What's happening
This bill establishes specific venue rules for matrimonial actions, requiring trials in counties where parties or minor children reside, with exceptions for confidentiality.
Why it matters
Ensures trials for divorce, custody, and related matrimonial matters generally happen in a county where at least one spouse or a minor child lives, making proceedings more accessible and relevant to the parties involved.
Provides special protection for victims of domestic violence or others whose addresses are confidential, allowing the plaintiff to choose a trial location to maintain privacy and safety.
Gives judges the flexibility to allow trials in other counties for “good cause,” potentially accommodating unique circumstances or hardships faced by parties.
Creates a more predictable and transparent framework for deciding where key family law cases are heard, which may reduce forum shopping and procedural disputes over venue.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Change Divorce Trial Location Rules
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
No co-sponsors yet.
History
- Substituted by A10353
- Ordered to third reading cal.1616
- Committee discharged and committed to rules
- Referred to judiciary
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Change Divorce Court Locations
Signed by Governor · Sponsor Jeffrey Dinowitz
Full text
2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
9733
IN SENATE
May 23, 2024
Introduced by Sen. HOYLMAN-SIGAL -- (at request of the Office of Court Administration) -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Judiciary
AN ACT to amend the civil practice law and rules, in relation to venue in matrimonial actions
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Section 509 of the civil practice law and rules, as amended by chapter 773 of the laws of 1965, is amended to read as follows:
§ 509. Venue in county designated. Notwithstanding any provision of this article except for rule 515, the place of trial of an action shall be in the county designated by the plaintiff, unless the place of trial is changed to another county by order upon motion, or by consent as provided in subdivision (b) of rule 511 of this article.
§ 2. The civil practice law and rules is amended by adding a new rule 515 to read as follows:
Rule 515. Venue in matrimonial actions. (a) This rule applies to all actions wherein all or part of the relief granted is divorce, all actions brought in supreme court for custody or visitation, all applications to modify a supreme court order of custody or visitation, all actions wherein all or part of the relief granted is the dissolution, annulment or declaration of the nullity of a marriage, all proceedings to obtain a distribution of marital property following a foreign judgment of divorce, and all post-judgment proceedings following a judgment of divorce.
(b) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this article, the place of trial in an action subject to subdivision (a) of this rule shall be in a county in which either party resides or, if there are minor children of the marriage, the place of trial may also be in the county where one of such children resides; except that where any of the addresses of these residences is not a matter of public record, or where any of these addresses is subject to an existing confidentiality order pursuant to section 254 of the domestic relations law or section 154-b of the family court act, the place of trial designated by the plaintiff
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD10083-01-3
in any action specified in subdivision (a) of this rule may be as specified in section 509 of this article.
(c) In any action specified in subdivision (a) of this rule, the court may, for good cause shown, allow the trial to proceed before it, notwithstanding that venue would not lie pursuant to subdivision (b) of this rule. Good cause applications shall be made by motion or order to show cause.
§ 3. This act shall take effect on the sixtieth day after it shall have become a law and shall apply to matrimonial actions commenced on or after such date.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the civil practice law and rules, in relation to venue in matrimonial actions
Source of bill
This bill is being introduced at the request of the Judiciary upon the recommendation of the Chief Administrative Judge's Matrimonial Practice Advisory and Rules Committee.
Purpose of bill
This bill would amend the CPLR by adding a new rule 515 to require that venue in a matrimonial action be in a county in which either party resides or, if there are minor children of the marriage, in the county where one of the parties or one of such children resides. This bill is designed to further access to justice by distributing judicial resources more fairly, speed the processing of divorce cases in counties overbur- dened by non-resident filings, and assure better outcomes for litigants by preventing plaintiffs from designating venue in distant counties where none of the parties or their children reside pursuant to CPLR § 509 (unless safety concerns warrant keeping an address confidential, in which case the bill permits CPLR § 509 to still be used to designate venue).
