Skip to content
S5356Senate2021-2022 SessionSame asA8159

Check Consultant Contract Costs

Official title

“Relates to the cost effectiveness of consultant contracts by state agencies”

Sponsor Neil D. BreslinSD-44+4 co-sponsorsAffects Finance
Status
Vetoed
Impact
7/10
Significant
Outcome
Vetoed

Bill progress

Vetoed

What's happening

This bill requires state agencies to conduct cost comparisons before entering consultant contracts over $1 million to ensure cost-effectiveness and transparency.

Why it matters

  1. Requires comprehensive cost comparisons. The bill mandates that agencies must fully account for all direct and indirect costs (such as salaries, benefits, equipment, facilities, oversight, and administrative expenses) when comparing in-house versus consultant-provided services, aiming to prevent hidden or underestimated expenses in outsourcing decisions.

  2. Adds checks for service quality and workforce impacts. It prohibits agencies from outsourcing unless the contract saves at least 10% without lowering service quality, and, if large-scale layoffs (50+ employees) are likely, requires agencies to help state employees organize and bid to keep the work, potentially preserving public jobs.

  3. Establishes accountability and transparency steps. Agencies must create detailed business plans for significant consultant contracts, covering performance standards, market analysis, risk management, transition plans for affected workers, and remediation for understaffing; these plans are reviewed by the state comptroller and are made public.

  4. Limits exceptions and ensures public oversight. The bill allows exceptions only in narrowly defined circumstances (e.g., urgent or highly specialized services), making it harder for agencies to bypass the cost comparison process, and subjects all related documentation to public records laws to promote transparency.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Check Consultant Contract Costs

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Neil D. Breslin

Senator · Senate District 44

Chair, Insurance

History

  1. Vetoed memo.166
  2. Delivered to governor
  3. Returned to senate
  4. Passed assembly
  5. Ordered to third reading rules cal.318
  6. Substituted for A8159
  7. Referred to ways and means
  8. Delivered to assembly
  9. Passed senateVote 61–0
  10. Advanced to third reading
  11. 2nd report cal.
  12. 1st report cal.864
Show 9 earlier actions
  1. Referred to finance
  2. Returned to senate
  3. Died in assembly
  4. Referred to governmental operations
  5. Delivered to assembly
  6. Passed senateVote 63–0
  7. Ordered to third reading cal.1449
  8. Committee discharged and committed to rules
  9. Referred to finance

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A8159Assembly

Check Consultant Contract Savings

Assembly Floor Calendar · Sponsor Harry B. Bronson

Impact 6 · Moderate0% to pass

Full text

4 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

5356

2021-2022 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

March 2, 2021

Introduced by Sen. BRESLIN -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Finance

AN ACT to amend the state finance law, in relation to the cost effectiveness of consultant contracts by state agencies and ensuring the efficient and effective use of state tax dollars

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Section 163 of the state finance law is amended by adding a new subdivision 16 to read as follows:

16. Consultant services. a. Before a state agency enters into a contract for consultant services which is anticipated to cost more than one million dollars in a twelve month period the state agency shall conduct a cost comparison review to determine whether the services to be provided by the consultant can be performed at equal or lower cost by utilizing state employees, unless the contract meets one of the exceptions set forth in paragraph g of this subdivision. As used in this section, the term "consultant services" shall mean any contract entered into by a state agency for analysis, evaluation, research, training, data processing, computer programming, the design, development and implementation of technology, communications or telecommunications systems or the infrastructure pertaining thereto, including hardware and software, engineering including inspection and professional design services, health services, mental health services, accounting, auditing, or similar services and such services that are substantially similar to and in lieu of services provided, in whole or in part, by state employees, but shall not include legal services or services in connection with litigation including expert witnesses and shall not include contracts for construction of public works. For purposes of this subdivision, the costs of performing the services by state employees shall include any salary, pension costs, all other benefit costs, costs that are required for equipment, facilities and all other overhead. The costs of consult-

