Skip to content
S9339Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA10346

Let Utilities Issue Recovery Bonds

Official title

“Enacts the "New York utility corporation securitization act"”

Sponsor Leroy ComrieSD-14+3 co-sponsorsAffects Finance
Status
Signed by Governor
Impact
8/10
Significant
Outcome
Signed into law

Bill progress

Signed into law

What's happening

This bill creates the New York Utility Corporation Securitization Act to allow electric utilities to issue bonds for storm recovery costs, subject to Public Service Commission approval.

Why it matters

  1. Shifts Utility Storm Recovery Costs Away from Traditional Rate Increases. By allowing utilities to issue bonds for storm recovery instead of directly raising rates, the bill aims to spread out the financial burden on consumers over a longer period, potentially lowering immediate rate hikes after major storms.

  2. Consumer Protection and Oversight Mechanisms. The Public Service Commission (PSC) must approve all bond issuances and ensure they provide a net benefit to consumers compared to traditional financing. The PSC also requires annual true-ups to adjust charges, minimizing the risk of utilities over-collecting from customers.

  3. Legal and Financial Certainty for Investors. The legislation creates a legally protected property right in the recovery charges, which are non-bypassable (all current and future customers must pay). This security is meant to improve bond marketability, potentially lowering financing costs, while also insulating the bonds from utility bankruptcy risks.

  4. Limited Scope and Eligibility. Only electric utilities or their subsidiaries with storm-related costs of $500 million or more as of July 1, 2024, are eligible, focusing the mechanism on large, potentially catastrophic events and the largest utility operators, rather than routine maintenance or smaller companies.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Electric utility corporations

    Utilities with at least $500 million in storm recovery costs, individually or collectively as subsidiaries of the same corporation, could seek approval to finance eligible costs through recovery bonds maturing within 20 years.

  • Residential and business electricity customers

    Customers in participating utilities’ service areas would pay non-bypassable recovery charges, adjusted at least annually, under financing orders required to provide quantifiable consumer benefits over traditional financing.

  • Public Service Commission

    The commission would review financing petitions, determine eligible costs and consumer benefits, and establish recovery charges and adjustment mechanisms.

  • Recovery bond investors

    Bondholders would receive protections backed by dedicated recovery charges and a state pledge against impairing those charges, but the bonds would not carry the state’s full faith and credit.

Headline styles

Let Utilities Issue Recovery Bonds

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Leroy Comrie

Senator · Senate District 14

Chair, Corporations, Authorities And Commissions

History

  1. Signed chap.224
  2. Delivered to governor
  3. Returned to senate
  4. Passed assembly
  5. Ordered to third reading rules cal.546
  6. Substituted for A10346A
  7. Referred to ways and means
  8. Delivered to assembly
  9. Passed senateVote 61–0
  10. Ordered to third reading cal.1863
  11. Committee discharged and committed to rules
  12. Print number 9339a
Show 2 earlier actions
  1. Amend (t) and recommit to energy and telecommunications
  2. Referred to energy and telecommunications

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A10346Assembly

Let Utilities Issue Recovery Bonds

Assembly Floor Calendar · Sponsor Amy Paulin

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

15 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9339--A

IN SENATE

May 13, 2024

Introduced by Sens. COMRIE, HARCKHAM -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Energy and Telecommunications -- committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee

AN ACT to enact the "New York utility corporation securitization act"

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Short title. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "New York utility corporation securitization act".

§ 2. Definitions. As used in this act, the following terms shall have the following meanings:

1. "Ancillary agreement" means any bond, insurance policy, letter of credit, reserve account, surety bond, swap arrangement, hedging arrangement, liquidity or credit support arrangement or other similar agreement or arrangement entered into in connection with the issuance of recovery bonds under this act, that is designed to promote the credit quality and marketability of such recovery bonds or to mitigate the risk of an increase in interest rates.

