Monday, February 13, 2023 · 11:35 AM–7:09 PM · 2023–24 session
Finance, Ways and Means
BEFORE THE NEW YORK STATE SENATE FINANCE
AND ASSEMBLY WAYS AND MEANS COMMITTEE
--------------------------------------------------
JOINT LEGISLATIVE HEARING
In the Matter of the
2023-2024 EXECUTIVE BUDGET ON
HUMAN SERVICES
----------------------------------------------------
Hearing Room B
Legislative Office Building
Albany, NY
February 13, 2023
11:35 a.m.
PRESIDING:
Senator Liz Krueger
Chair, Senate Finance Committee
Assemblywoman Helene E. Weinstein
Chair, Assembly Ways & Means Committee
PRESENT:
Senator Thomas F. O'Mara
Senate Finance Committee (RM)
Assemblyman Edward P. Ra
Assembly Ways & Means Committee (RM)
Senator Jabari Brisport
Chair, Senate Committee on Children
and Families
Assemblywoman Maritza Davila
Chair, Assembly Committee on Social Services
Senator Roxanne Persaud
Chair, Senate Committee on Social Services
Assemblyman Ron Kim
Chair, Assembly Committee on Aging
2023-2024 Executive Budget
Human Services
2-13-23
PRESENT: (Continued)
Senator Cordell Cleare
Chair, Senate Committee on Aging
Assemblywoman Kimberly Jean-Pierre
Chair, Assembly Committee on Veterans' Affairs
Senator Jessica Scarcella-Spanton
Chair, Senate Committee on Veterans,
Homeland Security and Military Affairs
Assemblyman Khaleel M. Anderson
Senator John C. Liu
Assemblyman Eric M. Dilan
Assemblywoman Jennifer Lunsford
Senator Samra G. Brouk
Assemblywoman Yudelka Tapia
Senator Andrew Gounardes
Assemblywoman Grace Lee
Assemblyman William Conrad
Assemblywoman Jo Anne Simon
Senator Jake Ashby
Assemblyman Jeff Gallahan
Assemblywoman Taylor Darling
Assemblyman Brian Maher
Senator Dean Murray
Assemblyman Chris Eachus
2023-2024 Executive Budget
Human Services
2-13-23
PRESENT: (Continued)
Assemblywoman Sarah Clark
Senator Rob Rolison
Assemblywoman Marcela Mitaynes
Assemblyman Chris Burdick
Assemblywoman Jessica González-Rojas
Assemblywoman Karines Reyes
Senator Alexis Weik
Assemblywoman Phara Souffrant Forrest
Assemblyman Tony Simone
Assemblywoman Pamela J. Hunter
Assemblywoman Jenifer Rajkumar
Assemblyman Sam Pirozzolo
Assemblywoman Marjorie Byrnes
Senator Peter Oberacker
Assemblyman Juan Ardila
Assemblywoman Alicia Hyndman
Assemblyman Andy Goodell
Assemblyman Lester Chang
Senator Rachel May
Assemblyman Angelo J. Morinello
2023-2024 Executive Budget
Human Services
2-13-2023
LIST OF SPEAKERS
STATEMENT QUESTIONS
Suzanne Miles-Gustave, Esq.
Acting Commissioner
NYS Office of Children
and Family Services
-and-
Daniel W. Tietz
Commissioner
NYS Office of Temporary
and Disability Assistance 13 31
Greg Olsen
Acting Director
NYS Office for the Aging
-and-
Rev. Viviana DeCohen
Director
NYS Division of Veterans'
Services 180 194
Meredith Chimento
Executive Director
Early Care & Learning Council
-and-
Steven Morales
NY Policy Director
All Our Kin
-and-
Krista Hesdorfer
Government Relations Manager
Hunger Solutions New York
-and-
Kate Ryan
Executive Director
Adirondack Birth to Three Alliance
-and-
Elizabeth Isakson, MD
Executive Director
Docs for Tots
-on behalf of-
Help Me Grow NYS 296 315
2023-2024 Executive Budget
Human Services
2-13-2023
LIST OF SPEAKERS, Continued
STATEMENT QUESTIONS
Gail Myers
Deputy Director
NY StateWide Senior Action Council
-and-
Rebecca Preve
Executive Director
Association on Aging in New York
-and-
Kimberly George
President and CEO
Project Guardianship
-and-
Beth Finkel
State Director
AARP New York 341 356
Trudy Morgan
Policy Director
NYS Network for Youth Success
-and-
Bonnie Landi
Chair
NYS YouthBuild Coalition
-and-
William T. Gettman, Jr.
CEO
Northern Rivers Family
of Services
-and-
Timothy Hathaway
Executive Director
Prevent Child Abuse New York
-and-
Kathleen Brady-Stepien
President & CEO
Council of Family and
Child Caring Agencies
-and-
Nicole Bryl
CEO
Children's Health Home of
Upstate New York 382 403
2023-2024 Executive Budget
Human Services
2-13-2023
LIST OF SPEAKERS, Continued
STATEMENT QUESTIONS
Joan Gerhardt
Director of Public Policy
and advocacy
New York State Coalition Against
Domestic Violence
-and-
Emilia Sicilia
Managing Attorney
Empire Justice Center
-and-
Dede Hill
Director of Policy
Schuyler Center for
Analysis & Advocacy
-and-
MJ Okma
Senior Manager of Advocacy and
Government Relations
SAGE-Advocacy & Services for
LGBTQ+ Elders
-and-
Stephen Piasecki
Upstate Coordinator
Supportive Housing Network
of New York
-and-
Melinda Mack
Executive Director
New York Association of
Training and Employment 414 433
2023-2024 Executive Budget
Human Services
2-13-23
LIST OF SPEAKERS, Continued
STATEMENT QUESTIONS
Gavin T. Walters Sr.
NYS Dwyer Coalition Facilitator
Hudson Valley National Center
for Veteran Reintegrating
-and-
Kirby Hannan
Board Member
New York State Council of
Veteran Organizations 459 467CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Good morning.
I am Helene Weinstein, chair of the New York State Assembly's Ways and Means Committee and cochair of today's hearing.
Today we begin the sixth in a series of hearings conducted by the joint fiscal committees of the Legislature regarding the Governor's proposed budget for 2023-'24. The hearings are conducted pursuant to the New York State Constitution and the Legislative Law.
And today the Assembly Ways and Means Committee and the Senate Finance Committee will hear testimony concerning the Governor's budget proposal for human services.
I'll now introduce the members who are here from the -- in the majority in the Assembly, and then Senator Krueger, chair of the Senate Finance Committee, will introduce her colleagues. And then our ranking members will introduce their colleagues.
So first we have the chair of our Social Services Committee, Assemblywoman Maritza Davila. We have Assemblyman Conrad, Assemblywoman Lee, Assemblywoman Lunsford, Assemblywoman Simon.
And I just wanted to mention that some of our -- that Assemblyman Hevesi unfortunately -- chair of our Children and Families Committee -- couldn't be here today.
We have Assemblywoman Clark with us.
Senator Krueger?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you very much.
Good morning. We are joined by Senator Jabari Brisport, Roxanne Persaud, John Liu.
Senator O'Mara, from the Republican rankers side, is running a little late, but we are joined also by Senator Murray, Senator Weik, Senator Ashby, and Senator Rolison.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Assemblyman Ra, if you can introduce your colleagues.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Yes, good morning.
We are joined by Assemblyman Gallahan; Assemblywoman Byrnes, our ranker on Children and Families; and Assemblyman Maher, our ranker on Social Services.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
I just want to -- so we have Assemblywoman Darling, who's joined us. And I do think -- oh, sorry, and Assemblyman Eachus, who's joined us.
And with that, let me go over the ground rules for today. For both witnesses and members, I just want to mention the time clocks and the times. That's -- well, actually for the governmental witnesses, let me start there, you'll each have your panel, but you each have 10 minutes to make your presentations. And after both of you have concluded, we will then have questions from the respective members of both houses.
Nongovernmental witnesses, many of whom are I believe sitting here will have three minutes to make their presentation. And I believe everyone will be in a panel. Each member of the panel gets three minutes, and then members will have an opportunity to ask questions.
In terms of the legislators, in terms of asking questions of the governmental witnesses, they're 10 minutes for the chair -- that's 10 minutes for the panel, not each individual witness. For the rankers of those -- of the respective committees, it's five minutes to ask questions and answers. All other -- and the chairs do get a second round of three minutes if they need it.
All other members, it's three minutes to ask questions. And when I say ask questions, it's questions and to get the answer.
Senator Krueger and I have needed to have a gavel handy after we had an incident at our first -- at one of our early hearings. We've yet to have to use it. And as Senator Krueger says, we haven't figured out if it's to bang the gavel on the table or to throw it at unruly individuals.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Legislators, not the audience.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Not the audience, yes. The legislators.
So I just encourage my colleagues, don't make us have to make a decision on that.
(Laughter.)
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:So with that, I believe -- and I know there will be a number of members coming and going. We do ask the members to please indicate, by the time the governmental panel has finished making the presentation, if you want to ask a question. Because otherwise we find that people come in an hour into it and start asking questions that have already been asked.
So with that, I'd like to introduce our -- and welcome our first presenters for today, Suzanne Miles-Gustave, acting commissioner, New York State Office of Children and Families, and Daniel Tietz, New York State Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance.
So if -- Suzanne, if you can go first, and then we'll move on. Thank you.
Oh, and just before you go, I'm sorry, I just want to -- both -- for everyone listening, all of your testimony has been distributed and received by the members, so please don't read your full testimony. The time goes much faster than people think it does, and then we end up not hearing the meat of what you want to present to us.
So thank you.
Senator Krueger, did you want to introduce some colleagues?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:I do. I just want to introduce Senator Cordell Cleare.
Did any other Senators sneak in? I think that's it. Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you. I'm sorry, Suzanne, if you can begin.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Thank you. Good morning, Chairs Krueger and Weinstein, and Children and Families Committee Chairs Brisport and Hevesi -- in his absence -- and distinguished members of the Senate and Assembly.
I am Suzanne Miles-Gustave, the acting commissioner of the New York State Office of Children and Family Services. I appreciate this opportunity to present Governor Hochul's fiscal year 2024 budget and its potential to enhance our mission -- a mission I know is near and dear to each of you as well -- ensuring all of New York's children, families and communities are served and uplifted.
This year's Executive Budget makes smart, responsible investments and provides ongoing support for OCFS's core childcare, child welfare, and juvenile justice programs while advancing a bold and ambitious agenda to make New York more affordable, more livable, and more equitable for all New Yorkers.
The Governor's budget proposals thoughtfully weave investments in children and families into the fabric of the larger human services network, rebuilding New York's mental health care system and addressing the housing crisis.
Never before in New York's history have we had a Governor with such a deep commitment to increasing access to quality, affordable childcare than Governor Hochul. From the moment she took office, it has been among the Governor's top priorities to build the strong and equitable childcare system that New Yorkers need and deserve.
Building on the extraordinary momentum of last year's budget, this proposal increases the state's commitment to childcare assistance to an unprecedented 7.6 billion over four years. The budget would also increase the income eligibility limits for childcare assistance to 85 percent of the state median income -- that's approximately 93,000 per year for a family of four. This is the maximum allowable by federal law and will make an estimated 113,000 children newly eligible for childcare assistance. In total, the Executive Budget invests over 1 billion for the New York State Child Care Block Grant, an increase from year to year of $137.5 million.
And we'll address the patchwork of standards across the state, ensuring that all of our most vulnerable families -- such as those who are unhoused or those who are caring for children in foster care or kinship care -- are provided the childcare assistance they so desperately need.
There's no doubt we need this funding to make childcare assistance available to more families. But we also know that less than 10 percent of all eligible children actually receive assistance. Although there are many reasons this might be the case, one barrier is New York's cumbersome and antiquated application process, which makes it far too difficult for families to apply for assistance. This year's budget includes important initiatives to streamline and centralize the childcare assistance application process.
First, we'll launch a statewide online solution that will allow families to pre-screen for eligibility and apply for assistance electronically.
Additionally, for families that already participate in other programs such as SNAP, HEAP, Medicaid and WIC, the budget proposes to eliminate the senseless and redundant requirement that these families also prove their income eligibility for childcare assistance. This will provide easier access for an estimated 83,000 children and families that are already eligible.
Last year we invested in a second round of stabilization grants for providers, with at least 75 percent of those funds dedicated specifically to supporting the workforce. This year the budget invests an additional 389 million for a third round of stabilization grants for workforce retention incentives.
The budget also maintains last year's investment to support the increase in the market rate to the 80th percentile, among the highest in the nation -- which not only broadens childcare options for families but also dramatically increases payments to providers, by over 40 percent for some.
Building off of last year's successful $100 million childcare desert initiative, the Governor's budget also includes several proposals aimed at rebuilding the supply of childcare.
First, New York Homes and Community Renewal will give priority to applications for its low-income housing tax credit that incorporate space for childcare facilities. On top of that, the budget proposes a flexible statewide business income tax credit for businesses that create or expand childcare slots for their employees.
The budget also provides 4.8 million to launch a new Employer-Supported Childcare Pilot Program in three regions of the state. Employers would contribute a third of the cost for low- and middle-income families, and the state will match it, reducing out-of-pocket costs for families who would not otherwise be eligible for childcare assistance.
Finally, the budget invests $1 million in state dollars for a new business navigator program in each of the state's 10 Regional Economic Development Council regions, to help businesses identify childcare options for their employees.
The Executive Budget also makes important investments in New York's most vulnerable children and families by investing 7 million for preventive and permanency placement services for foster, adoptive and kinship families. The 2.5 percent COLA that's included in this year's budget will also benefit families and the voluntary agencies who care for New York's children in foster care and adoptive parents.
The budget also increases the appropriation authority for child welfare payments, reinforcing the state's commitment to this landmark funding stream that provides an open-ended reimbursement for preventive services, child protective services, independent living services, after-care services, and adoption assistance.
The budget includes 17 million to support voluntary foster care agencies that provide medically necessary care to children and youth placed in congregate settings and that are impacted by federal requirements related to Institutions for Mental Disease, or IMD. For impacted voluntary foster care agencies, this funding will support the hiring of necessary staff, mitigate the loss of federal Medicaid reimbursement, and allow them to invest in additional programmatic needs.
OCFS applauds Governor Hochul's proposal to index the state's minimum wage to inflation, which will provide a vital economic lifeline to New York's low-wage workers, who are disproportionately women and people of color, and many of whom work in human services.
We continue to face a daunting workforce crisis in careers that are critical to OCFS's mission. The Governor's budget also includes 3.8 million to supplement state-funded contracts to mitigate the impact of the wage increase on struggling human services providers.
Before I close and take your questions, I just wanted to take a moment to say that I'm thrilled to work in partnership with each of you to accomplish these very lofty goals. It is my unwavering intention that our services reflect the communities we serve, that we hear the voices of children, parents and providers, and that our work promotes a safe, equitable and justice-driven reality for all New Yorkers. This is OCFS's mission.
In closing, this budget reflects our commitment to the safety and permanency of New York's children and families and to uplifting all New Yorkers to a standard that reflects the dignity and humanity of us all. Thank you so much.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Yes. Yes, you can go, and then we'll have questions.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Thank you.
Good morning, Chairpersons Krueger and Weinstein, Social Services Committee chairs Persaud and Davila, and the other members of the Senate and Assembly.
I'm Daniel W. Tietz, the commissioner of the Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance. I welcome the opportunity to speak to you today about Governor Hochul's 2024 Executive Budget and its impact on the important work our agency performs on behalf of New Yorkers.
OTDA supervises programs that provide economic and other assistance and support to eligible families and individuals. This includes helping New Yorkers living in or near poverty meet their essential needs and ensuring their economic security by providing opportunities for stable employment, housing, and nutrition. Our agency carries out this mission in cooperation with local social services districts and community-based service providers.
The Governor's budget maintains the essential funding of our agency's core programs, which serve the critical needs of millions of New Yorkers daily, while making targeted investments for areas of particular need.
Beyond what is proposed relevant to OTDA's work, Governor Hochul's proposed budget includes many important initiatives that will undoubtedly improve the lives of the families and individuals our agency serves. The Governor's plan proposes groundbreaking investments in mental health care, childcare and housing, while focusing on reducing and preventing gun violence and helping workers meet increased costs for household needs by indexing the minimum wage to inflation.
Significantly, the Executive Budget includes $1 billion for OTDA to help New York City provide shelter and services to support asylum seekers who have been coming to New York in record numbers over the last year. This funding will help offset the costs incurred through New York City's shelter system and the Humanitarian Emergency Response and Relief Centers.
The Governor's historic New York Housing Compact, which aims to build 800,000 new homes over the next decade, is a comprehensive and multifaceted approach to addressing the state's housing shortage.
On a related note, the budget continues the Governor's $25 billion, five-year housing plan to create or preserve 100,000 affordable units, including 10,000 supportive housing units. OTDA's --
(Protestors interrupt proceeding.)
(Off the record.)
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you all for being here. And I just want to remind people, we've let you have a few moments to speak. We've done that at prior hearings. I want to remind people that you can submit written testimony. It will be posted on our website, both the Assembly and the Senate, and it will be available for all members and all members of the public to be able to see that.
So I would encourage those that are here and other members of your organization to do that, so that we have that information in writing available to all of us.
UNIDENTIFIED PROTESTOR:We appreciate that.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you for being --
(Overtalk from protestors.)
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you for being here. Thank you for being here.
(Continued interruption.)
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you for being here. Thank you. Please send in your written comments --
(Continued loud chanting.)
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:So we will restart -- we will in a moment start up the clock now that everybody's woken up.
(Laughter.)
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:If we could start the -- are you okay just continuing?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yup.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Okay. So if we can just restart the clock, please continue.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I just want to state my gratitude for the activism and the participation in democracy that we just witnessed.
On a related note --
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Pull the mic a little closer, Dan.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Sure.
I think I left off here.
On a related note, the budget continues the Governor's $25 billion, five-year housing plan to create or preserve 100,000 affordable units, including 10,000 supportive housing units. OTDA's Homeless Housing and Assistance Program, with $128 million in the proposed budget, is a key part of this effort by funding capital projects that provide permanent supportive housing to families and individuals who have experienced homelessness.
HHAP also is the only state resource for the development of emergency shelters, which often play a critical role in communities' comprehensive homeless services system. Supportive housing brings together permanent housing and tailored services necessary for individuals to achieve and maintain stable lives in the community. The budget also includes increased funding to support these critical services and ongoing operation of permanent supportive housing.
The budget further proposes changes to public assistance that will improve the economic stability and outlook of recipients, and increases access to education and training opportunities, by ending the requirement for education to be combined with other activities after 12 months of post-secondary education.
Additionally, the budget authorizes the disregard of income a public assistance recipient receives from participating in a qualified work activity or training program, when calculating their monthly benefit. It also provides for a one-time disregard of all of a public assistance recipient's earned income following job entry for a period of up to six consecutive months, provided that the recipient's total income does not exceed 200 percent of the federal poverty level.
These amendments will help ease the effects of any benefits cliff by strengthening the recipient's financial footing when they become employed, before their household is no longer eligible for public assistance due to those earnings.
Unfortunately, we've been seeing instances here in New York, and nationwide, of thieves using skimming devices to copy Electronic Benefit Transfer or EBT card and personal identification number information from SNAP and public assistance recipients and steal their benefits.
In December, thanks to New York's congressional delegation, the federal government agreed to partially reimburse SNAP recipients whose benefits have been stolen. I'm pleased to say that the Executive Budget includes language that will allow the state to reimburse public assistance recipients who have been victimized as well.
This proposal will ensure that both SNAP and public assistance recipients can be reimbursed up to the lesser of the full amount stolen, or the amount of assistance provided during the two most recent months prior to their benefits being stolen.
The Governor is also committing $18 million in this coming year, growing to $37 million on an annual basis, to launch a new Youth Opportunities Program that will augment the Summer Youth Employment Program during the school year, providing year-round part-time employment to an estimated 2,500 youth. This program will operate in localities that have experienced high rates of violent crime.
Additionally, there's a $1 million increase for the Summer Youth Employment Program to $47.1 million, to accommodate the most recent minimum wage increase and ensure that the same number of youths can be served this year as last summer.
As you know, the application portal for the Emergency Rental Assistance Program, or ERAP, closed on January 20. More than 225,000 payments have been made on behalf of tenants to landlords, totaling more than $2.8 billion, and OTDA expects that we will fully utilize all available funds with the applications submitted through January 20.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Dan, we're still having trouble hearing you. Maybe another microphone (inaudible).
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I'll put this right in my face, how about that.
Where was I?
This program has overwhelmingly benefited some of our most vulnerable communities, with nearly nine out of 10 payments made on behalf of households at or below 50 percent of the area median income. When all is said and done, ERAP will have provided more than $3 billion in federal and state funding to keep our fellow New Yorkers who suffered financially due to the pandemic in their homes when they were unable to pay their rent.
The Child Poverty Reduction Advisory Council, of which I'm a cochair, continues its work to develop a plan for reducing child poverty by 50 percent statewide over the next decade. The council will have its third meeting in a few weeks, and I expect the pace of our work will increase moving forward.
I'm excited about the opportunity we have before us to meet this goal. Poverty remains a reality for millions of New Yorkers, but we know it is a problem that we can solve.
In closing, Governor Hochul's Executive Budget outlines a bold agenda that focuses on making New York State a more affordable, livable, and safe place for all. This plan includes sound investments and forward-looking policy proposals that will benefit all New Yorkers.
We look forward to our continued partnership with the Legislature in the coming months. Thank you again for the opportunity to testify, and I welcome your questions and comments.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Since the hearing began, we were joined by Kimberly Jean-Pierre, chair of our Veterans Committee; Assemblyman Kim, chairman of our Aging Committee; and Assemblyman Simone.
Did you want to introduce some people before we go to questions?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Senator O'Mara, the ranker on Finance.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:And Assemblyman Pirozzolo has joined us.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:I'm sorry --
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Go ahead.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Senator Scanlon --
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:Scarcella-Spanton.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you so much. I did it backwards and I got myself messed up. Thank you.
Oh, and Senator Gounardes just joined us. Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you. So now we'll go to -- and there may be some other colleagues joining us as the hearing continues.
So now we go to our first set of questions and answers for 10 minutes, to our Social Services chair, Assemblywoman Davila.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN DAVILA:Good afternoon, Commissioner Tietz. It's good to see you.
So my first question is directed towards public assistance. And the public assistance caseload for the safety net singles is projected to decrease by nearly 19,000 statewide. What are the factors that play into the decrease?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I think certainly an improving economy has made a difference here, and that people have more opportunities.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN DAVILA:What factors are contributing to the increase of the TANF families and the safety net public assistance recipients, which are estimated to increase by nearly 29,000 and 18,000 respectively?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I think what we're seeing here in part is the continuing impact of the COVID pandemic. We saw an increase in the last three years, and it's certainly proven challenging for families in particular.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN DAVILA:My next question would be on youth opportunities programs.
The budget involves funding for a new Youth Opportunities Program for localities participating in the Gun-Involved Violence Elimination -- the GIVE -- initiative. How will funds be distributed to the localities?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:It's based on the WIOA program from previous. So the communities with the highest rates of gun violence in the state will see additional funds through this program.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN DAVILA:Well, we have seen gun violence in New York City -- the increase is everywhere. Will this program be a sort of program that is -- that not-CBOs can apply for?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:In New York City?
ASSEMBLYWOMAN DAVILA:Yes.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:No. This program -- the expansion here is for communities outside of New York City.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN DAVILA:Okay. Thank you.
The next question is on emergency rental assistance. The Executive Budget does not include additional funding for the Emergency Rental Assistance Program, the ERAP program. In fiscal year 2023 and '24, how many rounds of additional federal reallocations can we anticipate?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I believe that there are a few more reallocations from the federal Treasury. In the last reallocation, which was a few weeks ago, we received $63 million. I think that our expectation is that that's in the ballpark of what we may see going forward. But I think we're in the low tens of millions, maybe, and not more than that.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN DAVILA:Is it not true that the applications have closed down now in -- starting January 2023?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yes.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN DAVILA:So people can no longer apply for ERAP?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:That's correct, Assemblymember.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN DAVILA:Okay. The next question is on the Migrant Resettlement Program. The executive proposed 5 million to support a new enhanced Migrant Resettlement Program. How will these funds be allocated regionally?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:So in the Governor's budget we've of course proposed a billion dollars overall, some in cash and some in kind, to help support migrants in New York State.
The single largest part of that, $767 million, will help cover the cost of shelter and services in New York City. There are significant costs here involved in terms of the approximately 900 National Guard that are right now helping to serve in those sheltering locations in New York City. There are costs with regard to Medicaid, significant investments that the state is making.
Among the resources we're providing here will be $25 million for resettlement in welcoming communities elsewhere in the state.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN DAVILA:Okay. The next question would be on eviction prevention assistance.
The Executive Budget proposes to move the funding for eviction prevention legal assistance to your agency. Will this impact -- how will this impact the contract, and how will it be administered? How many people have received service under the program? How many evictions were prevented as a result of legal assistance?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Thank you for the question.
The initial $25 million has been increased to $35 million, and in the last budget it was moved from HCR to OTDA. So OTDA has actually managed these contracts from the beginning. And it's largely through Legal Services Corporation providers across the state.
To date, I believe about 9500 households have been assisted.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN DAVILA:I am going to ask this last question because I've been asking a lot of questions today. I think this is extremely important.
The Executive Budget includes assistance to recipients who had their benefits stolen as a result of card skimming, cloning and other similar fraudulent activities. What will the application process be? What would be the steps for an applicant filing to receive their benefits?
And one of the reasons why I think this is extremely important is because it's taking an awful long time, once people have suffered the fraud, to go back to PA and ask, you know, to restore their benefits. It's taking a long time. And we know that a person can't be an extra month, two months without benefits and not suffer any consequences.
Going forward, will there be more safety measures to ensure the recipient's benefits will not be stolen again? As the Article VII states, then applicants cannot -- can seek reimbursement no more than twice in a fiscal year. So that maybe a little problematic.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:So in the federal omnibus that was passed near the end of December, it included for the first time granting the USDA authority to permit reissuance of federal SNAP benefits. Until now, no state has been able to reissue federal SNAP benefits. A handful of states have had state funds to reissue benefits for some reasons, but the federal government until now hadn't permitted this, the use of federal funds.
So for the first time we are -- we will soon be able to issue the lesser of the actual amount stolen or two months, twice in a year. The goal here would be to keep folks from going hungry. So the idea would be until you get your next regular benefit, you would have something to sustain you.
The USDA just in the last week issued guidance to states on submitting a plan. We expect to submit our plan to USDA before the end of the month. It would appear, on the face of it, that the requirements for demonstrating that loss will be pretty achievable, fairly modest. We won't know for certain until we actually submit that plan and obtain their approval.
So our hope is that within the next few months that the USDA will approve our plan and we'll begin to then roll that out to local districts so that they can in fact reissue the benefit.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN DAVILA:Thank you.
No further questions.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you. We've been joined by Assemblyman Anderson.
And we go to the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
We'll start off with our chair, Jabari Brisport.
SENATOR BRISPORT:(Mic off; inaudible.) Okay, I think okay. Great.
Well, thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you, Commissioners. My questions are all for OCFS. Good afternoon. Thank you for being here, Commissioner.
My questions -- I want to start out by talking about the continued and accelerating collapse of the childcare sector. We conducted a hearing on the childcare crisis a few weeks ago, and the Children's Agenda estimated that New York State has lost roughly 20,000 childcare slots as a result of childcare programs closing since 2020. That would be 10,000 from March of 2020 through July of 2022, and then an acceleration of another 10,000 on top of that just from July of 2022 through the start of 2023.
Does that match OCFS's assessment?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So we can -- I don't have that data with me here, but I'm happy to bring that back to you.
The additional acceleration from July 2022 sounds not like the numbers that I know of, but we'll confirm that and get back to you.
But I do hope you know that after the pandemic, coming out of the pandemic and all the federal funds that we were so gracious to receive, we did issue, as I mentioned in my testimony, that $100 million childcare desert grant. So that desert grant is meant to help build supply, because we do recognize we lost supply.
But that desert grant is not the only supply building we're doing. Our office has quite frankly almost doubled because we have so much focus on not only getting the money out the door for assistance and getting more families into the system, but also building supply. So we're laser-focused on that build. But it's -- it's not easy, so it's -- the pandemic was devastating to our industry, and we're continuing to work on building that back up.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Thank you. And not just the pandemic, you know, the Children's Agenda noted that this had been a long-term trend over the past decade with collapsing childcare slots across the state, some regions losing over 50 percent of their childcare slots in the past decade. Does that match OCFS's assessment?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So I will agree with you that it is not just the pandemic. I think the pandemic put a spotlight on this incredible infrastructure priority that no one else really knew about or cared about until after the pandemic. So good for OCFS, because we've always known it was important.
But yes, childcare has needed support for many, many, many years. I know many states like New York were also super-disappointed with Congress when they couldn't get Build Back Better passed. So I think nationally, again, the spotlight is on childcare. Hopefully next year -- we'll cross our fingers -- that Congress will also recognize. Because I know the focus is looking towards universal childcare, and the states just can't do that by themselves. We definitely need the federal support.
But we're doing a million things by ourselves. We're doing what we can with the money that we have.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Gotcha. And I just want to clarify that despite these annual stabilization grants, we continue to see an exodus of childcare workers and providers from the sector, yes?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Data that I would need to get back to you on.
But the childcare workforce is in crisis, I would not disagree there, as are many other workforces after bleeding out from the pandemic. This is a very difficult time. And I know that we are focused on not only providing the childcare workforce with stabilization grants -- we get that they're one-time incentives -- but we're working towards, as you know, the Childcare Availability Task Force that will -- has been reimagined by Governor Hochul -- will come together shortly.
And one of their tasks is to look at the impact of the pandemic on the childcare industry, including the workforce crisis. And also including, phased in, a rollout of universal childcare. That, granted, we likely can't do by ourselves, but I do believe that we look forward to having all the advocates and all the experts help us. This is a huge problem that we need all of our partners to help solve.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Thank you.
And I just want to keep circling back to this notion of stabilization. We're in multiple rounds of stabilization grants now. At last year's hearing I asked your predecessor if she considered the childcare sector as stable. She said no. Would you say the childcare sector is stable now?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:No, it's not stable now. I think this Governor's budget proposes that additional $389 million as a round 3 for stabilization, to help try to stabilize it. But we have -- we're -- we've done many things over the past two years. We have much more to do.
SENATOR BRISPORT:In taking the same strategy, though, of using a one-time infusion of federal funds for one time bonuses, do you think that the 389 million will stabilize the childcare sector this year?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:I think it will help. I think -- as you know, we've increased the market rate to the 80th percentile. I think that's helped stabilize some providers. I think the stabilization grants, as I've gone on tours myself, providers were very thankful. It helped them greatly.
So I think these sometimes one-time funding we get -- we're using our pandemic funding as effectively as we can. It is helpful. But I think we have a lot more to do.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Where did the $389 million figure come from?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:I would need to get back to you on the analysis of that dollar amount.
SENATOR BRISPORT:I have some other questions about reimbursement rates and compensation. I've been looking at the OCFS's market rates survey, and I've also seen reports from Cornell University and Ed Trust-New York regarding the true cost of care, and it seems like there's a big gap between the true cost of care and what New York is reimbursing its childcare providers. Would you agree that there's a gap?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:I would agree there's a gap. And we were in collaboration with Ed Trust, and I think they did a great job with their report.
But again, that's one of the questions that we have for our reimagined Child Care Availability Task Force. I think we all recognize that these questions aren't answered, and they have a big charge.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Do you think there are any benefits to our current practice of paying childcare providers less than what it costs them to provide care?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:I do not think it makes sense. I do know that we are -- with the 80th percentile change, it increased payments to providers by an average of 33 percent. Some regions got 40. So I do think that's helpful, absolutely.
I think we can see in the budget, because we have this third round of stabilization, that yes, we need more. We need to support our workforce and our industry as much as we possibly can.
SENATOR BRISPORT:In the OCFS analysis for its market rates survey, does that include a living wage for the childcare workforce? Or does it assume a low wage for childcare workers?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:If I understand your question, the market rate doesn't contemplate wages. It speaks to the rate that providers charge families. That is the survey that we take. The rate providers charge families, those who only receive families that get assistance. That is then tabulated by region, by modality, and the market rate is then set.
We are at the 80th percentile, so it's eight to 10 providers are accessible to our families who receive our childcare assistance.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Has OCFS calculated how much more it would take to pay providers what it actually costs them to provide care?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:No, we have not engaged in a cost-of-care study. That, again, was in Build Back Better. The funding for that was in Build Back Better; that unfortunately did not pass.
So as I mentioned, we were working collaboratively, providing data that we had to Ed Trust, and we're familiar with their report.
I know there are some think tanks looking to assess what that -- what that would cost, and Ed Trust is one of those. So, you know, the -- again, the childcare task force will look at this issue as well, one of their charges. And my hope is that we get additional federal support.
SENATOR BRISPORT:I had some questions about eligibility and who gets childcare.
The Governor's proposal continues to exclude undocumented children from childcare. Why is that?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So unfortunately our childcare dollars, our federal dollars did not allow -- well, they dictate who can get assistance and who can't.
Our current regulations do allow children with favorable immigration status to get assistance or be eligible for assistance, regardless of the eligibility of their parents. But that is federal law.
So our CCDF funds do not allow --
SENATOR BRISPORT:I'm just going to interrupt you briefly just for a time. Federal funds cannot be used for undocumented kids, I understand that. But even in New York City, they use city funds. And there is the option to do state funds.
So my question is, why has the Governor refused to use state funds to give access to childcare to undocumented children?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Well, I mean, I think this budget makes really difficult choices. I know that there is an access point for undocumented families in our New York State Head Start, or federal Head Start, and Early Start, of which we have about 278 in the state. So that is a federal program that does allow children to get care even if they're undocumented.
SENATOR BRISPORT:I have more questions about eligibility and waiting lists. We saw a letter from the New York City ACS to OCFS from May. It was requesting to amend their response whenever there is a waiting list when there are not sufficient funds to open all eligible cases from yes to no, essentially saying that they did not want to have a waiting list. Do you know if OCFS granted that request for ACS?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So I'm not familiar with that specific letter, but I can talk to you a little bit about ACS's previous waitlist that no longer exists.
So there are federal requirements to operationalize the federal funds for childcare, and one of the primary focuses is parental choice. So the concept of a waitlist was problematic, and New York City recognized that. And so now there is no waitlist and they are addressing the requests for assistance as they come in.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:We've been joined by Assemblywoman Mitaynes.
And we go to Assemblywoman Byrnes for five minutes, the ranker.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN BYRNES:All right. Thank you.
I want to thank both of the witnesses that are here. My questions, though, will be directed, ma'am, to the acting commissioner of OCFS.
First I want to just make one statement, and that is -- and I'm sure that everyone can agree on this -- the Minority is having an inability to actually contact our legislative coordinator, John Divito, and it's been for quite a while. And as a result, we can't get any answers to our questions.
So I just would respectfully ask that when we go back to the office, if there's anything you can do to try to make it so that our inquiries of him are responded to. I'd be most appreciative.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:I really thought you were joking, I'm sorry. John Divito is incredibly responsive. But if there is something open, we will absolutely respond to you.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN BYRNES:No, no, I was given specifically his name, that we've been trying to reach out, and we haven't.
All right, I'm going to move on, because I do have questions. But I wanted to make sure that was not lost in the shuffle.
Look, obviously childcare is a major part of this budget, and so I want to talk about that and ask some questions about it, ma'am. No disrespect to you, sir, but.
Look, how many more families, how many more children are going to be eligible for childcare by changing the income threshold to 85 percent of SMI?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Sure. Currently, what, 300 percent of the federal poverty level and about half of New York's children are eligible.
Once we, per our proposal, increase it to 85 percent of SMI, which is the highest allowable, another 113,000 children will be eligible.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN BYRNES:All right. Now, you made a comment in your opening statement that less than 10 percent of the eligible children currently receive, but yet apparently 50 percent would be eligible but only 10 percent receive.
Now, if you propose and if it goes through that this is increased dramatically so that many more people, children, would be eligible, how would you go about trying to make sure that these children, now expanded exponentially, will be actually receiving services?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Sure. So we know that there's like several reasons why only 10 percent of our uptake has been standard, and one is reflected in our proposal this year. So we have a mishmash of requirements for childcare assistance. It is an antiquated system. So we are trying to -- the purpose is to make it electronic, make it easier for families to receive assistance.
There is money out there. Counties have lots of money to open cases. So raising the eligibility just provides a larger pool for those counties to create those slots.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN BYRNES:I know that you mentioned, again, in your opening statement that one of the avenues would be a statewide online solution, quote, unquote.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Yes.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN BYRNES:You do realize -- and I'm sure you do -- but I come from a very rural district. Many people here do. There are significant parts of my district that don't have internet access. It's not a question of affordability, it's a question of literally have no access.
How in the world are you going to be able to reach out to these families through an online solution to vast portions of our state that have no internet?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Mm-hmm. Sure. I mean, we do intend to roll out a multilayered solution. So a family can still go down to the social services district and request a paper application and apply for assistance --
ASSEMBLYWOMAN BYRNES:They would have to know that they were eligible. They would have to know that there was a reason to go down and do that.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Correct. So last year we entered into like a multimedia campaign. So -- and that is ongoing this year as well. So it was radio ads, TV ads, bus ads, billboards. We do recognize that not everyone knows that they're eligible for childcare.
So we are -- we began that media campaign last year, and we will continue that this year. The goal is to get the word out, for sure.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN BYRNES:Now, are there actually enough daycare providers to provide services for this increased pool of people?
And even if we have enough actual providers, are there actually workers, people that can work for these providers, that are sufficient to handle this dramatic increase in people who are -- children who are eligible?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Yes. Well, we do think it's going to be a slow rollout. We do not think that 113,000 children will come to the doors of social services this year. Again, half of New York's children are already eligible and our uptake really is 10 percent.
So we do believe it will be a slow rollout, but we're encouraging to recognize their eligibility, come down to the social services district --
ASSEMBLYWOMAN BYRNES:But even if they're eligible, even if they come down -- I mean, at some point you have to have bodies to take care of them.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Yes.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN BYRNES:And that is a major problem in every aspect of our lives.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:And supply is something that's a main focus of ours, increasing supply.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Before we go to the Senate, we've been joined by Assemblywoman González-Rojas and Assemblyman Ardila.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Tom?
SENATOR O'MARA:We've been joined by Senator Rolison and Senator Oberacker.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
And next up is Senator Roxanne Persaud, chair, 10 minutes.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Good morning, everyone.
Commissioners, it's always great seeing you. And I just want to first thank you and -- both of you and your staff for everything that you do for us whenever we're calling. And, you know, we constantly call.
I would like to start with Commissioner Tietz. And my first question to you, Commissioner, you know, is always the COLA. We have this COLA that we talk about that's now proposed at 2.5 percent. But not everyone qualifies for the COLA, even though they're all doing the same work.
Can you give me your opinion of that and justify why someone who's doing the same work is not qualifying for the same COLA?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yeah, the COLA as proposed in the Governor's budget covers one of our programs at OTDA. It's the Nutrition Outreach and Education Program.
But you're correct that it doesn't reach to others.
We believe, of course, that everyone deserves a livable wage. And I can't say more on that, I guess.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Do you think -- would you say if you're having conversations about that? Because across human services, the need for a wage increase is great. These are people who are taking care of the most vulnerable people in our communities. And we're not treating them the same way even though they are doing the same work.
So I really would love for the Governor to look at that and see how can we rectify that so that everyone who's doing the job receives the COLA.
Can you tell me, also, stolen public benefits in the Article VII. As you know, we've been talking about it. People -- the money is placed on their card, and two minutes later it's gone and there's no way of them receiving a refund or the funds being replaced.