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD05251-02-1

S. 5356 2

ant services shall include the total cost of the contract including costs that are required for equipment, facilities and all other overhead and any continuing state costs directly associated with a contractor providing a contracted function including, but not limited to, those costs for inspection, supervision, monitoring of the contractor's work and any pro rata share of existing costs or expenses, including administrative salaries and benefits, rent, equipment costs, utilities and materials. The cost comparison shall be expressed where feasible as an hourly rate, or where such a calculation is not feasible, as a total estimated cost for the anticipated term of the contract.

b. Prior to entering any consultation services contract for the privatization of a state service that is not currently privatized, the state agency shall develop a cost comparison review in accordance with the provisions of paragraph a of this subdivision.

c. (i) If such cost comparison review identifies a cost savings to the state of ten percent or more, and such consultant services contract will not diminish the quality of such service, the state agency shall develop a business plan, in accordance with the provisions of paragraph d of this subdivision, in order to evaluate the feasibility of entering any such contract and to identify the potential results, effectiveness and efficiency of such contract.

(ii) If such cost comparison review identifies a cost savings of less than ten percent to the state and such consultant services contract will not diminish the quality of such service, the state agency may develop a business plan, in order to evaluate the feasibility of entering any such contract and to identify the potential results, effectiveness and efficiency of such contract, provided there is a significant public policy reason to enter into such consultant services contract.

(iii) If any such proposed consultant services contract would result in the layoff, transfer or reassignment of fifty or more state agency employees, after consulting with the potentially affected bargaining units, if any, the state agency shall notify the state employees of such bargaining unit, after such cost comparison review is completed. Such state agency shall provide an opportunity for said employees to reduce the costs of conducting the operations to be privatized and provide reasonable resources for the purpose of encouraging and assisting such state employees to organize and submit a bid to provide the services that are the subject of the potential consultant services contact.

d. Any business plan developed by a state agency for the purpose of complying with paragraph c of this subdivision shall include: (i) the cost comparison review as described in paragraph b of this subdivision, (ii) a detailed description of the service or activity that is the subject of such business plan, (iii) a description and analysis of the state agency's current performance of such service or activity, (iv) the goals to be achieved through the proposed consultant services contract and the rationale for such goals, (v) a description of available options for achieving such goals, (vi) an analysis of the advantages and disadvantages of each option, including, at a minimum, potential performance improvements and risks attendant to termination of the contract or rescission of such contract, (vii) a description of the current market for the services or activities that are the subject of such business plan, (viii) an analysis of the quality of services as gauged by standardized measures and key performance requirements including compensation, turnover, and staffing ratios, (ix) a description of the specific results based performance standards that shall, at a minimum be met, to ensure adequate performance by any party performing such service or

S. 5356 3

activity, (x) the projected time frame for key events from the beginning of the procurement process through the expiration of a contract, if applicable, (xi) a specific and feasible contingency plan that addresses contractor nonperformance and a description of the tasks involved in and costs required for implementation of such plan, and (xii) a transition plan, if appropriate, for addressing changes in the number of agency personnel, affected business processes, employee transition issues, and communications with affected stakeholders, such as agency clients and members of the public, if applicable. Such transition plan shall contain a reemployment and retraining assistance plan for employees who are not retained by the state or employed by the contractor. If any part of such business plan is based upon evidence that the state agency is not sufficiently staffed to provide the services required by the consultant services contract, the state agency shall also include within such business plan a recommendation for remediation of the understaffing to allow such services to be provided directly by the state agency in the future.

e. Upon the completion of such business plan, the state agency shall submit the business plan to the state comptroller.

f. (i) Not later than sixty days after receipt of any business plan, the state comptroller shall transmit a report detailing its review, evaluation and disposition regarding such business plan to the state agency that submitted such cost comparison review. Such sixty-day period may be extended for an additional thirty days upon a showing of good cause.

(ii) The state comptroller's report shall include the business plan prepared by the state agency, the reasons for approval or disapproval, any recommendations or other information to assist the state agency in determining if additional steps are necessary to move forward with a consultant services contract.

