What's happening
This bill reforms how New York recovers public assistance overpayments, adding new recipient protections, hardship waivers, and time limits on recovery actions.
Why it matters
Limits when and how the state can recover overpaid public assistance. , including barring recovery if the overpayment was due to government error or if the recipient was a child or recently lost eligibility due to changes in household circumstances. This means fewer vulnerable people (like children and those affected by agency mistakes) will face repayment demands.
Establishes new procedural safeguards for recipients. , like requiring detailed written notice before attempts to recover overpayments, clear explanations of rights, and documentation of the basis for claims. This increases transparency and gives recipients more ability to defend themselves or challenge errors.
Adds hardship and time-based protections. , such as automatically waiving recovery for those under 250% of the federal poverty line, allowing full or partial debt forgiveness after the COVID-19 emergency, and imposing a strict two-year time limit for the state to initiate recovery actions. This reduces long-term financial insecurity for low-income households and prevents old debt from threatening recipients for years.
Eliminates aggressive collection tactics. , including banning the use of confessions of judgment (which allow the state to seize assets without a court hearing) and requiring any settlement agreement to be supported by a sworn affidavit with specific evidence. This curtails practices that can lead to sudden or unfair asset loss for recipients.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Limit Welfare Overpayment Collections
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
History
- Vetoed memo.179
- Delivered to governor
- Returned to senate
- Passed assembly
- Ordered to third reading rules cal.681
- Substituted for A5613A
- Referred to ways and means
- Delivered to assembly
- Passed senateVote 42–20
- Advanced to third reading
- 2nd report cal.
- 1st report cal.209
Show 12 earlier actions
- Referred to social services
- Returned to senate
- Died in assembly
- Referred to ways and means
- Delivered to assembly
- Passed senateVote 44–19
- Ordered to third reading cal.1337
- Committee discharged and committed to rules
- Reported and committed to finance
- Print number 4540a
- Amend (t) and recommit to social services
- Referred to social services
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Limit Welfare Overpayment Recovery
Assembly Floor Calendar · Sponsor Richard Gottfried
Full text
6 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
4540--A
2021-2022 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
February 5, 2021
Introduced by Sens. RIVERA, HOYLMAN -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Social Services -- committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee
AN ACT to amend the social services law and the civil practice law and rules, in relation to recovery of overpayment of certain assistance; and to repeal certain provisions of the social services law related thereto
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Section 104 of the social services law, subdivision 1 as amended by chapter 573 of the laws of 1964, subdivision 2 as amended by chapter 909 of the laws of 1974, subdivision 3 as added by chapter 433 of the laws of 1993 and subdivision 4 as added by chapter 340 of the laws of 2003, is amended to read as follows:
§ 104. Recovery from a person discovered to have property. 1. For purposes of this section:
(a) "Overpayment" shall include erroneous payments made to an eligible person in excess of the recipient's needs as defined in this chapter and erroneous payments made to ineligible persons, including but not limited to, payments made to such persons pending a fair hearing decision.
(b) "Recipient" shall mean any individual who is currently receiving or at one time received assistance or care as pursuant to the provisions of this title.
2. A public welfare official may bring an action or proceeding in a court of competent jurisdiction against a [person] recipient who is discovered to have real or personal property, which resulted in an overpayment to the recipient, or against the estate or the executors, administrators and successors in interest of a person who dies leaving real or personal property, [if such person, or any one for whose support he is or was liable, received assistance and care during the preceding ten
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD09184-02-1
S. 4540--A 2
years, and] and there has been an overpayment to the recipient. The public welfare official shall be entitled to recover up to the value of such property which cause the assistance or care to constitute an overpayment to the recipient or the cost of such assistance or care, whichever is lower. [Any public assistance or care received by such person shall constitute an implied contract. No claim of a public welfare official against the estate or the executors, administrators and successors in interest of a person who dies leaving real or personal property, shall be barred or defeated, in whole or in part, by any lack of sufficiency of ability on the part of such person during the period assistance and care were received.
Nor shall the claim asserted by a public welfare official against any person under this section be impaired, impeded, barred or defeated, in whole or in part, on the grounds that another person or persons may also have been liable to contribute.]
In all claims of the public welfare official made under this section the public welfare official shall be deemed a preferred creditor.
