Skip to content
S4961Senate2021-2022 SessionSame asA6384

Expand 9/11 Benefits Eligibility

Official title

“Relates to including certain employees who were employed in public service for eligibility for those who participated in the World Trade Center rescue, recovery or cleanup operations”

Sponsor Andrew GounardesSD-22+2 co-sponsorsAffects Finance
Status
Signed by Governor
Impact
7/10
Significant
Outcome
Signed into law

Bill progress

Signed into law

What's happening

This bill expands World Trade Center rescue, recovery, or cleanup retirement benefits to include later-enrolled public employees who purchase qualifying service credit.

Why it matters

  1. Broadens eligibility for crucial WTC-related retirement benefits. by allowing public sector workers who were employed during the World Trade Center rescue, recovery, or cleanup—but who joined a public retirement system after the fact—to access these benefits if they buy back service credit. This can have a significant impact on workers who delayed pension enrollment or who changed career tracks.

  2. Addresses a longstanding coverage gap. for those who responded to 9/11 but were ineligible for enhanced retirement protections solely because they were not yet retirement system members at the time, potentially correcting what many see as an unfair exclusion given the risks they faced.

  3. May increase public retirement system costs. for state and local governments, as actuarial analyses suggest higher costs per qualifying incident (especially for police and fire pensions) and more cases classified as “accidental” deaths or disabilities, with costs shared by employers and employees.

  4. Recognizes and compensates a broader group of 9/11 responders. for long-term health consequences linked to their service, which could improve financial security for affected workers and families but also raises questions about the long-term fiscal sustainability of public pension systems.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Expand 9/11 Benefits Eligibility

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Andrew Gounardes

Senator · Senate District 22

Chair, Budget And Revenue

History

  1. Signed chap.424
  2. Delivered to governor
  3. Returned to senate
  4. Passed assembly
  5. Ordered to third reading rules cal.582
  6. Substituted for A6384A
  7. Referred to ways and means
  8. Delivered to assembly
  9. Passed senateVote 63–0
  10. Amended on third reading 4961b
  11. Ordered to third reading cal.1341
  12. Committee discharged and committed to rules
Show 4 earlier actions
  1. Print number 4961a
  2. Amend and recommit to finance
  3. Reported and committed to finance
  4. Referred to civil service and pensions

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A6384Assembly

Expand 9/11 Benefits Eligibility

Assembly Floor Calendar · Sponsor Peter Abbate

Impact 7 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

6 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

4961--B Cal. No. 1341

2021-2022 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

February 19, 2021

Introduced by Sens. GOUNARDES, JACKSON, MANNION -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Civil Service and Pensions -- reported favorably from said committee and committed to the Committee on Finance -- committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee -- committee discharged and said bill committed to the Committee on Rules -- ordered to a third reading, amended and ordered reprinted, retaining its place in the order of third reading

AN ACT to amend the retirement and social security law, in relation to including certain employees who were employed in public service but became members of a retirement system at a later date for eligibility for those who participated in the World Trade Center rescue, recovery or cleanup operations

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Paragraph (e) of subdivision 36 of section 2 of the retirement and social security law, as added by chapter 489 of the laws of 2008, is amended to read as follows:

(e) "Participated in World Trade Center rescue, recovery or cleanup operations" shall mean any member who: (i) participated in the rescue, recovery, or cleanup operations at the World Trade Center site, as defined in paragraph (f) of this subdivision; (ii) worked at the Fresh Kills Land Fill in New York; (iii) worked at the New York city morgue or the temporary morgue on pier locations on the west side of Manhattan; (iv) manned the barges between the west side of Manhattan and the Fresh Kills Land Fill in New York; (v) repaired, cleaned or rehabilitated vehicles or equipment, including emergency vehicle radio equipment owned by the city of New York that were contaminated by debris in the World Trade Center site, as defined in paragraph (f) of this subdivision, regardless of whether the work on the repair, cleaning or rehabilitation of said vehicles and equipment was performed within the World Trade