2. "Assignee" means any individual, corporation, limited liability company, partnership or limited partnership, trust or other legally recognized entity to which an interest in recovery property is created, recognized, assigned, sold or transferred, other than as security, including any assignee of such property.

3. "Commission" means the public service commission.

4. "Consumer" means any individual, governmental body, trust, business entity, nonprofit organization or other legally recognized entity that takes electric delivery service within the service area by means of electric transmission or distribution facilities, whether those electric transmission or distribution facilities are owned by a utility corporation or other entity.

5. "Financing costs" means:

(a) interest and acquisition, defeasance, or redemption premiums that are payable on recovery bonds;

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD05310-06-4

(b) any payment approved in the financing order and required under an ancillary agreement or other accounts established under the terms of any indenture, ancillary agreement, or other financing documents pertaining to recovery bonds;

(c) provided that recovery bonds shall be the only method used to recover the costs identified in this paragraph, any other cost related to issuing, supporting, repaying, and servicing recovery bonds, including but not limited to servicing fees, accounting and auditing fees, trustee fees, legal fees, consulting fees, administrative fees, placement and underwriting fees, capitalized interest, rating agency fees, stock exchange listing and compliance fees, and filing fees, including costs related to obtaining a financing order; or

(d) any federal, state or local taxes, payments in lieu of taxes, franchise fees or license fees imposed on recovery charge revenues.

6. "Financing order" means an order of the commission which authorizes:

(a) the issuance of recovery bonds;

(b) the imposition, collection, and periodic adjustments of recovery charges;

(c) the creation or recognition of recovery property; and/or

(d) the sale, assignment, or transfer of recovery property to an assignee.

7. "Financing party" means any holder of recovery bonds and any trustee, collateral agent, or other person acting for the benefit of holders of recovery bonds.

8. "Financing statement" shall have the same meaning as that provided in paragraph 39 of subsection (a) of section 9-102 the uniform commercial code. All financing statements under this act shall be filed in accordance with section 9-501 of the uniform commercial code.

9. "Lien creditor" shall have the same meaning as that provided in paragraph 52 of subsection (a) of section 9-102 of the uniform commercial code.

10. "Recovery bonds" means bonds, debentures, notes, certificates of participation, certificates of ownership, or other evidences of indebtedness or ownership that are issued pursuant to an indenture, contract, or other agreement of a utility corporation or its assignee pursuant to a financing order, the proceeds of which are used directly or indirectly to provide, recover, finance, or refinance commission-approved recovery costs and financing costs, to such level as the commission may authorize in a financing order, and which are secured by or payable from recovery property, and that have a final maturity date of no longer than twenty years from the original issuance. If certificates of participation or ownership are issued, references in this act to principal, interest, or premium shall be construed to refer to comparable amounts under such certificates. Recovery bonds shall be nonrecourse to the credit or any assets of the utility corporation other than the recovery property as specified in the financing order and any rights under any ancillary agreement. Recovery bonds shall be legal investments for financial institutions, insurance companies, fiduciaries, and other persons that require statutory authority regarding legal investment.

11. "Recovery charge" means the amounts authorized by the commission to recover recovery costs and financing costs. If provided for in a financing order, such amounts shall be imposed on consumer bills and collected by a utility corporation or its successors or assignees or a collection agent, in full, through a charge paid by existing and future consumers receiving transmission or distribution service, or both, from the utility corporation or its successors or assignees under rate schedules or special contracts approved by the commission. The recovery charge shall be non-bypassable and imposed on all consumers in the service area and collected by the utility corporation or its successor, agent, subcontractor, assignee, or collection agent or any other entity designated under the financing order.

12. "Recovery costs" means storm recovery costs identified for recovery in a financing order.

