Skip to content
S9198Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA10131

Easier to Overturn Convictions

Official title

“Relates to motions to vacate judgment; repealer”

Sponsor Zellnor MyrieSD-20+6 co-sponsorsAffects Legal
Status
In Assembly Committee
Codes
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 5 of 7

In Assembly · Codes

What's happening

This bill expands and clarifies procedures for vacating criminal convictions in New York, especially for offenses later decriminalized or found unconstitutional, and requires annual public reporting on such motions.

Why it matters

  1. Makes it easier to clear old convictions for acts that are no longer crimes. The bill explicitly allows people to vacate convictions for offenses that have since been decriminalized or declared unconstitutional, recognizing that keeping these convictions serves no legitimate purpose and can harm individuals’ lives.

  2. Strengthens and clarifies the process for post-conviction relief. The bill expands the types of evidence and legal grounds that can be used to challenge a conviction, including new or repudiated forensic evidence, actual innocence, and cases where a conviction was fundamentally unfair due to trafficking or other constitutional violations.

  3. Improves fairness and access to legal help. The bill requires assignment of counsel for those with a plausible claim, mandates broader discovery from prosecutors and defense counsel, and ensures that lack of resources or legal knowledge isn’t a barrier to seeking justice.

  4. Increases transparency and accountability. By requiring annual, publicly available reports on the number, outcome, and timeliness of vacatur motions in each county, the bill gives the public and policymakers insight into how the justice system handles wrongful convictions and post-conviction relief.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Easier to Overturn Convictions

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Zellnor Myrie

Senator · Senate District 20

Chair, Elections

History

  1. Referred to codes
  2. Delivered to assembly
  3. Passed senateVote 41–19
  4. Ordered to third reading cal.1658
  5. Committee discharged and committed to rules
  6. Reported and committed to finance
  7. Referred to codes

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A10131Assembly

Make Erasing Old Convictions Easier

Assembly Floor Calendar · Sponsor Jeffrion Aubry

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

12 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9198

IN SENATE

May 3, 2024

Introduced by Sen. MYRIE -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Codes

AN ACT to amend the criminal procedure law and the judiciary law, in relation to motions to vacate judgment; and to repeal certain provisions of the criminal procedure law relating thereto

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. The criminal procedure law is amended by adding two new sections 440.00 and 440.11 to read as follows: § 440.00 Definition.

As used in this article, the term "applicant" means a person previously convicted of a crime who is applying for relief under this article. § 440.11 Motion to vacate judgment; change in the law.

1. At any time after the entry of a judgment obtained at trial or by plea, the court in which it was entered may, upon motion of the applicant, vacate such conviction upon the ground that the applicant was convicted of any offense in the state of New York which has been subsequently decriminalized and is thus a legal nullity.

2. If the court grants a motion under this section, it shall vacate the conviction on the merits, dismiss the accusatory instrument, seal the conviction, and may take such additional action as is appropriate in the circumstances.

§ 2. Section 440.10 of the criminal procedure law, paragraph (g-1) of subdivision 1 as added by chapter 19 of the laws of 2012, paragraph (h) of subdivision 1, paragraph (a) of subdivision 3 and subdivision 4 as amended and subdivisions 7 and 8 as renumbered by chapter 332 of the laws of 2010, paragraph (i) of subdivision 1 and subdivision 6 as amended by chapter 629 of the laws of 2021, paragraph (j) of subdivision 1 as amended by chapter 131 of the laws of 2019, paragraph (k) of subdivision 1 as amended by chapter 92 of the laws of 2021, paragraphs (b) and (c) of subdivision 2 as amended by chapter 501 of the laws of 2021, and subdivision 9 as added by section 4 of part OO of chapter 55 of the laws of 2019, is amended to read as follows: § 440.10 Motion to vacate judgment.

