Skip to content
S8843Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA1633

Require Notice for Hospital Closures

Official title

“Requires public notice and public engagement when a general hospital seeks to close entirely or a unit that provides maternity, mental health or substance use care”

Sponsor Gustavo RiveraSD-33+15 co-sponsorsAffects Finance
Status
Vetoed
Impact
8/10
Significant
Outcome
Vetoed

Bill progress

Vetoed

What's happening

This bill requires extensive public notice, engagement, and review before a general hospital or certain hospital units can close or reduce services.

Why it matters

  1. Creates a much longer, more structured review process. for hospital or key unit closures, requiring early written notice (up to 270 days in advance), public forums, revised closure plans, and final review by a state health council. This gives communities and stakeholders more time and opportunity to influence or respond to potential reductions in healthcare access.

  2. Requires health equity impact assessments. as part of closure applications, ensuring that decisions weigh how closures would affect vulnerable groups, including the uninsured, Medicaid recipients, and medically underserved populations. This could shift hospital planning to more explicitly consider social and health disparities.

  3. Mandates repeated and accessible public engagement. not just one meeting, but notice to elected officials, unions, and community boards; forums held both in person and online; acceptance of written and electronic comments; and making closure plans publicly available. This ensures transparency and broader community input, not just administrative decisions behind closed doors.

  4. Limits hospitals’ ability to reduce or shift services without oversight. , including temporary or partial closures, unless they can show good cause like modernization, labor shortages, or financial emergencies outside their control. This prevents hospitals from quietly scaling back key services that communities rely on, especially in maternity, mental health, and substance use care.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • General hospital operators

    The bill would require advance notice, health equity impact assessments and public review for hospital and unit closures, with specified good-cause exemptions for unit closures or service reductions.

  • Department of Health and Public Health and Health Planning Council

    They would review closure plans, conduct public meetings and forums, and make recommendations or decisions before proposed closures.

  • Medicaid recipients, uninsured patients and medically underserved communities

    They would receive earlier information and opportunities to comment on closures and plans to preserve access to affected services.

  • Likely concerns

    Health care labor unions and providers

    They would receive notice of closure forums and opportunities to raise concerns that hospitals would have to address in revised closure plans.

Headline styles

Require Notice for Hospital Closures

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

History

  1. Vetoed memo.108
  2. Delivered to governor
  3. Returned to senate
  4. Passed assembly
  5. Ordered to third reading cal.47
  6. Substituted for A1633B
  7. Referred to ways and means
  8. Delivered to assembly
  9. Passed senateVote 57–4
  10. Amended on third reading 8843a
  11. Advanced to third reading
  12. 2nd report cal.
Show 2 earlier actions
  1. 1st report cal.837
  2. Referred to health

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A1633Assembly

Require Notice Before Hospital Closures

Assembly Floor Calendar · Sponsor Jo Anne Simon

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

6 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

8843--A Cal. No. 837

IN SENATE

March 20, 2024

Introduced by Sens. RIVERA, KAVANAGH, GONZALEZ, MYRIE, HINCHEY, WEBB, KRUEGER, BAILEY, BRESLIN, BRISPORT, HARCKHAM, HOYLMAN-SIGAL, RAMOS, SALAZAR, SCARCELLA-SPANTON -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Health -- reported favorably from said committee, ordered to first and second report, ordered to a third reading, amended and ordered reprinted, retaining its place in the order of third reading

AN ACT to amend the public health law, in relation to providing public notice and public engagement when a general hospital seeks to close entirely or a unit that provides maternity, mental health or substance use care

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Short title. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "local input in community healthcare act".