Can you tell me, are there any plans in place -- we know we're working with the federal government to rectify the problem, and for the federal government to fund it. What is OTDA doing about that?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:So there's a few things that we're doing. So as I'd mentioned earlier with regard to the SNAP benefits, we now have -- soon, you know, when we submit that plan later this month and hopefully soon thereafter receive USDA's approval on that plan, we will then roll that out to the districts so that they can replace up to two months of benefits twice a year for those who've suffered losses.
On the public assistance side, we're doing something very similar. It's much the same idea. We expect to be able to roll that out soon as well. We've essentially made these two efforts look similar, which I think is both helpful for recipients and helpful for the staff in the local districts who are charged with handling the matter.
In addition, we've taken several steps with regard to getting messages to recipients as well as to local districts. We've had some campaigns on how you can protect yourself. Among the ways in which you can protect yourself is to change your PIN frequently or change your PIN after every use.
In addition, we're speaking with our vendor that handles the EBT cards to permit recipients to turn their card on and off, to essentially lock it as they would like, as well as to prevent out-of-state transactions as well.
So there are several steps that we've done to help ensure that people don't suffer losses.
SENATOR PERSAUD:So talking about that, have we spoken to the vendor about updating their technology? Because, you know, we've been asking about having chips embedded in the cards. So what is the status on that with the vendor?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yes. With regard to chip-enabled cards, which essentially then we get away from this problem of the PIN and magnetic stripes, which can be copied.
So for -- for the -- there's no state in the nation right now that actually has a chip-enabled card. We of course would need guidance and assistance and approval ultimately from USDA to do this.
We are working right now with our vendors on a contract matter, so there's -- there's a big dispute with regards to the vendor that was awarded the contract going forward. So once that's settled, we'll then have -- which I'm hoping soon -- we'll then have conversations with that vendor. We know that that same vendor has begun such conversations with California on chip-enabled cards.
So we're -- I don't want to overpromise here. I'll just be clear that this will take a couple of years.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Thank you on that.
So we'll go to supportive housing. The reimbursement rates are not the same. Can you tell us the key difference between the two models, say for NYSSHP and ESSHI, why is it that the -- there's such a disparity in the reimbursement rates?
And then while you're looking at that, you can think about ERAP. What are we doing for the NYCHA tenants in ERAP? I know we've had this conversation; I just wanted to just go it over again.
And would you agree with me if I say that the time frame that we have for people who are in a holding pattern is too long? We're waiting for people to respond, and we're waiting and waiting, they're not responding, and we're still holding that money -- while we have people who have cleared everything and have qualified, but they're not getting the money.
Meanwhile, they're -- so do you think if I say that we need to shorten the time frame, would you agree with me on that?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yes.
To go back to your supportive housing question, I actually can't explain why there's a difference in the rates for those two programs. I'm happy to get you an answer. This predates me. The NYSSHP program is certainly well-established and older than ESSHI. But I'm happy to get you an answer on that.
With regard to ERAP, so your first question was with regard to public housing. And, I'm sorry, repeat it.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Right now they're just -- there are so many of them waiting because they didn't qualify, they weren't in the categories that were listed. What are we doing -- is there a plan for us to assist those people?
And would you -- if I say that the state should say, let's just cover all of that NYCHA arrears and then with the understanding that NYCHA will say everyone who fell under the pandemic arrears that, you know, we paid and swiped out and they go forward -- would you say that's something that we should think about?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:So for subsidized housing, including for public housing, in the program as given to us by the Legislature as settled in the last two budgets, it placed subsidized housing in a low priority. Believing that, I suspect, given that they already have a subsidy for their housing, they were placed in a lower priority than those who don't have subsidized housing.
At this moment I would say that there's approximately 73,000 subsidized housing applications. Those are largely on hold. Because they're a lower priority, they haven't been actively reviewed in the same way as the non-subsidized housing applications.
I suspect that we're -- at this moment we -- you know, we're working through the applications we received right through January 20. In the last three weeks of the program we received more than 17,000 applications. Our expectation is that we are a little shy of having sufficient resources to fund the nonsubsidized housing and no resources, therefore, to fund subsidized housing.
We would leave to the Legislature and Governor how best to address the shortfall relative to subsidized.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Okay. So while my time is running out, I just want to cover TANF. You know, why does the proposal continue to reimburse New York City for only 85 percent of expenditures? And, you know, let me ask this question of you: Why is so much of the cost being shifted to New York City?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:It's a fair question. I appreciate the question.
This well predates me. I think that this goes back maybe a decade to the prior administration, that the share that -- we cover 100 percent of TANF eligible in every district except New York City, in which we cover 85 percent of the TANF-eligible cost.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Well, we have to continue fighting against that, pushing back on it.
Then my final question, while my time is going, there's $1 billion that's being allocated for the migrant population. Could you cover that? Tell us, you know -- could you go over that, what is it really covering?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Sure. So of the billion dollars, the vast majority, 767 million is to cover the cost -- a portion of the cost of shelter and services. And that includes both DHS and the Humanitarian Relief and Response Centers.
Another $130-some million is for our cost on Medicaid. Somewhere around $150 million is our share of the cost for the National Guard who are serving in those shelters. And then there are smaller amounts -- for example, for resettlement.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Thank you very much.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you. Sorry to cut you off, Roxie.
SENATOR PERSAUD:That's okay.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:The ranker on Social Services, Assemblyman Maher, five minutes.
ASSEMBLYMAN MAHER:How's everybody doing? Thank you so much for being here.
The first question I have is for you, Commissioner. I know my colleagues started talking about the industry, childcare services, and you had brought up in your comments the desert grants, I know this is a structure that's put in place to help that workforce and to support these childcare service agencies and daycares.
So there's actually a handful in my district that are struggling through this application. Is there any flexibility in terms of the payments? I know that some facilities are waiting on their next $50,000 payment because they have to hit certain thresholds to hire employees to have enough seats. Has your office had this experience statewide? And what is a potential solution?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So thank you for that question. We have had this experience statewide, and I do believe we're trying to resolve it.
The purpose of the childcare desert grant was to absolutely build supply, and the first portion of that was for new providers. So if you've gotten your license, you're fulfilling the requirements of the regulation, you are not in violation and you're open, serving children, I believe we're working through the issues with those providers who are close to meeting those milestones.
So if we are not in touch with those providers, we can get in touch with them. I'm happy to have my office reach out to your office.
ASSEMBLYMAN MAHER:So in a specific case, if someone said, Hey -- and they had real proof -- we're going to have to shut our doors, we're really going to need this, you would work with them and try to make that a priority?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:We would have to look at, obviously, the circumstance. But we are working with providers who are open and serving children, absolutely.
ASSEMBLYMAN MAHER:Okay, great.
The second part is if they hit that 10 percent number, individuals who are receiving the childcare assistance. Now, obviously a lot of that, as you explained, is part of the process and there's some things that you're going to work on internally. But how much of it is also promotion? And what kind of partnerships have you created with counties, even elected officials, to try to work with getting the information out there appropriately?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Right. Well, I mean, I'm happy to work with anyone here to get the word out for our childcare assistance program.
But we did launch a huge campaign last year -- again, as I said, a multimedia campaign. And we have our community partners, we have our CCR&Rs who are out there in each region, helping our providers.
But we are open to any recommendations, because getting the word out truly is the priority.
ASSEMBLYMAN MAHER:We look forward to working with you to do that, for sure.
Another section in here with the Employer-Supported Childcare Pilot Program, you talked about three regions being selected. How will that process take place? Which regions will be awarded, and how does that work?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So all the details are still pending. But it is a process that I know we are mirroring from other states where it's been successful.
So I do think that we're still working through the details, but the important thing is that we've gotten the proposed funding in the budget.
ASSEMBLYMAN MAHER:Okay. And I know certain things are being developed. But would a partnership with a large employer, let's say a warehouse -- we have a lot of warehouses going on for a lot of internet sales going on -- would you creatively work with a business like that to try to establish potentially childcare facilities on the premises to make it more affordable and to create incentives for workers to take those jobs?
Because as much as those jobs are available, there's a lot of people who aren't taking the jobs because they don't want to work in that situation where they can't provide childcare because they don't make enough money.
So if there's incentives through a public/private partnership with these larger businesses, is that something that you guys have taken a look at so far?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Well, that sounds like our business income tax incentive. That's also in the budget. So that program would have a business significantly underwrite childcare for their employees and then apply to the state for a tax credit.
So also the details aren't quite worked out there either. But yes, the point is that we're looking at the economics of this all. And we're looking at private -- public and private partnerships for both of those two programs.
ASSEMBLYMAN MAHER:I am excited about that tax credit. And time's running short, but we very much look forward to seeing those details and hopefully working through your office to see how we can make it a perfect process -- as perfect as possible.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Yes. Thank you.
ASSEMBLYMAN MAHER:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
We've been joined by Assemblywoman Tapia.
To the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Senator Murray, ranker, for five minutes.
SENATOR MURRAY:Thank you very much. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you for being here.
I'm going to piggyback, actually, on what the Assemblyman was just talking about as far as childcare and businesses and the workforce.
First, just for clarification, when you said the statewide business income tax credit for businesses that create or expand childcare access for their employees, do you mean financially or do you mean on-site or both?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:I think it can be both. We partner with providers if they're looking to do an on-site facility that would likely need a licensed provider to come to their on-site location.
But yes, it's -- the point is to be creative. We're trying to be as creative as possible.
SENATOR MURRAY:And first, I don't want it going without saying that I applaud you, I applaud the Governor for taking this seriously and doing what she's doing in this budget, because we are in a crisis. And it's a threefold crisis. It's a crisis of are we reaching enough children and families.
When we do, are there providers available and are there workers available? And the answer is no to all of those.
So getting creative with the business community. So when we talk about business and private -- public/private partnerships, have you been in contact with groups like NFIB, the Business Council, MACNY, Ignite Long Island, some of these that maybe can create incentives. Because for any businesses out there listening -- Pssst: If you want a big advantage, offer this as a benefit. You will attract the best and the brightest to come there.
Because the ones that benefit the most, other than the parents getting -- knowing they're getting good childcare for their children, are the businesses.
We don't -- we have a problem getting people back in the workforce now, and the problem is because -- and I've talked to several who've said "It will cost me to go to work because of childcare."
Are we working with these groups, again, getting creative -- because again, the businesses are going to benefit from this. Is there maybe an effort in place to create a fund or something where they can contribute to offer even more incentives?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So love your ideas. We're going to write them down and take those back to our office.
But I think those two public/private partnerships that do involve business, that really speaks to the economic infrastructure issue we're trying to get at, and the business income tax incentive program is going to be throughout the 10 Regional Economic Development Councils. The REDCs are involved.
I don't know if we're working with those specific people, but I'm sure someone very smart in my office or the Governor's office has.
SENATOR MURRAY:We'll definitely talk on that and provide them.
But now I've talked to some in the industry who have also said, Well, that's great, but -- you had mentioned them, and I quote, the cumbersome and antiquated application process for families. But also for providers. They're saying, Hey, you know, we're jumping through a lot of hoops here.
Is there an effort to streamline the system?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Yes. So actually when we increased the market rate to the 80th percentile, we tried to streamline the process for the providers, particularly those who serve 100 percent of children that receive childcare assistance. So we streamlined the application as much as we could by state statute and regulation.
So we are. I mean, streamlining really is the name, like the word of the day. So our office has regional offices, we contract with CCR&Rs, they work with providers. So we have an infrastructure in place to provide providers with that support. We're trying to give as much flexibility now to the parents.
SENATOR MURRAY:Okay, good.
In my remaining time I want to focus on the funding too. Now, if I have my numbers right, it says the Executive proposes to utilize an estimated 800 million in unspent and rollover funds in addition to 500 million in federal pandemic.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Right. Yes.
SENATOR MURRAY:How long will that last? And then when that runs out, is that going to shift onto localities, onto the counties? Or how do we handle that?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:I think, as we mentioned -- even last year, the Governor made this historic investment in childcare at 7 billion. This year it goes on. It's 7.6 billion over four years.
I don't think any of us thought we'd be here four or five years ago. And I think in last year's financial plan we saw the investment in years out, and in this year's financial plan we will also see the investment in years out. So I think the Governor has made a commitment to support this industry.
So yes, our pandemic funds will eventually run out. We want our local counties to use their subsidy. But there is significant rollover every year. So we're just going to invest all of our funds as effectively as possible.
SENATOR MURRAY:Okay, great.
Thank you again. And I look forward to working with you together to maybe come up with some creative solutions. So thank you so much.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Thank you. Thank you, Senator.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
On the Assembly side we now move to three minutes for members to both ask the question and receive the answer. So make sure you leave time for our commissioners to respond as we go through the many members who have questions.
So we go first to our Veterans Affairs Chair Jean-Pierre, but only -- it's three minutes now. Kimberly?
(Off the record.)
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:We go to our Aging chair, I'm sorry, for three minutes.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:Thank you. Thank you, Chair.
And thank you, Commissioners, for testifying today.
My first question is to Children and Family Services. The 16 million in the capital funding that the Executive is requesting, is that for third-party provider capital projects or is it for your agency capital needs?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Thank you, Assemblymember. No, the 16 million is to support the state-operated facilities, our juvenile justice facilities.
We have an aging infrastructure, and we know we need to modernize our facilities to really meet the needs of youth we have now, with programming and education and vocational and mental health services. So that is for the state-operated facilities.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:Thank you. And in your testimony you said that funding is to support facilities that provide programming, education, mental health, treatment services. These are all in-house services that your agency is servicing directly to constituents, not third parties?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Yes. Yes. OCFS operates nine residential juvenile justice facilities, and we staff those facilities with clinicians, educators, program leads. So it's fully state-operated.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:Great. State workers, public pension, the whole nine yards.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Yup.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:Got it, okay.
For the OTDA commissioner, my colleague from Queens has done a wonderful job -- Khaleel Anderson -- of highlighting this problem with the scam involving SNAP and EBT cards and PIN cards. And you point to this problem in your testimony as well.
I think we all deal with these type of scams in one form or another dealing with vulnerable populations. And whenever we deal with identity theft, it is such a challenge to properly report it. We get punted from the local police to the state, sometimes the feds. It's a -- there's no one-stop place to really understand what the problem is.
And is there anything you're doing administratively to improve the situation? And is there any kind of data that you already have around the victims and what vulnerable populations that we should be focused on in trying to prevent these types of scams?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yes. As I'd mentioned earlier, our messaging to recipients as well as to local districts about how to prevent this from happening to them has been pretty extensive, and we're happy to do more.
As I mentioned earlier, we expect to roll out within the next few months, pending USDA's approval of our plan, which we expect to submit later this month. I don't believe that that plan will necessarily require a police report. We'll see.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:Okay. Thank you. Very quickly. The migrant services, is that an in-house program that you're -- are there OTDA personnel that's actually going to support this population, or is this an outsourced contract model you're adopting?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:A quick yes or no. There will be a later opportunity to explain.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:It's a yes and a no.
(Laughter.)
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Okay. We'll take that up later. Thank you.
To the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you. Three minutes to Cordell Cleare.
SENATOR CLEARE:Good morning.
Commissioner Tietz, I hope I get this right. This is my first hearing.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Your mic. Your mic.
SENATOR CLEARE:I have a question about the employment opportunities for youth, the GIVE initiative. Why is New York City excluded from the program? And if -- how do we increase, how do we get these opportunities to young people in New York City? We know that money is necessary for a lot of our younger New Yorkers, year-round employment is necessary.
Can you just answer?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yeah, I'm very pleased about the increase to the minimum wage for the Summer Youth Employment Program, to $47 million.
Admittedly, as I had mentioned earlier the new program is targeted to communities outside of New York City with high rates of violence. I would leave to the Legislature and the Governor how best to address concerns about the absence of that program in New York City.
SENATOR CLEARE:Okay. And on the SNAP benefit or the public assistance benefit reimbursements, I think -- how long does verification or that determination take from your agency to -- I just want to see how much time is it between that and when someone gets their benefits reimbursed.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:So at this moment we just in the last week received guidance from USDA. So the next step here is for us to submit a plan to USDA. That plan will go to them by the end of the month.
Some of the basics around that will be that you'd expect that a recipient would need to report to the local district that -- the loss of the benefits due to theft within 30 days.
SENATOR CLEARE:You said within three days?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Thirty days. Thirty days.
But beyond that, we actually haven't written that response to them yet. So I'll say that the guidance we got from USDA frankly doesn't expect a lot. So our goal here is to keep the administrative burden for recipients and the districts to a minimum and to be --
SENATOR CLEARE:Okay, can you just please follow up and let us know how long that's going to take? Because that's very important.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Sure. Yes.
SENATOR CLEARE:Okay. There were some advocates in here earlier, and I am concerned about what they were speaking about. The plan for AIDS housing for the rest of the state, is there a plan for AIDS housing?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:So a handful of years ago when the blueprint to end the epidemic was developed under the prior governor, it included HASA-like benefits for the rest of the state. The cost of that would be borne at the existing city/state split in terms of the share. So 71 percent of that cost would be borne by the district, and 29 percent would be borne by the state.
It was always an option, it remains an option for districts outside of New York City to expand services to people with HIV. None have chosen it.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Assemblyman Conrad, three minutes. (Pause.)
Assemblyman Burdick, you're next.
ASSEMBLYMAN BURDICK:Thank you.
And this is a question for the commissioner of OTDA.
First, thank you for your testimony and your work. I'm very pleased that OTDA helped provide funding for Freedom Commons, which provides housing for those released from New York State correctional facilities.
You mentioned that the budget includes $128 million for the HHAP program. And just three questions on that. Are there any rollover funds for HHAP? And do you believe that OTDA can help promote an increase in such transitional housing as part of a consortium with HCR and ESSHI and other agencies? And lastly, does OTDA reach out to Osborne, Fortune and other community-based organizations for creating more transitional housing?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Thank you. To your first question, of the $128 million, we pretty much annually get applications to use those funds in the year, within the same budget year. To the degree that they're not all taken up in that year, they roll to the next year. So the short answer to your question is yes, they roll to the next year.
We expect to have applications and approvals in the current year that will use the available funds.
Your next question was --
ASSEMBLYMAN BURDICK:Well, I was just trying to find out whether or not the -- it's 128 million plus any funds left over or any reappropriation.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Well, there weren't from last year. So -- so --
ASSEMBLYMAN BURDICK:So the answer to that's no.
The second question is, you know, do you reach out to Osborne, Fortune and other community-based organizations to increase transitional housing?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:We know each of those organizations well and respect their work. We think that folks coming out of prison are an important constituency and have great needs. We're always happy to engage with them about how best to meet those needs. I'm certainly happy to take up any conversations with them with regard to expanding transitional housing.
ASSEMBLYMAN BURDICK:And if I may, do the applications that you have for housing exceed, you know, the available funds?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:So both projects have multiple funding sources. Could include tax credits, could include -- so if they're in the city, for example, it could include resources from HPD, what have you.
So there's -- I would say that our funds for sure help to encourage others to come on board.
ASSEMBLYMAN BURDICK:But for the HHAP program itself, do you have applications, grant applications that exceed 128 million?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Oh, I'm sorry, exceed; I thought you said "seed." Exceed 128 million -- yeah, I'm not certain. I'd have to get back to you. I don't believe --
ASSEMBLYMAN BURDICK:If you could, that would be great.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Sure. I don't believe we do in the current year.
ASSEMBLYMAN BURDICK:Super. Thanks so much.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Senate?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Senator Rolison for five minutes, ranker.
SENATOR ROLISON:Thank you.
It's good to see you. And I have some questions for OCFS.
In reference to discussions that we've had in previous Public Protection budget hearings, and we also had conversations on data as it relates to public safety, one of the things that I have heard in my former capacity as mayor of the City of Poughkeepsie for seven years was the inability to find secure beds in cases where individuals have been taken into custody and are being brought through the Family Court system now because of Raise the Age.
And in one particular case, an individual who was charged with three gun crimes and there was inability to find a secure bed in two of those cases.
And I know that in the Governor's proposed budget there is additional upgrades for capital costs for OCFS facilities. And I know also, too, probably during the pandemic a lot of this building was not taking place because of all the restrictions that everybody found themselves under.
Commissioner, can you give us an update on where we are? Because we have had, especially in the criminal justice system -- and OCA was here; I asked the same question -- where we're at with that?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Absolutely. Thank you, Senator, for that question.
You're correct, the pandemic put a stop on much of our progress with respect to Raise the Age implementation. And as you know, detention is a local obligation. So we are working with all -- at this point it's six plus New York City, so seven counties that operate detention. We have been talking with them since 2017. But then the pandemic hit. And they all, by the way, had expansion plans.
So I think we all recognize that we needed additional beds because Raise the Age required that we open specialized secure detention. That didn't exist prior to the law. So all of these counties have expansion plans that were pretty much put on hold.
So we do work with counties daily, we provide 24/7 support to counties, to sheriffs, to find beds where they don't exist sometimes. But we often always find solutions for our counties.
But currently we are working with our partners' stock and expediting all of those capital plans. Every single county that operates has a capital plan for expansion. They are all moving forward. All told, within the next two to three years there should be 150 additional beds, based on all the plans from all the counties.
SENATOR ROLISON:So two to three years, if I understand the time frame. And I would say that, you know, obviously the challenge is real right now, you know, as we're here today.
And is it -- it might not necessarily just be more money, it's just capacity in trying to get these beds constructed. What about staffing as it relates to staffing the new beds and/or the new facilities?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Well, I'll tell you. So two to three years is the capital timeline. But we hope to have more beds open up way before then. Because staffing also impacts the capacity issues. So some of our counties, coming directly out of COVID, have challenges in workforce just like every other industry.
So we are working with them, encouraging them to increase their salaries for this critical workforce. And many counties have done so. So there are some counties that have really good data on their vacancy rate increasing, and we have some counties that are operating detentions that have beds that they can't fill because they don't have staff.
So we do think that the focusing on the staffing will open up beds more quickly, but then ultimately every county, as I said, has a capital plan to expand their physical footprint.
SENATOR ROLISON:Do you know -- and if you don't, certainly we can talk offline about this. You talked about the additional 150. Do you know currently in the state what our bed capacity is for individuals that need to be remanded for safety reasons, both for themselves and also while they're, you know, awaiting their time through the system?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Yes, I do, actually. For secure and specialized secure -- there's additional nonsecure beds, which I don't have. But for secure and specialized secure, New York City has about 212. And the rest of the state -- I'll get back to you. I think it's 179, but I'll get back to you on that.
SENATOR ROLISON:Okay, good. And thank you for your discussion with us here today.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:No problem. Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:We go to Assemblyman Goodell, for three minutes.
ASSEMBLYMAN GOODELL:Thank you very much.
For OTDA, thank you very much. I saw in your testimony that you recognized the fiscal cliff and one of the proposals you had was a six-month income disregard, which I think is great. So it helps people get their feet on the ground and establish some employment experience before they start losing benefits.
But at the end of six months, you have the same fiscal cliff facing you. Is there anything in this budget that would phase down the benefits on a coordinated basis so that a person can afford to earn more money after the six months?
And along the same lines, is there any proposal in this budget to, for example, reduce the premium charge once you lose Medicaid and you go into the health exchange, any discussion about changing the Earned Income Tax Credit so it can jump, for example, at fiscal cliffs? Or maybe even replacing categorical aid with cash, which is much easier to phase down.
So other than the six-month extension, what in your budget proposal addresses the fiscal cliff?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Well, Assemblymember, you came with a whole list of ideas. I appreciate that.
So I'll note that in the last budget of course you made some important changes with regard to public assistance so that folks could in fact have higher earnings and remain on public assistance. So this is taken together with that.
I appreciate your concerns about, you know, more is needed here. And certainly I would leave to the Legislature and the Governor on what exactly more might be useful or needed.
With regard to tax credits, I think maybe it's relevant to some degree to the work of the Child Poverty Reduction Advisory Council, which I cochair with Deputy Secretary Jihoon Kim. You know, there were -- you know, we just have pulled that together, had the first couple of meetings, we expect the third meeting in early March. And, you know, in a careful look using data and New York-specific research, we're going to come with recommendations, as charged by the statute. And I would expect that tax credits would likely be a part of that discussion when the time comes.
Unfortunately, in advance of this budget, we're not there yet.
ASSEMBLYMAN GOODELL:And I appreciate your efforts with the Child Poverty Reduction Task Force.
So I would hope as part of that you also look at the impact of our current cash system as it relates to two-parent families. Because as you know, if both parents are together, 100 percent of both parents' income is included in calculating eligibility. But if the parents are separated, the noncustodial parent only has that portion of their income that's attributable to childcare counted. So it's 17 percent for one child, 24 percent for two, and so on.
It might make long-term sense to us to expand the income disregard regardless of whether you're together or not, as a way of addressing child poverty.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Appreciate it.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
To the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Senator Gounardes.
SENATOR GOUNARDES:Thank you.
Good morning. I actually want to pick up where my colleague just left off on talking about child poverty.
Obviously we're waiting for the recommendations of the Action Council. We know we're required by law to have our child poverty rate halved by 50 percent over the next seven or eight years. And by any objective measure, we know that any way to do that's going to require a substantial increase in child tax credits or in funding families so they can pay for their necessities.
Setting that aside, because we know that it's not in this budget, what in this budget proposal -- and this is for both of you -- can we point to that will actually help tackle the child poverty crisis that we have here in New York, where we are one of the highest-poverty states in the nation for children living in poverty.
What in this budget proposal can you point to that would help do that, aside from the lack of investment in the child tax credit?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:My fellow commissioner just said that I should start.
(Laughter.)
SENATOR GOUNARDES:Eeny, meeny, miny, moe.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:So, look, I'd say that there are a few things. One is, of course, adjusting the minimum wage and tacking it to inflation. To the degree that folks can earn more money, it goes a long ways here.
In addition, we've got a number of options here. Certainly there are resources to prevent homelessness that we've got on the table which are pretty substantial. The Governor's housing proposals, that new housing compact to build 800,000 units. There are a host of items like that in this budget that, while maybe not specifically in my budget, would in fact have an impact on low-income households.
SENATOR GOUNARDES:Okay, thank you.
Commissioner?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Yes, thank you. Thank you for that question.
I can add that for quite some time OCFS has been investigating the intersection between poverty and child welfare. And we know that poverty and loss of income and material hardships have -- are the greatest predictors, quite frankly, of the risk of a family's involvement in the child welfare system. So we've been looking at anti-poverty tools for quite some time. We are so happy to be part of the advisory council and look forward to those recommendations.
But outside of that, we've been focusing on prevention, and most of the time those prevention dollars are provided as services to families. However, in our Child Welfare Unit, we are doing really innovative and creative things and looking at economic and concrete supports as a way to mitigate child welfare involvement. We have a direct --
SENATOR GOUNARDES:Commissioner, I'm going to have to cut you off there because I have one more question and 30 seconds. I appreciate it, though, and I'll follow up with you more on those ideas.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Absolutely.
SENATOR GOUNARDES:This question is for Commissioner Tietz, and it's about our shelter allowance. It's my understanding all of our local social service districts can choose to propose to increase their shelter allowance from the bare minimum, and only a number have -- I think only about 20 or so have so far in this state.
And I was wondering if you have any insight as to why more jurisdictions have not taken advantage of the opportunity to increase their shelter allowance, especially given that the state picks up the lion's share of that investment.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:You're out of time; you'll have to answer him later.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:All right.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:We go to Assemblywoman Lunsford.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN LUNSFORD:Thank you very much.
My question is for Commissioner Miles-Gustave.
OPWDD has been delegating much of its responsibility for our most profoundly disabled children, the ones that are not adequately served by our school system, to OCFS, and mainly our county CPS services. As a result of this, children with profound disabilities have been effectively living in our emergency rooms, sometimes for months on end.
Can you talk a little bit about how that's been a burden on your agency, on our county CPS services, and what if anything this budget does to help address that issue?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Thank you so much for that question.
So we do see this issue coming up year over year over year. But I will say that we have been collaborating, as state agencies, more now than I think I've ever seen. So we are in constant conversation with OMH and OPWDD and DOH to figure out not only funding streams but potentially even new licensing structures. Like how can we help and support these youth with very complex needs? Particularly coming out of COVID, like the mental health needs are stunning.
So we are in constant contact with OPWDD. We do know that child welfare is the system of last resort, unfortunately. But I think the recognition of that is there.
And as you know, we have a cross-systems workgroup with our Council on Children and Families. We look at, case by case, children in the emergency room to try to figure out what the next path is for their permanency. So we look at every child and, you know, try not to let any child fall through the cracks. But we are looking to systematize that -- that cross-collaboration with respect to the potentially new funding streams or new licensing structures.
So there's no specific funding in the budget right now, but we've been known at OCFS to use our existing funding quite creatively. So we're committed to trying to solve this problem.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN LUNSFORD:I think this is a case that illustrates well the need to start to blend some of our funding streams. Particularly when you have these children who have funds that come from different agencies, it becomes very complicated, the administrative cost is very high.
To that end, I also wanted to ask you a little bit about the $17 million for voluntary foster care agencies. Can you speak a little bit about the loss of the Medicaid funding for that and what you're doing to help alleviate that issue?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Absolutely. Thank you.
So the IMD concern -- IMD stands for Institutions of Mental Disease. It's a federal Medicaid concern. And so I'll make a very long story short. But IMD facilities are 17 beds or more, where the primary focus is to diagnose and treat for mental disease.
In us rolling out Family First, our volunteer agencies have increased their level of care. They had to do that to continue to receive Title IV-E funding. So we're at a point right now where some of our voluntary foster care agencies could potentially be considered IMDs, and then they would no longer be able to draw down federal matching funds.
So the Governor recognized this. This is a problem. We are talking with our partners at DOH. We've been talking with them for quite some time. And so we're going to solve this problem. But the 17 million in the budget is a recognition that this may be an opportunity to transform our system. And our voluntary agencies need investment to do so. So that 17 million will go in a variety of ways -- to hire more staff or make programmatic changes or even some structural changes to bypass the IMD definition.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN LUNSFORD:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
To the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you very much.
To Senator Jessica Scarcella-Spanton.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:Thank you.
And I want to make sure I don't say this incorrectly, so Commissioner Miles-Gustave.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Yes, thank you.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:Okay, good. Fellow hyphenated names.
(Laughter.)
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:I just want to bounce back to the childcare stuff really quick.
In November it was announced, after the childcare desert funds had dried up, that they were going to make the unused funds available. We have a few facilities in my district, one specifically which is expanding her daycare facility --
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Jessica, I'm sorry, you only get three minutes on this panel. You do get 10 minutes a little later. Sorry. Thank you.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:Yeah, that one I knew.
(Laughter.)
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:Oh, they put it -- okay.
So yeah, for the childcare desert funds. One of them, they let her know that they were going to make them available and they'll let those eligible providers know. She's in the process of reopening a new facility. Do you know when those grants, those childcare desert grants, may be made eligible again?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Sure. So our -- we had two specific RFPs. So Childcare Desert 1 was for new providers who wanted to open up new spaces in childcare deserts. So those have been pre-awarded, and people are working towards getting up and running.
Childcare Desert 2 is for existing providers who wanted to expand their slots. So those have also been pre-awarded, but the pre-awards are working towards getting the licensure necessary to open up those additional spots.
So I don't think we've made awards to the second group, that Childcare 2, but we can definitely get back to you. If you know someone in your -- one of your constituents was waiting for an answer, we can for sure get back to you. But all that is moving.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:Okay, great. And I guess my second question to that was if you're doing more than just expanding slots, so she's opening an actual second facility nearby, same childcare desert, to expand care, would she be eligible for that? Since she's not technically new and she's opening a new facility.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:It would depend on her modality of care, if she was a center versus family-based. So we would have to look at that specific scenario.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:Okay. So I'll make sure I send the specifics over to you. But thank you so much.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:No problem.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:We go to Assemblyman Simone. You need someone to give you a chair. Thank you.
ASSEMBLYMAN SIMONE:Hi, I have two questions, the first question for Commissioner Tietz. Hi, Dan.
I thank the Governor for the significant investment to assist New York City providing aid to asylum seekers, many who come to the Port Authority in my district. Is your office also advocating for additional federal aid and relief in the city and across the state, and can the city count on additional support?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:So -- I appreciate the question. The budget contemplated essentially covering a third of the estimated cost. And certainly the Governor and governors from other states that are so affected are speaking to the White House and continuing to urge additional funding and resources in coordination with regard to migrants. So that -- that is ongoing.
I think at the present moment the idea was that essentially at the existing social services share, as split between districts and the state, we sort of kept to that formula. So the sort of sheltering and services related cost here represents about 29 percent of the estimate for the city's expense to date.
ASSEMBLYMAN SIMONE:This is for Commissioner Miles-Gustave.
Students are going to be recovering from the COVID learning gap for years to come. I often hear from after-school programs on lack of funding in my district. How does the budget reconcile filling that need while offering no increases in the Empire State After School Program and cutting the Advantage Program by 5 million?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So there is no actual cut in the -- either Advantage or Empire. What the budget does this year, it proposes to move the funding from SED to OCFS, because we are in fact operating those programs. We facilitate all the contracts, we do them ourselves in-house.
So the Advantage After School and Empire contracts have been troubled because of COVID. Things shut down, as you know. But we have been working with all of our providers to try to get them back on track. Like we had to be slightly nimble during the pandemic, and the contract framework changed from, say, an expenditure base to an attendance base. But now, with talking with the advocates, talking to providers, and at their request, we are transitioning those contracts back to expenditure-based.
So those providers are in the middle of a contract amendment right now. And trust me, we have tons of people at our office working on this to make sure that those payments get out.
ASSEMBLYMAN SIMONE:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Senate?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Senator Persaud for three minutes, follow-up.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Thank you.
Commissioner Tietz, I just want to go back to you again. Could you tell us what of the $1 billion that's covering the migrant services, the funding that's allocated to the National Guard, could you tell us what it's covering? What is it that the National Guard is doing with that funding?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yeah, they're actually supplying National Guard troops to assist with the sheltering and services in New York City. So there's approximately 900 National Guard troops right now serving, and that represents the cost of that service. They don't do security, they do program-related work.
In fact, I think I was in your district the other day visiting just one of those locations, and I have to say that the National Guard troop that was in charge there was frankly extraordinary. I was like, do you want a different job? I can give you a different job.
(Laughter.)
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:He was quite good. I was very impressed.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Okay. And can you tell us, what is the status of the applications to the federal government for the hot meals program?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yes, we are expecting -- the application is in to them for review. We expect to hear something soon.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Like in a month, two months?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yeah, I would say within the --
SENATOR PERSAUD:The end of the year?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:No, no, I think -- I think within the next 60 days we can expect to have an answer, yeah.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Okay. And if the -- I'm not saying "if." When our application is approved, how long do you think the program will take to roll out?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:It's well in order. I would say that we've got a staffer who you know well who is a go-getter on this, and I expect that we'll have this up and ready very quickly.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Okay, thank you.
And Commissioner Suzanne, again, I'm finally coming to you to ask you a question. It's about the minimum wage.
And you heard me talk about the COLA. What are you going to do for -- to push for an increase in the COLA on your side?
And, you know, we have the $3.8 million to fund the minimum wage increase, but that's not enough, because we are -- we're bringing these workers, these critical workers, up to a minimum wage, but they're still dependent on social services. What are we doing for that?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Thank you for that question, Senator. I know every industry's workforce is suffering. That is without a doubt.
I do know that -- if you recall, several administrations ago, right, there was no COLA. So we are happy that there is a COLA, there was a COLA last year, and there is a COLA in the budget this year.
You know, I know that we all want more in the budget. But the COLA that's applied to the OCFS programs will support the voluntary foster care agencies, and they went through challenges last year as well. The good thing is that the budget also -- the language in the appropriation recognizes like the very unique nature of our foster care agency rates. So we're hoping that this will be a benefit to them.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Thank you.
I think I was cheated on my time.
(Laughter.)
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:We go to Assemblywoman Clark.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CLARK:Hello. Thank you. My questions are also for Commissioner Miles-Gustave.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Gus-tauv, no "ay."
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CLARK:No "ay," Gustave. Got it.
So I have three quick questions on childcare that I'm hoping I can get in.
I'm really looking forward to the Childcare Task Force meeting and finally getting to their very tough job of figuring out how to get us to universal childcare here in the state. What we have seen, I think, is that right now we do have dollars in the system and they're still not being used. They're not being used by families, we have providers start closing their doors.
I appreciate the investment into the workforce, but I just think these continued one-time investments or using these stabilization grants isn't sustainable. Truly if we're going to get sustainable, I think we need to get to the true cost of care, not market rate. The previous governor -- we passed in the Assembly a move to true-cost care, allowing that to replace our market rate. That was vetoed by the former governor.
Could we get support, if we get it through the Legislature, to move to a true-cost model for New York so that we could start to raise wages?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Well, I can say that the market rate increase I do think has been a significant increase for all providers, like really cash in their pockets.
And I would say that we honestly do need the federal government. I mean, increasing wages, absolutely, we all want to do that. But we need the federal government to pass that Build Back Better.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CLARK:Okay.
Second, I appreciate the also increased -- I mean, I do want to just say that we can't pay workforce more. No one can afford to pay more. Families can't afford to pay more. So how are we sustaining wage increases without really looking at true cost?
On the expansion of eligibility, I think it's great, but at 93,000 even for a family, what happens when that one parent makes a dollar more? All of a sudden they go from maybe paying $200 a month to $2,000 a month -- we're going to lose that parent. I understand this is the federal maximum, but I really think we need to start looking at state funds to have step-downs so we don't lose parents out of the workforce the moment they make a dollar more than eligibility. So I'd just add that.
And then as for the employer piece -- and what we've heard from our hospitals and other systems, our emergency workers, our front-line workers during COVID is we need 24-hour drop-in centers. We need childcare to work when overtime is all of a sudden offered.
Can we start to really look at how we pay through the subsidy system to make it follow the child and the family, not attendance, and really look at a way we could support these 24-hour drop-in centers?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So not aligned with our assistance, but aligned with our providers, we do have nontraditional hours, and that was an incentive in our childcare desert grants.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Thank you, Commissioner.
We go to the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
We have Senator Ashby.
SENATOR ASHBY:Thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you, Commissioners, for being here.
OCFS has a great innovative program with the family-type adult homes. And I was wondering if you could give me a policy update with that, because one of the things that's come up in my district is the hospice waiver that goes along with that. So you have elderly folks in place here who are used to this family-type adult home being their home, and then when they require hospice, there's a very big gap in terms of being able to remain in their home and receive treatment there.
And it's caused a bit of turmoil, and I'm wondering if you could give me an update and comment on that.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So thank you for that question.
I'm not familiar with your specific scenario, but I can say that our family-type home for adults has been the topic of our conversation with DOH for quite a bit. So we're collaborating with DOH to look at what is needed -- is there a need for a change in our licensing of our family-type homes for adults? Because you're right, it is not supposed to be nursing level of care. But we do want people to be able to age in their homes -- and that is really their home, for all intents and purposes -- gracefully and safely.
So we can get back to you. If you have a very specific scenario, I'm happy to get back to you.
But I also want to point out that you all know the Governor issued the executive order to create the Master Plan for Aging, the state's first Master Plan for Aging, with that exact purpose. So the goal is to make sure that we have our older population safe, aging with dignity in their homes if that's their choice.
So I sit on that council, so I'm very proud my agency is represented. So we look forward to the recommendations from that Master Plan for Aging Council. Because I think your point is well-taken; that is the goal.
SENATOR ASHBY:Yeah. And I look forward to that as well. But there is a sense of urgency here. You know, this request has been out for over a year, and there are people who are suffering because of this gap in policy. So I appreciate your time and attention to it.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:We go to Assemblywoman Darling.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN DARLING:Hello. Thank you, Commissioner and Acting Director, for your work and your testimonies today.
I'm Assemblywoman Taylor Darling, and I represent the 18th Assembly District in Nassau County. I also currently serve as the chair of the Subcommittee on Foster Care.
I'm grateful this year's budget provides us some opportunities to attempt to make the human services industries whole, but we have some serious issues that we have to really plan out this year. So we must increase the salaries for foster care direct care workers. At their current salaries, foster care direct care workers aren't able to live on the salary alone, requiring them to have multiple jobs.