[2. No] 3. The public welfare official shall not bring an action or proceeding under this section if excess payments or payments made to the person were made due to agency or contractor error, including but not limited to an error made by a facilitated enroller.
4. In an action or proceeding under this section, the complaint shall be accompanied by a certificate, signed by the attorney for the public welfare official, declaring the following:
(a) the attorney has reviewed the facts of the case and has concluded that there is a reasonable basis for the action or proceeding;
(b) certification that the continuous coverage protections under paragraph (c) of subdivision four of section three hundred sixty-six of this chapter do not apply to the recipient;
(c) the specific eligibility criteria under which the recipient was allegedly ineligible for benefits; the budgeting methodology that was applied in making the determination that the recipient was ineligible for benefits, including the applicable resource or income limit for the recipient's household composition during the claim period, and the recipient's applicable resources and income during the claim period; the time period during which the recipient was allegedly ineligible; the value of the real or personal property which resulted in an overpayment; and the amount of recovery sought; and
(d) the action or proceeding is supported by exhibits including an accounting of the recovery sought and all expenditures of assistance or care made on behalf of the recipient during the period of alleged ineligibility.
5. There shall be no right of action [shall accrue against] to recover an alleged overpayment for assistance or care received by a person under twenty-one years of age [by reason of the assistance or care granted to him unless at the time it was granted the person was possessed of money and property in excess of his reasonable requirements, taking into account his maintenance, education, medical care and any other factors applicable to his condition].
[3.] 6. To the extent described in section 7-1.12 of the estates, powers and trusts law, the trustee of a supplemental needs trust which conforms to the provisions of such section 7-1.12 shall not be deemed to be holding assets for the benefit of a beneficiary who may otherwise be the subject of a claim under this section and no action or proceeding may be brought against either the trust or the trustee to recover the
S. 4540--A 3
cost of assistance or care provided to such person, or anyone for whose support such person is or was liable.
[4.] 7. Any inconsistent provision of this chapter or of any other law notwithstanding, a social services official may not assert any claim under any provision of this chapter to recover payments of public assistance if such payments were reimbursed by child support collections.
8. There shall be no right of action against a recipient who loses medical assistance eligibility by reason of excess resources or income because the recipient's medical assistance eligibility group, as determined under section three hundred sixty-six of this chapter, changed from MAGI, as defined in section three hundred sixty-six of this chapter, to non-MAGI, for the two years subsequent to their eligibility change. A right of action against such a recipient begins to accrue only if the recipient remains ineligible for medical assistance after the two-year grace period.
9. The public welfare official shall not use confession of judgment to recover an overpayment of public assistance or care, or supplemental nutrition assistance benefits.
10. Any action or proceeding to recover an overpayment under this section shall be waived in cases of undue hardship in which a recipient's adjusted gross income for the applicable household size is two hundred fifty percent of the federal poverty line or lower and in cases of other extenuating circumstances as determined by the public welfare official.
11. Any action or proceeding under this section shall be commenced within two years from payment for assistance or care. No determination of a debt or award of debt shall be based upon payment for assistance or care that occurred more than two years before the action or proceeding is commenced.
12. The rate of interest for a judgment obtained pursuant to this section shall be calculated at the one-year United States treasury bill rate. For the purpose of this section, the "one-year United States treasury bill rate" means the weekly average one-year constant maturity treasury yield, as published by the board of governors of the federal reserve system, for the calendar week preceding the date of the entry of the judgment awarding damages.
13. There shall be no right of action against a recipient whose medical assistance eligibility was granted or extended during the period of the COVID-19 public health emergency, defined for the purposes of this section as March eighteenth, two thousand twenty through the end of the quarter when such public health emergency ends.
14. All settlement and payment agreements under this section in which the recipient has paid fifty percent or more of the debt by the end of the COVID-19 public health emergency are hereby deemed paid in full.
15. If a recipient subject to a settlement or payment agreement under this section has not paid fifty percent or more of the debt by the end of the COVID-19 public health emergency, the recipient may submit evidence of undue hardship and receive waiver of the remaining debt under subdivision ten of this section or an appropriate reduction of debt based on hardship. Notice regarding the opportunity for the waiver shall be provided by the public welfare official.
