Skip to content
S9967Senate2025-2026 SessionSame asA11463

Open PSC Decisions to Public

Official title

“Allows issues before the public service commission to be determined publicly rather than through settlement discussions not open to the public”

Sponsor Leroy ComrieSD-14+1 co-sponsorAffects Environment & Energy
Status
In Senate Committee
Energy And Telecommunications
Impact
7/10
Significant
Passage
20%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Energy And Telecommunications

What's happening

This bill lets parties in utility rate cases require important issues be decided publicly, not in closed settlements.

Why it matters

  1. Impacts all utility customers statewide. by changing how rate cases are decided at the Public Service Commission (PSC), making sure that major issues—like proposed rate increases or service changes—can be debated in open hearings instead of being resolved behind closed doors in private settlements.

  2. Empowers non-utility parties. (such as consumer advocates, municipalities, or environmental groups) to ensure their concerns are fully aired publicly if those issues were detailed in their official testimony, increasing transparency and potentially leading to more balanced outcomes for everyday New Yorkers.

  3. Introduces a new, formal process. for separating (“severing”) key issues from private settlements, including defined timelines for motions, responses, and appeals, which could slow down some settlements but will make the decision-making process more accessible and understandable to the public.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Consumer Advocacy Groups and Public Interest Organizations

  • These groups often participate in rate proceedings to advocate for fair pricing and transparency. The bill gives them more power to ensure key issues they raise—such as affordability, service quality, or environmental impact—cannot be quietly settled without public scrutiny.

  • Utilities and Regulated Companies

  • Electric, gas, water, and telecommunications utilities subject to Public Service Commission oversight will face new procedural hurdles and potential public litigation on issues they’d prefer to resolve confidentially, impacting their regulatory strategy and risk profile.

  • Independent Intervenors (e.g., Large Customers, Municipalities, Business Coalitions)

  • Entities with specific interests in rate cases now have a mechanism to force certain issues into the public record and litigation, rather than being compelled to accept private settlements that may not reflect their concerns.

  • Administrative Law Judges and Public Service Commission Staff

  • These officials will have new responsibilities to adjudicate motions to sever issues from settlement, manage additional procedural steps, and handle potential increases in litigated matters, affecting their workload and the overall transparency of commission proceedings.

Headline styles

Open PSC Decisions to Public

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Leroy Comrie

Senator · Senate District 14

Chair, Corporations, Authorities And Commissions

1 Co-sponsor

History

  1. Referred to energy and telecommunications

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A11463Assembly

Make Utility Decisions Public

In Assembly Committee · Corporations, Authorities And Commissions · Sponsor Edward Braunstein

Impact 7 · Significant34% to pass

Full text

4 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9967

IN SENATE

April 20, 2026

Introduced by Sen. COMRIE -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Energy and Telecommunications

AN ACT to amend the public service law, in relation to allowing issues before the public service commission to be determined publicly rather than through settlement discussions not open to the public

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Section 66 of the public service law is amended by adding a new subdivision 33 to read as follows:

33. (a) In any rate proceeding, any party may seek to sever from consideration in the settlement process or inclusion in any joint proposal any substantive issue that it discussed in its direct testimony through a motion to the presiding administrative law judge that is filed no later than ten days after the last permitted date for the filing of reply testimony by parties. Such motion shall indicate the substantive issue or issues for which the moving party seeks severance and the related page numbers in the moving party's testimony. Parties may file responsive motions within ten days supporting or challenging the moving party's assertion that it developed the identified substantive issue or issues in its direct testimony. The presiding administrative law judge shall issue a written ruling within fifteen days after the filing of responses that provides the reasons for concluding that the moving party did or did not provide a substantive issue or substantive issues in its testimony. The moving party may appeal the administrative law judge's decision to the commission through a request for interlocutory review pursuant to the department's rules.

(b) Upon the granting of the motion by the administrative law judge, or of the request for interlocutory review by the commission, the identified substantive issue or issues may be discussed in settlement negotiations during the first sixty days after the formal commencement of settlement negotiations. After sixty days have elapsed, disposition of the substantive issues or issues shall be subject to the litigation process only unless the moving party advises the parties, administrative

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD15291-01-6

law judge, and commission in writing that it waives its right to sever the identified substantive issue or issues from the settlement process and agrees to allow discussion of such issues in settlement negotiations and potential inclusion in a joint proposal. Waiving the right to sever does not preclude the moving party from objecting to any provision included in a filed joint proposal.

(c) As used in this subdivision, the following terms shall have the following meanings:

(i) "Joint proposal" shall mean a negotiated settlement agreement signed by two or more parties in a rate proceeding.