The turnover rate currently for these workers across the state is around 50 percent. This is disastrous for a lot of reasons, but we have to always stress the continuity of care that is necessary for our children and families, and we need these to increase positive outcomes. So where we stand right now, there is not a lot positive happening in this industry with these workers and the families they serve.
So I wanted to hear your thoughts about the direct care workers.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Thank you for that question.
So I would agree that our foster care population is also in crisis, that workforce is in crisis. And we do recognize that the voluntary agencies and the foster care workforce, they are the backbone of what we do. Like they are the frontline workers of all of our work.
So I think we've done a couple of things to help the industry -- not only just foster care workers that work in congregate settings, but foster boarding homes, like foster families. So we have raised the MSAR for foster family boarding homes. And you may have noticed we had a settlement last year where we required the local districts to pay 100 percent of the MSAR for foster boarding homes. So that's coming I think full circle this year.
And then we did promise that we'd also release an extraordinary rate, which would provide foster parents with a higher rate to support youth with complex needs so those youth can still remain in that foster home. So that extraordinary rate regulation will be issued pretty soon. That was the third part of our settlement promise.
So those rates will be out shortly. We plan to follow that up with some policy. So that's what we're doing on the foster boarding home side.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN DARLING:Great.
Okay, I have two more questions.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Sure.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN DARLING:I'm concerned about the restoration of the 65/35 child welfare funding to 75/25, as well as OCFS's shift from mandated reporting to mandated supporting.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So the 62/38 open-ended funding -- as you've mentioned, just landmark funding -- with your unwavering support, we were able to issue that.
It's been one of the major tools for the reduction in the foster care numbers. Because counties use this open-ended funding stream, New York has one of the lowest foster care admission rates in the country. And we do point to that funding stream for the field.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
To the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Three minute follow-up for Chair Jabari Brisport.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Thank you.
Thank you, Commissioner Miles-Gustave. I know we've been all figuring that today. But a pleasure. Thanks for taking my questions again.
I think my first just follow-up about the Governor's pilot program, the tri-share program between the state, employer and parent -- we've seen issues with tying healthcare to people's jobs, including but not limited to people staying in jobs that are not good for them or that they don't like because they want to keep their healthcare.
Do you see any similar issues coming up with tying childcare to somebody's current specific employment?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:I mean, I see your point. But I think it's just an incentive.
I don't see it as a negative, I see it as more of a positive than anything else, because there's so many industries that do not even recognize the importance of childcare. So these employers will not only recognize the importance but invest in their employees. So I do believe the good would outweigh the bad here.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Okay, thank you.
And my second question is just about uptake rates. You know, in the Governor's proposal she talks about how many more children will become eligible, but the number that is eligible is not the number that participates.
What's the current uptake rate for childcare assistance in New York?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So there are 100,000 families that are eligible for subsidy. About 66,000 get it every month. Annualized was 100,000.
So no, we do have a lot of work to do to get that number up. And I do think that the streamlining of the application and making things more electronic and accessible will increase that.
SENATOR BRISPORT:I like streamlining. I think eliminating means-testing in general would be the best way to streamline.
But in addition to streamlining the application there's also the issue of not enough providers, right? So while waiting lists -- does OCFS keep a list of how many kids are on waiting lists to even get childcare around the state?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So my understanding is that there are no waitlists around the state. Counties don't have waitlists anymore. It was more money to open cases. And granted, a lot of providers have low enrollment because we're still coming out of the pandemic.
So I think ultimately we need more childcare spots, absolutely. We have deserts. So those deserts are being filled right now. But there are many providers that are out there that have open spots.
So we don't keep private-sector waitlists. I'm sure there are some daycare centers in New York City that have waitlists. But OCFS wouldn't keep that.
As far as waitlists for subsidy, local districts don't have waitlists. There are no waitlists for any local districts that I know of.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Okay, I wish you had attended our hearing on the childcare crisis a few weeks ago. You would have heard providers saying that they've never seen their waitlists so long in the history of their time being a provider.
My last thing is in terms of child welfare, New York State is still continuing to fail to reimburse counties at the statutorily required 65 percent. We're still doing 62 percent. Why is that?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Well, 62/38 I believe is in the appropriations. So that's the share that gets appropriated year after year.
SENATOR BRISPORT:But do you think we lose and do decreased services from doing less than 65 percent?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:You'll have to follow up with him afterwards, sorry.
And everyone, remember, when you get a clock, it's both for you to ask and for your testifiers to answer. So testifiers, we're hoping that you will follow up in writing on questions you couldn't answer.
And if you get them to both Helene and myself, we will make sure to get them to all committee members. Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
We go to Assemblywoman Forrest for three minutes.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:Thank you.
My question -- thank you, Commissioners. My question is for Commissioner -- I'm not going to mess it up, I promise -- Miles-Gustave.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Thank you.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:Okay. Just a question on the stabilization grants, right?
The stabilization grants two years ago were around $1 billion, and we lost childcare providers. Right? Will this year's proposal of 389 million stabilize the sector?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Thank you for your question.
I think it will help. I think the $1 billion stabilization was in the height of the pandemic, when we knew we couldn't have childcare providers close even when schools were closed. So that was a critical lifeline for our community of providers.
And then last year's Stabilization 2.0, we've been hearing from providers that helped a lot. A majority of that stabilization incentive went towards workforce.
So I do think this Round 3 will help. We do have limited pandemic funds, so we're using the remaining funds just -- wisely.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:Okay. But we lost with 1 billion, and now we're going to be okay with 398 million. Okay.
My next question for you is regarding the data matching for children's benefits. We had talked about it in the hearing over the fall at the public assistance hearing. But in the Governor's State of the State she mentioned data matching for children's benefits. However, her actual written budget doesn't have anything regarding that.
Can you tell us more about this program for data matching for children's benefits? What would that mean for our programs, and maybe the programs for other vulnerable populations such as older adults?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Is that for Commissioner Tietz? I'm sorry.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:No, it's for you, yes.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Oh. I don't understand the question. Data matching for --
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:So data matching would be where if someone puts in information about this program SNAP, it would then populate and be able to say for --
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Okay.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:Oh, he's -- I thought it was for you. I really was --
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I apologize.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:OTDA does SNAP.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yes.
So yes, there actually is a unified application now. It does that now.
So outside of New York City -- so New York City has New York City Access, which does much the same thing -- but if you put in, you know, you apply for SNAP or you apply for public assistance, you apply for Medicaid, there is -- it's shared. So there's a single application now.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:Have you heard any reports on the effectiveness of this single application? Because even in New York City it has hiccups, but ...
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yeah, I won't suggest this is perfect. I mean, I'll note that the integrated eligibility system, which we're working on now, and I think the first bits will roll out in about three and a half years, will do this much better.
But yes, we're all heading in that direction.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:Thank you, Commissioners.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
To the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
I think I'm the last Senator, so to speak.
So going back to the migrant services and assistance money that the Governor put in her budget, so is it a billion dollars for New York City -- oh --
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Ten minutes on the clock for Senator Krueger.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thanks.
Is it a billion dollars for New York City or statewide?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:It's largely for New York City.
So it's a billion dollars. The vast majority of it, some 75 percent of that money is in the same kind of reimbursement that the city knows well for shelter and services. So that's the biggest chunk of it.
Some of this is in-kind, but it's all -- even that in-kind is for New York City. So that's referencing some Medicaid costs and some National Guard costs and what have you.
The only portion of this which is somewhat arguably not New York City is the $25 million for resettlement.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:So when my paperwork says that 741 million of this billion is used to provide New York City with 29 percent reimbursement for supportive services and assistance, my mayor is telling me that the costs are radically higher already than what a third coming from the state would be.
So is this really -- you're going to pay 29 percent of supportive services and assistance, so it could be more than 741 million in order to get to that -- keep at that 29 percent level?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:The budget proposes to spend 741 plus the existing $26 million to get to $767 million, for essentially 29 percent of the city's estimate for shelter costs from earlier in this state fiscal year through June of '24. That's what's on offer here right now.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:So you've mentioned Medicaid costs and also safety net costs. So those aren't really new dollars because they're for migrants, those are benefits that if you're eligible in New York State, you get them. So we might see a projected increase in some costs because of this population.
But I don't think that should really be counted as migrant funds, do you?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:To the degree that that Medicaid expense is in fact for migrants, I think that it could be fairly counted in that billion dollars.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:And what about the safety net money?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:The same is true there.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Why? There's not a new program, safety net for migrants, is there?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:No, but there is some tracking of course of migrants within the HRAs, right? So doing the eligibility, they are now keeping track of who are -- you know, the piece of paper you come with. Right? So these are all documented migrants. They're mostly asylum seekers. They are paroled into the country. Based on that eligibility status they may or may not get safety net assistance. That can be tracked.
And so this represents a portion of that cost.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:So what I'm trying to get at is trying to understand, of the billion dollars defined as being for migrant services in the budget, what percentage of that billion is actually new money versus dollars that would have been in the budget anyway, we just call it something different this year?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I would say again that the vast majority is new money, if only because -- I mean, the 741 by itself is clearly new money. It wouldn't otherwise be in this equation.
I'm happy to take a look further and answer your question maybe with greater detail, but I think it is fair to describe that billion dollars as largely new money.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:What are we paying the National Guard $162 million for?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I think it's covering the cost of the -- that personnel and their services for a lengthy period of time. It's 900 --
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:So current or going retroactive?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yeah, it's -- it's current. It's right through that same period. So this is essentially looking at -- this is an estimate of how much National Guard troops we would need to continue to serve in the way in which they are now.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Starting April 1st going forward, for the new year.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yes.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Does the state pay anything for them in the previous year?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I'm sorry?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Did the state pay anything for their services for the current fiscal year?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I'm uncertain. And we can certainly follow up with you on that.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Okay. And what happens if the city's costs just continue to grow and grow and grow for this population far beyond what's projected in the Governor's budget?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I think it's a very difficult equation all the way around.
Certainly we're concerned about the capacity of the city to continue to take migrants at this rate. I think we're hopeful -- you know, myself here at OTDA, my sister state agencies and the city are hopeful that with the changes that the federal government's made at the end of December, beginning of January, that we'd see a decrease in the number of migrants.
I'll note that last week we saw a slight dip in terms of entrants to DHS or to HERCs. So -- but for sure it will be challenging going forward, and we stand ready to assist further as needed.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Because of the growth in the migrant population, there seems to be almost a triggered new set of problems for people who were in our homeless shelter system already -- I think partly because of just the volume of people, where they can possibly go, how many providers there are who actually can be in the business of operating services within shelters and HERCs and whatever else we call them next.
Does the state have any plan to help us with that? I know we don't have enough not-for-profit service providers to take the contracts even for the new shelters for the, quote, unquote, traditional homeless population. So forget getting them to take on all these giant HERCs. I mean, you know -- you're shaking your head yes because you also know this.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yes.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:And you worked for the city previously, so I know you know this.
How can the state be more helpful? Because this is really a growing crisis that's not going to go away tomorrow.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I would say that the National Guard troops' presence is vital at this moment. It is 900 heads we wouldn't otherwise have.
You're exactly right that there's not a bottomless pit of nonprofit providers ready and able, willing, right here, right now, to staff up some new shelter. The city is in over 80 hotels. The -- the -- rather than traditional, how about nonmigrant shelter residents -- actually there's been only a slight uptick in this same period, mostly on the families with children side. So there's maybe around 49,000. But for migrants, the shelter census actually wouldn't be much changed from a year ago.
But with, you know, some 21,000 in DHS and another 8,000 in HERCs that are overseen by the city's Health + Hospitals, it's -- it's become a serious challenge to operate the entire system.
I'll frankly admit that I worry at times about the potential collapse of DHS. But for what was -- what we did with regard to the HERCs, which I'm very grateful for emergency services in New York City and New York State and for Health + Hospitals in stepping up to do what was necessary. And I think, you know, with my other state colleagues, we will continue to step up as necessary.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:I am also very grateful for all of their work. I am just afraid that there's just going to be, at some point in the next few months, a total breakdown of these systems because they can't absorb and handle this many assignments at one time. So I share your appreciation, but I also -- I really feel like we are literally at the verge of just total chaos in trying to operate these programs. And we need to come up with more ideas and more assistance for the City of New York on these issues.
Now, I'm biased, obviously; I represent Manhattan, and everybody's in my island. And I'm not saying they shouldn't be, I'm just saying we need a lot more help coming into the future.
I will give back my one minute. Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
We go to Assemblyman Gallahan, three minutes.
ASSEMBLYMAN GALLAHAN:Thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you both for your testimony today and all you do every day to make New York a better place to live.
My question is for Commissioner Tietz regarding ERAP and LRAP.
We know that 225,000 checks have been cut and that the application period ended on the 20th of January. It's my understanding that only applicants who have applied through October 31, 2022, are being reviewed. And will applicants after October 31, 2022, also be reviewed going forward?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:So we're reviewing applications received right through January 20. We're currently paying for those that are otherwise eligible and approved through November 30.
Looking at resources available, my expectation is that for the non-subsidized housing we'll be in the ballpark.
ASSEMBLYMAN GALLAHAN:Okay. How much of the appropriated money from the fiscal year budget '23 has been awarded so far, and how much is left?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:So I don't know off the top of my head in terms of the amount of appropriation for '23. We've distributed, as you noted, about 2.82 billion. I think the total is somewhere -- leaving aside LRAP and the over 80 program, but ERAP alone, I think the total is somewhere around 3.1 billion. So we have around 300 million or so left.
ASSEMBLYMAN GALLAHAN:Thank you.
And as far as the LRAP, how much money from the 125 million for LRAP in the fiscal year '23 appropriation has been awarded to recipients? And how much money would be left there?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Almost all of it has. That -- there's a handful of millions left in the LRAP program.
ASSEMBLYMAN GALLAHAN:Okay, thank you.
And should the state reopen LRAP with new funding?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I'm sorry, say again? Say again?
ASSEMBLYMAN GALLAHAN:Should the state open LRAP again with new funding?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I leave, of course, to the Legislature and the Governor on how best to address the need.
We've not -- the Governor's budget doesn't propose to add any additional state resources to this program. But certainly if there is an interest, I leave to you all how best to address.
ASSEMBLYMAN GALLAHAN:So I'll let you know in my district that I hear quite frequently from landlords saying "I've never been made whole." They can't maintain their properties and keep a good place to live for their tenants. They're broke, they can't pay their taxes, they can't pay the utilities.
So it's paramount that we do something for those folks. Thank you very much.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Of course.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:The Senate is finished with questioners, so we're going to just keep calling on Assemblymembers.
Assemblywoman Simon.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN SIMON:Thank you. Thank you.
So, Commissioner Tietz, I have a question to sort of follow up some of the recent questions about the issues around migrants and being able to work, which I know is federal, but there have been relaxations.
What is the state doing to help kind of push the feds into allowing people to be able to work more quickly? Because right now they're working off the books, they're not protected. And they're not paying taxes.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:So you're correct that this is federal rules.
So the -- in the normal course for an asylum seeker, as I understand it, you would have to apply, and then it's essentially 180 days from receipt of your application that you would have work authorization.
I know that the Governor, along with sister state governors, is urging our federal friends to permit work authorization, to provide work authorization sooner.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN SIMON:Thank you.
And Commissioner Miles-Gustave, I have two questions.
One is I notice that after-school programs are being moved to OCFS. Advantage After School is going to lose $5 million. So one question is, like what's the purpose of this? Is there -- does anybody think we need fewer after-school programs?
And then the other issue is the proposed elimination of the Committee on Special Education state share to those residential programs. And my question is, who's going to be picking up that tab, and do they have that money?
And also, what about the out-of-state placements that actually cost us more and in some cases are highly problematic in other ways?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Thank you for your question.
So just to clarify, the after-school funding is moving from SED's budget to OCFS's budget because we've functionally been operating these programs for the past several years. So it just made more sense for it to come to our budget.
And there is not an actual decrease. We are looking to consolidate the future RFP, to consolidate the programmatic requirements, which will help us consolidate the payments and the claims. So there's Empire and Advantage; our hope is to let a consolidated RFP for the next contract year.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN SIMON:Like a cost savings, you're saying.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:I don't think it was a cost savings, but we can surely get back to you.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN SIMON:Okay. Please, because we have -- and then the other thing is the CSE state share on the residential programs.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Yes, thank you.
So that was an extension, that that's the current operations currently. We don't -- the state does not pay that share. It's to the CSEs and the local districts. So under the proposal in the budget is to make that permanent.
But for the past several years, I think folks realized that these children are in voluntary agencies placed by CSEs in the custody of local districts. So that's the current operation of the fiscal -- that share.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN SIMON:I'll follow up. Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Assemblyman Pirozzolo.
ASSEMBLYMAN PIROZZOLO:Good afternoon. Thank you both for being here. I truly appreciate it.
My questions are really going to go to Commissioner Miles-Gustave.
Unfortunately, you know, a lot of the work that we get to do, some of it is pleasant, some of it is unpleasant. And my question is going to go into more -- probably the most unpleasant things that come up.
But could you just give me a brief overview of what your office does when it comes to the abuse, exploitation and trafficking of children?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So we have the Safe Harbour laws in New York State, I think one of the most supportive and helpful.
So we have divisions in our OCFS office that provide -- we have funding that provides allocations to local counties. So human trafficking is something that the local districts provide services and support.
But again, we have Safe Harbour laws. So the point of that is that we're not -- we're no longer criminalizing young women for, say, prostitution if they've been trafficked. And I think the point of focusing on trafficking is to make sure that we get to the trauma of that trafficked individual. So we take trafficking and trafficking prevention very seriously.
And in the rollout of our Family First implementation, there are several voluntary agencies that were interested in becoming one of our QRTP exceptions, which is an EMPOWER program specifically for youth who are at risk of being trafficked. So there's now a congregate setting for those potentially trafficked youth.
ASSEMBLYMAN PIROZZOLO:So I appreciate that. But do you have any suggestions or any way we could work with you so -- the victims certainly need as much help as they can get, but what do you see that we can do, or what can we do to go after the people who are actually doing the abuse?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Yes. Such a huge issue. I do not disagree with you.
I know that some of our voluntary agencies and local districts are working in partnership with their local law enforcement, with the DA. There were situations that happened maybe several years ago in one of our voluntary agencies where the FBI was brought into this specific case. So I know there's partnership between the child welfare system, our voluntary agencies, and local county social services and local DAs, to try to stave off this very -- it's very troubling, a very troubling issue.
ASSEMBLYMAN PIROZZOLO:Well, I appreciate all the work that you're doing. I certainly look forward to working with you in the future on ways that we can reduce the amount of incidents that's happening by maybe better prosecution of people who are perpetrating these crimes against our children.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Absolutely.
ASSEMBLYMAN PIROZZOLO:Thank you very much.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Assemblywoman Mitaynes.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN MITAYNES:Hello. Good afternoon.
This is for the OTDA Commissioner. This is about SNAP benefits fraud.
It seems that this state is allocating the money it received from the federal government to only replace the stolen funds on or after October 1, 2022, through September 30, 2023. And it seems that it may only replace once in the federal fiscal year for funds stolen after October 1, 2024.
Why hasn't OTDA looked into providing more funding as well from the state so that those with funding stolen before October 2022 are also covered and made whole? The federal government has already committed to addressing instances after October 2022, but it seems that the state has not moved further to supplement the existing aid.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I think you actually wanted me to answer that, yes.
So just to be clear, the federal law as of late December permits states, once they submit a plan that's approved by USDA, to replace two -- benefits equal to two recent months of your benefits, twice in a year. I think it's through 2024, and thereafter once per year.
And you're right that that law begins -- that's for, you know, losses October 1, 2022, going forward. Right? And so of course we're doing the same, we've proposed to do much the same with regard to the public assistance benefits. This is not confined to SNAP.
As I had mentioned earlier, our expectation is that within the next few months, following the USDA's approval of our plan, which we're submitting later this month, that we'll be able to begin reissuing those benefits to the local districts.
With regard to earlier periods, of course we leave to the Legislature and the Governor how best to address that need. But the proposal is what we have here on the table now.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN MITAYNES:Okay, so we would have your support to be able to do that?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I'm happy to do at OTDA whatever the budget requires of me.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN MITAYNES:Just very quickly, a second question, and this is about childcare and the fact that it leaves out undocumented kids. Has OCFS calculated the cost of a dedicated state fund to provide childcare for undocumented children?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So we don't have that data right now. I don't know if we would even begin to know if that would be statewide. But I'm happy to take your question back to my team and get back to you.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN MITAYNES:I appreciate it, thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:We go to Assemblyman Ardila.
ASSEMBLYMAN ARDILA:Thank you so much, Madam Chair.
Thank you, Commissioner Tietz; thank you for coming. And I really appreciate you both for showing up today. I wanted to talk to you a little bit about HRA predominantly impacting New York City residents.
Maybe you can tell me a little bit about this when it comes to SNAP benefits, public assistance. When people are applying and there's a wait time and they don't hear back, and then when they try to contact HRA, they can be on the phone for hours without being in contact with anyone. Can you talk to me about that, why that's taken place?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I couldn't speak to that specifically. I'm happy to get you an answer about the wait times.
I can say, more broadly, that the city of course has sought waivers from us for federal or state rules with regard to timeliness of issuing benefits or conducting a certification or a recertification. We have again -- as we have since early 2020, we've again waived a bunch of those rules after the city proposed taking some -- several actions to fill seats. They're having a staffing problem.
And I think we were satisfied that their proposal with regard to how best to fill those seats was sufficient to further extend by six months those waivers.
ASSEMBLYMAN ARDILA:Okay. And then to that point, right, so when we have -- this impacts a lot of seniors in my district, a lot of people that are waiting for SNAP benefits, SNAP assistance, and this is essentially what makes or breaks -- so they can help -- it helps them make ends meet.
So, you know, what can we do to work together to ensure that we don't have those staffing issues? What can the State Legislature do to ensure that we have the proper resources so people don't have to have those wait times where their cases are pending, they don't know the status, they want to do check-ins in terms of where they are in the application process?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yeah, I'd say that we're happy to take up any idea that would both help the city fill the open seats and to retain the staff they have.
Admittedly, much of this is within their control alone, and not ours.
So if -- I would just say that if the waivers in and of themselves were enough, they'd have worked by now. So I think it's important, because you want to keep people on benefits, and for those who apply to get them benefits and to limit the workload by issuing those waivers, so you don't have, for example, to do recertifications at the same rate or pace as you would have in the absence of those waivers.
But at the end of the day, it is on the city to figure out how best to fill those seats. We stand ready to help in any way we can if there's some measure beyond issuing those waivers.
ASSEMBLYMAN ARDILA:I appreciate that.
And I do want to say appreciate the work you do, and you have my full commitment to reach those goals.
Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
We go to Assemblywoman Lee, three minutes.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN LEE:Good afternoon. Thank you. My first question is for OTDA.
I commend the Governor for recognizing the need for more housing in the budget. But I wanted to ask, what are the state standards for the siting of homeless shelters and ensuring that there's not a disproportionate concentration in any particular neighborhood, particularly in low-income communities of color?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:The siting of -- I'm presuming you're asking principally around New York City.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN LEE:Yes.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:So the siting of shelters is really up to the city's Department of Social Services -- and therein, it's the Department of Homeless Services -- and other city officials.
Our role at OTDA is to engage in oversight with regard to the services, the quality of services, to certify shelters, and to provide resources. But the actual siting of them, the determination about where best to place them, is up to the City of New York.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN LEE:Understood. Thank you.
And for OCFS, as you mentioned, local districts can set different standards under the Child Assistance Program, but standardization doesn't necessarily mean improved care.
So specifically for New York City, can you please elaborate more on how standardizing benefits and services will impact how New York families will receive care, and also how they will be applying?
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:So for New York City they have a slightly more complicated process. They have a contract of care system, which is EarlyLearn for older children. They still have typical standard childcare assistance for infants and toddlers.
So our hope is that for that specifically for the infant and toddler population, the systems will be standardized. They have no waitlists, so in New York City you might have heard from your constituents with issues getting to childcare because there was a significant waitlist. That is now gone. They are giving waivers, and we are monitoring that process.
So it really should be standardized and should be beneficial to all families.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN LEE:Okay, great. Thank you.
And then when it comes to ERAP, I wanted to focus specifically on the 73,000 applications that you said are outstanding for subsidized housing. How many of those are specifically for NYCHA residents?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I don't know off the top of my head, although it is a substantial number. We can get it. We can get that to you.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN LEE:Okay, great. And so would you know how much in need those 73,000 applications represent?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:So because they're of a lower priority, you know, given the two previous budgets that set them at that priority, we haven't thoroughly reviewed them. They're essentially on hold.
If there were resources available, then of course we would go through the process of reviewing them. So we would have, at best, you know, just an estimate. So I couldn't tell you today exactly what the value of those are.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN LEE:Okay, thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
We go to Assemblywoman Gonzalez-Rojas.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN GONZALEZ-ROJAS:Thank you. Thank you both for being here.
Commissioner Tietz, benefits skimming -- again, this is just a critical issue. You're hearing this quite a bit today. How much in dollars would you estimate has been skimmed from New Yorkers at this point?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:The last numbers I saw were somewhere in the ballpark of $5 million.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN GONZALEZ-ROJAS:And is there language that allows for the replacement of SNAP in particular? As I understand, this is about 50 percent of the cases that have been happening in terms of skimming.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Actually I think that the SNAP skimming represents a significant majority of the losses, as opposed to the public assistance cash benefit. And, I'm sorry, your question was?
ASSEMBLYWOMAN GONZALEZ-ROJAS:The replacement of that SNAP. I know that there is money in partnership with the federal government, but --
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Actually, it's their money.
So to be clear, we couldn't -- we cannot, even as of this very moment, we cannot replace stolen SNAP benefits.
So in the budget, in the omnibus budget the federal government passed in late December, for the first time it's permitting the replacement of those benefits, consistent with a plan, a state plan that we submit to them, which we're intending to do by the end of the month.
Once approved by them, we will then roll out guidance to the districts on actually implementing that plan. So essentially, as I've mentioned earlier, a couple of months, an amount equal to the lesser of the amount stolen or two months of benefits, twice in a year thereafter.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN GONZALEZ-ROJAS:Is there a way to do more than just that minimum? I know that minimum was standard -- the standard by the federal government. But just, you know, the two replacements and the two months, it just seems very limiting for people who have maybe lost thousands of dollars in skimming.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Not with federal resources. So that would be the limit with regard to replacing the federal benefit.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN GONZALEZ-ROJAS:Could we put in money at the state level to do that?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Well, I leave it to the Legislature about how best to address that.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN GONZALEZ-ROJAS:And given that SNAP is our number-one hunger program, and that the NOEP has increased the number of people on SNAP, why isn't there more here for NOEP? We know that's just incredibly effective programs. Many counties stand to see a reduction altogether, or loss of SNAP assistance.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I don't have it in front of me, but I know that we've increased the amount to NOEP. I want to say it's $5 million. But I think we've carried that on from previous.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN GONZALEZ-ROJAS:And in my last seconds I want to go back to the HIV out of state. Would you -- you know, there's activists that joined us earlier. Is there anything in the Executive proposal that would provide housing? I know you mentioned some of the counties haven't opted in. But what can we do to ensure that there's greater access to housing for people with HIV?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Um --
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:I think you're going to have to answer that offline.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN GONZALEZ-ROJAS:Thank you. Thank you so much.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:You know, again, as the Senator said, answers to any questions that are posed here that there isn't time to answer, please send us the answers and we'll make sure all the colleagues receive them.
So we move on to Assemblywoman Reyes.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN REYES:So this is for Commissioner Tietz.
In 2020 we passed legislation to start in New York State a restaurant meals program through the SNAP program. Just wondering where you guys are on the implementation of that pilot program, if you have gotten the necessary approvals from the U.S. Department of Agriculture, and whether there are resources that the state can provide to help kind of move that along.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yes, your colleague asked it earlier and I had mentioned that our plan is in to USDA and that we expect in the next, I would say within 60 days, to have a response from them. I'm hopeful that it will be an approval.
And I would suggest that we're pretty much all set to roll it once approved.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN REYES:Perfect.
My next question is so your office works on child support issues along with the courts. We are working on a proposal that is currently being revised that would create a streamlined, expedited settlement conference process for families who generally agree on child support in family courts.
Do you see the need for this sort of new process and the value in helping families who want to utilize this option to establish child support orders as a more streamlined, straightforward process?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yes.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN REYES:Great. And it's also my understanding that the state is reimbursed for costs associated with the child support program through the federal Title IV-D Social Security funds. Would those funds be available for a program like an expedited settlement conference process for child support in family courts?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Now you've gotten off of my page. So we'll follow up with you on that.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN REYES:Okay.
Those are my questions. Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
We go to Assemblyman Chang.
ASSEMBLYMAN CHANG:Thank you, Madam Chairman.
Thank you, Commissioners, for being in here. You have a thankless job. It's a very tough judgment of this program. Thank you.
I represent Sunset Park, Boro Park and Dyker Heights. I'm a 24-year veteran and I served a tour in Afghanistan. So I have a question about veterans; that's for Commissioner Tietz.
Veterans are included as an eligible group for the affordable housing program in the Empire State Housing Initiative. How many veterans have been recipients of this program, and how much have they been awarded, sir?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I'm uncertain, but I'm certainly happy to -- I don't have that detail in front of me, but I'm certainly happy to get it to you.
ASSEMBLYMAN CHANG:Okay, thank you.
And earlier in your testimony you praised the National Guardsmen that had been doing outstanding service in providing immigrant services. You have the resources; how would you expand their scope and mission if you had that desire?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I think ideally, as much as we are grateful for the presence of the National Guard, it is an unusual -- I would suggest it's a somewhat unusual use here. Ideally we would have nonprofit human services, shelter providers on contract to do the entire task.
So, for example, in the site that I visited in Brooklyn last Friday, there is a nonprofit partner there, they just don't have all of the staff in place yet. So hence, the National Guard to fill that gap.
Again, grateful for that. I don't think that's the ideal approach. And we would prefer that the nonprofit staffed up as usual.
ASSEMBLYMAN CHANG:Okay, thank you.
And a question for the Landlord Rental Assistance Program, the LRAP. How many applicants have been completed -- I know that the program's been closed, but how many have been completed and processed and how many have not, sir?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:So as of the end of last month, we made almost 28,000 payments to landlords totaling more than $283 million. That was after last February we moved some of the unexpended under-80 program to the LRAP program because the LRAP program was oversubscribed. So that's how much we've put out to date.
ASSEMBLYMAN CHANG:And you were so oversubscribed, so what's left on oversubscriptions, sir?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I don't have the amount left. I know it's a modest sum. That program is, you know, oversubscribed as well, but it's a modest sum that's left. We're working through existing applications.
ASSEMBLYMAN CHANG:I see. Thank you.
That's all the questions I have, Commissioner.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
We go to the Ways and Means ranker, Assemblyman Ra, for five minutes.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Thank you.
Good afternoon, Commissioner and Commissioner. Commissioner Tietz, thank you for that meeting last week to discuss some of the budget proposals. And I appreciate your answers today.
With regard to ERAP, though, I wanted to get into a little bit, as we're winding down this program, a few issues including Guidehouse, the outside entity that was contracted to -- obviously before your time -- to administer this program. My understanding is their contract is going to expire in May, is that correct?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yes.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:And will there be any need to continue any type of contract with them, or do you think everything will be wrapped up by that point?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Oh, it would be nice if it were wrapped up. But no. We're moving to extend that contract.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Okay. Do you know how long that would be for or what any of the terms of that might be expected to be?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I don't have the term of the extension. I think our hope is that by the end of calendar '23 that the vast majority of this work on ERAP would have been completed.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Okay. So by the end of the calendar year you're expecting to have the program --
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Largely done, that's right.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Yeah, okay.
So I know that as you're going through, you know, these processes, a couple of issues that have been brought to my attention that are kind of recurring, one of them being applicants who have been denied multiple times but continue to apply.
Is there any process to streamline if they've applied again and again?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:Yes, we've worked with the vendor to do an initial sort for just such applications.
So in some instances folks have reapplied because they didn't obtain, as an initial matter, the full amount available to them -- so 12 months of rent or three months of prospective rent. In other cases there may have been errors, what have you. But -- so in some instances.
But where they essentially have applied in much the same way and it's clearly, you know, not a fundable application, then we would quickly move to deny it. At which point, by the way, then, I think what you're hitting at here is the protections that come with the statute.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Yes.
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:In which case the protections then are not in existence.
So if -- I would just note that for someone who's never had an approved application, then -- for whatever sets of reasons -- they don't have the protections upon denial. But because, say, in the instance in which someone had a previously approved application, got some funding, then they actually have the eviction protections for a period of time going forward.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Okay. And then regarding owners, I've heard of situations where owners have had payments and then they get clawed back, you know, months later. Why, you know, would this be happening to some -- is there a change in information? What requires that? And what if any recourse does an owner have if, you know, they dispute the reason that the money's being clawed back?
OTDA COMMISSIONER TIETZ:I would -- you know, among the states with ERAP programs, New York ranks high in terms of its success rate here in terms of getting dollars out the door to as many households as we've done. I think some evidence of that is we've obtained nearly $400 million from the federal Treasury in reallocations from unspent dollars from elsewhere. So I think we've demonstrated an ability to get these resources out the door to those most in need.
There are errors, as there are with any program. The error rate in this program is at about 6 percent, which is frankly akin to most public assistance programs. So, for example, that's an error rate akin to SNAP. And so that would be the instance in which we would potentially look to claw back some resource.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Okay, thank you.
And just with my limited time, Commissioner Miles-Gustave, just relative -- you know, we've talked about the providers, the childcare providers. And certainly, you know, the minimum wage proposal, on the one hand it's going to help lots of people hopefully be able to afford childcare, but it certainly has the potential to drive up costs for providers.
So I hope that's something we can keep an eye on with some of the things we're doing with regard to ensuring there are adequate opportunities for childcare.
ACTING COMMISSIONER MILES-GUSTAVE:Yes.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
So this concludes this portion of the hearing.
Just to restate that to the extent that there are questions that there wasn't sufficient time to answer, please -- to Senator Krueger and myself -- forward those answers.
And next we are going to be hearing from the New York State Office for the Aging, Greg Olsen, acting director; and New York State Division of Veterans' Services, Reverend Viviana DeCohen, director.
And while we are having a quiet transition, if you have any conversations, please take them into the hall. I just want to remind people who are going to be testifying later to make sure that you've checked in with the desk at the top of the stairs so that we know that you are here.
Commissioner, if we could -- Assemblywoman, if we could take the conversation out in the hall.
(Pause.)
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:And while we are getting ready to start, I want to acknowledge we've been joined by Assemblywoman Hunter. Assemblywoman Jean-Pierre joined us recently. And I think that's it for our new members.
So we're ready to start our second panel of governmental witnesses. A reminder to both of you that you each have 10 minutes to make your presentation; then there will be a number of members who have questions. And hopefully they will be leaving you enough time to be able to answer those questions. Thank you.
So Greg, do you want to start?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Sure, happy to. Thank you.
Just let me know, is that close enough for you guys? Okay, great.
Well, good afternoon, Chairpersons Krueger, Weinstein -- Senator, congratulations on getting the Senate Committee on Aging -- and of course Assemblyman Kim and all the distinguished members of the Legislature.
My name is Greg Olsen. I'm the acting director of the New York State Office for the Aging, and I'm honored to testify today.
Governor Hochul's Executive Budget is aptly named "Achieving the New York Dream." The Executive Budget seeks to create a more affordable, more livable, and safer New York, while opening doors to the communities and people who have historically been blocked from equal chances at success.
I am pleased, as always, to testify on provisions of Governor Hochul's proposed budget that directly affect NYSOFA programs and our services, along with additional budget proposals that will positively impact older New Yorkers and their families and move towards the broader goal of creating a more affordable and livable New York.
The Governor's State of the State message and subsequent Executive Budget proposal aims to make New York the healthiest state in the nation through a multi-agency, coordinated effort that's focused on developing a Master Plan for Aging, improving physical and behavioral health, combating social isolation, preventive health care strategies, expanding access to services and training for LGBTQ individuals, supporting informal as well as working caregivers, addressing disparities, diversity, equity and inclusion, and more.
Utilizing the state's 2019-2024 Prevention Agenda as the umbrella, and instituting a "Health Across All Policies approach," New York State agencies are incorporating health considerations into our planning, programs, and initiatives. As agencies, we are committed to working together and considering how our policies fulfill New York's pledge as the first age-friendly state in the nation.
Now we have an opportunity to further strengthen and coordinate this vital work through the Governor's priority of developing a Master Plan for Aging. This master plan is consistent with the goals and work that New York has been engaged in to improve communities for people of all ages and create healthy environments in which to grow up and grow old.
In 2018, as you know, New York became the first age-friendly state in the nation to receive that designation from AARP and the World Health Organization. New York was first because we rank pretty high in the eight domains of age-friendly, livable communities, and due to our comprehensive plan to systematically build age-friendly and smart-growth principles into how government operates and functions.
Through much-needed investments, the Governor’s FY '24 Executive Budget expands and strengthens the foundation with initiatives that help individuals access needed services and lead healthy lives by maintaining funding for vital services like the Community Services for the Elderly program, or CSE; elder abuse and Holocaust survivors funding; increasing funding for the Master Plan for Aging; continuing the historic $23 million investment to help older New Yorkers who are awaiting services; continuing the $2.9 million to expand our efforts to combat isolation, bridge the digital divide, address elder abuse, and strengthen NYSOFA's stipend program for volunteer recruitment and retention; continuing our bill-payer service program in 10 counties in Western New York to prevent and mitigate financial exploitation of older adults; the continued improvements in our New York Connects system, further increasing access to long-term services and supports; maintaining a half a million dollars that's used to draw down more than $2 million in federal funds to combat elder abuse and financial exploitation through our enhanced increasing multidisciplinary team program; continuing funding that was in the budget last year for the Long Term Care Ombudsman Program, and providing a 2.5 percent human COLA for our providers.
The Governor's budget provides the support necessary to continue our trailblazing initiatives. Examples include our award-winning animatronic pet project; the GetSetUp platform that offers more than 900 lifelong learning and health and wellness classes; our Virtual Senior Center to bring senior center programming into the homes of older adults; our Elli-Q program that provides a proactive artificial intelligence tool to combat isolation and loneliness and improve connectivity to others as well as improving overall health and wellness; our GoGoGrandparent partnership, which provides specialized ride-sharing to increase transportation options; and our evidence-based caregiver support platform, TRUALTA, which is available to any New Yorker, regardless of age, who provides some type of uncompensated care to somebody else.
Further, the proposed Executive Budget increases eligibility for those older adults that wish to use services via a private pay model. Legislation that we passed in 2019 allowed individuals and families for the first time to purchase services directly from their area Agency on Aging when their income was above 400 percent of the federal poverty level.
What we found is that created a gap, and so we're pleased that this year the Governor's proposal expands access to these services for those individuals between 250 and 400 percent of the federal poverty level.
NYSOFA has also launched several pilot projects that expand outreach, communication and engagement, as well as measure the effectiveness of these new models. These innovations will inform the Master Plan for Aging. One such innovation is the launch of a multicounty evidence-based intervention pilot that uses complex analytics to identify caregiver burnout. It's called TCARE, and it's a leading cause of referral to higher levels of care for older adults.
NYSOFA is also currently conducting the state's first-ever statewide needs assessment survey. The results of this assessment will not only inform our federal plan that is due to the feds this summer, our county plans that will be due later in the year, but also the Master Plan for Aging.
NYSOFA is also the nation's first state unit on aging to partner with the National Association of Home Builders to make their Certified Aging in Place Specialist, or CAPS, training certification available to our case managers. This certification improves the ability of our front-line staff to assess, recommend, and incorporate home safety features into care plans, helps individuals age in place, and prevents injuries and falls.
Finally, through our partnership with the Department of Health, we will be expanding a successful integrated care model that coordinates aging services with health services and physicians' offices and strengthens the New York Connects data and reporting system as well as the state resource directory.
