What's happening
This bill creates a civil legal process to protect companion animals from mistreatment or neglect, allowing for court-ordered care or removal.
Why it matters
Establishes a clear, civil pathway for intervention. when companion animals are suspected of mistreatment, allowing authorities to act even when criminal charges are not pursued or proven, which could help prevent suffering before situations become dire.
Requires judicial oversight and due process. Owners or caretakers receive written notice and a court hearing before an animal can be removed, with the right to present evidence and challenge allegations—balancing animal welfare with property and due process rights.
Sets specific standards and timelines. for emergency intervention, hearings, and appeals, including requirements for veterinary evaluation and expedited court action, potentially leading to swifter protection for animals in need.
Holds owners financially responsible for care costs. if animals are seized, through a supersedeas bond, which may deter neglect and reduce the financial burden on shelters and animal protection organizations.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Who cares
Companion animal owners and caretakers
They could face court-ordered care and inspections, forfeiture of mistreated animals and restrictions on keeping other companion animals, with a right to defend themselves and appeal.
Police officers and SPCA agents
They would gain a civil process to demand proper care, seek emergency inspection orders and pursue forfeiture when owners cannot or will not provide adequate care.
Municipal shelters and humane societies
They could receive forfeited companion animals for adoption or other disposition under existing law.
Licensed veterinarians
They could inspect animals at an authorized agent’s direction under emergency court orders and provide evidence of veterinary care at animal care hearings.
Headline styles
Let Courts Protect Abused Pets
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
History
- Referred to agriculture
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Let Courts Protect Neglected Pets
In Assembly Committee · Agriculture · Sponsor John T. McDonald III
Full text
4 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
8543
IN SENATE
February 12, 2024
Introduced by Sen. GIANARIS -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Agriculture
AN ACT to amend the agriculture and markets law, in relation to establishing a civil remedy for the protection of companion animals denied proper care
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. The agriculture and markets law is amended by adding a new article 26-D to read as follows:
ARTICLE 26-D
CIVIL REMEDY FOR THE PROTECTION OF COMPANION ANIMALS Section 440. Legislative purpose.
441. Definitions.
442. Jurisdiction; courts; venue.
443. Notice of mistreated companion animal.
444. Emergency powers.
445. Animal care hearing.
446. Appeal.
447. Construction with other laws.
§ 440. Legislative purpose. The purpose of this article is to provide a civil means by which a companion animal that is found to be mistreated or not properly cared for may be:
1. Made the subject of a court order to provide care issued to its owner or caretaker, and
2. Removed from its present custody if necessary to ensure proper care.
§ 441. Definitions. As used in this article, the following terms shall have the following meanings:
1. "Mistreated or not properly cared for" means every act or omission that results in a companion animal suffering unnecessary psychological or physical injury or pain, or failing to provide adequate food, water, shelter or veterinary care necessary to preserve the physical and mental well-being of a companion animal.
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD14303-03-4
2. "Companion animal" shall have the same meaning as defined by section three hundred fifty of this chapter.
3. "Authorized agent" means any police officer, or agent or officer of any duly incorporated society for the prevention of cruelty to animals pursuant to section three hundred seventy-three of this chapter.
4. "Impounding organization" shall mean any municipal pound or shelter, duly incorporated society for the prevention of cruelty to animals or duly incorporated humane society.
§ 442. Jurisdiction; courts; venue. 1. A special proceeding to ensure proper care or seizure of a companion animal shall be maintained in the supreme court.
2. The place of the special proceeding shall be within the jurisdictional area of the court where such companion animal thereof is situated.
§ 443. Notice of mistreated companion animal. If an authorized agent has reason to believe that a companion animal has been or is being mistreated or not properly cared for, such authorized agent may notify the owner or caretaker, in writing, of such owner or caretaker's duty to provide certain care, including but not limited to, proper shelter, food, water or veterinary care to such companion animal at the owner's or caretaker's expense and within a time period determined by such authorized agent's discretion.
§ 444. Emergency powers. 1. If such owner or caretaker fails to provide care to such companion animal and such companion animal remains mistreated or not cared for after receiving notice and within the time period determined by such authorized agent, an authorized agent may immediately petition the court for an ex-parte emergency care and inspection order.
2. An emergency care and inspection order shall be immediately issued upon a showing of probable cause that such companion animal has been or is being mistreated or not properly cared for.
