What's happening
This bill makes the DAMP tax exemption for Housing Development Fund Company (HDFC) co-ops permanent, clarifies their rights regarding dissolution, and updates rules for distressed HDFCs.
Why it matters
Provides long-term stability for HDFC co-ops and their residents. by making the DAMP tax exemption permanent, eliminating the looming expiration in 2029 that has threatened affordability and access to mortgage financing. This stability can help preserve affordable homeownership for thousands of low- and moderate-income families.
Clarifies legal rights concerning dissolution and reincorporation. by explicitly stating that HDFCs whose regulatory agreements and tax benefits have expired can dissolve and reincorporate as market-rate co-ops—but only if they are no longer receiving tax exemptions or abatements. This clarity ends years of legal uncertainty and prevents arbitrary barriers to co-ops’ self-determination.
Incentivizes continued affordability in exchange for tax benefits. by requiring HDFCs that wish to keep tax exemptions to adhere to specific affordability and income restrictions when selling apartments. This approach balances autonomy with public benefit, encouraging more HDFCs to voluntarily remain affordable co-ops rather than convert to market-rate housing.
Strengthens protections for distressed HDFCs and their neighborhoods. by updating eligibility for special tax forgiveness for financially troubled HDFCs, allowing more co-ops at risk of tax foreclosure to access relief. This prevents loss of affordable housing and helps stabilize communities facing displacement pressures.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Protect Affordable Co-ops
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
No co-sponsors yet.
History
- Referred to rules
Full text
9 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
9950
IN SENATE
November 20, 2024
Introduced by Sen. JACKSON -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Rules
AN ACT to amend the private housing finance law, in relation to enacting the housing development fund company self-determination, preservation and affordability act
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Short title. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "housing development fund company self-determination, preservation and affordability act".
§ 2. Legislative findings and declarations. 1. In 1966, the Legislature enacted Article 11 of the private housing finance law. Article 11 authorized the development of rental and cooperative housing that is subject to certain income restrictions. The type of income-restricted housing is referred to as housing development fund companies (HDFCs).
2. Beginning in the early 1980s, New York city adopted the HDFC form of housing cooperative as a means to divest itself of -- and revitalize -- its tax-foreclosed multi-family housing stock. At the time the city was experiencing large-scale abandonment of its private low and middleincome multi-family housing stock. In response to this housing crisis, the city determined to turn over the ownership and management of many city-owned tax-foreclosed multifamily buildings to the existing tenants in the form of HDFC co-ops.
3. Previously, the city sold at auction nearly all of its tax-foreclosed multi-family property to private investors - and that traditional approach to disposing of tax foreclosed property had led to an accelerating cycle of housing disinvestment and abandonment. The city's HDFC initiative was in the city's own interests: it enabled the city to avoid the counterproductive private auction process and to return the buildings to the tax rolls.
4. Over the past four decades the city's HDFC initiative proved to be one of New York's most enduring housing success stories. Tens of thousands of resident-shareholders of HDFCs played an important role in the stabilization and preservation of New York city's multi-family housing
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD16173-04-4
stock in the period following the city's fiscal crisis of the 1970s and 1980s. The city's large-scale creation of HDFC co-ops was a major policy innovation and was an important part of the city's response to the housing crisis of that era. Today, there are over 1,100 HDFC co-ops in New York city.
5. All government and community stakeholders benefitted from the large-scale creation of HDFCs. The city benefitted by reducing its enormous portfolio of tax-foreclosed apartment buildings at a time when the buildings were a substantial burden to the city and when there was little in the way of a private market for these properties. The residents benefitted by the preservation and upgrading of their own buildings and by becoming homeowners for the first time. And the surrounding communities benefitted by the stabilization of the neighborhood, the upgrading of housing and by the transformation of a rental community into a homeowning community.
6. When the city imposed regulatory controls on the city-sponsored HDFCs, the regulatory controls placed on HDFCs were time-limited. Consequently, the HDFCs that were created in the 1980s and 1990s have regulatory controls that already have expired or will soon expire. For this class of HDFCs, there is a great deal of uncertainty as to their legal status and their financial future.
7. This legislation clarifies the legal status of HDFCs with expired regulatory controls in a way that protects and promotes their autonomy and self-governance while strengthening the inducements for these HDFCs to voluntarily agree to continue to operate as affordable housing.