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD03559-13-1

S. 4961--B 2

Center site, provided such work was performed prior to decontamination of such vehicles or equipment; or (vi) worked in the following departments, worksites and titles: (A) New York City Police Department at 11 Metrotec Center in Brooklyn or 1 Police Plaza in Manhattan as a Police Communication Technician (PCT), Supervisor Police Communication Technician (SPCT), Principal Police Communication Technician I, Principal Police Communication Technician II, Principal Police Communication Technician III, Administrative Manager - Communications, or in the Police Administrative Aide title series; (B) Fire Department of the City of New York at 35 Empire Boulevard in Brooklyn, 79th Street Transverse in Manhattan, 83-98 Woodhaven Boulevard in Queens, 1129 East 180 Street in the Bronx, 65 Slosson Avenue in Staten Island, 9 Metrotec Center in Brooklyn, or 25 Rockaway Avenue in Brooklyn as Fire Alarm Dispatchers (FAD), Supervising Fire Alarm Dispatchers I (SFAD), Supervising Fire Alarm Dispatchers II (Borough Supervisor), Deputy Director & Director Fire Dispatch Operations, or Assistant Commissioner for Communications; (C) for the Fire Department of the City of New York's Emergency Medical Service at 1 or 9 Metrotec Centers in Brooklyn, or 55-30 58 Street in Maspeth Queens as Emergency Medical Specialist-Level I (EMT), Emergency Medical Specialist Level II-(Paramedic), Supervising Emergency Medical Specialist Level I (LT), Supervising Emergency Medical Specialist Level II (Capt), Deputy Chief EMS Communications, or Division Commander EMS Communications. For purposes of this paragraph, the term "member" shall include each person who during the qualifying period was in the employment of a public employer which then participated for such employees in a public retirement system in this state, irrespective of whether the person was a participant in such system at that time, provided that the person has become a participant in such retirement system and has purchased service credit for a period of time that includes some or all of the qualifying period in accordance with provisions of law applicable to such purchase of service credit.

§ 2. Notwithstanding any other provision of law to the contrary, none of the provisions of this act shall be subject to section 25 of the retirement and social security law.

§ 3. This act shall take effect immediately.

FISCAL NOTE.-- Pursuant to Legislative Law, Section 50:

This bill would expand the definition of a member who participated in

World Trade Center rescue, recovery or cleanup operations. The term

member shall include any person during the qualifying period who was

employed by a public employer participating in the New York State and

Local Retirement System (NYSLRS) irrespective of whether the employee

was a participant of the system at that time. The employee must have

become a participant in NYSLRS since that time and purchased service

credit for some or all of qualifying period.

If this bill is enacted, it would reclassify certain current and

future retirement benefits. The cost of the revised benefit will depend

upon the applicant's age, service, salary, plan, and benefit type other-

wise payable.

Benefit without None Ordinary In Performance Service

enactment: Disability of Duty Disability

Cost for WTC 9 times 5 times 2.5 times 2 times

benefit: salary salary salary salary

S. 4961--B 3

This bill would also lead to more deaths being classified as "acci-

dental". For each death classified as accidental due to this bill, the

cost would depend on the age, service, salary, plan, and status at time

of death. It is estimated that the cost for each Employees' Retirement

System (ERS) member affected would average approximately 3.5 times final

average salary. The estimated cost for each Police and Fire Retirement

System (PFRS) member would average approximately 11 times final average

salary.

ERS Costs: These costs would be shared by the State of New York and

the participating employees in the ERS.

PFRS Costs: These costs would be shared by the State of New York and

the participating employees in the PFRS.

Summary of relevant resources:

Membership data as of March 31, 2020 was used in measuring the impact

of the proposed change, the same data used in the April 1, 2020 actuari-

al valuation. Distributions and other statistics can be found in the

2020 Report of the Actuary and the 2020 Comprehensive Annual Financial

Report.

The actuarial assumptions and methods used are described in the 2020

Annual Report to the Comptroller on Actuarial Assumptions, and the

Codes, Rules and Regulations of the State of New York: Audit and

Control.

The Market Assets and GASB Disclosures are found in the March 31, 2020

New York State and Local Retirement System Financial Statements and

Supplementary Information.

I am a member of the American Academy of Actuaries and meet the Quali-

fication Standards to render the actuarial opinion contained herein.

This fiscal note does not constitute a legal opinion on the viability

of the proposed change nor is it intended to serve as a substitute for

the professional judgment of an attorney.

This estimate, dated May 17, 2021, and intended for use only during

the 2021 Legislative Session, is Fiscal Note No. 2021-142, prepared by

the Actuary for the New York State and Local Retirement System.

FISCAL NOTE.--Pursuant to Legislative Law, Section 50:

This bill (legislative bill draft 03559-08-1) would amend paragraph e

of subdivision 36 in section 2 of the Retirement and Social Security Law

to expand the term "member" to include those individuals who were

employed by a public employer during a qualifying period of the World

Trade Center rescue, recovery or cleanup operations, who later became a

member of a New York State public retirement system and purchased prior

service credit during all or part of a qualifying period of the World

Trade Center rescue, recovery or cleanup operations. The public employer

must be a participating employer in a New York State public retirement

system.

The annual cost to the employers of members of the New York State

Teachers' Retirement System is estimated to be negligible if this bill

is enacted.

