Skip to content
S9120Senate2021-2022 SessionSame asA10443

Allow Parkland for Rail Expansion

Official title

“Authorizes the discontinuance of parkland and the granting of easements for improvements to the Metro-North railroad”

Sponsor Luis R. SepúlvedaSD-32Affects Finance
Status
Signed by Governor
Impact
6/10
Moderate
Outcome
Signed into law

Bill progress

Signed into law

What's happening

This bill allows New York City to convert certain Bronx parkland for Metro-North railroad improvements, enabling service to four new Bronx stations and Penn Station, with provisions to replace or improve parkland.

Why it matters

  1. Trade-off Between Transit Expansion and Parkland Use. The bill enables NYC to permanently convert specific Bronx parkland for rail infrastructure, raising questions about the balance between expanding vital transit access and the loss or alteration of public green space in local neighborhoods.

  2. Guarantees for Parkland Replacement/Improvement. The city is required to offset the loss of parkland by dedicating an amount equal to or greater than the parkland’s fair market value for acquiring new parkland or improving existing parks/recreational facilities in the Bronx, aiming to maintain or enhance community access to public spaces.

  3. Federal Compliance and Funding Safeguards. If any of the affected parkland was improved with federal funds, the city must comply with federal requirements before conversion—ensuring no loss of federally protected park resources without equivalent replacement, which could affect project timelines and scope.

  4. Community and Local Oversight. Restoration of park surfaces after construction must be coordinated with the city and local community boards, offering some local input and accountability, and ensuring that, where possible, parkland continues to serve public recreational purposes after the railroad work is completed.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Allow Parkland for Rail Expansion

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Luis R. Sepúlveda

Senator · Senate District 32

Chair, Cities 1

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Signed chap.544
  2. Delivered to governor
  3. Returned to senate
  4. Passed assembly
  5. Home rule request
  6. Ordered to third reading rules cal.646
  7. Substituted for A10443
  8. Referred to ways and means
  9. Delivered to assembly
  10. Passed senateVote 61–2
  11. Ordered to third reading cal.1592
  12. Committee discharged and committed to rules
Show 3 earlier actions
  1. Print number 9120a
  2. Amend and recommit to local government
  3. Referred to local government

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A10443Assembly

Allow Parkland for Train Expansion

Assembly Floor Calendar · Sponsor Michael Benedetto

Impact 7 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

9 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9120--A

IN SENATE

May 10, 2022

Introduced by Sen. SEPULVEDA -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Local Government -committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee

AN ACT to authorize the city of New York to discontinue a portion of real property in the county of the Bronx as parkland and to grant easements for improvements to the railroad right-of-way to bring Metro-North railroad service to four new stations in the Bronx and to Pennsylvania Station in the county of New York

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subject to the provisions of this act, but notwithstanding any provision of law to the contrary, the city of New York is hereby authorized to discontinue the use as parklands of the lands described in section three of this act and to grant easements to the metropolitan transportation authority, upon such terms and conditions as the city shall determine, to enable the metropolitan transportation authority and Metro-North commuter railroad company, an affiliate of the metropolitan transportation authority, to construct improvements and gain ingress and egress to and from railroad equipment, stations and right-of-way on such former parkland, and to construct below surface and surface utility infrastructure, in order to bring Metro-North commuter railroad company service to four new stations in the Bronx and to Pennsylvania Station in the county of New York.

§ 2. The authorization provided in section one of this act shall be effective only upon the condition that the city of New York dedicates an amount equal to or greater than the fair market of the parklands being discontinued towards the acquisition of new parklands and/or capital improvements to existing parklands and recreational facilities within the borough of the Bronx.

§ 3. The lands hereby authorized to be discontinued as parklands and for which easements may be granted to the metropolitan transportation authority are located in the county of the Bronx, city and state of New York, and are bounded and described as follows:

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD15728-03-2

Easement 1 on BLOCK 3861, PART OF LOT 14:

ALL THAT CERTAIN LOT, PIECE OR PARCEL OF LAND SITUATED, LYING AND BEING IN THE BOROUGH OF THE BRONX, COUNTY OF BRONX, CITY, AND STATE OF NEW YORK BOUNDED AND DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:

AREA STE-115-03: HORIZONTAL LIMITS

Beginning at a point in the southeast line of Block 3861, Lot 14, as depicted to the City of New York (Reputed Owner) as per Reel 770 Page 1136, as recorded in the Register's Office of the City of New York, Borough of the Bronx, same being a northwest line of Block 3861, Lot 8, being N 65°40'15" W, distant 242.23 feet from the intersection of the northeast line of E. 172nd Street (60 feet wide) and the northwest line of Bronx River Avenue (100 feet wide) to a common corner of said Lots 14 and 8, N 30°52'59" E, distant 246.92 feet along a common line between said Lots 14 and 8 to the said Point of Beginning having coordinates N 242,522.5836, E 1,016,853.7105, and running thence;