13. "Recovery property" (a) means the property rights and interests created pursuant to this act, including but not limited to any and all right, title, and interest:

(i) in and to recovery charges established pursuant to a financing order, as approved by the commission and adjusted from time to time in accordance with such financing order;

(ii) in and to all revenues, collections, claims, payments, money, or proceeds of or arising from the recovery charges or constituting recovery charges that are the subject of a financing order, regardless of whether such revenues, collections, claims, payments, money, or proceeds are imposed, billed, received, collected, or maintained together with or commingled with other revenues, collections, claims, payments, money, or proceeds; and

(iii) in and to all rights to obtain periodic adjustments to the recovery charges pursuant to the terms of the financing order; and

(b) shall constitute a vested, presently existing property right.

14. "Secured party" means a financing party in favor of which a utility corporation or its successors or assignees creates a security interest in all or any portion of its interest in or right to recovery property. A secured party may be granted a security interest in recovery property under this act and a security interest in other collateral subject to the uniform commercial code in a single security agreement.

15. "Security interest" means a pledge, hypothecation, or other encumbrance of or other right over any portion of recovery property created by contract to secure the payment or performance of an obligation.

16. "Service area" means the geographical area within which a utility corporation provides electric distribution services as of the date of a financing order.

17. "Service interruption" means the loss of service for five minutes or more, for one or more consumers, which is the result of one or more component failures.

18. "Storm" means a period of adverse weather during which service interruptions affect at least ten percent of the consumers in an operating area and/or result in consumers being without electric service for durations of at least twenty-four hours.

19. "Storm recovery activity" means any activity or activities by or on behalf of a utility corporation taken before July 1, 2024 in connection with the restoration of service and infrastructure associated with electric power outages affecting consumers of a utility corporation as the result of a storm or storms, including but not limited to mobilization, staging, and construction, reconstruction, replacement, or repair of electric generation, transmission, or distribution facilities.

20. "Storm recovery costs" means, if requested by a utility corporation and approved by the commission, costs incurred before July 1, 2024 by a utility corporation in undertaking a storm recovery activity. Such costs may be net of applicable insurance proceeds, tax benefits, and any other amounts intended to reimburse the utility corporation for storm recovery activities such as governmental grants or aid of any kind and may include adjustments for normal capital replacement and operating costs, or other potential offsetting adjustments. Storm recovery costs may include retiring any existing indebtedness relating to storm recovery activities.

21. "Utility corporation" means any electric corporations individually or collectively who are subsidiaries of the same corporation who jointly or collectively have storm recovery costs of $500 million or more as of July 1, 2024.

§ 3. Financing orders. 1. No utility corporation or its affiliate or other assignee shall issue any recovery bonds unless it has been specifically authorized to do so by a financing order issued pursuant to this section. No later than two years after the effective date of this act, a utility corporation may petition the commission for a financing order granting such authority. Such petition shall be made under oath and shall be signed and filed on behalf of the utility corporation or its affiliate or other assignee by the president or by a vice president, treasurer, or other executive officer having knowledge of the matters set forth therein and shall be submitted in such form as the commission shall prescribe.

2. Each petition filed under this section shall include all of the following:

(a) A description of the storm recovery activities that the utility corporation has undertaken and the reasons for undertaking the activities.

(b) The storm recovery costs the utility corporation has determined would be appropriate to recover through recovery bonds and is seeking to recover, and the level that the utility corporation is funding or will seek to fund through other means, together with a description of the factors and calculations used in determining such amounts and methods of recovery.

(c) Whether the utility corporation proposes to finance all or a portion of the recovery costs using recovery bonds. If the utility corporation proposes to finance a portion of such costs, the utility corporation must identify the specific portion in the petition. An election not to finance a portion of the recovery costs using recovery bonds by a utility corporation shall not be deemed to waive its right to recover such costs pursuant to a separate proceeding with the commission pursuant to this act.

(d) An estimate of the financing costs related to the recovery bonds.

(e) An estimate of the recovery charges necessary to recover the recovery costs and financing costs and the period for recovery of such costs.

(f) A comparison between the net present value of the costs to consumers that are estimated to result from the issuance of recovery bonds and the result from the application of the traditional method of financing and recovering recovery costs from consumers. The comparison should demonstrate that the issuance of recovery bonds and the imposition of recovery charges are expected to provide quantifiable benefits to consumers.

