Skip to content
S9375Senate2023-2024 Session

Tax on Fuel-Efficient Cars

Official title

“Enacts a highway use tax on fuel-efficient vehicles; repealer”

Sponsor Andrew GounardesSD-26Affects Finance
Status
In Senate Committee
Budget And Revenue
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Budget And Revenue

What's happening

This bill creates a mileage-based highway use tax for fuel-efficient vehicles in New York, requiring on-board tracking units for tax calculation and data collection.

Why it matters

  1. Shifts Road Funding for Fuel-Efficient Drivers. As more vehicles surpass 30 miles per gallon (or equivalent), traditional fuel taxes generate less revenue for road maintenance. This bill ensures that owners of fuel-efficient cars contribute to highway upkeep based on actual miles driven rather than fuel consumed, aiming for a more sustainable funding model as vehicle technology evolves.

  2. Mandates On-Board Mileage Tracking, Raising Privacy Concerns. All "covered vehicles" must be equipped with electronic devices that track and report mileage via GPS or similar systems. Although location data is not reported, this raises questions about data security, government surveillance, and the burden of installing and maintaining such devices.

  3. Reduces Double Taxation for Hybrid Owners. To avoid charging drivers twice, the bill offers a credit for state fuel taxes paid by owners of fuel-efficient vehicles, but only up to the amount owed under the mileage tax (no refunds if credits exceed tax). This is especially relevant for hybrid drivers who might otherwise pay more than their fair share.

  4. Creates a Framework for Ongoing Adjustments and Oversight. The bill requires annual reporting to the legislature, including recommendations for rate or threshold changes, total revenues, and data on compliance. This means the policy can be adapted over time to reflect technological shifts, usage trends, or public concerns.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Tax on Fuel-Efficient Cars

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Andrew Gounardes

Senator · Senate District 26

Chair, Budget And Revenue

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to budget and revenue

Full text

5 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9375

IN SENATE

May 14, 2024

Introduced by Sen. GOUNARDES -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Budget and Revenue

AN ACT to amend the tax law, the vehicle and traffic law and the state finance law, in relation to a highway use tax for fuel-efficient vehicles; and to repeal certain provisions of the state finance law relating to the dedicated highway and bridge trust fund

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. The tax law is amended by adding a new article 21-B to read as follows:

ARTICLE 21-B

HIGHWAY USE TAX FOR FUEL-EFFICIENT VEHICLES

Section 530. Definitions.

531. Creation of highway use tax for covered vehicles.

532. Collection of tax.

533. Data privacy.

534. Reimbursements for gas tax.

535. Penalties, interest, and tax fraud acts.

536. Disposition of revenues.

537. Annual report.

§ 530. Definitions. As used in this article, the following terms shall have the following meanings:

1. "Covered vehicle" shall mean a motor vehicle, as defined in section one hundred twenty-five of the vehicle and traffic law, that receives at least thirty miles per gallon or miles per gallon equivalent.

2. "Global positioning system" or "GPS" shall mean a location tracking technology that uses navigational satellites to determine a user's location and velocity in real time and is capable of collecting, storing, and transmitting geographical data.

3. "Miles per gallon" shall refer to the measure of distance that a covered vehicle running on gasoline or diesel fuel can travel per gallon of such fuel as rated by the environmental protection agency.

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD14194-02-4

4. "Miles per gallon gasoline equivalent" shall refer to the measure of distance that a covered vehicle running on non-liquid fuels can travel per unit of energy as rated by the environmental protection agency.

5. "Motor fuel" shall mean the same as defined in subdivision two of section two hundred eighty-two of this chapter.

6. "On-board unit" shall mean an electronic device installed in a covered vehicle that records traffic and driving data and can connect to roadside and satellite navigation systems.

7. "Public highway" shall mean any public highway, street, avenue, road, public place, public driveway, or any other public way in this state.

§ 531. Creation of highway use tax for covered vehicles. 1. There is hereby created a highway use tax for covered vehicles for the privilege of operating a covered vehicle upon the public highways of this state and for the purpose of recompensing the state for the public expenditures incurred by reason of the operations of such covered vehicle on such public highways. The tax shall be levied upon the owner of a covered vehicle for miles driven on public highways.

2. The amount of highway use tax owed shall be equal to the number of vehicle miles traveled, as reported by the on-board unit, times a tax rate of 1.9 cents per mile.

§ 532. Collection of tax. The highway use tax for covered vehicles shall be collected as follows:

1. An on-board unit shall be installed in every covered vehicle at the point of such vehicle's registration, reregistration, or renewal pursuant to section four hundred one of the vehicle and traffic law. The on-board unit shall transmit to the department the number of vehicle miles traveled on public highways on a regular basis for the purposes of calculating the amount of highway use tax owed by the owner of the covered vehicle.

