Gaveled in 11:14 AM · Albany, New York · 2023–24 session
NEW YORK STATE SENATE
THE STENOGRAPHIC RECORD
ALBANY, NEW YORK
April 17, 2024
11:14 a.m.
REGULAR SESSION
SENATOR SHELLEY B. MAYER, Acting President
ALEJANDRA N. PAULINO, ESQ., Secretary
P R O C E E D I N G SACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The Senate will come to order.
I ask everyone to please rise and recite the Pledge of Allegiance.
(Whereupon, the assemblage recited the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:In the absence of clergy, let us bow our heads in a moment of silent reflection or prayer.
(Whereupon, the assemblage respected a moment of silence.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The reading of the Journal.
THE SECRETARY:In Senate, Tuesday, April 16, 2024, the Senate met pursuant to adjournment. The Journal of Monday, April 15, 2024, was read and approved. On motion, the Senate adjourned.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Without objection, the Journal stands approved as read.
Presentation of petitions.
Messages from the Assembly.
The Secretary will read.
THE SECRETARY:Senator Hinchey moves to discharge, from the Committee on Investigations and Government Operations, Assembly Bill Number 8622 and substitute it for the identical Senate Bill 8334, Third Reading Calendar 710.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:So ordered.
Messages from the Governor.
Reports of standing committees.
Reports of select committees.
Communications and reports from state officers.
Motions and resolutions.
Senator Gianaris.
SENATOR GIANARIS:Good morning, Madam President.
We're going to begin with previously adopted Resolution 2210, by Senator Webb. Please read its title and recognize Senator Webb.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The Secretary will read.
THE SECRETARY:Senate Resolution 2210, by Senator Webb, mourning the death of Billie D. Anderson, a dedicated mother, fierce advocate for justice and civil rights, and distinguished member of her community.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Senator Webb on the resolution.
SENATOR WEBB:Thank you, Madam President.
I rise to lift up the passing of an important leader, not just in my community in the Senate district but also in our state, and that is Billie D. Anderson.
I want to thank my colleagues and also you, Madam President, and of course Senate leadership for supporting this resolution mourning the death of Ms. Anderson. She was a dedicated mother, a very fierce and unapologetic advocate for justice and civil rights. She was a distinguished member of my community. She was a member in the city of Binghamton and passed away last year at the ripe young age of 91.
For 30 years, she worked with one of our local organizations called Opportunities for Broome that helps individuals, families, in getting access to quality affordable housing. She also, through that organization, worked with their Head Start program to improve early education opportunities and quality of life for countless families in my community.
She was a trailblazer, a leader in the civil rights movement. She organized bus trips to Washington, D.C., to right here to the Capitol here in Albany, to fight for equality. She spoke out against racism and inequality in employment, the criminal justice system, education, housing, and so many other important issues.
Over the course of her very distinguished life she lifted up those who are often rendered voiceless, those who are oppressed and strive for a better world.
Ms. Anderson was a community leader and her work was instrumental in vitalizing the Broome Tioga NAACP. She was a woman of indomitable faith, an active member of Trinity AME Zion Church in Binghamton.
However, her greatest passion -- when she wasn't fighting the good fight -- was being a mother to her six children, whom she raised to always stand up for what they believed in.
I am very proud to be voting in favor of this resolution, and I hope my colleagues will join me by voting aye.
Additionally, Madam President, I rise on the occasion of this resolution to welcome distinguished guests to the chamber. I am honored that the family of Billie D. Anderson is here in the gallery with us today. Some of her family members include, but we have a few that are here: Dr. Roxanne Graham, who's her daughter, E. James Anderson, Carl Anderson, Kison Anderson, Warren Carter.
And with that, Madam President, I ask that you welcome the family of Billie D. Anderson to our chamber.
(Applause.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Thank you, Senator Webb.
To the Anderson family, we welcome you on behalf of the Senate. We extend to you the privileges and courtesies of the house.
Please rise and be recognized.
(Standing ovation.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Senator Gianaris.
SENATOR GIANARIS:Next up is previously adopted Resolution 2202, by Senator Helming. Please read that resolution's title and recognize Senator Helming.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The Secretary will read.
THE SECRETARY:Resolution 2202, by Senator Helming, congratulating the Hobart Men's Ice Hockey Team upon the occasion of capturing their second consecutive NCAA Division III Men's Ice Hockey Championship on March 23, 2024.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Senator Helming on the resolution.
SENATOR HELMING:Thank you, Madam President.
It's my honor to welcome to the chamber the Hobart Statesmen Men's Ice Hockey Team, NCAA Division III National Champions for the second year in a row. It was almost one year ago to the day that we honored this team on their 2023 national championship. During my comments I sort of issued a subtle challenge, saying "I can't wait to see what the next season brings." And here we are.
Three weeks ago the top-ranked Statesmen defeated Trinity 2 to nothing. Goalie Damon Beaver was on fire, stopping all 25 shots. Juniors Luka Aquaro and Matthew Iasenza scored for Hobart, with junior Jonah Alexander adding an assist. And Senior Austin Mourar was named the tournament's Most Outstanding Player.
