Skip to content
S9110Senate2023-2024 Session

Change Criminal Appeal Rules

Official title

“Relates to the determination of appeals in criminal proceedings”

Sponsor Andrew GounardesSD-26Affects Legal
Status
In Senate Committee
Codes
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Codes

What's happening

This bill changes how appellate courts handle errors in criminal cases, expands review for certain errors, and requires demographic reporting on affected appellants.

Why it matters

  1. Shifts the burden in appeals. By requiring the party claiming an error was harmless to prove it “beyond a reasonable doubt,” this bill makes it harder for the government to dismiss appellate challenges based on procedural errors, potentially leading to more convictions being overturned or retried.

  2. Broadens review of unpreserved errors. Appellate courts must now review errors not raised at trial if related to ineffective assistance of counsel or if the error may have influenced the jury’s verdict, increasing the likelihood that overlooked mistakes or inadequate defense representation can be addressed on appeal.

  3. Mandates demographic data collection and transparency. By requiring courts to record and publicly report the race, ethnicity, national origin, age, and gender identity of appellants affected by technical-error rulings, the bill creates a new tool for tracking and exposing possible patterns of bias or disparate impact in appellate decisions.

  4. Applies immediately and retroactively to pending cases. The changes take effect right away and apply to both new and already pending appeals, meaning that current appellants could benefit from these expanded protections and reporting requirements.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Change Criminal Appeal Rules

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Andrew Gounardes

Senator · Senate District 26

Chair, Budget And Revenue

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to codes

Full text

2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9110

IN SENATE

April 26, 2024

Introduced by Sen. GOUNARDES -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Codes

AN ACT to amend the criminal procedure law and the judiciary law, in relation to determination of appeals

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subdivision 1 of section 470.05 of the criminal procedure law is amended to read as follows:

1. (a) An appellate court must determine an appeal without regard to technical errors or defects which do not affect the substantial rights of the parties.

(b) When an appellate court considers errors which require a showing of harm to the proceedings, the burden is on the party claiming harmlessness to show that the error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt.

§ 2. Section 470.15 of the criminal procedure law is amended by adding two new subdivisions 7 and 8 to read as follows:

7. The court shall consider all errors or defects in the interest of justice, even if they were not duly protested at trial as prescribed in subdivision two of section 470.05 of this article so as to present a question of law, where a defendant asserts that such failure to protest is the result of ineffective assistance of counsel or where an error or defect may have contributed to a jury verdict.

8. Where an appellate court considers an error or defect and deems it to be technical and not affecting the substantial rights of the parties as provided in subdivision one of section 470.05 of this article, it shall record the race, ethnicity, national origin, age, and gender identity of the appellant. Such information shall then be included in the annual report submitted to the legislature and governor pursuant to paragraph (j) of subdivision one of section two hundred twelve of the judiciary law, in a manner consistent with the provisions of paragraph (ff) of subdivision two of such section.

§ 3. Subdivision 2 of section 212 of the judiciary law is amended by adding a new paragraph (ff) to read as follows:

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD15027-02-4

(ff) The chief administrator shall include the information required to be recorded in subdivision eight of section 470.15 of the criminal procedure law, both across all appellate courts and disaggregated by county, in the annual report submitted to the legislature and the governor pursuant to paragraph (j) of subdivision one of this section. The chief administrator shall also make such information available to the public by posting it on the website of the office of court administration and shall update such information on a yearly basis. The information shall be posted in alphanumeric form that can be digitally transmitted or processed and not in portable document format or scanned copies of original documents.

§ 4. This act shall take effect immediately and shall apply to all appeals pending as of such effective date and to all appeals filed on and after such date.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the criminal procedure law and the judiciary law, in relation to determination of appeals

Purpose or general idea of bill

To improve and reform New York's harmless error and preservation doctrines for appellants

Summary of provisions

Section one of this bill amends subdivision one of section 470.05 of the Criminal Procedure Law to add a new paragraph (b) to provide that when a party claims a harmful error in an appellate proceeding, the burden is on the party claiming harmlessness to show that such error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt, aligning New York's statute with the federal standard for constitutional errors created in Chapman v. California, 507 U.S. 619 (1967).

Read the full memo (1,118 words)

Section two of this bill adds two new subdivisions to section 470.15 of Criminal Procedure Law to reform the standards for preservation of errors by allowing appellate courts to review unpreserved errors where the lack of preservation may be due to ineffective assistance of counsel or where the error may have substantially contributed to a jury verdict. This language expands upon the existing exceptions to the preservation rule prescribed in CPL § 470.15(3) and (6), which allow judges to review unpreserved errors if they deprived the defendant of a fair trial or if a sentence is unduly harsh or severe.