§ 2. Section 2801-g of the public health law, as added by chapter 541 of the laws of 2010, subdivision 4 as added by section 3 of part E of chapter 57 of the laws of 2023, is amended to read as follows:

§ 2801-g. Community [forum] notice and engagement on hospital closure. 1. Process for the closure of a general hospital or a unit of a general hospital. (a) This section sets forth a process for the closure of a general hospital or a unit of a general hospital. As used in this section, "unit" means a portion of a general hospital that offers licensed emergency, maternity, mental health or substance use services, including any specialty care or any other hospital service in an operating certificate as approved under section twenty-eight hundred five of this article. For the purposes of this section, the closure of a unit of a general hospital shall include a reduction of such services. As used in this section, "reduction" means a reduction in services that results in:

(i) more than fifteen percent of a reduction in patient capacity of a unit within twelve months; or

(ii) a twenty-five percent or more reduction in patient capacity in aggregate within a twenty-four month period; or

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD14019-11-4

(iii) a thirty-five percent or more reduction in patient capacity in aggregate within a thirty-six month period.

2. Closure of a general hospital. (a) Written notification of a proposed closure of a general hospital must be provided to the department and all parties listed in subparagraph (ii) of paragraph (c) of this subdivision no later than two hundred seventy days prior to the proposed closure date. Nothing in this section shall prohibit a general hospital from conferring with the department prior to submitting such written notification to give informal notice and seek guidance.

(b) Application. A general hospital that seeks to close entirely shall submit an application that requires review by the public health and health planning council, or any successor entity. The application for the closure shall include a health equity impact assessment, as defined by section twenty-eight hundred two-b of this article, and a proposed closure plan. The application shall be submitted at least two hundred ten days before the proposed closure. No cessation, pause, transfer, or limitation of service may be carried out while the closure application is pending without prior written approval by the commissioner or the commissioner's designee, who may take into consideration the impacts on quality of care and patient safety stemming from changes in patient volume or services. As used in this section, "transfer of services" shall include conversion of services from inpatient to outpatient services, the moving of services to other facilities, or the transfer of personnel that would constitute a reduction or unavailability of services.

(c) Public community forum. (i) No later than [thirty] one hundred fifty days [after] prior to the proposed closure of a general hospital, the commissioner shall hold a public community forum for the purpose of obtaining public input concerning the anticipated impact of the general hospital's closure on access to health care services by members of the surrounding community, including but not limited to recipients of medical assistance for needy persons, the uninsured, and medically underserved populations as defined in paragraph (d) of subdivision one of section twenty-eight hundred two-b of this article, and options and proposals to ameliorate such anticipated impact. The commissioner shall afford community members, health care providers, labor unions, payers, businesses and consumers a reasonable opportunity to speak about relevant matters at such community forum.

[2.] (ii) No later than [sixty] thirty days [after] before holding a community forum pursuant to [subdivision one of this section] this paragraph, the commissioner shall make available to the public on the department's website information regarding:

[(a)] (A) the proposed closure plan submitted by the general hospital;

(B) the anticipated impact of the general hospital's closure on access to health care services by members of the surrounding community, including but not limited to recipients of medical assistance for needy persons, the uninsured, and underserved populations;

[(b)] (C) specific measures the department and other parties have taken or will take to ameliorate such anticipated impact including but not limited to ensuring that the services to be eliminated would be available to Medicaid, or individuals that are insured by a publiclysubsidized plan and uninsured patients at the surrounding area facilities that are taking new patients; and

[(c)] (D) any further recommendations regarding access to health care services in communities impacted by the general hospital's closure.

[3.] (iii) A community forum conducted pursuant to this section shall be held at a location within a reasonable proximity to the general hospital or unit subject to the proposed closure, and shall be announced no less than [ten] fourteen days prior to the date of such community forum. Such forum shall be held at a proper time and be accessible to the impacted community virtually and physically.

[4. At least thirty days prior to a general hospital applying to the federal centers for medicare and medicaid services to convert from a general hospital with inpatients to a rural emergency hospital under 42 USC 1395x(kkk), or successor provisions, such hospital shall hold a public community forum for the purpose of obtaining public input concerning the anticipated impact of the hospital's closure of inpatient units, including but not limited to, the impact on recipients of medical assistance for needy persons, the uninsured, people with disabilities, and medically underserved populations, and options and proposals to ameliorate such anticipated impact.