Congratulations to Coach Mark Taylor, who continues to add to his reputation as the most successful hockey coach in Hobart's history. Coach Taylor has guided the Statesmen to a 28-2-1 overall record. He has been named the American Hockey Coaches Association Division III Men's Coach of the Year for the second time. He's been named the 2024 New England Hockey Conference's Coach of the Year and is the 2024 Edward Jeremiah Award winner.
But having the opportunity to speak with Coach Taylor, and knowing him, I imagine the real honor for him is building and mentoring a roster of young men who show great character and are ethical, hardworking team players.
Coach Taylor and the team describe their strength and their special chemistry as Mudita, an extreme joy and pleasure that comes from embracing and delighting in other people's well-being and success.
I got to personally witness this Mudita this morning when this wonderful team, led by their coach, went over to the LOB to engage, to recognize and to honor all of the Honor Flight veterans who are here in the Capitol today. I had chills. It was a wonderful experience for all of those veterans. Thank you very much.
To Coach Taylor and the team, I want you to know that you have made all of us here in the state very, very proud because of your accomplishments on the ice and off the ice.
But you know this. I get to feel it every day back at home. The city of Geneva is still buzzing with excitement because of everything that you continue to do -- again, on and off the ice.
And I'll wrap up with this. And again, no pressure. But will I see you next year?
(Laughter.)
SENATOR HELMING:Three-peat, right?
(Laughter.)
SENATOR HELMING:Congratulations.
Madam President, I am honored to the able to sponsor this resolution and to vote in the affirmative. Thank you.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Thank you, Senator Helming.
Senator Cooney on the resolution.
SENATOR COONEY:Thank you, Madam President.
And thank you, Senator Helming, for bringing forth this resolution. I stand here today as a very proud Hobart alum. And this is just an overwhelming experience for me to be able to stand here on the floor and look up and see the best and brightest from Geneva, New York, here with us today.
Of course let me add my congratulations to the back-to-back NCAA Division III National Hockey Champions. This is just such huge news, not only for Hobart College but for New York State. We should feel proud that we are bringing this cup back to New York year after year.
Of course, you know, I take special pleasure in seeing the final game and making sure that we beat Trinity College -- no offense to any Trinity College alums who may be in the chamber. But they worked hard all season long. And we saw that culminate, culminate, after each -- each game.
Thank you for your hard work, for your commitment. It is very shared. And I'm very confident that we can say that Hobart is the team to beat going forward.
So Coach of the Year Mark Taylor, thank you for your leadership. To all the players and the staff and of course all the fans home across the Finger Lakes region, I want to say thank you and congratulations. We do look forward -- I agree, Senator Helming -- to welcoming you back next year as our three-year-in-a-row champions.
And of course let me say this as a proud Hobart alum: Hip Hobart! And Go, Statesmen!
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Thank you, Senator Cooney.
To our guests, the national ice hockey champions from the Hobart Men's Ice Hockey Team, we welcome you to the Senate. We extend to you the privileges and courtesies of the house. Please rise and be recognized.
(Standing ovation.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The resolution was previously adopted -- both resolutions were previously adopted on April 9th.
Senator Gianaris.
SENATOR GIANARIS:Please take up previously adopted Resolution 1923, by Senator Cleare, read its title, and recognize Senator Cleare.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The Secretary will read.
THE SECRETARY:Resolution 1923, by Senator Cleare, memorializing Governor Kathy Hochul to proclaim April 2024 as Jazz Appreciation Month in the State of New York.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Senator Cleare on the resolution.
SENATOR CLEARE:Thank you.
As the Senator representing Harlem and East Harlem, El Barrio, it is with a great sense of pride that I rise to celebrate Jazz Appreciation Month. Jazz is the quintessential American-born improvisational art form that speaks a universal language that gave singular, resonant, clear and compelling voice to the lives of Black people during the rise of the Harlem Renaissance.
Jazz in many ways evolved from work songs, Black spirituals, blues, brass band music and ragtime, to create something new that was greater than the sum of its parts.
I am proud to represent the 30th Senatorial District where the absolute jazz legends of the Harlem Renaissance lived or worked and/or played, including Louis Armstrong, Duke Ellington, Earl "Fatha" Hines, Cab Calloway, Thelonius Monk, Dizzy Gillespie, Count Basie, "Jelly Roll" Morton, Charlie Parker, Fats Waller, Ella Fitzgerald, Bessie Smith, Ethel Waters, Bill "Bojangles" Robinson, Lena Horne, Billie Holiday, Josephine Baker, and so many more.
These individuals created a collective body of work that has inspired billions of people, given hope, creativity and inspiration to multiple generations, and left a legacy beyond compare.
When I think about jazz in Harlem, I picture all the classic spaces -- the Alhambra Ballroom, The Cotton Club, Count Basie's Lounge, The Lenox Lounge, The Renaissance Ballroom, The Savoy, and Monette's Supper Club. Today the fine tradition of jazz in the 30th is carried on by formidable places like Bill's Place, Minton's Playhouse, Jazz Mobile, Paris Blues, the Apollo Theater, among so many others.
