Skip to content
S9323Senate2021-2022 SessionSame asA10449

Transfer Parkland for Subway Upgrades

Official title

“Authorizes discontinuing the use as parkland of certain real property in Brooklyn and the transfer of such lands to enable the NYC transit authority to make station improvements”

Sponsor Julia SalazarSD-18Affects Finance
Status
Signed by Governor
Impact
4/10
Low
Outcome
Signed into law

Bill progress

Signed into law

What's happening

This bill authorizes New York City to transfer part of Callahan-Kelly Park in Brooklyn to the MTA for transit station improvements and pedestrian bridges, while requiring dedication of new parkland of equal value.

Why it matters

  1. Enables critical transit upgrades in East New York, Brooklyn. By allowing the transfer of parkland and air rights, the bill paves the way for new at-grade subway station improvements and pedestrian bridges connecting multiple subway lines (L, J, Z, A, and C), potentially improving accessibility, safety, and connectivity for a high-traffic transit hub.

  2. Mandates protection and replacement of public green space. The legislation requires that any parkland taken for transit purposes must be replaced with new parkland of equal or greater fair market value, or that equivalent investments be made in acquiring or improving parkland within Brooklyn. This helps safeguard community access to public open space amid infrastructure changes.

  3. Includes safeguards for federal interests and community oversight. If federal funding was ever used for the affected parkland, the city must comply with all federal requirements—including fair market value and usefulness standards—before any transfer occurs. Additionally, once construction is complete, the MTA must restore temporarily used parkland in consultation with the local community board, ensuring local input and oversight.

  4. Reflects a broader city planning balance between infrastructure and recreation. The bill highlights the ongoing tension in urban areas between expanding transit infrastructure and preserving recreational space, setting a precedent for future projects that require the conversion of parkland for public works while maintaining a focus on community benefits.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Transfer Parkland for Subway Upgrades

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Julia Salazar

Senator · Senate District 18

Chair, Crime Victims, Crime And Correction

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Signed chap.548
  2. Delivered to governor
  3. Returned to senate
  4. Passed assembly
  5. Home rule request
  6. Ordered to third reading rules cal.647
  7. Substituted for A10449
  8. Referred to ways and means
  9. Delivered to assembly
  10. Passed senateVote 62–1
  11. Ordered to third reading cal.1598
  12. Committee discharged and committed to rules
Show 3 earlier actions
  1. Print number 9323a
  2. Amend (t) and recommit to local government
  3. Referred to local government

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A10449Assembly

Use Parkland for Subway Upgrades

Assembly Floor Calendar · Sponsor Latrice Walker

Impact 6 · Moderate0% to pass

Full text

7 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9323--A

IN SENATE

May 16, 2022

Introduced by Sen. SALAZAR -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Local Government -committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee

AN ACT to authorize the city of New York to discontinue the use as parkland a portion of real property in the borough of Brooklyn and to transfer such lands to the metropolitan transportation authority, to enable the New York city transit authority to construct in such areas new permanent at-grade station improvements and pedestrian bridges

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subject to the provisions of this act, but notwithstanding any provision of law to the contrary, the city of New York is hereby authorized, upon such terms and conditions the city shall determine, to: (a) discontinue permanently the use as parklands the lands described in section three of this act, and transfer such lands to the metropolitan transportation authority, to enable the New York city transit authority to construct in such areas new permanent at-grade station improvements; (b) discontinue permanently the air rights over the parklands described in section four of this act, and transfer such air rights to the metropolitan transportation authority for pedestrian bridges between and among the L, J, Z, A and C subway lines; and (c) discontinue temporarily the use as parklands the areas described in section five of this act for construction staging areas.

§ 2. The authorization provided in section one of this act shall be effective only upon the condition that at the time of the transfer of the lands and air rights described in sections three and four of this act, the city of New York dedicates as parkland the lands described in section six of this act provided that the city of New York has never used such lands for public open space or park purposes. In the event that such land to be dedicated is not equal to or greater than the fair market value of the park land to be discontinued, the city of New York shall dedicate the difference between the fair market value of the park land to be discontinued and the fair market value of the land to be

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD15828-03-2

dedicated towards the acquisition of new parklands or capital improvements to existing parklands and recreational facilities within the borough of Brooklyn.

