What's happening
This bill imposes a new annual tax on New York residents with net assets over $1 billion, taxing unrealized capital gains each year as if assets were sold at fair market value.
Why it matters
Shifts Tax Timing for Billionaires. The bill would require New York residents with over $1 billion in net assets to pay taxes on their unrealized gains each year, meaning they’d owe taxes on the increased value of their assets even if they haven’t sold them. This fundamentally changes how wealth is taxed and could significantly increase tax bills for the ultra-wealthy.
Broad and Aggressive Asset Definition. The bill's definition of "assets" is unusually broad, including not just personally owned property, but assets held by spouses, minor children, trusts, and even certain charitable donations made in the last five years. This could make it difficult to avoid the tax through common wealth-planning techniques and could capture a wider array of wealth than most existing taxes.
Complex Compliance and Enforcement. Billionaire taxpayers would have to annually value a wide range of assets—from art and collectibles to private business interests—and report them in detail. The state tax commissioner is empowered to request filings from anyone expected to be over the threshold, including those on published billionaire lists. The bill also gives regulators authority to create rules to prevent tax avoidance through transfers or related parties.
Interstate and Legal Ramifications. The bill includes provisions for credits if assets were taxed in another state before the taxpayer became a New York resident, and for adjustments if other states have similar mark-to-market regimes. It also tries to shield the state from legal challenges by restricting injunctions against collection and routing constitutional challenges directly to the highest court. This suggests lawmakers anticipate significant legal pushback and potential issues with constitutionality or federal preemption.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Tax Unrealized Billionaire Gains
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
History
- Referred to budget and revenue
- Referred to budget and revenue
Full text
4 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
4482
2021-2022 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
February 5, 2021
Introduced by Sen. RAMOS -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Budget and Revenue
AN ACT to establish the "billionaire mark to market tax act"; and to amend the tax law, in relation to establishing a mark to market tax
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "billionaire mark to market tax act".
§ 2. The tax law is amended by adding a new section 612-a to read as follows:
§ 612-a. Billionaire mark to market taxation. (a)(1) Notwithstanding any other provision of law to the contrary, resident individual taxpayers with net assets worth one billion dollars or more on the date of December thirty-first, two thousand twenty, shall recognize gain or loss as if each asset owned by the individual taxpayer were sold for its fair market value on that date. Any resulting net gains from these deemed sales, up to the phase-in cap amount, shall be included in the taxpayer's income for the two thousand twenty-one tax year. Proper adjustment shall be made in the amount of any gain or loss subsequently realized for gain or loss taken into account under the preceding sentence. At the taxpayer's option, any additional tax payable as a result of this subsection shall either be payable along with any other tax owed for the two thousand twenty-one tax year or else shall be payable annually in ten equal installments beginning in the year of the effective date of this section and with all such installment payments commencing after the initial installment payment also being subject to an annual nondeductible deferral charge. The annual nondeductible deferral charge shall be set by the state comptroller at a rate that the comptroller estimates is equal to the unsecured borrowing rate of the taxpayer for a loan repaid over a ten-year term in equal annual installments. The comptroller may estimate a single rate for all taxpayers subject to the deferral charge.
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD06600-02-1
S. 4482 2
For resident individual taxpayers who would recognize net gains as a result of this subsection except for the operation of this sentence, if the taxpayer can show that any portion of such gains was accumulated prior to the taxpayer becoming a resident individual of New York, and if the taxpayer can also show that such portion of such gains was previously taxed by any prior state or jurisdiction in which the taxpayer was a resident prior to becoming a resident individual of New York, then credit shall be provided in the amount of any such tax on such gains paid to any such prior states or jurisdictions in which the taxpayer was a resident prior to becoming a resident individual of New York. Any credits so provided by this subsection, however, shall not exceed the lesser of the total tax owed under this subsection on such gains and the tax imposed on such gains by such other prior states or jurisdictions in which the taxpayer was a resident prior to becoming a resident individual of New York.
(2) For the two thousand twenty-one tax year, whether an individual is a resident individual for purposes of this section shall be determined using the tests provided pursuant to paragraph one of subsection (b) of section six hundred five of this article.