(iii) If the state comptroller does not act on a business plan submitted by a state agency within ninety days of receipt of such business plan, such business plan shall be deemed approved.

g. A cost comparison shall not be required if the contracting agency demonstrates:

(i) the services are incidental to the purchase of real or personal property; or

(ii) the contract is necessary in order to avoid a conflict of interest on the part of the agency or its employees; or

(iii) the services are of such a highly specialized nature that it is not feasible to utilize state employees to perform them or require special equipment that is not feasible for the state to purchase or lease; or

(iv) the services are of such an urgent nature that it is not feasible to utilize state employees; or

(v) the services are anticipated to be short term and are not likely to be extended or repeated after the contract is completed; or

(vi) a quantifiable improvement in services that cannot be reasonably duplicated.

h. Nothing in this section shall be deemed to authorize a state agency to enter into a contract which is otherwise prohibited by law.

i. All documents related to the cost comparison and business plan required by this subdivision and the determinations made pursuant to paragraph g of this subdivision shall be public records subject to disclosure pursuant to article six of the public officers law.

§ 2. On or before December 31, 2023 the state comptroller shall prepare a report, to be delivered to the governor, the temporary presi-

S. 5356 4

dent of the senate and the speaker of the assembly. Such report shall include, but need not be limited to, an analysis of the effectiveness of the cost comparison review program and an analysis of the cost savings associated with performing such cost comparison.

§ 3. This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become a law and shall apply to all contracts solicited or entered into by state agencies after the effective date of this act; provided, however, the amendments to section 163 of the state finance law made by section one of this act shall not affect the repeal of such section and shall be deemed repealed therewith.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the state finance law, in relation to the cost effec- tiveness of consultant contracts by state agencies and ensuring the efficient and effective use of state tax dollars

Purpose or general idea of bill

Sets forth conditions when an agency shall enter into a contract for consultant services. Requires agencies to conduct a cost comparison prior to entering into a contract for consultant services to determine if there is a less expensive alternative.

Summary of specific provisions

Amends the state finance law by amending section 163 to add a new subdi- vision 16, setting forth conditions that must be met when an agency shall enter into a contract for consulting services of more than $1,000,000 ($1 million), the agency shall compare costs to determine whether the work can be performed at lower cost by utilizing state employees rather than consultants. Certain exceptions are specified when this cost comparison is not required. The agency must retain documenta- tion of the cost comparison as a public record.

Justification

The purpose of this bill is to require state agencies to do cost compar- isons before entering into contracts for consultant services. Any time the taxpayers' money is used to fund a contract. for services there is a need to insure that this expenditure is necessary and prudent, The State of New York spends over $2 Billion per year on consultants, In many cases these consultants perform work that could be done by professional state employees and the cost of using consultants is substantially high- er.

In 1998 the use of engineering consultants by the State Department of Transportation was studied by the State, Comptroller and OSC concluded that the State could save millions of dollars by reducing the use of consultants. The Comptroller recommended cost/benefit, analysis prior to contracting with consultants. Other studies have confirmed this finding, including an analysis by the State Assembly in 2009 that estimated the state could save $250 million over three years by reducing the use of information technology consultants. In 2010 The state Senate Task Force on Government Efficiency estimated that the Department of Transportation could save about $46 million per year by implementing this policy. In 2009 the Federal Office of Management and Budget issued a directive to Federal government agencies that calls for them to perform a cost bene- fit analysis before entering into contracts and to initiate pilot projects for in-sourcing work in cases where the cost analysis supports the conclusion that the work can be performed by government employers at lower cost that by using contractors. OMB estimates that this and other contracting reforms can save the Federal government $40 billion.

Prior legislative history

A10781 of 2011-12: vetoed; A7506 of 2013-2014: referred to Government Operations;

A2499 of 2015-16: referred to Government Operations

S.383 of 2017-18: Passed both Houses, Vetoed Memo 272; Tabled

S6048 of 2019-20: Passed both Houses, Vetoed Memo 230

Fiscal implications

None.

Effective date

This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become a law, with provisions.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.