Skip to content
S9857Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA8324

Dismiss Claims For Bad Pleading

Official title

“Relates to allowing for a dismissal of a claim based on claimant's failure to comply with pleading requirements”

Sponsor Brad Hoylman-SigalSD-47
Status
Senate Floor Calendar
Impact
4/10
Low
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Vetoed via A8324

What's happening

This bill allows claimants in the New York Court of Claims to request court permission to correct good faith mistakes in pleadings, except for errors in filing or service timing.

Why it matters

  1. Increases fairness and access to justice. by letting claimants fix honest mistakes or omissions in their pleadings, reducing the chance that technical errors (not related to deadlines or service) will automatically get a case dismissed.

  2. Balances claimant relief with protection for the state. by allowing corrections only if the other party (usually the state) is not prejudiced, ensuring that the right to defend is not undermined.

  3. Makes the legal process more efficient and less wasteful. by preventing potentially meritorious claims from being thrown out over minor, good-faith paperwork errors, possibly saving time and resources for both claimants and the court system.

  4. Standardizes court discretion. by formally giving judges the authority to allow corrections in pleadings, creating clearer guidelines and predictability for both claimants and attorneys handling claims against the state.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Dismiss Claims For Bad Pleading

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Brad Hoylman-Sigal

Senator · Senate District 47

Chair, Judiciary

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Substituted by A8324
  2. Ordered to third reading cal.1921
  3. Referred to rules

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A8324Assembly

Dismiss Claims for Bad Pleadings

Vetoed · Sponsor Jenifer Rajkumar

Impact 4 · LowVetoed

Full text

1 pageUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9857

IN SENATE

June 6, 2024

Introduced by Sen. HOYLMAN-SIGAL -- (at request of the Office of Court Administration) -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Rules

AN ACT to amend the court of claims act, in relation to allowing for dismissal of a claim based on claimant's failure to comply with pleading requirements

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Section 11 of the court of claims act is amended by adding a new subdivision d to read as follows:

d. A claimant may, at any time after the timely service of a notice of intention or timely filing and service of a claim, and at any stage of the action, apply to the court for permission to correct a mistake, omission, irregularity, or defect made in good faith in the notice of intention or claim required to be served by this section, not pertaining to the manner or time of filing and service thereof. The notice of intention and/or claim may be corrected, supplied, or disregarded, as the case may be, in the discretion of the court, provided it shall appear that the other party was not prejudiced thereby.

If such permission is granted, the notice of intention and/or claim shall be deemed corrected nunc pro tunc. The application to correct shall be accompanied by a copy of the proposed corrected notice of intention and/or claim.

§ 2. This act shall take effect immediately.

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD11460-01-3

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the court of claims act, in relation to allowing for dismissal of a claim based on claimant's failure to comply with pleading requirements

AN ACT to amend the court of claims act, in relation to allowing for dismissal of a claim based on claimant's failure to comply with pleading requirements

This is one in a series of measures being introduced at the request of the Chief Administrative Judge upon the recommendation of his Advisory Committee on Civil Practice.

Read the full memo (829 words)

This measure would amend Court of Claims Act § 11 by adding a new subdi- vision (d) to permit an amendment to the notice of intention or claim to be freely granted at any time during the pendency of an action absent a showing of prejudice by the State.

This measure would supply a procedure for a claimant to correct a good faith mistake, omission, irregularity or defect in the notice of inten- tion or claim even when such error resulted in no prejudice to the State.

Background

The Court of Claims Act (CCA) requires that a claimant either serve and file a claim or serve a notice of intention within a specified time after accrual of the claim in order to permit the State to timely inves- tigate the allegations. (CCA § 10-1, 2, 3, 3-a, 3-b, 4 and 5.)

The CCA has provisions for a claimant who fails to timely serve or file a notice of intention or claim, (see § 10-6 and 8(a)), but it has no provision allowing a claimant to amend a timely served notice of inten- tion or timely served and filed claim to correct a mistake, omission, irregularity, or other defect.

In contrast to the CCA, the General Municipal Law (GML) 50-e specif- ically provides a remedy to correct an error in a timely filed notice of claim made in good faith which does not prejudice the municipality.

This proposed measure seeks to incorporate the language of GML 50-e into the CCA.

Justification

A new provision specifically addressed to circumstances where a notice of intention or claim is timely served or filed but contains an error made in good faith which results in no prejudice to the State is neces- sary to avoid the dismissal of a potentially meritorious case for purely procedural reasons. As noted by Professor Vincent Alexander (a member of the committee) in the Practice Commentaries to CPLR 2001, a statute permitting the correction of non-prejudicial mistakes is essential in an enlightened system of civil procedure that eschews the elevation of form over substance.

The need for a provision to allow for amending a timely served notice or served and filed claim is demonstrated by Constable v. State of New York, 172 A.D. 3d 681 (Second Dept. 2019), where the claim was dismissed because the notice of intention and claim failed to adequately describe the location of the alleged accident. As noted in the decision, the State's motion seeking dismissal was filed six months after the last deposition was conducted.

In another case, Hyatt v. State of New York, 2018 NY Slip Op 51983 (U), the claimant's action was dismissed because he had incorrectly described the location of the automobile accident in his otherwise timely notice of intention and claim. The claimant had relied on incorrect information provided in the report issued by the New York State Police which had investigated the accident. The claimant's subsequent attorneys discov- ered the mistake, and the claimant sought permission to serve an amended notice of intention to file a claim and moved to serve and file a late claim. The Court of Claims noted that there was no provision in the CCA for service of an amended notice of intention to file a claim. Instead, the Court weighed the factors set forth in CCA § 10(6) and denied the application to file a late claim. The decision is presently on appeal.

The more stringent requirements for filing a late claim under CCA § 10(6) are not available even to a claimant who has timely served or filed initially unless an application is made within the prescribed statute of limitations. This measure would ensure that a claimant who has timely served or filed is not precluded from correcting the good faith error or omission solely because the statute of limitations has run. This measure is intended to provide a remedy in the interest of justice to a claimant who timely serves a notice of intention or serves and files a claim which contains an error that caused no prejudice to the State.

Change in existing law

This measure is intended to provide a remedy in the interest of justice to a claimant who timely serves a notice of intention or serves and files a claim which contains an error that caused no prejudice to the State. This measure would take effect immediately.

Legislative history 2021-22

A7797 (MA Rajkumar)(PASSED) OCA-31

Legislative history 2019-20

OCA-77

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.