§ 2. Subdivision 7 of section 158 of the social services law is REPEALED.
§ 3. The civil practice law and rules is amended by adding a new section 3012-c to read as follows:
S. 4540--A 4
§ 3012-c. Certificate of merit in certain overpayment of assistance actions. In any action or proceeding for recovery of an overpayment of assistance or care, as defined in section one hundred four of the social services law, the complaint shall be accompanied by a certificate, signed by the attorney for the public welfare official, meeting all the requirements of section one hundred four of the social services law.
§ 4. The civil practice law and rules is amended by adding a new section 3202 to read as follows:
§ 3202. Confession of judgment for recovery of overpayment of certain assistance invalid. Notwithstanding the provisions of section thirty-two hundred eighteen of this article, no judgment by confession shall be entered to recover an overpayment, as defined in section one hundred four of the social services law. Any judgment entered in violation of this section is void and unenforceable.
§ 5. The civil practice law and rules is amended by adding a new section 213-e to read as follows:
§ 213-e. Actions to be commenced within two years; actions to recover certain overpayments. An action or proceeding on an overpayment by a public welfare official under section one hundred four of the social services law shall be commenced within two years from payment for assistance or care, and no determination of a debt or award of debt shall be based upon payment for assistance or care that occurred more than two years before the action or proceeding is commenced.
§ 6. Section 106-b of the social services law, as amended by chapter 81 of the laws of 1995, is amended to read as follows:
§ 106-b. Adjustment for incorrect payments. 1. For purposes of this section:
(a) "Overpayment" shall include erroneous payments made to an eligible person in excess of the recipient's needs as defined in this chapter and erroneous payments made to ineligible persons, including but not limited to, payments made to those persons pending a fair hearing decision.
(b) "Recipient" shall mean any individual who is currently receiving or at one time received assistance or care under this title.
2. Any inconsistent provision of law notwithstanding, a social services official shall, in accordance with the regulations of the department and consistent with federal law and regulations, take all necessary steps to correct any overpayment or underpayment to a public assistance recipient[; provided, however,]. However:
(a) A social services official shall not bring an action or proceeding under this section:
(i) if excess payments or payments made to an ineligible person were made due to agency or contractor error, including but not limited to an error made by a facilitated enroller; or
(ii) to recover an overpayment under this section for assistance or care received by a person under twenty-one years of age.
(b) [that a] A social services official [may] shall waive recovery of a past overpayment, in the case of an individual who is not currently a recipient of public assistance, where the cost of recovery is greater than the cost of collections as determined in accordance with department regulations consistent with federal law and regulations. [For purposes of this section, overpayment shall include payments made to an eligible person in excess of his needs as defined in this chapter and payments made to ineligible persons (including payments made to such persons pending a fair hearings decision). The commissioner shall promulgate regulations to implement procedures for correcting overpayments and underpayments. The]
S. 4540--A 5
(c) In any action or proceeding to recover an overpayment under this section, the social services official shall be entitled to recover no more than the value of the property which resulted in an overpayment to the recipient or the cost of the assistance or care, whichever is lower.
(d) Any action or proceeding to recover an overpayment under this section shall be waived in cases of undue hardship in which a recipient's adjusted gross income for the applicable household size is two hundred fifty percent of the federal poverty line or lower and in cases of other extenuating circumstances as determined by the social services official.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the social services law and the civil practice law and rules, in relation to recovery of overpayment of certain assistance; and to repeal certain provisions of the social services law related thereto
Purpose
To simplify the Public Assistance and Medicaid overpayment recovery and collections process in New York and provide much needed due process and consumer protections for benefits recipients
Summary of specific provisions
Section 1 amends the Social Services Law to allow a public welfare offi- cial in an overpayment lawsuit to recover an amount up to the value of the property which caused the overpayment or the cost of the assistance or care received, whichever is lower. It prohibits lawsuits to recover overpayments from recipients under the age of 21 and in circumstances in which an overpayment did not result through any fault of the recipient but from agency or contractor error. It protects Medicaid recipients in circumstances in which an overpayment resulted from a change in Medicaid eligibility group and recipients whose eligibility was granted or extended during the COVID-19 public health emergency. It creates a defined waiver for recipients for whom an overpayment judgment would create undue economic or other hardship. For recipients who currently are subject to overpayment settlement agreements, it creates debt forgiveness and relief in light of the COVID-19 public health emergency. It requires that a public welfare official's complaint commencing an action to recover an overpayment be accompanied by a certificate of merit, disallows the use of confessions of judgment to recover overpay- ments, reduces the statute of limitations for commencing a n overpayment action to two years, and reduces the interest rate on overpayment judg- ments to a rate corresponding to the one-year United States treasury bill rate.