2. Owners of a covered vehicle under this article shall be required to file a return for the highway use tax no less than four times throughout the year, on or before the last day of the calendar month following each of the calendar quarters: January through March, April through June, July through September, and October through December, provided, however, that owners may file such returns on a more frequent basis through the creation of a prepaid account or any other method prescribed by the commissioner.

§ 533. Data privacy. The commissioner shall promulgate regulations to ensure the privacy and integrity of all data collected from covered vehicles and vehicle owners under this article, provided that:

1. The on-board units, as defined in this article, shall be programmed to track mileage on public highways in this state using a GPS system or other comparable technology, but shall not report exact location coordinates, times of travel, trip data, or any other geographic information about the use of a covered vehicle to the department. Such on-board units shall report mileage as an aggregate number for a given time period as prescribed by the commissioner.

2. The department shall be subject to the requirements of article six-A of the public officers law when implementing any and all provisions of this article.

§ 534. Reimbursements for gas tax. The commissioner shall create a system by which the owner of a covered vehicle may, electronically or otherwise, submit a record of payment for motor fuel in this state. Such commissioner shall then determine the portion of such payment attributable to the fuel taxes described in this chapter which are levied upon the purchase of such motor fuel and shall apply such portion as a credit against the amount of highway use tax owed, provided, however, that if the amount of the credit shall exceed the amount of tax owed, no refund shall be issued thereof.

§ 535. Penalties, interest, and tax fraud acts. 1. Any person failing to file a return or to pay any tax within the time required by or pursuant to this article shall be subject to the penalties prescribed in section five hundred twelve of this chapter, excepting, however, such failures which are due to reasonable cause and not willful neglect as determined by the commissioner and described in such section.

2. Any person committing a tax fraud act shall be subject to the penalties prescribed in sections eighteen hundred one, eighteen hundred two, eighteen hundred three, eighteen hundred four, eighteen hundred five, eighteen hundred six and eighteen hundred seven of this chapter. "Tax fraud act" as used in this subdivision shall include any intentional frustration of the provisions of this article including, but not limited to, tampering with, replacing, or disconnecting an on-board unit with the intent to defraud.

§ 536. Disposition of revenues. All taxes, interest, penalties, and fees collected or received pursuant to this article shall be deposited daily in one account with such responsible banks, banking houses, or trust companies as may be designated by the comptroller, and to the credit of the comptroller on account of the dedicated highway and bridge trust fund established pursuant to section eighty-nine-b of the state finance law. Such an account may be established in one or more of such depositories and such deposits shall be kept separate and apart from all other moneys in the possession of the comptroller. The comptroller shall require adequate security from all such depositories.

§ 537. Annual report. No later than one year after the effective date of this section, and each year thereafter, the commissioner shall deliver an annual report to the legislature containing:

1. Recommended changes, if any, to the tax rate established in subdivision two of section five hundred thirty-one of this article;

2. Recommended changes, if any, to the miles per gallon or miles per gallon equivalent threshold for covered vehicles to which this article applies;

3. The total number of covered vehicles in this state which are subject to the provisions of this article;

4. The total amount of mileage recorded and reported for purposes of this article on public highways in this state; and

5. The total amount of annual revenues collected under this article.

§ 2. Subparagraph (a) of paragraph 1 of subdivision (c) of section 301 of the vehicle and traffic law, as amended by chapter 444 of the laws of 2016, is amended to read as follows:

(a) A safety inspection shall be made with respect to the brakes; steering mechanism; wheel alignment; lights, including but not limited to the lights which are designed and placed on a vehicle for the purpose of illuminating the vehicle's license plates; odometer; tire pressure; seat safety belts; shoulder harness safety belts; any window which is composed of, covered by or treated with any material which has a light transmittance of less than seventy percent pursuant to section three hundred seventy-five of this title, an on-board unit for covered vehicles, as such terms are defined in section five hundred thirty of the tax law, and such other mechanisms and equipment as shall be determined by the commissioner to be necessary for proper and safe operations. Such inspection shall also be made with respect to vehicle identification number. Upon inspection, the mileage appearing on the odometer shall be recorded upon the inspection sticker. For covered vehicles, as defined in section five hundred thirty of the tax law, both the mileage appearing on the odometer and the mileage recorded by an on-board unit shall be recorded and transmitted to the commissioner, in a manner and form prescribed by the commissioner.

§ 3. Section 375 of the vehicle and traffic law is amended by adding a new subdivision 55 to read as follows:

55. Every covered motor vehicle subject to the provisions of article twenty-one-B of the tax law registered in this state shall be equipped with an on-board unit, as defined in section five hundred thirty of the tax law. Such on-board unit shall be programmed to track mileage on public highways in this state using a GPS system or other comparable technology, but shall not report exact location coordinates, times of travel, trip data, or any other geographic information about the use of a covered vehicle to the tax department.