The] (iv) No later than thirty days prior to a community forum under this section, the general hospital shall notify health care providers, labor unions, the [congressional] local, state, and federal legislative representative, the office of the attorney general, the county executive, mayor, town supervisor, and in the case of the city of New York, the borough president, and community board for [the] every district in which the [facility] general hospital is located, [the county executive of the county in which the facility is located, and the state senator and assembly member representing the area within which the facility is located] of the date, time, and location of the community forum. The general hospital shall afford all public participants a reasonable opportunity to speak about relevant matters at such community forum. Prior to [any] a community forum and as soon as practicable, the general hospital shall be required to:

[(a)] (A) notify the office of mental health and the local director of community services in the event such general hospital has psychiatric inpatient beds licensed under article thirty-one of the mental hygiene law or designated pursuant to section 9.39 of the mental hygiene law, and

[(b)] (B) notify the office of addiction services and supports in the event such general hospital has inpatient substance use disorder treatment programs or inpatient chemical dependence treatment programs licensed under article thirty-two of the mental hygiene law. The commissioner shall also accept comments submitted in writing at such public forum and by mail or electronic mail within at least two weeks following the community forum.

(v) The commissioner shall also accept comments submitted in writing at such public forum and by mail or electronic mail within at least two weeks following the community forum.

(d) Revised closure plan. No later than thirty days after the community forum, the general hospital shall submit a revised closure plan to the department addressing concerns raised by community stakeholders during the community forum. The general hospital and the department shall make the revised closure plan publicly available on their websites no later than forty-five days after the community forum.

(e) Public health and health planning council review. No later than ninety days prior to the proposed closure, the public health and health planning council, or any successor entity, shall hold a public meeting before the council to review the application, including the health equity impact assessment and revised closure plan. Within two weeks after such meeting, the public health and health planning council shall make a recommendation to the commissioner for the commissioner's consideration.

3. Closure of a unit of a general hospital. (a)(i) Written notification of a proposed closure of a unit of a general hospital, as defined in subdivision one of this section, must be provided to the department and all parties listed in subparagraph (iv) of paragraph (c) of subdivision two of this section no later than two hundred ten days prior to the proposed closure date. Nothing in this section shall prohibit a general hospital from conferring with the department prior to submitting such written notification to give informal notice and seek guidance.

(ii) A reduction in services or closure of a unit in a general hospital shall not be required to undergo the process set forth in this section if the general hospital demonstrates to the department a good cause for such reduction or closure of a unit, which shall include one or more of the following:

(A) whether such closure or reduction is temporary in order to modernize a facility;

(B) whether such closure addresses the current health care demand, such as patient volume and the overall availability of services in the facility's health service area or county served;

(C) there are acute labor shortages outside of the control of the general hospital that impacts patient safety; or

(D) an acute financial emergency outside of the control of the general hospital.

(b) Application. A general hospital that seeks the closure of a unit shall submit an application to the department of health that requires review by the public health and health planning council, or any successor entity in addition to approval by the commissioner. The application for the closure shall include a health equity impact assessment, as defined by section twenty-eight hundred two-b of this article, and a proposed closure plan. The application shall be submitted at least one hundred fifty days before the proposed closure. No cessation, pause, transfer, or limitation of service may be carried out while the closure application is pending without prior written approval by the commissioner or the commissioner's designee, who shall take into consideration the impacts on quality of care and patient safety stemming from changes in patient volume or services. As used in this section, "transfer of services" shall include conversion of services from inpatient to outpatient services, the moving of services to other facilities, or the transfer of personnel that would constitute a reduction or unavailability of services.