§ 3. The lands hereby authorized by section one of this act to be discontinued permanently as parkland and transferred to the metropolitan transportation authority are located in the county of Kings, city and state of New York in a park known as the Callahan-Kelly Park, and are bounded and described as follows:

Area A: acquisition of property rights on Tax Lot 1 in Block 1546, Borough of Brooklyn:

Beginning at the Point of Commencement, (N=186378.8532, E=1009899.0749) (NAD83 / NAVD88) at the corner formed by the intersection of the northerly line of Fulton Street, an eighty feet width right of way, and the easterly line of Eastern Parkway, a one-hundredand ten-feet width right of way, running thence,

Easterly along the said northerly sideline of Fulton Street 883.90', along the same northerly sideline of Fulton Street to a point, thence,

On a line in a general northerly direction having an interior angle of 84°14'59" with the previous course 72.29' to a point known as the Point of Beginning, thence,

1) On a line in a general westerly direction having an interior angle of 89°57'01" with the previous course 55.94' to a point, thence,

2) On a line in a general Northerly direction having an interior angle of 79°17'17" with the previous course 65.85' to a point, thence,

3) On a line in a general easterly direction having an interior angle of 100°47'48" with the previous course 23.82' to a point, thence,

4) On a line in a general northerly direction having an interior angle of 270°17'30" with the previous course 18.55' to a point, thence,

5) On a line in a general easterly direction having an interior angle of 89°14'48" with the previous course 112.13' to a point, thence,

6) On a line in a general southerly direction having an interior angle of f 70°59'29" with the previous course 18.01' to a point, thence,

7) On a line in a general westerly direction having an interior angle of 109°20'10" with the previous course 45.81' to a point, thence,

8) On a line in a general southerly direction having an interior angle of 270°00'00" with the previous course 17.40' to a point, thence,

9) On a line in a general westerly direction having an interior angle of 90°00'00" with the previous course 40.29' to a point, thence,

10) On a line in a general southerly direction having an interior angle of 270°00'00" with the previous course 48.23' to the Point of Beginning.

Said parcel described above contains 5,836 square feet (0.13 acres) of land more or less.

Area B: acquisition of property rights on Tax Lot 1 in Block 1546, Borough of Brooklyn:

Beginning at the Point of Commencement, (N=186378.8532, E=1009899.0749) (NAD83 / NAVD88) at the corner formed by the intersection of the northerly line of Fulton Street, an eighty feet width right of way, and the north-easterly line of Eastern Parkway, a one-hundred-and ten-feet width right of way, running thence,

Easterly along the said northerly line of Fulton Street 1011.31', to a point of curvature on the same northerly sideline of Fulton Street, thence,

Along the arc, having a curve to the left, a radius of 70 feet, delta of 102°54'18", and an arc distance of 125.72 feet to the point of tangency along the westerly line of Van Sinderen Avenue, a one-hundred width right of way, thence,

Along the same westerly sideline of Van Sinderen Avenue in a general northerly direction, from the point of tangency 53.99' along the same westerly line of Van Sinderen Avenue, to a point, thence,

On a line in a general westerly direction having an interior angle of 97°09'24" with the previous course 45.92' to the Point of Beginning, thence,

1) On a line in a general westerly direction having an interior angle of 180°00'00" with the previous course 38.50' to a point, thence,

2) On a line in a general northerly direction having an interior angle of 90°00'00" with the previous course 18.75' to a point, thence,

3) On a line in a general easterly direction having an interior angle of 90°00'00" with the previous course 0.90' to a point, thence,

4) On a line in a general northerly direction having an interior angle of 250°39'50" with the previous course 51.96' to a point, thence,

5) On a line in a general easterly direction having an interior angle of 89°54'43" with the previous course 13.21' to a point, thence,

6) On a line in a general northerly direction having an interior angle of 270°09'15" with the previous course 1.50' to a point, thence,

7) On a line in a general easterly direction having an interior angle of 89°42'05" with the previous course 19.98' to a point, thence,

8) On a line in a general southerly direction having an interior angle of 116°54'23" with the previous course 9.83' to a point, thence,

9) On a line in a general southerly direction having an interior angle of 153°20'13" with the previous course 10.30' to a point, thence,

10) On a line in a general easterly direction having an interior angle of 285°10'47" with the previous course 1.53' to a point, thence,

11) On a line in a general southerly direction having an interior angle of 74°53'38" with the previous course 40.81' to the Point of Beginning.

Said parcel described above contains 2,485 square feet (0.06 acres) of land more or less.