3. Such order shall require the owner or caretaker to provide care to such companion animal and allow an authorized agent to enter onto the premises where such companion animal is being kept to ensure such companion animal is receiving necessary food, water, shelter and care.
4. An ex-parte emergency care and inspection order issued pursuant to this section shall be effective upon service, in accordance with section three hundred eight of the civil practice law and rules, and shall:
(a) provide specific details of such mistreatment or failure to provide proper care to such companion animal and direct such owner or caretaker to take corrective action;
(b) allow an authorized agent and licensed veterinarian at the direction of such authorized agent to inspect such companion animal to ensure compliance with the order to provide care;
(c) prohibit such owner or caretaker from interfering with such inspection by the authorized agent or veterinarian;
(d) prohibit an owner or caretaker from transferring ownership of such companion animal;
(e) prohibit an owner or caretaker from euthanizing such companion animal without first seeking and obtaining permission of the court on a showing that such procedure is to prevent undue suffering or physical pain to such companion animal; and
(f) allow a veterinarian to examine such companion animal at least twenty-four hours prior to such animal care hearing.
5. Upon issuance of an emergency care and inspection order, the court shall set a time within ten calendar days of the date of issuance for an animal care hearing pursuant to section four hundred forty-five of this article, to determine whether such companion animal has been mistreated or not properly cared for. The date and time for the scheduled hearing shall be noted within such order, or as an attachment to such order.
6. Such emergency care and inspection order and notice of animal care hearing shall be provided within at least five days prior to the scheduled animal care hearing and served in accordance with section three hundred eight of the civil practice law and rules. If such owner or caretaker is not known, the emergency care and inspection order and notice of animal care hearing may be affixed to such premises where such companion animal was located.
§ 445. Animal care hearing. 1. In a proceeding to determine whether such companion animal has been or is being mistreated or not properly cared for, and that such owner is unable to or unwilling to provide immediate and continued proper care for such companion animal, the court may consider the following:
(a) testimony from the authorized agent and other witnesses as to the condition of such companion animal;
(b) testimony from the authorized agent and other witnesses as to the conditions under which such companion animal was kept;
(c) evidence as to any veterinary and behavioral care provided to such companion animal;
(d) testimony from witnesses as to the prior treatment or condition of such companion animal or other companion animals in the owner or caretaker's custody;
(e) prior convictions of statutes prohibiting cruelty to animals; and
(f) any evidence the court deems material or relevant.
2. The authorized agent shall have the burden to prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that such companion animal was mistreated or not properly cared for, and that such owner or caretaker is unable or unwilling to provide immediate and continued proper care for such companion animal. The owner or caretaker shall have the right to a full defense including, but not limited to, the right to cross-examine witnesses and to present witnesses and evidence.
3. If the court determines that such owner or caretaker of the companion animal is unable or unwilling to provide adequate care for the companion animal and that the companion animal was mistreated or not properly cared for, the court shall order the immediate forfeiture such companion animal that has been the subject of the hearing to the authorized agent. The court shall also enjoin the owner or caretaker's further possession, custody, or ownership of such other companion animals for a time determined by the court to be reasonable.
(a) Upon an order of forfeiture pursuant to this subdivision, the authorized agent may deliver such companion animal to an impounding organization for adoption or other disposition pursuant to section three hundred seventy-four of this chapter.
(b) Any order of forfeiture pursuant to this section shall identify a supersedeas bond amount based on the reasonable cost to care for the companion animal subject to the order of forfeiture, to be paid by the owner or caretaker. Reasonable costs of care shall be determined based on testimony provided at the animal care hearing and shall be calculated based on the total number of animal or animals and the reasonable daily cost of care for such animal or animals for, at minimum, a period of one hundred eighty days.
4. If the court determines that such owner or caretaker of the companion animal has provided and will continue to provide adequate care for the companion animal that has been the subject of the order to provide care, or that the companion animal was not mistreated or not properly cared for as set forth in the emergency order, the court shall vacate the order to provide care. Vacatur pursuant to this subdivision shall not preclude the court from entering an order to provide care in the future.
5. A finding in a court of competent jurisdiction that the owner or caretaker of the animal is guilty of an offense brought pursuant to this article relating to the companion animal that is the subject of the animal care hearing is prima facie evidence that such companion animal has been mistreated or not properly cared for.