3. (a) The commission may grant a petition under subdivision one of this section in whole or in part by issuing a financing order, with such modifications thereto and upon such terms and conditions as the commission prescribes and that are consistent with this act, provided such financing is prudent and would provide a net benefit to the consumer. If the commission issues a financing order approving the issuance of recovery bonds under this act, the commission shall consider whether:

(i) the proposed issuance of recovery bonds and the imposition and collection of a recovery charge are expected to provide quantifiable benefits to consumers as compared to the costs that would have been incurred absent the issuance of recovery bonds; and

(ii) the proposed structuring, expected pricing, and financing costs of the recovery bonds are reasonably expected to result in the lowest recovery charges consistent with market conditions at the time the recovery bonds are priced and the terms of the financing order or would avoid or mitigate rate impacts to consumers as compared with traditional methods of financing or recovering recovery costs.

(b) The commission may determine what degree of flexibility to afford to the utility corporation or assignees in establishing the terms and conditions of the recovery bonds, including but not limited to repayment schedules, interest rates, and other financing costs. A copy of any financing order issued under this act duly certified by a commissioner or other person authorized to act on behalf of the commission shall be sufficient evidence for all purposes of whole and complete compliance by the utility corporation with all procedural and other matters required precedent to the issuance of the order.

4. Proceedings on a petition submitted pursuant to this section begin with the petition for a financing order filed by a utility corporation with the commission for review and approval within 135 days of the filing of the petition and shall be disposed of in accordance with the requirements of this act and the rules of the commission.

5. A financing order issued by the commission to a utility corporation shall:

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to enact the "New York utility corporation securitization act"

Purpose or general idea of bill

To create the legislative framework required to enable the use of "secu- ritization" to recover storm costs and arrearage costs incurred by inve- stor-owned utilities ("recovery costs"). Securitization is a mechanism for financing recovery costs that enables rate payer savings in the form of lower debt service costs and longer recovery periods relative to the standard ratemaking approach.

Summary of provisions

Section 1. Title of the Act.

Read the full memo (2,110 words)

Section 2. A new article 12 is added to the Public Service Law entitled the "New York Utility Corporation Recovery Securitization Act" Article 12 provisions:

Section 302: Financing Orders

Amends section sixty-nine of the Public Service Law to add a new subdi- vision b that would permit a utility corporation to petition the Public Service Commission (Commission) for authorization to issue recovery bonds by the utility corporation or its affiliate or another assignee. Proscribes the affirmation attendant with and contents of the petition, including a description of the (i) storm recovery activities and costs both undertaken and not undertaken, level of the storm recovery reserves and the amount for recovery through recovery bonds and/or (ii) the amount of arrearages that are over 60 days past due recorded by a utili- ty corporation, estimate of financing costs and recovery charges to recover the costs, as well as the period for the recovery, and estimate of customer benefit from utilization of recovery bonds. Authorizes the Commission to grant in whole or in part the petition by issuance of a financing order with terms and conditions that are consistent with the Act.

In issuing a financing order, the Commission may consider the quantifi- able benefits to customers and the structure, expected pricing and financing costs, as market conditions warrant at the time of bond issu- ance. The Commission may also provide flexibility to the utility corpo- ration or assignees as to the terms and conditions of the bonds, includ- ing repayment schedules, interest rates, and other financing costs. The Commission is required to issue a final decision on the petition within 135 days of receipt of the petition.

Any financing order issued under this provision shall include the amount of recovery costs, including consideration of storm reserves, plus any other available funds or collection methods, associated financing costs and the quantifiable benefits to customers. In addition to the authori- zation to issue the recovery bonds, the order creates the right in and to the recovery charges collected from the utility corporation's custom- ers and the right to periodic adjustments of the recovery charges (these rights being referred to as "recovery property"). The recovery property is both the sole source of payment to pay the recovery bonds and financ- ing costs and is the primary collateral to secure the recovery bonds.