But the budget is much more than any one program or service. It must be examined holistically. Older adults, like all New Yorkers, touch many different systems in their day-to-day lives, not just the Office for the Aging, which is why the Governor's systemic investments are so important.
Key investments and proposals that will further our ability to allow New Yorkers to age in place include -- and some have been mentioned already -- the New York Housing Compact to build 800,000 new homes; expanding access to behavioral health services; strengthening EMS, which for many is the first healthcare responders; making energy more affordable to reduce out-of-pocket costs; expanding food access -- and there's many, many more.
So NYSOFA will continue to engage our sister agencies, private partners, not-for-profits, and community-based organizations as we work to serve New York's older population and their families as effectively as possible.
I really appreciate all of your guys' support and the opportunity to be here, and I'm happy, as always, to answer any questions.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Reverend?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Good afternoon, everyone.
Good afternoon, Chairs Krueger and Weinstein and distinguished members of the Senate and Assembly. My name is Viviana DeCohen, I'm a Marine Corps veteran, and I have the distinct honor of being the director of the New York State Division of Veterans’ Services, or DVS.
Thank you for the opportunity to discuss Governor Hochul's 2023-2024 Executive Budget as it relates to New York State Veterans’ Services.
Governor Hochul has made clear in her administration and in her budget the importance of veterans, servicemembers and their families here in our great state. As we approach our agency's transition from a division to a department, the Governor's expansion and improvements in the veterans services realm have been outstanding, and DVS stands ready to continue providing the highest-quality services for our New York State veterans, servicemembers, and their families.
Under Governor Hochul's administration, New York continues to be a state where veterans and their families are proud to call home thanks to the continued investment into veterans and their families. These investments can be seen through new programs, staffing, and additional funds for peer-to-peer support programs such as the Joseph P. Dwyer Program.
DVS has increased its economic impact, which directly benefits the lives of New Yorkers throughout each and every community. Through these increases, DVS assisted veteran families in bringing in over $900 million in tax-free federal dollars in 2022. This is in addition to the $400 million brought into New York with over 23,000 veterans utilizing educational opportunities.
These funds filter their way into every community across the state, to support the over 688,000 veterans of New York. The work of this agency delivers concrete results and benefits for veterans and their families in New York State in the form of federal funds and healthcare access.
We know that we could not produce such outstanding results alone. We are grateful for the support of the Legislature, Executive Chamber, and the tremendous work of DVS staff which has enabled us to rise to the occasion. No one is an island unto themselves, and we do know that without all of you and our incredible partners, the work we do would not be possible.
Our work addressing food insecurity, increasing access through digital technologies and transportation, and educating providers on veteran and military competency is only possible through our continued partnership.
Food insecurity has been repeatedly cited as a concern for our military-connected families. One in nine working-age veterans lives in food-insecure households nationally. We know that this is unacceptable, and in New York State we're doing something about it. We're very proud that this past year the millionth meal was distributed -- between our partners -- to our New York veterans, servicemembers and their families through a partnership between the New York State Division of Veterans' Services and Hello Fresh, which will continue on into 2023.
This builds on the successful Nourish New York initiative, a multi-agency effort to reduce food insecurity and support our food producers.
Additionally, Governor Hochul has committed to doubling the funds committed to the FreshConnect checks program which allows our veterans, servicemembers and their families to receive food vouchers to use at farmers' markets and stands across the state.
DVS continues to create and provide additional points of access for veterans and their families to learn about the benefits they earned through their military service. One of the most common issues we hear when talking about bringing veterans into contact with their benefits is transportation and isolation. We want to pursue innovative solutions to address that.
In her Executive Budget Governor Hochul is supporting an initiative to help DVS find and serve veterans in their communities -- find and serve -- through the dedication of $300,000 for the purchase of vehicles that will form our first-ever fleet of Mobile Veterans Service Centers.
This initiative will allow us to reach those with some of the highest needs and the largest barriers to access by eliminating transportation concerns. These mobile centers will bring the DVS's accredited veterans benefits advisors and their best-in-class technologies on the road to meet our New York veterans, servicemembers and military families where they work, live, where they thrive.
Lastly, DVS understands the immense burden that finding quality, affordable housing can pose to a veteran and their family. This is why Governor Hochul's administration is taking a twofold approach to this with the required military and veteran cultural competency trainings for supportive-housing providers that receive state funds for veteran-designated housing units and a $1.1 million investment to create the Homeless Veterans’ Housing Program, which will be used for emergency housing, providing temporary shelter, repair to homes damaged by disasters, and renovating homes to house veterans with certain special abilities -- some call them disabilities. This creates a holistic and comprehensive approach to address the unique needs that veterans, our servicemembers and their families face with housing.
Governor Hochul's State of the State agenda and Executive Budget provide DVS with the resources to build upon these successes and to deliver more support than ever to New York's veterans and their families. DVS appreciates the continued support of Governor Hochul and her administration in addressing the needs faced by our veterans, servicemembers and their families.
Thank you for the opportunity to discuss the Governor's Executive Budget with this committee. And on behalf of New York's veteran families, thank you for your continued support of the agency's mission. I look forward to answering any questions that you may have.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
We go to Assemblyman Kim, chair of the Assembly Aging Committee, first.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:Thank you. Thank you both for your testimonies today.
According to a report by the Center for an Urban Future, older New Yorkers grew in population by 31 percent from 2011 to 2021. During this time the State Office for the Aging's budget grew by approximately 25 percent. There seems to be about a 6 percent gap between overall growth of older adults, older New Yorkers, versus SOFA's budget, causing the delay in services and an increase in waiting lists for vital services.
During this period, older New Yorkers living below the poverty line, and who most likely qualified and applied for Medicaid, increased by 37 percent in the last 10 years.
My office ran some models, with the help of the Association on Aging, based on how much we would have saved on Medicaid if we fully invested in non-Medicaid care programs administered by SOFA. In the last 10 years, our conservative figures show that we could have decreased older adults living in poverty by up to 10 percent and saved the state $3.75 billion.
An additional $390 million investment in SOFA in the last 10 years would have saved the state $3.75 billion in Medicaid spending and decreased the number of older adults living in poverty.
Now, I know, Director Olsen, you already know these numbers. And I wonder why the former governor, the current governor, and the Department of Health won't fully invest in SOFA. Do they not care, or are they just incompetent at taking care of older adults?
You don't need to answer that, Commissioner.
(Laughter.)
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:But what we do know is that $3.75 billion in Medicaid waste ended up in the pockets of predatory nursing homes and corrupt home care agencies that see older adults as dollar signs, not humans. We systematically, systemically force older adults to spend down into poverty so we can institutionalize them into facilities we supposedly oversee to protect consumers through an advocacy program called the Long Term Care Ombudsman Program that we purposely underfund.
And here you are, Director Olsen, knowing all this, biting your tongue for years, trying your best to make things work under a broken and aged system, but offering alternative solutions to finance SOFA's work.
So please tell us, for my first question, more about the Executive's Article VII private payment system and the impact that could have on the state's waiting list.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yeah, thanks, Assemblyman. You know, the question was directly about private pay. I just want to, you know, just mention something in terms of some other things you said.
I think this administration really does care about older adults. So we've got a couple of things we're working on now with multiple state agencies. As I said, you know, our partnerships with folks like DVS are critical. We have 24,000 veterans in our caseload; 63 percent of the state's veterans are over the age of 60. And, you know, the Reimagine Long Term Care is going to be -- once we get the appointments, we'll be working on that.
But the private pay I think, you know, I've heard a couple of folks back in '19 when we passed this, and now that we're trying to make it really a technical amendment, are suggesting that we would be passing costs on to low-income individuals.
As you know, Assemblyman, I've been doing this work for 31 years. That is not the intent of this, and that's not what it is. We have never been allowed, the network, to offer individuals that have the ability to pay -- we have 1.6 million older adults that have incomes of $55,000 or more. That's not a lot of money. But you have people like me that could afford to purchase a service on behalf of my mother or my father -- we were literally barred, under law.
So the only thing the private pay allows is for the AAA network who wants to opt in -- it's not mandatory -- to offer it if they have already utilized their federal, state and local dollars. Ninety-nine-point-five percent of all of our funding goes towards individuals who are low-income, limited English, cultural and ethnic minorities. That's by federal law, state law. And those are folks we want to protect. So this really provides an option.
And one last thing. Families are already doing this. You do what you gotta do to help the people in your family, your loved ones, et cetera. We would rather that they come to us because we can look much more holistically, connect you to the hundreds of programs -- federal, state and local -- that Veterans provides, connect you to OMH or OASAS if it's alcohol and substance abuse, and so on and so forth.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:And I guess the hope is that if we allow folks to purchase the program who can, that may alleviate some of the people on the waiting list so we can promptly get to those on the bottom of that income bracket who are still on the waiting list. Correct?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yeah, that was the design. So, you know, there's a cost to the service. And so like if a home-delivered meal is $7, what we allowed but capped it was a max of, you know, the cost of the service plus 20 percent. That could be because you're contracting with Medicare Advantage, an MLTC, Mainstream, or just somebody in the community that finds these things valuable.
What we required is all the accounting to be separate and if there's any revenue generated from this proposal for the services, it is required by law to go back in to serve lower-income people, because that's our book of business.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:And since 2019, since we allowed the network to purchase -- or charge older adults for the programs, how many -- do you have data on how many older adults actually purchase services from the local agencies?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:We do, Assemblyman. The date that that was supposed to go into effect -- so it passed in fiscal year 2019, April of 2019. It was to go into effect April 11, 2020, and we know what happened in March of 2020. So I would be tone deaf as an individual to be pushing this during the middle of the pandemic. So we didn't do that.
I think we're going to be reevaluating where we wind up this year. But right now we have five counties that chose the opt-in. Most of it is for the personal emergency response system, which has been shown overwhelmingly to reduce hospitalizations, ER visits, observation status. It's about $200,000.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:I mean, obviously if we can find the necessary funding to cover all, or other fundings and mechanisms, public finance mechanisms to eliminate the waiting list, it's best to pursue a path that we don't have to charge any older adults seeking SOFA services.
But here we are, because of some of the references that I made earlier, that we know what the impact this could be on Medicaid and on Medicaid populations, we're trying to find alternative solutions, trying to get us there. But if we work together in the coming weeks to figure out a different pot of money, different revenue to fully fund SOFA's programs, I'm hoping that we don't have to charge any older adults.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:You know, it would be great to fully subsidize everybody. And I don't think that we can do that. And, you know, you and I have had this conversation, Assemblyman. This body, the Legislature, Governor's office and county governments, have picked up all of the costs where the feds have really let us down.
The Older Americans Act has been amended 13 times and added a whole bunch of work to us and to the network. All of it is appropriate, all of it. But none of it came with any money, so the least amount of money that this state receives is from the federal government, which is directing us on what we need to do.
Which is why we developed an Older Americans Act modernization proposal. Senator Gillibrand is embracing that. We're working with her to get really the due share that we deserve that can really go a long way. What we need is an annual increase of -- in my opinion, of about $2.7 billion, which would bring the resources to New York to allow this network to do what it does so well: You know, promote happy, healthy lives, living with dignity, avoiding hospitalizations and so forth, but having a strong infrastructure if people wind up in those settings and then are discharged back to the community.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:We're going to be taking testimony from AARP later, and I think they'll be releasing a report on the ineffectiveness of the ombudsman program. And the data just looks -- the initial data that we're getting looks horrifying: 52 percent of nursing homes and other care facilities failed to receive a long-term-care ombudsman visit due to lack of resources and staff. Nearly 80 percent of New York City's nursing homes and other care facilities failed to receive a single visit from an ombudsman. You know, the data goes on and on.
And, you know, we need -- my colleagues and I, you know, we want to professionalize, we want to reset the ombudsman program, we want to rebuild it. But every time, you know, we have these discussions we run into institutional pushback that people tell us, "Oh, if we remodel this, we may not qualify for the federal dollars."
It's my understanding the original framers of the program at the federal level wanted the LTCOP program to be independent. And there are other states that even host this under nonprofit organizations, not even government agencies, to execute that independence of this program.
So I think it's just a matter of political will to get us to a better place where we can truly have an advocacy program for these facilities.
And I'll continue my questions in my next five minutes. Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
To the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
And to our new chair of Aging, Senator Cordell Cleare.
SENATOR CLEARE:Thank you.
And thank you for your testimony. I'm looking forward to sitting down and speaking with you, Commissioner.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Absolutely.
SENATOR CLEARE:I'm not on -- it is on?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yes.
SENATOR CLEARE:Anyway, I'm going to try to project.
I'm Senator Cordell Cleare. I represent the 30th Senatorial District, which is Harlem, East Harlem, West Harlem, a portion of Washington Heights and the Upper West Side.
And I listened to your opening remarks about people who are historically blocked from achieving success. And a group of those people, I think, are home care workers. AARP submitted testimony that I was reading; nearly half of home care workers live in or near poverty, and more than half depend on public assistance to survive. These workers are continuously training and developing their skills and expertise to elevate the level of care they can provide, only to remain unable to support themselves and their families because of low wages.
The proposed Executive Budget provides for a 2.5 percent COLA for hardworking staff that fall under SOFA as well as other agencies. Why is this less than last year's 5.4 percent? And how is this low figure expected to retain staff and provide continuity of services? And also, what can we do to link it to the rate of inflation so this doesn't keep --
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yeah. Well, as you know, Senator -- and it was great talking to you last week, and look forward to our partnership. You know, the Governor proposed an increase that is tied to -- why am I drawing a blank -- the inflation rate.
So there was a couple of different things that you mentioned in there. Our COLA that we're provided this year was like 5, 5-plus percent last year -- 2.5, that was used primarily to cover the rate increase for personal care aides that we fund through our in-home program, which is separate from the Medicaid program.
And you're right, the wages are low. I mean, many of our counties, we authorized them to negotiate their own rates back in 2014 when MLTC kind of entered the marketplace. It was originally tied to Medicaid's rate. But in order to get aides assigned to the individuals that we serve that are just above Medicaid limit, they can negotiate their own rates. So many of our counties are paying a much higher rate, between 30 and 40 dollars an hour.
And I think some of them are starting to make sure that the contracts that they have with the licensed home care services agency has language that passes those increases actually to the worker and not to the administrative side.
So, you know, the COLA is developed based on -- the three big areas are the WIN program, Wellness in Nutrition; EISEP, Expanded In-Home Services for the Elderly Program; and the CSE program. And that's -- and the value is about $5 million.
SENATOR CLEARE:Okay. I was going to cut you off, but I wanted to hear everything you had to say.
But right now this is not enough money for our very valuable workers. And it affects even the care and the amount of care that people are receiving, and I'd like to see us work toward increasing that rate.
I'm going to try to speed up my questions, and you answered about private pay.
The Master Plan for Aging. You know, there has been a million-dollar appropriation in the budget for the master plan. Can you just explain such a large expenditure for the development of the master plan and also, in creating it, how much stakeholder input will be provided or sought out? And if you know, who is a part of that body right now? Who is a part of the --
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:I do. I mean, you know, there's a partnership that we have with the Department of Health, we're cochairing. Health is taking the lead. We're certainly a part of it.
But as was mentioned earlier, you know, we have over 20 state agencies as part of this. We have a stakeholder group that has I think 25 people. We plan on -- you know, what we have talked about over and over in the first couple of meetings that we've had is the responsibility that we ask of them not only to participate but to make sure that their partnerships and coalitions throughout the state are also represented. And we have an association group.
The original dollars that were put in last year's budget was half a million dollars, and so we -- you know, we're using NYSTEC to coordinate. There's a lot that goes on behind the scenes in getting this together. Like we talk every day, every morning; we have several calls during the week.
So the million dollars is going to, again, help us continue this, because the effort's about 18 months long, and then anything else that we identify that we need to do. We plan on doing a lot of public outreach. We need you guys engaged. We're going to be out around the state. But we really just started the -- the executive order was signed in November. We've had a couple of state council meetings. And moving on, I think next week will be our second stakeholder meeting, and then the association. But there's a lot of moving pieces and certainly I can give you the website where we're starting to populate that.
SENATOR CLEARE:When is that meeting next week?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:It's the second stakeholder committee meeting. So there's a state agency task force, there's a stakeholder, and then there's an association. And all will help, again, you know, populate at least the beginning of the draft plan.
SENATOR CLEARE:Okay, thank you.
And over the last few years we've passed a number of bills and pushed for investments in the LTCOP program, with the goal of increasing transparency, coordination between DOH and LTCOP, and to increase the number of paid staff.
Can you update us on these efforts and, in particular, address what seems to be -- and I know you spoke a little bit about it with Assemblyman Kim -- but a continuing problem of LTCOP staff or volunteers not being in the facility that they're meant to oversee?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yeah. So again, I thank you guys and the Governor for adding that 2.5 million in last year's budget that is baseline this year. That allowed us to hire 35 staff. So we went from 30 percent of facilities visited to between 50 and 60.
You know, this goes back to my original points on the federal government. This is a required program that could either be in-house or external, and we've looked at a variety of ways to structure this. And it's now, you know, with us. But we get $1.4 million from the feds to run a statewide program. I mean, you can't do that with the number of facilities that we have in the state.
The fundamental flaw of the Older Americans Act when it was passed in 1965 is the heavy reliance on volunteers. And volunteers are fantastic. We have almost a million of them over the age of 55. But I don't know how you could have a professional network when you're relying on somebody giving their time and energy.
And when you talk about the Long Term Care Ombudsman Program or the Health Insurance Information Counseling and Assistance Program, those are really, really intense programs and need to be -- you need to have hired staff, not volunteers. We lost --
SENATOR CLEARE:What was that annual amount you said you needed?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:From the feds we get about $1.4 million.
SENATOR CLEARE:And you need?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:What's that?
SENATOR CLEARE:And how much do you need?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:What we need is to try to get to a ratio where you're visiting every facility, you know, maybe 7:1 or 5:1 or something to that effect. So that we can cover what we're supposed to cover.
And again, I think that that will be a conversation I'm sure you guys will all have over the next couple of months.
SENATOR CLEARE:Well, what's the dollar amount? I'm sorry.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:The total dollar amount?
SENATOR CLEARE:Yeah.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:We receive about 6.9 million altogether. But if only 1.4 of that is federal, then -- you do the math.
SENATOR CLEARE:Okay. We'll continue the conversation. Thank you.
We've continued to hear a lot about unmet need and waiting lists for services at the county offices for the aging, which the Legislature has provided increased funds a few times to address. Can you walk us through the state of things there? And is there still unmet need? Are we making progress?
And also, can you update us on the Reimagining Long Term Care Task Force?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yeah, I'll start with the latter first.
So we're waiting for the appointments to come in. I think all of the Governor's appointments are done. It's the Legislature's appointments. So we're hoping to get that up and running soon.
So yes, you know, we had an original baseline of $15 million four budgets ago, and then the Legislature added another eight to it two years ago. So we receive about $23 million. That has provided services for people who are on -- who are assessed and needing services, 26,000 over the first two years of that funding.
Yeah, waitlists are going up. A lot of it is for the personal care aide shortage. So, you know, we don't -- we don't, Senator, wait for things to happen, we try to make things happen. And here's what I mean by that. So back in the day, all the county offices for the aging hired their own personal care aides, and then they all got out of the business and contract with LHCSAs, licensed home care services agencies.
We have been pushing with our association trying to get the counties to either hire their aides, so that we can eliminate the waitlists in those particular areas, or work with their LHCSAs to have aides assigned. We have 12 counties now that fit that mold. So there's other things that we can do.
SENATOR CLEARE:Okay. I'm going to ask a short question. I think you mentioned 800,000 units of housing in your opening remarks.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yes, that's the Governor's --
SENATOR CLEARE:How much of that is senior -- dedicated for senior housing, assisted --
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Well, it's a five-year, $25 billion plan. I'm not sure which is -- why HCR is so important for the Master Plan for Aging, because we need all of those agencies that are working across the age spectrum.
The Master Plan for Aging is not just about aging, it's obviously inclusive. But it's across all agencies. I was also sitting here for the first two testimonies. The impact of poverty on children and middle income -- access to food, education, et cetera -- is going to matter for -- as people age, and so we need to really look at this across the age spectrum.
SENATOR CLEARE:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:We've been joined by Assemblywoman Hyndman.
And we go to our Veterans chair, Assemblywoman Jean-Pierre.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN JEAN-PIERRE:Well, good afternoon. Thank you both for your testimonies.
My question will go to Reverend Viviana DeCohen. Thank you for meeting with me and my staff just a few weeks ago to catch up. But I have a few questions.
So last December the Assembly held a hearing on veterans' services and the assessment of going from a division to a department. And one of the questions that have been held is that there was no representation from your office at the hearing. And as we transition from a division to department, some folks are asking, What are going to be some of the stronghold communications between the department to the Legislature? And what type of funding shifts will be necessary, needed for the change?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you, Assemblymember.
First of all, let me say good afternoon again to all of you.
One of the things that happened with that hearing is something that is innate when there's technology. It was a lack of communication, and we actually did not receive our formal invitation. However, we did listen to the hearing and heard all of the thoughtful questions that were given by you as well as our stakeholders.
One of the first things that we did was to reach out to our stakeholders to ensure that we were all on one page going forward as we make this transition from division to department. We know that more is going to be needed on our part.
One of the things that I'm proud that we were able to do as we move into this transition -- and the communication will continue with all of our stakeholders on our monthly meetings that we have, with our in-person visits that we have -- and continues to be central on all of our media platforms as well -- is to ensure that the information, the communication is going to be done before, during and after the process.
We've already begun to change all of our forms as we move into that era. Our forms that used to ask and be able to ascertain assistance with benefits, we're now asking crucial questions: Are you sheltered now? Do you need help or assistance with rent now? Do you have food in your home? So that we can continue to meet all of our veterans' needs across the board.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN JEAN-PIERRE:So the second part of my question -- thank you for the first part. The second part of the question was, what are going to be the funding needs from -- because it is going to be a department. So do you anticipate funding needs, and what are those needs?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: We're so glad to tell you that the Governor's Executive Budget just gave us $300,000 for the veteran-mobiles. We know that this is going to be something that will allow us to access those veterans who are often hidden, and those who often will not walk into a building for these services. That's the money that's been given.
As we continue to go through the process, we're going to know step by step what we're going to be needing at that time. But the money that's been released thus far, we know that that's going to be huge in the impact as we continue to move into the department.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN JEAN-PIERRE:Okay, thank you. And I look forward to being one-on-one so we can talk more about those funding needs.
But also during that testimony there were some veterans who provided some emotional testimonies as far as homelessness. And in the executive proposal, there was 1.1 million to assist homeless veterans.
And so my question is, how many veterans -- do you have a number of how many veterans face housing insecurity in New York? And with this funding, is there going to be a joint program? How many veterans do you think that 1.1 million is going to be served?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: First of all, let me say, as not only the director of Veterans' Services but as a veteran who has experienced this, if we have one veteran who's served their country, God and country, and then come out to continue the service with family and the continued service with community, it is one veteran too many that is homeless.
We are so happy to hear that money is coming not just for our veterans for this program, who are unsheltered, but those again who have received devastation. So many of our veterans have experienced fires and end up being unsheltered, and they've lost so many other things. And then we have so many of our veterans with chronic conditions that moved them to where they have to have accessibility to their homes, and this is crucial.
So we are very excited about this funding. You know, to a lot of people, you know, it seems -- people say it's such a little amount with what's out there. You know, but there was a story of a woman who had just a vial of oil, and she went and got bigger vats and she began to pour the oils into the vats. And as she did that, the bigger vats were overflowing and overpouring.
And we feel that's what this Governor's budget is, that what seems like little is so much in the right hands. The last year's budget allowed us to bring in $900 million of services to our veterans across the state, with another 400 million in educational benefits. So, you know, we're very grateful for what we've been able to do. We've been able to accomplish a lot together.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN JEAN-PIERRE:So just for the essence of time, because I have a few more questions. So on behalf of myself and the Legislature, we thank you for your service and your expertise here. But the $1.1 million we still, as a Legislature, need to see numbers and who and how and where and how many is going to be served under $1.1 million. Because dollars matter here, and numbers matching dollars is critical.
So if you can get us what that $1.1 million is going to serve, and are there any participating programs that's going to support this $1.1 million?
And my third question is: So irregardless to last year's budget, again, we're talking about dollars. Five million dollars was a capital grant program. What is the progress so far, approvals, how many have applied? Do we have any stats on the $5 million capital project?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Yes, thank you, Assemblymember Jean-Pierre.
The capital grants program was announced by the Governor on November 11th, on Veterans Day, which we had declared was Veterans Month across the state. So that made it even sweeter. We worked with DASNY and our grants management partners, who actually opened up the gateway, but made also a very inclusive video on how to apply for the RFP, how to fill out the applications, and an intensive question-and-answer video that they can replay. Many of them are still replaying it.
As of right now, we have about a dozen in-process applications. The application period closed on February the 8th, and we're looking forward to continuing the process so that these grants can be disbursed. For so many of our partners across New York State, that will allow them to up-build and to reenergize and strengthen the foundations and continue to serve the veterans in their communities.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN JEAN-PIERRE:Thank you.
I see I have a little bit more time, so I'm just going to go back to something you said about the 300,000. So that's in this year's Executive Budget proposal, to establish a fleet of mobile veterans' services. How many veterans will they serve? Again, it's going back to dollars and how much is going to serve what population.
So what services will they provide? I know you talked about regional one time we met. But what is the 300 -- compared to 300,000, how many veterans is it going to serve and where is it going to serve?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Well, we are going to begin this program -- and again, we're very grateful and excited about it, because for us this program is getting to those veterans who were like myself, that were not in areas where there was a local DSO across the street.
So these mobile units are so important to be able to go across the state. We're going to begin with three -- one at the beginning, New York City, one in the middle, and one at the end -- so that we can get into those places and spaces where our veterans are.
One of the things that we're doing as we transition into the department is a program called Find and Serve. And Find and Serve allows us to get on these mobiles and take them into an area where a veteran will know that every Wellness Wednesday at the Piggly-Wiggly, between this time and this time, there's a van there that can help them to seek their services and all of the things that they've earned through the services, and be able to have someone there that can check their health status and ensure everything else that they're in need of.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN JEAN-PIERRE:Thank you.
My time is up. Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
We go to the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Our new chair of Veterans, Senator Scarcella-Spartan -- Senator Scarcella-Spanton. I'm making you a Spartan.
(Laughter.)
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:Hi, Reverend. Thank you so much for being here today.
We had a wonderful meeting where we got to discuss a lot of these ideas, and now we're seeing them, you know, come to fruition.
The one thing that I was concerned about with this upcoming Executive Budget was the cut of almost 14 percent to the Veterans' budget. I do understand that a lot of those legislative adds will be put back. But the 5 million for veterans nonprofit capital funding is something I would love to see continued as members also patch in with their local district needs as well.
But the one thing I did want to start with, which I think is wonderful, is the 300,000 for the mobile veterans advisor clinics. As we discussed, it's really important to meet people where they're at. I think it's great, the Find and Serve motto.
I guess I wanted to ask, how long will it take to actually get these mobile vans up and running? And do we have a breakdown of where they'll be going, which counties? Is it every county? And how frequently?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you so much for that question, Senator.
We're looking at all of the details right now as far as having them wrapped, what is going to be supplied on there. because there may be a few surprises on there. We may be able to not only give them some of the services that they need on paper, but we just may be able to supply them with a good pair of warm socks on there as well.
And again, we're looking forward to having them in all of those places. We've been listening to our partners, and some of our partners are looking forward to getting these into areas where they feel may have been a little large for them and conjoining with them.
One of the wonderful things that I have to tell you that I'm proud of the Governor, but also so many of you that sit here, is that we were allowed to go out and to join with you and support so many of our veteran partners at over 425 events just between September and December.
And seeing you there and supporting our veterans, and seeing their response, and utilizing not veterans as a number -- because we are not numbers -- but allowing all of you and all of us to be able to listen to them and not assume their voice, but to use a qualitative, phenomenological approach to asking them what their needs were -- when I saw this, and we received the responses as to the things that we need, that helps us to know what it is that we need on these mobiles.
Because some of them needed diapers. Others needed the food coupons that our Governor has invested in again. Some of them did not need some of the other programs that we were assuming that they need.
But I want to thank you again, because we saw you out there at these over 400 events in the past few months, and listening to what it is that the veterans need. And I know if we continue to do that, continue to listen to them and allow them their own voice, then we're going to do bigger and better even this year than that 900 million that we brought in.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:So, you know, I think that was a very positive piece of the budget and something that everybody is going to be able to utilize, and hopefully our collective offices will be able to call upon these mobile units to request them at different VFW meetings in our own districts.
The one issue that I really took -- that I wanted to highlight was in the Executive Budget it indicates that there's a decrease in funding for veteran nonprofit capital programs. Why are we decreasing this funding? And which nonprofit capital programs will be affected as a result of that decrease?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you for that question. I'm going to have to get back to you on that because I'm not --
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:That's okay.
And also the $1.1 million in funding for the Veterans Homeless Housing Program, could you provide details on plans for this funding? Is there supportive housing built into this?
In our district in Coney Island we have Surf Vets, which is affordable housing for veterans. And one of the issues that we run into is that these are people with service-related disabilities, they may have mental health issues, they're people who were formerly experiencing homelessness. So there's not a lot of support within that housing -- within that affordable housing system.
So I think that anything with housing for veterans really does need to be supportive. I say this as a military wife of somebody with a service-connected disability. And you need to provide resources for people who have mental health conditions.
So I would love to see supportive housing built into this. I don't think that 1.1 million could possibly provide the support that it needs. So I wanted to see what you do need to provide the supportive housing.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you, Senator. And I look forward to working with you on that as we actually -- we're in talks now for that program, because that's exactly what we want.
This is not a one-tier with these veterans. We have to meet them at the several levels to where they are. And that's why we're having this thoughtful discussion, to ensure that that happens. I look forward to continuing that work with you.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:Okay. And if you guys could please get me a number on what it would take to have a real comprehensive and supportive housing program for veterans, that would be great.
I also wanted to -- I know when we met we discussed the funding for the Veterans Memorial Registry, which is built in here, which is wonderful. I wanted to see if there was any comprehensive list of resources for veterans and their families. I think sometimes there's these great organizations -- I met with one today, Cohen Veterans Network, that provides mental health services to not just veterans but also their families, their children, spouses, whoever may need it.
Is there a comprehensive list within the state that veterans and their families could tap into? And if there's not, would a similar project like the registry for memorials make sense?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you for that question. And we're actually working out the details of that. In fact, after this meeting I have a meeting -- we have a meeting to discuss that program as well.
But we're looking forward to that half a million dollars that the Governor has given us to have this searchable database so that our family members can continue to honor the memories of their loved ones and have access to that for their children and their great-grandchildren. I happen to be a grandmother of 10, so I will appreciate when my grandchildren are able to look up Grandma and see the services in there as well.
Thank you for that, and look forward to working with you on this piece.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:Absolutely.
And my last question will be about the Dwyer Peer-to-Peer Program, which is a wonderful program. I think that veterans supporting veterans, especially upon their return, is critical to their success in reintegration into civilian life.
Do you feel that the Governor's budget sufficiently covers it? There was a very, very moderate increase to the funding for the peer-to-peer program. Do you think that it's sufficient or it should be increased?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Well, as you know, the Joseph P. Dwyer Program is an essential program around this nation. And for our state, we were happy last year when the Governor doubled that budget to the 7.7 million, which allowed us to be able to work with them and OMH to be able to get this program out to our various counties throughout the state so that they could erect a program as well.
We work closely with OMH to be able to do that, as well as our SUNY Albany researchers and partners, to be able to put together a concise listing, a guideline booklet, a Q&A booklet on how to erect and continue to strengthen and support them.
You know, wherever they are right now, we are committed, I'm committed to -- because this is a program that I used to send my veteran students to many years ago. So we know that this team is committed to continuing to support them with where they are, and we'll continue to push them as far as we can to ensure that our veterans across the state are serviced by that program.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:And if you could also just let me know -- I see that there's a breakdown by county. We don't have it quite as broken down for New York City, it just has New York City listed as the county.
If you could send me a breakdown of the peer-to-peer services and the funding that are in both Kings County and Richmond County, I think that would be really helpful. We're happy to get the word out and, you know, provide support to our local veterans.
And yeah, I just wanted to say thank you for your service and I know I'm very much looking forward to working together with the mobile vans. I think it will be a great help to veterans in need.
So thank you.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you so much, Senator.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:So we go to Assemblyman Eachus for three minutes.
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:Thank you, Ms. Chair.
Reverend DeCohen, thank you for your service. And I assure you your division, soon to be department, has all my support.
I also want to thank you for your optimism when you're sitting there eyeing a governor's state appropriations of a decrease of $4.78 million, or approximately 14 percent, and you still seem to have a little bit of a smile on your face.
So -- and relative to those new vans, do please check with the counties. My county is very, very concerned and gracious to all veterans. We have vans traveling throughout the county. We actually take veterans to their medical appointments and to shopping and so on like that.
But the question I have for you is I would like to first let you know that for 40 years I was a high school teacher, and I'm affiliated with many of the military service organizations. And I was wondering if you knew about something with the American Legion -- I'm going to pick out one service organization -- the Boys State and Girls State program at all.
This is a program where posts across the state can send kids for a week of basically boot camp, and every student that I have ever sent there through these organizations and has returned has bragged about it.
And we no longer support that -- we, being the state, no longer support that. So I am definitely going to ask for an appropriation of 150,000 for the Boys State and 150,000 for the Girls State to get us back helping these programs, because I feel they really need help.
Would your department support these programs?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: First of all, let me happily and proudly say I am a Legionnaire, and so I am very familiar with these programs.
And as a Legionnaire -- listen, as a department -- as a division to department, we want to continue to support all of our partners who are supporting our veterans. Part of our veterans is their families as well as the children. And there is no better way that we know to continue to strengthen our partnership than to ensure that the next generation continues to have the fortitude and the strength and the knowledge and support them, you know, as they go into adulthood, honoring our nation's heroes.
So I look forward to working with you with that, Assemblyman.
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:Director Olsen, I only have a half-minute, so I'm just going to pose my two questions. There won't be any time to answer them.
But the first is back to the LTCOP program. Eighty percent of those participants, those ombudsmen, are volunteers, and I just would like to hear specifically at some point in time what you're doing to encourage these volunteers. Because I didn't even know about the program, and I was 12 years on the Orange County Legislature.
And then the other question I would have is you have in your key investments and proposals "strengthening EMS," and I'd like to hear how you're going to do that too.
Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Senate?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Senator Ashby, five minutes, ranker.
SENATOR ASHBY:Thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you, Director DeCohen. Thank you, Commissioner Olsen.
Real quick, Commissioner Olsen, what's the timeline for the master plan?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:We're supposed to have a draft early on in the spring, and then it will commence -- hopefully after, you know, huge public input -- sometime next year.
SENATOR ASHBY:Okay, appreciate it.
Director DeCohen, good to see you.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Yeah, it's good to see you, Senator.
SENATOR ASHBY:You know, I'm happy to hear that we're starting to put something forward with, you know, these -- the mobile response. I think that's a good thing.
But in light of, you know, really the lack of funding and the lack of effort that we've seen with this Governor's administration with this new department, I'm kind of surprised to hear that, you know, that's the only thing that's going on. I mean, are there any other subdivisions that you're looking to outfit? Is there any other federal programming or federal dollars that you're looking to get to implement into this new agency?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Oh, thank you, Senator. Thank you for that.
Absolutely. And again, being into the public and going across this state now, from New York City, Bronx, all the way to Buffalo, has allowed us to be able to listen to the needs of our veterans. And so absolutely. We're continuing to work with our veterans who are incarcerated. As you know, we've already put in programs and veterans benefit advisors into so many of these correctional programs, and we're doing the welcome back with them as well so that they have a warm handshake back into society when they come in.
Our volunteerism, our programs for our veterans -- as you know, volunteerism has been a lifesaver for so many of our veterans who have gotten their dignity back because their self-worth is not only in God and country and family, but now back into the community with that.
Continuing to meet the needs of our veterans who are expecting babies and unemployed -- and this state has done a great job in our --
SENATOR ASHBY:Director DeCohen, if I could interrupt you, though.
Is -- are there any -- aside from the prison program that you had mentioned, is there any specific program that you know of right now that you're looking to implement with this new agency? I mean, other than the volunteers, which are great, but -- the elevation allows us to garner federal dollars for this. What are we targeting?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Well, we're continuing to target our suicide prevention programs. We're continuing to --
SENATOR ASHBY:I'm glad you brought that up. And I -- because I only have five minutes, I apologize for interrupting you.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: That's all right.
SENATOR ASHBY:But the Dwyer program, part of the aim of elevating the division to an agency is the hope that the Dwyer program could be permanent funding, so we wouldn't have to go back and do this each and every year. Is that something that your department is committed to?
Because right now, I mean, we're seeing a modest increase in that. This is something that needs to happen, that we hear about it every day. And I know that we have people here in the audience that are going to provide testimony to this.
Why is the Governor not moving on this issue the way that we need her to?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Well, Senator, we're glad for the movement that we have because, again, so much has been accomplished with the Dwyer program and what they're doing, and the doubling of those funds to $7.7 million.
And we continue to work with them as well as OMH and all of our other partners. We're going to ensure that we continue to support them in any way that --
SENATOR ASHBY:And I'm sure in your role, Director, and as a veteran, you know that that's not good enough. I know that that's not good enough. Our veterans and their families deserve better than that. And we've worked too hard over the last years to elevate this division to an agency to be satisfied with that response. That's as plain as it gets.
With $30 million -- take a look at these numbers. Thirty million in funding for New York State veterans. We have roughly 700,000 veterans in New York. In New Jersey they have $104 million in state funding. They have 300,000 veterans. In Massachusetts, $97 million in funding, roughly 300,000 veterans.
There's a huge disparity there. And we have a great opportunity here, and we have a great leader in you. And we need to do a better job for our veterans in making this happen. I know that you recognize this, and I know that you're pushing for it in a variety of ways. But New York State's veterans and their families deserve better.
What do we need to do as a Legislature to make that happen? What do we need to do to make the Dwyer funding permanent, to capitalize on federal grants and programming that could benefit our veterans and their families? This is your opportunity.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank -- thank you, Senator.
One thing that we need to do is to continue to work together to allow the voices of our veterans to allow us to know what their needs are. But also we have to look at what we've brought in. And again, the work that we've done this past year with what we were given has brought in so much and helped so many that remain unseen to all of us.
And as we know, our service, as was said earlier, is often unthanked, often unknown to all of the things that you're doing. But I want you to know that so much has been done already with what we have accomplished this past year, and we can only continue to do more. And we will.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you, Reverend. Thank you, Senator.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you, Senator.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Assemblywoman Clark.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CLARK:Thank you.
Good to see you. This is to Director Olsen at Aging.
I thank you for your testimony and for some of the many good things that are in there, but I know you were at -- in Rochester last week, and I, at a breakfast that our organizational group around aging issues was there. And you heard firsthand, as I did, that one of our amazing groups that does a lot of work in this space said it was probably one of the worst budgets she'd ever seen for older New Yorkers. And so that really does throw a huge amount of concern to me.
I think that particularly when you look at the issues we see around increasing poverty in our older New Yorkers, when you see the just huge population growth in older New Yorkers, when you understand what COVID has done in our long-term-care facilities, that even holding flat is a disappointment when we know we need to move forward to really make this work.
And I want to focus on the Long Term Care Ombudsman Program quickly, which we've heard a lot about. And I get that we keep saying we need federal support and we need federal investment, but last I heard we were 39th in the country in terms of a state investing dollars into that program. So if 38 other states are doing more than we are right now, I think we owe it to do more as well.
What do you think would be -- I mean, you know we can't run this program on volunteers. We can't have weekly visits based on volunteers. We can't have volunteers going toe-to-toe with DOH on answers for complaints. Do you sort of recognize that we have to get to the point where we truly professionalize this and invest dollars into it?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:I think the entire network needs that. Again, because the structure of the Older Americans Act 50-something years ago really relied on volunteers.