(c) Community public forum. (i) No later than ninety days prior to the proposed closure of a unit of a general hospital, the commissioner shall hold a public community forum for the purpose of obtaining public input concerning the anticipated impact of the unit's closure on quality and access to health care services by members of the surrounding community, including but not limited to recipients of medical assistance for needy persons, the uninsured, and medically underserved populations as defined in paragraph (d) of subdivision one of section twenty-eight hundred two-b of this article, and options and proposals to ameliorate such anticipated impact. The commissioner shall afford community members, health care providers, labor unions, payers, businesses, and other participants a reasonable opportunity to speak about relevant matters at such community forum.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the public health law, in relation to providing public notice and public engagement when a general hospital seeks to close entirely or a unit that provides maternity, mental health or substance use care

Purpose or general of bill

Requires public notice and public engagement when a general hospital seeks to either close entirely or close a unit that provides emergency, maternity, mental health, or substance use care.

Summary of specific provisions

Section one names the act as the "Local Input in Community Healthcare Act"

Read the full memo (1,573 words)

Section two amends section 2801-g of the public health law (PHL) as it relates to a community forum on hospital closure, to set forth a process for closure of a general hospital or unit of a general hospital.

Subdivision 1 defines unit and reduction for purposes of this section.

Subdivision 2 is amended to set forth the process for the closure of a general hospital. General hospitals must provide written notification of proposed closure of a general hospital to the Department of Health (DOH) no later than 270 days before the proposed closure date, and allows hospitals to confer with DOH prior to giving written notice. The closure application will require review from the Public Health and Health Planning Council (PHHPC), which includes the health equity impact assessment. The application would be submitted at least 210 days before the proposed closure. No cessation, transfer, pause, or limitation of service may be carried out without prior written approval by the Commis- sioner of Health (COH).

*Paragraph (c) is added to extend the period that the COH is required to hold a public community forum to obtain public input concerning the anticipated impact of the hospital closure from no later than 30 days after to 150 days before the proposed closure. Additionally, requires the commissioner to make the following information publicly available no later than 30 days prior to a community forum: the proposed closure plan submitted by the health facility, the impact on access to health care services to the surrounding community and information on specific meas- ures DOH will take, and any other recommendations to address the impact of the closure on health care services, including but not limited to ensuring services being eliminated are still accessible to medicaid recipients or individuals insured by publicly subsidized plans, and uninsured residents in the surrounding facilities. The COH must announce the date and location the community forum on the proposed closure of a hospital 14 days prior, instead of 10 days prior, to be held and must ensure the forum is held at a proper time and accessible to the impacted community virtually and physically.

*Paragraphs (d)-(e) require hospitals to submit a revised plan address- ing community concerns no later than 30 days after the community forum and make it publicly available within 45 days after the forum. PHHPC must meet to review the application with the revised plan no later than 90 days after the forum and must make a recommendation to the commis- sioner within two weeks after meeting.

Subdivision 3 sets forth the process for unit reductions or closures that affect emergency, maternity, mental health, substance use, or any other licensed services in the operating certificate including specialty care. Requires written notification no later than 210 days prior and provides for exemptions from the required process for a reduction or closure of a unit. The community forum is required to be held no later than 90 days prior to the proposed closure date. At least 14 days before the forum, the hospital must notify the community stakeholders of the date and location of the forum and the COH must make the proposed closure plan publicly available.

*Paragraph (d)-(e) requires hospitals to submit a revised unit closure plan addressing community concerns no later than 30 days after the community forum and make it publicly available within 45 days after the forum. PHHPC must meet to review the application with the revised plan no later than 90 days after the forum and must make a recommendation to the commissioner within two weeks after meeting.

Subdivision 4 requires the COH to make a decision to either approve or deny a closure plan within 30 days following receipt of a PHHPC recom- mendation.

Former subdivision 4 is now new subdivision 5

Adds a new subdivision 6 requiring an annual report to the legislature by the DOH on a list of general hospitals or units of general hospitals that notify the department of their intent to close.

Adds a new subdivision 7 to require a hospital to submit a revised closure plan to DOH addressing concerns raised during the community forum no later than 30 days after the forum and requires DOH to make the revised plan publicly available on their website no later than 45 days after the community forum.