The recovery property may be sold, assigned or transferred by the utili- ty corporation to a subsidiary of the utility corporation, another assignee, any of which shall be the issuer of the recovery bonds. Recov- ery property may also be created or recognized as property of an assig- nee.

This section also establishes the means for which the recovery charges will be updated and trued-up periodically to ensure sufficient payment of the principal and interest on the recovery bonds.It allows by opera- tion of law the implementation of periodic adjustments to the recovery charge 60-days from the filing of such change with the Commission to ensure sufficient collections to pay principal, interest and other financing costs on the recovery bonds. Apart from the periodic adjust- ment of the recovery charges, and regardless of changes in ownership or solvency of the utility corporation or successors, the financing order remains in effect and is otherwise irrevocable and cannot be amended, modified or terminated until the recovery bonds and any associated financing costs are paid in full.

The financing order must specify how amounts collected from customers will be allocated between the recovery charges and other utility charge and direct the utility corporation to maintain service to its customers and collect for and remit to the appropriate recovery charges for the benefit of the assignee or financing party.

The Commission may include in the financing order limitations on poten- tial assignees and requirements related the voluntary filing of a bank- ruptcy petition on behalf of the assignee. This section authorizes the Commission to require information related to the organization of assig- nee and recognizes the creation of the recovery property upon certain actions/events.

After issuance of the financing order, the utility corporation has discretion to sell, transfer or assign the recovery property, and facil- itate the issuance of the recovery bonds in a timeframe of the corpo- ration's discretion. The Commission is also authorized to issue a subse- quent financing order associated with the refinancing, retiring, or refunding of recovery bonds and make associated changes to the recovery charges, consistent with the provisions of the Act.

The recovery bonds issued pursuant to the financing order will not be deemed by the Commission to be the debt of the utility corporation, other than for federal income tax purposes, nor shall the recovery charges be viewed as revenue or costs of the utility corporation and all supporting acts in execution of the financing order shall be viewed as just and reasonable. The recovery bonds cannot be used to finance any other costs, will be issued at the discretion of the utility corpo- ration, and cannot be used by the Commission to disallow access by the corporation to other methods of storm or arrearage cost recovery.

Except for election matters, challenges to the Commission financing order or issuance of recovery bonds shall be given priority for consid- eration by the courts.

Section 303: Recovery property Defines the nature of the property right created by a financing order pursuant to the statute and the conditions under which such right may be sold, assigned or transferred.

Requires that the utility corporation include recovery charges as a separate line item on the customer bill.

Establishes that the recovery charges established pursuant to a financ- ing order to service the recovery bonds are non-bypassable, meaning that customers are not able to avoid paying recovery charges.

Section 304: True Sale

Governs the sale, assignment or other transfer of the recovery property by a utility corporation and establishes the conditions for a true sale to an assignee. The true sale is a critical component of a utility secu- ritization because the segregation of the recovery property from the rest of the utility corporation's property allows the transaction to be "bankruptcy remote".

Establishes that the assignee shall be bankruptcy remote and that the utility corporation will not have a claim on recovery property in the event of a bankruptcy or reorganization of the utility corpora- tion.Subsection (2) clarifies that notwithstanding several undertaken back the utility corporation or any assignee, for purposes of state law, the sale of the recovery property will be recognized as a sale by the utility corporation to the assignee that ultimately will issue the recovery bonds. This subsection is important for establishing the facts to ensure the assignee is treated as bankruptcy remote which helps ensure the transaction receives a higher credit rating which in turn will lead to lower costs for rate payers.

Section 305: Security Interests

Establishes that the Act, and not the Uniform Commercial Code, governs the granting of security interest in the recovery property. It is customary that utility securitizations have their own procedures for securing the liens created against the recovery property. The procedures are mechanical in nature and expected by bondholders and rating agen- cies.

Section 306: Choice of law; conflicts

Establishes that property rights and security interest created pursuant to this statute shall be governed exclusively by New York State Law.