Read the full memo (1,874 words)
Summary of provisions
Section 1 of the bill amends CPLR § 509 to provide an exception to the requirement that, notwithstanding any other provision of the CPLR's venue article (article 5), the place of trial shall be as designated by the plaintiff unless it is changed to another county by order upon motion, or by consent as provided in CPLR rule 511(b). The exception added is for new proposed rule 515.
Section 2 of the bill adds a new rule 515 to the CPLR providing for venue in matrimonial actions. Subdivision (a) of this new rule applies to actions wherein all or part of the relief granted is divorce, all actions brought in supreme court for custody or visitation, all applica- tions to modify a supreme court order of custody or visitation, all actions wherein all or part of the relief granted is the dissolution, annulment or declaration of the nullity of a marriage, all proceedings to obtain a distribution of marital property following a foreign judg- ment of divorce, and all post-judgment proceedings following a judgment of divorce.
Subdivision (b) of new rule 515 provides that, notwithstanding anything to the contrary in article 5 of the CPLR, the place of trial in an action subject to subdivision (a) shall be in a county in which either party resides or, if there are minor children of the marriage, the place of trial may also be in the county where one of such children resides; except that where any of the addresses of these residences is not a matter of public record, or where any of these addresses is subject to an existing confidentiality order, the place of trial designated by the plaintiff may be as specified in section 509 of article 5.
Subdivision (c) of new rule 515 provides that in any action specified in subdivision (a), the court may, for good cause shown, allow the trial to proceed before it, notwithstanding that venue would not lie pursuant to subdivision (b), and that good cause applications shall be made by motion or order to show cause.
Section 3 of the bill provides that, if enacted, the bill shall take effect on the sixtieth day after it shall have become a law and shall apply to matrimonial actions commenced on or after such date.
Justification
This bill will significantly further access to justice by distributing judicial resources more fairly, speed the processing of divorce cases in counties overburdened by non-resident filings, and assure better outcomes for litigants.
Matrimonial plaintiffs have long used CPLR § 509 to designate venue in a county even though none of the parties may reside there. This is partly to convenience attorneys who do not want to travel to file papers, and partly to take advantage of what is widely believed to be more expe- ditious processing of divorces in certain counties. This causes prob- lems, however, as was pointed out in Castaneda v Castaneda, 36 Misc. 3d 504 (Sup Ct, NY County 2012)( conducting a "detailed examination" of the "recurrent practice of bringing divorce actions in New York County regardless of where parties to the divorce actually live," and noting the "significant problems" the practice creates for parties, "partic- ularly defendants who are unrepresented by counsel," and "the court system as a whole").
Designating venue in a divorce action in a county distant from the resi- dence of the parties and children will require defendants to travel long distances - where judges require appearances to resolve conflicts in the papers or testimony on a range of issues, or to meet with professionals in relation to the litigation. Moreover, it burdens the courts of that county. It also requires that judges appoint and deal with counsel and mental health and other professionals in distant jurisdictions with whose work and expertise they are unfamiliar. When venue is designated in a distant county, defendants are also more likely to default, in the process giving up valuable rights and increasing the likelihood of post- judgment applications.
Compounding the need for this measure, CPLR § 503(a) was amended in 2017 to permit the fixing of venue in a county where a substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred. This amend- ment (L. 2017, c. 366) was not designed with matrimonial actions in mind. Nonetheless, by adding another venue option unrelated to residence without restricting plaintiff's ability to designate a venue unrelated to residence pursuant to CPLR § 509, the amendment underscores the need for this measure.
To be sure, electronic filing, now widely available, greatly alleviates problems for defendants caused by CPLR § 509 venue designations, and also makes it easier and less costly for plaintiffs to file and prose- cute divorce actions in the county of residence. However, this bill remains necessary to eliminate continued and ever-increasing abuses caused by CPLR 509 designations of venue in distant counties.
The burden of CPLR § 509 venue designations has been great both upstate and downstate for many years, especially, in the 1st, 2nd, 6th, 7th, and 8th Judicial Districts. Matrimonial judges in Buffalo and Rochester have expressed concern for the large number of uncontested divorce actions filed in Erie and Monroe Counties, respectively. Court statistics on uncontested divorce filings reported in Matrimonial Reports to the Chief Administrative Judge posted at REPORTS FROM PREVIOUS YEARS I NYCOURTS. GOV show that both of those counties have sizable numbers of filings, as do Nassau, Suffolk, and Westchester, along with the boroughs of New York City aside from Richmond. Indeed, the burden has increased in all parts of the State.