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD00806-06-4

1. At any time after the entry of a judgment obtained at trial or by plea, the court in which it was entered may, upon motion of the [defendant] applicant, vacate such judgment upon the ground that:

(a) The court did not have jurisdiction of the action or of the person of the [defendant] applicant; or

(b) The judgment was procured by duress, misrepresentation or fraud on the part of the court or a prosecutor or a person acting for or in behalf of a court or a prosecutor; or

(c) [Material evidence adduced at a trial] Evidence that was likely relied upon by a fact finder resulting in the judgment at trial or that was likely relied upon by any party as a basis for a plea agreement was false [and was, prior to the entry of the judgment, known by the prosecutor or by the court to be false]; or

(d) [Material evidence adduced by the people at a trial] Evidence that was likely relied upon by a fact finder resulting in the judgment at trial or that was likely relied upon by any party as a basis for a plea agreement was procured in violation of the [defendant's] applicant's rights under the constitution of this state or of the United States; or

(e) During the proceedings resulting in the judgment, the [defendant] applicant, by reason of mental disease or defect, was incapable of understanding or participating in such proceedings; or

(f) Improper [and prejudicial] conduct not appearing in the record occurred during a trial resulting in the judgment which conduct, if it had appeared in the record, would have [required] made possible a reversal of the judgment upon an appeal therefrom; or

(g) New evidence has been discovered [since the entry of a judgment based upon a verdict of guilty after trial, which could not have been produced by the defendant at the trial even with due diligence on his part and which] or become available that, when viewed alone or with other evidence, is of such character as to create a reasonable probability that had such evidence been received at the trial or discovered prior to trial or plea agreement that the verdict or plea would have been more favorable to the [defendant; provided that a motion based upon such ground must be made with due diligence after the discovery of such alleged new evidence] applicant. Types of new evidence shall include, but not be limited to newly available forensic evidence or evidence that has either been repudiated by the expert who originally provided the opinion at a hearing or trial or that has been undermined by later scientific research or technological advances; or

(g-1) [Forensic DNA] In cases involving the forensic testing of evidence performed since the entry of a judgment, [(1) in the case of a defendant convicted after a guilty plea, the court has determined that the defendant has demonstrated a substantial probability that the defendant was actually innocent of the offense of which he or she was convicted, or (2) in the case of a defendant convicted after a trial,] the court has determined that there exists a reasonable probability that the verdict or plea offer would have been more favorable to the [defendant] applicant, or the applicant would have rejected the plea offer.

(h) The judgment was obtained in violation of a right of the [defendant] applicant under the constitution of this state or of the United States, including, but not limited to, a judgment entered, whether upon trial or guilty plea, against an applicant who is actually innocent. An applicant is actually innocent where the applicant proves by a preponderance of the evidence that no reasonable jury of the applicant's peers would have found the applicant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt; or

(i) The judgment is a conviction where the [defendant's] applicant's participation in the offense was a result of having been a victim of sex trafficking under section 230.34 of the penal law, sex trafficking of a child under section 230.34-a of the penal law, labor trafficking under section 135.35 of the penal law, aggravated labor trafficking under section 135.37 of the penal law, compelling prostitution under section 230.33 of the penal law, or trafficking in persons under the Trafficking Victims Protection Act (United States Code, title 22, chapter 78); provided that

(i) official documentation of the [defendant's] applicant's status as a victim of sex trafficking, labor trafficking, aggravated labor trafficking, compelling prostitution, or trafficking in persons at the time of the offense from a federal, state or local government agency shall create a presumption that the [defendant's] applicant's participation in the offense was a result of having been a victim of sex trafficking, labor trafficking, aggravated labor trafficking, compelling prostitution or trafficking in persons, but shall not be required for granting a motion under this paragraph;

(ii) a motion under this paragraph, and all pertinent papers and documents, shall be confidential and may not be made available to any person or public or private [entity] agency except [where] when specifically authorized by the court; and

(iii) when a motion is filed under this paragraph, the court may, upon the consent of the petitioner and all of the involved state [and] or local prosecutorial agencies [that prosecuted each matter], consolidate into one proceeding a motion to vacate judgments imposed by distinct or multiple criminal courts; or