As a State Senator, I've been so proud to help orchestrate annual events such as our John Coltrane Jazz Festival. Due to a number of factors, we were not able to bring a big band that we planned to to Albany this year, but fortunately Jazz Appreciation Month is an annual tradition and one we will build on year after year.
And in the words of the great American trumpeter and composer Wynton Marsalis: "Jazz music is America's past and its potential, summed up and sanctified and accessible to anyone who learns to listen to, feel, and understand it. The music can connect us to our earlier selves and to our better selves-to-come. It can remind us where we fit on the timeline of human achievement, an ultimate value of art."
Thank you, Madam President. Happy Jazz Appreciation Month to one and all.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Thank you, Senator Cleare.
Senator Serrano on the resolution.
SENATOR SERRANO:Thank you very much, Madam President.
And I would like to take the opportunity to thank my colleague Senator Cordell Cleare for bringing forth this resolution celebrating Jazz Appreciation Month.
I have the good fortune of being the chair of the Committee on Arts and Culture, and working with Senator Cleare on issues involving arts and culture is truly a highlight of the work that we do. Her district and my district border one another. East Harlem and Harlem are some of the -- a bit of the epicenter of our cultural world as we know it in New York City.
And the arts and culture really are what make New York New York, when you think about the mecca for culture it has become and what that has meant to the communities in which they are represented.
And jazz in particular, such an important art form that is as much entertainment as it is education. And I think it is intrinsically important that all generations learn about the history of jazz and understand the players and the instruments and the history of jazz, because it is truly the history of New York.
So again, immense gratitude to Senator Cleare for this wonderful resolution, and many thanks to all who support it.
Thank you.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Thank you, Senator Serrano.
Senator Ramos on the resolution.
SENATOR RAMOS:Thank you, Madam President.
You know, we can't celebrate jazz without talking about the Queens Jazz Trail. And in my district we have a very rich history, because in their heyday in Jackson Heights we had Glenn Miller, Benny Goodman, Woody Herman living there. And there was Dizzy Gillespie on 106th Street in Corona. Charlie Shavers lived on 101st Street in Corona. Junior Mance and Jimmy Heath both lived in East Elmhurst.
And of course Satchmo himself, Louis Armstrong, lived on 107th Street, where today we have a beautiful museum and a brand-new education center to welcome students and aspiring musicians, including my favorite trumpet player, my youngest son, Tomás.
So today this is -- being able to celebrate jazz as one of the most quintessential American sounds is really important, I think, especially for people of color. Because whether you're Black or Latino, and knowing that Machito in El Barrio was planting the seeds towards what would become a salsa movement, the Latino response to the Beatles, was really about building our character and our identity and our history in New York City as a whole.
And I don't want to just talk about jazz in the past, because jazz is very much a part of the present. I of course want to reiterate my invitation for folks to visit the Louis Armstrong Museum on 107th Street in Corona. But there's also Terraza 7 on Gleane Street in Elmhurst in my district.
And shout-outs to the staff at the Zinc Bar, Smalls, Mezzrow, Smoke and all of the amazing jazz clubs that make New York City what it is.
Thank you.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Thank you, Senator Ramos.
Senator Sanders on the resolution.
SENATOR SANDERS:Thank you, Madam President.
I want to commend our Senator Cleare for understanding that jazz has to be recognized. It is a force of nature. It's beyond a music; it has become part of the lifestyle, a world unto itself.
You've heard many of the previous speakers speak of jazz and its influence. Of course, Senator Ramos was kind enough to say some of where jazz ended up in Queens. I am still researching my own particular area. It seems that many of these folk made it to Senator Comrie's area. I'm sure they were about to come to mine over time, but --
(Laughter.)
SENATOR SANDERS:-- they enjoyed his district so much that they didn't make it to mine, to my knowledge. But we're still doing the research.
But jazz is more than that. Jazz is -- can be considered American classical music. It's one of the only musics that have been made in America. Every other music can trace its roots to some other place in the world, but this music was made in America and by Americans.
But jazz is more than that. Jazz is part of a lifestyle. It's a culture. It's -- when you think of what's cool, you think of -- you start with jazz musicians for whatever reason. When you try to be cool, the word "cool" itself probably came out of the jazz, the bebop era. It's part of a language. It's part of everything. It's ingrained in the things that we do.
And on my best days, when I'm really -- especially when I'm sitting next to Senator Liu, when I'm at my coolest moment is because of the jazz that the Senator projects into me. So I appreciate that.
(Laughter.)
SENATOR SANDERS:So I close with the words of that immortal philosopher Miles Davis, who told us that if you understand everything that I'm saying, then you'd be me.
(Laughter.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Thank you, Senator Sanders.
Senator Comrie on the resolution.
SENATOR COMRIE:Thank you, Madam President.
I want to compliment Senator Cleare for bringing this resolution forward.
I wasn't going to speak, but since I got mentioned. And my wonderful community, Addisleigh Park, where back in 1923 Clarence Williams was a producer and a pianist, purchased a home in Addisleigh Park. And he convinced a lot of the jazz figures to come. Big names like Billie Holiday, Dizzy Gillespie, Ella Fitzgerald and Count Basie all ended up living in Addisleigh Park, as well as sports heroes as well. Addisleigh Park today now is a historic community as a result of all of the figures that moved there.
