Skip to content
S976Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA5455

Protect Non-Abusive Parents

Official title

“Relates to the creation of Melinda's Law in relation to the basis for removal of children”

Sponsor Mario MatteraSD-2+1 co-sponsorAffects Health
Status
In Senate Committee
Children And Families
Impact
7/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Children And Families

What's happening

Melinda's Law creates protections for non-abusive spouses in domestic violence cases, allowing them to report abuse without risking losing custody of their children.

Why it matters

  1. Protects non-abusive spouses from retaliation. By explicitly defining "victim spouse" and creating a legal safe harbor, the bill removes a key tool of control used by abusers—threatening that reporting child abuse will result in the non-abusive spouse also losing custody.

  2. Encourages earlier intervention. The law is designed to make it easier and less risky for non-abusive spouses to report both spousal and child abuse, potentially stopping the escalation of violence before it worsens.

  3. Shifts custody and court procedures. If the court determines a spouse is a victim of domestic violence and not neglectful or abusive toward the child, that spouse is treated as a "non-respondent," prioritized for custody, and protected by temporary orders—changing how courts handle removal and protection orders in these cases.

  4. Clarifies definitions and exceptions. The bill provides broad definitions of domestic violence (including psychological and emotional abuse), but also excludes cases involving sexual crimes, murder, or severe disfigurement from these protections—helping to set clear boundaries for when the law applies.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Parents subjected to domestic violence

    Qualifying parents who report the incident triggering removal proceedings would be removed as respondents and awarded custody if they were not abusive or neglectful and custody serves the child's best interests.

  • Family Court judges

    The bill would require new domestic violence inquiries when both parents are respondents and temporary protection orders against the abusive respondent when the reporting parent qualifies for protection.

  • Child protective services agencies

    The bill would change removal and placement procedures by requiring courts to consider whether a reporting parent qualifies to retain custody before considering placement with relatives.

  • Attorneys for children

    A finding that a parent qualifies for removal as a respondent would constitute good cause for a hearing on returning the child, providing another basis for seeking that hearing.

Headline styles

Protect Non-Abusive Parents

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Mario Mattera

Senator · Senate District 2

1 Co-sponsor

History

  1. Referred to children and families
  2. Referred to children and families

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A5455Assembly

Protect Domestic Violence Victims

In Assembly Committee · Children And Families · Sponsor Doug Smith

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

3 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

976

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

January 9, 2023

Introduced by Sen. MATTERA -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Children and Families

AN ACT to amend the family court act, in relation to the basis for removal of children and the creation of "Melinda's Law"

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. This act shall be known and may be cited as "Melinda's Law".

§ 2. Legislative intent. The legislature hereby finds and declares that in cases of domestic violence, the abuse sometimes moves from the spouse to the children. Once the abusive spouse begins to over-discipline the children, the abusive spouse will often use threats or the removal of the children by child protective services as a means to compel subjugation from the non-abusive spouse. In addition, the abusive spouse prevents the reporting of such incidents to child protective services by making the non-abusive spouse an accomplice in this abuse. Under this threat, children are subjected to escalating abuse that could have been prevented if the non-abusive spouse had a safe harbor to report such abuse at the early stages without fear of losing their children. By this act the legislature intends to take such tool away from the abusive spouse by providing the non-abusive spouse a way to report such incidents without fear of having their children removed from their custody. The sequence of events above are an apt description of "Melinda". Melinda is a woman suffering from domestic violence. She had been abused by her husband over a twenty-year period. The abuse had seen verbal, psychological, and physical. She took the abuse in the belief that her children needed a father. Eventually the abuse was transferred to the children. It started with excessive spanking, locking a young teenager in the basement, and pushing a five-year-old to the ground. Melinda confronted her husband and put herself between her husband and her children resulting in a black-eye to Melinda. She told her husband

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD01036-01-3

that she would not let him hit the children and would call the police and have him arrested. Her husband responded that if she called the police, her children would be taken away from her by child protective services. The husband than graduated to hitting his teenage son with a wooden rod that left welts. The abuse in this cycle of domestic violence is escalated over time when the abusive spouse believes that the non-abusive spouse or caretaker is afraid to report such abuse, under the fear of losing their children. By creating a safe harbor under Melinda's Law we have the opportunity to prevent the escalation of abuse to both the spouse victim and the children who are the victims of domestic violence.

§ 3. Section 1012 of the family court act is amended by adding two new subdivisions (o) and (p) to read as follows:

(o) "Domestic violence" means:

(i) any conduct which would constitute an offense in the penal law, and created a substantial risk of physical or emotional harm, regardless of whether such injury occurred; or

(ii) any other abuse, including but not limited to verbal, emotional or psychological abuse, including slapping, that creates a substantial risk of physical or emotional harm to such person or such person's child, regardless of whether such harm occurred.