Section three provides an effective date.

Justification

Across New York State, there have been several incidents when hospitals summarily announce planned closures of maternity services, emergency departments, mental health, and substance use services, and even entire hospitals, without any prior communication or meaningful engagement with the local communities they serve. Over the last decade, 10 hospitals in New York State closed their maternity services (in Columbia, Franklin, Lewis, New York, Niagara, Ontario, Otsego, St. Lawrence, and Wyoming counties). So far in 2024, two more maternity service closures are pend- ing in Rensselaer and Suffolk counties. Two major closings of entire hospitals are under consideration and facing community opposition in lower Manhattan and in Central Brooklyn, after last year's closures of another Brooklyn hospital and a hospital in Eastern Niagara County. More closures are likely; a recent study by the Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform found that there are 27 rural hospitals in New York

State at risk of closing, amounting to 53 percent of all rural hospitals in the state.

(source:https://r.,.beckershospitaireview.com/financei646-hospitals-at-ri sk-of-closure-ranked-by-state.html)

Closures of any of these services, or of the entire hospital, can have a devastating impact on the communities that have depended on these facil- ities for care. When the COVID-19 pandemic hit New York City in early 2020, one of the boroughs most affected (Queens) was ill-prepared because of hospital closings in that borough. Elmhurst Hospital, a public hospital, was forced to shoulder more than its fair share of COVID-19 cases because of the closures of St. John's Queens Hospital, Mary Immaculate Hospital, and Parkway Hospital in 2009.

(source:https://gns.com/2020/03/demise-of-three- gueens-hosoitals-11-years-ago-adds-to- pain-ofboroughs- coronae irus- tragedies/)

Closures of hospital maternity services are leaving entire counties without any nearby access to labor and delivery, causing pregnant patients to have to travel long distances to the nearest hospital with maternal health services. The proposed closure of the Burdett Birth Center in Troy, for example, would leave Rensselaer County as the larg- est county in the state without maternity care, and also affect pregnant people in adjacent rural Washington and Columbia counties, which lack their own maternity services. The March of Dimes warns that the further a pregnant person has to travel to obtain maternity care, the greater the chances that there will be a negative outcome. There is a higher risk for complications and death for both mothers and babies in communi- ties that do not have maternity care services, according to the Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform.

Closures of hospital psychiatric services were numerous during the pandemic, with more than two dozen hospitals closing more than 500 psychiatric beds. The Hochul administration has been working to bring those back into service, citing a severe shortage of short-term beds for patients suffering psychiatric crises.

(Source: https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/1 2/nyregiortihospita;s-hochul-rnental-he th.html)

Despite the serious impact of such closures on communities, especially those where people are already medically-underserved and not easily able to travel elsewhere for care, New York State Public Health Law does not adequately require hospitals to engage the public and work to address their concerns. Too little (if any) advance notice is given to the community and key stakeholders, and under the law, a public hearing is not required until 30 days after a hospital closes

(although recent state Department of Health guidance to hospitals has required an advance hearing).

While the states new Health Equity Impact Assessment law is helping to improve community engagement, it does not apply to closings of entire hospitals because those are carried out through simple notice to the Department and a closure plan, not a Certificate of Need application. Moreover, none of these types of closures (the entire hospital, or maternity, emergency or mental health services) requires a full Certif- icate of Need review process that would go before the state Public Health and Health Planning Council for review in a public meeting at which community members could make comments.

This proposed legislation will address these gaps in the state's review of proposed hospital and hospital unit closures by ensuring adequate advance notice to the public, public disclosure of hospital closing plans, a community forum held well in advance of the closure date to allow public comment on the proposed closure plan, and preparation of a final closure plan that addresses concerns raised at the community forum.

Prior legislative story

New bill.

Fiscal implicat

None.

Effective date

Effective on the sixtieth day after it shall have become law, and shall not apply to any matter subject to section 2801-g of the PHL that is pending on the date it shall take effect.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.