§ 4. The area above certain limiting planes set forth below authorized to be discontinued permanently as parkland by section one of this act, and granted as easements to the metropolitan transportation authority is bounded and described as follows:

Area C: Acquisition of air rights on Tax Lot 1 in Block 1546, Borough of Brooklyn:

Beginning at the Point of Commencement, (N=186378.8532, E=1009899.0749) (NAD83 / NAVD 88) at the corner formed by the intersection of the northerly sideline of Fulton Street, an eighty feet width right of way, and the easterly sideline of Eastern Parkway, a one-hundred- and ten-feet width right of way, running thence,

Along the easterly sideline of Eastern Parkway, a one-hundred- and ten-feet width right of way, in a general northeasterly direction 70.74' to a point in the same easterly sideline of Eastern Parkway and the southerly sideline of Truxton Street, a 70 feet width right of way, thence,

Along the southerly sideline of Truxton Street in a general easterly direction having an interior angle of 142°03'22" with the previous course 945.72' to the point to curvature along the same said southerly sideline of Truxton Street, thence,

Along the arc, having a curve to the right, a radius of 70 feet, delta of 36°53'27", and an arc distance of 45.07', also described as having an interior angle of 161°33'16" with the previous course 44.30' chord length to the Point of Beginning in the same southerly sideline of Truxton Street, thence,

1) On a line in a general southerly direction having an interior angle of 82°10'13" with the previous course 60.33' to a point, thence,

2) On a line in a general easterly direction having an interior angle of 90°05'13" with the previous course 13.21' to a point, thence,

3) On a line in a general northerly direction having an interior angle of 89°50'45" with the previous course 56.52 to a point along a curve, thence,

4) Along an arc on the southerly sideline of Truxton Street having a curve to the left, a radius of 70 feet, a delta angle of 11°22'02" and an arc distance of 13.71', also described as having an interior angle of 106°17'35" with the previous course 13.69' chord length to the Point of Beginning.

The property rights described above begin at an elevation (NAVD 88) of 121.5 ± feet with no upper limit. The park ground is at an elevation of 86.5± feet.

Said parcel containing 773 square feet more or less.

Area D: acquisition of air rights on Tax Lot 1 in Block 1546, Borough of Brooklyn:

Beginning at the Point of Commencement, (N=186378.8532, E=1009899.0749) (NAD83 / NAVD 88) at the corner formed by the intersection of the northerly sideline of Fulton Street, an eighty feet width right of way, and the easterly sideline of Eastern Parkway, a one-hundred- and ten-feet width right of way, running thence,

Easterly along the said northerly line of Fulton Street 1011.31', to a point of curvature on the same northerly sideline of Fulton Street, thence,

Along the arc, having a curve to the left, a radius of 70 feet, delta of 102°54'18", and an arc distance of 125.72 feet to the point of tangency along the westerly sideline of Van Sinderen, a one-hundred width right of way, thence,

On a line in a general northerly direction, from the point of tangency 111.19' along the same westerly sideline of Van Sinderen, to the Point of Beginning,

1) On a line in a general westerly direction having an interior angle of 101°43'05" with the previous course 24.87' to a point, thence,

2) On a line in a general southerly direction having an interior angle of 78°06'04" with the previous course 10.46'to a point, thence,

3) On a line in a general southerly direction having an interior angle of 206°39'47" with the previous course 10.30'to a point, thence,

4) On a line in a general easterly direction having an interior angle of 74°45'47" with the previous course 29.48' to a point along the westerly sideline on Van Sinderen Avenue, a one-hundred feet width right of way, thence,

5) On a line in general northerly direction having an interior angle of 78°45'18" with the previous course 20.38' to the Point of Beginning. The property rights as described above begin at an elevation (NAVD 88) of 96.5± feet with no upper limit. The park ground is at an elevation of 86.5± feet.

Said parcel containing 522 square feet more or less.

§ 5. The lands hereby authorized to be discontinued temporarily as parklands by section one of this act and granted as temporary easements to serve as construction staging areas for the duration of construction are bounded and described as follows:

Area E: Temporary Construction Easement on Tax Lot 1 in Block 1546, Borough of Brooklyn:

Beginning at the Point of Commencement, (N=186378.8532, E=1009899.0749) (NAD83) at the corner formed by the intersection of the northerly sideline of Fulton Street, an eighty feet width right of way, and the easterly sideline of Eastern Parkway, a one-hundred- and tenfeet width right of way, running thence,

Easterly along the said northerly sideline of Fulton Street 883.90', to the Point of Beginning along the same northerly sideline of Fulton Street, thence,

1) On a line in a general northerly direction having an interior angle of 84°15'59 with the previous course 72.29' to a point, thence,

2) On a line in a general westerly direction having an interior angle of 89°57'02" with the previous course 55.94' to a point, thence,

3) On a line in a general northerly direction having an interior angle of 280°42'43 with the previous course 65.85' to a point, thence,

4) On a line in a general easterly direction having an interior angle of 259°12'12" with the previous course 23.82' to a point, thence,

5) On a line in a general northerly direction having an interior angle of 89°42'30" with the previous course 18.55' to a point, thence,

6) On a line in a general westerly direction having an interior angle of 90°45'12" with the previous course 42.04' to a point, thence,

7) On a line in a general southerly direction having an interior angle of 89°48'43" with the previous course 97.30' to a point, thence,

8) On a line in a general easterly direction having an interior angle of 90°00'11" with the previous course 7.38' to a point, thence,

9) On a line in a general southerly direction having an interior angle of 280°27'29" with the previous course 39.17' to a point, thence,

10) On a line in a general southerly direction having an interior angle of 169°22'25" with the previous course 13.72' to a point, thence,

11) On a line in a general easterly direction having an interior angle of 95°46'34" with the previous course 62.48' along the northerly line of Fulton Street to the Point of Beginning.