(ii) "Interlocutory review" shall mean a motion to the commission requesting review of a ruling by an administrative law judge.

(iii) The "moving party" shall mean the party who seeks severance of an issue or issues under this subdivision.

(iv) "Party" shall mean any party to a commission rate proceeding other than the department or the utility.

(v) "Settlement process" shall mean a set of formal negotiations of the parties organized by the department that is intended to resolve all or some of the issues in any rate proceeding and lead to a joint proposal.

(vi) "Substantive issue" shall mean an issue in which testimony by a moving party contains allegations of facts or law, which, after further development through the litigation process, including evidentiary hearings, interrogatories or discovery, may be material to the resolution of the issue in the recommended decision or final order. The intent of this definition is to permit any allegation of fact with any evidentiary support or legal claim to meet this standard; where the issue concerns at least in part a factual allegation, only conclusory assertions of fact without any evidentiary support in the moving party's testimony are not substantive.

§ 2. Section 80 of the public service law is amended by adding a new subdivision 13 to read as follows:

13. (a) In any rate proceeding, any party may seek to sever from consideration in the settlement process or inclusion in any joint proposal any substantive issue that it discussed in its direct testimony through a motion to the presiding administrative law judge that is filed no later than ten days after the last permitted date for the filing of reply testimony by parties. Such motion shall indicate the substantive issue or issues for which the moving party seeks severance and the related page numbers in the moving party's testimony. Parties may file responsive motions within ten days supporting or challenging the moving party's assertion that it developed the identified substantive issue or issues in its direct testimony. The presiding administrative law judge shall issue a written ruling within fifteen days after the filing of responses that provides the reasons for concluding that the moving party did or did not provide a substantive issue or substantive issues in its testimony. The moving party may appeal the administrative law judge's decision to the commission through a request for interlocutory review pursuant to the department's rules.

(b) Upon the granting of the motion by the administrative law judge, or of the request for interlocutory review by the commission, the identified substantive issue or issues may be discussed in settlement negotiations during the first sixty days after the formal commencement of settlement negotiations. After sixty days have elapsed, disposition of the substantive issues or issues shall be subject to the litigation process only unless the moving party advises the parties, administrative law judge, and commission in writing that it waives its right to sever the identified substantive issue or issues from the settlement process and agrees to allow discussion of such issues in settlement negotiations and potential inclusion in a joint proposal. Waiving the right to sever does not preclude the moving party from objecting to any provision included in a filed joint proposal.

(c) As used in this subdivision, the following terms shall have the following meanings:

(i) "Joint proposal" shall mean a negotiated settlement agreement signed by two or more parties in a rate proceeding.

(ii) "Interlocutory review" shall mean a motion to the commission requesting review of a ruling by an administrative law judge.

(iii) The "moving party" shall mean the party who seeks severance of an issue or issues under this subdivision.

(iv) "Party" shall mean any party to a commission rate proceeding other than the department or the utility.

(v) "Settlement process" shall mean a set of formal negotiations of the parties organized by the department that is intended to resolve all or some of the issues in any rate proceeding and lead to a joint proposal.

(vi) "Substantive issue" shall mean an issue in which testimony by a moving party contains allegations of facts or law, which, after further development through the litigation process, including evidentiary hearings, interrogatories or discovery, may be material to the resolution of the issue in the recommended decision or final order. The intent of this definition is to permit any allegation of fact with any evidentiary support or legal claim to meet this standard; where the issue concerns at least in part a factual allegation, only conclusory assertions of fact without any evidentiary support in the moving party's testimony are not substantive.

§ 3. Section 89-c of the public service law is amended by adding a new subdivision 18 to read as follows:

18. (a) In any rate proceeding, any party may seek to sever from consideration in the settlement process or inclusion in any joint proposal any substantive issue that it discussed in its direct testimony through a motion to the presiding administrative law judge that is filed no later than ten days after the last permitted date for the filing of reply testimony by parties. Such motion shall indicate the substantive issue or issues for which the moving party seeks severance and the related page numbers in the moving party's testimony. Parties may file responsive motions within ten days supporting or challenging the moving party's assertion that it developed the identified substantive issue or issues in its direct testimony. The presiding administrative law judge shall issue a written ruling within fifteen days after the filing of responses that provides the reasons for concluding that the moving party did or did not provide a substantive issue or substantive issues in its testimony. The moving party may appeal the administrative law judge's decision to the commission through a request for interlocutory review pursuant to the department's rules.