We are working with, you know, physicians' offices, hospitals, plans, long-term-care facilities, et cetera. And you're absolutely right, you can't expect, you know, 75-year-old, 80-year-old volunteers -- who are unbelievably dedicated and smart -- to do the job that a professional ought to do.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CLARK:Excellent.
And I just also want to say, you know, some of the things to flag as we look particularly at removing and getting -- continuing to get older New Yorkers who are on these waitlists for critical basic needs off these waitlists. You know, DOH had 2.1 million in its budget to create a new program that is particularly or could be considered duplicative to what we're already doing. Why not put that into SOFA? Why not get that extra $9.5 million that we need to remove waitlists, let alone go above and beyond to see what we can do to really help seniors in poverty?
Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
To the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Senator May.
SENATOR MAY:Thank you.
Hi, Commissioner Olsen, or Director Olsen. Great to see you again.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:You too.
SENATOR MAY:I wanted to thank Senator Cleare for asking a number of the questions that I had.
But I wanted to follow up about the NORC funding in the budget. And I'm glad to see there's Neighborhood NORC as well as the traditional NORC funding. But what are you thinking about our upstate cities which don't fall typically into either category? Is there planning for a third category of NORCs so we can have smaller apartment buildings, for example, in our upstate cities participate in this program?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yeah, Senator, good to see you as well.
You know, when we did the modernization of the NORC program a few years ago, it was at '14 or so, we did attempt in there to create models that would serve rural communities, urban communities and suburban. We worked with you last year and some of the NORCs, specifically for one in your district in Syracuse, where a couple of other tweaks needed to be made.
So, you know, I think that's something that we should all look at. It's budget-neutral, and what the Naturally Occurring Retirement Communities does was so ahead of their time in terms of bringing together healthcare and social determinants of health, social services that we provide to serve people holistically. So it's not meant to be exclusive, and I think that's what we tried to do, and the modernization might need a tweak.
SENATOR MAY:Okay, great.
And then following up to what Assemblymember Clark said, I heard you say earlier that we were hoping to get to about 60 percent coverage of nursing homes with ombudsmen.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:That's where we are now with the additional 35 staff that was negotiated, thanks to you and then the Governor last year, to add that to our budget.
SENATOR MAY:Okay. Because by law it should be 100 percent, and so we've got to start putting the money in to make sure that we're getting to 100 percent. That's where I am.
Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Assemblyman Gallahan.
ASSEMBLYMAN GALLAHAN:Thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you both for your testimony and all that you do for us here in New York State.
Director Olsen, I have one topic, and it is constantly coming across my email screen, it is constantly on my phone, and I constantly get bombarded with it, and it has to do with home healthcare aides. And the biggest complaint I have is retention and hiring, which we all are well aware of that. The biggest problem I have is in my own community. There's such a shortage, the retention rate is -- it's just dysfunctional. It's terrible. Because all these folks are going to McDonald's and Burger King for two and three dollars more an hour.
Now, you know, the state mandated wages for fast food workers. Is there any discussion about this situation with home healthcare aides? And if there is, I would love to know, so I can report that back to my constituents. Because I'm really -- I'm really catching it on this, and rightfully so. I mean, our loved ones are not getting the care that they need, and they're the most important people in our lives.
So I would really respect your response.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yeah, absolutely, Assemblyman. That is the problem.
As you know, last year's budget contained a $2 increase for personal care aides and home care aides, and another dollar coming up in October of '23.
You're right, it's difficult work. You know, you're not guaranteed a certain number of hours, you don't get paid when you travel. And the people that are in that business really love the work that they do. But you're right, when you have aides in somebody's house, you can help them remain independent with dignity for a very, very long time.
I mentioned earlier, and I'm not sure if you were here at the time, we have been working -- because our in-home program is not Medicaid. We serve people who are just above Medicaid -- who could certainly spend down, but they don't need to, because we coordinate a package of services around them, including PC 1 and 2, which is the personal care aides.
And what we have seen by, you know, trying to work with our counties to hire aides directly or have the licensed home care services agencies provide a certain number of aides just to the OFA, we've seen elimination of waitlists, we've seen no turnover. They're part of the care teams. Who's the most important part of that care team is the person that's in the home every day that can report things in realtime.
So these are the kinds of things that I think -- well, this one in particular, but there's other models of things that the Offices for the Aging do so well that really we're excited to bring to the Master Plan for Aging and the Reimagine Long-Term Care. Because I think a real continuum starts at the community level, and hopefully Medicaid is the payer of last resort.
And there's things out there that have been tried and tested and show a return on investment, both in terms of savings but really these are people, as you had talked about. I would love to -- I know I'm done, I was just going to offer in your district, we should have a conversation and see if that's something we can get the county executives to do.
I also just want to mention that, you know, as of this morning -- and vouchers may be late -- our AAAs have about $77 million available to them for ARPA funds through '24. That can certainly help.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank -- thank -- thank you.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:I'm so sorry, Assemblywoman.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
ASSEMBLYMAN GALLAHAN:Thank you. Thank you very much.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:To the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
To Roxanne Persaud.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Thank you.
Reverend, it's always great to see you. And thank you for your passion and your commitment to, you know, your colleagues, your fellow veterans. I really appreciate everything that you continue to do.
Director Olsen, are you aware of our legislation where we're talking about breaking up the 24-hour work rule for home health attendants?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yeah. That's not applicable to us, Senator, I'm sorry --
SENATOR PERSAUD:No, I'm just asking.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yeah, I'm familiar with it.
SENATOR PERSAUD:So we were talking about -- why I brought it up is when we're talking about the salaries for home health attendants, and across the board they are not being paid enough. They are working -- and you have some -- who work 24-hour shifts without being paid the appropriate amount of money. As you know, they are only paid for 13 hours that they work. And so we're looking to change that. I just wanted to bring that up.
Could you tell me what is the plan for the home-delivered meals? There are so many people who are still on a waitlist. What is being done to ensure that our seniors are receiving the meals that they should receive?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yup, Senator, I'd love to know where the waitlists are for home-delivered meals, because we don't -- we're not seeing that. There's pockets for sure, and there's some places in the city.
As you know, we do operate and administer with our partners the largest nutrition program in the country.
I'll also just mention that, again, meals are -- was the number-one service provided from the beginning of the pandemic to now, no question. And it's extraordinarily important. Food is medicine.
SENATOR PERSAUD:We're still having some -- so I have -- for example, I have a couple, both of them are cancer patients, and they're still trying to get it. They're constantly calling about having meals delivered. And, you know, we contact the agencies and, you know, then we have a stop-gap method, and then it happens again.
So, you know, we'll send -- we'll follow up with you on that, because --
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yeah, I'd appreciate that.
SENATOR PERSAUD:-- it's something that, you know, we need to --
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:I'd appreciate that.
SENATOR PERSAUD:-- to address.
And one last thing for you -- no, that was it, what we -- the home-delivered meals. I think I covered it --
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Can I just say something in 48 seconds really to everybody here?
SENATOR PERSAUD:Sure.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:SNAP benefits are extraordinarily important that a lot of older adults are eligible for that don't use it. It could put an extra $2,000 in their pocket.
Starting probably in the next month, last year's budget raised the income level for the Medicare Savings Program.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Right.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:That will serve 300,000-plus people, put $7,000 back into their Social Security checks.
We could really use your help, in addition to the networks that we're going to engage, to get the word out so that -- again, you put just those two together, that's $10,000 in people's pockets in this really difficult inflationary time. So we could certainly use all of your help as well to advertise in your district offices and public forums, that these exist.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Thank you. I hope you will send that to DFTA so they can send it to all our senior centers across the -- yeah, thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Assemblywoman Forrest.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:Thank you.
Thank you, Reverend DeCohen, for being here. We appreciate your service.
My question is for Director Olsen. As you know, SOFA is required by law and statute to submit a report to both the Assembly, the Senate, and the Governor. Right? That was due since September 1, 2020.
Now, you had spoken a bit about the report, but I wanted to get some more clarity. Who is leading the report at this time? And when the report --
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Which report are we talking about?
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:SOFA is supposed to give a report.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:You're talking about an annual report?
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:The Master Plan for Aging report, yes. And it's supposed to be given.
But who is actually leading this -- the report? And do you have a time frame on when this --
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:You mean leading the development of the plan?
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:Yes.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:So the Health Department is leading that, and we are working hand in hand with them.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:Do you know a time frame? Is there a time frame, a month, two months?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Oh, absolutely. Like I said, we were supposed to have the draft report due in the spring, but it's an 18-month process. The final report will be in 2024. I'd be happy to tell you what the timelines are that were laid out in the executive order.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:In the meantime, the $1 million that is in the executive report, is that part of that $1 million being spent on this plan as well?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:It's for development and technical support. There's -- like I said, there's a lot that goes on behind the scenes, from the development of a website to organizing the meetings and the calls and things like that.
So, you know, in last year's budget and State of the State, the Governor had announced that we would get 1.5 million. We got 500,000 last year and then preserve that commitment this year.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:All right, thank you.
And then also the AARP says that 96 percent of New York City's nursing homes and adult care facilities failed to receive a single visit from the New York federally required adult oversight program, the ombudsman program. Right? And they said that the -- you need one employee to visit five different facilities. And I'm a nurse, so I'm all for safe staffing, right?
Can you explain why this funding is -- I still don't understand, and I want to make sure. Why is this funding still not properly allocated? I mean, an only $2.5 million increase does not man the entire state, much less just -- it doesn't man New York City, much less the whole state.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yeah, I think, you know, it has traditionally been underfunded. I talked to you about how much we get from the federal government, and we have cobbled together through a variety of sources since at least I've been at NYSOFA, to try to increase --
ASSEMBLYWOMAN FORREST:I'm not talking about the federal, I'm talking about the New York City -- New York State's commitment.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Again, I can't comment on AARP's visits or not. I can get you data directly from us.
I think budgets are hard because they're big and there's a lot of different things that people want, and this is the beginning of the process where, you know, Governor outlays her priorities, you guys will do the same thing, and then, you know, there'll be a dialogue over the next couple of months --
(Inaudible overtalk.)
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Senate?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Cordell Cleare, three-minute second round, to close for the Senate. Oh, I'm sorry, not to close for the Senate. I forgot Senator Weik.
Three minutes, go ahead.
SENATOR CLEARE:Okay. Director Olsen, I just wanted to ask, did SOFA receive any pandemic money directly or through another agency? And if so, is it continued in the '23-'24 budget proposal?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Are you talking about stimulus dollars?
SENATOR CLEARE:Any dollars that SOFA received to --
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yeah, we received five different packages of federal stimulus dollars. That's what I was mentioning; the largest one is the ARPA funds that expire September 31, '24. And there's still quite a bit of available resources to the counties.
All of our money, except those that are outlined in our budget, are required by law to go to the counties. So I'm frustrated that some of them are not spending dollars that could help, again, with some of these needs that we have.
SENATOR CLEARE:Okay. And also a little off-topic, you know, I have senior centers in my district that provide incredible service to the seniors that are living there, who are living at home who depend on them daily for social, health and other resources. And they are literally, many of them, falling apart. They're not in good facilities, they are in need of capital.
How can SOFA help these very important centers? In my district I have A. Philip Randolph Center -- I mean, and they're scrambling, they're providing really critical services, as you know --
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:They really are. And there's never been federal or state capital dollars for senior centers. They're mostly funded, besides the service money we provide, they're mostly funded locally, as you know.
But you're right. I've been around, you know, for 31 years; I've seen a lot of these centers. Some of them are amazing in terms of their structure, and some of them are really struggling.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Yeah, and we really need it, because some -- they need to be retrofitted, they need to have bathrooms done, they need their kitchens --
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:They need to be welcoming.
SENATOR CLEARE:They need to be welcoming, and they need to be habitable for the period of time that people are in them, technology needs, and so forth and so on.
So that's just something I really want to bring to you and talk to you about how we can get those centers upgraded. I have Central Harlem Senior Center, they're operating in a basement. You know, that's not -- it's just not cool.
So I just thank you for that. The pandemic money -- you know, I saw senior centers and senior programs happening during the pandemic that really should have been happening all along. So that's why I asked that question about pandemic dollars, because some of that needs to be continued. We should have been doing it even pre-pandemic.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:You're absolutely right. We can talk afterwards because there's a lot of things that we launched with our association partners in counties over the last two years that absolutely are continuing.
SENATOR CLEARE:Thank you.
And Reverend, I'd just like to thank you for your service. I will contact you about the mobile units.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you, Senator.
SENATOR CLEARE:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Assemblyman Burdick.
ASSEMBLYMAN BURDICK:Thank you.
And thank you, Reverend DeCohen, for your service and for your testimony.
And I have to confess that I do share the concerns and being perplexed how your testimony seems to describe an increase in services and yet there's a substantial decrease in the budget. And, I mean, it kind of defies gravity.
And I'm wondering if you could try to explain how that might be accomplished, particularly with what I think is very laudable, to have the new Homeless Veterans Housing Program.
And, you know, the other question I would ask in connection with the latter is whether that's a program that you intend to work in collaboration with OTDA.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Oh, thank you. Thank you, Assemblymember.
That program, as I stated, it's still a new program to us, so we're still hashing out all of the details.
Less, I don't know from this administration, but I do know the dollar and cents amount that we were able to bring in. And again, that $900 million in services to our veterans across the state is a number that exceeded the one on last year.
And we know that there's more to be done, especially as we are moving into our new nomenclature as a department. There's so many levels and so many tiers. And we know that that is not our area, but we are looking forward to working with you to be able to ensure that this is going to meet the needs of all of our veterans across the state as we move forward.
ASSEMBLYMAN BURDICK:Well, I think it's a daunting task, you know, with the decrease in expenditures, as one of my colleagues noted. And, you know, it's commonly known that it's almost a 14 percent cut in the budget at a time of high inflation as well as increasing needs and a large veterans population. And as one of the Senators noted, it contrasts quite poorly, I think, frankly, with Massachusetts, New Jersey, other states in terms of the funds that they devote in their state budgets to their veterans services.
So I think there certainly will be some interest in increasing the budget. I don't know whether we'll be successful in that. But I think that that's something that we all would like to see.
But in any event, we certainly thank you for your service and everything that you're trying to do on behalf of the veterans.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you, Assemblymember.
I'd like to say, in this last 17 seconds, I remember the old adage of my grandmother having a half a cup of rice and looking like she could only feed herself, and she ended up not only feeding the entire family but she felt she was able to feed the community as well. And that's what we're hoping to continue to do with what we have.
ASSEMBLYMAN BURDICK:Sounds like a biblical reference.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
To the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Senator Weik.
SENATOR WEIK:Thank you very much.
And I want to say thank you to Reverend DeCohen. Thank you for your service. Thank you for your testimony today.
I come from Suffolk County, which has the greatest number of veterans in all of New York State. I'm very proud to say that. And I work very hard with our veterans to make sure that we're providing however we can.
We do have a lot of veterans who are complaining of kind of the same thing over and over again, which is that their posts are in disrepair. They've been applying for grants, they're waiting for signatures, they've gotten that far. And these posts are really vital to their services when they provide Joseph P. Dwyer Peer-to-Peer Program services. And if I heard you correctly, that you'll be going around assisting to try to help them apply for these grants. Is that accurate, you're able to do that?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Yeah. The grants gateway is open and they have recorded a video on how to apply for the grant and all of the Q&A that are out there.
Just so that you know, Suffolk -- I used to work in Suffolk and Nassau County, and so I know so many of these organizations -- and I have recused myself from the actual process of who was applying. But we did ensure that there was a comprehensive video that has been made that they can still access on how to, what to, and all of the questions and answers. And thus far, I've been told from a great many of them that are applying, that is relatively easy to follow.
SENATOR WEIK:I guess getting the signatures at the end is the hard part; that continues to be holding them up.
So of course if there's any way that you can advocate for them as well, that would certainly be much needed and truly appreciated.
I know our homeless veterans is a big issue as well in many areas. Are there any other services that you're going to be able to provide to assist getting them out of these tents in the woods and into shelters of any sort?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: We were -- we were happy to be able to have the service of Find and Serve and to utilize a platform for more outreach, the Find and Serve. And on Veterans Month we were able to access so many, so many veterans. One of our advisors walked over a couple of our veterans to the Department of Social Services and was able to get them the assistance that they needed.
One of them that I can tell you from last year now has 100 percent of her services, having been housed. We were able to work with and continue to work with those who have been sheltered with our resources so that they can get things like furniture and continue to get the food and other things that they need -- and especially those that have children, to be able to get them the book bags that are fully slotted.
So absolutely. Listen, we could make a list of a hundred things today and tomorrow the list is going to be a thousand, and more and more. Because I have to tell you, as a veteran, I always say if I could bounce a basketball and do a layup, everything that we would need as a veteran would be in our home free of charge.
SENATOR WEIK:Well, I look forward to working with you in the future.
Thank you.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: I look forward to working with you as well, Senator.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Assemblywoman Hunter.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN HUNTER:Thank you.
Thank you to you both.
Director DeCohen, at our December hearing we heard from several different witnesses. They were very compelling, and I wish you had been able to be in-person to hear the gentlemen talk about being homeless, not having housing.
So while we're having aspirational dreams about this budget and what both the Assembly and Senate will have to put in -- because it is not adequate where it is right now -- I'd like know what services are available today while another veteran is homeless. So that's my first question.
My second question -- and again, this was from the hearing, but I live and breathe it every day. As a veteran, I actually have a case that spanned four years that was one of the biggest issues that was brought forward from our service providers about not getting assistance from the state to help them facilitate these claims from the feds.
So my second question is, what is your relationship with the federal government in aiding our veterans to get their claims processed which have been languishing for years?
And my last question is relative to mental health and PTSD. We had a conversation about 988 and you press 1 and it will get you to someone who can speak to someone who can help a veteran. They have millions and millions of calls since that number was instituted, and that leaves the veteran hanging out, waiting. That's a lot, millions and millions, just to get to someone to talk to.
And so I'm looking for leadership. I'd like to see the $300,000 worth of vans. Give them to the county, give them to the direct service organizations. We don't need to see the state-level people right in the area, because our local people know where these veterans are.
And so if you could answer my questions in the time allotted. Thank you.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you so much. And if you don't mind, I'll answer them not directly in the order that you've given.
With the 888 {sic} number, we've been working with the American Red Cross. I'm wearing the band today. There is actually a committed and dedicated hero care line for our veterans for not just emergencies with fires, but all emergencies that they need, whether it's housing, emergency housing, emergency clothing, emergency cash for gas to get to school.
We continue to work with our partners at the VA right now, especially as the PACT Act has become a reality. We've also put out a video for that as well. We continue to talk with them.
They're also having an aggressive program right now where they've hired more people to address homelessness by getting dedicated workers and social workers and more in the mental health.
And right now we're doing just what we said. The 15 that we found and the 14 more that just came to us, we have had them walked over to shelter assistance ourselves, and then we've put in resources to assist those shelters to get the clothing and the things that they need while they're in shelter.
We continue to work with the Department of Labor to ensure the jobs, to ensure the education and even to ensure that their military transcripts are properly translated into jobs and things that they can get right now.
We're about the right amount of services because so many of us have been that homeless person.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you, Director.
Senate?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Senate is closed.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Okay, we have several more Assemblymembers.
Assemblyman Pirozzolo.
ASSEMBLYMAN PIROZZOLO:I'd like to say thank you to both of you for being here today. Reverend DeCohen, thank you for your service.
This question is really for both of you. Director Olsen, it kind of falls to you under Aging, and then, Reverend DeCohen, it falls to you because -- just because, right?
So last Friday I was sitting in my office and a gentleman comes in through the door, and he was a veteran from the Vietnam War. And he had his tax bill with him, and he said, "Could you do me a favor? Could you go over this and see what exemptions or tax breaks I'm not getting?" And we were able to do that, and I think we found two, if not three.
So as our veterans age, maybe using the internet or getting this information or emails, for some -- not all, absolutely not all, right -- but for some veterans who are a little bit older, it's more difficult to use this system.
So how do we let these veterans know or what are ways we can increase avenues to let all veterans know that there are tax exemptions, tax credits that they can be made aware of? How can we do a better job of doing that?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:So I guess I'll start.
And I know Beth Finkel is following us at some point today from AARP, but AARP and many other community organizations sponsor free tax services. It's like here in Albany they'll do that every Sunday during the entire tax season for hundreds and hundreds of people.
I think that there's a lot of things that happen that either the state's working on or the counties are working on that the public generally doesn't know about because we don't consolidate them somewhere to be able to provide that this may be available in, you know, the district that you work in or what have you.
So there are those types of services that are available free of charge for older adults specifically. I'm not sure their veteran status would matter. If you're just an older adult and you need help, those types of things are available.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you, Assemblymember.
And Greg and I actually work hand in hand with our seniors -- I am a senior now. And so we've been able to partner together to ensure, when we're having our seminars, that those who are aging do get the information.
We have it not only posted on our website, but now we have flyers that are posted in places like laundromats and the post office, with the names of our advisors, that says, Call us and you can ask us any questions -- especially for those who are aging, as far as knowing what their benefits are for home health aides for themselves through aides and attendants, for themselves and also for their spouses, anything that they do.
You know, the municipalities are serving so many with their own tax benefits, and we're working with them to do the same -- some of the same things that we're doing to get the message out in places and spaces that they frequent.
ASSEMBLYMAN PIROZZOLO:Thank you very much.
And I'd just like to say, once again, thank you for your service. I'd like to thank every veteran for their service. If you think about it, if it weren't for the service of veterans, hearings like this may not be happening.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
We go to Assemblywoman Lee.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN LEE:Good afternoon. Thanks for being here.
I just had a quick question for Director Olsen about NORCs. I wanted to get a better understanding of how the services for NORCs are provided. Is it mostly privatized, or is there any of the services administered from the county and state agencies?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yup. So there are multiple -- so we have NORCs throughout New York State, but most of them are centralized in the city. The original NORC SSP started there in '95, and then we drafted, when I was in the legislature, the Neighborhood NORC program in '05.
So what we did or have done on multiple occasions is an RFP that provides money to the community, and what they use is the same community infrastructure in the city that they would use for, you know, home-delivered meals. The nursing could go like VNS or others. But, you know, there's a pretty large infrastructure in the city of vendors that DFTA and others use to provide the services, and that's how that would work. They're not-for-profits and community-based organizations.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN LEE:And how did this model evolve? Like why is it that it's mainly privatized or given off to -- you know, farmed out to nonprofit organizations rather than being serviced in-house?
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:I'm not sure I understand the question.
So all of the services that are provided within a NORC building are also provided in residential homes throughout New York State. So what this model tried to do in the beginning was recognize that people had moved into a particular building at the time, when they were much younger, and they aged into the building. And so you have density of ability to serve individuals with both healthcare and social services.
So it's not farmed out, it's -- you know, an organization would apply for the funds and provide the services, based on the geographic area.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN LEE:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:We go to Assemblyman Ra for five minutes, ranker.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Thank you.
Directors, thank you for being here.
Director DeCohen, I just want to somewhat continue where my Senate colleague left off, you know, in terms of the overall funding. We did have a proposal that we worked on last year putting forward that would put $250 million on the services side, $250 million on the capital side for our organizations and all of that. And I think that's more in the ballpark of where we need to go.
But, you know, I hope with your leadership and the passion of people like my colleague Senator Ashby we can get there.
I will say, though, one of the -- I'm happy with the expansion of the Dwyer funding last year, happy to see it's in this, you know, executive proposal. But there is a cut that would potentially impact a bunch of other programs, including Helmets to Hard Hats, the Outdoor Prescription program which, you know, gets veterans outdoors and has them taking advantage of things that we think are therapeutic for their mental health.
So, you know, while I feel like the Legislature will advocate for those restorations, you know, I wish that didn't have to be the case, that they could be there in the Executive Budget proposal. So I won't even ask you to comment on that, because I think you probably agree.
But I do want to ask about -- there was some capital in the budget last year to help our veterans service organizations, which I think any of us in this Legislature have heard from them about the need for, you know, new roofs and paving the parking lot and boilers and everything under the sun to keep those places better places for veterans to gather and access services and, you know, be with people that have that shared experience.
So could you tell me -- I know applications are still open till the end of March -- but how that's gone or how many applications have come in? Do you think the information has gotten out there to the veterans' organizations that this capital funding is available?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you, Assemblymember. I'm going to go back to what I stated earlier, that right now we have a dozen in the process.
And we're continuing to put out the word actually monthly on all of our platforms, by snail mail -- we're still doing that -- by email, on all of our social platforms, including our website as well.
We were so happy to be one of the first states to have the Outdoor Rx program, and we have six people right now to be able to get the $25,000 to have an extensive program in their natural lands to continue to have those programs for our veterans, our military, and our families, that we know it's so vital to have these outdoor programs that can help on a mental level, a physical level, and on every level for our veterans across the state.
So very happy that the Governor was able to roll that out.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Okay. And just going back to the capital. So do you see a need to, you know, maybe do another round of that, put it -- you know, match that funding again this year so that we can help more veterans organizations keep roofs over their heads so there's a place for those veterans to go?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Listen, we want everything and everything times 10 for our veterans across this state. And so we know that this is just the beginning of so many programs that together we'll be able to roll out more and more -- all of our veterans, and especially our supporters who are supporting our veterans and their families.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Great. Thank you very much.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you. Thank you both for (pause) -- for staying here just for another three minutes --
(Laughter.)
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:-- while Assemblyman Morinello asks a question.
ASSEMBLYMAN MORINELLO:Hi.
I want to thank you for your service. I'm a veteran also, and that is -- and I've been on the Veterans Committee since I've been in the Assembly. And I'm very concerned about a number of issues.
One is more financial. This may have been asked, and if it has, I apologize, because I was in another hearing, and you can stop me. But the Governor removed funding for 17 veterans programs totaling 2.6 million that were added by the Legislature last year. To highlight some of the programs which have been very effective, Helmets to Hard Hats and outdoor recreation programs, which are healthy alternatives for veterans.
Is there any underlying reason as to why these were removed and whether you're intending to put them back? I mean, if we lose Helmets to Hard Hats, we're losing an incredible, incredible program to assist those veterans that have difficulties coming back, after they've been pretty much willing to give it all just to protect us. So ...
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you, Assemblymember.
That question was asked earlier. And again, for the RFP for the new $25,000 apiece for our new Rx program -- which is going to be ending very soon, and we will be disbursing the funds in April for those six recipients of that $25,000 grant. We're glad that that's there.
The other program -- I'm sorry, sir -- I was not familiar with as --
ASSEMBLYMAN MORINELLO:Well, Helmets to Hard Hats, I'd ask you to maybe look into that.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: That's right.
ASSEMBLYMAN MORINELLO:Okay? Because it's been a very valuable program.
And apparently it's probably been asked also, the elimination of the 5 million for capital improvements. The money from fiscal year '23, it's still available in appropriation -- reappropriations. How much of that, do you know, has been reappropriated, how much is available, and is there still an opportunity to request?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: The $5 million capital grants management program is still in effect. And so we're still working through all of the applications. We have 12 in process right now.
And we're looking forward to being able to disseminate those funds, and of course looking forward to continuing the program in the future.
ASSEMBLYMAN MORINELLO:Thank you.
And I want to compliment you on the creation of the mobile veterans benefits advisory clinics. I think you know rural areas, there's many veterans that live in rural areas. It just seems that a lot of the rural individuals are those that are willing to volunteer.
Will those be dispersed throughout the state?
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: We do have some counties that already have this program, so we will continue to work with those veterans service organizations and those counties that have been asking for this, that have been telling us that transportation continues to be the number-one problem, that they're looking forward to it. It's for those that want it. And those that have it, you know, we're so happy to be able to see our veterans being served.
ASSEMBLYMAN MORINELLO:Let me just add one last thing --
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:I'm sorry, Judge. The time has expired.
ASSEMBLYMAN MORINELLO:Thank you. I'm done.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Okay. Actually, I misspoke before. Assemblyman Ron Kim, our Aging chair, has a second round of three minutes.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:Thank you, Chair.
Director Olsen, just to wrap up my questions from earlier. So in Washington, D.C., the state's Long Term Care Ombudsman Program is housed under AARP's national office. The head of that program is Mark Miller, who actually used to head the New York State LTCOP program. In Michigan, the LTCOP is housed under the Michigan Elder Justice Initiative. And I'm sure there's plenty of other examples like this in the country.
And I bring these up because I just want to demonstrate the flexibility of the program. And depending on how we're able to build capacity for these programs, we can do a lot more. And I just want to give you an opportunity to discuss what we need to be doing together to fully fund and professionalize the Long Term Care program, which will save lives of nursing home residents.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:I mean, I think the short answer is you need to hire staff, which, you know, we were able to bring on 35 new people to take the place of, again, asking people to volunteer for a very complicated program. As part of our federal Older Americans Act modernization, a huge increase in workforce across the aging network, but also included in the Long Term Care Ombudsman Program for that reason.
So, you know, I think again -- I think you were out, Assemblyman -- I see there's a lot in the budget, there's a lot of needs. We hear them from every single agency, from every constituent, and it's a starting point for a dialogue.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:And, honestly, going back to the private payment system, it's a very intriguing, you know, concept for me because when you think about charging people a fee-for-service model, we often think about the MTA, the buses, the bridges, the tunnels, and it's usually housed under public benefit authorities or corporations who are able to leverage those fees to borrow against those incomes for -- to finance future projects.
And you're kind of -- because SOFA doesn't deal with intermediaries like MLTCs and through EISEP, counties are able to directly administer the reimbursements. You know, it's a unique situation for us to experiment on how to properly finance long-term care. And I'd love to stay in touch with you about not only this, but different mechanisms where we can rethink about public financing long-term care.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Yeah, I am always interested in having that conversation.
And the other thing, just to point out, is the service infrastructure that we oversee with the counties and their 1200 partners intervenes a lot earlier. And so you can help somebody get better or maintain themselves and not have to devolve to a point where they need a higher level of care.
And that should be -- that's what a real system of long-term care -- it goes from information to skilled nursing, but that's what a real system ought to look like.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:Great. Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Thank you both for being here and participating in today's hearing.
I know there's some questions that there wasn't time to answer, so to the extent that you have some answers to individual members, please send them also to myself and Senator Krueger so we can distribute to all of the members.
Thank you.
DVS DIRECTOR REV. DeCOHEN: Thank you.
NYSOFA ACTING DIRECTOR OLSEN:Thank you guys. Thanks, everybody.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:So now we will go to -- we are completed with the governmental witnesses, so now we will have witnesses from the members of the public. If you're following along, it's Panel A: Early Care & Learning Council; All Our Kin; Hunger Solutions New York; Adirondack Birth to Three Alliance; and Docs for Tots.
If there is anybody here who hasn't checked in -- I think most people have -- please let us know. I know people tend to stay in the back, but the panel after this will be AARP, New York StateWide Senior Action Council, Project Guardianship, Association on Aging -- so some of those folks may want to, as this panel nears its end, move a little further down.
We also have been joined by a member of Ways and Means, Assemblyman Dilan. So you have to do a little sharing of the microphone.
Just a reminder, everybody gets three minutes to make their presentation after all members of the panel have completed their presentation. Any members that wish to ask questions, just let myself or Senator Krueger know. And members, all members will have up to three minutes to ask questions, and please leave time for the answer.
So maybe just identify yourselves when you speak. I think we'll -- I think everybody's checked in. So why don't we start with the Early Care & Learning Council, the way I introduced people.
MS. CHIMENTO:Good afternoon. And thank you, Chairs Krueger and Weinstein.
My name is Meredith Chimento. I'm the executive director of the Early Care & Learning Council. ECLC is the coordinating body for the network of some 35 childcare resource and referral agencies that you've heard a lot about today.
We often refer to CCR&Rs as the workforce behind the childcare workforce. At the start of the pandemic, we worked directly with OCFS to ensure that childcare stayed open --
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Excuse me one second.
The clock should say three minutes because we are nongovernmental.
MS. CHIMENTO:As federal funds flowed through OCFS, it was the network that ensured that these childcare programs could access much-needed financial relief. We are grateful to the Governor and OCFS for their commitment to childcare, but unfortunately these investments do not go far enough.
In 2012, CCR&R state contracts were cut and have remained flat-funded ever since. Imagine no core contract increase in more years than it takes to send a child through the public school system. CCR&Rs are faced with a more dynamic and complex system, bigger problems -- funding levels have failed to keep up.
Since 2012, inflation has risen at a rate of 29.7 percent. What are we to do, a resourceful group of nonprofits, one that seeks out alternative funding streams and continuously cuts cost. But now things are too tight. Like our childcare providers, many of our agencies are struggling.
It is with this in mind that ECLC and the network of CCR&Rs respectfully request that the Governor and Legislature support the following increases:
Increase childcare resource and referral contracts, including registration contracts, by $7.9 million annually to cover increasing costs to staff the network who train the 17,000 licensed and regulated childcare providers serving 400,000 children in our state. Last year we delivered 50,000 hours of technical assistance and helped 32,000 families find quality, affordable care through our referral networks.
We also ask for $6.5 million annually to fund the Stabilization and Deserts Grant technical assistance positions. The funding for these positions will sunset in the next year. CCR&Rs offer core business trainings to assist providers who are often financially unstable and at a risk of closing their doors.
As you've heard, 64 percent of New York State is a childcare desert. Without the TA specialists working closely with new and existing childcare providers, the situation will only deteriorate, undercutting parents' ability to work and undermining the state's economic future. These TA positions delivered grant assistance to 10,600 existing childcare providers and helped 846 prospective providers navigate the grant process.
Additionally, we request $4 million to increase infant/toddler mental health consultation programming to ensure that our younger children get off to the start they deserve, with nurturing and responsive care, and an additional 5.5 million to provide DEIB training to mitigate and address racism and unconscious bias.
CCR&Rs were established into law in 1993. We are asking that you continue to honor the critical role that CCR&Rs play in the New York State economy through their support of childcare businesses, employers, and families, by increasing contracts that have unfortunately remained stagnant for far too long. Our work, which is critical to keeping New York working, will struggle to continue without this adjustment.
Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Next, All Our Kin.
MR. MORALES:Senators, members of the Assembly, my name is Steven Morales, and I'm the New York policy director at All Our Kin. All Our Kin is a nonprofit organization that trains, supports, and sustains family childcare educators in New York City, and we're also proud members of the Empire State Childcare Campaign.
Family childcare, or home-based -- childcare in a home-based setting is a critical part of New York's childcare infrastructure, and many parents choose family childcare for its ability to offer flexible hours, mixed-age, culturally responsive care in a family's home language.
In New York State, 40 percent of children in publicly funded care are cared for in family childcare settings.
Despite the demand for care across the state in any type of setting, our childcare system remains in crisis, with programs across the state closing their doors. At the core of the childcare crisis lies one simple fact: Compensation for childcare professionals is woefully inadequate. On average, childcare educators in New York are in the bottom 3 percent of all earners, and when childcare providers struggle, children and families suffer the consequences.
Since the beginning of the pandemic, New York State has experienced a net loss of over 1,300 childcare programs, which translates to over 10,000 lost childcare slots. That's thousands of working families whose lives are disrupted daily because of lack of childcare access. And the crisis is ongoing.
In a December survey, one-third of family childcare educators in New York expressed that they are considering leaving their jobs and closing their programs, and the number-one reason for that is low compensation.
So to begin addressing this crisis, All Our Kin is calling for the following investments. First, in the short term, a childcare workforce compensation fund of $1 billion this year. We consistently hear from childcare providers that past stabilization grants temporarily helped keep their business afloat, but when temporary payments stopped, providers found themselves back at square one wondering how they would pay the bills.
The $389 million in the Executive Budget for stabilization grants is a good start but is not enough to keep educators from leaving the field for higher-paying jobs in other sectors. So we ask that you build on the Governor's investment by increasing the amount to $1 billion this year.
Second, we know -- and a recent EdTrust study confirms -- that our current childcare subsidy system pays educators thousands of dollars less than it actually costs to run a childcare program. So we need a long-term commitment to pay educators based on what it actually costs to provide care so they can be in the field for the long term.
And finally, we call on the state to expand childcare access to all children, regardless of immigration status, by investing $60 million in a childcare fund for undocumented children. No child should be denied access to childcare and an education because of their immigration status.
In closing, despite the achievements of last year's budget, the childcare crisis in New York State is far from over, and we urge you to seize the opportunity to invest in children and families this year.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you. We go to Hunger Solutions New York.
MS. HESDORFER:Good afternoon, and thank you for the opportunity to testify today.
My name is Krista Hesdorfer, and I'm here representing Hunger Solutions New York, a statewide nonprofit dedicated to alleviating hunger for all New Yorkers by maximizing federal nutrition assistance programs, including SNAP, WIC, school meals, and other child nutrition programs.
Today I'll focus on SNAP, our nation's largest anti-hunger program, which provides monthly food benefits to more than 2.8 million New Yorkers.
For over 35 years, through a contract with OTDA, we have worked to maximize SNAP through the Nutrition Outreach and Education Program, or NOEP. Through NOEP, a network of community-based organizations provide outreach and assistance to help more eligible low-income New Yorkers connect with SNAP benefits.
Recognizing the importance of this work amid an ongoing hunger crisis, last year the Legislature successfully championed an additional $1 million in NOEP funding, for a total of 4.22 million. That additional funding supported 14 new SNAP assistors in high-need and rural counties, and expanded remote SNAP assistance statewide.
This year NOEP is on track to reach 134,000 New Yorkers. However, without sustained funding, NOEP will be forced to scale back. And unfortunately, the executive proposal does not include the $1 million that the Legislature added last year.
Without added investment this year, NOEP services will be reduced in Erie and Monroe counties and all boroughs of New York City. Chemung, Cortland, Essex, Franklin, Lewis, and Schuyler counties will lose all NOEP services.
To avoid these devastating cuts, we ask the Legislature to restore and build on previous investments, funding NOEP at $5.22 million to sustain and expand outreach and assistance for SNAP and other federal nutrition programs, all of which are undertapped in New York.
This modest investment brings a uniquely high return. Every dollar the state invests in SNAP outreach is federally matched dollar for dollar. And because SNAP benefits are 100 percent federally funded, NOEP has had a more than 27-fold return on investment for New York.
And I must mention one other critical anti-hunger proposal, outside of human services on paper but not in spirit. New York must provide free school buses and lunch for all students across the state. This is a critical step to support families, providing an estimated $140 per child in monthly grocery savings, while also supporting children's learning and development.
We urge the Legislature to adopt these vital anti-hunger proposals to support families and alleviate hunger across the state. Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Adirondack Birth to Three Alliance.
MS. RYAN:My name is Kate Ryan. I'm the director of the Adirondack Birth to Three Alliance, the signature program of Adirondack Foundation. We're a coalition of providers, organizations, and community members across the Adirondacks. We appreciate the opportunity to share with you the needs of our region.
The Adirondacks are home to approximately 7,000 children three years of age or younger. Our population density is 14 people per square mile, compared to the state average of 428. Although beautiful, our landscape presents unique challenges. Many families travel over an hour to access services, including childcare.
The childcare crisis cannot be solved for our region with centers serving 30 to 100 children. We need family or group family childcare. This is a big undertaking, as it requires eight to 12 family and group childcare providers to serve 100 children.
Prior to the pandemic, nearly 80 percent of our census tract were already considered childcare deserts, and since then we've lost another 1200 slots. Investments and recruiting and onboarding new childcare providers are essential.
I'm proud to sit on this panel with my colleagues. Much of my testimony seeks investment in the work that they do. Local childcare resource and referral agencies are uniquely positioned to provide support to new and existing childcare providers and assist families in identifying programs.
CCR&Rs in the Adirondacks simply do not have the capacity to recruit and support the large number of families and group family providers needed. The alliance supports the Early Care & Learning Council's request for new state funding of $7.9 million to support the CCR&R program.
High-quality early childhood education systems rest on standards that are based on longstanding and current research that demonstrates improved outcomes for children. QUALITYstarsNY provides support to program staff and providers to achieve these standards, and we request an additional investment of $20 million.