The Deputy Chief Administrative Judge for Courts Outside New York City, as well as Administrative Judges and District Executives in the western, northern and middle portions of the State have reported large numbers of out of county uncontested divorce filings, many of them from New York City. A recent survey of the 3rd through the 10th Judicial Districts upstate conducted in September 2023 revealed that filings of uncontested divorce by non-residents was a prevalent issue in nearly all Judicial Districts. It also revealed that service issues are frequent in non-re- sident uncontested filings, and it is difficult for judges to assess allegations made in the filings, leaving the possibility that issues of domestic violence and abuse may go undetected. It was also revealed that CPLR § 509 filings are frequently made by attorneys who present them- selves as self-represented litigants, raising ethical issues. Some judg- es report that the relief sought in non-resident filings often appears so unfair that it requires further explanation and financial disclosure by the parties. Within New York City, some counties are overburdened by filings from other New York City counties as well.
A number of thoughtful remedial proposals have been made in the last few years by bar association groups such as the New York State Bar Standing CPLR Committee, and by judges and clerks in New York County. These proposals have called for amendment of CPLR § 509 to narrow a plaintiff's choice of venue in a matrimonial action. Under that section, only a plaintiff can now fix venue, and under existing CPLR § 510(1), only the defendant may demand a change in venue.(1) Courts cannot over- turn a matrimonial plaintiff's choice to designate venue outside the county of residence of one of the parties if defendants do not ask for a change.(1)
This bill would avoid problems of venue designations in distant counties by requiring that venue be related to the parties' residence notwith- standing CPLR § 509. It requires that venue in a divorce action be related to the residence of the parties or child(ren) of the marriage with exception only for instances where the address of a party is not a matter of public record or is subject to a confidentiality order, when it may be specified pursuant to CPLR § 509. It also gives the court authority for good cause shown to allow the trial to proceed before it even if venue is not proper, thus avoiding time consuming venue trans- fers to other counties fraught with delays when appropriate. Moreover, because proposed CPLR rule 515 is expressly limited to matrimonial actions, it will have no impact on non-matrimonial actions.
This bill will ensure that divorces will be processed more quickly statewide as it should result in the volume of divorces being more even- ly distributed among counties. This measure will also ensure better outcomes in divorce cases by ensuring that defendants are less likely to default, that parties and their children do not have to travel long distances for in-person hearings, and that judges can appoint and deal with professional counsel and forensic evaluators in custody matters with whose work and expertise they are familiar. As a result, outcomes in divorce cases will be fairer since judges will be better able to assess allegations and fairness of the relief sought because they will have more readily available important information about children and families that would not be available if the venue were not related to residence.
Prior legislative history
The Judiciary has proposed similar bills that have been introduced in the past, including in 2017 (S.5736-A (Bonacic)), 2018 (A.9920 (Dinow- itz)), 2019 (A.7517 (Dinowitz)) and 202122 (OCA-56)
Fiscal implications
This bill would have no State fiscal impact.
Effective date
This bill would take effect on take effect on the sixtieth day after it shall have become a law. (1) In the Practice Commentaries, Vincent Alexander explains: "CPLR 510 specifies three grounds for a motion to change venue. Subdivision (1) provides for such motion when venue is improper, i.e., plaintiff has failed to comply with the rules specified in CPLR 501 and 503-508 or some other venue-regulating statute (e.g., CPLR 7502(a)). Only the defendant may make this motion; if the plaintiff places venue in an improper county, she forfeits the right to select a proper one.- See N.Y. CPLR 510 (McKinney). (2) "A change of venue requires a motion. That the change cannot be made by the court sua sponte is an old rule, generally still followed." (16 Siegel, N.Y. Prac. § 116 (5th ed.)).
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.