So I want to thank Senator Cleare for continuing this resolution, for reminding people that jazz music is American-made music, an American-made product. It had its heyday in the jazz clubs in Harlem. And I hope that we can continue to celebrate jazz and continue to have venues in Harlem.
We don't have venues in Queens that are at that level yet, but we're going to work on that by the reconstruction of downtown Jamaica so we can encourage people to come and listen to music in our communities. We have Greater Jamaica Development Corporation and Jamaica Center for Arts and Culture, and I look forward to jazz events happening there, as well as continuing to make it to Harlem to attend the events there.
As soon as Senator Cleare invites us, we'll all be there to celebrate an event.
Thank you, Madam President.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Thank you, Senator Comrie.
The resolution was previously adopted on March 12th.
Senator Gianaris.
SENATOR GIANARIS:Now on to previously adopted Resolution 2254, by Senator Salazar. Read its title and recognize Senator Salazar, please.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The Secretary shall read.
THE SECRETARY:Resolution 2254, by Senator Salazar, memorializing Governor Kathy Hochul to proclaim April 21-27, 2024, as Crime Victims' Rights Week in the State of New York.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Senator Salazar on the resolution.
SENATOR SALAZAR:Thank you, Madam President.
I rise to introduce this resolution to proclaim next week, starting on April 21st, as Crime Victims' Rights Week in the State of New York. This moment also marks the observance of National Crime Victims' Rights Week as well.
Crime victims and survivors do not fit a stereotype or a single demographic. Victims and survivors look like each and any one of us in this chamber today, and are New Yorkers from all walks of life.
Recognizing this week is an opportunity to emphasize a comprehensive approach to achieving justice and healing in our communities, and in turn preventing further harm in the first place.
Every single person who is victimized by crime in this country deserves to be treated with dignity and compassion. As advocates for victims, particularly of violent crime and gender-based violence, will rightly remind us, there is no such thing as a perfect victim.
I myself have also personally survived violence in my life. Every year an estimated 22 million Americans are directly impacted by crime, and each incident further affects family members, friends, neighbors, and our communities. These experiences often leave lasting physical, psychological, financial impacts on New Yorkers of all ages, of all abilities, of all economic racial and social backgrounds.
In 1984 the federal Victims of Crime Act established the Crime Victims Fund to seek to provide a permanent source of support for crime victim services and compensation. Today thousands of victim assistance programs provide help and support to child victims of violence and sexual abuse, to stalking victims, survivors of homicide, victims of drunk driving crashes, victims of domestic violence, sexual violence, other forms of harm.
Those who do the critical work of victim assistance constantly face new challenges in our efforts to serve all victims and survivors, including people affected by newer crimes such as cyber crimes.
Many survivors also have valid reasons for not always trusting the criminal legal system as a mechanism for justice, due sometimes to a victim's marginalized identity. This includes a victim's immigration status, individuals who may be involved in the sex industry, individuals who are LGBTQ or gender-nonconforming, and New Yorkers who may have been victims of violence by law enforcement or public officers who have abused their trust.
Perhaps most difficult, yet very important for our society to consider, is how often those who have committed crimes were previously victims of crime themselves. Indeed, harm frequently begets further harm. If we are serious about supporting crime victims and protecting our communities, we must break these cycles of violence and harm.
New frameworks and initiatives are being developed to ensure the availability of culturally relevant, trauma-informed and restorative services and treatment to support victims and survivors.
We need to continue to assist communities in maintaining safety for all of us. I'm grateful that my colleagues on the Senate's Crime Victims, Crime and Corrections Committee and colleagues in this chamber are committed to this -- these innovative ways of ensuring that all crime victims and survivors can be supported and empowered to live freely and without fear.
Thank you, Madam President.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Thank you very much, Senator Salazar.
Senator Jackson on the resolution.
SENATOR JACKSON:Thank you, Madam President.
My colleagues, I rise in support of Senate Resolution J2254 -- and I compliment Senator Salazar for bringing this forward -- which addresses the critical issue of Crime Victims Week.
This resolution transcends mere acknowledgment. It embodies a holistic perspective encompassing the diverse needs of all who have endured injustice.
I remember when my younger brother -- we were called, and my mother and I had to go to the hospital because he was the victim of a crime, he got stabbed, and he got stabbed to death. And I remember that so clear even though that was, you know, like 45 years ago. You never, never lose faith of that when you experience anything like that.
So it's about recognizing that the traditional narratives surrounding crime victims often overlook marginalized communities, including immigrants, BIPOC youth, sex workers, LGBTQ+ individuals. These are individuals who for valid reasons may have harbored distrust towards the very systems meant to protect them. And yes, this even includes those who have experienced misconduct at the hands of law enforcement.
Today we have the opportunity to redefine the narrative. We can choose to stand on the side of inclusivity, empathy and understanding. And this resolution calls for culturally relevant assistance, trauma-informed care, and restorative justice options. It acknowledges that healing cannot occur in a vacuum; it requires a comprehensive approach that takes into account the unique experiences and needs of each individual.