There is a need to invest in the development of trauma-informed practices in classrooms that incorporate appropriate and social/emotional strategies implemented through racial equity and multigenerational poverty lenses. In 2018, the Infant/Toddler Mental Health Consultation Project was launched. An increased investment would ensure that young children birth to five would have access to nurturing environments with the skills and resources to address social, emotional, and behavioral needs. The alliance supports the ECLC request for 4 million to support mental health consultants.
Lastly, the Help Me Grow model works to promote child development, makes developmental and social and emotional screening universally available, and provides ongoing support for families. Help Me Grow is a proven prevention model that fosters strong families and ensures that all children get the support they deserve. The alliance supports an investment of $500,000 to enhance access in the existing catchment areas and additional funding to expand the program into regions like the Adirondacks.
On average, our families earn $10,000 per year less than other New Yorkers. Approximately 18.2 percent of our region's children live at or below the federal poverty level. Franklin County rates second in the entire state for the percentage of children ages 18 and under living in poverty.
The proposals I have mentioned only address a fraction of the issues faced by the Adirondacks, but each would be highly impactful toward improving the services offered to young children and their families.
Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
And Docs for Tots.
MS. ISAKSON:Hi. Good afternoon, everyone. Thank you for the opportunity to speak today regarding New York State's Help Me Grow model.
My name is Liz Isakson, and I'm the executive director of Docs for Tots. Docs for Tots is a nonprofit organization that believes that every child under five deserves a chance to reach their full potential. We believe that working together, from family members to Assemblymembers and Senators like yourselves, we can ensure New York's zero to five thrive their whole lives.
What is Help Me Grow? Help Me Grow New York represents the four existing Help Me Grow systems: Long Island, Western New York, Finger Lakes, and Onondaga. Each Help Me Grow is organized locally and respectively organized by Docs for Tots, Community Connections of New York, the Children's Institute, and the Onondaga Early Childhood Alliance. However, within each community, there's a coalition or leadership team.
If you put together all the people that are involved in overseeing and creating this Help Me Grow system, over 100 community-based organizations over 17 counties in New York State are currently working to build better systems for young children.
Help Me Grow is a national evidence-based model of community support for families with children under five. It's basically a form of primary prevention, addressing things before they start. It focuses on promoting optimal child development by linking families to existing community resources, identifying developmental concerns early through universal access to screening, and celebrating the amazing transformation that occurs from the time you take that newborn home from the hospital to the day you're sitting at their fifth birthday party and they're blowing out the candles on their cake.
The model works across sectors -- human services, healthcare, childcare -- to help families at the community level effectively navigate really unfamiliar systems. In 2022 alone, the four Help Me Grow systems reached 10,000 children.
Why is this needed? For too many families in New York, whether because of location, poverty, or systemic inequity, access to vital services for the under-five-year-old child are out of reach. They're just unknown. Children thrive when their families are informed and supported, and Help Me Grow provides that information and support to new families.
It doesn't replicate resources, it elevates existing ones. The four Help Me Grow communities in New York State are serving a fraction currently of their potential need. Yet additional communities, like the North Country over there, are eager to join the ranks and become Help Me Grow communities. They see how the model improves their community-level data, their services and supports for young children.
We are disappointed that the Executive Budget merely reappropriated last year's investment of $200,000 -- which we haven't even got the chance to spend yet -- and does not allocate continued funding for Help Me Grow.
We request $500,000 total to maintain the four communities and add at least one or two new communities. Ideally, with everybody who's lined up to become a Help Me Grow, something like $2 million would really help us.
Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
So for questions -- just a reminder colleagues, three minutes for both question and answer. And we go first to Assemblywoman Clark.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CLARK:I never get to go first. Thank you, Chairwoman.
A couple of questions. First, Krista, just -- I know it's not the committee of jurisdiction, but I just want to uplift universal school meals. No child should go hungry in our state. Both of my school districts that I talked to about this, one went up 40 percent and one doubled when there were universal school meals. We know we were reaching children who were going unreached before. So thank you for bringing that up. We will continue that drumbeat.
This is a question for some of our childcare experts. We do talk about the stabilization grants, we talked about different -- differential rates, we talked about all these different things. What do you see as sort of the real how we get to really uplifting on a permanent, sustainable basis for paying our workforce a wage -- I mean, no one can afford it, right? Families can't pay more, and providers don't have the dollars to give their staff more money.
So the stabilization's great, but I think you kind of touched on it a little. And we've been trying to put a drumbeat around this. So just wondering what you see as a real answer to getting to that point where we sustain wages at a higher level.
MR. MORALES:Absolutely. There we go. Okay, yeah, absolutely. We need to get to a place where we are paying providers based on the actual cost of care.
What our current subsidy system does is it pays them based on a collection of what the state is able to charge families. And we know that families are already not able to pay what it costs.
And so there are studies out there, multiple studies that show that it really costs thousands more dollars per child than we pay. So we need to do that, in addition to the stabilization measures, and then we need to continue expanding access to care to more and more families.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CLARK:Excellent.
And then on the differential pay, we would love to hear as well -- you know, one of the things we're struggling with in terms of not just -- I mean, providers are closing their doors, but the nights and weekends are really, really an issue. As far as we've been told, the differential pay can be a bump-up of 5 to 15 percent, but most counties are paying 5 percent.
Do you see, if we actually got a differential pay up to 15 percent across the state, that it might make a difference towards there being more spots available for nights and weekends?
MR. MORALES:I mean, increases in funding and reimbursement rates are always great, and providers appreciate them. But again, we're not going to get to the place where we need to get to until we're paying based on the cost of care. Because at a certain point the mathematics for a childcare provider, whether they are a center or a home-based program, don't add up.
So we have to get --
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CLARK:Well, we have a bill for that. So we'll get you on it. Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Senate?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Senator Jabari Brisport.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Well, good afternoon. Thank you all for sticking it out. And a pleasure to see some of you again.
My question is for the panelists in the childcare space. Earlier this -- earlier today I was speaking with OCFS; I asked them about waiting lists, if they had more data on just the need for childcare. And they weren't able to give a number or any sensibility of waiting lists, what was going on.
Could any of you speak to waiting lists, what you're seeing? Are they getting longer? Are people who qualify for subsidized childcare on these waiting lists? What can you share with us?
MS. CHIMENTO:Sure.
So the state doesn't require childcare providers to maintain waiting lists. And our referral database, which does the majority of parent referrals, does not necessarily track waiting lists. It's not set up to do that. So it's the individual childcare provider that maintains the waitlist.
With that said, I have three staff coming back from maternity leave; they're two years out to find infant care in the Capital Region. It's not available. It's that simple.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Thank you.
I also just had a question, too, for All Our Kin, Mr. Morales. The gap in between, you know, the cost of care and how much we reimburse, how does that affect your providers?
MR. MORALES:It makes our providers make extremely difficult choices every day. We've seen that. We've seen providers themselves who have had to close or who have lost staff members to other industries.
And so that gap is really taking money out of the pockets of educators, because what they are doing is they are then subsidizing the system with their own dollars, with their own time, when they're working extra shifts. And so they're doing their best to care for children. But when the money is not there, they're making those really tough calls, working 80, 100-hour weeks to make up for the difference.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Thank you.
And with the time I have left, just one more question for Adirondack. Ms. Ryan, I believe someone from Adirondack gave us written testimony for our hearing earlier on the crisis, and basically gave us the data that prior to the pandemic, around 80 percent of your census tracts were considered childcare deserts. And then since then, you've lost 1200 more slots, or 25 percent of your capacity.
Have the stabilization grants slowed that down or reversed the trend of losing childcare slots in the Adirondacks?
MS. RYAN:I don't have the data to support that. But I will say anecdotally that it was helpful, but we are still seeing serious discrepancies and loss of slots.
Specifically, many of our centers that have been able to maintain are no longer able to do so, and we're seeing them closing.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Thank you. I appreciate it.
I believe it was said earlier when OCFS was here, but $1 billion in stabilization grants wasn't enough to save the sector about two years ago. And we definitely need more that 389 million this year.
Thank you all.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:We go to Assemblyman Maher.
ASSEMBLYMAN MAHER:Thank you. Thank you for painting this portrait of what you all do on the ground level. And obviously on behalf of all of us, thank you so much for what you're doing. Hopefully our job is going to be able to do what we can to support you all to go back into the community and do what you do.
I have three questions, and anyone who'd like to jump out and answer, I just would love to have your feedback.
First, we talked earlier -- my colleagues and I asked some questions of the Office of Children and Family Services. Specifically, I would love to know your interactions with providers on applying for desert grants, how difficult that can be. It can be frustrating in terms of receiving funding and then not getting to the next step. Do you have any recommendations that we can pass on to our contacts at the Office of Children and Family Services?
The second is promoting more folks to let them know that they are eligible for the expansion of childcare assistance, not taking into account the fact that it's difficult to apply for. Is there anything promotionally that you guys are currently doing that we can assist you with and we can collaborate on? That's something we can do offline as well. But if you have some specific things, I'd love to have everybody hear from them.
And then public-private partnerships. For the new tax credit that's going to be coming out, have you guys already started to engage with private businesses on potentially having sites on-site for some of these warehouse jobs and other locations that people would work at if they had some relief?
MS. CHIMENTO:Thank you. Those are great questions.
So as far as Stabilization and Deserts, OCFS funded 70 positions through the CCR&R network to have -- help them navigate the process of applying for the grants. It was at times laborious. And childcare providers serve and care for the love of children, which is why the business support specialists that I spoke about are so necessary. They are the ones that are helping childcare providers run a business -- a losing-proposition business, but still a business.
So I think the piece about Stabilization and Deserts is increased access, multiple languages -- all the things that they've done -- but it's keeping these 70 staff in place to help them navigate the process.
The second piece that you asked was about business partnerships. That is something that the CCR&R network also does. It's another piece of what we'd like to do, is to continue to employ business experts that are able to navigate that public-private partnership. And some of the Governor's recommendations have funding identified for that. We would like to see that funding -- some of that funding come to the CCR&R networks.
I forget the third question.
ASSEMBLYMAN MAHER:The third one was promotion of the expansion of childcare services, what we can do to kind of collaborate, on some of the efforts you've been making, to promote it.
MR. MORALES:I mean, I think I would love to see a concerted effort on the part of OCFS and working with local agencies in making folks aware of the services that they are eligible for.
I worked for New York City for a time, in the Department of Education, on the expansion of pre-K, and there was a dedicated team whose job it was to go out into communities and make sure folks knew that they were eligible for these things.
So that's something I think we could really think about.
ASSEMBLYMAN MAHER:Would love to work with you on that.
MS. CHIMENTO:We do that through the CCR&R network.
ASSEMBLYMAN MAHER:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
To the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Senator Samra Brouk.
SENATOR BROUK:Hi. Thank you so much.
First, I just want to thank all of you for being here and sticking it out and sharing this testimony. So often many of us talk about giving voice to the voiceless, right? You're literally giving voice to the little kids who can't come here and advocate for themselves, and then probably very overworked parents who can't make it here as well. So thank you for everything you do.
I have two questions. One of them is probably not a surprise. We've talked a lot about compensation for this workforce. It's a societal ill that we seem to give the least amount of value to human services in this country and in this state, and we're working to address that.
But for anyone that wants to answer specifically around the childcare piece, based on the trends that you've seen over the last couple of years, what do you think is going to happen next in this sector if we don't make increased investments on top of what we've done with the Executive Budget to make these actually competitive wages?
MS. CHIMENTO:I'm going to flip it to you.
But you're going to see mass exodus and a complete collapse of the childcare system. So that's why the Empire State Campaign for Childcare speaks about the $12,500 annual bonus or incentive for childcare providers. The system's this close to collapsing.
MR. MORALES:Yeah, I mean, we've seen the trends. We know that programs continue to close. And they're going to continue to do so without that sustained investment.
SENATOR BROUK:And we're talking not 10 years from now, five years from now. When you're thinking about collapse, what's your time frame you're thinking about?
MR. MORALES:So I'm pretty sure in a recent survey in December, done by the National Association for the Education of Young Children, they surveyed providers in New York. And they were worried that -- 33 percent of family childcare providers said they were worried about having to close within the next year.
SENATOR BROUK:In the next year. Thank you.
My next question is about something, Mr. Morales, that you brought up around children with specific immigration statuses. And I was just curious -- I didn't catch it -- how many children right now are not covered because of their immigration status?
MR. MORALES:So I can follow up, or someone from the Empire State Campaign can follow up with that estimate. Because we have -- we have some estimates which we can share with you.
SENATOR BROUK:And your best guess, maybe having talked to any of these families, what do they do?
MR. MORALES:I -- I think there's a range. They do what any parent who's struggling to find childcare does. They might have a relative. They might have a neighbor. They might go to a family childcare provider who might offer them a discount out of their own pocket, which we see a lot of times.
So really -- and a lot of times they leave the workforce or they're unable to work because of it. So there's a lot of negative consequences for -- when we don't provide care.
SENATOR BROUK:Thank you. I appreciate it. Thank you.
MR. MORALES:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:We were joined a little while ago by Assemblywoman Rajkumar.
And we go to Assemblywoman Gonzalez-Rojas.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN GONZALEZ-ROJAS:Thank you all for your testimony.
Krista, these questions are for you. Can you tell us how much families save per month in groceries if we fund universal school meals?
MS. HESDORFER:Happy to.
It's an estimated $140 per child per month in grocery savings.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN GONZALEZ-ROJAS:Great.
And can you talk about some of the other specific benefits in funding universal school meals? As you know, I'm a champion for this initiative, and I really want the Assembly and Senate to really understand the implications of something so profound and how helpful it could be for our families and children.
MS. HESDORFER:Yes, definitely, thank you for your continued support.
It's really hard to imagine a more impactful investment that New York State could make. Providing universal free school meals supports children's education. Kids score better on tests, they're better able to focus and engage, their attendance improves. Of course it reduces food insecurity, which is of concern to many folks here today. And it also improves children's mental and physical health.
There's also benefits for schools. They're no longer spending administrative and financial resources chasing down debt from families who can't afford to pay.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN GONZALEZ-ROJAS:Can you talk about the way in which it could draw down funds from the federal government if we put our own money into this?
MS. HESDORFER:Yes. So our work focuses on maximizing the federal Nutrition Assistance Program. So I spoke a little bit about how the NOEP investment would be federally matched, all SNAP outreach dollars. And part of the universal school meals policy is maximizing federal and nutrition programs as well. So making sure that any school that's eligible for the community eligibility provision is able to participate in that, and maximizing those reimbursements for free school meals as well.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN GONZALEZ-ROJAS:Great.
And so can you share more about NOEP, the Nutrition Outreach and Education Program? Exactly how does it work, and what is the return on investment in this program in particular?
MS. HESDORFER:Sure.
So we manage, through a contractor, through OTDA, a network of community-based organizations across the state. They provide outreach and free and confidential application assistance to make sure that all folks who are eligible for SNAP benefits are able to receive those benefits. They're friendly, hand-holding sort of folks, to get people through that process.
The return on investment for New York in recent years has been 27-fold, because SNAP benefits are 100 percent federally funded and because SNAP outreach dollars that the state invests are matched dollar for dollar by USDA SNAP outreach funds.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN GONZALEZ-ROJAS:Great, thank you so much.
I want to underscore how helpful this is for children and families. But we heard from the earlier panel that many seniors who are eligible for SNAP are not enrolling because they're not aware.
Thank you. Any comments there?
MS. HESDORFER:Yes. I'll just say there is an estimated 200,000 seniors who are eligible and not participating in New York State, and part of our work is providing the resources and assistance to help senior service providers connect more of those folks with SNAP as well.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN GONZALEZ-ROJAS:Thank you for your work. Thank you all.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Senate?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Senator Rolison.
SENATOR ROLISON:Thank you, Chair.
We had a hearing a few weeks ago about this very topic, which was described as a crisis and is being described again as a crisis by you, and I think we all understand that. And I don't think we talked about this in the hearing, so I wanted to get your perspective, and anybody can really jump in.
Let's just say money became available, staff could get hired based on the money available and the wages paid, and to staff up and create additional childcare slots and to retain the employees that are currently doing this great work throughout the state.
What goes into -- timewise and finances -- to properly train someone in the business of childcare? It is not something where obviously you're going to bring someone in at an entry-level position and say just, you know: Go do the best you can, and we're here to help you out. I mean, I know that there are programs out there, but it seems to me that that seems to be something sort of new, that the emphasis on the training of the individuals who are doing this critical work, when we know statistically zero to three is so important, right, in the development of a child.
So could you just, in a minute and 45 seconds, just give us a brief -- give me a brief understanding of what goes into this and how the state can be helpful in that area as well?
MS. CHIMENTO:Thanks, that's great.
So there's a variety of organizations throughout the state that work on the business of childcare and work on the quality of childcare: The National Association -- or New York Association for the Education of Young Children, PDI, QUALITYstars, the CCR&R network, the unions, to name a few.
There is a prescriptive career ladder that childcare providers can follow to maintain or to attain certain educational requirements. The CCR&R network, through Stabilization and Deserts, implemented a seven-part core business training series to focus on the business, the finances behind the childcare business. But it's those considerable investments in all of the agencies that I spoke about that can really bring that -- the educational piece of it, along with the business support.
Funding for wages is great, but funding for operations and infrastructure is just as critically important. You had -- someone had asked why people were leaving or what could happen with Stabilization and Deserts. Just increased awareness about what they are being held accountable for during the process will improve what -- how childcare providers are responding to these investments.
SENATOR ROLISON:So there's a corresponding system that needs to be enhanced as well, just besides just raising wages?
MS. CHIMENTO:One hundred percent.
SENATOR ROLISON:Thank you.
Absolutely. Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
We go to Assemblyman Eachus.
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:Thank you, Chair.
Krista, the first thing that I'd like you to know is -- which my colleagues know -- I was 40 years in the classroom. Okay? I was a teacher, and I absolutely know that there's a difference between the kids who know where their next meal's coming from in the learning pattern versus those who are worried about it and what they're concentrating on, 100 percent. And so as these folks know, I'm completely in on that program, the universal breakfast and lunch program.
I would like you, though, sometime, if possible, to call or come to my office to explain to me a little more about the SNAP program and how the elders qualify for it -- maybe what process they need to go through, so I can transmit that to them.
Meredith, hi. I must apologize, I had to run up to session to make sure I was checked in up there, and I missed it. But when I walked back in, I heard a term, TA. Is that what you use?
MS. CHIMENTO:Technical assistance.
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:Technical assistance, okay. All right. Because I was wondering exactly what that was, and I --
MS. CHIMENTO:Sure. As an educator, you wonder.
It's the services that childcare resource and referral agencies provide to childcare providers. And it can be anything from running a budget to social-emotional development within our mental health consultation project.
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:Okay. And Senator Rolison just asked my question, actually. I was wondering what it took to train an individual to be a childcare worker, you know, and specialist. And going from testimony before, we realize that actually, as of today, most of the people that are in childcare, they're in there because they love it and they love their children and they love what they do.
But one of the things I was thinking about -- because I heard this relative to another program which I won't go into -- is, are you making this available to college students? Maybe training and so on like that? Is -- you know, maybe that's a resource if you're not taking advantage of -- especially when we talk about the Adirondacks and all. We know we have SUNY schools up there and all that, you know, I hope there's some method by which we're advertising.
I had to work -- I won't tell you, but I had to work three or four jobs to get through college while in college. So, you know --
MS. CHIMENTO:Yeah, I mean, there absolutely is. SUNY Adirondack, all of those programs have -- or were looking to implement CDA prep programs, so that's the Child Development Associate degree. After-school programs, childcare centers definitely attract the young college students, and it's a great way for them to enter.
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:Yeah, because that was one of the questions -- just real quickly, that was one of the questions about, you know, after business hours and through the night hours. And of course most college kids are up during that period of time anyway.
(Laughter.)
MS. CHIMENTO:Why not, yeah.
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:So -- yeah. So okay. Thank you very much.
MS. CHIMENTO:You're welcome.
MS. ISAKSON:Do you mind if I take the last 15 seconds and just jump in?
So I'm a pediatrician by training, right? So when we're talking about stabilizing the market of childcare, we forget about stabilizing the care for the children.
So turnover of care providers has a real damaging effect on young kids. And so we have to kind of -- I think actually Dr. -- Senator Rolison kind of mentioned that, the impact.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:So -- thank you, Liz. The time is up.
I don't believe we have any other questions. Thank you for being here. I just wanted to remind all of my colleagues and the people who are going to be coming in the panels after, that all of the written testimony has been submitted, has been received by all of the legislators. And again, not to read your testimony so we have time for the questions.
So our next panel will be AARP New York; New York StateWide Senior Action Council; Project Guardianship; and Association on Aging in New York.
Gail, do you want to start?
MS. MYERS:I'm happy to.
Yes, thank you. Thanks. My name is Gail Myers. I'm deputy director at New York StateWide Senior Action Council.
Investments are needed now to ensure access to services that are vital to preserving the dignity of older New Yorkers and their ability to age in their community homes. Reports are coming, task forces will be producing those, but we cannot wait.
We operate two programs that are funded through the New York State Office for Aging, through your good graces. We have operated our patients rights hotline and advocacy projects since 1987. The executive proposal is $31,500 in funding. You have in the past added, which we appreciate, $200,000 -- a total funding of 231,500.
We implore you to let us keep the lights on. Please restore that program. It's a cut otherwise, and we really need to continue to offer the services.
We also operate the Managed Care Consumer Assistance Program. You heard Director Olsen talk about the increase in the income levels that you granted last year for the Medicare Savings Program. An extra 300,000 people will be eligible for cash in their pocket.
It doesn't happen just because you pass those programs. Someone needs to do the case finding, the outreach, the enrollment assistance, make sure that they're being followed up on, so that they get those benefits that you have entitled them to and that they so much need. So I'm asking you to increase the funding for those programs to help us to achieve the capacity we need.
So we are very concerned about the private-pay program that is being proposed to be expanded by reducing the income eligibility in the budget. We are particularly concerned that middle-income residents will think that the network of aging service providers are not available to them unless they pay a 20 percent surcharge or tax to receive those services. It's 120 percent of the fee. Otherwise, they -- now they get it for 100 percent.
So we ask you to look at that very carefully. We don't think that the justification to say there's not enough money to support aging services is a justification for doing these things. You make difficult decisions during the budget based on your priorities, and we ask you to make these decisions that -- just like childcare needs all your support, very, very important, we need to make sure that elder care is being supported as well.
Home care worker shortage. There's 12 hours to be said on this; I know I have like four seconds. We support Fair Pay for Home Care. We reject the Governor's cap on wages for home care workers. And we ask you to also reject the pay equity provisions in the CDPAP program.
The ombudsman program, we certainly support an increase in those services. However, there's also a Part Z in the funding in the Article VII bill that changes the way the surveillance is for assisted living, and we would ask you to make sure that the ombudsman is included in those recommendations.
Please see my written 27 pages of testimony --
(Laughter.)
MS. MYERS:-- and I'm happy to answer any of your questions.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Yes, go ahead.
MS. PREVE:Good afternoon, and thank you all for hosting this very important hearing.
I'm Becky Preve. I'm the executive director of the Association on Aging in New York, and I have the pleasure to represent the 59 Offices for the Aging that you heard Director Olsen testify about today.
I want to make you all aware, as I'm sure you are, the population of older residents in the State of New York is rapidly growing, as is the demand for our services. The COVID-19 pandemic severely impacted the older population, and the need for services has substantially increased without adequate investments to support the 4.6 million individuals over the age of 60 in the State of New York.
On behalf of the network, we were very shocked that the proposed budget does not include any significant investments for the New York State Office for the Aging. The state has proudly announced a Master Plan on Aging with executive order language stating, and I quote: Ensure older New Yorkers can live fulfilling lives in good health with freedom, dignity, and independence to age in place as long as possible.
However, the proposed budget refuses to acknowledge or address the funding needs that have been presented repeatedly. In fact, the budget continues to harm aging services providers specifically regarding home care services.
We serve individuals that are above income from the Medicaid benchmark to receive home care services, but they can't afford to privately pay for the care. We use the exact same licensed home care provider network as the Medicaid system, and we're also mandated to pass a $2 rate increase on October 1st for all the personal care aides serving the older population, with no investment from the state to absorb this cost.
This obviously has created a huge issue within this aging services infrastructure, because we also are facing a $1 mandated rate increase for October 1 of 2023. And again, the proposed Executive Budget completely ignored the fact that we're serving thousands of older New Yorkers with our home care program and did not receive these investments.
I also want to put into perspective that the individuals that we're serving in the aging services network absolutely qualify for nursing home placement. Our traditional client is an 83-year-old female who lives alone, is low-income, and has four or more chronic conditions, and needs assistance with activities of daily living such as going to the bathroom or taking a shower.
We know that our aging services infrastructure serves that individual for less than $10,000 per year, on average for six and a half years -- versus $150,000 per year in a skilled nursing facility.
We know that people waiting for the services through the aging services network on waiting lists, 10 percent of them will go directly to a nursing home, another 7 percent will spend down to MLTC. On the current waiting list right now we have in the State of New York for services, it's going to cost $70 million for those 10 percent of individuals to go to nursing homes.
Additionally, the proposed Executive Budget completely disregards the rising costs of inflation that severely impacted the largest nutrition program in the country, which is ours. We know the cost of raw food, transportation and workforce has substantially increased, along with an increase in the older population. Coupled with inflation and the loss of federal stimulus dollars, the aging services network in the State of New York is facing severe issues and very long waiting lists for services.
Again, under the context of the Master Plan on Aging, we wanted to ask the Legislature to really take into consideration the fact that we have to make sure that the basement isn't flooded before we can build the fourth floor. And we really need to look at our current infrastructure, which I outlined in my written testimony.
Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Project Guardianship.
MS. GEORGE:Hello? Hi. Thank you, Chairs Krueger and Weinstein and committee members.
My name is Kimberly George. I'm the president and CEO of Project Guardianship. We are a nonprofit organization providing person-centered, court-appointed guardianship services to hundreds of limited-capacity New Yorkers.
Our clients are living with disabilities, serious mental illness, dementia, substance misuse disorders, traumatic brain injury, and other conditions that negatively impact their ability to make decisions.
We serve clients regardless of their ability to pay and provide services for some of the most compelling and complex cases in New York. We also share research and policy recommendations for a better guardianship system and advocate for more equitable service provision for people in need of decision-making supports.
For New Yorkers with limited capacity, the New York Mental Hygiene Law provides for the appointment of a guardian to help manage personal and/or property needs. Guardianship is a critical link between supportive services for New Yorkers whose functional limitations have prevented them from accessing those services. And while New York is fortunate to have strong legal protections that entitle individuals access to guardianship services, this mandate is underfunded, and there's currently no direct funding stream to ensure statutory compliance.
If a family member cannot serve as guardian, nonprofits, county social services districts, and private attorneys must step in to provide services in a patchwork manner. But the demand for assistance greatly outpaces capacity. In some regions there's no access to these resources, especially for low-income individuals with family, without family, and unable to pay for a private attorney.
At the same time, our state's older population is growing, becoming more diverse, and increasingly living in poverty. You know the stats, and they're in my written testimony so I won't go through them now. But because of them, guardianship petitions are on the rise.
Guardianship itself encompasses many services, including legal services, financial management, healthcare coordination, and other vital tasks to promote the overall health, safety, and stability of the individual.
An effective guardian works to prevent institutionalization and supports these populations in their own communities. Not only do these efforts support the local economy by redirecting funds back into the community, but guardianship also saves public dollars by decreasing Medicaid spending on avoidable hospitalizations and institutionalizations.
Guardianship services are also critical in achieving the goals of the Master Plan for Aging. With data that clearly reflects the imminent need of growing guardianship, it is crucial that community-based guardianship programs be robustly funded to ensure that New Yorkers are able to access the services that they need.
We, along with a coalition of guardianship providers and advocates called Guardianship Access New York, are asking for a $15 million investment to provide nonprofit community guardianship services to 1,500 people annually across the state. This funding would help us provide technical assistance, quality assurance, data collection, and a statewide guardianship prevention and support helpline.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
AARP?
MS. FINKEL:Can you hear me? Sorry.
Good evening. Thank you so much, Senator Krueger and Assemblymember Weinstein. So much of the data -- and all of you for hanging out with us. I really appreciate it.
I know a lot of data has been given. I appreciate -- many of you have quoted AARP's data, and I'm very appreciative of that. As you heard, 65-plus is the fastest growing, and it grew by 31 percent in the last decade. We just commissioned a report, which we will share with all of you -- there are now more people 65-plus in New York State than 15 and under. Which is kind of a sad thing in some ways, and a good thing in other ways.
But we're here today because we really need to talk about how the budget is going to address this demographic shift. We talked about caregivers; my colleagues have talked about home- and community-based services. We really feel like we need a stable home care system so people can age in place so we can get those savings that were just documented before.
We also want to make sure that we have fair pay, that we make sure that the money that was allocated in the budget that you did last year actually ends up going to the home care workers, because we know it's getting caught up with the insurance companies and it's not getting through. And that's just, I think, appalling to everybody.
We also want to make sure that we relieve the pressure of the home care family members, like all of us -- there's two and a half million of them in New York who are feeling this pressure.
We know that -- Becky talked about the 10,000 waiting list. But we also know that we don't actually have a true reading on that number because there's no transparency. SOFA is supposed to report those numbers every two years, and they haven't. We need to do that so that all of you can decide how the budget should be spent and where, so we can really document where people are waiting for services and what they need.
We need to make sure that we're cost-effective and compassionate about all this home care. We also -- I want to just hit the LTCOP really quickly. We're asking for 15 million in LTCOP. Again, we know that people have not been going in to visit -- it's supposed to be one every week, and we know that only 9 percent of the facilities in New York State are getting that one visit a week, which is unconscionable.
Finally, we want to talk about data matching. I know that came up earlier. There is over $4.4 billion of federal funds that are not coming into New York State as an economic stimulus because of SNAP, Medicare Savings Program, and HEAP benefits -- that are federal dollars, for the most part -- and they're not reaching seniors. If they did, there would be as, I said, the 300,000 Medicare Savings Program beneficiaries -- who would, by the way, get on the average $7,000 back every year in their Social Security checks. And just the economic stimulus from that alone is over $2 billion.
So I know you're all going to help us in this fight, so I thank you all.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
We go to Assemblyman Kim.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:Thank you. It's good to see everyone. Thank you for your patience today. And a couple of quick questions.
Rebecca, the -- I just wanted to simplify the numbers for a minute. So if we put in a dollar toward SOFA programs, we can save, in my calculation, up to $8 in the back end on Medicaid savings. Does that sound about accurate?
MS. PREVE:It does, yes.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:Okay. And I just -- I mean, the number is so stunning to me, that -- and there are between 7 to 10 percent of people on the waiting list that if we don't serve today, they will spend down to poverty level so that they can qualify for Medicaid. So we are systemically fueling older adults into poverty by not fixing this, correct?
MS. PREVE:I 100 percent agree. And I would say -- and I know I've had this conversation with you numerous times -- we look at prevention in every other system's infrastructure. Right? We want to make sure that pregnant moms know about the WIC program so they can prevent health disparities moving forward.
We're doing nothing to prevent impoverishing people down to Medicaid. And I can tell you from direct practices -- I used to be a director that did home visits -- if I knew I had 200 people on my waiting list but I had an 85-year-old who really needed home care, I would get them a full trust that week and get them on Medicaid coverage because they needed the care, and that's exactly a backwards system.
And if the state is very concerned about savings overall, we know the efficacy of our programs. Why are we not investing on the front end to make sure we're keeping people in homes and communities, as the master plan outlines, and keeping them off of the Medicaid system so that Medicaid can serve the purpose that it's been intended to do, to support low-income older individuals.
ASSEMBLYMAN KIM:Right. And as far as the EISEP non-Medicaid home care services and the problems with reimbursement of wages, it's further exacerbating the problem because if you don't take care of the reimbursements, people will again try to go to Medicaid health care and not wait for SOFA's EISEP program.
So it's urgent, it's incumbent upon us to make sure that we put in funding for the non-Medicaid to make sure that the entire home care universe of older adults are properly serviced.
Gail, you mentioned the ZZ surveillance around LT -- can you just expand on that? I want to give you 30 seconds just to expand on that.
MS. MYERS:Yeah. There is a provision within the Governor's budget that she says is about improving quality, and it changes -- it lays out a system for allowing industry to self-regulate and to say that they have met quality measures, which would allow the Department of Health to extend the frequency of surveillance inspections.
And there's no -- while you need to examine that on its own, if you agree to do that, we really would like you to see the ombudsmen play a role in establishing quality.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
To the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Senator Cordell Cleare.
SENATOR CLEARE:I want to thank you all for coming today and hanging around this long.
So I just have a couple of questions maybe AARP can answer. You know, I know you're strong supporters of Fair Pay for Home Care, as I am. And if you could tell me what that looks like for your members. And also, you know, have you seen the crisis getting worse or getting easier? And also I'll just -- let me give you -- no, I'm going to stop right there.
MS. FINKEL:Absolutely. I hear it from everywhere I go. It's probably the number-one call that I get. When I'm out with my own friends and relatives, it's the number-one thing that I hear.
So yes, there is a dearth of home care workers. And it's mostly because they are not getting a decent wage and they can't support their own family. We're not being respectful of the worker, and we're certainly not being respectful of the person who needs the care, is desperate for the care.
MS. MYERS:And if I can, from our patients' rights helpline, the two biggest concerns that we have are on the lack of home care workers, both the people who need to stay at home and for people who want to exit the nursing home and then go back home, and they can't get discharged because they don't have a safe environment.
The second thing, of course, is the quality of care in nursing homes, which increasingly the ombudsman program certainly will help to address.
SENATOR CLEARE:The Association for the Aging, if you could just tell me more about the rates for home care workers. We're hearing that some counties are not increasing the funding to agencies to meet the mandated wage. Can you speak to that?
MS. PREVE:What I can tell you -- and I think the commissioner spoke to this earlier -- most of our counties are actually paying well above Medicaid rates. And that's why I really talk about an un-level playing field.
So because our authorizations are traditionally lower than the Medicaid system, we're not as attractive to a licensed home care provider because you're not getting a block of hours at one individual's home.
So again, I surveyed the members last month; we're paying anywhere between 35 and $40 an hour for personal care services. We were mandated for the $2 rate increase above the minimum wage benchmark. On October 1st we got no revenue in the State Budget to absorb that. We have no revenue forecasted for the additional $1.
Again, it's an unfunded mandate on the non-Medicaid system for a solution that didn't solve the problem. Because now as you index minimum wage, you're going to see the same thing -- home care becomes a minimum-wage job once again, in competition with retail, fast food, et cetera.
So it's really done nothing to alleviate the long-term problem, which is why we support Fair Pay for Home Care.
SENATOR CLEARE:Thank you.
And to StateWide Senior Action Council -- and you can send this answer to me -- I just need -- I want a breakdown of the private pay and why it's not a good thing. Why is that something that -- because it was confusing to me when I heard it, and I heard it again and it's still confusing. And I'd like to get some more clarity, because I think I'm right.
(Laughter.)
MS. MYERS:I think you're right too. Let's talk.
Just very quickly, just if you look at the EISEP services, EISEP is a sliding scale up to 250 percent of the federal poverty level. At 250 and above, it's 100 percent pay. This proposal would say it's 120 percent pay if the county opted into providing it in this particular way.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Assemblywoman Clark.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CLARK:Thank you.
It's been a long day, so I'm going to do some rapid-fire questions so that --
Can we ever get to once-a-week visits across all our long-term care facilities without the trustful eye of our volunteers?
MS. FINKEL:Absolutely not.
And that's why we need the $15 million in the budget for the long term care ombudsman. We can't have what happened in COVID again. We have to have transparency. We have to have advocates looking out for --
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CLARK:Thank you. You answered my second question, so I'll move to my third question for you.
We get the visits, we understand that. Are we getting clear access to the reports and data on the visits from SOFA, what the visits entail, and if the complaints are resolved?
MS. FINKEL:I'm going to have to get back to you on that one, but the complaints do go to DOH.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CLARK:Are you getting, are we as a state getting good access to the data on those visits, on those complaints?
MS. FINKEL:I will get back to you.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CLARK:Okay. I think I know the answer, but we will keep working on that.
I have some questions on elder abuse. So first and foremost, are we seeing more or less cases of elder abuse right now?
MS. PREVE:We have seen an explosion in elder abuse -- most predominantly, financial exploitation and scams. I think all of you have heard in your district offices of very, very well-rehearsed, very tangible scams that are targeting older individuals.
And again, I'm glad you raised this, Assemblymember Clark. When you look at the Executive's proposed budget, there was a $375,000 cut to Lifespan of Greater Rochester, who host the Statewide Elder Abuse Coalition. And again, when you look at a million dollars being invested into a planning committee for the Master Plan on Aging, and yet you're going to cut the service organization that protects the one in 24 older New Yorkers that actually report that they were exploited, it's kind of hard to wrap your mind around that.
So, you know, again in my testimony we fully support full implementation of restoring that funding for Lifespan.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CLARK:And these complaints are getting more or less confusing and complicated -- more?
MS. PREVE:Absolutely.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CLARK:Last but not least, on the prevention piece of this, if we were to reach more seniors' basic needs, if we were able to take care of them, if we were able to hand-hold them through some of the complex issues, would we or would we not save money in the long run on healthcare?
MS. PREVE:We would save an extraordinary amount of money.
And when I -- every year I come in and talk at these budget hearings, we're talking about the high need, right, that 85-year-old who needs home care? That doesn't take into account the thousands of other older New Yorkers that we serve through wellness programs and prevention through volunteer activities.
So, you know, again, I would love to be able to talk about the fact that our transportation program gets older individuals to medical appointments, which we know then reduces emergency department visits. We know that 80 percent of home-delivered meal participants self-report that the reason they're able to stay in homes and communities is because of a meal that costs $7 a day.
So again, we desperately need the investment.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN CLARK:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
To the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Senator Tom O'Mara.
SENATOR O'MARA:Thank you, Chairwoman.
Good evening. Thank you for your testimony here today.
I've just got one question, with regards to the change in the -- I guess the number of ADLs needed for home care. Have any of you received any justification for this change and why they're going about it? Because it seems to me it's going to -- it's going to cost a lot more money.
MS. MYERS:Well, we've seen the Medicaid Redesign Team put this forward as a cost saving for the state. There were not consumers on that panel to be able to say, Here's what happens if you reduce our benefits.
In other words, if -- you're saying the only time you can get home care under Medicaid, under that provision -- which may soon go into effect -- would be if you were otherwise eligible to be in a nursing home. And it just flies in the face of good prevention to be able to say some housekeeping, some assistance with bathing, some food services in the home may be able to keep a large number of people off of Medicaid. And also, it keeps them active in their houses of worship and their social programs locally. And that ending isolation is incredibly important in terms of the prevention piece as well.
MS. PREVE:And I would just add, Senator, that the changes on the Medicaid side will actually create more customers on the aging side, because we did not change our triggers for home care services. So we still provide Personal Care Level 1, which is housekeeping, grocery shopping, bill paying. And when that's carved out of the Medicaid benefit because of the ADL requirements, we're going to get customers that come to our service infrastructure.
Additionally, when Medicaid home care puts into effect the 30-month lookback period, people that traditionally would have been able to access Medicaid for home care services will no longer be eligible. And guess where they're going to come? They're going to come to Office for the Aging for the care. So ...
SENATOR O'MARA:Thank you. Thank you very much. Very concerning.
MS. MYERS:One of the things that -- just if I may, one of the things that you did last year, which was great, was you expanded the income eligibility for Medicaid.
So some of the most needy people within the Office for Aging services will now become Medicaid-eligible under that expansion. That's a good thing for them getting comprehensive benefits. It's also a good thing to allow more dollars to go to people above the Medicaid level.
But if the ADL piece goes through and they are newly eligible for Medicaid, they're not going to get the services that they had the day before under the EISEP program.
SENATOR O'MARA:Thank you all.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:We go to Assemblywoman Rajkumar.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN RAJKUMAR:Thank you.