§ 446. Appeal. 1. An appeal may be taken to the appellate division as of right, originating in the supreme court from where the order of forfeiture was issued. As a condition of perfecting such appeal, the owner or caretaker shall file a notice of appeal and pay such supersedeas bond set by the court, not later than ten calendar days after the date the order of forfeiture was issued.
2. Any appeal filed with the appellate division of the supreme court shall be perfected within thirty days following the date of the order of forfeiture.
3. A hearing on such appeal shall be heard within thirty calendar days after such appeal is perfected unless a continuance is mutually agreed upon the parties. If a continuance is granted, the owner or caretaker of such forfeited companion animal shall pay a second supersedeas bond in the amount ordered by the appellate division.
4. The filing of such appeal shall not prevent the removal of a forfeited companion animal from such owner or caretaker's possession by the authorized agent. However, if such supersedeas bond has been paid under subdivision one of this section, such companion animal or animals may not be adopted or otherwise disposed of, except under circumstances which would require the humane euthanasia of such companion animal to prevent undue suffering or physical pain, or where such companion animal poses a severe and immediate danger to itself, people or other animals.
§ 447. Construction with other laws. Nothing in this article shall be construed to (a) limit or restrict agents or officers of societies for the prevention of cruelty to animals or any police officer from enforcing other provisions of article twenty-six of this chapter or any other law relating to the humane treatment of, or cruelty to, animals, or (b) prevent a dog control officer or peace officer, acting pursuant to the officer's special duties, or police officer in the employ of or under contract to a municipality from seizing any dog pursuant to article seven of this chapter. Relief pursuant to this section shall not be stayed or continued due to the filing of criminal charges involving or otherwise relating to such companion animals that are subject of the emergency care and inspection order and animal care hearing.
§ 2. This act shall take effect on the one hundred twentieth day after it shall have become a law.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the agriculture and markets law, in relation to estab- lishing a civil remedy for the protection of companion animals denied proper care
Purpose
This bill would provide a civil process by which humane law enforcement agencies can implement a non-criminal process to address acts or omis- sions that result in a companion animal suffering unnecessary psycholog- ical or physical injury or pain, or failing to receive food, water, shelter or veterinary or behavioral care necessary to preserve the phys- ical health and mental well-being of an animal.
Summary of provisions
Section 1 of the bill amends the agriculture and markets law to estab- lish a new Article 26-D entitled, "Civil Remedy for the Protection of Companion Animals." This article is comprised of seven sections to effectuate its purpose, as follows:
Read the full memo (1,500 words)
Section 440 provides the declaration of purpose for the establishment of this article, which is to provide a civil means by which a companion animal found to be mistreated or not properly cared for may be made the subject of a court order to provide care issued to its owner or caretak- er or removed from its present custody by court order to ensure proper care.
Section 441 provides definitions for specific terms in the statute.
Section 442 provides that state supreme courts shall have jurisdiction over these civil proceedings.
Section 443 describes the process by which written notice is given to the owner or caretaker of a mistreated companion animal.
Section 444 describes the process by which an authorized agent may peti- tion the court for an ex-parte emergency care and inspection order should the owner or caretaker fail to provide care after written notice was given. This section then describes when the court shall issue the order and what the order shall require. Upon the issuance of such order, this section requires the court to schedule an Animal Care Hearing with- in a specified time period. The court must also provide timely notice to the owner or caretaker of both the order and the hearing.
Section 445 provides for the Animal Care Hearing process, whereby the court determines whether the owner or caretaker of a companion animal being denied proper care is fit to continue owning such animal. If the court determines that such owner or caretaker is unable or unwilling to provide adequate care, then the court shall order the animal's immediate forfeiture and enjoin the owner or caretaker from further possession, custody, or ownership for a time determined by the court to be reason- able. The order of forfeiture shall identify a supersedeas bond amount that the owner or caretaker must pay based on the reasonable cost to care for the companion animal. Section 446 establishes the owners right to appeal and the process that must be followed in that regard.
Section 447 relates to the new Article 26-D interacts with other laws.
Section 2 of the bill provides the effective date of the new Article 26-D, which is 120 days after it becomes law.
Existing law
New York law only provides a criminal process for adjudicating animal cruelty cases. There is currently no civil remedy to effectively protect companion animals from mistreatment.
Justification
This bill would create a civil remedy to ensure that unfit owners are properly caring for their companion animals or, if necessary, remove such animals from their custody to prevent further mistreatment. A civil process for addressing animal mistreatment is critical given the signif- icant challenges that come with enforcing criminal animal cruelty stat- utes.