§ 4. Paragraph (a) of subdivision 3 of section 89-b of the state finance law, as amended by section 4 of chapter 368 of the laws of 2019, is amended to read as follows:

(a) The special obligation reserve and payment account shall consist (i) of all moneys required to be deposited in the dedicated highway and bridge trust fund pursuant to the provisions of sections two hundred five, two hundred eighty-nine-e, three hundred one-j, five hundred fifteen, five hundred thirty-six and eleven hundred sixty-seven of the tax law, section four hundred one and article twelve-d of the vehicle and traffic law, and section thirty-one of chapter fifty-six of the laws of nineteen hundred ninety-three, (ii) all fees, fines or penalties collected by the commissioner of transportation and the commissioner of motor vehicles pursuant to section fifty-two, section three hundred twenty-six, section eighty-eight of the highway law, subdivision fifteen of section three hundred eighty-five of the vehicle and traffic law, section two of part U1 of chapter sixty-two of the laws of two thousand three, subdivision (d) of section three hundred four-a, paragraph one of subdivision (a) and subdivision (d) of section three hundred five, subdivision six-a of section four hundred fifteen and subdivision (g) of section twenty-one hundred twenty-five of the vehicle and traffic law, section fifteen of this chapter, excepting moneys deposited with the state on account of betterments performed pursuant to subdivision twenty-seven or subdivision thirty-five of section ten of the highway law, and section one hundred forty-five of the transportation law, (iii) any moneys collected by the department of transportation for services provided pursuant to agreements entered into in accordance with section ninety-nine-r of the general municipal law, and (iv) any other moneys collected therefor or credited or transferred thereto from any other fund, account or source.

§ 5. Paragraph (a) of subdivision 3 of section 89-b of the state finance law, as amended by section 5 of chapter 368 of the laws of 2019, is amended to read as follows:

(a) The special obligation reserve and payment account shall consist (i) of all moneys required to be deposited in the dedicated highway and bridge trust fund pursuant to the provisions of sections two hundred eighty-nine-e, three hundred one-j, five hundred fifteen, five hundred thirty-six and eleven hundred sixty-seven of the tax law, section four hundred one and article twelve-d of the vehicle and traffic law, and section thirty-one of chapter fifty-six of the laws of nineteen hundred ninety-three, (ii) all fees, fines or penalties collected by the commissioner of transportation and the commissioner of motor vehicles pursuant to section fifty-two, section three hundred twenty-six, section eightyeight of the highway law, subdivision fifteen of section three hundred eighty-five of the vehicle and traffic law, section fifteen of this chapter, excepting moneys deposited with the state on account of betterments performed pursuant to subdivision twenty-seven or subdivision thirty-five of section ten of the highway law, and section one hundred forty-five of the transportation law, (iii) any moneys collected by the department of transportation for services provided pursuant to agreements entered into in accordance with section ninety-nine-r of the general municipal law, and (iv) any other moneys collected therefor or credited or transferred thereto from any other fund, account or source.

§ 6. Paragraph (a) of subdivision 3 of section 89-b of the state finance law, as amended by section 8 of part UU of chapter 59 of the laws of 2018, is REPEALED.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the tax law, the vehicle and traffic law and the state finance law, in relation to a highway use tax for fuel-efficient vehi- cles; and to repeal certain provisions of the state finance law relating to the dedicated highway and bridge trust fund

Purpose or general idea of bill

To create a tax based on vehicle miles traveled (VMT) for fuel-efficient cars that are no longer paying gas tax

Summary of provisions

Section one adds a new Article 21-B to the Tax Law to create a highway use tax for fuel-efficient vehicles that receive at least 30 miles per gallon or miles per gallon equivalent, which is the same fuel efficiency threshold used in Oregon's VMT tax.

Read the full memo (1,283 words)

Qualifying vehicles would be subject to the tax at a rate of 1.9 cents per mile on in-state public roadways. Applicable mileage would be recorded via an on-board unit installed at the time of vehicle registra- tion. The on-board unit would report an aggregate number of taxable miles to the Department of Tax and Finance (DTF) for the purposes of calculating VMT tax owed but would not be programmed to report other data such as precise geolocation or times of travel. The Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) and DTF would additionally be subject to the provisions of Article 6-A of the Public Officers Law, which enacts strict privacy protections for consumer data.

The VMT tax would be owed on a quarterly basis, unless a taxpayer elects to file a return more frequently through, for example, the creation of a digital prepaid account similar to an E-ZPass account.

Fuel-efficient vehicles that continue to pay some amount of gas tax could submit their receipts to DTF and receive a credit against the VMT tax owed under the bill.