Colleagues, this is not just about words on a paper or passing legislation. It's about sending a powerful message, one of solidarity, compassion and hope. It's about reaffirming our commitment to justice for all, regardless of race, gender, sexual orientation or socioeconomic status.
And as we move forward, let us remember the voices that often go unheard, the pain that is often overlooked, and the healing that is long overdue. Let us be champions of change, the advocates for those who have been silenced, and the architects of a brighter, more equitable future.
I proudly support Resolution J2254.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Thank you, Senator Jackson.
The resolution was previously adopted on April 16th.
Senator Gianaris.
SENATOR GIANARIS:Next up is previously adopted Resolution 2074, by Senator Ashby. Please read its title and recognize Senator Ashby.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The Secretary will read.
THE SECRETARY:Resolution 2074, by Senator Ashby, commemorating the 2nd Annual Honor Flight Day in the State of New York.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Senator Ashby on the resolution.
SENATOR ASHBY:Thank you, Madam President.
I'm proud to stand today and commemorate the Second Annual Honor Flight Day in the State of New York. We hosted earlier today veterans from World War II, the Korean War, the Vietnam War.
And while the Honor Flights started out as focusing on bringing our World War II veterans down to our nation's capital to experience the memorials and commemorate their service, it's now expanded to other wars such as the Korean War and the Vietnam War, which I think are imperative to show our respect and resolve for what we failed to do earlier on with our Vietnam veterans.
And I can tell you firsthand that this act has done amazing things for these veterans and their families. Five thousand veterans, over 5,000 veterans just alone from the State of New York, have experienced this free of charge. And for those who've served as escorts on this, I can tell you that they get just as much out of this experience serving as an escort, helping and ushering our nation's heroes down to our nation's capital -- who are welcomed as heroes each step of the way.
So I'm very proud that we are commemorating again the Second Annual Honor Flight Day in the State of New York, and I look forward to doing it again.
Thank you.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Thank you, Senator Ashby.
The resolution was previously adopted on April 3rd.
Senator Gianaris.
SENATOR GIANARIS:Now on to the highly anticipated previously adopted Resolution 2121, by Senator Gounardes. Please read that resolution's title and recognize Senator Gounardes.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The Secretary will read.
THE SECRETARY:Resolution 2121, by Senator Gounardes, memorializing Governor Kathy Hochul to recognize April 20, 2024, in honor of the 247th Anniversary of the adoption of the first New York State Constitution.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Senator Gounardes on the resolution.
SENATOR GOUNARDES:Thank you, Madam President.
My colleagues, this Saturday is New York's 247th birthday. That's right: On April 20, 1777, the State of New York ratified our first constitution after we declared independence in 1776.
And as I have for several years now, I look forward to this day to talk about a chapter of our state's constitutional history that not only do I find interesting, but that is relevant to the work that we do here in this chamber. And this year is no different.
Now, we all know that one of Albany's favorite parlor games is to shake our fists at the clouds and lament how much power the Governor has in the budget process. But did you know that it was not always this way? It was not until 1927 that the Constitution was amended to include the Article VII budget process known as the Executive Budget. Before that, before 1927, the Legislature had the power of the purse.
So, ladies and gentlemen, gather round and hear/the tale of how our state did persevere./Through trials and tribulations we did find/a way to reform our budget so refined.
Our story begins with the Constitutional Convention of 1915, the zenith of the reform movement that was taking hold across the country in the wake of the Progressive Era that defined American politics from the 1890s to the 1920s. The goal of that convention was to modernize state government and create the architecture for the administrative state.
During the prior century the size and scope of state government was relatively small, so it didn't matter much if the Legislature appropriated a thousand dollars for this, $2,000 for that -- which at that time was still a lot of money. But as the state grew in population and also in revenue, it became painfully obvious that a better system was necessary.
Between 1885 and 1914 the Legislature approved expenditures that increased spending by 600 percent over that 30-year period, while revenue only grew by 274 percent. During the 1915 convention, a proposal was adopted to centralize the budget process in the executive branch and provide a framework for financial planning.
As Henry Stimson, the future Secretary of State and Secretary of War and the chairman of the Constitutional Convention's Committee on State Finances, Revenues and Expenditures -- really a great committee -- explained: "The United States is substantially the only civilized country where, in both its national and state governments, a scientific budget system is unknown.
"No financial plan is presented to our legislature in public each year by men who are responsible for the conduct of government. No considered estimates of the future, no material whatsoever for comparison with the past is presented by our executives to the legislature in such a way that the body and the public can understand them and hold spenders of our public money responsible.
"Instead, our appropriation and revenue bills are made up in the comparative secrecy of legislative committees and rushed through the final days of a legislative session."
Now, there were six primary reasons why reform was so needed and why the Legislature was not the appropriate branch of government to control the purse strings for the state.
First, there was no centralized process to actually determine how much money each department, division and office under state government needed to carry out its work. There was a state law passed in 1910 that required the Comptroller to collect information from every department about what they needed to operate, but the Comptroller had no ability to evaluate or revise what those proposals were.
In practice, what that meant was every state government entity treated this process as a way to compile their wish list for more money, without even needing to justify what they wanted to spend their money on.