8. An important feature of city-sponsored HDFCs is the city's use of its authority to enter into a "regulatory agreement" with the HDFC. Under section 576 of the private housing finance law, either the state or the municipal "supervisory agency" (i.e., HPD) may enter into a regulatory agreement with an HDFC if the agency advances public funds to the HDFC. Under such section of the private housing finance law, every HDFC regulatory agreement must provide that:
(1) Households must meet income eligibility guidelines, which are defined by statute as six times the annual rent plus six percent of the shareholder's "original investment" in the HDFC. See paragraph b of subdivision 1 of section 576 of the private housing finance law.
(2) Profits must be used only for capital improvements or to reduce rent/maintenance. Dividends cannot be paid to owners. See paragraphs c and d of subdivision 1 of section 576 of the private housing finance law.
(3) The property may not be sold or transferred without HPD approval for so long as the regulatory agreement remains in effect and/or unless and until any funds or mortgages owed to the city are paid in full. See paragraph e of subdivision 1 of section 576 of the private housing finance law.
(4) The HDFC may not be dissolved without HPD approval for so long as the regulatory agreement remains in effect and/or unless and until any funds or mortgages owed to the city are paid in full. See paragraph e of subdivision 1 of section 576 of the private housing finance law.
9. Thus, under section 576 of the private housing finance law certain key restrictions remains in effect only for so long as a regulatory agreement remains in effect. Put differently, the city's authority to impose section 576 restrictions (including restrictions on dissolution of HDFCs and on the sale and disposition of HDFC property) is limited to only those HDFCs that are subject to a regulatory agreement and does not extend to HDFCs in which a regulatory agreement or mortgage is no longer in effect.
10. The city applied its section 576 authority to HDFCs in two ways: i.e. (1) some of the terms of the section 576 "regulatory agreement" were incorporated into various HDFC incorporation documents and in the deed conveying title to the property; and (2) a regulatory agreement was incorporated into mortgage documents when the city made loans to HDFCs to finance capital improvements. In each case the city imposed resale restrictions that had a fixed term. At the inception of the HDFC program in the early 1980s, city-sponsored resale restrictions imposed by the sale documents expired in ten years. By the late 1980s, city-sponsored resale restrictions imposed by the sale documents ran for 25 years. Furthermore, resale restrictions that were made a part of city-sponsored rehabilitation loans to HDFCs ran for the life of the loan -- i.e., usually 15 to 25 years.
11. Thus, the city used section 576 of the private housing finance law as a means to impose additional terms and conditions (including resale restrictions) on the operation of the HDFC for a fixed term following the establishment of the housing cooperative or during the life of a city-sponsored loan to the HDFC. For the vast majority of HDFCs, these restrictions have expired.
12. There are presently over 1,100 HDFCs in New York city containing approximately 25,000 apartments. Of these HDFCs, approximately 20 percent are subject to regulatory agreements. A substantial number of non-regulated HDFCs date from the 1980s and 1990s. These older HDFCs are no longer subject to city resale restrictions that expired after either ten years or 25 years following the incorporation of the HDFCs.
13. For as long as a particular city-imposed resale restrictions remained in effect, an HDFC is subject to a detailed scheme of regulations imposed by the city pursuant to section 576 of the private housing finance law. In general, HPD resale restrictions govern such important issues of HDFC governance as income limitations for purchasers, succession rights, sublet rights, flip taxes, HPD consent as a precondition to the sale of an HDFC building and HPD consent to the dissolution of an HDFC. Upon the expiration of the city-imposed restrictions, the HDFC is no longer subject to these externally imposed regulations.
14. An HDFC with expired regulatory controls nevertheless remains subject to Article 11 of the private housing finance law as well as to various governing documents, such as its certificate of incorporation, deed restrictions, proprietary lease and by-laws. Most importantly, an HDFC is required to provide housing for "persons of low income," as defined in paragraph a of subdivision 3 of section 573 of the private housing finance law. However, once an HDFC regulatory agreement or other HPD-imposed income restriction has expired, nothing in the private housing finance law expressly precludes these HDFC co-ops from converting to a non-HDFC co-op by reincorporating as a conventional co-op (and thereby opting out of the remaining statutory restrictions imposed by the private housing finance law). That circumstance raised the possibility that some HDFCs may opt-out of the HDFC statute and become market-rate housing - which would represent a loss to the city's inventory of affordable housing stock.
