What's happening
This bill allows non-parties to appeal certain criminal court orders denying motions to quash subpoenas based on privilege claims.
Why it matters
Empowers non-parties (such as journalists, doctors, or others holding privileged information) to challenge court orders compelling them to disclose sensitive records or testify, without having to risk contempt of court to obtain appellate review.
Creates a clear, expedited path for appeals when privilege, immunity from disclosure, or other protected status is claimed, offering stronger protection for confidential sources, patient records, attorney-client communications, and other sensitive data.
Requires reasonable notice to all parties and ensures that appeals and requests for stays are handled promptly, balancing the need for swift criminal proceedings with the rights of non-parties to protect privileged information.
Specifically excludes grand jury subpoenas from these new appeal rights, maintaining the secrecy and efficiency of grand jury investigations while enhancing protections in other criminal court contexts.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Allow Non-Parties to Appeal
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
No co-sponsors yet.
History
- Reported and committed to finance
- Referred to codes
- Referred to codes
Full text
2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
37
2021-2022 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE (Prefiled)
January 6, 2021
Introduced by Sen. HOYLMAN -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Codes
AN ACT to amend the criminal procedure law, in relation to establishing provisions for appeals by a non-party to an intermediate appellate court
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. The criminal procedure law is amended by adding a new section 450.25 to read as follows: § 450.25 Appeal by non-party to intermediate appellate court; in what
cases authorized.
An appeal directly to the intermediate appellate court may be taken as of right by a non-party from the following orders of a criminal court:
1. An order of a criminal court denying a non-party's motion to quash a subpoena duces tecum on the grounds that the movant is protected from compelled production by claim of privilege, immunity from disclosure, or any other constitutional, common law, or statutory privilege, including those set forth under article forty-five or subdivision (c) of section thirty-one hundred one of the civil practice law and rules and section seventy-nine-h of the civil rights law.
2. An order denying a motion to quash a subpoena ad testificandum on the grounds that the movant is protected from compelled testimony by claim of privilege, immunity from disclosure, or any other constitutional, common law, or statutory privilege, including those set forth under article forty-five or subdivision (c) of section thirty-one hundred one of the civil practice law and rules and section seventynine-h of the civil rights law.
3. An appeal taken pursuant to subdivision one or two of this section shall be expeditiously filed, heard and determined in accordance with the rules of the appellate division of the department in which such
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD02382-01-1
S. 37 2
intermediate appellate court is located. Such appeal may be taken only upon reasonable notice to the parties to the action or proceeding who shall have an opportunity to be heard thereon.
4. The appellate division of each judicial department shall adopt rules for providing notice to the parties pursuant to subdivisions one and two of this section, and for the expeditious filing, briefing, hearing, and determination of appeals under this section.
5. This section shall not apply where the subpoena that is the subject of the motion to quash relates to a grand jury proceeding.
§ 2. The opening paragraph of section 450.60 of the criminal procedure law is amended to read as follows:
The particular intermediate appellate courts to which appeals authorized by sections 450.10 [and], 450.20 and 450.25 must be taken are as follows:
§ 3. Section 460.10 of the criminal procedure law is amended by adding a new subdivision 4-a to read as follows:
4-a. An appeal by a non-party to an intermediate appellate court by right, pursuant to section 450.25 of this title, shall be taken in accordance with the rules of the appellate division of the department in which such intermediate appellate court is located.
§ 4. The section heading of section 460.50 of the criminal procedure law is amended and a new subdivision 7 is added to read as follows:
Stay of judgment or proceedings pending appeal to intermediate appellate court.
7. (a) Where a non-party to a criminal action or proceeding has appealed an order of a criminal court, pursuant to section 450.25 of this title, such non-party may apply to the criminal court that issued such order for an order staying such action or proceeding pending the determination of such appeal.
(b) If an application brought pursuant to paragraph (a) of this subdivision is denied, the non-party may apply to the intermediate appellate court where the appeal is then pending for an order staying such action or proceeding pending the determination of such appeal.
