Skip to content
S8770Senate2023-2024 Session

Retirement Residents' Rights Guaranteed

Official title

“Establishes a continuing care retirement community bill of rights”

Sponsor Sean RyanSD-61+1 co-sponsorAffects Health
Status
In Senate Committee
Aging
Impact
7/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Aging

What's happening

This bill establishes a bill of rights for residents of continuing care retirement communities in New York and creates ombudsman oversight.

Why it matters

  1. Empowers residents with contractual and governance rights. The bill requires CCRCs to honor all service contracts, allows residents to inspect those contracts, and mandates annual evaluations of service fulfillment, giving residents leverage and transparency in their interactions with facility management.

  2. Strengthens resident self-governance and participation. Residents gain explicit rights to establish and operate their own associations, select representatives to the CCRC’s governing board, attend board meetings, and receive regular board and financial reports, ensuring their voices are integral to decision-making.

  3. Increases operational transparency and input. The bill obligates CCRCs to provide clear disclosures about services, advance notice and opportunities for feedback on fee increases and staffing changes, and full financial transparency—including actuarial assurances about long-term viability—helping residents make informed decisions about their care and investments.

  4. Establishes independent oversight and complaint resolution. By mandating a county-level ombudsman system, residents and their families have an impartial authority to contact with complaints or concerns, and these records are public, creating accountability and a formal mechanism for addressing grievances without fear of retaliation.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Retirement Residents' Rights Guaranteed

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Sean Ryan

Senator · Senate District 61

Chair, Commerce, Economic Development And Small Business

1 Co-sponsor

History

  1. Referred to aging

Full text

3 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

8770

IN SENATE

March 8, 2024

Introduced by Sen. RYAN -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Aging

AN ACT to amend the public health law, in relation to establishing a continuing care retirement community bill of rights

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. The public health law is amended by adding a new section 4625 to read as follows:

§ 4625. Continuing care retirement community bill of rights. 1. Every continuing care retirement community (CCRC) shall adopt, implement and distribute to residents the following continuing care retirement community bill of rights. All residents of CCRCs shall have the right to:

a. expect full, prompt and complete fulfillment by the CCRC's management of those services delineated in their contracts and other affiliated contracts. An annual survey of such services with an evaluation of their fulfillment shall be implemented by the residents' association with results distributed to residents. Contracts approved by the management of the CCRC shall be available for inspection by residents or their designated representatives;

b. establish, organize, fund, develop by-laws for, and operate a residents' association whose purposes include, but are not limited to, representing the interests of the residents to the administration and the CCRC's corporate governing board;

c. freely assemble, with or without the participation of management and staff as the residents in their judgment deem advisable, to enhance communication and information-sharing among the residents, and to promote active learning and discussion of issues facing the CCRC community;

d. select and appoint, in accordance with the resident association's own by-laws, at least three members of the CCRC's corporate governing board, who have rights and duties commensurate with the other board members;

e. receive regularly scheduled reports from the association-appointed governing board members about the board's deliberations, actions and

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD14783-01-4

policies. Residents have a right to a corporate governing board every member of which acknowledges their fiduciary responsibility to the residents. All corporate board and corporate board committee meetings shall be open to any resident or their representative wishing to attend without fear of reprisal except for meetings closed in accordance with state or federal statutes and regulations. Meetings shall be closed only for discussion of personnel or personal health issues;

f. be kept informed by the administration, on a semiannual basis, about all significant issues of management which directly affect residents' well-being or their financial investment, or any issues about which residents are concerned, limited only by necessary and explicitly defined policies of confidentially and privacy;

g. full disclosure of the finances of the corporation, presented at least on an annual basis. In cases where a community is a member of a consortium of communities, residents have the right to be fully informed of the finances of both their local community and of the parent corporation. CCRC residents have the right to receive periodic written reports from a duly certified actuary affirming that sufficient funds will be available for the future likely needs of the resident population. Residents have the right to be informed in advance if any sale of the community to another operator or provider comes under consideration;