Courts would also be required in this section to record the race, ethnicity, national origin, age, and gender identity of appellants in all cases where they deem errors to be harmless, not affecting the substantial rights of the parties. This information would then be included in the annual report that the Chief Administrative Judge compiles on the Unified Court System (UCS) pursuant to paragraph (j) of subdivision one of section 212 of Judiciary Law and published online in an accessible format on the Office of Court Administration (OCA)'s website.

Section four of this bill sets the effective date.

Justification

This bill would reform New York's preservation and harmless error doctrines to ensure that miscarriages of justice occurring in the crimi- nal trial courts are rectified on appeal without appellate courts resorting to procedural mechanisms to avoid curing injustices.

"Harmless error" refers to an error by a trial judge over the course of a trial that an appellate court finds was not damaging enough to the appealing party to justify reversing a judgment or warranting a new trial. Implicit in this doctrine is the recognition that a defendant is entitled to a fair trial but not a perfect trial. "Preservation" occurs when a party complains of a potential error at trial, so that the appeals court will later examine it to determine whether it is harmful or harmless. New York's rules for preservation are notoriously exacting, far stricter than the standard for federal cases articulated in the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure (FRCP), Rule 52(b), which allow federal courts of appeals to review any "plain error that affects substantial rights even though it was not brought to the court's atten- tion." In the New York court system, however, courts may only examine unpreserved issues "(a)s a matter of discretion in the interest of justice" (CPL § 470.15(3)(c)) if the "error or defect...deprived the defendant of a fair trial" (CPL § 470.15(6)(a)). In practice, however, courts rarely if ever exercise this "interest of justice" discretion, declining to review any potential unpreserved errors unless they are particularly egregious.

The extreme rigor with which New York courts have applied the preserva- tion and harmful error doctrines has had an incredibly disparate impact on criminal cases across racial and socioeconomic lines. This is because, while in theory both sides of a criminal trial have equal access to these appellate tools, in reality many indigent defendants in criminal trials are assigned public defenders with overwhelming case- loads and an inability to prepare for trial as thoroughly as white-shoe law firms representing wealthier defendants. The latter attorneys meti- culously preserve issues for appellate review in a way that is simply impossible for indigent defense attorneys such as legal aid service providers or counsels assigned under 18-B of County Law.

For the relatively few indigent defendants who can afford trial and then proceed to the appeals process, judges then tend to be far more exacting in their determination of what kind of errors are harmful versus harm- less in cases involving wealthy defendants. Some real-life examples of appellate courts deeming errors harmless in blue-collar criminal cases include a failure to instruct the jury that cross-racial identification in eyewitness testimony is unreliable, or the exclusion of a defense expert who would have testified to problems with a prosecutor's ballis- tic evidence.

In stark contrast, in one case involving a bond trader who had committed securities fraud to his clients, the defendant trader received an entirely new trial after an appellate judge found the exclusion of an investment expert who would have said that making false statements to investors is a normal part of business harmful, despite the investors themselves testifying that the defendant trader's misrepresentations were significant and material. And while the Court of Appeals will frequently reverse the harmful error designations of lower appellate courts, they take only one to two percent of the cases that seek leave.

This bill aims to reform New York's preservation and harmless error doctrines in recognition of their stark racial and socioeconomic impact. It would change New York's standard for harmless errors in Criminal Procedure Law § 470.05(1) that the court considers "technical" and "not affect(ing) the substantial rights of the parties" with the federal standard for constitutional errors created in Chapman v. California, 507 U.S. 619 (1967), which requires the party claiming harmlessness to prove that the error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. It would also allow more appellate courts to review errors on their merits, regardless of whether or not they were preserved, to better capture the legisla- ture's original intent of the "interest of justice" safety valve created in CPL § 470.15(3)(c). Finally, it would add a measure of transparency to the appellate court system by requiring courts to include demographic data on cases where errors are deemed harmless in the annual report they are already required to produce under Section 212 of Judiciary Law.

These reforms will ensure a more even distribution of justice in an inherently unjust system while providing policymakers key insight into the impact and use of one of the most critical yet overlooked tools available to criminal defendants on trial.

Prior legislative history

None

Fiscal implications

TBD

Effective date

This act shall take effect immediately and shall apply to all appeals pending as of the effective date as well as all appeals filed on or after such date.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.