For one thing, the animal itself often serves as evidence of the alleged crime, but unlike all other forms of evidence, pets are also personal property and are living, breathing, sentient creatures. They cannot be placed in secure storage unattended, or in an evidence locker until a criminal case is adjudicated. Even when removed from severely neglectful or abusive situations, the quality of life for a seized pet can diminish significantly in a relatively short period of time without a permanent living situation. At the same time, shelters have no way of knowing when a criminal case will be resolved; depending upon numerous factors beyond their control, a conviction or dismissal can take months, if not years.During this same period, costs borne by impounding organizations increase proportionally and quickly become prohibitive. Animals entrusted to their care require food, water, veterinary care, and behav- ioral, enrichment and volunteer services that must be continuously available to the shelter's entire population.
Because towns and cities often contract with not-for-profit entities for sheltering services, these costs directly impact them as well. In one recent case, the City of Watervliet incurred $30,000 in sheltering costs in a case that may have been able to be dispensed with more quickly if a civil remedy was already in place.
As a result of such circumstances, some shelters may decline to harbor pets seized during criminal cruelty investigations, especially if their shelter is already stretched thin due to high intake rates and veterinary/staff shortages. This in turn impacts the ability for law enforcement agencies to effectively investigate animal cruelty complaints; when an officer responds to a complaint, suspects cruelty but has nowhere to bring an animal at risk, it can drastically compli- cate the manner in which an investigation can proceed, if at all.
In addition, law enforcement and humane agencies have long expressed frustration with using criminal law to address specific types of neglect & cruelty situations like animal hoarding. Yet, it is their only option. To cite one recent example from the ASPCA in NYC, a routine welfare check at a small home in Queens alerted police to horrific conditions inside, where a search warrant was obtained to remove over 70 animals from an aging mother and her daughter, who was subsequently arrested and charged with animal cruelty. A petition was filed with the court for the owners to post a security bond for the care of their animals at ASPCA's animal hospital, in an attempt get the court to order forfeiture of the animals. This case took more than a year to litigate, resulted in over $420,000 in medical care and sheltering costs, and because the organiza- tion was unable to adopt the pets into loving homes, many languished despite high-quality professional care. Mental health issues for the mother and daughter also contributed to court delays which resulted in even longer legal hold times for the animals. This family needed help - not the cost of defending themselves in criminal court or the stigma of a criminal conviction; unfortunately, under current law a search warrant and criminal charges (twice) was the only option.
In a 2021 example, Hudson Valley Humane Society in Rockland County was called to a home where they found two dogs chained to an outbuilding. The shelter eventually gained access to the home and seized 24 adult dogs. The owner, a man in his early 60's, was a classic animal hoarder, using multiple veterinarians to hide how many animals he actually owned. The case went on for 18 months until finally the court recognized the overwhelming cost HVHS had absorbed by awarding the shelter custody of the animals. Nonetheless, the shelter housed these dogs for 18 months, meaning other homeless companion animals couldn't be sheltered due to space constraints. The total cost of care in the case was $75,000 in veterinary bills and close to $260,000 in daily care at a rate of $20/day (which is actually below average).
In 2023, Finger Lakes SPCA took in 13 dogs, mostly Cane Corsos (seven adults and six puppies) from an animal cruelty case. The seizure was done by the County Sheriff with the shelter's assistance. The owner refused to relinquish ownership of the animals and the court process was "a nightmare," according to the shelter's Executive Director. The owner managed to keep delaying the case, and the dogs were housed at the shel- ter for 11 months. The cost of care and damage because of overcrowding is estimated at between $75,000 and $100,000. The county was able to assist with only about 20% of this financial burden.
While nothing in this measure would prevent the pursuit of criminal charges for any situation regarding suspected animal cruelty when warranted, the establishment of a civil process option - whereby a court can render a decision, based on the evidence, regarding an animal owner's ability to care for a companion animal - is good for law enforcement, good for shelters, good for social justice and of course good for companion animals. This procedure is not a new concept; it is used successfully in other states where, when appropriate, it provides a sound and fair means to wrest animals from harm's way without having to charge the owner with misdemeanor or felony-level crimes.
Legislative history
New bill.
Fiscal implications
To be determined.
Local fiscal implications
To be determined.
Effective date
This act shall take effect 120 days after it shall have become law.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.