Member data is from the System's most recent actuarial valuation

files, consisting of data provided by the employers to the Retirement

System. Data distributions and statistics can be found in the System's

Annual Report. System assets are as reported in the System's financial

statements and can also be found in the System's Annual Report. Actuari-

al assumptions and methods are provided in the System's Actuarial Valu-

ation Report.

The source of this estimate is Fiscal Note 2021-55 dated May 27, 2021

prepared by the Actuary of the New York State Teachers' Retirement

S. 4961--B 4

System and is intended for use only during the 2021 Legislative Session.

I, Richard A. Young, am the Actuary for the New York State Teachers'

Retirement System. I am a member of the American Academy of Actuaries

and I meet the Qualification Standards of the American Academy of Actu-

aries to render the actuarial opinion contained herein.

FISCAL NOTE.--Pursuant to Legislative Law, Section 50:

SUMMARY OF BILL: This proposed legislation (see Appendix) would amend

Section 2 of the Retirement and Social Security Law (RSSL) to permit

eligible members of the New York City Retirement Systems and Pension

Funds (NYCRS)1 who participated in the Rescue, Recovery, or Cleanup

operations related to the World Trade Center (WTC) attack on September

11, 2001 as non-members employed by a public employer within the State

and subsequently purchased such service as a NYCRS member, to be eligi-

ble for the applicable WTC presumption.

Effective Date: Upon enactment.

FINANCIAL IMPACT - OVERVIEW: There is no data available to estimate

the number of members who might buyback service during qualifying WTC

participation periods and potentially benefit from this proposed legis-

lation. Therefore, the estimated financial impact has been calculated on

a per event basis equal to the increase in the Present Value of Future

Benefits (PVFB) for an average member who is diagnosed with a qualifying

WTC condition and could benefit from the enactment of the proposed

legislation.

In determining the increase in the PVFB for members who could benefit

from the proposed legislation, we have shown the impact due to disabili-

ty and death separately. To value the impact due to disability, it has

been assumed that 100% of the members who would retire with a WTC quali-

fying condition were those who would have retired with an Ordinary Disa-

bility Retirement benefit or Service Retirement benefit, if eligible, if

the proposed legislation were not passed. To value the impact due to

death, it has also been assumed that 100% of the beneficiaries of

members who would die due to a WTC qualifying condition would have been

entitled to receive an Ordinary Death benefit, if the proposed legis-

lation were not passed.

With respect to an individual member, the additional cost of this

proposed legislation could vary greatly depending on the member's length

of service, age, and salary history. In particular, the increase in PVFB

due to the proposed legislation would be greater for a member who is not

yet eligible for an Ordinary Disability Retirement benefit when a disa-

bling WTC related event occurs.

FINANCIAL IMPACT - PRESENT VALUES: Based on the census data and the

actuarial assumptions and methods described herein, the enactment of

this proposed legislation would increase the PVFB as follows:

NYCRS Estimated increase in Estimated increase in

the average PVFB for the average PVFB for

each occurrence of each occurrence of

Accidental Disability Accidental Death due

Retirement due to a WTC to a WTC related

qualifying condition illness

NYCERS $101,500 $358,600

TRS $332,900 $292,000

BERS $68,700 $156,900

POLICE $614,500 $2,207,700

FIRE $656,400 $2,185,100

S. 4961--B 5

FINANCIAL IMPACT - ANNUAL EMPLOYER CONTRIBUTIONS: Enactment of this

proposed legislation would increase employer contributions, where such

amount would depend on the number of members affected as well as other

characteristics including the age, years of service, and salary history

of the member.

As there is no credible data currently available to estimate the

number of members who might buyback service during qualifying WTC

participation periods, the financial impact would be recognized at the

time of event. Consequently, changes in employer contributions have been

estimated assuming that the increase in the PVFB will be financed over

the same time period used for actuarial losses in accordance with

Section 13-638.2(k-2) of the Administrative Code of the City of New

York. Using this approach, the additional PVFB would be amortized over a

closed 15-year period (14 payments under the One-Year Lag Methodology)

using level dollar payments.

Based on the Actuary's actuarial assumptions and methods described

herein, the enactment of this proposed legislation is estimated to

increase annual employer contributions as follows:

NYCRS Estimated Increase in Annual Estimated Increase in Annual

Employer Contributions for Employer Contributions for

Each Occurrence of Each Occurrence of

Accidental Disability Accidental Death Due to a

Retirement Due to a WTC WTC Related Illness

Qualifying Condition

NYCERS $12,000 $42,400

TRS $39,400 $34,500

BERS $8,100 $18,600

POLICE $72,700 $261,100

FIRE $77,600 $258,500

With respect to the timing, increases in employer contributions would

depend upon when members would retire or die due to a WTC qualifying

condition but, generally, increased employer contributions will first

occur the second fiscal year following approval of the Accidental Disa-

bility Retirement or Accidental Death.