Read the full memo (1,034 words)
Section 2 repeals subdivision 7 of section 158 of the social services law.
Section 3 adds a new section to Civil Practice Law § 3012-c to require that a complaint in an action to recover an overpayment be accompanied by a certificate of merit attesting to and including the reasonable basis for the claim and case-specific information verifying the claim allegations.
Section 4 adds a new Civil Practice Law § 3202 to prohibit the use of confessions of judgment to recover Public Assistance and Medicaid over- payments.
Section 5 adds a. new Civil Practice Law § 213-e to reduce the statute of limitations for commencing an action to recover an overpayment to two years.
Section 6 amends Social Services § 106-b, which governs the Public Assistance and Medicaid overpayment investigation process. Section 5 makes several parallel changes to Section 1 including: limiting the amount of recovery to whichever is lower between the value of the prop- erty causing the overpayment and the cost of the assistance or care received; prohibiting recovery from recipients under the age of 21; protecting recipients in circumstances in which an overpayment resulted from agency or contractor error or from a change in Medicaid eligibility group; protecting Medicaid recipients whose eligibility was granted or extended during the COVID-19 public health emergency; defining an undue hardship waiver; creating COVID-19 debt forgiveness and relief for recipients who have existing payment agreements; and prohibiting the use of confessions of judgment in the investigation process to recover over- payments. In line with existing policy regarding initial eligibility determinations, Section 5 clarifies that, in determining whether a recipient is subject to an overpayment, the most favorable budgeting must be used. It also includes due process guarantees for recipients during the investigation process, including notice that adequately informs a recipient of the overpayment claim, the basis and proof of that claim, and the recipient's rights in the process. No settlement or payment agreement to recover an overpayment obtained will be effective unless a social services official produces an affidavit attesting to the validity of the claim and enumerated case-specific detail
Section 7 is the effective date.
Justification
This act will simplify the Public Assistance and Medicaid overpayment recovery and collections process in New York and provide much needed due process and consumer protections for benefits recipients. Overpayment recoveries are intended to allow the State to recover for benefits that were received by individuals and families when they were not eligible for those benefits. But the current overpayment recovery process in New York is deeply flawed: in many cases, beneficiaries who are subject to overpayments were actually eligible for all or part of their alleged overpayment time period or were approved for benefits in error through no fault of their own. Often, budgeting rules and protections are misap- plied in determining liability, claims are not properly calculated or validated, and beneficiaries are not given the opportunity to challenge the claims against them and to prove eligibility. The stakes for benefi- ciaries facing an overpayment are high: most overpayments are in the thousands of dollars and many in the tens of thousands. Still, due to the lack of protections for beneficiaries in this process, individuals frequently are pressured into signing settlement agreements for which they are not liable or that they cannot afford. Others are sued and many people are subject to default judgments, even in cases with little or no proof that a debt is owed. For many of these beneficiaries, an overpayment debt may push them and their family back into poverty just when they were getting on their feet or the debt may permanently trap them in poverty and threaten their wellbeing. Beneficiaries who are particularly vulnerable to these process flaws and are thus the most impacted include immigrants, those with limited English proficiency, and the working poor. Other states which recover benefits overpayments from recipients have more robust due process protections and procedures for beneficiaries. Beneficiaries in New York should have equally robust protections.
This Act will not hinder a public welfare official's ability to recover benefits incorrectly received, but instead will ensure that any action or proceeding to recover Public Assistance and Medicaid overpayments are valid and vetted and that beneficiaries receive proper protections, including ensuring that any overpayment debt ultimately imposed will not threaten a beneficiary's and their family's ability to survive.
Prior legislative history
New bill.
Fiscal implications
None.
Effective date
Immediately.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.