Skip to content
S9732Senate2023-2024 Session

Seal Parentage Court Records

Official title

“Ensures the sealing of certain records relating to a proceeding for judgment of parentage”

Sponsor Brad Hoylman-SigalSD-47Affects Legal
Status
In Assembly Committee
Judiciary
Impact
4/10
Low
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 5 of 7

In Assembly · Judiciary

What's happening

The bill ensures that names of children or parties in parentage proceedings are not publicly displayed in court records or electronic indexes.

Why it matters

  1. Strengthens privacy protections. for families and children involved in parentage cases by tightening rules on how sensitive information is handled in court records and indexes.

  2. Reduces risk of unintended disclosure. of identities, which is especially important for children born via surrogacy, assisted reproduction, or in contentious parental disputes where exposure could lead to stigma, harassment, or emotional harm.

  3. Clarifies the responsibilities of court clerks. , making them explicitly responsible for ensuring that personal names are not displayed in any public-facing court documentation—whether on paper or online—thus addressing potential gaps in current practices.

  4. Supports consistency across counties and courts. , potentially closing loopholes or uneven application of privacy standards in New York’s family and surrogate courts.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Seal Parentage Court Records

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Brad Hoylman-Sigal

Senator · Senate District 47

Chair, Judiciary

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to judiciary
  2. Delivered to assembly
  3. Passed senateVote 59–0
  4. Ordered to third reading cal.1800
  5. Committee discharged and committed to rules
  6. Referred to judiciary

Full text

1 pageUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9732

IN SENATE

May 23, 2024

Introduced by Sen. HOYLMAN-SIGAL -- (at request of the Office of Court Administration) -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Judiciary

AN ACT to amend the family court act, in relation to ensuring the sealing of certain records relating to a proceeding for judgment of parentage

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Section 581-205 of the family court act, as added by section 1 of part L of chapter 56 of the laws of 2020, is amended to read as follows:

§ 581-205. Inspection of records. Court records relating to proceedings under this article shall be sealed, provided, however, that the office of temporary and disability assistance, a child support unit of a social services district or a child support agency of another state providing child support services pursuant to title IV-d of the federal social security act, when a party to a related support proceeding and to the extent necessary to provide child support services or for the administration of the program pursuant to title IV-d of the federal social security act, may obtain a copy of a judgment of parentage. The parties to the proceeding and the child shall have the right to inspect and make copies of the entire court record, including, but not limited to, the name of the person acting as surrogate and any known donors. The county clerk and the clerks of the surrogate's or family courts shall not display the name of the child or party in any caption document, index, or minutes available to the public, whether filed in hard copy or electronically.

§ 2. This act shall take effect immediately.

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD10566-02-4

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the family court act, in relation to ensuring the seal- ing of certain records relating to a proceeding for judgment of parent- age

Source of bill

This bill is being introduced at the request of the Judiciary, on the recommendation of the Chief Administrative Judge's Matrimonial Practice Advisory and Rules Committee.

Purpose of bill

This bill amends the Child Parent Security Act to ensure that the seal- ing provisions of the Act are not compromised by rules requiring parties' names in captions in papers.

Read the full memo (1,459 words)

Summary of provisions

Section 1 of the bill amends Family Court Act § 581-205 to provide that the county clerk or the clerks of the surrogate's or family courts shall not display the surname of the child or party in any caption, document, index or minutes available to the public, whether filed in hard copy or electronically on the NYS Courts Electronic Filing System.

Section 2 of the bill provides that it shall take effect immediately.

Justification

This proposal would amend the Child Parent Security Act (CPSA) enacted in 2020 to make clear that the sealing requirements of the Act are enforced and are not compromised by rules requiring parties' names in captions in papers.

The Child Parent Security Act provides that court records relating to parentage proceedings shall be sealed with certain exceptions for child support administration by state authorities, but may be available for inspection and copying only by the parties or the child. However, pursu- ant to both CPLR § 2101(c) and 22 NYCRR § 202.5(d)(1), the County Clerk as the Clerk of the Supreme Court, or the Surrogate's Court Clerk where the initial petition is filed, is required to display the names of parties unless the statute, a court rule or court order specially prohi- bits.(1)

The CPLR and court rules requiring parties' names in captions are intended for the typical type of litigation where (i) the parties' interests are adverse to each other and the defendant needs to know the plaintiff's identity in order to defend the case, and (ii) where there is no statutory sealing requirement as there is with the CPSA.(2) Even then, there are exceptions granted depending on the facts of the case, such as where there are good reasons to allow anonymity and plaintiff's identity can be ascertained sufficiently to allow the court jurisdic- tion.(3) By contrast, in most cases under the CPSA, the parties petition the court consensually for a judgment of parentage, and rules as to names of parties in captions are inapplicable. (1) See CPLR § 2101 (c) which reads as follows:

c) Caption. Each paper served or filed shall begin with a caption setting forth the name of the court, the venue, the title of the action, the nature of the paper and the index number of the action if one has been assigned. In a summons, a complaint or a judgment the title shall include the names of all parties, but in all other papers it shall be sufficient to state the name of the first named party on each side with an appropriate indication of any omissions. N.Y. C.P.L.R. 2101 (McKin- ney).