h. a plain English list of those services guaranteed by the contract, as well as a list of those services offered by the CCRC but not guaranteed in the contract (and which may be modified or withdrawn at the discretion of the management or corporate governing board), provided to all prospective residents prior to their being asked to sign the contract;

i. visit the assisted living and skilled nursing facilities, as well as all the amenities associated with independent living, before signing a contract;

j. be informed in advance of, and be given an opportunity to comment on, changes in the delivery of services, including changes in staffing levels in its administrative and service departments and changes in staff credentialing requirements in areas such as health care, food service, and facilities maintenance. Such notice shall be given in advance of implementation with sufficient time for residents to respond;

k. be informed, at least a month in advance of implementation, about any change in fees, and have the opportunities to comment on such changes to management and to the governing board. The CCRC management and/or corporate board shall respond with written responses to residents;

l. participate directly in the governance of the residents' association through communication, discussion, and decision-making in open meetings, through membership in association committees, and through the election of officers and members of the resident association's own board of directors, in accordance with by-laws;

m. raise issues concerning their own well-being, their quality of life, and the sufficiency of their involvement in community life and governance, and to advocate openly for issues of concern to them to be discussed and dealt with by the residents' association, the administration, and the governing board as appropriate;

n. establish and operate informal activities of any kind, so long as they do not impact negatively on the lives of others, violate the law, interfere with other activities in community space and facilities, or require resident association funds;

o. organize and seek residents' association recognition of a new committee or other resident activity needing community facilities, or residents' association funds;

p. all the benefits of living in community, including all the services and amenities on offer, and all regulations applying to community life, provided and enforced impartially and without prejudice, regardless of a resident's age, gender, religion, race, economic status, professional background, sexual orientation, past or present advocacy of issues and policies applying to community life and governance, past or present activism in the polity outside of the retirement community, or past or present service on boards or committees;

q. select, based on availability and the resident's financial qualifications, an independent living apartment of the resident's choice and to appoint and furnish it to the resident's taste, within the provisions of the life-care contract and fire and safety regulations; and

r. participate as fully and meaningfully as possible when the need to move to an assisted living facility or skilled nursing unit comes under discussion. Family members designated by the resident shall have the right to be kept informed of the resident's condition and care plan. Residents or their designated medical proxies shall have the right to refuse medications and treatments.

2. The commissioner shall designate an ombudsman for each county to monitor the bill of rights established by this section and any other regulations concerning residence in independent living at a CCRC. The commissioner shall promulgate regulations providing direction and regulatory authority to the ombudsman. Residents and/or their family members or representatives shall have the right to contact their county ombudsman with complaints, compliments, and/or comments without prejudice or recrimination. Records of the contacts made under the ombudsman program shall be a matter of public record and available on request.

§ 2. This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become a law. Effective immediately, the addition, amendment and/or repeal of any rule or regulation necessary for the implementation of this act on its effective date are authorized to be made and completed on or before such effective date.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the public health law, in relation to establishing a continuing care retirement community bill of rights

Purpose

This bill would create a continuing care retirement community bill of rights to protect residents and provide them with avenues for active participation in their community.

Summary of provisions

Section 1: amends the public health law to create a new section 4625:

Read the full memo (1,131 words)

Subsection 1: Mandates that every continuing care retirement community (CCRC) adopt, implement, and distribute to their residents the CCRC bill of rights, which outlines residents' rights to the following:

a. The right to expect CCRC management to fulfill the duties outlined in their contract agreement. Residents shall also have the right to evalu- ate the execution of the services outlined in their contract agreement through a survey distributed by a residents' association. The results of the survey and the contract language itself must be made available for residents to review.

b. The right to form a residents' association that will represent resi- dents' interests to the CCRC administration and governing board.

c. The right to freely assemble with or without the participation of management or staff in order to facilitate open communication around issues relating to the CCRC.