My question is about the waiting lists. So there have been calls for an increase in the provision of public information, specifically regarding waiting lists. And according to you, the Association on Aging in New York, over 10,000 seniors in our state who are not Medicaid recipients are waiting for essential services such as adult day care, meal delivery, and transportation.
I understand that there's a call for clear information on how many seniors are waiting and what services they are waiting for, as well as requesting a change to reporting on a county-wide level versus a statewide aggregate.
So can you tell this legislative panel what you're seeing on the ground with regards to waiting lists and how it's affecting families?
MS. PREVE:So I can tell you that we have roughly about 10,000 people that are waiting for services. It's nuanced, because you might have someone waiting for a meal and personal care services, so you could have duplicate services within that catchment.
But I can tell you, just for case management, these would be unique customers. We have 7,713 that are waiting for services today. And what that means is those individuals are seeking alternate ways to get care, whether that be spend down to Medicaid -- unfortunately, many times, by the time someone gets to our service network, if they're told you might have a six-month waiting period, the family automatically looks towards assisted living or skilled nursing facility placement out of necessity.
And it also means that specifically regarding home care services, because the home care workforce is in such crisis -- I can tell you I surveyed all of the AAAs: 100 percent of them reported waiting lists for personal care services due to the lack of direct care professionals.
So this is something, you know, we've talked about at a state perspective. It's also a federal issue; you're seeing a national shortage as well. But we're never going to be able to serve individuals if we don't have funding to do so, but also if we don't have an infrastructure to serve them.
And that's why Fair Pay for Home Care to actually raise these wages to a livable wage, and getting 50 percent of home care workers off public service benefits, is so important for the state, because it's going to save us money long-term.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN RAJKUMAR:Thank you.
And also I'd like to ask you about data matching again, which has already come up. Last month Governor Hochul announced a new data matching policy to help connect recipients of one benefit to other benefits to which they are entitled. And the plan identified families receiving benefits who are eligible for childcare assistance.
So do you support basically a similar data matching program for seniors --
MS. PREVE:Yes.
MS. FINKEL:Yes.
MS. MYERS:Absolutely.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN RAJKUMAR:-- to connect them to SNAP, HEAP, and the Medicare Savings Program? I assume you do. But can you speak to how that expansion of data matching would help?
MS. FINKEL:Well, we know there are 300,000 New Yorkers 65-plus who are now newly eligible for MSP. We also know that there are 200,000 older New Yorkers that are now eligible for SNAP that are not getting it. And we know that there are a lot of people that are struggling out there to pay their utility bill.
So when you put all of that together, yes, we know that it would help. Why you would just single out family and children and leave out older adults is something that we really can't understand.
And you saw, when we asked -- when someone here asked the OTDA commissioner, he said that it's going to be three and a half years. Well, I've been hearing it's going to be five years for the last 20 years.
ASSEMBLYWOMAN RAJKUMAR:Okay.
MS. FINKEL:So honestly, I don't understand it. We're making people struggle personally when they don't have to. They could have upwards of seven or eight or nine thousand dollars back in their pocket every year. And --
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
MS. FINKEL:Sorry.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
MS. FINKEL:This is an issue I'm very passionate about.
(Laughter.)
ASSEMBLYWOMAN RAJKUMAR:Thank you for that information.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you, Beth.
So we move on to the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Senator Murray.
SENATOR MURRAY:Thank you, Chair.
Thank you all for being here in this kind of late hour.
I want to touch on something -- I hear the frustration in your voice, we hear it all the time as far as home care workers and pay. But I want to take it from a different angle.
Can you tell me, first, how long does it take to properly train a home care worker and how much investment does it take to do that?
MS. PREVE:So you have to become certified through a licensed home care agency. And I can follow up -- I believe the requirement is a six-week-long in-person training for the personal care worker.
And we've really seen a variety. So there's many licensed home care providers throughout the state. Predominantly, they're not-for-profits that absorb the cost of the training because they have to.
Specifically in upstate, those licensed home care agencies are also trying to reimburse travel time, which they don't get reimbursement for on the Medicaid side. And specifically in my district, you could drive 50 miles in between cases.
So the licensed home care providers are absorbing those costs to get individuals trained, but then what you run into is extensive competition with healthcare. Right? Because the CNA at a nursing home can make much more than a community home care worker can.
So it's -- and then with recruitment and retention bonuses, you also run a risk of then having an aide that's trained who then has to jump agency to agency to get that benefit.
So again, you know, the CUNY research report that came out two years ago clearly outlined that a significant state investment of about 4 billion would reach $7 billion in return by raising those wages to 150 percent of poverty.
SENATOR MURRAY:And there's also the problem of the quality of care, because I've heard from seniors who they'll get a home care worker, they feel very comfortable with them, they trust them -- and before you know it, they're gone. And now they have to get to know someone else, maybe they're not as comfortable. You start shifting who you're sending, causing all sorts of problems.
So as much as recruiting is a problem, would you say retention is also as high or higher?
MS. PREVE:Retention is a huge issue. And again, competition with other markets.
And again, we believe everyone should get a living wage. But I find it disheartening that my 16-year-old son works at a local farm and he makes more than a home health aide does for an hour of care where they're giving someone a bath.
And, you know, I think to talk about the home care workforce, these people are so dedicated, they are so in love with the position that they work two or three jobs to support their families because they believe in the cause.
But again, you raise a great point. These are personal relationships. Home care workers are social workers, they're nurses, they're physicians, they're therapists, and they need to be paid in a way that we can retain them and have them part of a long-term-care team.
SENATOR MURRAY:And I'm wondering if something like -- I mean, we have IDAs and we have Economic Development Councils for businesses. Is there something we can do for the workers similar to what we do for EMS and all, where we give maybe retirement credits or something, but somehow thinking outside of the box to offer some sort of a longevity bonus or something to that effect? Would that be helpful?
MS. PREVE:I completely agree. And I think that the model that Director Olsen referenced this morning in the 12 counties that are directly employing aides, we've seen 100 percent retention of those home health aides.
In Putnam County specifically, they had over 80 people on a waiting list. Their waiting list has been cleared for two years, and they have the same aides.
SENATOR MURRAY:Wow. That's great.
Thank you very much.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:We have no other questioners.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:We have one final questioner, Roxanne Persaud.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Good evening, everyone.
I just wanted to ask a question to follow up on something Director Olsen said. When asked if -- because we were saying many agencies and aging reports were saying there are wait lists for home delivery meals, et cetera. And he said that he was not hearing that.
But you just said the opposite of what he said. Could you clarify that for me, please?
MS. PREVE:I can tell you we have 362 people waiting in the State of New York for a home-delivered meal.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Thank you.
MS. PREVE:You're welcome.
MS. MYERS:You know, and in part they're waiting for an assessment, they're waiting for case management to be able to say they've done a home visit, they see that this person is homebound, that they need these services in order for that spigot to start.
So you were talking about somebody who was getting emergency home-delivered meals and then it runs out and then they try to get it again and it runs out?
SENATOR PERSAUD:No, it's just a person waiting for home delivery.
MS. MYERS:Right. Waiting and waiting.
SENATOR PERSAUD:The whole process, yes.
MS. MYERS:So part of it that connects together with all of the workers that are needed in the aging network are also to make sure that there are enough case managers to do that assessment so that people are getting the services that they have earned after so long living in our community.
SENATOR PERSAUD:What's the average time for the 300-plus people who have been waiting?
MS. PREVE:It really varies based on your geographic area and population density. So we can absolutely talk offline if you want further information specifically about your constituents.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Absolutely.
MS. PREVE:But traditionally, especially post-discharge from an acute care facility, we try to start meals within seven days. There are some areas of the state where that's not possible, based on geography and also waiting lists. But it's definitely more prevalent in the New York City region than it is in other parts of the state.
But again, when you talk about the raw cost of food, everybody feels this at the grocery store right now. We're feeding, you know, hundreds of thousands of older New Yorkers, and the food cost has gone up with no revenue to offset it. Gasoline for meal delivery -- again, a huge expense that we haven't been reimbursed for.
So I think you're going to see that waiting list grow if we don't do something to address those ongoing issues.
SENATOR PERSAUD:Ongoing.
Thank you very much. We'll talk.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you to all the members of this panel.
And we're going to now ask Panel C to come: New York State Network for Youth Success; New York State YouthBuild Coalition; Northern Rivers Family of Services; Prevent Child Abuse New York; Council of Family and Child Caring Agencies; and Children's Health Home of Upstate New York.
And so that we don't mess up -- so we get your name correctly on the broadcast, if we can go in that order, starting with New York State Network for Youth Success.
MS. MORGAN:Hello. Thank you for allowing me to testify today.
My name's Trudy Morgan, and I'm the policy director at the New York State Network for Youth Success. Our goal as a statewide network is to build an effective and integrated statewide system of high-quality, expanded learning programs in New York.
Decades of research shows that after-school and summer expanded learning programs play a critical role in improving student outcomes. Research spanning several states shows that every dollar invested in our school programs saves at least $3.
In New York, an overwhelming majority of caregivers are satisfied with their child's after-school and summer school experience. It is no surprise that the impact of after-school spans across critical issue areas. For many students and families, after-school goes beyond after-school hours.
After-school provides a safe haven for some, a support system for others, academic empowerment for leadership development or career exploration or youth development. After-school is integral to students' education. These programs complement what students learn in school by providing more time for deeper learning, creative spaces for hands-on projects, and opportunities to explore careers.
After-school is also integral to New York's childcare system. After-school services, through high-quality school-age childcare programs, promote stability in families who rely on them to balance work and life. That is why any improvements to the childcare system must include support for school-age childcare and children.
After-school is integral to youth development. In after-school, children and youth are surrounded by caring adults and mentors that help create a safe space for participants to express themselves, along with a sense of belonging and discovering their passions while fostering an environment that supports healthy development.
Over the last few years New York's after-school programs have experienced many crises, and that's why we have presented a roadmap in this year's budget to reimagine the system. And among our priorities we ask for your support to reorganize after-school through a $219 million investment.
And this is a critical year to align the Empire State After-School Program and Advantage After School Program, as both programs follow very similar objectives and benchmarks. Streamlining these programs will mitigate the many barriers providers face when accessing after-school funding.
And as we take this critical step, we must do more and do things differently to ensure that our programs are better resourced, by adopting a higher per-student rate of $4,300 and engaging the expertise and experience of after-school stakeholders to develop and access program success, and guaranteeing the current base funding for these programs, including the restoration of Advantage by $5 million.
We also ask that you dedicate 500,000 through the CCDBG grants to support technical assistance for after-school providers that we provide support for as the statewide after-school network. Currently the state does not provide any dedicated funding to support TA for after-school, and this funding can help sustain these programs while helping us to partially pay the statewide landscape analysis for after-school, summer, and expanded learning programs, which is currently lacking and much needed.
After-school, summer and expanded learning programs help keep students safe, support working families, and empower youth success. We count on your support to continue these programs.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
New York State YouthBuild Coalition.
MS. LANDI:Thank you, Senator Krueger, Assemblywoman Weinstein, for the opportunity to provide information on the value of YouthBuild programs in New York State.
First, on behalf of the thousands of vulnerable youth we serve, thank you for the '22-'23 budget support we received in the amount of $10 million in ESD Pay for Performance Workforce strategies funding and 2.5 million appropriated for the Legislature to fund YouthBuild program wraparound services, such as addressing mental health and substance use issues, addressing community gun violence, housing insecurity, food insecurity, job coaching, resume writing, self-care, proper hygiene, how to dress appropriately, how to speak appropriately, and leadership development -- all of which have been determined as integral to the outstanding outcomes YouthBuild programs achieve.
We are requesting the same level of budget funding that we received in the '23-'24 budget.
Recently, YouthBuild participated in an OCFS Workforce Development Demonstration Project. The outcomes from that project clearly indicate the effectiveness of the comprehensive training provided. Those outcomes were:
Programs exceeded the number of required enrollments by 6 percent, serving more than what was expected;
Placement rate in a job or a post-secondary education program after completion, 100 percent;
HSE and industry-recognized credentials earned, 99 percent;
Youth with prior justice system involvement, no rearrests -- zero recidivism. We're very proud of that.
As a point of information, YouthBuild began right here in New York State, in 1978 in East Harlem. In 1992 it was replicated by the federal government and expanded across the nation into 44 states. Today there are over 225 YouthBuild programs nationwide.
Currently in New York State there are 17 programs, located from Long Island to Buffalo. Additionally, we have requests from Hudson, Monticello, Syracuse, and Yonkers, who are seeking to start a YouthBuild program.
As you are aware, the aftermath of COVID has exacerbated the inequities facing young people of color. One of the most troubling issues facing these young people is community gun violence. YouthBuild programs across the state have already begun to take the necessary steps to address the issue and its adverse effects on our young people.
The highly successful YouthBuild program model. Our efficacy rates indicate YouthBuild has the ability to address the very issues leaders and U.S. state policymakers are grappling with for young people. However, program resources are limited. We need the willingness of the state to continue to invest in our efforts.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
MS. LANDI:We must stop reinventing the wheel and keep these youth working --
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
MS. LANDI:-- toward what they need for success.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Next, Northern Rivers Family of Services.
MR. GETTMAN:Good evening, members of the Legislature and chairs.
My name is Bill Gettman. I'm the CEO of Northern Rivers Family of Services. I'm here representing the 18,000 children, adults, and families that we serve in 40 counties across New York State.
I'm also here today to talk on behalf of the 1400 employees who work for Northern Rivers -- seven days a week, 24 hours a day -- 25 percent who have a second job, 10 percent who have to have a third job to make ends meet.
I'm here today to talk about while we appreciate the Governor's investment after a decade of poor investments in the areas of mental health and childcare and other areas, we need to go a step further.
First, we need to go ahead with the 8.5 percent COLA that has been advocated by many associations around New York State. Our workers need to hear from the Legislature and the executive branch that they are respected, they are cared for, and the work they do is important to the future of this state.
Our staff take care of families and kids when no one else will do it. Just Friday night, we admitted an 11-year-old who was in the hospital who had no place to go. They ended up at our doorstep, and we admitted them. We will place them in a foster home, and we will get them back to a permanent and safe situation someday.
But you don't do that if 25 percent of your staff have to work a second job, if you have a turnover rate of 30 percent. And I have 105 vacancies today. I have over 1,000 on my waitlist for mental health services and community-based services. We need a trained and experienced workforce to meet those community needs.
Mental health and child welfare are a single item. The Governor's proposal for mental health we applaud. However, in child welfare we provide mental health every single day. And as part of that, we need to correct some of the deficiencies in the Governor's budget related to rate-setting and the underfunding of the childcare agency budgets.
Our rates will end on April 1st this year unless the Legislature takes decisive actions. I don't know how many businesspeople can provide services without knowing what they're going to get paid. However, we have thousands of kids in our care, and we need to improve the rate-setting.
We also need to look at prevention. And so I call to your attention the bills in the Legislature to increase primary prevention to 75 percent, and also to the Poverty Agenda that the Governor's task force has worked on. We need to make long-term investments so that we can change the curve and create a better place for kids in this state.
Kids are our future. They will take care of all of us. They will take care of our grandchildren. They are the people that are going to care for us, and we need to invest in them now if we want to make New York a great place to live, work, and raise a family.
So thank you for your time. I applaud you for what will be some tough decisions in the next few weeks, but thank you for your dedication and your service, because you also are heroes.
Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Next is Prevent Child Abuse New York, Timothy Hathaway.
MR. HATHAWAY:Good afternoon.
My name is Tim Hathaway. I'm the executive director with Prevent Child Abuse New York. Thank you to the members of this committee for your dedication this afternoon and throughout this legislative session.
Prevent Child Abuse is a training and technical assistance organization serving folks across the State of New York, as well as providing policy and advocacy work. Primarily, we're looking at how do we build strong families in the state. And that work is critical to avoid the downstream impacts that we all know are extremely cost-prohibitive.
So our testimony outlines a number of different priorities. They're bulleted on the first page of my testimony, and I want to just take a couple of minutes and dive into some specifics on a couple.
The first one is around the Child and Family Well-Being Fund. We know that the best solutions to prevent child abuse come at a neighborhood level. The research tells us that. When families are strong, when neighborhoods are strong, kids do better. This fund is aimed at directly that.
How do we get more money directly down to the faith-based communities, the organizations that are operating on a shoestring budget? How do we make sure that they receive a part of the funding that really helps get them to the next level so that they can do what they do best, help families in their neighborhood do this work?
We also want to talk about maternal, infant, and early childhood home visiting. We applaud the state's investment in Healthy Families New York. We do have a concern, and we want to urge restoration of the $200,000 line item for ParentChild+. This is something that was in the budget, has been taken out.
We also want to encourage the restoration of $200,000 for Help Me Grow. You've heard from those folks earlier today.
We also are pushing forward this large investment around universal home visiting. We know this model works, we've seen it work in other states. It's an investment in the future of New York and in our children and families.
Childcare, we continue to support -- and love the testimony from our earlier folks -- after-school programs. We know this is critical to what we do in terms of prevention and building strong families. The work that Mr. Gettman already outlined around 75/25 is very important; we urge that.
And then relative to housing, the right for counsel bill that will be coming before you folks. Again, strong families need safe housing. They need good housing.
And I'll close with that.
(Laughter.)
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you. Appreciate it.
Next up is the Council of Family and Child Caring Agencies, Kathleen Brady-Stepien.
MS. BRADY-STEPIEN:Hello. My name is Kathleen Brady-Stepien. I'm the CEO of COFCCA. We represent the state's child welfare nonprofit organizations.
This past year the state took action to diminish funding for foster-care programs and services. It was an unacceptable action that has left our foster-care programs in free fall, unable to plan ahead for their budgets. And still right now, today, these programs do not know what rate they're going to receive from the state as of April 1st to provide care and services for young people in foster care.
We are asking for the Legislature's support in ensuring that these programs are fully funded through the end of their current fiscal year, which goes to June 30th, so that they don't receive a midyear rate reduction, and also that we invest meaningfully in salaries to support the very hardworking foster-care staff, of which we have a 49 percent turnover rate across the state. This is a Darling/Brisport proposal that we strongly support.
Human services programs have had to contend with incredibly rising costs, and so we have to not only get to an 8.5 percent COLA to support these programs, but we also have to make sure that those programs that have been left out of this human services COLA in the past are included going forward. And for us, in our world, that's prevention services programs, it's also health home care management supporting children. Let's make sure that they're included going forward also.
And not only do we need the COLA for prevention services programs, but we want to make sure that we invest meaningfully in doing more prevention across the State of New York so that families are kept safely together and are supported in the challenges that they're experiencing. We strongly support the proposal, as my colleagues have said, to raise this up to 75 percent support for counties around the state to do more prevention services.
Finally, we have to make sure that we are working together towards policy solutions for really critical challenges ahead of these nonprofit organizations. We strongly support Assemblymember Lunsford's efforts to establish a fund for the Child Victims Act, to ensure that there is justice for victims who are bringing their claims forward.
We also note with concern the inclusion of funding in the Governor's budget for the state's forward direction on submitting a Medicaid waiver. This is relating to residential foster care. And we don't think that this is the best long-term solution for making sure that there is appropriate in-state capacity for those young people who are assessed to need this level of care.
We continue to recommend the provision of state-only Medicaid until such time that there is a federal solution to ensure that children and youth in residential foster care can receive federal funding for their healthcare and their behavioral healthcare.
Thank you for the opportunity to testify.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you very much.
Okay, and our last testifier on this panel, the Children's Health Home of Upstate New York, Nicole Bryl.
MS. BRYL:Good evening.
My name is Nicole Bryl, and I'm the CEO of the Children's Health Home of Upstate New York, also referred to as CHHUNY.
I would like to thank Chairs Krueger and Weinstein and all members of the Legislature for allowing me to provide testimony today.
CHHUNY is the largest upstate health home designated to serve children and youth under the age of 21. We serve over 13,500 members each month and almost 18,000 unique members annually. CHHUNY provides health home care management services in 55 counties and upstate New York through a network of over 90 care management agencies. Our population consists of seriously emotionally disturbed children, medically fragile children, children with multiple chronic conditions, developmentally disabled children, and children who have experienced complex trauma.
I want to start by commending Governor Hochul for the significant investments in mental health services as proposed in her Executive Budget. With over 75 percent of the children and young people we serve experiencing at least one mental health condition, we applaud her acknowledgment of the dire need to support this sector.
Today I'm here on behalf of the 1,000-plus individuals that make up our children's health home care management workforce and the children and families we serve. I am here to ask for your support in ensuring that our Children's Health Home Program is specifically identified as an eligible program for the proposed human services COLA, and that the COLA be consistent with the Consumer Price Index, which would equate to 8.5 percent instead of 2.5 percent.
Over the last six years, care management services for children have been consolidated under the health home model to streamline and simplify the children's system of care. OMH Targeted Case Management transitioned in 2016, and then six waiver programs previously under OMH, OCFS, and OPWDD state agencies transitioned in 2019.
With these transitions came immense responsibility and new requirements to understand all systems of care for children, truly breaking down silos by consolidating pathways to care and ensuring no wrong door for struggling youth and families.
Unfortunately, over the past six years the state has failed to support our program through these transitions and added responsibility. Since the inception of this program, our rates have increased by only 1 percent. Children's health homes were excluded from the 5.4 percent COLA last year, and without your support to explicitly identify our program as eligible in this year's budget, we again will be excluded from a COLA, while our colleagues who serve health home members in OPWDD or the adult Health Home Plus world are benefiting from the COLA the past two years. So due to the bifurcation of this program, and under our DOH oversight, Children's Health Home is consistently left out of funding opportunities.
Children's Health Home services are not adult health home services. Our systems are multifaceted, and our care managers are expected to know how to navigate state plan services -- OMH, OCFS, OPWDD, OTDA, State Ed, Early Intervention, managed care waiver, and so much more.
And although the lift is a lot for one person, our care managers are doing it successfully. We are seeing positive outcomes such as increased annual primary-care visits and annual dental visits, increased compliance with metabolic monitoring when a child is on two or more antipsychotic medications, and improving the completion of post-hospitalization outpatient appointments.
Thanks.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
So we go to Assemblyman Maher, for three minutes.
ASSEMBLYMAN MAHER:Sorry about that. I actually did not have any particular questions at this time.
I do plan to reach out to all of you, and just thank you so much for all that you do. Such amazing information you give us, also -- thank you.
MS. BRYL:Thank you.
MR. GETTMAN:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Senate?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Jabari Brisport.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Thank you, Madam Chair.
And thank you, panelists. I really appreciated your testimonies.
I just had a question about public safety. You know, a lot of times in Albany when we discuss public safety the conversation gets framed around policing, prisons, the criminal legal system. But many of the programs that you offer and advocate for seem like they could serve a much more expansive vision of what keeps us safe. So I'm just curious, how could these investments that you're talking about help make our communities more safe?
And this is for everyone. I'm certainly interested in the YouthBuild answer, Northern Rivers, CHHUNY, but it's open to everybody.
MR. GETTMAN:So let me start. We have partnered with the City of Albany and the County of Albany to look at how we can use our prevention staff and our community-based staff to reduce the occurrence or reoccurrence of the violence in the community.
And it goes back to what Tim was talking about: It's about prevention. It's about housing. It's about having the care manager in partnership with the family to create means of a plan for alternatives to perhaps stress, inappropriate reactions to conflict.
But it's about investing in our workforce, who is out there every day. So it's the prevention workforce, it's our health home workforce, it's our YouthBuild partners, who do great, great work keeping kids meaningfully employed and then getting them jobs in the future.
MS. LANDI:I would like to address the gun violence issue as well.
When gun violence became prevalent amongst YouthBuild programs, we did not wait to have somebody come in and tell us what we needed to do. We took the bull by the horns, and we went in and we tried to address those issues by providing the preventative care that the young people need.
It comes out of their neighborhoods. They come into the program every single day talking about being afraid to walk to the program. So we have staff that will go pick them up to make sure they get there.
We are regularly meeting and bringing in workshop leaders to help us with prevention. We work closely with the police department and the sheriff's department.
The young people in a YouthBuild program know they're safe there. They aren't safe anywhere else when they leave. So we try to do whatever we can to help them understand what they need to do to be able to cope with the things that are providing them the problems and the issues that they face every single day.
MS. MORGAN:I'll share that for after-school, one of the main benefits for after-school is that it keeps young people safe.
Our research actually shows that the hours between 3 to 6 are the times where young people are most likely to engage in juvenile crime or be victimized by crime. And so we recognize that the after-school hours are a critical part of students' development and also their safety as well.
And I'll also share that in addition to this, after-school provides protective factors such as self-management, self-control, and enables them to have the social networks to help them thrive.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
We go to Assemblyman Ra.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Thank you. Can you hear me? There we go. Sorry about that.
So I just wanted to go, Kathleen, with regard to the COLA and all of that stuff. Because I think it's important, but it's technical as to where we are.
So you have -- last year we have this COLA, but it's not in the normal rate-setting that you go through. So we hit the end of our budget year, and now you have a gap between the end of the state budget year and the calendar year -- or the budget year that you would -- the providers operate on, correct?
MS. BRADY-STEPIEN:Right.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:So there's -- you don't know what it looks like for that gap between April 1st and, what, June 1st?
MS. BRADY-STEPIEN:That's right, yup.
So we're six weeks out from April 1st, and we don't know what rate the programs will get. Because of what happened last year, yes.
MR. GETTMAN:And we will not take the money back from our workforce. If anything, we need to invest in them. So this is a double whammy.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:But, I mean -- so really what we need in this budget is, you know, something to plug that gap in that last quarter, correct?
MS. BRADY-STEPIEN:Yup, that's right.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:And then a COLA for next year.
MS. BRADY-STEPIEN:Yup.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:But we have to make sure this all ties together so that we don't at some point go back to a rate-setting that looks at a number from two or three years ago at that point, correct?
MS. BRADY-STEPIEN:That's right. And so what we need to accomplish is making sure that the programs have their full funding through the end of the fiscal year to June 30th.
Then we have to make sure that the COLA continues forward into the rate so that, as Bill says, you know, nobody is pulling money back from their workforce. In fact, we're here talking with all of you about the need to build on that, right?
And so what we have to accomplish together really is making sure that we have the funding not only for right now, but building into the future, so that we can give these staff the increases that they need.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Yeah. I mean, if you don't -- I mean, I would look at it this way. If you don't carry a COLA forward years into the future, really it was a one-year bonus, not --
MS. BRADY-STEPIEN:Right.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:-- a COLA, correct.
MR. GETTMAN:And they will go find another job. Because the message that will be sent is "Your work is not valued. We love you, but we're not going to pay you." They will go find another job, especially if we're being -- indexing minimum wage. That's one of the harsh realities that our workforce faces.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:All right. Well, thank you, guys.
MS. BRADY-STEPIEN:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Senate?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Senator Cordell Cleare.
SENATOR CLEARE:Thank you, all of you. I -- that -- you took my question. But some of my question, you answered it. But I do want to just thank all of you for the work that you do. It is very important that every child should have after-school.
And YouthBuild, I've got to shout you out, because it started in my district, East Harlem. Nina Saxon is a big cheerleader for you over there. And I know how important that work is, not just because it provides something for young people to do, but it also gives them a skill, something that they will make money from and they will be able to live off of. So I support the work that you do a hundred percent.
MS. LANDI:Thank you. It supplies affordable housing, too.
SENATOR CLEARE:Absolutely, that part.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Assemblyman Eachus.
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:Thank you very much.
And I want to thank all these groups for what they do.
Just to let you know, I had 13 foster brothers and sisters, so --
MR. GETTMAN:We could reenroll you, if you'd --
(Laughter.)
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:Thanks.
But what I would like to say is that earlier in the hearing there were some folks talking about like the GIVE program, if you're familiar with that, and, you know, why isn't it in New York City and all. New York City has a number of programs which are great and hopefully address that. But I want you to know that I taught in the second most violent city in all of New York, and that's in upstate New York: Newburgh. Okay? And so we definitely need these programs in upstate also.
And so I think I'm just going to make an ask of you folks. I hope that you will visit my office at some point in time, come in, talk to me in depth, and let's find out what we really can do to, you know, get you out there. Because I have to honestly say that I have not heard of a few of your programs. I'm unaware of them. Not that I'm supposed to know everything, but I would love to learn more, so --
MS. LANDI:We just started one in Newburgh last year.
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:Okay, great. Thank you.
MR. GETTMAN:Thank you.
MS. MORGAN:Thank you.
MR. GETTMAN:We'll be there.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Senate?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:I don't believe we do have any other Senators, no.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:And no further Assemblymembers.
So thank you all for being here. Thank you for the work that your organizations do for New Yorkers.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Next we have Panel D: New York State Coalition Against Domestic Violence, Empire Justice Center -- and if you're keeping score, we have a -- Jessica Radbord couldn't be with us today because of illness, and Emilia Sicilia is replacing her. Then we also have the Schuyler Center for Analysis and Advocacy; SAGE - Advocacy & Services for LGBTQ+ Elders; Supportive Housing Network of New York; and New York Association of Training and Employment.
So if you can go in that order, starting with the New York State Coalition Against Domestic Violence.
MS. GERHARDT:That would be me.
Hello, everyone. Thank you.
I'm Joan Gerhardt, director of public policy and advocacy at the New York State Coalition Against Domestic Violence.
NYSCADV is recognized by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and the U.S. Department of Justice as the information clearinghouse and resource center on domestic violence in the State of New York.
Domestic violence advocates are dedicated and passionate professionals. Their work is challenging and requires unique skills and training. It is a 24-hour-a-day, seven-day-a-week obligation, meeting domestic violence survivors where they are at the police station, in the hospital, and in court. We provide crisis services which are often life-stabilizing and lifesaving.
Recognizing this critical need, domestic violence advocates were included in New York's pool of essential frontline workers at the start of the pandemic. And it's a good thing, because during the pandemic and even since, the demand for domestic violence services is incredibly high. In fact, it's the highest in the nation. In the nation. On just one day last year when the national count was conducted, more than 9100 adult and child victims received services. Extrapolate that for a full year -- we're talking about thousands of New Yorkers in need.
That's why it's so frustrating that far too many domestic violence advocates do not earn a living wage. Their compensation is tied to restrictive contracts with New York State which are not sufficiently funded. At current salaries, most domestic violence staff do not earn enough to afford a two-bedroom rental.
DV advocates were not included in the pool of human service workers who received additional salary, bonuses and COLA adjustments last year. Nor are we included in this year's COLA proposal. These employees are mostly women providing support to other women and children. They should be first on the list to receive a wage increase.
At the beginning of the pandemic a tremendous number of domestic violence staff left their jobs for fear of working in congregate settings. Now thousands of positions are still vacant because domestic violence agencies can't offer a living wage. NYSCADV urges the Legislature to increase the minimum wage of all domestic violence staff and provide us with a COLA.
I also want to mention our request that the Legislature carry forward a $14.4 million transfer to OVS for victim service providers, as well as appropriate 11.7 million for the 87 providers who received significant cuts in the most recent round of awards. Over the three-year course of those contracts, these legacy providers stand to lose 35.1 million. New York's crime victims will bear the brunt of these costs.
These are certainly described more in our written testimony. I will leave it at that. Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Empire Justice.
MS. SICILIA:Hello. My name is Emilia Sicilia, and I'm a managing attorney at the Empire Justice Center. I want to thank Chairs Krueger, Weinstein, the committee chairs, and other members here today.
The Empire Justice Center is a nonprofit law firm that seeks to make the law work for all New Yorkers, especially those who need it the most. We teach the law by providing training, support, and technical assistance; we practice the law by providing direct civil legal assistance and undertaking impact litigation; and we change the law by engaging in policy analysis, research, and advocacy.
Support for human services has never been more essential. As we work to recover from the pandemic, we must strengthen access to healthcare and other benefits and address the disparities laid bare. We must also prepare thoughtfully for coming changes, including the end of the public health emergency and the expansion of the Medicare Savings Program.
Our written testimony includes more details about the following priorities. For public benefits, the need to increase the basic needs grant amounts, the need to address skimming of public benefits, and the need to expand and improve the rental supplement program.
The need to increase the shelter allowances for households with children. OTDA has not updated the shelter allowance schedule since 2003, even though rents have doubled since then. For households without children, OTDA has not increased the shelter allowance since 1988, but rents have tripled in the last 35 years.
The opportunity to support children who have lost parents and family members caring for these children by establishing a kinship legal network pilot program.
The need to increase funding for the Managed Care Consumer Assistance Program -- notably, to be prepared to respond to the expansion of the Medicare Savings Program.
The importance of maintaining funding of $35 million for OTDA's Emergency Rental Assistance Program, which provides legal representation to low-income renters outside of New York City facing eviction, and where there's no right to counsel.
I'd like to spend the rest of my allotted time discussing the need to increase funding for the Disability Advocacy Program, known as DAP. This year marks the 40th anniversary of DAP, which was created by this Legislature in 1983. And for four decades, DAP has been providing civil legal assistance to low-income disabled New Yorkers denied or cut off from their federal disability benefits -- Supplemental Security Income, known as SSI, or SSD, Social Security Disability.
DAP services help stabilize people's income, which in turn helps to stabilize health, housing, and quality of life overall. And for every dollar invested in DAP, at least $2 is generated to the benefit of New York State and local governments in the form of public assistance costs avoided and in money spent in local economies.
The disability appeals process is complex and becoming increasingly more challenging. Financial issues, homelessness, inadequate healthcare, and sometimes the very symptoms of the disability often make it exceedingly difficult to gather the evidence needed for a claim.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
MS. SICILIA:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Schuyler Center.
MS. HILL:Yeah, hi. Good evening, and thank you to the chairs and members of the respective committees for the opportunity to present our testimony.
My name is Dede Hill, and I'm policy director at the Schuyler Center. For more than 150 years we have been advocating for policies that strengthen and improve public systems that serve low-income and disenfranchised New Yorkers, with a real focus on children and families.
I'll begin with a general observation about this Executive Budget. While it includes some important investments to improve child and family well-being -- absent our key poverty-reducing proposals -- also missing are the significant sustained investments that are truly needed for New York's child-serving systems, which have been chronically underresourced for many years. But there is time and we think real opportunity to craft a final enacted budget that centers New York children and families.
First, I want to talk about childcare. We welcome and support the Executive Budget proposals to continue expanding income-eligibility levels for childcare assistance and cutting copays, and the proposals to break down unnecessary and burdensome administrative barriers.
However, these expansions will be meaningless if New York does not act quickly to halt the exodus of the workforce. And you have heard this many times already today, but it's worth repeating: What the workforce needs is an investment of $1 billion this year, and that will support a wage supplement of $12,500 per member of the workforce. Nothing less will stop the exodus.
The Governor has proposed $389 million. This is a good step, but it is not enough. We need $1 billion.
And further, to be effective, the supplement must continue until New York has transitioned to a new provider-reimbursement model and pay scale. Providers simply cannot retain staff or recruit new staff with a small one-time bump in pay.
Also missing from the Executive Budget is an expansion of childcare assistance to children currently excluded due solely to their immigration status. Among those children who are excluded currently are many children who are lawfully present. Many of the children who are here seeking asylum are among that group who are excluded. New York should end this exclusion immediately.
Other missed opportunities: New York is overdue to increase the monthly foster-care housing subsidy and index it to inflation. We haven't changed that housing subsidy since 1988.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
SAGE?
MR. OKMA:Good evening. My name is MJ Okma, with SAGE.
SAGE has been serving LGBTQ+ and HIV-affected older New Yorkers for over four decades, providing comprehensive social services and community-building programming through a network of LGBTQ+-welcoming older adult centers across New York City. We are also the on-site service provider of the state's first LGBTQ-affirming elder housing developments and run the statewide SAGE Veterans Program.
As they age and need more assistance and care, LGBTQ+ and HIV-affected elders have fewer biological family caregivers than older people in general. Because of thin support networks, they are more likely to rely more heavily on community service providers, yet they're often distrustful of providers after facing a long history of stigma and compounding discrimination.
For many of these elders in New York, SAGE is their lifeline. It is because of them I'm here today, respectfully asking for your support in the fiscal year '24 budget for restoration of our programming. This includes restoration of 300,000 to support LGBTQ+ residents and community members in and around New York State's first LGBTQ+-welcoming affordable elder housing developments; a restoration of 150,000 to increase our multilingual programming services; a restoration of fiscal year '22 levels of funding of 260,000 for SAGEVets, after receiving a smaller designation last fiscal year; and, finally, a new funding designation of 150,000 to help meet the growing demand for services among HIV-affected older people across the state through the expansion of our SAGEPositive program.
With the support of the New York Legislature, SAGE has been able to evolve and expand to best address the widespread disparities facing LGBTQ+ New Yorkers. SAGE has redesigned our program and service delivery models to provide a variety of in-person, virtual, and hybrid options. This helps draw elders in for in-person services while addressing the direct needs of homebound elders, those with mobility challenges, those with caregiving and work responsibilities, and those elders who have health concerns about returning to in-person programs and services.
As noted, SAGE works with prominent developers to directly address the housing insecurity experienced by many LGBTQ+ elders, by building the first LGBTQ+-welcoming affordable elder housing developments. Here we provide on-site services to residents and surrounding community members, including programming, wellness checks, a food pantry, grocery delivery, and coordinated care with other providers. We have also expanded our multilingual programming into Spanish, Mandarin, and Cantonese.
Utilizing state funding and the momentum of the passage of the Restoration of Honor Act, our SAGEVets program helps older LGBTQ+ veterans navigate the VA to get the benefits they deserve, aiding in their overall health and wellness and providing referrals to counsel for discharge status upgrades. SAGE provides this life-changing support while saving New York significant amounts of funding by ensuring veterans access all their federal benefits instead of relying solely on state programs to address their housing and healthcare needs.
SAGE respectfully requests for the restoration of our funding to continue this vital work. We also request the new funding designation to replicate the success of the SAGEVets program and similarly provide statewide support for older New Yorkers living with HIV through the expansion of our SAGEPositive program.
Thank you so much.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Supportive Housing Network of New York.
MR. PIASECKI:Hi, everyone. I'm Steve Piasecki, with the Supportive Housing Network of New York. And thank you, Chairs Krueger and Weinstein and all the members of the committee, for this opportunity to thank you for a bunch of other stuff, to start with.
The Governor's budget has really got lots of bright new, shiny new things for supportive housing. I'll focus on the ESSHI program that we've been working on for the past decade or so.
But now, Year 7, I'm happy to report that (a) the funding for ongoing services and operations for the existing ESSHI units that are up and running -- which are now over 7400 in total -- meeting the Governor's obligation for that supportive housing plan, is fully funded in the OTDA budget. So that is excellent news for us.
We're happy that the recommitment for the Affordable Housing Fund last year in the HCR budget is present, and that will help us build the next 1400 units worth of supportive housing.
We're also happy for the new initiative around the mental health housing in the OMH budget.
But really what I'm here today to talk about is our legacy programs, or the first generation of supportive housing, that have gone underfunded to an extent that dwarfs imagination -- in particular, the NYSSHP funding program.
NYSSHP, the New York State Supportive Housing Program, has been around for almost 30 years. It funds a little bit of services in a lot of different supportive housing programs, about 20,000 units statewide. Half of them are a joint project with New York City DHS, and the other half are spread all around the state. They serve individuals and families at this point. The families were added in 2002.
These programs are funded at about 1/10 of the rate of the funding that the ESSHI program has -- maybe $2400 to $3500 per unit per year, as compared with $25,000 for ESSHI. So we're really looking to fix that. The total price tag to fix it, to be honest with you, would be about a little less than $150 million.
But we're also looking for a technical fix, as many others are. For some reason, even though this program funds strictly staffing that provide direct services to homeless people in supportive housing, it has never been in the COLA, so it didn't receive the 5.4 percent last year like many of my colleagues have already talked about.
And once again, we really need to have that added as an ongoing program to the COLA legislation that is being proposed this year, and carried forward in the future, as another means to catch up.
We're also advocating for additional funding to support the state's Preservation Plan that was funded last year. It's sort of the same thing -- there is just not enough support for programs that really need to be physically rehabilitated without expanding the services.
Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
New York Association of Training and Employment.