Section 307: Recovery bonds not public debt

Recovery bonds are not a debt or general obligation of the state or any of its political subdivisions, agencies or instrumentalities. While the utility gets authorization from the Commission in a financing order to issue recovery bonds, recovery bonds are not issued by the state nor are they state obligations and there are no state guarantees.

Section 308: State pledge

State pledges not to take any action that would limit, alter or impair recovery property or, except as required by the periodic adjustment process described in the financing order, reduce, alter or impair recov- ery charges that are imposed, collected and remitted for the benefit of the owners of recovery bonds, any assignee, and all financing parties, until any principal, interest and redemption premium in respect of recovery bonds, all other financing costs and all amounts to be paid to an assignee or financing party under an ancillary agreement are paid or performed in full.

The state pledge, and the periodic adjustment mechanism, are the two most important features of a utility securitization.The rating agencies and bondholders rely on the state pledge as protection against future state action that could undermine the collection of recovery charges and ultimately the recovery bonds. Because of the state pledge, rating agen- cies no do not require expensive overcollateralization allowing for the overall recovery charges billed to rate payers to be lower.

Section 309: Not a utility corporation

An assignee or financing party shall not be considered a utility corpo- ration or person providing electric or gas service by virtue of engaging in the transactions described in this section.

Section 310: Effect of invalidity

Subsequent invalidation of any provision of this statute does not affect the validity of actions allowed by the Act.In addition to the state pledge, bondholders rely on this section that their investment in recov- ery bonds cannot be impaired by a future court action.

Section 311: Effect of Financing Order

The section clarifies that Section 70 of the PSL shall not apply to recovery bonds, the sale of the recovery property or any other trans- action contemplated by a financing order.

Section 3 of the bill provides the effective date.

Justification

Destructive storms that were once every 100 years are becoming the norm annually in New York State. Over the past several years, these damaging storms have wreaked havoc on the state's infrastructure, primarily elec- tric transmission and distribution systems. In 2024 alone, costs to restore, and in many cases rebuild, the utility transmission and distribution system has run into the hundreds of millions of dollars.

In addition, during the unprecedented COVID-l9 pandemic and resulting state of emergency, New York imposed a moratorium on the disconnection of electrical or gas services from residential customers. As a result, New York electric and gas corporations have significant legacy arrearag- es from such customers. Despite the end of the state of emergency, many of these residential customers are still facing unmanageable debt as a result of the pandemic and unlike years past, the FY 2025 budget did not include direct arrears assistance under the Energy Affordability Program.As of March 2024, more than 1.3 million utility customers have arrears of 60 days or more equating to $1.6 billion in debt owed to their utility provider.

Legislation is required to authorize the PSC to accept a financing peti- tion for securitization from a utility. This petition is reviewed by PSC to determine if securitization is in the public interest. If granted by the PSC, the financing order is issued allowing the recovery of costs by issuing bonds with lower financing costs. Securitization involves transferring the right to collect costs (e.g., major storm cost defer- rals and legacy arrears) to a newly created entity formed specifically for the securitization. The newly formed entity sells bonds with lower financing costs to a bond issuer to fund its purchase of the assets from the utility. Securitization enables bonds to be issued by a third party at very advantageous interest rates, thereby lowering the financing cost associated with these assets and in turn lowering customer bills. Total customer bills are adjusted downward to reflect the impacts of the tran- saction, with a dedicated line item to pay off the bonds, with periodic true-ups to ensure utility compliance with the bond repayments.

The use of securitization to recover storm expenses already incurred and arrearages will permit electrical or gas corporations to recover these amounts at a lower cost than, would otherwise be imposed on the electric or gas corporations' customers. Securitization is a mechanism to resolve legacy debt, at no expense to the general fund and at lower interest rate and lower cost for customers.

Legislative history

This is a new bill.

Fiscal implications

: :

None.

Effective date

This act shall take effect immediately.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.