Secondly, the Legislature as an institution was simply not well structured to control the state's financial planning. Our purpose was to legislate. We had no administrative control over the offices of state government and therefore no ability to directly manage the administrative state.
Additionally, as we all well know, crafting a budget is a delicate balance of advocating statewide spending priorities while making sure that we can bring home enough bacon for our local districts. The track record of the Legislature up to that point showed that the expenditures were approved based on the needs solely of individual members rather than the needs of the state as a whole.
Thirdly, there was no process laid out anywhere, either in the Legislature or with some outside authority, for a financial plan that measured expenses against projected revenues. This defect was incredibly problematic, as the Legislature routinely authorized spending that far exceeded the available budget to pay for it. In fact, in 1914 the Legislature had to gavel back into special session to consider authorizing a tax of $18 million, which at that time represented 30 percent of the state's revenue for that whole year, just to cover a structural deficit.
Fourthly, the Legislature routinely used the appropriations process to engage in logrolling. You know, that trading favors back and forth to try to buy people's votes and win influence.
And to make matters worse, the Legislature would frequently pass stand-alone bills to appropriate money even outside of its own internal appropriations process. In 1915 alone, the Legislature passed 17 -- I guess you'd call them supplemental appropriations bills as local favors for individual members -- a bridge in Waterloo, a foot bridge in Seneca Falls, a school in Potsdam, a canal bridge in Yorkville, a new paved road in Lockport, and even the reimbursement to a private citizen for a personal expense he made to fix a local waterway -- just to name a couple of examples.
Fifth, as the size of the budget grew and grew, it became more difficult for the Legislature even to pretend to manage its finances responsibly. Partly out of complexity of the size of the budget, but partly out of political considerations, the Legislature would authorize expenses that they knew were ridiculously high but they expected the Governor to use his discretion to administratively reduce how much would actually be spent for any given purpose.
This allowed individual legislators to score a political win by securing passage of an appropriation that benefited their own parochial interests, all while knowing that the money might never actually be spent. In some way that's not unlike our own one-house budget process, right, where we all put our biggest budget hopes and dreams forward, only to see them get whittled down by the end of the day.
And the last major defect of the status quo was simply the lack of transparency. The appropriations bills were drafted solely by the respective financial chairpersons in each chamber. As one delegate to the Constitutional Convention complained, "At the present time the work is carried on in quiet by the chairmen of the two finance committees. The legislature knows nothing about it, the people know nothing about it, the press know nothing about it until the report of the committee nears the close of the session. Then there is scant time for deliberation, and it's too late to criticize and do it all over again."
Now, the 1915 convention proposed replacing this chaotic system with something more professional and orderly -- a centralized process where financial estimates for the necessary operation of the various departments of state government were put together alongside a financial plan that detailed the projected incoming revenue the state could authorize to spend.
Importantly, this centralized authority was to be given to the Governor, because the Governor had the constitutional duty to enforce the laws of the state and, functionally speaking, the expense of state funds through various state departments was how a great deal of those laws were to be put into effect.
Now, although the convention ultimately adopted the Executive Budget amendment, the debate was wild -- and believe you me, I spent hours reading through these transcripts, and it was wild -- and generated strong opposition from delegates to the convention who were also members of the Legislature.
One delegate, who we can confidently say deserves an award for legislative hyperbole, asserted: "The legislature is being destroyed. And if it is being destroyed, I want to be the old Cato that calls attention to it, that stern old Cato that calls attention to the fact that the power of the direct representatives of the people of the state is being gradually taken away and is being tucked off down in the corner of the second story of the building here." As we all know, our second floor.
Nevertheless, led by the leader of the Progressive Reform Movement, Assemblymember and future Governor Al Smith, the convention passed the amendment and sent the proposal to the people for a public referendum, along with several other proposed amendments. And then the public voted against it.
So although the amendment failed to garner public ratification, the push for budget reform continued. In 1916, Governor Charles Whitman sought to consolidate all of the budget requests from state agencies and then held a series of public hearings around the state about the budget before submitting a tentative spending plan for the Legislature's consideration.
And although this effort won him considerable praise from the press and New York's reform leaders, the Legislature was simply not impressed, arguing that the Governor's actions would only confuse the public, who were accustomed to the Legislature having direct control of the budget.
However, in a sign of how the tide was starting to turn, the Legislature that year managed to adopt a budget which, as it turned out, was very similar to what Governor Whitman originally proposed.
The following year, our Legislature adopted the Sage-Meyer Act, which proposed some modest budget reforms but cemented the authority for the budget process firmly with the legislative branch. The Sage-Meyer Act gave clear responsibility to the financial committees in each chamber to lead the budget drafting process, allowed each committee to hire full-time budget staff for the first time, and importantly authorized the Governor to submit to the Legislature a suggested budget for the Legislature's consideration.
Despite this progress, by 1920 that process fell apart and the Legislature went back to routinely ignoring the Sage-Meyer Act, the very law that they passed themselves, and disregarding the Governor's input.
With the election of Governor Al Smith, however, the reform effort took on new life, and Smith committed himself to see through the reforms that he helped propose a decade earlier.