d. The right to select and appoint at least 3 members to the CCRC governing board who will have the same rights and obligations as other board members.

e. The right to receive regular updates on the actions and deliberations of the board from their appointed representatives. Committee meetings must also be made open to residents or their representatives except as prohibited by state or federal regulations, or in the case that person- nel and personal health issues are the subject of discussion.

f. The right to be informed on a semi-annual basis of significant issues of management pertinent to residents' financial and personal well-being, limited only by explicitly defined policies of confidentiality.

g. The right to full disclosure of the finances of the corporation, presented at least on an annual basis, including, but not limited to, periodic reports from an actuary on the financial future of the corpo- ration and notice when the sale of the community is under consideration.

h. The right to review a plain English list of all the services guaran- teed in the contract and all the services offered (but that may be subject to modification or withdrawal) before the resident signs the contract. i. The right to visit the assisted living and skilled nursing facili- ties, as well as amenities associated with independent living, before signing a contract.

j. The right to be informed of and comment on any potential changes to the delivery of services, including but not limited to, changes in the required staffing level of administration or the required credentialing of healthcare, food service, or facility maintenance staff.

k. The right to at least one months' notice with respect to planned changes in fees and the opportunity to comment to the CCRC governing board on prospective fee changes. 1. The right to participate in the governance of the residents' association.

m. The right to raise issues surrounding personal wellbeing and partic- ipation in community life and governance, as well as to advocate for issues of concern to management and the CCRC governing board.

n. The right to establish informal activities of any kind as long as they do not infringe on the wellbeing of other residents or the opera- tion of the community as a whole and do not require residents' associ- ation funds.

o. The right to organize and seek approval of committees and activities that require use of community facilities or residents' association fund- ing.

p. The right to access the benefits of the community regardless of iden- tity or past or present advocacy within the community or outside the community.

q. The right to select and furnish, based on availability and the resi- dent's financial capability, an independent living apartment.

r. The right to fully participate in discussions about moving to an assisted living facility or skilled nursing unit. Family members desig- nated by residents shall also have the right to be informed of the resi- dent's care plan. Residents and their designees have the right to refuse treatment or medication.

Subsection 2. Directs the Department of Health to appoint an ombudsman for each county in the state and to promulgate regulations to provide guidance and regulatory authority to the ombudsman.

Section 2. Establishes the effective date.

Justification

New York is home to 12 continuing care retirement communities across the state. These communities provide vital services to the thousands of seniors that they serve. As of 2024, 18.1% of the state's population is over 65 years old. As New York's population grows older, providing dignified and competent care to elder New Yorkers will require new stra- tegies. With New York's nursing homes and assisted living facilities already stretched thin, CCRCs will be asked to manage more of the aging population. An increase in usage must be accompanied by an increase in protection for residents of these communities. That is why a CCRC bill of rights is so vital. CCRCs provide essential services to thousands of New Yorkers. However, these services come with a hefty price tag. The entrance fee for any CCRC in New York starts at $115,000 and only goes up from there, with the nationwide average for entrance fees sitting at around $400,000. On top of this, residents must also pay a monthly fee that bottoms out at $2,100. These high costs must come with a state-backed set of rights. Residents deserve to have input on the direction of their community and to be informed about any significant changes that will affect them. Elders want to be active participants in the governance and operation of their communities, and they need the proper access and information to do so.

New York already struggles to prevent people from leaving the state to retire. Whether it is a result of the colder climate or the higher cost of living, it can be difficult for some to commit to settling down for retirement in the state. One way to make it easier for elders to feel comfortable staying in New York is to do what many other states have done and enshrine in law rights and privileges for those choosing CCRCs. Some of these states that have gone above and beyond to establish a bill of rights for CCRC residents include Connecticut, Virginia, and New Jersey. Following suit would create a more welcoming environment for elders from across the country and help to prevent the exodus of retired New Yorkers out of the state.

Legislative history

New bill.

Fiscal implications

None to the state.

Effective date

This act shall take effect immediately.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.