What's happening
This bill requires that if an alternate juror replaces a regular juror, the jury must start deliberations over from the beginning.
Why it matters
Ensures full participation of all jurors. By requiring deliberations to start over when an alternate is substituted, the bill guarantees that the new juror is involved in the entire decision-making process, rather than just joining an ongoing discussion.
Promotes fairness and thoroughness. This change reduces the risk that earlier deliberations (without the alternate) could unfairly influence the final verdict, helping to ensure that all issues are reconsidered by the newly reconstituted jury.
Protects the rights of parties in the trial. Both plaintiffs and defendants benefit from having their case reviewed by a jury where all members have considered the evidence and issues from the beginning, potentially strengthening the legitimacy of the verdict.
Applies immediately and broadly. The bill covers not only future cases but also any ongoing proceedings, meaning its impact will be immediate and affect a wide array of current litigation.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Update Alternate Juror Rules
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
No co-sponsors yet.
History
- Referred to rules
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Revise Alternate Juror Rules
In Assembly Committee · Rules · Sponsor Jenifer Rajkumar
Full text
1 pageUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
9856
IN SENATE
June 6, 2024
Introduced by Sen. HOYLMAN-SIGAL -- (at request of the Office of Court Administration) -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Rules
AN ACT to amend the civil practice law and rules, in relation to alternate jurors
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Section 4106 of the civil practice law and rules, as amended by chapter 204 of the laws of 2013, is amended to read as follows:
§ 4106. Alternate jurors. One or more additional jurors, to be known as "alternate jurors", may be drawn upon the request of a party and consent of the court. Such alternate juror or jurors shall be drawn at the same time, from the same source, in the same manner, and have the same qualifications as regular jurors, and be subject to the same examinations and challenges. They shall be seated with, take the oath with, and be treated in the same manner as the regular jurors. After final submission of the case, the court may, in its discretion, retain such alternate juror or jurors to ensure availability if needed. At any time, before or after the final submission of the case, if a regular juror dies, or becomes ill, or is unable to perform the duties of a juror, the court may order that juror discharged and draw the name of an alternate, or retained alternate, if any, who shall replace the discharged juror, and be treated as if that juror had been selected as one of the regular jurors. Once deliberations have begun, the court may allow an alternate juror to participate in such deliberations only if a regular juror becomes unable to perform the duties of a juror. After an alternate juror has been substituted, the jury shall deliberate anew on all of the issues that were submitted to the jury at the outset of deliberations. Where a jury has rendered the verdict on one or more issues, and an alternate juror must be seated, the jury shall deliberate anew on all issues that were not determined by such rendered verdict.
§ 2. This act shall take effect immediately and shall apply to all actions and proceedings pending on or after such effective date.
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD11446-01-3
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the civil practice law and rules, in relation to alter- nate jurors
This is one in a series of measures being introduced at the request of the Acting Chief Administrative Judge upon the recommendation of her Advisory Committee on Civil Practice.
This measure would amend CPLR 4106 in relation to use of alternate jurors.
Read the full memo (639 words)
Selection of one or more alternate jurors at the request of a party and with the consent of the court is authorized by CPLR 4106. This provides an invaluable mechanism for continuing a trial and avoiding declaration of a mistrial when, during the trial, a juror is unable to continue to serve because of some physical or mental disability or evinces a bias or prejudice against one of the parties.
In 2013 (effective January 1, 2014), upon recommendation of the Advisory Committee, CPLR 4106 was revised to permit a court, without first secur- ing the permission of the parties, to seat an alternate juror after a case has been submitted to the jury and deliberations have begun, and to permit that juror to participate in deliberations if a regular juror has become unable to perform the duties of a juror. However, when an alter- nate is seated during deliberations, CPLR 4106 is silent as to whether the jury shall then continue to deliberate from the point where the alternate is seated, or must start deliberations over, from the begin- ning, even reconsidering issues that had been resolved by the original jurors.
This measure would amend CPLR 4106 to provide a direction that when an alternate juror is seated after deliberations have begun, the reconsti- tuted jury shall begin deliberations over again on all issues that were presented to the jury when the case was submitted to them.
No appellate courts have addressed this matter in New York. In Gallegos v. Elite Model Management Corporation, 28 A.D.3d 50 (1St Dep't, 2005), during deliberations in the damages trial of a bifurcated case, the trial judge seated two alternate jurors with this instruction to the newly constituted jury: "You are going to start deliberations from scratch... It is as if you were starting from the very beginning." On appeal, however, the damages verdict was reversed because, absent consent by defense counsel, the substitution of alternate jurors was improper.
We believe that when an alternate juror has been seated during deliber- ations, the court should instruct the newly constituted jury that it must start over and deliberate on all of the issues that were submitted to it when the deliberations began. Even though this procedure may prolong the length of deliberations, its virtues are several: the original jurors will now have the benefit of input from the newly substituted juror on all issues; the substituted juror will hear the positions previously advanced by those jurors. Those positions may now change. After a verdict is announced and a request is made to poll the jury, all six members of the reconstituted jury will be able to honestly state that it was, or was not, their verdict. The parties will have the assurance that all six jurors in the jury box, including the substituted juror, participated in the deliberations leading to the verdict.
We recognize that where trial has been bifurcated and a verdict has already been recorded in the liability phase, when an alternate is seat- ed in the damages phase, the newly constituted jury should be instructed to begin again only with regard to the issues raise in the damages phase.
We also recommend that the Pattern Jury Instruction Committee consider an amendment to PJI 1.13A to reflect these proposals.
This measure would take effect immediately and apply to all actions pending on or after such effective date.
Legislative history 2021-22
A7799 (MA Rajkumar)(Ref to Judiciary)
OCA-30
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.