What's happening
This bill directs New York's Department of Transportation to study and report on whether key bridges can withstand collisions from large vessels.
Why it matters
Aims to proactively identify vulnerabilities in bridge infrastructure. by requiring a thorough evaluation of specific bridges’ ability to withstand impacts from increasingly large commercial vessels, in light of recent catastrophic incidents elsewhere.
Mandates a broad, multi-agency collaboration. including the Department of Transportation, various bridge authorities, and the Port Authority—to ensure that a range of expertise and jurisdiction is applied to the assessment.
Requires a detailed and holistic analysis for each bridge. , not just of structural integrity, but also factors like bridge age, traffic (vehicular and maritime), known issues, barrier design, local geography, and emergency maneuvering space for ships—providing a nuanced understanding of risk.
Establishes a timeline and public accountability. , with a comprehensive report (including recommendations and possible legislative changes) due by January 2026, to be shared with state leaders and made publicly accessible, which could drive future infrastructure policy and funding decisions.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Study Bridge Impact Safety
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
Senator · Senate District 56
No co-sponsors yet.
History
- Referred to transportation
Full text
3 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
9362
IN SENATE
May 14, 2024
Introduced by Sen. COONEY -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Transportation
AN ACT directing the Department of Transportation to conduct a study of certain bridges spanning bodies of water connected to deep water ports in the state to determine whether such bridges have the structural integrity to withstand an impact from a large vessel; and providing for the repeal of such provisions upon the expiration thereof
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Legislative intent and findings. 1. On March 26, 2024, the commercial container ship, the "Dali", lost power and slammed into a support piling of the Francis Scott Key Bridge in Baltimore, resulting in the immediate and near-total collapse of the bridge. Six individuals who were working on the bridge died in the collapse. The bodies of two of those victimes have not been recovered. The Dali was 984 feet long and weighed approximately 95,000 tons. As a result of the collision and collapse, trade through the Port of Baltimore has been severely compromised and will remain so for some time, costing an estimated fifteen million dollars in lost economic activity each day. The estimated cost to repair the bridge will be $4,000,000,000. The repairs are estimated to take several years.
In addition to being a part of a sea passage for trade, the Francis Scott Key Bridge was also a major part of the Baltimore transportation system for commercial, commuter and personal travel. Until the bridge repairs are completed, a key part of the Baltimore infrastructure is closed not only to sea-going traffic, but also to vehicular traffic, as well. The current and future financial impacts on Baltimore, its residents and the state of Maryland are profound.
2. Less than two weeks after the Baltimore incident, the 89,000-ton, 1,100-foot-long vessel "APL Qingdao" lost propulsion near the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge. Fortunately, there was no collision between the vessel and the bridge.
3. While these ships seem to be extremely large, Allan Post, the deputy superintendent at Texas A&M University's Maritime Academy states that
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD15209-04-4
1,000 foot ships are now the standard size. In contrast, the Summit Venture, a cargo vessel that caused the 1980 collapse of the Sunshine Skyway in Florida, was 600 feet long and weighed 35,000 tons.
4. These recent incidents raise concerns about the condition of bridges spanning waterways involved in seagoing commercial transportation in our state and the ability of such structures to withstand an impact from such a large vessel. In most cases, New York bridges were designed and built long before the advent of the enormous commercial vessels common now and most would likely not be able to sustain a direct collision with such a vessel. The occurrence of such an accident would have a devastating impact on our state and local economies and, depending on the bridge involved, our local transportation. In addition, there is the potential for enormous loss of life when a bridge collapses.
5. In view of these considerations, the legislature declares it to be in the best interest of the state and its people to proactively conduct a study of bridges spanning bodies of water connected to deep water ports in the state to determine whether such bridges have the structural integrity to withstand an impact from a large vessel.
§ 2. 1. The Department of Transportation, in conjunction with the New York State Bridge Authority, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, and the Buffalo and Fort Erie Public Bridge Authority, as applicable, shall conduct a study to determine the ability of certain bridges in the state to withstand an impact to the support structures of the bridges from large ships, including but not limited to, cargo vessels, oil tankers and passenger ships. Upon the conclusion of the study, the Commissioner of the Department of Transportation ("the Commissioner") shall prepare and issue a comprehensive report of the study findings and recommendations for improvements to each bridge, if any.