Northwesterly, leaving said common line, crossing said Lot 14, N 59°07'01" W, a distance of 7.66 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing across said Lot 14, N 30°52'59" E, a distance of 103.45 feet to a point, thence;

Southeasterly, continuing across said Lot 14, S 59°07'01" E, a distance of 7.66 feet to a point, said point being in the common line between said Lots 14 and 8, thence;

Southwesterly, along said common line, S 30°52'59" W, a distance of 103.45 feet to the Point or Place of Beginning and containing 792 square feet (0.018 acres) of land more or less.

Easement 2 on BLOCK 3861, PART OF LOT 14: ALL THAT CERTAIN LOT, PIECE OR PARCEL OF LAND SITUATED, LYING AND BEING IN THE BOROUGH OF THE BRONX, COUNTY OF BRONX, CITY, AND STATE OF NEW YORK BOUNDED AND DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:

AREA STE-116-02A: HORIZONTAL LIMITS

Beginning at a point in Block 3861, Lot 14, as depicted to the City of New York (Reputed Owner) as per Reel 770 Page 1136, as recorded in the Register's Office of the City of New York, Borough of the Bronx, same being a northwest line of Block 3861, Lot 8, being N 65°40'15" W, distant 242.23 feet from the intersection of the northeast line of E. 172nd Street (60 feet wide) and the northwest line of Bronx River Avenue (100 feet wide) to a common corner of said Lots 14, and 8, N 30°52'59" E, distant 246.92 feet along a common line between said Lots 14 and 8, N 59°07'01" W, distant 7.66 feet leaving said common line and crossing said Lot 14 to the said Point of Beginning having coordinates N 242,526.5132, E 1,016,847.1402, and running thence;

Northwesterly, continuing across said Lot 14, N 59°07'01" W, a distance of 17.31 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing across said Lot 14, N 30°00'36" E, a distance of 50.98 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing across said Lot 14, N30°49'33"E, a distance of 70.57 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing across said Lot 14, N 31°33'35" E, a distance of 88.39 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing across said Lot 14, N 32°14'48" E, a distance of 107.82 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing across said Lot 14, N 33°04'35" E, a distance of 60.89 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing across said Lot 14, N 33°35'42" E, a distance of 42.32 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing across said Lot 14 along a curve to the left, having a radius 771.90 feet, an arc length of 133.13 feet, and a chord that bears N 27°40'31" E, a distance of 132.97 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing across said Lot 14 along a curve to the left, having a radius 626.87 feet, an arc length of 27.45 feet, and a chord that bears N 22°38'50" E, a distance of 27.45 feet to a point, said point being in a northeast line of said Lot 14, same being a southwest line of Block 3861, Lot 114, thence;

Southwesterly, along said common line, S 10°22'48" W, a distance of 77.44 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, leaving said common line and crossing said Lot 14 along a curve to the right, having a radius 789.90 feet, an arc length of 88.00 feet, and a chord that bears S 29°25'29" W, a distance of 87.96 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 14, S 33°35'29" W, a distance of 42.47 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 14, S 32°58'25" W, a distance of 60.76 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 14, S 32°18'18" W, a distance of 107.59 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 14, S 31°33'35" W, a distance of 88.17 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 14, S 30°22'14" W, a distance of 18.00 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 14, S 30°52'59" W, a distance of 103.45 feet to the Point or Place of Beginning and containing 9,767 square feet (0.224 acres) of land more or less.

Easement 3 on BLOCK 3861, PART OF LOT 14: ALL THAT CERTAIN LOT, PIECE OR PARCEL OF LAND SITUATED, LYING AND BEING IN THE BOROUGH OF THE BRONX, COUNTY OF BRONX, CITY, AND STATE OF NEW YORK BOUNDED AND DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:

AREA STE-116-02B: HORIZONTAL LIMITS

Beginning at a point in a southeast line of Block 3861, Lot 14, as depicted to the City of New York (Reputed Owner) as per Reel 770 Page 1136, as recorded in the Register's Office of the City of New York, Borough of the Bronx, same being a northwest line of Block 3861, Lot 114, being N 65°39'02" W, distant 315.96 feet from the intersection of the southwest line of East 174th Street (80 feet wide) and the northwest line of Bronx River Avenue (100 feet wide), along said southwest line to the common corner of said Lot 14 and Block 3861, Lot 114, S 25°23'15" W, distant 75.09 feet along the common line between said Lots 14 and 114 to the said Point of Beginning having coordinates N 243,353.3499, E 1,017,273.8724, and running thence;