Finally, in 1927, under the threat of Smith calling the Legislature into special session every day until they acquiesced to budget reform, the Legislature approved a constitutional amendment formalizing the Executive Budget process, along with legislation to hire full-time executive staff to manage the state's finances, which created the Division of Budget.
The amendment was ratified by the public a year later. And in 1929, New York State adopted its first Executive Budget. With the adoption of Article VII to the Constitution, New York became one of the first states -- and still to this day one of only a handful of states -- to enshrine a formal budget process in its state constitution.
Now, throughout the years, Article VII has been modified slightly, but at its core it remains the same -- a process for the financial management of the state's affairs that is anchored firmly in the executive branch.
And so, my colleagues, as we sit here today waiting to finish this year's budget, just know that things used to be very, very different. And arguably, from the Governor's perspective, maybe a little worse. The State Budget was anything but an actual budget, and it took years and years before the winds of change brought about actual reform.
Now, you might be wondering -- I haven't even touched on Silver v. Pataki, which I know brings often more ire from those of us in this chamber at the budget process. But that will have to wait for another Constitution Day.
So with that, Madam President, I say Happy Birthday, New York. Happy Constitution Day. And I vote aye.
Thank you.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Thank you, Senator Gounardes.
Senator Krueger.
(Applause.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Senator Krueger on the resolution.
SENATOR KRUEGER:I just want to thank Senator Gounardes for his tutorial on the history of New York and the importance of the Constitution and what gets done or not done when we have the right and wrong things in our Constitution.
I've also been thinking about the fact that in three years it will be the 250th anniversary of our great state, and clearly we need to do something momentous in celebration of the 250th anniversary. So maybe we need to change our Constitution specific to budget powers in honor of the 250th anniversary. And it's really about time we start on that, because it takes about three years minimum to bring a vote to the public about constitutional changes.
So it's not necessarily an amendment to his resolution, but I think it's an excellent discussion for those of us interested in this to start focusing on.
I'm delighted to be added to the this resolution, if he will allow me to add my name at some point.
Thank you very much.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Thank you, Senator Krueger.
Senator Borrello on the resolution.
SENATOR BORRELLO:Thank you, Madam President.
As usual, I was riveted by the words of Senator Gounardes on his Constitution Day speech.
But I was particularly interested to hear about the history of more than 100 years ago where the politicians asked for more than they thought was realistic, where there were deals made behind closed doors and it was a non-transparent, completely opaque process.
I'm so glad that here in 2024 we don't live in a state like that anymore.
So Happy Constitution Day.
Thank you.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Thank you, Senator Borrello.
Senator Fernandez on the resolution.
SENATOR FERNANDEZ:Thank you, Madam President.
And yes, Happy Constitution Day. Thank you, Senator Gounardes, for that very -- very, very good, comprehensive history lesson.
And to Senator Krueger, I agree, we do need to do something. And we can do something, because I have a bill for that.
So if you'd like to see this momentum pick up, as I would too -- and I hope that my other colleagues do as well -- know that we have a bill, S2062, Protecting the People's Budget, and that momentum can start today. So let me know.
But thank you so much. Happy Constitution Day. Happy Birthday, New York. And let's go, New York!
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The resolution was previously adopted on April 9th.
Senator Gianaris.
SENATOR GIANARIS:Madam President, the various resolution sponsors, and especially Senator Gounardes, want to open these up for cosponsorship.
(Laughter.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The resolutions are open for cosponsorship. Should you choose not to be a cosponsor, please notify the desk.
Senator Gianaris.
SENATOR GIANARIS:Please take up the calendar.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The Secretary will read.
THE SECRETARY:Calendar Number 214, Senate Print 1199B, by Senator Parker, an act to amend the Public Service Law.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Read the last section.
THE SECRETARY:Section 2. This act shall take effect on the 30th day after it shall have become a law.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Call the roll.
(The Secretary called the roll.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Announce the results.
THE SECRETARY:Ayes, 59.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The bill is passed.
THE SECRETARY:Calendar Number 275, Senate Print 791A, by Senator Comrie, an act to amend the New York State Urban Development Corporation Act.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Read the last section.
THE SECRETARY:Section 5. This act shall take effect immediately.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Call the roll.
(The Secretary called the roll.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Announce the results.
THE SECRETARY:In relation to Calendar 275, those Senators voting in the negative are Senators Oberacker, O'Mara, Ortt, Palumbo, Stec and Weik.
Ayes, 53. Nays, 6.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The bill is passed.
THE SECRETARY:Calendar Number 365, Senate Print 308, by Senator Salazar, an act to amend the Correction Law.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Read the last section.
THE SECRETARY:Section 2. This act shall take effect immediately.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Call the roll.
(The Secretary called the roll.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Announce the results.
THE SECRETARY:In relation to Calendar 365, those Senators voting in the negative are Senators Ashby, Borrello, Canzoneri-Fitzpatrick, Griffo, Helming, Lanza, Martins, Mattera, Oberacker, O'Mara, Ortt, Palumbo, Rhoads, Stec, Tedisco, Weber and Weik.
Ayes, 42. Nays, 17.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The bill is passed.
