What's happening
This bill allows courts to consider outside evidence to determine if retiree health insurance benefits are meant to continue beyond a collective bargaining agreement’s term.
Why it matters
Impacts retiree security and labor negotiations. By allowing courts to consider outside evidence, the bill could strengthen or weaken retirees’ claims to continued health insurance, affecting how unions and employers negotiate these benefits.
Addresses ambiguity in contracts. Many collective bargaining agreements are unclear about whether retiree health benefits persist after the contract expires; this bill ensures courts can look beyond the contract text to clarify intent, potentially reducing litigation uncertainty.
Shifts legal strategy for both sides. Employers and unions may need to keep more thorough records of negotiations and communications, knowing these materials could influence future court decisions about retiree benefits.
Could set precedent for other contract disputes. The approach of admitting extrinsic evidence could influence how other ambiguous employment agreement terms are interpreted in New York, possibly broadening the use of external context in labor law cases.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Allow Evidence in Retiree Cases
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
History
- Substituted by A10425
- Ordered to third reading cal.1826
- Committee discharged and committed to rules
- Referred to civil service and pensions
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Let Courts Review Retiree Evidence
Vetoed · Sponsor Peter Abbate
Full text
1 pageUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
9347
IN SENATE
May 18, 2022
Introduced by Sen. JACKSON -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Civil Service and Pensions
AN ACT to amend the civil service law and the labor law, in relation to clarifying the vesting of retiree health insurance within collective bargaining agreements
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. The civil service law is amended by adding a new section 157-a to read as follows:
§ 157-a. Admissibility of extrinsic evidence in cases related to retiree health insurance. Whenever a collective bargaining agreement between an employee organization and a public employer, as those terms are used in this chapter, refers to a health insurance benefit for retired employees, extrinsic evidence shall be admissible and the court or other forum may consider such evidence to determine whether the parties to that agreement intended for that retiree health insurance benefit to vest in the retirees beyond the durational term of the collective bargaining agreement and, if so, to what extent and scope.
§ 2. The labor law is amended by adding a new section 702-c to read as follows:
§ 702-c. Admissibility of extrinsic evidence in cases related to retiree health insurance. Whenever a collective bargaining agreement between a labor organization and an employer refers to a health insurance benefit for retired employees, extrinsic evidence shall be admissible and the court or other forum may consider such evidence to determine whether the parties to that agreement intended for that retiree health insurance benefit to vest in the retirees beyond the durational term of the collective bargaining agreement and, if so, to what extent and scope.
§ 3. This act shall take effect immediately.
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD15793-01-2
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the civil service law and the labor law, in relation to clarifying the vesting of retiree health insurance within collective bargaining agreements
Purpose
The purpose of this bill is to allow extrinsic evidence to be admitted by the court for determining whether the parties to a contract intended for the retiree to have health insurance vest beyond the time limits of a collective bargaining agreement.
Summary of provisions
Section 1 adds a new Section 157-A to the Civil Service Law to allow employee organizations to use extrinsic evidence to determine intent for retiree health insurance during contract negotiations.
Read the full memo (1,049 words)
Section 2 adds a new Section 702-C to the Labor Law to allow employee organizations to use extrinsic evidence to determine intent for retiree health insurance during contract negotiations.
Section 3 is the effective date.
Justification
For over 30 years, the federal courts considered retiree health insur- ance in the context of ongoing collective bargaining relationships and would infer that the parties intended to vest retiree health insurance on retirees for life, especially when eligibility for retiree health insurance was associated with eligibility for pension benefits, reason- ing that otherwise, if the benefit lasted only for the durational term of the collective bargaining agreement, typically three years, the reti- ree health insurance benefit would be illusory. This standard is best known from the case of Yard-Man and became known as a Yard-Man infer- ence. International Union, UAW v. Yard-Man, Inc., 716 F.2d 1476 (6th Cir. 1983).
In 2015, however, in the case of Tackett, the United States Supreme Court abrogated Yard-Man, holding that the courts could not make such inferences, and that a collective bargaining, like any other contract, needed to be explicit about the duration and scope of retiree health insurance benefits and the federal courts could not infer from the ongo- ing collective bargaining relationship that retiree health insurance benefits vested on retirees beyond the durational term of the collective bargaining agreements and, further, that courts could only consider extrinsic evidence of the parties' intent if the agreement was on its face ambiguous. M & G Polymers USA, LLC v. Tackett, 574 U.S. 427 (2015). Moreover, extrinsic evidence, according to the court, could not be used to show that the agreement was ambiguous as to whether retiree health insurance vested for life. Id.
In 2014, the New York State Court of Appeals had declined to address the issue in the case of Kolbe v Tibbetts, 22 N.Y.3d 344 (2013), holding that the collective bargaining agreement under review in that case, in fact, contained explicit terms showing that the retiree health insurance benefit was to vest on retirees beyond the durational term of the agree- ment.
But the issue was put squarely before the New York Court of Appeals by certified question of the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in Donohue v. Cuomo, 980 F.3d 53 (2020).
In answering the question, the New York Court of Appeals agreed with the United States Supreme Court in Tackett and rejected the use of Yard-Man inferences, holding that collective bargaining agreements must be explicit in making retiree health insurance vest for life, or be suffi- ciently ambiguous on their face to allow for the consideration of extrinsic evidence on that point, but that extrinsic evidence was not admissible to show that the agreement was ambiguous. Donohue v Cuomo, ---- N.E.3d---- (February 10, 2022). Based on the New York Court of Appeals' answer to its certified question, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, which includes New York, held that held that CSEA's collective bargaining agreements with the State did not vest retiree health insurance beyond the duration of the CBAs, even though the CBA's use of terms such as: "Employees covered by the State Health Insurance Plan have the right to retain health insurance after retire- ment upon completion of ten years of service;" "An employee who is eligible to continue health insurance coverage upon retirement is enti- tled to a sick leave credit to be used to defray any employee contrib- ution toward the cost of the premium (with the calculation based on 'the actuarial equivalent in monthly installments for the remaining life expectancy of such retired employee' under Civil Service Law § 167);" "The State has the right to make prospective changes to the percentage of credit to be available under this alternative method for future reti- rees . . . ;" and "An employee retiring from State service may delay commencement or suspend his/her retiree health coverage and the use of the employee's sick leave conversion credits indefinitely." Donohue v. Hochul, No. 18-3193-cv (April 27, 2022). According to the courts, none of these terms, or others like them in the agreements, either singly or in combination were enough to make the terms ambiguous, let alone clear- ly establish that the retiree health benefit vested for life, notwith- standing that the State, in fact, paid the benefit for life.
As a result of this upending of established law, decades' worth of collective bargaining agreements in New York, agreements negotiated when Yard-Man inferences were the rule, are now open to question by employ- ers, notwithstanding that at the time they negotiated the agreements, the intent on both sides of the negotiating table was that the benefit vested for life. The parties' intent has not changed, rather the law of evidence has changed, opening a legal loophole that might be used to deny labor and employee organizations the benefit of their bargain, leave retiree health insurance in a state of uncertainty, and strip retirees of the health insurance benefits they relied upon.
This bill simply would address the holdings in the Donohue cases and put the parties back exactly where they were before the Donohue decisions and allow extrinsic evidence to be admitted by the court or other forum to determine whether the parties intended retiree health insurance to vest beyond the durational limits of the CBA and to what extent and scope. Otherwise, the benefit would be illusory and employee organiza- tions and labor organizations would not get the benefit of their bargains.
Legislative history
New bill.
State and local fiscal implications
To be determined.
Effective date
This act shall take effect immediately.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.