See also 22 NYCRR section 202.5(d) 1) WHICH READS AS FOLLOWS:

" IN ACCORDANCE WITH CPLR 2102(C), A COUNTY CLERK AND A CHIEF CLERK OF THE SUPREME COURT OR COUNTY COURT, AS APPROPRIATE, SHALL REFUSE TO ACCEPT FOR FILING PAPERS FILED IN ACTIONS AND PROCEEDINGS ONLY UNDER THE FOLLOWING CIRCUMSTANCES OR AS OTHERWISE PROVIDED BY STATUTE, CHIEF ADMINISTRATOR'S RULE OR ORDER OF THE COURT:

(II) THE SUMMONS, COMPLAINT, PETITION, OR JUDGMENT SOUGHT TO BE FILED WITH THE COUNTY CLERK CONTAINS AN "ET AL" OR OTHERWISE DOES NOT CONTAIN A FULL CAPTION;

(2) SEE DOE V. ROMAN CATH. ARCHDIOCESE OF NEW YORK, 64 MISC. 3D 1220(A), 117 N.Y.S.3D 468 (N.Y. SUP. CT. 2019) WHERE JUSTICE RUDERMAN QUOTED VARIOUS AUTHORITIES ON THE REASONS WHY NAMES SHOULD NOT BE ANONYMOUS: : "IT IS ELEMENTARY THAT THE PRIMARY FUNCTION OF A PLEADING IS TO APPRISE AN ADVERSE PARTY OF THE PLEADER'S CLAIM ... ABSENT SUCH NOTICE, A DEFENDANT IS PREJUDICED BY ITS INABILITY TO PREPARE A DEFENSE TO THE PLAINTIFFS ALLEGATIONS" (COLEY MANDELL FOOD STORES, INC., 93 NY2D 34, 40 (1999) (INTERNAL QUOTATION MARKS AND CITATIONS OMITTED)). "THE RATIONALE FOR THE DISCLOSURE OF A PLAINTIFFS NAME IN A COMPLAINT OR PETITION IS GROUNDED IN THE BASIC DUE PROCESS RIGHTS OF NOTICE AND AN OPPORTUNITY TO BE HEARD" (3B CARNIODY-WAIT 2D § 28:6) (NOTE: ONLINE TREATISE). MORE- OVER, CPLR 2101 REQUIRES THAT THE CAPTION OF A SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT INCLUDE THE NAMES OF ALL PARTIES (SEE 22 NYCRR § 202.5 (D) (1) (II);

(3) SEE E.K. V. NEW YORK HOSP.-CORNELL MED. CTR., 158 MISC. 2D 334, 336, 600 N.Y.S.2D 993, 994 (SUP. CT. 1992), WHERE THE COURT IN AN ACTION AGAINST A HOSPITAL AND ITS EMPLOYEE FOR ALLEGED WRONGFUL DISCLOSURE OF MENTAL ILLNESS TREATMENT RECORDS TO PROTECT PLAINTIFF SUFFERING THE "STIGMA AND DISCRIMINATION" FROM HAVING THE RECORDS OF HER MENTAL ILLNESS PUBLICLY VIEWABLE, ALLOWED THE PLAINTIFF TO PROCEED AS E.K. AND ORDERED THE COUNTY CLERK TO ENTER THE PLAINTIFF'S NAME IN THE CAPTION AS E.K. DESPITE THE REQUIREMENTS OF CPLR § 2101(C) CITED BY THE DEFENDANTS. IN THAT CASE, THE PLAINTIFF HAD PROVIDED THE HOSPITAL WITH ACTUAL NOTICE OF HER IDENTITY BY LETTERS DETAILING THE ALLEGATIONS OF THE COMPLAINT AND THE DATES SHE SOUGHT TREATMENT AND WHERE AN EMPLOYEE OF THE HOSPITAL COULD BE SAID TO HAVE HAD CONSTRUCTIVE KNOWLEDGE OF PLAINTIFF'S IDENTITY SINCE THE HOSPITAL HAD KNOWLEDGE AND BOTH DEFENDANTS WERE REPRESENTED BY THE SAME LAW FIRM.

THIS BILL WOULD MAKE CLEAR THAT ANONYMOUS SURNAMES IN CAPTIONS ARE REQUIRED, NOTWITHSTANDING COURT RULES OR PROVISIONS IN THE CPLR REQUIR- ING CLERKS TO SHOW PARTIES' NAME IN CAPTIONS. RATHER THAN MERELY PROHIB- ITING THE CLERK FROM SHOWING THE PARTIES' NAMES IN "ANY DOCUMENT, INDEX OR MINUTES AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC," AS IN THE 2023 VERSION OF THE PROPOSAL, THE BILL WOULD NOW PROHIBIT THE CLERK FROM SHOWING THE PARTIES' SURNAMES IN "ANY CAPTION, DOCUMENT, INDEX OR MINUTES AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC."