(c) An application brought pursuant to paragraph (a) or (b) of this subdivision, shall be brought upon reasonable notice to the parties to such action or proceeding and such parties shall be accorded adequate opportunity to appear and be heard in support thereof or in opposition thereto. Such application shall be made in a manner determined by the rules of the appellate division of the department in which such intermediate appellate court is located.
§ 5. This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become a law.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the criminal procedure law, in relation to establishing provisions for appeals by a non-party to an intermediate appellate court
Purpose or general idea of bill
To codify the right of a nonparty to appeal a denial of a motion to quash a subpoena issued as part of a criminal proceeding where the movant is seeking to protect confidential and privileged information.
Summary of specific provisions
Section 1 of the bill adds a new section 450.25 to the criminal proce- dure law. Section 450.25 provides that an appeal directly to the inter- mediate appellate court may be taken as of right by a non-party from certain orders of a criminal court where the movant is protected by claim of privilege, immunity from disclosure, or any other constitu- tional, common law, or statutory privilege or protection. Provides that such appeal shall be expeditiously filed, heard and determined, and shall be taken only upon reasonable notice to the parties to the action or proceeding who shall have an opportunity to be heard.
Read the full memo (1,517 words)
Section 2 of the bill amends section 450.60 of the criminal procedure law to include reference to section 450.25.
Section 3 of the bill adds a new subdivision 4-a to section 460.10 of criminal procedure law. Provides that an appeal by a nonparty to an intermediate appellate court by right pursuant to section 450.25 shall be taken in accordance with the rules of the appellate division of the department in which such intermediate appellate court is located.
Section 4 of the bill amends section 460.50 of criminal procedure law by adding a new subdivision 7. Provides where a nonparty to a criminal action or proceeding has appealed an order of a criminal court pursuant to section 460.25, such nonparty may apply to the criminal court that issued such order for an order staying such action or proceeding pending the determination of the appeal. If such application is denied, the nonparty may apply to the intermediate appellate court where the appeal is then pending for an order staying such action or proceeding pending determination of the appeal. An application shall be brought upon reasonable notice to the parties to such action or proceeding and such parties shall be accorded adequate opportunity to be heard.
Section 5 of the bill is the effective date.
Justification
This bill will restore a longstanding practice of the Appellate Divi- sions of the Supreme Court of the State of New York that has been upended by the recent New York State Court of Appeals decision in PEOPLE v. JUAREZ, 31 N.Y.3d 1186 (2018). In JUAREZ, the Court held that "unless the legislature acts, CPL article 450 does not authorize a nonparty's appeal" of a denial of a motion to quash a subpoena issued after an accusatory instrument has been filed in a criminal proceeding.
Prior to the decision in JUAREZ, the Appellate Divisions that considered the question allowed nonparties to appeal from such denials, recognizing that a contrary rule would "irrevocably preclude (a third party) from any opportunity to vindicate its position before an appellate body." See PEOPLE v. MARIN, 86 A.D.2d 40, 42 (2nd Dept. 1982) (holding that law firm could appeal from a denial of its motion to quash as the order was final as to the law firm); see also PEOPLE v. LAUGHING, 979 N.Y.S.2d 416 (3rd Dept. 2014) (considering but ultimately denying appeal of subpoena duces tecum brought by non-party).
While the Appellate Divisions have historically allowed appeals by a wide variety of nonparties, this bill seeks only to address the narrow procedural gap left by the Court of Appeals decision in JUAREZ by ensur- ing appellate review for nonparties only where a challenge is brought against a subpoena based on a recognized protection from disclosure, such as the attorney-client privilege, attorney work product protection, priest-penitent privilege, marital privilege, physician-patient privi- lege, psychotherapist-patient privilege, or the protections afforded reporters under the New York Reporters Shield Law.