CENSUS DATA: The estimates presented herein are based on the census

data used in the June 30, 2020 (Lag) actuarial valuation of each NYCRS

to determine the respective Preliminary Fiscal Year 2022 employer

contributions. The analysis was based on members that are currently over

age 40 on an age-nearest basis (since this population would have been

over age 21 as of September 11, 2001).

NYCRS Count Average Age Average Service Average Salary

NYCERS 132,874 53.8 15.1 $83,700

TRS 72,077 52.1 16.2 $96,700

BERS 22,698 55.2 10.4 $50,400

POLICE 12,911 46.9 19.3 $144,300

FIRE 5,430 48.3 21.0 $142,400

ACTUARIAL ASSUMPTIONS AND METHODS: The changes in the PVFB and annual

employer contributions presented herein have been calculated based on

the actuarial assumptions and methods in effect for the June 30, 2019

(Lag) actuarial valuations used to determine the Preliminary Fiscal Year

2021 employer contributions of each respective NYCRS.

S. 4961--B 6

In addition, for the purposes of this Fiscal Note we have assumed that

members have already purchased this service and therefore the only addi-

tional benefit of this legislation is the qualification for WTC presump-

tions and benefits.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the retirement and social security law, in relation to including certain employees who were employed in public service but became members of a retirement system at a later date for eligibility for those who participated in the World Trade Center rescue, recovery or cleanup operations

Purpose or general idea of bill

This bill would close a gap in coverage and ensure that all who were employed in qualified service during the World Trade Center rescue, recovery or cleanup operations and whose credited pension service includes credited time for such work will be eligible for the same bene- fits that others are entitled to.

Summary of provisions

Paragraph (e) of subdivision 36 of section 2 of the retirement and social security law (RSSL) defines the group of persons who may avail themselves of the disability benefits provided to those who worked on World Trade Center rescue, recovery or cleanup operations. The language contained in this definition refers to "members." Retirement systems administering the law have interpreted the definition to mean that only those who were actually members of the retirement system during the relevant period are eligible for the coverage. Excluded from coverage is a small group of individuals who engaged in the rescue, recovery or cleanup, working in covered classifications, who were not then members of the retirement system but who thereafter became members and, in accordance with other provisions of law, were able to buy back the pension credits covering this same period of time. This bill would amend the definition to permit these individuals to be covered.

Read the full memo (790 words)

As section two of RSSL sets baseline definitions for the World Trade Center Presumption Law that are referenced in other parts of statute, amending this section of law covers all members of public retirement systems included in the Presumption Law.

Justification

The 2001 attacks on the World Trade Center were a scarring experience for all Americans. The work of those who engineered rescue, recovery and cleanup was nothing short of heroic. Many have suffered from disabling illnesses and death. The legislature has long recognized that it is only just that those who have suffered, or who have been exposed to condi- tions that may lead to suffering over time, should be entitled to special disability benefits or the right to claim that benefits as disa- bling illnesses become manifest. In 2008, the Legislature enacted Chap- ter 468 to accomplish this. That law has been amended thereafter to expand coverage where equities warranted expansion. See L. 2013, c. 489; and L. 2014, c. 472. This bill would expand the application of the law to a group of persons not currently covered whose equitable claim for coverage is as strong as any other group of persons who worked on rescue, recovery or cleanup. Retirement and Social Security Law Section 2 (36) (e) provides that "Participated in World Trade Center rescue, recovery or cleanup operations' shall mean any member who" worked in certain operations at the relevant locations or worked in certain job titles or departments, during the relevant period. Retirement systems administering the law have concluded that the inclusion of the word "member" in this definition means that the individual must have been a member of the system during the period in question. Thus, even if the individual worked on the relevant operations or in the relevant title or department, the individual would be deprived of coverage if she/he were not a member of the retirement system while performing that work.

While nearly all who worked in relevant public employment during this time were members of the retirement system, some were not. The reasons for their nonmembership varied, but their non-membership was lawful and not in any way the result of any wrongdoing on their part. This bill would provide these individuals with access to the disability benefits received by the persons they worked with shoulder-to-shoulder, including EMTs who performed emergency services at the site.

Notably, the bill extends this opportunity only to those who (1) there- after became members of the retirement system and (2) bought back the service credit that applies to the applicable time period of rescue, recovery and cleanup (a payment that requires not just the payment of the mandated contribution, but also the payment of interest). Thus, these are individuals who are in every way indistinguishable from those currently covered: they performed the same work in the same hazardous conditions and made the same financial contributions to the pension fund that their coworkers made. For all these reasons, the bill is a just and equitable measure and should be enacted.

Prior legislative history

2020: S8703 - Referred to Rules

Fiscal implications

See bill

Effective date

Immediate

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.