MS. MACK:Hi. Good evening, everyone. Let me know if you can't hear me. Thank you for allowing me the opportunity to testify again this year. I always appreciate the chance to share with you what our members care about.
My name is Melinda Mack. I am the executive director at NYATEP, which is the statewide workforce development association representing the education, job training and employment providers across New York State.
As I'm sure you are speaking to folks in your districts, you're hearing that people just don't want to work and people should just go out and get a job. I'm here to tell you that over the last decade our labor force participation rate has begun to slide, and it's been happening long before COVID.
And it's predominantly due to retirements, lack of birth rate -- sort of, you know, folks don't have 10 kids, like they used to -- and also the challenges we're having around educational attainment across New York as well as, you know, low-wage work. You're hearing about some of it today. Some of it is grossly underpaid, and in many ways it's something that we absolutely need to rectify if we're going to recruit and retain folks.
In our last four annual State of the Workforce Development reports we basically laid out the fact that the vast majority of jobs in New York are low-wage work. In fact, 2 million jobs from the top 10 largest occupational groups pay less than a living wage.
In addition to that, when you take those two points between low-wage work and the fact that 36 percent of our population has a high school diploma or less, we understand why we're not getting more folks into good or better jobs.
One of the challenges we have identified as a major hurdle that keeps low-income New Yorkers not able to access economic mobility is the benefits cliff. And the benefits cliff, for those who are unaware, is a sudden or gradual loss of your benefits because you took a job, because you decided to go into an apprenticeship program that gave you a wage, because you are taking a subsidized job training program. A lot of folks make the decision not to participate because they will lose their benefits immediately.
Thankfully, both the Governor and the Legislature have put forth proposals to support a six-month income disregard. We are fully supportive of that income disregard and thank the leadership here that has supported that on our behalf.
In addition to that, you already heard earlier that the Office of Strategic Workforce Development at Empire State Development has also provided support to many community-based organizations on the ground. This year in the Governor's budget the Governor, despite saying they support workforce, it provided zero dollars. There's no money going to ESD this year for the Office of Strategic Workforce Development.
That's a problem because without job training, again, that 36 percent of New Yorkers who have a high school diploma or less will not be accessing good or better jobs.
Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Assemblyman Eachus.
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:Thank you again, Ms. Chair.
Joan, I'm going to pile on here a little bit of stuff. Your call for an increase in wages and benefits is absolutely important, because domestic violence is generational. It gets passed from one generation down to the next, down to the next. And when you're talking about that, you're sometimes talking about parents to many children.
And we've seen this with the increase in teen violence, with relationships, and that's something that we need to stop now, as it may be.
I'm going to do a little dirt here and do a little PR for a program that I have locally. It's called FEARLESS. It used to be called formerly Safe Homes. My wife worked for it for years as a volunteer, but they do have professionals that are paid there. But they do function a lot on the volunteers.
And I encourage anybody who can avail themselves to it to see what's called their T-Shirt Project. It is hundreds upon hundreds of T-shirts from folks who were affected by this domestic violence. And you should take the opportunity to view that if you can. Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Senate?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Senator Jabari Brisport.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Thank you, Madam Chair.
And thank you all for being here and your testimonies. I have questions for SAGE and for Schuyler Center.
For SAGE, I just want to express my gratitude. You do incredible work in my district in Fort Greene. I actually just feel guilty that others don't have a SAGE to help out their LGBTQ+ seniors.
I'm just curious, in any of your analysis, if you have a way to share a sense of like the need throughout this state, like if you have any numbers of how many LGBTQ+ seniors are not being served at the moment.
MR. OKMA:I will say that it's really hard to get adequate data about this population, so there isn't a good number of how much.
We have data that says that there is everywhere from 250,000 to like 800,000 LGBTQ+ elders in New York State. So there's a big disparity. And part of that is we really do need more sexual orientation and gender identity data collected on all places where demographic data's collected, to get a sense of how big this population is.
I will stress, though, specifically with the new funding designation that we're asking for SAGEPositive, is that we do have data that shows that by 2030, 72 percent of New Yorkers living with HIV will be over the age of 50. And quite frankly, the state just is not adequately prepared to make sure that we're serving that population.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Thank you. So we have a long way to go.
And for Schuyler Center, thank you for reiterating the need for workforce support.
As you know, and I just want to repeat it for everyone here, the Executive Budget is once again attempting to stabilize the sector by doing -- using one-time federal funds. And I'm just curious if you've heard in your advocacy from any providers anywhere if they've used this one-time limited infusion to create long-term wage increases.
MS. HILL:No, I have not heard that.
What I can say is that what we heard from providers who received the first round of stabilization, and the second round, where they had -- they could use those funds in a real broad variety of ways, they used almost all of it for workforce. I mean, that is the number-one issue. And they've poured it all into workforce, and they're still losing workforce every day. It's not enough.
SENATOR BRISPORT:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Assemblyman Burdick.
(Pause.)
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Is he here?
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:He left.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:I don't see him.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:So the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Oh, okay. We have Senator Murray.
SENATOR MURRAY:Thank you, Chair.
And thank you all for being here.
I'd like to ask Ms. Mack a couple of things.
First, when we talked about the benefit cliff and you talked about holding on to the benefits for six months, we're just looking for a little clarification. Were you talking about the benefits they currently have with the state, or would it be transitioning to the benefits they would have when they go?
MS. MACK:Yeah, so the benefit cliff is really around losing your public benefits, so the public assistance that you're already receiving.
What we find is that again, even with the Summer Youth Employment Program, it was again the Legislature that really helped us out, because we had young adults who were unwilling to participate in SYEP because, if they did, that couple hundred bucks they'd earn over the summer, it would likely kick their family off of public assistance.
It makes no sense for us to keep people poor, especially folks who are trying to do all of the right things to get out of poverty.
SENATOR MURRAY:Right. I wanted to talk also about when we talk about the different types of jobs, I've spoken to many manufacturers who are saying their number-one problem -- it's not taxes, not infrastructure -- they can't find a trained workforce.
Are we investing enough in BOCES, CTE programs, things like this?
MS. MACK:Absolutely not.
And again, in the Governor's infinite wisdom she opened this new office of Strategic Workforce Investment, but they are providing zero dollars, zero flexible dollars for workforce development this year.
So the vast majority of workforce development funding is federal funding that has very specific requirements in terms of how you can spend it.
We need to meet people where they're at. Again, everybody who is available to work should be able to get a good job in New York, and we have great programs that are not being attended because people can't cover the cost of their childcare, because they can't cover transportation, they don't have a car, they don't have a driver's license.
Think of all the places in your district that you need to get to with a car. And I lived in Brooklyn for a while -- try to get to Kingsborough without a car.
(Laughter.)
MS. MACK:It will take you the whole day.
SENATOR MURRAY:And I was also going to ask, when you mentioned -- so you mentioned childcare, you talked about the workforce and reasons that people aren't getting back into the workforce. How big of a problem is the childcare issue?
MS. MACK:It's one of the number-one issues. Childcare, transportation, workforce, housing. So, you know, affordable rents, but then also, again, this benefits cliff.
The vast majority of people who are underutilized are either utilizing public assistance or have low basic educational skills and often can't step away from the low-wage job they have for job training.
SENATOR MURRAY:Thank you very much.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Assembly.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Assemblyman Burdick.
ASSEMBLYMAN BURDICK:Thank you.
This is a question for Joan Gerhardt. And I first want to apologize for not being here at the time of your testimony, but I did read it.
And I'm wondering if you could explain more fully what you have experienced or what agencies have experienced with respect to the loss of funding, these legacy agencies that have been handling victim services for quite some time and I think were just totally shocked that they didn't get the funding levels that they had before -- actually, at a time when Linda Rosenthal and I thought that we had gotten the money into the budget that we thought would do the trick so that those agencies would not sustain some drastic cuts in funding.
What was the outcome? I mean, what have you heard? Have victims been turned away? Have staff been cut? Can you describe a little bit what those outcomes have been?
MS. GERHARDT:Absolutely, and thank you for the question.
It's been devastating. It's really been devastating for those 87 programs. We've heard of vacant positions. You know, we've heard of layoffs. We've heard of job postings that have been pulled back because they can't offer the position any longer.
For the legal service organizations that are included in that mix, we've heard that they've been unable to take on new clients because they are ethically required to be able to follow that client through the end of their proceeding. And with those cuts, they're not sure how long those employees will still be in their rolls.
So yeah, it's $11.7 million to the state's infrastructure, this critical infrastructure of victim service providers. And like you said, we thought we had dealt with this in last year's budget, but unfortunately, with OVS's recent round of awards for these 87 programs, we didn't resolve anything. So I think it's a dramatic impact.
ASSEMBLYMAN BURDICK:Well, thank you for that.
And, you know, we will try to see what we can do, because I think that the Executive just wasn't aware. Some may take a cynical view; I don't. I think that they just didn't realize that it wasn't enough to go up by 14.4 million, because the whole process of the competitive bidding that was required by the Comptroller resulted in new agencies -- which I'm sure are doing a good job scoring very high for the desert areas.
And so we're going to work very hard to try to get the funding in for the legacy agencies.
MS. GERHARDT:I appreciate that.
ASSEMBLYMAN BURDICK:Thanks for your work.
MS. GERHARDT:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Senate?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Excuse me. Senator Jessica Scarcello-Stanton -- I'm going to get it right, I promise, yes.
(Laughter.)
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:I know, it's a tough name. It's Jessica Scarcella-Spanton.
Hi. My question is for you, Joan. I just wanted to thank you for the work that you're doing.
I know that incidents of domestic violence have gone up significantly from the pandemic. How are you balancing the uptick in domestic violence cases?
And I also want to say I think you're doing a really wonderful job highlighting different kinds of abuse. We often talk about physical abuse. I'm happy to see that you're highlighting stalking, emotional abuse -- there's all sorts of abuse which you're talking about, which I also imagine results in more cases for you.
So how are you balancing an uptick in caseload with a loss of workforce, especially given that they can't afford it, is the first part of my question.
My second part of my question is I think domestic violence victims often have a hard time trusting people. So if a domestic violence victim is working with a certain caseworker or an advocate, and then through that process they lose that advocate, how does that impact the progression of the case? Which we know a lot of times victims of domestic violence tend to take -- I believe it's eight times before they finally go. So how does that impact the case?
MS. GERHARDT:Great. I don't think we are balancing that difficulty between the increased demand and the loss of -- the increase in job vacancies. I think it's every program in the state -- there's 100 programs with about 250 facilities that they operate -- is struggling with this, whether they received cuts or whether they, you know, are maintained. It's a case by case.
And I want to point out, too, it's not just the increase in numbers of requests for service, it's the lethality that's connected to those requests. Because what we're hearing as well is not only the increase in number, but they're much more volatile incidents.
So I agree with you, it's not just physical violence, but of the individuals who are in that circumstance, the lethality factors are very, very high. So I agree with you there.
And I would say we need more help. We're not balancing it well. And victims are going to be the ones who bear the brunt of that.
And I forget your second question, I'm sorry.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:Oh, my second question was, you know, if -- because of the lack of COLA increases, because of the lack of a pay raise, if a victim is working with an advocate -- I think a lot of times it takes a victim of domestic violence a while to actually trust who they're confiding in and who they're working with. It's -- like I said before, it can take up to eight times for a victim to leave before they finally actually leave.
So if you lose an advocate while you're in the middle of working with a victim, how does that impact the progression of some of your case -- of your caseloads?
MS. GERHARDT:Thank you.
Often they won't come back for services. So if they're working closely with an advocate and they've developed a relationship and that advocate for whatever reason is no longer there, that could be enough for them to say, You know what, I didn't get the assistance I needed, I don't want to start over again.
And I think that is one of the issues: We ask survivors over and over and over again to tell their story, which is very re-traumatizing.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:Absolutely. Thank you so much.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
No more Assemblymembers. Any Senators?
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Okay, we have Senator Cordell Cleare.
SENATOR CLEARE:Thank you, everyone, for your testimony.
I just -- you know, you all do a fantastic job of talking really fast --
(Laughter.)
SENATOR CLEARE:-- so I missed a few things a little bit.
And SAGE, you know, I'm a fan of your work and you're also in my district, so I feel really lucky to have you there. You said $300,000 for housing and then I think there's some -- $150,000 for HIV-impacted older people. But I missed the other 150.
MR. OKMA:Yeah, of course. Thank you so much.
The restoration of 150,000 to support our multilingual programs and services. So we currently offer programs and services in English, Spanish, Cantonese, and Mandarin. And the support of the Legislature really helps us provide that, and we'd love to expand for more language options as well.
And then the other designation was for our SAGE --
SENATOR CLEARE:250,000.
MR. OKMA:260 for SAGEVets. And I will say that that is fiscal year '22 funding levels -- we saw a reduction last fiscal year, where we got 150,000 -- and we saw a really big impact in what we were able to do specifically in being able to partner with more providers and affiliates outside of New York City to make sure that we provide the service.
It is the only program that specifically serves LGBTQ+ older veterans, and we would really like to see it restored back to those fiscal year '22 levels.
SENATOR CLEARE:Thank you so much.
I'm sorry, I don't know your -- could you tell me about the DAP program?
MS. SICILIA:Yes.
SENATOR CLEARE:Yeah.
MS. SICILIA:Yes. From Empire Justice, Emilia Sicilia.
SENATOR CLEARE:I wanted to hear a little bit -- you went down a little bit and I didn't hear everything.
MS. SICILIA:Thank you for -- I'm happy to talk at length about DAP.
(Laughter.)
MS. SICILIA:So we in the DAP program are facing many obstacles in helping our clients overcome many of the hurdles that they're facing. And they've been compounded by the pandemic and compounded by the difficulties at the Social Security Administration with severe understaffing that has resulted in a lot of difficulty in our clients accessing those services.
So although --
SENATOR CLEARE:Just tell me what DAP was for, because the {inaudible} --
MS. SICILIA:Excuse me?
SENATOR CLEARE:DAP, what is that?
MS. SICILIA:Oh, DAP is the Disability Advocacy Program.
SENATOR CLEARE:Oh, okay.
MS. SICILIA:So we're assisting individuals who have been denied benefits and representing them in their appeals.
And so we are -- it is a -- the appeals process is really difficult, lasts a long time. And at this moment we're really -- we're addressing a lot of COVID-related obstacles due to closures of Social Security. They were closed for two years and reopened with real severe understaffing.
And we also are representing many people with Long COVID claims. That's something that is amounting to new challenges, in that it's not very well understood. Those claims present a lot of difficulty also in obtaining the evidence that's required. And again, there's just a lot of access issues for our clients.
And so although we've -- we're really grateful for the executive funding increase last year, we really do need the Legislature to restore the $3 million add-on in order to continue to meet the current demands that have been compounded -- presented by the pandemic.
SENATOR CLEARE:Thank you.
MS. SICILIA:Sure.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Okay.
Senator Rolison.
SENATOR ROLISON:Thank you, Chair.
This question is for Ms. Gerhardt.
There was a time when crime victims were essentially voiceless -- and I'm going back many years, as a retired police officer of 26 years. And there was the term "crime victim-centered approach," which we were all trained in and we needed to really do more for the victims. And this was through the entire system. And systems were put in place, money was allocated, groups got together, we collaborated, we weren't in silos because it was about the crime victim.
In the Executive Budget there is additional money for DCJS in a variety of areas that are important. There is a small increase, I think, in the Crime Victim Compensation Fund, probably -- definitely not enough. But now we're hearing from you, we've heard this from others in other hearings and other testimony, where we're stagnant and we're going backwards in the area of domestic violence and crime victim services.
And speaking with my colleague from the Assembly, I think we're talking a little over $11 million. Is that the number, what needs to be restored, reallocated, or increased to make sure, as we've heard from all of the members of the Legislature today about the importance of having those advocates, having people you can go to, even creating places that -- where every service was brought together so you weren't going from one place to another, because people wouldn't go. Or they'd go to the first step and they wouldn't go to the second or to the third.
I'd like to take the position, too, as my colleague, that maybe this is an oversight. Because if you think about the money that's committed in DCJS and other agencies related to public safety, that's not a whole heck of a lot of money, in my estimation. And I hope that when this budget is debated and people work together to try to create some changes, that will be one of them.
I'd like to be helpful to the extent that I can. But I realize, as a freshman Senator, I won't have probably those opportunities other than to advocate for you. But we're going backwards. We've made a lot of strides, and now here we are in 2023 and it sounds like we're talking about what we were talking about in the '80s and in the early '90s when these changes were made.
MS. GERHARDT:You know -- thank you, Senator. We're doing a lot of talking about public safety and increases in crime rates, and very little about crime victims. Very little about crime victims.
SENATOR ROLISON:Right. Because they're there no matter what the crime rate is. Somebody is a victim. And that is the loneliest place in the world to be if you don't have people there to help you through it.
I give you all the credit in the world for what you're doing -- all of you. Thank you.
MS. GERHARDT:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
I believe I'm the last Senator.
So for Stephen, Supportive Housing.
MR. PIASECKI:Yes.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:So you described the continuing saga of the older programs getting so little reimbursements instead of the newer ones.
So I've been telling people for years, just don't do the older contracts. Move your resources to the newer contracts. Trust me, the state will come up with the money rather than have nobody provide those programs. Because it's ridiculous that you've been strung along like this forever and that we don't make progress on this. So that's just my advocacy position.
Shelter allowance. Seriously, they're paying you almost less than -- a little more than half of what they're paying the newer contracts. You're supposed to be doing the same services for --
MR. PIASECKI:It's 10 percent.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Pardon me?
MR. PIASECKI:Ten percent of what is in the newest contracts.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Far less.
So, you know, the punch line is apparently we think you can keep doing it because you keep doing it. So stop doing it.
MR. PIASECKI:Well, some of -- there's been some erosion. There's certainly erosion in the physical plants of many of the early supportive housing buildings.
And that's why last year you guys were gracious enough to create the Preservation Program.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Because you know what, we're desperate for supportive housing.
MR. PIASECKI:Yeah.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:No one's letting those really go. You just have to -- we're playing a game of chicken, and -- if I'm the government in this conversation, and we're winning. And that's wrong, in my opinion.
Shelter allowance also. How many families might not be evicted every year in New York State if we just adjusted the shelter allowance, even just for inflation?
Does anybody -- do you have any calculations on that?
MS. SICILIA:I would be happy to bring that back to my colleagues who prepared our written testimony on that point and be in touch with you with the specifics.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Because I'm almost going to guarantee we are spending so much more money on the emergency rents in assorted programs that we're paying because we just won't pay a realistic shelter allowance.
So it's -- but I would like you to --
MS. SICILIA:We'd agree with you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:-- get back to me with any data you have.
And on domestic violence, you talked about the number -- the demand going up so much during the pandemic and post-pandemic. Are you also seeing growth in the number of victims of sex trafficking coming to you for help? And are they eligible for the same kinds of services that your other --
MS. GERHARDT:Yes. So that the pool of service providers that I've been talking about includes providers of services for trafficking victims.
I'd have to give you some more -- you know, go back and research if there's been a bump in the number of trafficking survivors that have been provided assistance. I'm happy to do that.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Great. I appreciate it.
And thank you all for the very hard work you do.
Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you. Thank you for being here with us. And I want to echo the thank you for the work you do to help New Yorkers.
MR. OKMA:Thanks.
MS. GERHARDT:Thanks.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Our last, our final panel, Panel E, Hudson Valley National Center for Veteran Reintegrating, and New York State Council of Veterans Organizations.
(Pause.)
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:So sometimes we say we save the best for last. Thank you both for staying with us throughout this day.
And we can go first with Hudson Valley.
MR. WALTERS:Thank you. My name is Gavin Walters. Thank you, Senate and Assembly members, for allowing me to sit here and represent our military community.
I sit here on behalf of the Ulster County Dwyer Program, which is under the Hudson Valley National Center for Veteran Reintegration, and have the great privilege of sitting here as the facilitator of the New York State Dwyer Coalition, also known as the Joseph P. Dwyer Veteran Peer Support Project, which is officially a state program.
2022 was a tremendous year for the PFC Joseph Dwyer Program because it was expanded to every county in New York State. This will allow every veteran and their family to become connected to veteran peers.
The Dwyer program has allowed servicemembers to feel equally represented, because time, duty, and length of service do not matter when you put on the uniform. If you're homeless, let’s pay for a day or two for a hotel. If you enjoy the outdoors, well, let us take a hike or camp out. Equine Encounters, Mindfulness, and groups help continue the camaraderie that we experienced in the service. That is what the Dwyer counties represent, and that is what was brought to every county in New York State.
Now, for every Dwyer county to be represented, we knew a united front and a collective body were needed. In December 2020, the New York State Dwyer Coalition, under the Hudson Valley National Center for Veteran Reintegration, was created. We have been meeting once a month to discuss challenges that we have seen in our communities. Guest speakers as well as representatives from our New York State Assembly and Senate sit at the table and hear our voices. Our open and well-represented meetings give our community a large voice.
With the support and leadership of OMH, DVS, the Dwyer Evaluation Team, and the Governor's Office, the Dwyer Coalition uses its voice to help with the collaboration to assist new counties to develop their programs. The collaboration amongst these departments reflects the unity that was created within the Dwyer Coalition.
Our importance for being at any table means that we are being represented collectively, as one voice, when issues may bother us or challenges might affect us. For each of the counties that house a Dwyer program, representation is very important, because every Dwyer program in their respective county is supposed to service their community uniquely and with 100 percent autonomy. Those two caveats have allowed every program to help an armed forces member that received a dishonorable or honorable discharge.
Collectively, many Dwyer programs have shared the concern of the program never receiving an increase in funding since its enactment in 2012. The Dwyer program has evolved into peers transporting veterans, assisting with food insecurities, advocating for housing, and many more. With inflation and the cost of living increasing, some programs have been able to offset the additional cost with fundraising and community generosity, which sometimes doesn't cover the cost of many services.
Sitting here as a Jamaican-born immigrant that honorably served in the U.S. Air Force and now who is a disabled veteran with invisible wounds fighting for a service connection, I understand the advocacy. That is why funding the Dwyer Coalition and an increase in funding for Dwyer programs would positively impact each county.
Thank you for your time.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
Kirby?
MR. HANNAN:Well, don't be fooled by Gavin's title, Hudson Valley National Center for Veteran Reintegration. That's his job, okay? But what he does with Dwyer is he's got at least 30 to 40 counties that are participating on a weekly basis -- on a monthly basis in his furthering of -- {cellphone interruption}.
Yeah, I know. Don't worry about it. You know, it has to happen. I apologize.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Okay.
MR. HANNAN:And what he's done is he's brought the Dwyer program to a brand-new level. It went from 30 counties to 60 counties. Thank you so much, okay.
And what is Dwyer doing now? Every peer-to-peer situation is something that's happening at a post level. You don't walk into a brick building and say, I'm here to get peer-to-peer mentoring. No, it's something that happens through a veteran's service officer, it's something that happens in a whole variety of ways.
So first of all, thank you, Gavin, for bringing this. We've been talking about this for about eight years. And some folks here recognized the Dwyer program eight years ago in four counties -- and I won't mention what counties they were. But nonetheless, Dwyer has now migrated to the whole state. Terrific. All right?
Having said that, at every county there's a veteran service officer, there's county veteran service officers, there's VFW veteran service officers, there's DAV veteran service officers, AMVET veteran service officers, and Legion veteran service officers. The funding was just increased for them to about $25,000, the state's share.
But where we're going from here is keep an eye on the veterans service officer, because not only does that person perform a claims function -- and you heard from DVS earlier today -- but that person is also a leader, a veteran leader in their community.
So when we talk about veteran service officers, you've got to understand that that's also an integral part of Dwyer's peer-to-peer program. So keep in mind funding for that.
Finally, Veterans Treatment Court and the Veterans Defense Program. Okay, you've got two pieces of that. Veterans Treatment Court is mostly for misdemeanors, all right? I'm going to say that the Veterans Defense Program is largely felony level, all right? And the Veterans Treatment Courts need monitors. So funding for monitors. If any -- that's found in different places in the budget, but not a lot of money.
Okay, funding for Veterans Treatment Court monitors is incredibly important, because they're all volunteers. We've heard about volunteers today. So when you see an opportunity to increase the funding for Veterans Treatment Court monitors, seize on it, because it's saving the state money.
And then, finally, the Veterans Defense Program, that's the last stop for a veteran who gets himself in serious trouble with the law. And they have been -- the Veterans Defense Program has been very, very successful in pleading those down, using -- educating the court system and using the jargon in a way in which the court can understand it so that they know what kind of a veteran they're dealing with.
That's it. That's all I got.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank --
MR. HANNAN:I do have one more thing, come to think of it.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Go ahead.
MR. HANNAN:I have to give you guys, everybody up there, the Hard Ass Award.
(Laughter.)
MR. HANNAN:Yeah.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:How'd you know?
(Laughter.)
MR. HANNAN:Seriously.
(Laughter.)
MR. HANNAN:You've heard it before but, you know, you people are just fantastic. And thank you very much.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:We'll take it.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Yeah, we'll take it.
We go to Assemblyman Ra.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Thank you two very much for your patience today, and certainly for your service and serving our veterans.
So Mr. Walters, quickly, I mean, I think it's so great to hear from somebody like you that the state has now invested to grow this program. And it takes people like you to, you know, make this program great. And that's why we know it's always worked is because of the people who've walked in those same shoes that are working with our veterans.
But what have you seen in those counties that are, you know, putting this into effect for the first time as a result of the funding last year? Is there just a growing need to continue investing in this? I would think there is.
MR. WALTERS:Investing financially or just investing --
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Financially and otherwise.
MR. WALTERS:Definitely financially, yes. Time, yes.
I sit with the individuals from OMH, DVS, as well as the Dwyer Evaluation Team, where we sit and discuss what can be done regarding the counties that's trying to figure out what to do if they're a different process -- because every county is unique, every county is different. So each county has their own, you know, challenges or, you know, questions about, okay, what should I do, how can I run this, you know, who can I hire. You know, it goes through a different process. So it's an ongoing thing.
But financially, absolutely. One of the things that, you know, I sit here is because the Dwyer program has not been -- since its enactment about 10 years ago, it has not been increased. So just from the program's deliverables of people doing things like going and helping individuals with groceries or sitting with someone at the store or whatever it is, you know, the service has increased just from the peer-to-peer, but just -- you know, they've actually turned into like case managers, but without being case managers. Advocates. You know, speaking with someone at 2 o'clock in the morning, where I've taken a phone call from someone suicidal.
Those are things that we've done beyond, you know, just our office hours or just beyond what we have to do.
But absolutely, the need for financial -- you know, a monetary gain would be great for a lot of the programs.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Great. Thank you.
And Mr. Hannan, I don't know if you were here earlier, but when we were talking to the director --
MR. HANNAN:DVS?
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Yes. We mentioned the grant program that was in the $5 million in grants that was put in for veterans service organizations.
MR. HANNAN:That's for infrastructure improvements and the like.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Yeah, in last year's budget.
And the number of applicants seemed to be very low. So are local veterans organizations aware of this? I just --
MR. HANNAN:You just asked my favorite question.
You know, the problem as I see it -- and, you know, I'm outspoken, and I apologize for that. But DVS is treating it as a procurement program, not a grant program. So if it's a procurement program, they can't answer any questions.
Have you ever navigated that grants gateway? I have. It's a bear. It's incredibly counterintuitive.
ASSEMBLYMAN RA:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
To the Senate.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
(Slowly.) Senator Jessica Scarcella-Spanton.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:Ooh, very good. Thank you.
(Laughter, applause.)
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:I have been making mistakes with her name all day. That's why we're laughing.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:It is -- it's tough.
But Kirby, Gavin, I just wanted to thank you both so much for being here today and being patient and making us laugh at the end of the day also.
(Laughter.)
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:But the Assemblyman asked the question I was going to ask -- is, you know, how is that $5 million that's not being allocated in the Executive Budget going to affect you?
And I also wanted to ask if the -- if it's sufficient, the amount of peer-to-peer funding that you have to include all the counties this year -- if it's enough, if you need more. I just wanted to -- I know it's a very, very important program, so I want to make sure that it's being appropriately funded.
MR. HANNAN:Well, it's different things for different people. Gavin said it, all right? So, you know, you have to look at it in terms of one county maybe is adequately funded and another county has obviously significantly more needs. Rural versus urban, et cetera. Transportation versus homeless, you know. So all of that is going on.
I can't say whether more funding needs to -- my testimony says that Dwyer ought to be allowed to evaluate this in a grassroots way with SUNY, and that at the end of some budget period you need to take a second look at, okay, where do we allocate our funds.
Because I think that it's a very important question, and I don't -- I think that there's not a clear-cut answer for it. Certainly I don't have one.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:And that makes sense. If you're in an area that is more densely populated with veterans, whether it's, you know, if you're near a VA, or if you're up in Fort Drum, and maybe that's just the area that they tend to gravitate to, they may need more funding than an area who doesn't have as many veterans.
So it gives you the opportunity to have more flexibility with how you spend that money. Is that correct?
MR. HANNAN:Well, yes.
And I think a lot of people don't realize that Dwyer is actually -- a lot of people think that it's connected with DVS. It's really not. OMH contracts with Dwyer, with the county OMH as well as the county Division of Veteran Services, and that's how they figure out what CBOs and what not-for-profits are out there that can provide some of the services that are specific.
Do me a favor, don't listen me. Just Google "WHY6Vet." WHY, 6, Vet.
MR. WALTERS:We Have Your 6. It's called "We Have Your 6." It's an organization that helps veterans in need that are suicidal and just going through the issues that so many of us, you know, have experienced.
But they are one of those organizations that's out there that have been helping many veterans. But it's WHY6, but it's We Have Your 6.
MR. HANNAN:And for your information, because I've heard several people asking about New York City and certainly Staten Island, Senator. And DVS just -- New York City, just issued how they're going to administer Dwyer for New York City. So it's -- and if anybody wants it, just give me a shout and I'll --
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:I want it.
(Laughter.)
MR. HANNAN:Okay. All right, Senator.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:Thank you so much.
MR. HANNAN:You bet. Okay.
SENATOR SCARCELLA-SPANTON:I appreciate it.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Assemblyman Eachus.
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:There we go. Thank you.
Thank you for your service, and thank you for helping out vets. It's very important.
Just recently when I was home, one of the complaints I heard from a member of the posts has to do with brick and mortar, and that is the fact that there really are no funds out there that are available for posts to fix their facilities unless they spend the money first.
And many of them told me: You know what, if we had the money to spend, I wouldn't go through all the paperwork to try to get grants from New York State to work on these buildings.
MR. HANNAN:Let me -- let me correct you on something.
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:Sure.
MR. HANNAN:The way DVS has worked it out, and the way I know DASNY, Dormitory Authority of the State of New York, has actually interacted on this issue is that they've got a method by which they can reimburse the contractor.
So the 5 million that we were talking about before for infrastructure improvements, that can actually be contracted for with the contractor, and then DASNY will take over and execute the contract and will actually pay. So you don't have to spend the money first.
That was the case a while back, in the last round of -- I'll call them crest fundings -- but not this time.
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:Well, I thank you for that. I deal with a number of folks that are even older than myself, and maybe they remember from those points in time.
Gavin, I just wanted to ask you real quickly, how does the Dwyer program work with the county service officers?
MR. WALTERS:So depending on which county you go to, you know, it might be different.
I could speak about Ulster County. We have a great relationship with Mark Cozzupoli at the Ulster VSA, where we will meet -- actually, last year we met once a month just to speak about the veterans in the community, the veterans that are being impacted, such as the ones that were homeless or just had some type of need of services. But we always will work with one another.
We have luncheons that we'll actually sit at different tables together to share each other's resources. If a veteran -- we know a lot of servicemembers will not go to the VSA. So when they do actually come to our office, we'll actually speak to them and say, Hey, you know, have you gotten your service connection? Or what do you know about benefits? And we'll actually escort them to there, speak to them collectively and say, Hey, this is the person that you should speak to regarding service connection, and then come back to our office and then see what you want to do.
So that relationship really blends, you know, when you work really well with your VSA.
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:That's great to hear.
The final thing that I would say is you mentioned about OMH. It is my hope that OMH is working very closely with you. Because when you have a veteran that calls up and has an immediate, serious problem, there should be somebody in OMH, a professional -- I mean, thank you for what you do, thank you for all the volunteers and so on like that, but there should be a professional also available to answer the questions and help that particular --
MR. WALTERS:They actually sit at our coalition meetings monthly. So they sit at our meetings, and anytime we have an issue or anything like that, they actually will address us and speak to us. So their relationship is really close to us now.
ASSEMBLYMAN EACHUS:Good.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Senator Tom O'Mara.
SENATOR O'MARA:Thank you, gentlemen, for the great work you do day in and day out for our veterans.
I think, as we've heard testimony throughout the day today, kind of the state's attention to veteran services is woeful and could be a heck of a lot better. But you're doing a great job with what you have.
Can you comment at all, are we making any progress in the treatment of post-traumatic stress and how that fits into the whole equation of our mental health and, frankly, addiction issues of so many veterans? What kind of progress is being made there?
MR. WALTERS:Well, I think the biggest hurdle is the reintegration. Because we know once someone's in service and once they get out is two different attitudes. Because we'll see someone when they're in the most harsh situation.
And because there's not that piece of, like, connecting them right before they get to our county, then it becomes that challenge of trying to reach out to them and say, Hey, how you doing, what's going on, are you experiencing any issues?
And we know the young veterans will not reach out to anybody unless -- until, you know, they need to get somewhere. But the older veterans, we do know that they will -- you know, they're more willing to reach out to someone. If we go to the VA or wherever, they'll be willing to speak to us.
But the younger veterans are the ones that we're always trying to reach out to, because they're the ones that's usually not willing because -- as a young veteran that came out myself, that didn't have any service connections, just got -- you know, just was I'll say booted out, I didn't want to speak to anybody because I didn't feel like I qualified, as well as I didn't think anybody understood.
It took a long time until another veteran talked to me and said, Hey, Gavin, you might qualify for some VA services, speak to someone. And that connection with another peer actually connected me. And that's what usually happens with a lot of the veterans.
So just for the PTSD, or just speaking to someone with that, it's about the reintegration part where we actually -- if we just speak to somebody if like when they -- you know, if we knew that they were in combat, if we knew that they were deployed somewhere and we were able to talk to them right before they got -- came back to the States, that would be a big impact.
That would be so good that we could say, Hey, we know that you're going through something, come to our office. Or, listen, if you're not able to come to our office, we'll talk to you, we'll talk to your family -- or educate their families, which is the biggest component where eight, nine times out of 10, it's the families that's reaching out to us.
So if we could educate the family members to say, Hey, listen, if you know your sister, brother, cousin, or whoever is in this situation, these are the tools that you should have. Have a number that's on text or speed dial that you could just reach out to somebody while you're comforting that person in the corner and they're crying. Listen, don't make them feel like they're, you know, isolated or anything like that, just give them the necessary tools to understand that they're not alone, and then reach out to that person or that friend that they might have that could get connected to them.
So it's an interesting process. It just depends on where you might -- who you might speak to, who you might go to. But there's no real good answer for that. I just say I always go back to the reintegration part, where if we can actually speak to someone when they leave service, that will be the biggest component to actually dealing with that.
SENATOR O'MARA:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:We do have Senator, I believe, Ashby. Senator Ashby.
SENATOR ASHBY:Thank you, Madam Chair.
Gavin, Kirby, thanks for being here today. Thanks for your testimony. Thanks for all the work you do every day.
The Dwyer program in Ulster -- is it growing?
MR. WALTERS:Yes, it's growing. With the funds and with the individuals and the individuals that see what we're doing, it is absolutely growing.
SENATOR ASHBY:And the other members across the state in your program, are their Dwyer programs growing as well in terms of participation?
MR. WALTERS:I believe so, yes.
SENATOR ASHBY:And when you look at the increase that we saw in this Executive Budget, do you think it's commensurate with the growth that we're seeing in Dwyer throughout the state? Or do you think it should be more?
MR. WALTERS:It should be more, absolutely.
The 7.7 million was a great impact because it actually gave every county a Dwyer program, which was huge. But it didn't cover what the Dwyer programs were actually doing in the counties.
Like for us, I'm the actually only full-time individual in the county, and then everybody else is part-time. And then we have one person part-time on Monday and another person three days part-time, and then one two days part-time. And it's all around.
But then when you have a veteran that's in crisis, I'm usually the one that would actually default to that. And then if someone's in crisis at nighttime, I'll be the one that will default to that.
So the burden will actually default to the program managers, anyone in that full-time role, to really do -- you know, interact with someone. Where if we had individuals to really cover a lot of this stuff, it will be a big impact.
SENATOR ASHBY:Yeah.
MR. WALTERS:And a lot of our funds even go to paying for hotel fees and stuff like that. So it's through fundraising that we actually -- that we can pay for a hotel for our veteran.
SENATOR ASHBY:Right.
And when you see how much the Dwyer program has grown over the years and the effectiveness that it's had, you know, at this point, with the division being elevated to an agency, it gives us the opportunity -- more of an opportunity, I believe, to make it a permanent part of the budget. You know, so that way, you know, we don't have to come back and ask for this.
And I think the other programs that Kirby had mentioned, the legal funding -- and reintegration really as a whole, right, we have the opportunity to take, you know, a 50,000-foot-level perspective on this and really mold this.
So I really hope that you're in contact with Director DeCohen on this and some of the other people that made this program -- made this, you know, elevation happen behind the scenes. Because we do have a real opportunity here, and I hope that the Governor hears what you have to say on this.
MR. HANNAN:Senator, you asked if the program is growing, and I believe it is. I don't think we have specific statistics that can point to that.
But women are getting left behind right now because they don't go to the post to engage in peer-to-peer-type activities on a regular basis. So if you're expecting this program to grow, I think you have to take a look at women veterans. They're 17 percent of the veteran population right now, okay?
But hey, you know, I'm part of the veteran population that -- at sixty -- at 79 years old -- trying to give myself a break there -- you know, I got eight years of life expectancy. So what's going to happen to that veteran population? It's going to rise to at least 25 percent women.
And what we need to do now is start to plan so that women veterans have the type of peer-to-peer counseling activities that make sense -- childcare, women's health, all of those things. Because this is just the tip of the iceberg in terms of the changing dynamic.
SENATOR ASHBY:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
One more Senator, Cordell Cleare.
SENATOR CLEARE:My questions were mostly answered.
First of all, thank you so much for your service. Thank you for hanging in there with us today. You get an award, too.
(Laughter.)
SENATOR CLEARE:This is the first one I've ever gotten.
But I just wondered, is there a place where all the posts are compiled? Lists of posts. Are they registered in one place?
MR. HANNAN:Yes.
MR. WALTERS:Yeah.
SENATOR CLEARE:I would like to know all the posts in my district.
MR. HANNAN:That's yet another thing. I'll send you the DVS New York City information. And I'll send -- there are not enough posts in New York City, but I'll send you the posts in New York City.
SENATOR CLEARE:Right. Right.
I'd like to know which ones are there and where the need might be. I'm interested. So thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:So I think the Senate is closed.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Thanks.
So I want to thank you both for being here, sticking with us till the end. And --
MR. WALTERS:Would it be okay if I submit some other information? Because I -- that I've brought to you guys as well on your email?
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:Sure. You know, if you have anything you want to add, you can send -- make sure to send information to myself and Senator Krueger's office, and we will make sure it's distributed to all the members.
In fact, anybody can submit information regarding -- before the hearing ends, people can submit testimony. So we may have some other written materials that have been submitted, but we'll make sure that it's distributed to all of the members of the respective committees.
I want to thank you for the work you do and staying with us till the end of this hearing.
MR. WALTERS:Thank you.
MR. HANNAN:Thank you.
CHAIRWOMAN WEINSTEIN:So the Human Services hearing is now over.
We ask you to join us, if you're listening, and colleagues, tomorrow morning at 9:30, when we will have the Environmental Conservation hearing.
The hearing is adjourned.
CHAIRWOMAN KRUEGER:Thank you.
(Whereupon, the budget hearing concluded at 7:09 p.m.)