(j) The judgment is a conviction for [a class A or unclassified] any misdemeanor entered prior to the effective date of this paragraph and satisfies the ground prescribed in paragraph (h) of this subdivision. There shall be a rebuttable presumption that a conviction by plea to such an offense was not knowing, voluntary and intelligent, based on ongoing collateral consequences, including potential or actual immigration consequences, and there shall be a rebuttable presumption that a conviction by verdict constitutes cruel and unusual punishment under section five of article one of the state constitution based on such consequences; or

(k) The judgment occurred prior to the effective date of the laws of two thousand [twenty-one] twenty-three that amended this paragraph and is a conviction for an offense as defined in [subparagraphs] subparagraph (i), (ii), (iii) or (iv) of paragraph (k) of subdivision three of section 160.50 of this part, or a misdemeanor under the former article two hundred twenty-one of the penal law, in which case the court shall presume that a conviction by plea for the aforementioned offenses was not knowing, voluntary and intelligent if it has severe or ongoing consequences, including but not limited to potential or actual immigration consequences, and shall presume that a conviction by verdict for the aforementioned offenses constitutes cruel and unusual punishment under section five of article one of the state constitution, based on those consequences. The people may rebut these presumptions[.]; or

(l) Any offense in the state of New York that an intermediate appellate court, court of appeals, or United States federal court with jurisdiction over New York state law issues has deemed in violation of the constitution of this state or of the United States, or any other right under state or federal law.

2. Notwithstanding the provisions of subdivision one, the court [must] may deny a motion to vacate a judgment when:

(a) The ground or issue raised upon the motion was previously determined on the merits upon an appeal from the judgment, unless since the time of such appellate determination there has been a retroactively effective change in the law controlling such issue. However, if all of the evidence currently before the court was not duly considered previously by the court, the court shall grant the motion or order the hearing; or

(b) The judgment is, at the time of the motion, appealable or pending on appeal, and sufficient facts appear on the record with respect to the ground or issue raised upon the motion to permit adequate review thereof upon such an appeal unless the issue raised upon such motion is ineffective assistance of counsel. This paragraph shall not apply to a motion under paragraph (i), (j), (k) or (l) of subdivision one of this section; or

(c) [Although sufficient facts appear on the record of the proceedings underlying the judgment to have permitted, upon appeal from such judgment, adequate review of the ground or issue raised upon the motion, no such appellate review or determination occurred owing to the defendant's unjustifiable failure to take or perfect an appeal during the prescribed period or to his or her unjustifiable failure to raise such ground or issue upon an appeal actually perfected by him or her unless the issue raised upon such motion is ineffective assistance of counsel; or

(d)] The ground or issue raised relates solely to the validity of the sentence and not to the validity of the conviction. In such case, the court shall deem the motion to have been made pursuant to section 440.20 of this article.

[3. Notwithstanding the provisions of subdivision one, the court may deny a motion to vacate a judgment when:

(a) Although facts in support of the ground or issue raised upon the motion could with due diligence by the defendant have readily been made to appear on the record in a manner providing adequate basis for review of such ground or issue upon an appeal from the judgment, the defendant unjustifiably failed to adduce such matter prior to sentence and the ground or issue in question was not subsequently determined upon appeal. This paragraph does not apply to a motion based upon deprivation of the right to counsel at the trial or upon failure of the trial court to advise the defendant of such right, or to a motion under paragraph (i) of subdivision one of this section; or

(b) The ground or issue raised upon the motion was previously determined on the merits upon a prior motion or proceeding in a court of this state, other than an appeal from the judgment, or upon a motion or proceeding in a federal court; unless since the time of such determination there has been a retroactively effective change in the law controlling such issue; or

(c) Upon a previous motion made pursuant to this section, the defendant was in a position adequately to raise the ground or issue underlying the present motion but did not do so.]

(d) Although the court may deny the motion under any of the circumstances specified in this subdivision, in the interest of justice and for good cause shown it may in its discretion grant the motion if it is otherwise meritorious and vacate the judgment.