Said parcel containing 5,752 square feet (0.13 acres) of land more or less.

Area F: temporary construction easement on Tax Lot 1 in Block 1546, Borough of Brooklyn:

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to authorize the city of New York to discontinue the use as park- land a portion of real property in the borough of Brooklyn and to trans- fer such lands to the metropolitan transportation authority, to enable the New York city transit authority to construct in such areas new permanent at-grade station improvements and pedestrian bridges

Purpose of the bill

This bill would authorize the City of New York to alienate certain parcels of land to enable the New York city transit authority (NYCTA) to make critical Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) upgrades and other circulation improvements at the Broadway Junction Station Complex in Brooklyn.

Summary of provisions

Section 1 would authorize the City of New York to discontinue portions of parkland at the Callahan-Kelly Playground, and grant to the Metropol- itan Transportation Authority (MTA), for the use of the NYCTA, rights over such areas to facilitate NYCTA construction of urgently needed ADA upgrades and circulation improvements at the Broadway Junction transit station.

Read the full memo (769 words)

Section 2 requires that MTA provide appropriate consideration to the City of New York in exchange for the granted easements and establishes the relevant processes; it being the intent that such consideration will be determined after granting of such easements by the City pursuant to the provisions of Section 1266(12-a) of the Public Authorities Law, as it may apply.

Sections 3 and 4 identify the metes and bounds of those portions of parkland that are proposed to be occupied by permanent station improve- ments at grade and located above a certain limiting plane, and which will be conveyed to the MTA either through transfer of real property, lease, exclusive permanent easement, or by other means.

Section 5 identifies those portions of parkland that will serve as construction staging areas exceeding a period of two years for the permanent station improvements described in Sections 3 and 4.

Section 6 details the metes and bounds of the portion of Sackman Street that is proposed to be discontinued as a city street and reestablished as substitute parkland referenced in Section 2.

Section 7 provides for compliance with federal law, to the extent appli- cable.

Section 8 provides that upon completion of the construction project, the MTA will restore those portions of parkland that served as construction staging areas for the permanent station improvements to be restored as public parkland.

Section 9 provides that the bill shall take effect immediately.

Justification

The Broadway Junction Station is an MTA/NYCTA subway station complex in East New York, Brooklyn which connects the elevated Jamaica (J/Z) Line, elevated Canarsie (L) Line, and the underground Fulton Street (A/C) Line.As one of the busiest stations in Brooklyn, this Project will make Broadway Junction Station fully accessible in accordance with the ADA. In addition, this Project will also improve the circulation capacity of the complex by providing direct transfer between the A/C Line and L Line, as well as adding a new entrance and egress at the L Line station.

The underground A/C Line station was constructed below a triangular property which was later given to New York City Parks & Recreation to construct the Callahan-Kelly Playground (Park) and bounded by Fulton Street, Truxton Street, Eastern Parkway, and Van Sinderen Avenue in the Borough of Brooklyn. The only street level entrance to the station complex is from the A/C Line one-story station headhouse located at the eastern end of the Park on Van Sinderen Avenue. To provide the urgently needed ADA upgrades and circulation improvements, this project will expand the A/C headhouse in the Park to enable the MTA to use such prop- erty for the construction of the new elevators for ADA compliance at the A/C Line station and new transfers to L Line and J/Z Line Stations.

Certain property rights and air rights, as well as temporary easements, are necessary to conduct this construction project.Upon the completion of construction, the MTA will restore the lands subject to the temporary easements so those lands can continue to be used for park purposes. Additionally, the MTA will construct a comfort station in the Park in accordance with New York City Parks & Recreation specifications. In partial consideration for the property rights, the MTA will facilitate the demapping of a portion of Sackman Street which runs through the Park between Truxton Street and Fulton Street, to be used as parkland.

Amended bill

The "A" print of the bill just makes minor technical changes. There are no changes to the substance of the bill.

Prior legislative history

None.

Fiscal implications

None.

Effective date

The bill would take effect immediately.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.