15. A city-established HDFC is eligible to receive a partial real estate tax exemption granted by the city pursuant to section 577 of the private housing finance law. Pursuant to this authority, the city in 1989 enacted a partial tax exemption for most city-sponsored HDFCs. The tax exemption is generally referred to as the "Division of Alternative Management Programs" tax exemption, or "DAMP tax exemption".
16. The tax exemption runs for forty years and will expire in 2029. A condition of the DAMP tax exemption is that the HDFC remain an HDFC for the duration of the tax exemption. Hence, an HDFC that opt-outs of the HDFC statute and become market-rate housing would be required to forfeit the DAMP tax exemption.
17. The city in 2017 proposed local legislation that would revoke the DAMP tax exemption from any HDFC that declined to sign a new regulatory agreement with HPD. The proposed new regulatory agreement would contain many provisions that would largely deprive HDFCs of autonomy and selfdetermination, including the imposition of external fiscal monitors paid for by HDFC income, new restriction on apartment sales and subletting, and limitations on the assets and other real property owned by HDFC shareholders. By 2019 the city abandoned the proposed legislation in the face of widespread opposition by HDFC community groups and other stakeholders.
18. Also in 2017, the city proposed new state legislation that would re-regulate HDFCs and that would change the law to ensure that all HDFCs remain subject to affordability controls in perpetuity. See S2543 (2017) (proposed amendment to the private housing finance law). As stated in the city's memorandum in support of S2543:
"(T)here is a great need for an amendment to clarify that the corporate purpose of an HDFC -- to provide affordable housing to persons and families of low income -- is perpetual in duration. Absent the checks and balances provided by the (proposed amendment to private housing finance law, which would subject HDFCs for the time to the requirements of the not-for-profit corporation law), there may be a great loss of affordable housing."
19. Thus, the city expressly acknowledged that, under existing law, HDFCs with expired regulatory agreements have the option of remaining as an HDFC or, in the alternative, the option of converting to another form of housing cooperative without affordability controls. S2453 was intended to eliminate the second option. Ultimately, S2453 was not enacted and the statutory law governing HDFCs remains unchanged.
20. Contrary to the city's 2017 statement, the New York Attorney General issued an opinion in 2015 to the effect that HDFC cooperatives could never opt-out of the PHFL and that they were subject to the perpetual regulation of the HPD Commissioner. See New York Attorney General, "Guidance on Housing Development Fund Corporations Seeking to Transfer or Sell Property for, or Otherwise Convert Property to Market- Rate Use" (hereafter "Guidance"). HPD joined in the Guidance. The Attorney General reached this conclusion based on his determination that the statutory term "amendment" - as used in subdivision 5 of section 573 of the private housing finance law - encompassed and implied the commissioner's additional authority to consent to the dissolution of an HDFC. The Attorney General's Guidance is incorrect as a matter of law, in that it misconstrues the plain text of the HDFC statute as well as ignores the distinct treatment of the concepts of "amendment" and "dissolution" in other New York corporate law settings, including the business corporation law.
21. Consistent with the city's 2017 statement, HDFCs always have had the right under the private housing finance law -- and continue to have the right under the private housing finance law -- to dissolve and reincorporate under the business corporation law or other applicable law, provided that the housing development fund company: (1) was formerly subject to a regulatory agreement but such regulatory agreement has expired and/or was formerly subject to contractual restrictions implementing the requirements of section 576 of the private housing finance law but that such contractual restrictions have expired; and (2) had formerly received a tax exemption under section 577 of the private housing finance law but such tax exemption either has expired or is otherwise no longer being received.
22. This legislation squarely addresses the legal uncertainty that threatens the future of many city-sponsored HDFCs. More particularly, this legislation has three overriding goals: (1) to protect and promote the self-determination of HDFC co-ops; (2) to provide strong incentives for HDFC co-ops with expired controls to agree to remain as affordable housing; and (3) to ensure that the HDFC co-ops that agree to remain as affordable housing are in sound condition and are economically self-sufficient. These three overriding objectives are complementary.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the private housing finance law, in relation to enacting the housing development fund company self-determination, preservation and affordability act
Purpose
To clarify and update the private housing finance law to incentivize housing development fund company (HDFC) cooperatives to remain in NYC's affordable housing stock and to promote their long-term viability and continued affordability.
Summary of provisions
Section 1 states that this act shall be known and may be cited as the "housing development fund company self-determination, preservat ion and affordability act."