(p) "Victim spouse or domestic partner subjected to domestic violence" means the respondent spouse or domestic partner who is the non-abusive spouse or domestic partner, and is determined to be subjected to domestic violence as defined by subdivision (o) of this section.

§ 4. Section 1017 of the family court act is amended by adding a new subdivision 1-a to read as follows:

1-a. (a) In determining whether there is a suitable person related to the child with whom such child may appropriately reside under subdivision one of this section and if both parents are respondents the court shall first inquire as to the following:

(i) whether either respondent has been subjected to domestic violence by the other respondent and if so;

(ii) whether such victim spouse or domestic partner subjected to domestic violence reported the incident precipitating a removal order or hearing under this article and if so;

(iii) whether such victim spouse or domestic partner subjected to domestic violence has been neglectful or abusive in their behavior towards the child or children at issue.

(b) If the court shall determine under paragraph (a) of this subdivision that a respondent is a victim spouse or domestic partner subjected to domestic violence and reported the incident precipitating the order or hearing under this article then the court shall deem such victim spouse or domestic partner subjected to domestic violence a non-respondent for purposes of the removal order or hearing; provided that, such victim spouse or domestic partner subjected to domestic violence is not neglectful or abusive in their behavior towards the child or children at issue. If the court so finds, the court shall award custody to such non-respondent parent provided that such custody is in the best interests of the child or children.

(c) If a determination is made that both parents remain as respondents, the court may then determine whether there is a suitable person related to the child with whom such child may appropriately reside under subdivision one of this section.

(d) The court may conduct in camera interviews, bar the appearance of the respondent abuser or take any other steps as it deems necessary within its statutory and constitutional powers to determine whether or not a respondent is a victim spouse within the meaning of subparagraph (i) of paragraph (a) of this subdivision.

(e) This subdivision shall not apply to instances of sexual crimes, murder or where there has been prior incidents involving disfigurement of the child or children at issue.

§ 5. Paragraphs (vi) and (vii) of subdivision (a) of section 1022 of the family court act are renumbered paragraphs (vii) and (viii) and a new paragraph (vi) is added to read as follows:

(vi) If the court shall determine, pursuant to subdivision one-a of section one thousand seventeen of this article that a respondent parent is a non-respondent for the reasons given thereunder, the court shall issue a temporary order of protection against the respondent abuser pursuant to paragraph (v) of this subdivision.

§ 6. Subdivision (b) of section 1027 of the family court act is amended by adding a new paragraph (vi) to read as follows:

(vi) If the court shall determine, pursuant to subdivision one-a of section one thousand seventeen of this article that a respondent parent is a non-respondent for the reasons given thereunder, the court shall issue a temporary order of protection against the respondent abuser pursuant to paragraph (v) of this subdivision.

§ 7. Subdivision (a) of section 1028 of the family court act, as amended by chapter 41 of the laws of 2010, is amended to read as follows:

(a) Upon the application of the parent or other person legally responsible for the care of a child temporarily removed under this part or upon the application of the child's attorney for an order returning the child, the court shall hold a hearing to determine whether the child should be returned (i) unless there has been a hearing pursuant to section one thousand twenty-seven of this [article] part on the removal of the child at which the parent or other person legally responsible for the child's care was present and had the opportunity to be represented by counsel, or (ii) upon good cause shown, which shall include a finding by the court, at any time in the proceedings, that a respondent parent is a non-respondent pursuant to section one thousand seventeen of this article. Except for good cause shown, such hearing shall be held within three court days of the application and shall not be adjourned. Upon such hearing, the court shall grant the application, unless it finds that the return presents an imminent risk to the child's life or health. If a parent or other person legally responsible for the care of a child waives his or her right to a hearing under this section, the court shall advise such person at that time that, notwithstanding such waiver, an application under this section may be made at any time during the pendency of the proceedings.

§ 8. This act shall take effect immediately.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the family court act, in relation to the basis for removal of children and the creation of "Melinda's Law"

Purpose

To provide a safe harbor for a non-abusive spouse to report abuse while still retaining custody of children.