(b) Upon the granting of the motion by the administrative law judge, or of the request for interlocutory review by the commission, the identified substantive issue or issues may be discussed in settlement negotiations during the first sixty days after the formal commencement of settlement negotiations. After sixty days have elapsed, disposition of the substantive issues or issues shall be subject to the litigation process only unless the moving party advises the parties, administrative law judge, and commission in writing that it waives its right to sever the identified substantive issue or issues from the settlement process and agrees to allow discussion of such issues in settlement negotiations and potential inclusion in a joint proposal. Waiving the right to sever does not preclude the moving party from objecting to any provision included in a filed joint proposal.

(c) As used in this subdivision, the following terms shall have the following meanings:

(i) "Joint proposal" shall mean a negotiated settlement agreement signed by two or more parties in a rate proceeding.

(ii) "Interlocutory review" shall mean a motion to the commission requesting review of a ruling by an administrative law judge.

(iii) The "moving party" shall mean the party who seeks severance of an issue or issues under this subdivision.

(iv) "Party" shall mean any party to a commission rate proceeding other than the department or the utility.

(v) "Settlement process" shall mean a set of formal negotiations of the parties organized by the department that is intended to resolve all or some of the issues in any rate proceeding and lead to a joint proposal.

(vi) "Substantive issue" shall mean an issue in which testimony by a moving party contains allegations of facts or law, which, after further development through the litigation process, including evidentiary hearings, interrogatories or discovery, may be material to the resolution of the issue in the recommended decision or final order. The intent of this definition is to permit any allegation of fact with any evidentiary support or legal claim to meet this standard; where the issue concerns at least in part a factual allegation, only conclusory assertions of fact without any evidentiary support in the moving party's testimony are not substantive.

§ 4. This act shall take effect on the one hundred twentieth day after it shall have become a law, and shall apply to public service commission proceedings initiated on or after such date. Effective immediately, the addition, amendment and/or repeal of any rule or regulation necessary for the implementation of this act on its effective date are authorized to be made and completed on or before such effective date.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the public service law, in relation to allowing issues before the public service commission to be determined publicly rather than through settlement discussions not open to the public

Purpose

To enhance transparency, fairness, and public accountability in Public Service Commission (PSC) rate proceedings by allowing parties to require that substantive issues be resolved through the public litigation proc- ess rather than private settlement negotiations.

Summary of provisions

This bill amends sections 66, 80, and 89-c of the public service law by adding new subdivisions that establish a process by which parties may sever substantive issues from settlement negotiations in rate proceedings.

Defines key terms, including "joint proposal," "settlement process," "interlocutory review," "party," "moving party," and "substantive issue," ensuring clarity in application; Any party may file a motion to sever a substantive issue it raised in its direct testimony from the settlement process, within ten days after the filing of reply testimony; The motion must identify the issue(s) and corresponding portions of testimony supporting the request; Other parties may respond within ten days, either supporting or opposing the motion; The presiding adminis- trative law judge (ALJ) must issue a written determination within fifteen days, explaining whether the issue qualifies as a substantive issue; The moving party may seek interlocutory review by the Commission of the ALJ's determination.

Upon approval of a severance motion: The identified issue(s) may be discussed in settlement negotiations only during the first sixty days after settlement discussions formally commence. After sixty days, the issue(s) must be resolved exclusively through the litigation process, including evidentiary hearings and discovery, unless the moving party affirmatively waives its right to sever; A waiver of severance does not limit a party's ability to object to provisions in any resulting joint proposal.

The act takes effect 120 days after becoming law and applies to PSC proceedings initiated thereafter.

Justification

While settlement negotiations are an important tool in resolving complex PSC rate cases, they are typically conducted outside of public view and may limit transparency into how key decisions affecting utility rates and services are made. As a result, critical issues with significant consumer impact may be resolved through private negotiation rather than through a fully developed public record, which often does not incorpo- rate the due diligence required to protect consumers.

This legislation preserves the benefits of settlement while restoring balance by ensuring that parties retain the right to have substantive issues adjudicated through an open and transparent process. By allowing parties to sever issues they have meaningfully developed in testimony, the bill ensures that such matters can be fully examined through discov- ery, evidentiary hearings, and public Commission review.

The bill also introduces clear procedural timelines and standards to prevent abuse of the severance process and to maintain efficiency in proceedings. The limited 60-day window for settlement discussion of severed issues encourages early resolution while ensuring that unre- solved matters are ultimately subject to public adjudication.

By strengthening procedural fairness and increasing transparency, this legislation promotes greater public confidence in the PSC's decision- making and helps ensure that outcomes are based on a complete and acces- sible evidentiary record.

Legislative history

This is a new bill.

Fiscal implications

None.

Effective date

This act shall take effect on the one hundred twentieth day after it shall have become law and shall apply to PSC proceedings initiated on or after such date. Necessary rulemaking is authorized prior to the effec- tive date.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.