Read the full memo (944 words)
Section 2 includes legislative findings and declarations regarding the history and development of HDFCs and the challenges HDFCs face with the sunsetting in 2029 of the partial tax exemption.
Section 3 amends subdivision 5 of § 573 of the private housing finance law and provides that an HDFC with expired regulatory controls may dissolve and re-incorporate under the business corporation law or anoth- er applicable law, provided that the HDFC is no longer receiving tax benefits under § 577. Section 3 clarifies the rights that HDFCs already have under the existing law.
Section 4 amends § 576 of the private housing finance law by adding a new subdivision 4, which provides that an HDFC that is no longer subject to regulatory controls imposed by the commissioner or supervising agency shall continue to be subject to the oversight of t he commissioner or supervising agency, as long as it elects to receive a tax exemption or abatement under § 577 of the private housing finance law. If an HDFC elects not to receive this tax exemption or abatement, it will no longer be subject to the regulation and oversight of the commissioner or super- vising agency.
Section 5 amends subdivision 1 of § 577 of the private housing finance law to grant a tax exemption and abatement to HDFCs that comply with specified affordability requirements. This section details that HDFCs electing to receive this benefit must limit the income o f purchasers to either the threshold set in paragraph b of subdivision 1 of § 576 or to 165% of the area median income as determined by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. Section 5 also requires HDFCs to file an annual certification confirming compliance with these affordability requirements and grants the supervising agency authority to audit sales records and to suspend or revoke the tax exemption and abatement if an HDFC is found in willful noncompliance.
Section 6 amends paragraph (b) of subdivision 1 of § 577-b of the private housing finance law, specifying that for the term eligible prop- erty to apply under this section, an HDFC must have outstanding munici- pal real estate taxes as of January 1, 2024, relating to an y period prior to January 1, 2023. This amendment replaces the previous require- ment, which was based on outstanding taxes as of January 1, 2002, for periods prior to January 1, 2001. Section 6 applies to certain HDFCs with real estate tax arrears of one year or more and that require finan- cial assistance with appropriate oversight by the supervisory agency.
Section 7 sets the effective date.
Justification
Housing Development Fund Companies (HDFCs) have been a crucial source of affordable housing for New York City residents since the early 1980s, when the city converted hundreds of tax-foreclosed multifamily buildings into cooperatively owned housing. Today, over 1,100 HDFCs provide affordable homes to approximately 90,000 New Yorkers. However, these affordable housing cooperatives are at a crossro ads. HDFCs were initially subject to fixed-term regulatory controls that maintained affordability and imposed certain regulatory controls. As these controls expire and the partial tax exemption sunsets, many HDFCs face uncertainty as to their legal status and financial future.
This bill would address this uncertainty by clarifying that under exist- ing law HDFCs with expired regulatory controls have the autonomy to determine their future, while incentivizing them to remain permanently affordable and promoting their long-term economic viability. The bill offers tax incentives for HDFCs that elect to remain affordable, ensur- ing they continue to serve low and middle-income residents and remain in New York City's affordable housing stock. The bill clarifies that HDFCs may dissolve and re-incorporate if they so choose, without consent from the commissioner or supervisory agency, provided they are no longer bound by regulatory controls and provided further that they elect to no longer receive HDFC tax benefits.
The DAMP (Division of Alternative Management Programs) tax exemption for HDFCs is set to expire in 2029, which may lead some HDFCs to convert to market-rate housing or simply abandon affordability restrictions to avoid financial collapse. This bill provides incentives for HDFCs to remain affordable by offering a tax exemption and abatement to those that meet income limitations and other condition s designed to support long-term financial stability for their 90,000 residents. The bill also establishes annual compliance requirements to ensure HDFCs receiving these tax benefits adhere to affordability standards.
By providing HDFCs with a clear legal framework, this bill ensures that these vital housing resources remain accessible to low and middle-income New Yorkers and that HDFCs that agree to remain as affordable housing are in sound condition and are economically self-sufffficient. This bill recognizes the contributions of HDFC shareholders who have worked to stabilize and improve their communities and respects their right to homeownership and self-determination. In addition, the bill addresses ambiguities in current law that have left HDFCs with limited guidance as their original regulatory controls expire.
Legislative history
New Legislation
Fiscal implications
Minimal
Effective date
This act shall take effect on the first of January next succeeding the date on which it shall have become a law.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.