Summary

Section 1 of this bill provides that this act will be known as "Melinda's Law."Section 2 of this bill provides for the legislative intent. Threats by the abusive spouse to call Child Protective Services are often used as a means to compel subjugation from the non-abusive spouse. This was the case for Melinda. The abuse she and her children suffered at the hands of her husband was horrific, and her husband used the threat of her children being taken away from her to keep her in the abusive relation- ship. Section 3 of this bill amends section 1012 of the Family Court Act, adding a new subdivision (o) to define "domestic violence." "Domestic violence" is defined as any conduct which would constitute an offense in the penal law, and created a substantial risk of physical or emotional harm regardless of whether such injury occurred, or any other abuse that creates a substantial risk of physical or emotional harm to such person or such person's child i regardless of whether such harm occurred, including but not limited to verbal, emotional or psychological abuse, including slapping. A new subdivision (p) is also added to define "victim spouse or domestic partner subjected to domestic violence." This is defined as the respondent spouse or domestic partner who is the non-abusive spouse or domestic partner, and is determined to be subjected to domestic violence as defined by the previous subdivision(o).Section 4 of this bill amends section 1017 of the Family Court Act by adding a new subdivision 1-a to provide for procedure determining whether there is a suitable person related to the child for custody purposes in the case of domestic violence. Paragraph (a) of this new section provides for what the court may determine for custody purposes. Subparagraphs (i) through (iii) list the factors the court may determine: whether either respondent has been subjected to domestic violence by the other respondent, and if so, whether such victim spouse or domestic partner subject to domestic violence reported the incident precipitating a removal order or hearing under this article of the Family Court Act, and if so, whether such victim spouse or domes- tic partner subjected to domestic violence has been neglectful or abusive in their behavior towards the child or children at issue. Para- graph (b) of this new section provides that if the court determines a respondent is a victim spouse or domestic partner subjected to domestic violence and reported such incident precipitating the order or hearing, then the court must deem that person a non-respondent for the purposes of the removal order or hearing, providing the victim spouse or domestic partner subjected to domestic violence was not neglectful or abusive in their behavior toward the child or children at issue. If the court finds such, the court must award custody to the non-respondent parent.Paragraph (c) of this new section provides that if a determi- nation is made that both parents remain respondents, the court can determine whether there is a suitable person related to the child for the purposes of custody.Paragraph (d) of this new section provides of the respondent abuser or take any other steps deemed necessary within its statutory and constitutional powers to determine whether or not a respondent is a victim spouse subjected to domestic violence.Paragraph (e) of this new section provides that this new subdivision shall not apply to instances of sexual crimes, murder, or where there have been prior incidents involving disfigurement of the child or children at issue.Section 5 of this bill renumbers paragraphs (vi) and (vii) of subdivision (a) of section 1022 of the Family Court Act and adds a new paragraph (vi) which provides that if the court determines that a respondent parent is a non-respondent for the reasons given by Family Court Act section 1017(1-a), the court shall issue a temporary order of protection against the respondent abuser.Section 6 of this bill amends subdivision (b) of section, 1027 of the Family Court Act to provide that if the court determines that a respondent parent is a non-respondent, the court shall issue a temporary order of protection against the respondent abuser.Section 7 of this bill amends subdivision (b) of section 1027 of the Family Court Act to provide that at any time in the proceedings for removal of a child, a finding by the court that a respondent parent is a non-respondent because of the determination that the non-respondent is a victim spouse or domestic partner subjected to domestic violence, a hearing will no longer be necessary for return of the child if this is shown.

Read the full memo (1,202 words)

Section 8 of this bill provides that this act shall take effect imme- diately.

Justification

This bill addresses a dilemma faced by many parents who are victims of domestic violence. One parent in New York that struggled with this dilemma is "Melinda," whose full name is not used to protect her fami- ly's privacy. Melinda is a woman suffering from battered person syndrome as a result of over twenty years of physical and psychological abuse by her husband. Like many parents who suffer from battered person syndrome, Melinda accepted her abuse with the belief that her children needed a father. Eventually, the abuse was directed at the children, prompting Melinda to warn her husband that she would go to the authorities if the abuse continued. In response, Melinda's husband issued his Own warning: that if she were to report him, Child Protective Services would take their children away. Unfortunately, her husband's threat was not unfounded. Current law does not adequately protect the interests of victims of domestic violence, who are deemed virtual accomplices in the abuse despite often being the party who reported the abuse in the first place. This is fundamentally unfair. The law should not lend credence to the threats of abusers who coerce their victims into remaining silent about domestic violence. Instead, the law should allow good parents to report domestic violence with the confidence that they will not be sepa- rated from their children for doing so. This bill achieves that goal while protecting the interests of the child through several safeguards. First, where the court deems a victim parent a "non respondent" and awards custody to that parent, the court shall issue a protection order against the abusive parent removing such parent awarding custody to a non-respondent parent where such parent has been neglectful or where serious crimes such as murder or sexual crimes have been committed. Third, the court shall only award custody to the victim parent if it is in the best interests of the child. This grant of judicial discretion

will allow courts to take into account other relevant circumstances not explicitly provided for in this bill.

Legislative history

2020 held for consideration in children and families in Assembly

2021- 2022 Referred to Children and Families

Fiscal implications for state and local governments

None

Effective date

This act shall take effect immediately.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.