In JUAREZ, prosecutors subpoenaed a New York Times reporter, seeking to compel her testimony and production of her notes related to an interview she conducted of a criminal defendant while he was held in pretrial detention. The reporter moved to quash the subpoenas, arguing that the information was protected from disclosure based on the qualified privi- lege in the Reporters Shield Law. While the trial court initially grant- ed the motion to quash for the purposes of a HUNTLEY hearing, it later denied the motion to quash in connection with trial. On appeal, the Appellate Division unanimously reversed, finding that the People had not satisfied their burden of making a "'clear and specific showing' that the disclosure sought . . . is 'critical or necessary' to the People's proof of a material issue." PEOPLE v. JUAREZ, 39 N.Y.S.3d 155 (1st Dept. 2016). The Court of Appeals, addressing the procedural question, it raised sua sponte at oral argument held: "Unless the legislature acts, CPL article 450 does not authorize a nonparty's appeal under these circumstances. In the absence of statutory authorization, an order resolving a nonparty's motion to quash a subpoena issued after the filing of the accusatory instrument in a criminal proceeding - contrasted with an order issued before the criminal action begins - is simply not appealable."
This bill heeds the call of the Court of Appeals by creating a statutory basis for nonparties to challenge an erroneous denial of a motion to quash. The fundamental question, as noted in JUAREZ, is "how best to balance the interest of the expedient resolution of criminal actions against the right of a nonparty in a pending criminal action to seek appellate review of an order denying a motion to quash a subpoena when the State's longstanding interests in protecting the newsgathering role of reporters, or other weighty third-party concerns, are implicated." Id. at 1191. This bill addresses this balance by limiting the right to appeal a trial court order denying a motion to quash strictly to nonpar- ties challenging a subpoena based on a privilege or protection against disclosure, as opposed to those seeking to challenge the relevance or scope of a subpoena. Such a limitation greatly minimizes any risk that such challenges will unnecessarily frustrate the speedy determination of criminal trials or overly burden the appellate courts of New York. Even with the Appellate Divisions' prior practice of allowing appeals from a broad group of nonparty witnesses, such appeals appear to have been quite infrequent. This bill further calls for each of the Appellate Divisions to adopt rules for such appeals to be handled in an expe- ditious matter and to ensure the parties to the criminal matter are provided adequate notice of any appeal.
This bill will not only preserve fundamental rights advanced by nonpar- ties, but it will bring predictability and consistency to challenges to nonparty subpoenas. As explained in one of the dissenting opinions in JUAREZ, the other two avenues by which nonparty challenges to subpoenas may be brought - challenging a criminal contempt finding or subsequent denial of a CPLR article 78 action - are just as likely (if not more likely) to cause delay to the ongoing criminal proceedings, while also significantly increasing the burden on the nonparty. PEOPLE v. JUAREZ, 39 N.Y.S.3d 155 (1st Dept. 2016) (Rivera, J., dissenting).
The Court of Appeals has said that a challenge to a subpoena even one related to a criminal investigation is "'limited in scope, challenging only the validity of the subpoena or the jurisdiction of the issuing authority,' and 'substantial delay in the proceedings is unlikely' to result from permitting appeals from orders deciding such motions." See IN RE 381 SEARCH WARRANTS DIRECTED TO FACEBOOK, INC., 29 N.Y.3d 231, 246 (2017). The limited scope of challenges to a subpoena, and unlikelihood of substantial delay to result therefrom, are no different whether the subpoena is issued prior to, but in connection with, a criminal matter, or once a criminal matter has already commenced.
Absent a direct right to appeal, individuals who believe they are obli- gated, or permitted, to maintain the confidentiality of information they gain under the promise of confidentiality would face the impossible choice of facing fines or possible jail time through potential contempt findings or disclosing the at-issue information, knowing that doing so would violate the promise of confidentiality. This bill takes a middle-ground approach to fix this procedural gap by limiting the right to a direct appeal only to those parties who have moved to quash based on a privilege or protection. Codifying a limited right to appeal here is an important step in ensuring that New York remains a champion of the free press (as well as a protector of other societally important privi- leges), and that its courts have adequate procedures for protecting the rights of nonparties who assert privileges in criminal actions.
Prior legislative history
S.7343 of 2020 (Hoylman): Died in Codes A.9666 of 2020 (Lenthol): Died in Codes
Fiscal implications
To be determined.
Effective date
This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become a law.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.