DESPITE EFFORTS TO ENCOURAGE FILERS TO APPLY BY LETTER APPLICATIONS FOR COURT ORDERS TO HAVE ANONYMOUS CAPTIONS IN CPSA MATTERS, ATTORNEYS DO NOT ALWAYS DO SO. IN SUPREME COURT ACTIONS, AT PRESENT, THE ONLY WAY FOR A LITIGANT TO ENSURE THAT NAMES OF THE PARTIES OR CHILD WILL NOT BE REVEALED IN THE CAPTION OF A DOCUMENT IN THE PROCEEDINGS IS BY SUBMIT- TING A REQUIRED LETTER APPLICATION FOR AN ANONYMOUS CAPTION IN ALL PUBLICLY VIEWABLE CASE LISTINGS. A MODEL SAMPLE LETTER APPLICATION IS POSTED ON NYSCEF AND IS AVAILABLE ON THE COURT'S DIVORCE RESOURCES WEBSITE AT LETTER.APPLICATION.PDF (STATE.NY.US), BUT MAY ALSO BE SUBMITTED IN HARD COPY. ONCE THE APPLICATION IS APPROVED BY THE COURT, THE COUNTY CLERK OR SURROGATE'S COURT CLERK IS AUTHORIZED NOT TO DISCLOSE THE NAME OF THE CHILD OR ANY PARTY IN THE CAPTION ON ANY DOCU- MENT PUBLICLY VIEWABLE.

THE BILL WILL MAKE THE LETTER APPLICATION UNNECESSARY AND ENSURE THAT PARTIES' SURNAMES WILL NOT APPEAR IN ANY DIVORCE CASES.

THE BILL WILL ALSO PROMOTE COURT EFFICIENCY. USE OF THE LETTER APPLICA- TION REQUIRES AN APPLICATION IN EVERY CASE AND WASTES JUDICIAL RESOURCES AS WELL AS LITIGANTS' TIME AND IS NOT ALWAYS SUBMITTED AS NOTED ABOVE. IT WOULD BE FAR MORE EFFICIENT AND EFFECTIVE TO AMEND THE STATUTE AS PROPOSED. THE PROPOSAL WOULD ALLOW THE COUNTY CLERK (AS THE CLERK OF THE SUPREME COURT) OR THE SURROGATE'S COURT CLERK WHO RECEIVES THE FILES NOT TO DISPLAY THE NAME OF THE CHILD OR PARTY IN ANY CAPTION, DOCUMENT, INDEX OR MINUTES AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC.

THE BILL LIMITS THE SEALING PROVISIONS TO SURNAMES ONLY IN ORDER TO MAKE IT EASIER TO SEARCH RECORDS WITHOUT ENDANGERING CONFIDENTIALITY.

IT SHOULD BE NOTED THAT THE ISSUE OF ANONYMOUS CAPTIONS IS AN ISSUE IN SUPREME COURT AND SURROGATE'S COURT AND NOT FAMILY COURT BECAUSE IN FAMILY COURT THERE IS NO PUBLICLY AVAILABLE RECORD OF THE NAMES OF THE PARTIES. BUT FAMILY COURTS ARE INCLUDED IN THE PROPOSAL JUST IN CASE PRACTICE SHOULD CHANGE IN THE FUTURE WITH E-COURTS.

THIS BILL WILL ENSURE CONFIDENTIALITY OF HIGHLY INTIMATE PRIVATE INFOR- MATION IN PARENTAGE PROCEEDINGS, WHILE PRESERVING JUDICIAL RESOURCES AND PROMOTING EFFICIENCY.

Prior legislative history

A BILL CONTAINING THE PRIOR VERSION OF THE PROPOSAL WITHOUT THE EXPRESS CAPTION LANGUAGE WAS INTRODUCED AS S.5107-B(HOYLMAN-SIGAL)/A.4921-B(PAULIN) AND PASSED THE SENATE IN 2023, BUT DID NOT PASS THE ASSEMBLY. IT HAS BEEN REINTRODUCED IN 2024.

ANOTHER BILL CONTAINING THE PRIOR VERSION OF THE PROPOSAL WITHOUT THE EXPRESS CAPTION LANGUAGE WAS INTRODUCED IN 2023 AS 5.7749 KRUEGER AND REINTRODUCED IN 2024.

Fiscal implications

THIS BILL WOULD HAVE NO MEANINGFUL STATE FISCAL IMPACT.

Effective date

THIS BILL WOULD TAKE EFFECT IMMEDIATELY.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.