Penalties and interest for failure to pay would be equivalent to those for New York's existing highway use tax for trucks that weigh more than 18,000 pounds as provided in Tax Law § 52. Acts of overt tax fraud such as tampering with, replacing, or disconnecting an on-board unit with intent to defraud would be subject to the penalties prescribed in Part 2 of Article 37 of the Tax Law.

All revenues collected from the VMT tax would be earmarked to the dedi- cated highway bridge and trust fund.

DTF would be required to produce an annual report on:

- Recommended changes to the VMT tax rate per mile

- Recommended changes to the mileage threshold for the VMT tax

- The total number of covered vehicles and mileage reported for the VMT tax - Total amount of revenues the state collected from the VMT tax

Section two of the bill amends § 301(c)(1)(a) of the Vehicle and Traffic Law to include verification of the presence of an on-board unit in annu- al vehicle safety inspections. Inspectors would be responsible for recording both the mileage on an odometer and the mileage reported by an on-board unit in their inspection report.

Section three of the bill amends § 375 of the Vehicle and Traffic Law (VTL) to include on-board units among the list of mandatory pieces of equipment that vehicles subject to the VMT tax must have. The installa- tion of the on-board unit could be done by an automobile dealer at the point of sale or lease.

Sections four, five, and six amend § 89-b(3)(a) of the State Finance Law to make conforming amendments.

Section seven sets the effective date.

Justification

This bill creates a vehicle miles traveled (VMT) tax for the owners of fuel-efficient vehicles who no longer pay a sufficient amount of gas tax to repair the roads, bridges, and tunnels upon which they drive. Tax revenues per VMT are decreasing in real terms while expenditures for the maintenance of public roadways are increasing. According to the Tax Foundation, a passenger car in 1994 averaged 20.7 miles per gallon and drivers paid 3.2 cents in state and federal tax per VMT (Who Will Pay for the Roads?, August 2020, Tax Foundation, p. 1). By 2018, average fuel economy had increased to 24.4 MPG and drives paid only 2.1 cents in state and federal tax per VMT. The U.S. Energy Information Adminis- tration estimates that gas consumption will decline 19% by 2050, and EVs may comprise up to 17.5% of auto sales nationwide by 2028. The gap between gas tax revenues and public expenditures on road maintenance will continue to grow as both average fuel economy improves overall and the share of electric vehicles (EVs) on the road increases. The federal gas tax, meanwhile, which is not indexed to inflation, has not been raised by Congress since 1993.

While New York has made many meaningful strides in recent years to encourage the transition to EV vehicles in order to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, including rebates of up to $2,000 through NYSERDA's Drive Clean program, the current gas tax scheme does not account for electric vehicles' greatest externality - the significant wear-and-tear which they incur upon public roadways through batteries that are thousands of pounds heavier than traditional gas-powered cars. The creation of a highway use tax, which is based on vehicle miles traveled rather than volume of gasoline consumed, would both correct for this externality while ensuring that our state's motor fuel tax is fulfilling its intended purpose of funding public infrastructure.

There is a precedent, meanwhile, for a VMT tax in New York State, which has had a highway use tax for trucks weighing more than 18,000 pounds in place since 1951 (Evaluation of the New York State Highway Use Tax, 1953, Proceedings of the Annual Conference on Taxation under the Auspices of the National Tax Association, National Tax Association, p. 123). Decades ago, the legislature justified this VMT because of the direct relationship between vehicle weight and highway damage, the fact that heavier vehicles cause greater construction and maintenance costs, the fact that lighter vehicles were paying more than heavier vehicles for use of the same roadway, and the fact that the fuel tax was no long- er an accurate index of roadway use - arguments that all still apply today.

A VMT tax of 1.9 cents a mile for fuel-efficient vehicles could easily be implemented with existing technology, toll and tax collection schemes, and vehicle enforcement checkpoints. On-board units (OBUs), which are capable of being programmed to track in-state mileage on public roadways while collecting no other data, could transmit the number of taxable miles per covered vehicle to the Department of Taxa- tion and Finance, who could then bill vehicle owners electronically in a manner similar to E-ZPass. OBUs could be installed at the point of retail sale by auto dealers, who could then certify to DMV that such unit has been installed when they go to register the vehicle on behalf of the new owner. Annual vehicle safety inspections could serve as one of several enforcement checkpoints to ensure that OBUs are properly installed in fuel-efficient vehicles, and that the reported mileage of an OBU matches that on the vehicle's odometer.

This new tax based on vehicle miles traveled would better approximate highway use for fuel-efficient vehicles while raising hundreds of thou- sands in new revenue for our roads, bridges, and tunnels. This bill represents a commonsense solution to the problem of an antiquated motor fuel tax regime that no longer reflects the realities of the vehicle market it attempts to tax.

Prior legislative history

None

Fiscal implications

TBD

Effective date

This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become a law and apply to all covered vehicles registered or re-regis- tered on or after such date.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.