Southwesterly, continuing along said common line, S 25°23'15" W, a distance of 37.54 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, leaving said common line, crossing said Lot 14, along a curve to the left, having a radius of 201.86 feet, an arc length of 97.38 feet, and a chord that bears S 33°57'13" W, a distance of 96.45 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 14, S 15°04'20" W, a distance of 80.23 feet to a point said point being on the said common line between Lots 14 and 114, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing along said common line, S 25°23'15" W, a distance of 107.08 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, leaving said common line, crossing said Lot 14, N 18°52'55" E, a distance of 11.88 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing across said Lot 14, N 16°41'14" E, a distance of 49.13 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing across said Lot 14, N 14°24'26" E, a distance of 107.98 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing across said Lot 14, along a curve to the right, having a radius of 201.08 feet, an arc length of 121.59 feet, and a chord that bears N 31°33'40" E, a distance of 119.74 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing across said Lot 14, along a curve to the right, having a radius of 185.72 feet, an arc length of 37.40 feet, and a chord that bears N 51°33'21" E, a distance of 37.34 feet to the Point or Place of Beginning and containing 4,406 square feet (0.101 acres) of land more or less.

Easement 4 on BLOCK 3861, PART OF LOT 114: ALL THAT CERTAIN LOT, PIECE OR PARCEL OF LAND SITUATED, LYING AND BEING IN THE BOROUGH OF THE BRONX, COUNTY OF BRONX, CITY, AND STATE OF NEW YORK BOUNDED AND DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:

AREA STE-116-03: HORIZONTAL LIMITS

Beginning at a point in a northwest line of Block 3861, Lot 114, as depicted to the City of New York (Reputed Owner) as per Reel 290 Page 20, as recorded in the Register's Office of the City of New York, Borough of the Bronx, same being a southeast line of Block 3861, Lot 14, being N 65°39'02" W, distant 315.96 feet from the intersection of the southwest line of East 174th Street (80 feet wide) and the northwest line of Bronx River Avenue (100 feet wide), along said southwest line to the common corner of said Lot 14 and Block 3861, Lot 114, S 25°23'15" W, distant 286.95 feet along the common line between said Lots 14 and 114 to the said Point of Beginning having coordinates N 243,161.9562, E 1,017,183.0434, and running thence;

Southwesterly, leaving said common line, crossing said Lot 114, S 15°04'20" W, a distance of 25.49 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 114, S 15°15'32" W, a distance of 35.28 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 114, S 16°14'46" W, a distance of 24.96 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 114, S 18°16'10" W, a distance of 16.37 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 114, S 19°27'15" W, a distance of 28.06 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 114, S 21°36'23" W, a distance of 47.44 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 114, along a curve to the right, having a radius of 789.88 feet, an arc length of 36.79 feet, and a chord that bears S 24°49'11" W, a distance of 36.78 feet to a point. Said point being on the common line between said Lots 114 and 14, thence;

Northeasterly, along said common line, N 10°22'48" E, a distance of 89.42 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing along said common line, N 25°23'15" E, a distance of 126.35 feet to the Point or Place of Beginning and containing 2,257 square feet (0.052 acres) of land more or less.

Easement 5 on BLOCK 3861, PART OF LOT 114: ALL THAT CERTAIN LOT, PIECE OR PARCEL OF LAND SITUATED, LYING AND BEING IN THE BOROUGH OF THE BRONX, COUNTY OF BRONX, CITY, AND STATE OF NEW YORK BOUNDED AND DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:

AREA STE-116-05: HORIZONTAL LIMITS

Beginning at a point in a northeast line of Block 3861, Lot 114, as depicted to the City of New York (Reputed Owner) as per Reel 290 Page 20, as recorded in the Register's Office of the City of New York, Borough of the Bronx, same being a southwest line of E. 174th Street (80 feet wide) being N 65°39'02" W, distant 266.86 feet from the intersection of the southwest line of East 174th Street and the northwest line of Bronx River Avenue (100 feet wide), along said southwest line to the said Point of Beginning having coordinates N 243,400.9477, E 1,017,350.8040, and running thence;

Southwesterly, leaving said common line, along a curve to the right, having a radius of 181.58 feet, an arc length of 6.77 feet, and a chord that bears S 39°37'44" W, a distance of 6.77 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, crossing said Lot 114, along a curve to the right, having a radius of 140.49 feet, an arc length of 47.24 feet, and a chord that bears S 43°22'54" W, a distance of 47.02 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 114, S 51°25'10" W, a distance of 9.40 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 114, along a curve to the right, having a radius of 112.86 feet, an arc length of 20.56 feet, and a chord that bears S 53°51'05" W, a distance of 20.53 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 114, along a curve to the left, having a radius of 201.86 feet, an arc length of 24.58 feet, and a chord that bears S 55°36'56" W, a distance of 24.56 feet to a point, thence;

