor Cuomo's approval message, and which ulti- mately gave rise to this legislation's initial introduction, has only been further exacerbated, leading to New York City's unilateral imposi- tion of many additional "grievances" upon the people of Staten Island, including the City's unfair congestion pricing program, the placement of illegal migrants without proper community input, and the arbitrary COVID-19 restrictions upon local businesses and public school students, which are totally inconsistent with the character and quality of life of a county of almost a half a million disenfranchised New York State resi- dents.

Accordingly, now, more than ever, this legislation is vital to restore meaningful and effective representative local municipal government for the people of Staten Island

Fiscal implications

Will not increase any liability to the State. LEGISLATIVE - HISTORY:

1994: S.6820 - Passed Senate / A.9662 - Referred to Cities

1995: S.3781 - Passed Senate / A.6436 - Referred to Cities

1996: S.3781 - Referred to Finance / A.6436 - Referred to Cities

1997: S.3966 - Referred to Finance / A.6949 - Referred to Cities

1998: S.3966 - Referred to Finance / A.6949 - Referred to Cities

Effective date

This act shall take effect immediately; provided, however, that: (a) the provisions of sections 7-009, 7-010, 13-001, 15-001 and 15-002 of this act shall take effect on the first of January next succeeding the date on which it shall have become a law; (b) the provisions of sections 7-001 through 7-008, 8-001 through 8-024, 9-001 through 9-012, 9-050 through 9-053, 10-001 through 10008, 11-001, 12-001 through 12-020 and 14-001 of this act shall take effect on the first of July in the second year next succeeding the date on which it shall have become a law; (b-1) the amendments made to subdivisions 8 and 14 of section 2554 of the education law by sections 4-007 and 4-008 of this act, respectively, shall take effect upon the revival of such subdivisions as provided in section 34 of chapter 91 of the laws of 2002, as amended; (c) provided that the amendments to paragraphs (a), (b), (c), (d), (e), and (f) of subdivision 2 of section 209 of the social services law made by section 8-021 of this act shall take effect on the same date and same manner as section 2 of part Z of chapter 56 of the laws of 2023, takes effect; (d) the amendments to the second undesignated paragraph of subdivision 4 of section 246 of the executive law made by section 8-004 of this act shall be subject to the expiration and reversion of such paragraph pursuant to subdivision (aa) of section 427 of chapter 55 of the laws of 1992, as amended, when upon such date the provisions of section 8-004-a of this act shall take effect; and (e) provided that the amendments made to sections 257-c, 262, 266 and 267 of the executive law made by sections 8-007, 8-008, 8-009 and 8010 of this act shall not affect the expiration or repeal of such sections and shall be deemed expired and repealed therewith.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.