[4.] 3. If the court grants the motion, it must, except as provided in subdivision [five] four or [six] five of this section, vacate the judgment, and must either:

(a) dismiss and seal the accusatory instrument, or

(b) order a new trial, or

(c) take such other action as is appropriate in the circumstances.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the criminal procedure law and the judiciary law, in relation to motions to vacate judgment; and to repeal certain provisions of the criminal procedure law relating thereto

Summary of specific provisions

Section 1 adds sections 440.00 to the Criminal Procedure Law, which defines the term "applicant" as a person previously convicted of a crime who is applying for relief under this article. Section 1 also adds section 440.11 to the Criminal Procedure Law, which provides specific grounds for vacating a judgment due to decriminalization of the appli- cant's act that led to his or her conviction, or a change in a law applied in the process leading to the applicant's conviction that calls for retroactive application of the new legal standard. If a court grants a motion under this section, it must vacate the judgment on the merits, dismiss the accusatory instrument, seal the judgment, and take addi- tional appropriate action as needed.

Section 2 amends multiple subdivisions of section 440.10 of the Criminal Procedure Law.

Read the full memo (754 words)

Section 3 amends multiple subdivisions of section 440.20 of the Criminal Procedure Law.

Section 4 amends multiple subdivisions of section 440.30 of the Criminal Procedure Law.

Section 5 amends multiple subdivisions of section 450.10 of the Criminal Procedure Law.

Section 6 repeals subdivision 5 of section 450.10 of the Criminal Proce- dure Law.

Section 7 adds a new subdivision 7 in section 216 of the Judiciary Law, which requires the chief administrator of the court to report annually on the number of post-conviction applications and motions filed annually in each county and appellate department in the state and to post the aggregated data on the websites of the office of court administration and the division of criminal justice services.

Section 8 creates a severability clause.

Section 9 provides the effective date.

Justification

New York State is 3rd in the nation for highest number of wrongful convictions. New York also plea bargains 98% of felony cases. Yet, indi- viduals who plead guilty in exchange for a lesser sentence are the least likely to be exonerated due to enormous structural barriers. These people are often under tremendous pressure to plead guilty when bail is unaffordable, or the pre-trial process is prolonged for a substantial period. Post-conviction review processes are necessary in both cases that went to trial and those that ended in a plea deal. This bill amends section 440 of the Criminal Procedure Law governing post-judgement motions by removing procedural barriers and further ensuring meaningful review is performed. In short, if there is evidence of a person's inno- cence, courts will now have a legal mechanism to review the case and vacate the conviction where appropriate.

In the 2018 case of People v. Tiger, the New York Court of Appeals ruled that individuals who plead guilty cannot challenge their convictions unless they have DNA evidence to support their innocence. This bill not only requires courts to.order hearings in cases with colorable claims of innocence, but also allows for admission of various types of evidence to support such claims. The convicted will also be entitled to retain defense counsel for post-conviction relief, have the court appoint pro- bono representation if the applicant cannot afford an attorney, request re-testing of physical evidence and access both the defense and prose- cution's discovery files. The bill further expands protections for people exposed to significant collateral consequences from their convictions.

Although the New York State legislature has taken some steps to reform the pre-trial process, there are still numerous individuals who obtained criminal records in years prior as a result of plainly unfair and coer- cive tactics. This bill also brings New York law in line with five other states and the District of Columbia that have mechanisms for people to clear old convictions for crimes that have subsequently been decriminal- ized.

Finally, throughout this bill, the term defendant is replaced with applicant in an effort to humanize those seeking redress under the Crim- inal Procedure Law of New York. For more details on the importance of using people-first language refer to: http://prisonstudiesproject.org/language/.

New York State must act to right past wrongs and allow people wrongfully or improperly convicted in previous decades to clear their names and their records. This requires a fundamental overhaul of our state's post- judgment process.

Prior legislative history

S266A of 2021-22: Referred to Codes

S7255 of 2019-20: Referred to Codes

Fiscal implications

To be determined

Effective date

The sixtieth day after it shall have become a law.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.