(b) Subsequent to two thousand twenty-one, resident individual taxpayers with net assets that are worth one billion dollars or more at the end of the last day of any tax year shall recognize gain or loss as if each asset owned by such taxpayer on such date were sold for its fair market value on such date, but with adjustment made for tax paid on gain in previous years. Any resulting net gains from these deemed sales, up to the phase-in cap amount, shall be included in the taxpayer's income for such taxable year. Proper adjustment shall be made in the amount of any gain or loss subsequently realized for gain or loss taken into account under the preceding sentence. To the extent that the losses of a taxpayer exceed such taxpayer's gains, such net losses shall not be recognized in such taxable year and shall instead carry forward indefinitely. For resident individual taxpayers who would recognize net gains as a result of this subsection except for the operation of this sentence, but who were not resident individuals for all of the preceding five tax years, solely for purposes of deemed sales pursuant to this subsection, the tax basis of each asset owned on the last day of the last tax year before the resident individual became a New York resident shall be the fair market value of the asset as of that day.
(c) For each date on which gains or losses are recognized as a result of this section, the phase-in cap amount shall be equal to a quarter of the worth of a taxpayer's net assets in excess of one billion dollars on such date.
(d) For the purposes of determining whether a resident individual taxpayer has net assets worth one billion dollars or more, the term "assets" shall include all of the following, but only to the extent allowable under the New York Constitution, the United States Constitution, and any other governing federal law: all owned real or personal, tangible or intangible, property, wherever situated, (1) owned by the taxpayer, (2) owned by the taxpayer's spouse, minor children, or any trust or estate of which the taxpayer is a beneficiary, (3) contributed by the taxpayer or any person or entity described in paragraph two of this subsection to any private foundation, donor advised fund, and any other entity described in section 501(c) or section 527 of the Internal Revenue Code of which the taxpayer and/or any person or entity described in paragraph two of this subsection is a substantial contributor (as such term is defined in Section 4958(c)(3)(B)(i) of the Internal Revenue
S. 4482 3
Code), and (4) without duplication, all gifts and donations made within the past five years by the taxpayer or any person or entity described in paragraph two of this subsection as if such gifts and donations were still owned by the taxpayer. For the purpose of this section, "net assets" shall include the fair market value of assets less the fair market value of liabilities of the taxpayer and, in appropriate cases as determined by the commissioner, liabilities of such other persons described in the definition of assets.
(e) (1) The fair market value of each asset owned by the taxpayer shall be the price at which such asset would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither being under any compulsion to buy or to sell, and both having reasonable knowledge of relevant facts. The value of a particular asset shall not be the price that a forced sale of the property would produce. Further, the fair market value of an asset shall not be the sale price in a market other than that in which such item is most commonly sold to the public, taking into account the location of the item wherever appropriate. In the case of an asset which is generally obtained by the public in the retail market, the fair market value of such an asset shall be the price at which such item or a comparable item would be sold at retail.
(2) For purposes of this section, any feature of an asset, such as a poison pill, that was added with the intent, and has the effect, of reducing the value of the asset shall be disregarded, and no valuation or other discount shall be taken into account if it would have the effect of reducing the value of a pro rata economic interest in an asset below the pro rata portion of the value of the entire asset.
(f) (1) (A) The commissioner shall amend the New York personal income tax forms and amend or create any other forms as necessary for the reporting of gains by assets. Assets shall be listed with (i) a description of the asset, (ii) the asset category, (iii) the year the asset was acquired, (iv) the adjusted New York basis of the asset as of December thirty-first of the tax year, (v) the fair market value of the asset as of December thirty-first of the tax year, and (vi) the amount of gain that would be New York taxable income, unless the commissioner shall determine that one or more categories is not appropriate for a particular type of asset.
(B) Asset categories shall include, but not be limited to, the following:
(i) stock held in any publicly traded corporation;
(ii) stock held in any private traded C corporation;
(iii) stock held in any S corporation;
(iv) interests in any private equity or hedge fund organized as a partnership;
(v) interests in any other partnerships;
(vi) interests in any other noncorporate businesses;
(vii) bonds and interest bearing savings accounts, cash and deposits;
(viii) interests in mutual funds or index funds;
(ix) put and call options;
(x) futures contracts;
(xi) financial assets held offshore reported on IRS tax form eight thousand nine hundred thirty-eight;
(xii) real property;
(xiii) art and collectibles;
(xiv) pension funds;
(xv) other assets;
(xvi) debts and liabilities; and
S. 4482 4
(xvii) assets not owned by the taxpayer but which count toward the one billion dollar threshold pursuant to subsection (d) of this section.