THE SECRETARY:Calendar Number 471, Senate Print 8576, by Senator Martinez, an act in relation to authorizing the Church of the Living God Pillar & Ground to file an application for exemption from real property taxes.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Read the last section.
THE SECRETARY:Section 2. This act shall take effect immediately.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Call the roll.
(The Secretary called the roll.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Announce the results.
THE SECRETARY:In relation to Calendar 471, voting in the negative: Senator O'Mara.
Ayes, 58. Nays, 1.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The bill is passed.
THE SECRETARY:Calendar Number 520, Senate Print 280, by Senator Gounardes, an act to amend the Executive Law.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Read the last section.
THE SECRETARY:Section 2. This act shall take effect immediately.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Call the roll.
(The Secretary called the roll.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Announce the results.
THE SECRETARY:Ayes, 59.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The bill is passed.
THE SECRETARY:Calendar Number 522, Senate Print 3260, by Senator Hoylman-Sigal, an act to amend the Estates, Powers and Trusts Law.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Read the last section.
THE SECRETARY:Section 2. This act shall take effect immediately.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Call the roll.
(The Secretary called the roll.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Announce the results.
THE SECRETARY:In relation to Calendar 522, those Senators voting in the negative are Senators Martins, Rhoads and Weik.
Ayes, 56. Nays, 3.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The bill is passed.
THE SECRETARY:Calendar Number 580, Senate Print 4036, by Senator Mannion, an act to amend the General Business Law.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Read the last section.
THE SECRETARY:Section 3. This act shall take effect immediately.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Call the roll.
(The Secretary called the roll.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Announce the results.
THE SECRETARY:Ayes, 59.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The bill is passed.
THE SECRETARY:Calendar Number 702, Senate Print 6646, by Senator Ramos, an act to amend the Labor Law.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Read the last section.
THE SECRETARY:Section 2. This act shall take effect immediately.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Call the roll.
(The Secretary called the roll.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Senator Ramos to explain her vote.
SENATOR RAMOS:Thank you, Madam President.
You know, in Gothamist this past Monday we learned that Cornell University's School of Industrial and Labor Relations designed a new tool called the Wage Atlas Tool that tracks the cost of living and the depth of poverty in New York State. The tool actually showed that only half of New Yorkers right now are earning a living wage.
And as you might recall, last year we raised and indexed the minimum wage. And we know it didn't go far enough to end the scourge of poverty in New York State that's pushing families out of our state and compromising our safety.
Yearly rises in inflation have decreased the value of the minimum wage over time, meaning that the value of a paycheck can't stretch to cover the basics the way it should.
Factor in the sheer scale of wage theft in our state that's estimated at about $3.2 billion -- and $50 billion nationwide -- and we begin to understand the scale of that problem.
We raised the minimum -- I'm sorry, we saw the minimum wage go up to $15 a few years ago, and New York City actually saw a sharp decline in crime rates. So instead of finding new ways to punish and criminalize poor people, we can make ourselves safer by lifting from the bottom.
With the current budget that we're trying to negotiate, our Governor seems to be much more concerned with punishing people who have been driven to desperation by poverty rather than the thieves at the top who keep people poor.
As a Legislature, we need to see the numbers, and that's what this bill is about. With this bill the cost of living is going to be measured and analyzed utilizing many available cost-of-living measures, and the data will be disaggregated by race, ethnicity, gender, age, disability status, household size, and education level for each of the four regions in our state.
The state has an obligation to ensure that the Legislature has access to accurate data on the cost of living and the adequacy of the current minimum wage. This bill is going to ensure that we actually fulfill that obligation, and I vote aye.
Thank you.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Senator Ramos to be recorded in the affirmative.
Announce the results.
THE SECRETARY:In relation to Calendar 702, those Senators voting in the negative are Senators Borrello, Canzoneri-Fitzpatrick, Griffo, Helming, Oberacker, O'Mara, Rhoads, Stec, Weber and Weik.
Ayes, 49. Nays, 10.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The bill is passed.
THE SECRETARY:Calendar Number 710, Assembly Print Number 8622, by Assemblymember Barrett, an act to amend the Public Officers Law.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Read the last section.
THE SECRETARY:Section 2. This act shall take effect immediately.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Call the roll.
(The Secretary called the roll.)
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:Announce the results.
THE SECRETARY:Ayes, 59.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:The bill is passed.
Senator Gianaris, that completes the reading of today's calendar.
SENATOR GIANARIS:Is there any further business at the desk?
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:There is no further business at the desk.
SENATOR GIANARIS:Let me remind my Majority colleagues we are moving immediately to a continuation of conference.
And with that, I move to adjourn until tomorrow, April 18th, at 11:00 a.m.
ACTING PRESIDENT MAYER:On motion, the Senate stands adjourned until April 18th at 11:00 a.m.
(Whereupon, at 12:08 p.m., the Senate adjourned.)
Highest impact first.
Set Utility Payment Plan Rules
Cap Rental Car Fuel Fees
Let ADAs Live Nearby
Ease Residency for ADA Jobs
Expand Notice for Public Hearings
Track Temporary Release Data
Update Spouse Disqualification Rules
Report on Minimum Wage Adequacy