2. Bridges to be evaluated for the study shall include the following:
a. the Bronx-Whitestone Bridge;
b. the Cross Bay Veterans Memorial Bridge;
c. the Henry Hudson Bridge;
d. the Marine Parkway-Gil Hodges Memorial Bridge;
e. the Robert F. Kennedy Bridge;
f. the Throgs Neck Bridge;
g. the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge;
h. the Governor Mario M. Cuomo Bridge;
i. the Bear Mountain Bridge;
j. the Newburgh-Beacon Bridge;
k. the Mid-Hudson Bridge;
l. the Kingston-Rhinecliff Bridge;
m. the Rip Van Winkle Bridge;
n. the George Washington Bridge;
o. the Bayonne Bridge;
p. the Goethals Bridge;
q. the Outerbridge Crossing Bridge;
r. the Alfred H. Smith Memorial Bridge;
s. the Castleton Bridge;
t. the Dunn Memorial Bridge;
u. the Patroon Island Bridge;
v. the Peace Bridge;
w. the Walkway over the Hudson Pedestrian Bridge;
x. any bridge under the control of a New York entity spanning a water shipping route through Lake Erie or Lake Ontario utilized by large cargo vessels or oil tankers to access commercial shipping ports in the Niagara or Rochester areas of the state; and
y. any other bridge the Commissioner deems necessary.
3. For each bridge, the study shall include, at a minimum, an evaluation of the following:
a. the age of the bridge;
b. the amount of traffic traveling on top of and through the waters below the bridge;
c. the current condition of the bridge;
d. any known or newly discovered chronic issue or problem with the bridge;
e. the type, size, and construction of the support structures of the bridge;
f. the type, size and construction of any barriers surrounding the base of the support structures of the bridge and the distance between such surrounding structures and the water channels occupied by vessels;
g. the width between the support structures of the bridge;
h. the height of the bridge;
i. the topography near the bridge, including sand bars, shallows, cliffs, etc.;
j. the area a vessel may safely access during a maneuver to avoid the bridge in the event of a loss of power or propulsion or other emergency; and
k. any other matters the Commissioner deems necessary.
§ 3. The report required by this act shall be submitted to the governor, the speaker of the assembly, and the temporary president of the senate no later than January 1, 2026. The report shall include the findings, conclusions and recommendations of the Commissioner of the Department of Transportation and other involved entities. The Commissioner shall submit with this report such legislative proposals as the Commissioner deems necessary to implement such recommendations. The report shall also be published on the website of the Department of Transportation no later than one month after it is completed.
§ 4. The Commissioner of the Department of Transportation may request, and is authorized to receive, any information from any state agencies that is relevant and material to the completion of this study and report. Such information received by the Commissioner shall be subject to the same requirements for confidentiality and limitations on use, if any, as are applicable to such state agency's use of such information. In addition to the entities listed in subdivision one of section two of this act, the Commissioner may consult with any additional entities the Commissioner deems necessary.
§ 5. This act shall take effect immediately and shall expire and be deemed repealed April 1, 2026 or 3 months after the report is submitted, whichever is later.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act directing the Department of Transportation to conduct a study of certain bridges spanning bodies of water connected to deep water ports in the state to determine whether such bridges have the structural integrity to withstand an impact from a large vessel; and providing for the repeal of such provisions upon the expiration thereof
Purpose or general idea of bill
To examine the structural integrity of bridges in New York STate to withstand the impact from large ships and make recommendations to issues discovered.
Summary of provisions
Section 1 sets forth the legislative intent and findings for the study.
Read the full memo (1,116 words)
Section 2 directs the New York State Department of Transportation, in conjunction with the New York State Bridge Authority, the MTA, the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, and the Buffalo and Fort Erie Public Bridge Authority, to conduct a study to determine the ability of certain bridges in the state to withstand an impact to the support structures of the bridges from large ships, including but not limited to:
*Cargo vessels,
*Oil tankers, and
*Passenger ships
Upon the conclusion of the study, the Commissioner of the Department of Transportation shall prepare and issue a comprehensive report of the study findings and recommendations for improvements to each bridge, if any.