(2) The commissioner shall specifically request the filing of such forms by any resident individual expected to have net assets in excess of one billion dollars. Such taxpayers shall include, but not be limited to, (A) taxpayers listed as billionaires on published lists, and (B) taxpayers with an adjusted gross income summed over the previous ten years in excess of six hundred million dollars.
(g) In the event that any resident individual taxpayer becomes a New York resident subsequent to paying tax to another state as a result of recognizing gain or loss pursuant to any mark-to-market or deemed-realization regime of that other state, proper adjustment shall be made in the amount of any gain or loss subsequently realized for gain or loss taken into account under such mark-to-market or deemed-realization regime of that other state for purposes of computing gain or loss under subsection (a) or (b) of this section or under section six hundred twelve of this article.
(h) In the event that any provision of this section is found to be invalid, unconstitutional, or otherwise unenforceable, that finding shall not affect any other provision in this section which can be enforced without the use of the offending provision.
(i) No legal or equitable process shall issue in any proceeding in any court against this state or any officer thereof to prevent or enjoin the collection of the tax imposed by this section. Any action for a refund of the tax imposed by this section paid, with interest, based solely on a question of law involving the construction of the constitution of the state or of the United States shall be heard in the court of appeals. All other claims for a refund, with interest, shall be maintained in the same manner as the personal income tax.
(j) The commissioner shall promulgate such rules and regulations necessary or appropriate to carry out the purposes of this section, including rules to prevent the use of year-end transfers, related parties, or other arrangements to avoid the provisions of this section.
§ 3. This act shall take effect immediately.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to establish the "billionaire mark to market tax act"; and to amend the tax law, in relation to establishing a mark to market tax
Summary of provisions
Section 1. Establishes the act to be cited as the "billionaire mark to market tax act".
Section 2. Amends the tax law by adding a new section 612-a, which treats residential billionaires capital gains on their net assets as annual income, furthermore, taxing billionaires yearly unrealized capi- tal gains. Year one taxes all built in gains on assets owned by billio- naires before 2020 with an option to pay in ten installments. Year two onward, taxes the yearly gains of assets unrealized.
Section 3. This act shall take effect immediately.
Justification
In the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, the economy is in free fall and the New York State budget is facing massive deficits. State budget projections show a $15 billion annual budget deficit. At the same time, wealth inequality is exploding across New York. While regular New York- ers struggle to make ends meet, New York's 120 billionaires are $77 billion richer than they were at the beginning of the pandemic. The Billionaire Mark-to-Market Tax tax would give the state a mechanism to raise revenue in a progressive manner while addressing growing wealth inequality.
Today, people pay taxes on stocks other assets only when they sell them. They do not pay annual taxes on the increased value of these assets and often never sell them and pass them on to their spouses at death at a stepped up basis. Moreover, the Mark-to-Market Tax would tax the increase in value of billionaires assets at the same rate as other income- 8.82%.
While New York State's constitution does not permit an "ad valorem tax on intangible property", a Mark-to-market tax is not an ad valorem tax. An ad valorem tax would tax a billionaire who started and ended 2021 with 1 billion dollars in wealth, a mark to market does not tax this billionaire or his wealth because there were no gains. In comparison, if a billionaire starts the year at $1 billion in worth, but ends the year at $2 billion in net assets, then this tax would treat the $1 billion gain like income.
This tax is necessary to address the growing wealth inequality crisis and to raise the necessary funds to fill budget gaps and to fully fund the programs New York State needs to survive LEGISLATIVE HISTORY: New Bill.
Fiscal implications for state and local governments
Year 1 Revenue: $23.3 Billion. The legislation provides an option to pay year 1 of the tax in 10 annual installments. Year 2- onward Revenue: $1.2 Billion or more
Effective date
This act shall take effect immediately.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.