Southwesterly, continuing across said Lot 114, S 49°54'54" W, a distance of 15.96 feet to a point, said point being a northwest line of said Lot 114, same being a southeast line of Block 3861, Lot 14, thence;

Northeasterly, along said common line, N 25°23'15" E, a distance of 37.54 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, leaving said common line, crossing said Lot 114 along a curve to the right, having a radius of 185.72 feet, an arc length of 6.94 feet, and a chord that bears N 58°23'47" E, a distance of 6.94 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing across said Lot 114 along a curve to the left, having a radius of 209.63 feet, an arc length of 61.64 feet, and a chord that bears N 48°31'41" E, a distance of 61.42 feet to a point, thence;

Northeasterly, continuing across said Lot 114, N 41°28'18" E, a distance of 13.91 feet to a point, said point being on the common line between said Lot 114 and E. 174th Street, thence;

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to authorize the city of New York to discontinue a portion of real property in the county of the Bronx as parkland and to grant ease- ments for improvements to the railroad right-of-way to bring Metro-North railroad service to four new stations in the Bronx and to Pennsylvania Station in the county of New York

Purpose

This bill would authorize the City of New York to alienate certain parcels of land to enable the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) to make critical improvements related to Penn Station Access Project which would enable Metro-North passengers to travel directly into Penn Station.

Summary of provisions

Section 1 would authorize the City of New York to discontinue select parkland as detailed within section three of the bill, to further the implementation of the Penn Station Access Project.

Read the full memo (679 words)

Section 2 requires that MTA provide appropriate consideration to the City of New York in exchange for the granted easements, and establishes the relevant processes; it being the intent that such consideration will be determined after granting of such easements by the City pursuant to the provisions of Section 1266(12-a) of the Public Authorities Law, as it may apply.

Section 3 identifies the metes and bounds of those portions of parkland that are proposed to be discontinued as parkland.

Section 4 provides for compliance with federal law, to the extent appli- cable

Section 5 authorizes the MTA, at its discretion, to, at the end of the project, make certain transfers of some or all easements to the National Railroad Passenger Corporation.

Section 6 Provides that the MTA restore the surface of the lands described and restore them to park use.

Section 7 provides that the bill shall take effect immediately.

Justification

The Penn Station Access- Project seeks to allow commuters and other train passengers in the Northern suburbs of the New York City Metropol- itan area and Connecticut to access the West side of Midtown Manhattan more easily for working, business meetings, shopping, entertainment, dining, and other purposes. Currently, such train passengers are limited to Grand Central Terminal, and can only reach the West side through some combination of walking, taxi, bus, or subway, each of which presents its own obstacles of time, cost, and inconvenience. By bringing Metro-North trains directly into Penn Station, The Metropolitan Transportation Authority will provide an efficient and convenient method for seamless integration of travel to destinations on the West side of Manhattan for passengers who would otherwise be restricted to traversing through Grand

Central Terminal and engaging in supplemental travel by pedestrian, car, bus, or subway service.

This project is intended to supplement The Metropolitan Transportation Authority's related plan to bring trains of the Long Island Rail Road directly into Grand Central Terminal commonly known as "East Side Access" that promises to allow commuters and other train passengers using the Long Island Rail Road to directly access the East side of Midtown, Manhattan for working, business meetings, shopping, enter- tainment, dining, and other purposes. Until now, Metro-North trains only terminated at Grand Central Terminal in Midtown Manhattan, and Long Island Rail Road trains only terminated at Penn Station in Midtown Manhattan (although some of these trains terminated at Atlantic Terminal in Brooklyn). The Penn Station Access Project addresses half of this situation by allowing Metro-North passengers direct access to the West side of Midtown Manhattan, and the East Side Access Project addresses the other half of this situation by allowing Long Island Rail Road passengers direct access to the East side of Midtown Manhattan. This integration is further bolstered by the fact that for the Penn Station Access Project, Metro-North trains will be allowed to use existing Amtrak rails along Amtrak's Northeast corridor to connect Metro-North's existing rail lines to Penn Station. Metro-North plans to install and construct four new station buildings along Amtrak's line to facilitate better service availability for projected Metro-North customers seeking quicker and easier access to the West side of Midtown Manhattan.

Legislative history

None.

Fiscal implications

None.

Effective date

The bill would take effect immediately.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.