Subsection 2 of Section 2 contains the lists of the bridges to be included in the study, which are but not limited to:
a) Bronx-Whitestone Bridge; and
b) Cross Bay Veterans Memorial Bridge;
c) Henry Hudson Bridge;
d) Marine Parkway-Gil Hodges Memorial Bridge;
e) Robert F. Kennedy Bridge;
f) Throgs Neck Bridge;
g) Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge;
h) Governor Mario M. Cuomo Bridge;
i) Bear Mountain Bridge;
j) Newburgh-Beacon Bridge;
k) Mid-Hudson Bridge; 1) Kingston-Rhinecliff Bridge;
m) Rip Van Winkle Bridge;
n) George Washington Bridge;
o) Bayonne Bridge;
p) Goethals Bridge;
q) Outerbridge Crossing Bridge;
r) Alfred H. Smith Memorial Bridge;
s) Castleton Bridge;
t) Dunn Memorial Bridge;
u) Patroon Island Bridge;
v) Peace Bridge;
w) Walkway over the Hudson Pedestrian Bridge; and
x) Any bridge under the control of a New York entity spanning a water shipping route through Lake Erie or Lake Ontario utilized by large cargo vessels or oil tankers to access commercial shipping ports in the Niagara or Rochester areas of the State.
y) any other bridge the Commissioner of the Department of Transportation deems necessary.
For each bridge, the study shall include:
a) Age of the bridge;
b) Amount of traffic traveling on top of and through the waters below the bridge;
c) Current condition of the bridge;
d) Any known or newly discovered chronic issue or problem with the bridge;
e) Type, size, and construction of the support structures of the bridge; 0 Type, size, and construction of any barriers surrounding the base of the support structures and the water channels occupied by the vessels;
g) Width between the support structures of the bridge;
h) Height of the bridge;
i) Topography near the bridge, including sand bars, shallows, cliffs, etc..; j) The area a vessel may safely access during a maneuver to avoid the bridge in the event of a loss of power or propulsion or other emergency; and
k) Any other matters the Commissioner deems necessary.
The report shall be submitted to the Governor, Speaker of the Assembly, and Temporary President of the Senate no later than January 1, 2026.
The Commissioner shall submit with this report such legislative proposals as deemed necessary to implement the recommendations of the study.
The report shall also be published on the website of the Department of Transportation no later than one month after it is completed.
Justification
Anyone watching the Francis Scott Key bridge in Baltimore collapse so easily after being hit by a cargo ship had to wonder, "What about our bridges? Are they safe from a wayward cargo ship or tanker? What would be the loss of life and the impact on our economy? What would it cost to replace the bridge?"
That bridge, which carried Interstate 695, collapsed like a house of cards. Were it not for the quick actions of the ship's crew in communi- cating what had happened, and the swift response of emergency operators and bridge authorities in closing the bridge, many more people would have died.
Tragically enough, six individuals working on the bridge died. If the collision had occurred during rush hour, rather than at 1:30 in the morning, much more traffic and many more people would have been on the bridge, resulting in a greater tragedy.
1-695 is one of three crossings through and around Baltimore heading north/south and to the east coast. The Key Bridge carried approximately 12 million vehicles a year - about 33,000 vehicles per day. With its collapse, the inner loop of 1-695 is closed and drivers must take the 195 or 1-895 tunnels for these routes.
The Port of Baltimore is still not operational, costing approximately $15 million per day in lost economic activity, including $1.5 million each day in state and local taxes.
Repairing the Key Bridge will cost an estimated $4 billion and take several years.
In my district in the Hudson Valley, the Newburgh-Beacon Bridge, which crosses the Hudson River and carries 1-84, goes east/west and connects the northeast to the rest of country. 1-84 is a major commercial and passenger route that connects with the New York State Thruway (1-87) less than 5 miles from the Newburgh-Beacon Bridge. It averages more than 65,000 vehicles per day. The economic impact to the local, state and national economy would be huge.
The George Washington Bridge carries more than 300,000 vehicles per day. The loss of life and damage to the economy of the greater New York City metropolitan area would be immeasurable if this bridge collapsed. The same can be said of all the bridges proposed for review in this bill.
This bill would require New York State to be proactive by mandating the review of bridges that are subject to large cargo ships and tankers, and understanding whether their piers are protected.
We, as a State, do not want to be in a position of only offering our thoughts and prayers if any of our bridges collapse after being hit by a wayward cargo ship. We should not wait for a New York State bridge to collapse to conduct this study.
Prior legislative history
None. New bill.
Fiscal implications for state and local governments
Cost of review of bridges to be determined. No cost to local govern- ments.
Effective date
This act shall take effect immediately and shall expire and be deemed repealed April 1, 2026 or three months after the report is submitted, whichever is later.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.